Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33714041)

Chris 05-10-2026 10:12

Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
… due to being the leader of a party whose official policy is that the State of Israel has no right to exist, which is, regardless of what weasel-worded apologists might try to claim, purely and simply all that Zionism is. The belief in the existence of a nation state called Israel.

If you are a member of the Green Party, and also a Jew who is a member of a synagogue that believes Israel has a right to exist, you are now subject to censure by your political party. The optics are … troubling.

It’s going to make the run-in interesting this week while he tries to get elected to Starmer’s former seat in Holborn. I notice that he and several others are trying to distance themselves from the motion passed at their party conference this past weekend, but thanks to the way the party operates, it is now policy. A policy he might not have voted for, but then he didn’t stand and speak or vote against it either, despite being party leader.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6jdm5n1vy7go

Anyway. Newsflash for anyone who still thinks the Green Party is for tofu-knitting environmentalists. It is a hard left nut hatch inhabited by people with an unhealthy interest in a very specific form of racism that was popular in parts of Europe in the 1930s and sadly, never seems to have quite gone away.

papa smurf 05-10-2026 10:29

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
i thought Israel welcomed Jews

Chris 05-10-2026 10:35

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36223434)
i thought Israel welcomed Jews

Apparently not ones whose job it is to argue that Israel shouldn’t exist.

Apart from that, yes, I believe it’s generally super-easy to emigrate to Israel if you’re Jewish.

papa smurf 05-10-2026 10:47

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223436)
Apparently not ones whose job it is to argue that Israel shouldn’t exist.

Apart from that, yes, I believe it’s generally super-easy to emigrate to Israel if you’re Jewish.

but only if you're the right kind of Jew,with the right opinions,i guess they're not too hot on free speech over there in the promised land, i wonder why they haven't banned all members of the green party, maybe they're working on that

Jaymoss 05-10-2026 11:58

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
A lot of what the conspiracy theorists especially financial blames the Jews for how the financial system is run managed and future planned. I often sit and just nod my head

Chris 05-10-2026 12:16

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36223437)
but only if you're the right kind of Jew,with the right opinions,i guess they're not too hot on free speech over there in the promised land, i wonder why they haven't banned all members of the green party, maybe they're working on that

Do you not think that campaigning for the extinction of an entire country is the sort of thing that could legitimately cause that country not to want you to visit?

TheDaddy 05-10-2026 12:30

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223432)
… due to being the leader of a party whose official policy is that the State of Israel has no right to exist, which is, regardless of what weasel-worded apologists might try to claim, purely and simply all that Zionism is. The belief in the existence of a nation state called Israel.

If you are a member of the Green Party, and also a Jew who is a member of a synagogue that believes Israel has a right to exist, you are now subject to censure by your political party. The optics are … troubling.

It’s going to make the run-in interesting this week while he tries to get elected to Starmer’s former seat in Holborn. I notice that he and several others are trying to distance themselves from the motion passed at their party conference this past weekend, but thanks to the way the party operates, it is now policy. A policy he might not have voted for, but then he didn’t stand and speak or vote against it either, despite being party leader.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6jdm5n1vy7go

Anyway. Newsflash for anyone who still thinks the Green Party is for tofu-knitting environmentalists. It is a hard left nut hatch inhabited by people with an unhealthy interest in a very specific form of racism that was popular in parts of Europe in the 1930s and sadly, never seems to have quite gone away.

Maybe they think all the illegal settlements, occupations and wars as part of the greater Israel/ Revisionist Zionism shouldn't exist...


Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36223437)
but only if you're the right kind of Jew,with the right opinions,i guess they're not too hot on free speech over there in the promised land, i wonder why they haven't banned all members of the green party, maybe they're working on that

I think they label them self loathing Jews it's easy to dismiss legitimate criticism that way, in much the same way it is to label anyone who ever disagrees with any of their governments illegal policies as antisemitic

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223438)
A lot of what the conspiracy theorists especially financial blames the Jews for how the financial system is run managed and future planned. I often sit and just nod my head

What forced the Jews into finance and money lending, was it because they were banned from land ownership and pretty much all trades were closed off to them.

Chris 05-10-2026 12:34

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36223441)
Maybe they think all the illegal settlements, occupations and wars as part of the greater Israel/ Revisionist Zionism shouldn't exist...

Maybe they do. That would be a fair point, if that’s what they actually meant.

But if you think that’s what they mean by ‘Zionism is racism’ you’re wilfully deceiving yourself. The text of the motion is in the public domain. Green Party policy is that