Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   [Merged] Dixons Freetalk (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=36081)

Mike 03-10-2005 18:03

[Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Hi all

This package looks good to me.

I am correct if you get this you can then cancell your exsisting line rental for your phone because it uses the broadband connection. (that would save £126pa) plus you get free uk calls !!!

I am correct in my thinking !

mike

Hom3r 03-10-2005 20:27

Re: Dixons Freetalk. Cancel line rental
 
Is you phone line BT or NTL, It might not work with an NTL line.

etccarmageddon 03-10-2005 20:34

Re: Dixons Freetalk. Cancel line rental
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike
Hi all

This package looks good to me.

I am correct if you get this you can then cancell your exsisting line rental for your phone because it uses the broadband connection. (that would save £126pa) plus you get free uk calls !!!

I am correct in my thinking !

mike

correct it goes via your broadband connection so you can cancel your BT or NTL phone line provided your broadband isn't via ADSL. yes, the package is good if you do loads of UK calls. I use sipgate which is a similar product ie. voice over IP. The prices on freetalk are better for uk mobile calls compared to sipgate during evenings and weekends. I suggest you check what notice period you're on with BT or NTL re cancelling your phone line before you order freetalk.
__________________

nb. it uses 64k upload and 64 download bandwidth so if you're on a low tier then you will struggle to make phone calls and use your broadband connection at the same time.
__________________

Quote:

Originally Posted by david.ewles
Is you phone line BT or NTL, It might not work with an NTL line.

it doesn't go via a phone line mate, it replaces it (if you're happy to lose the 999 facility).

danielf 03-10-2005 20:50

Re: Dixons Freetalk. Cancel line rental
 
Bear in mind that if you have television from NTL you can only cancel your phone line if you cancel the tele as well. They're bundled...

Mike 03-10-2005 22:04

Re: Dixons Freetalk. Cancel line rental
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Bear in mind that if you have television from NTL you can only cancel your phone line if you cancel the tele as well. They're bundled...

OOH dear did not realise they were bundled. Bang goes that plan !

Mike

Mike 04-10-2005 11:19

Dixons Freetalk
 
Hi all

Well I've done it just brought one of these

http://www.freetalk.co.uk

I was paying for talkunlimited £14.50 per month with ntl now paying 6.66 pm for unlimited Uk calls !

All other calls are cheaper like weekend 5p pm to mobiles :) :) :)

If it goes ok I will cancel my ntl line rental (saving £10.50) per month as this uses the broadband connection! So reduced charges from 24.50 per month to 6.66

Mike

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 11:34

Re: Dixons Freetalk
 
do they offer a 14 day money back guarantee if you dont like it?
__________________

what's the call quality like? and what broadband tier are you on? 1meg 2meg or 3meg?
__________________

I thought you weren't able to cancel your phone line as you have the NTL TV service which is bundled with it?

Chris W 04-10-2005 11:37

Re: Dixons Freetalk
 
You started a topic on freetalk just yesterday. One thread is enough thank you, so i'm merging these two.

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 11:43

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
a big benefit over their main competitor, Vonage is that they are cheaper per month and dont have a sneaky cancellation charge if you decide to leave them. Vonage boast that there is no contact which is a bit or a lot misleading as they charge £24 if you wish to leave them.
__________________

you're on a 14 day trial mike so make sure you're happy before day 15!

"freetalk offers a 14 day trial period from the date of activation ("Trial Period") to new users for their first freetalk account. If You are not satisfied with the Services during the Trial Period, You may obtain a refund of the monthly subscription fee from freetalk."
__________________

oh and it looks like Freetalk DO have a sneaky cancellation charge:-

"8.8 Cancellation fee.
If You terminate this Agreement within 12 months from activation of Your Service, You must pay a cancellation fee ("Cancellation Fee"), which is equal to the cost incurred by freetalk in making the Service available to You or £23.99, whichever is the greater. A Cancellation Fee is not payable where You terminate this Agreement after 12 consecutive months of receiving the Service. Cancellation Fees shall be billed to Your Payment Card when You notify us of the cancellation of the Service. The Cancellation Fee shall be waived if You have selected a Monthly Service Plan and terminate the Service during the Trial Period."

Although once you're out of the 12 month period you dont have this fee.

Mike 04-10-2005 12:00

Re: Dixons Freetalk
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
do they offer a 14 day money back guarantee if you dont like it?
__________________

what's the call quality like? and what broadband tier are you on? 1meg 2meg or 3meg?
__________________

I thought you weren't able to cancel your phone line as you have the NTL TV service which is bundled with it?

Call quality is really good..........easy it set up and phone away.

I am on 3mb

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 12:24

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
how are you gonna ditch the phone line as it's bundled? are you jumping ship to sky?

Mike 04-10-2005 14:04

Re: Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike
Call quality is really good..........easy it set up and phone away.

I am on 3mb

I take it all back.................having problems now. Most of the local numbers are engaged via Freetalk but fine on a normal landland. I am not sure why this is and it's driving me a bid mad now.

Any ideas. Thanks Mike

Shaun 04-10-2005 14:21

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Send it back and use www.18866.co.uk

For £6.66 you can make 222 local/national calls in a month, if you don't then you save money.

Never have problems with engaged lines or bad quality calls.:)
__________________

Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
how are you gonna ditch the phone line as it's bundled? are you jumping ship to sky?

If you jump ship to sky you'll have to plug your digi box into a phone line, don't know if Sky allow you to use VOIP lines :confused:

gazzae 04-10-2005 14:26

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun
If you jump ship to sky you'll have to plug your digi box into a phone line, don't know if Sky allow you to use VOIP lines :confused:

Only if you take advantage of one of the subsidised deals, and then only for a year.

SMHarman 04-10-2005 14:36

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun
If you jump ship to sky you'll have to plug your digi box into a phone line, don't know if Sky allow you to use VOIP lines :confused:

How can they tell? Your line will have a standard UK 01 or 02 phone number allocated to it.

Mike 04-10-2005 14:49

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun
Send it back and use www.18866.co.uk

For £6.66 you can make 222 local/national calls in a month, if you don't then you save money.

Never have problems with engaged lines or bad quality calls.:)
:

Extremly good point !

Mike :dunce:

SMHarman 04-10-2005 14:56

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Does require dialing lots of access digits first though.

danielf 04-10-2005 15:01

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman
Does require dialing lots of access digits first though.

Stick it on speed-dial

Mike 04-10-2005 15:17

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike
Extremly good point !

Mike :dunce:


AHHHHHHHHHH But with freetalk you do not pay line rental !

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 15:32

Re: Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike
I take it all back.................having problems now. Most of the local numbers are engaged via Freetalk but fine on a normal landland. I am not sure why this is and it's driving me a bid mad now.

Any ideas. Thanks Mike

try dialling the full code - e.g. 0161 nnnnnnnn instead of just the nnnnnnn bit.

Mike 04-10-2005 16:11

Re: Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
try dialling the full code - e.g. 0161 nnnnnnnn instead of just the nnnnnnn bit.

Tried that but have just spoke to CS in the states !!!

They say they are now on the case and hopefully there will be a fix.

Will let people know

Mike

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 16:35

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
be patient, this isn't the cutting edge... it's the bleeding edge!

new technology and all that. I knew when I got my voip it was also about the experience on being one of the first to adopt a new technology. just make sure if it's failing you return it within 14 days!

Shaun 04-10-2005 17:44

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman
How can they tell? Your line will have a standard UK 01 or 02 phone number allocated to it.

I assumed the service was using the new 056 numbers being allocated to other VOIP lines :confused:

Quote:

056 numbers are a special number block allocated for VoIP use by OFCOM the UK telecoms regulator.

These are designed to be location independent and at the same time be included in standard monthly call plans as if they were a UK geographic number.

https://store.hub.voxhub.net/phones/...undnumbers.jsp

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 17:48

Re: [merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun
I assumed the service was using the new 056 numbers being allocated to other VOIP lines :confused:

no, with vonage, freetalk, sipgate and all decent uk voip providers you get a proper 'normal' phone number.

www.freetalk.co.uk/Features_.aspx#2

"CHOOSE YOUR AREA CODE

Choose a phone number from any of the available UK rate centres, regardless of where your freetalk phone will be physically located. freetalk asks you to specify the "rate centre" (calling area or city name) that you would like to have assigned to your account. There can be many rate centres within one area code. With freetalk, you can request a rate centre that is local to those who call you the most. Rate centre selection does not affect your freetalk calling rates.

When you make calls from your freetalk account, all calls within the UK are included with your flat rate freetalk service. On all of our calling plans, calls between two freetalk subscribers are free and unlimited, anywhere in the world. Remember: freetalk is available to you even if we do not have your local area code or rate centre. Your freetalk area code and phone number is only used for inbound calls. If a more desirable rate centre later becomes available, freetalk will assign a new number to your account. This is a freetalk feature that is free of extra charge. "

Shaun 04-10-2005 17:51

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Makes it a little more attractive but I still cant see it beating 18866 for call costs.:erm:

etccarmageddon 04-10-2005 18:02

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
I think 18866 are the same people who own/run www.voipcheap.co.uk/en/index.html which is voip but doesn't give you a phone number and has ****e support for technical issues.

vonage and freetalk etc are attractive as they are mass market toys aimed at passing trade and non techy people - they also allow you to connect your normal phone to it so it has the appeal of being an (almost) replacement for the BT line.
__________________

the ideal solution would be something like sipgate for incoming calls (so you have a normal phone number) and voipcheap or 18866 etc for your outgoing calls.
__________________

the £80 for a year upfront is a bloody good deal though - if it works! as it includes hardware which would cost you at least £20. my voip box cost me in the region of £50 to get up and running.

Shaun 04-10-2005 18:51

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
the ideal solution would be something like sipgate for incoming calls (so you have a normal phone number) and voipcheap or 18866 etc for your outgoing calls.

I agree, I did mention this the other day, if you're willing to sit at your PC and use firefly then it would be a virtually free service (As voipcheap don't make any charge for uk calls, not even a connection fee).

I believe there are routers (Draytec is the one I've seen mentioned) that can handle this and allow you to plug your home phone in if you don't mind replacing your router.

Stuart 04-10-2005 20:37

Re: Dixons Freetalk. Cancel line rental
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Bear in mind that if you have television from NTL you can only cancel your phone line if you cancel the tele as well. They're bundled...


Also bear in mind that you do really need a phone that can dial 999 in the event of an emergency. Nine times out of ten, a Mobile will be fine, but there's always then tenth where the battery is flat, or you don't have a good signal.

Mike 05-10-2005 13:50

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
01235 local code has now been sorted so I am well happy !

Will leave it a couple of days then cancel ntl phone/tv. It's VOIP for me now.

I have been on a bit of a cost saving fews days because I am broke. Phoned ntl as I was paying 72.39 per month. TV / Phone / Talk unlimited / 3 MB BB.

Their response was : free TV for 6 months / cancelled Talk unlimited / half price BB at 3MB for 18.99 for six months. Just shows what happens if you ask nicely :tu: :tu: :tu: > Customers services :tu:

Mike

etccarmageddon 05-10-2005 14:12

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
if you ring up to cancel your tv and phone I recon they'll offer you a deal to keep it - like half price tv service - I was offered that (a few years back) when I cancelled.

Shaun 06-10-2005 00:29

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
I've been thinking about this again.

Etc. do you know of a hardware solution that would allow you to replace the firefly software in this example :

http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/sh...1&postcount=11

I was wondering if this box would allow you to configure one of the lines as above; with one provider for incoming calls and oinr for outgoing?

http://www.broadbandbuyer.co.uk/Shop...0&ShopGroupID=

etccarmageddon 06-10-2005 19:55

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun
I've been thinking about this again.

Etc. do you know of a hardware solution that would allow you to replace the firefly software in this example :

http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/sh...1&postcount=11

I was wondering if this box would allow you to configure one of the lines as above; with one provider for incoming calls and oinr for outgoing?

http://www.broadbandbuyer.co.uk/Shop...0&ShopGroupID=

ok, firstly that box is the linksys pap2 which is what I have - it's a rebadged Sipura 2000 in a nicer case and a lot cheaper!

www.voiptalk.org/products/Sipura+SPA+2002

yes you can connect 2 VOIP services to it but you would need to use 2 seperate phones.

so perhaps you need a higher spec model... in theory you can setup the sipura 3000 to take your incoming calls from sipgate and pass them through to your phone and use that same line for outgoing via another voip provider.

www.voiptalk.org/products/Sipura+SPA+3000

ok, now there are dedicated forums such as voxilla for all this and it's dam technical - they talk about settings and loads of techy stuff which goes over my head. I researched for hours when I got mine and concluded I wanted the linksys/sipura base model as it was my first venture/experiment into this. the sipura 3000 also has the benefit of being able to route calls to your normal phone line - so really this is aimed at the higher end of the market. I think it's also got a built in router.

here's a couple of threads re what you're attempting to do:-
http://www.voxilla.com/forum-viewtop...ight-2000.html
http://voxilla.com/PNphpBB2-viewtopic-t-6044.html
http://voxilla.com/PNphpBB2-viewtopic-t-6051.html


ok, next problem, the voipcheap/voipbuster provider does not work on this hardware although someone on that forum you quote has said they've managed it - I've not been able to get it to work. your calls dial out but when the other person answers it drops it. it doesnt help that voipbuster shut down their forums a few months back.

Shaun 06-10-2005 20:49

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Well according to this thread:

http://voxilla.com/PNphpBB2-viewtopi...oipbuster.html

It is possible to get VOIPbuster working with it, just wonder if it's possible to get one line forwarded to the other so you don't have to use two phone. :confused:

etccarmageddon 06-10-2005 21:10

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
I suggest you also check this forum out:-

www.voipuser.org/forum_index.html

Shaun 06-10-2005 21:36

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun
It is possible to get VOIPbuster working with it, just wonder if it's possible to get one line forwarded to the other so you don't have to use two phone. :confused:

Well thanks to your links Etc. I think I've answered my own question.

Looks like you can have voipbuster on line one and another provider on line two (who supply your geo number) and forward your calls from 2 to 1. The only issue is whether your geo number supplier allows "reinvites". Apparently Sipgate and the like have that feature disabled.

:banghead:

Guess I'll just have to wait until voipbuster start issuing incoming numbers! :(

etccarmageddon 06-10-2005 21:55

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
what's viopbuster got that's so appealing for you? the free uk calls?

Shaun 06-10-2005 21:58

Re: [Merged] Dixons Freetalk
 
Pretty much, that and free calls to the states.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:56.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum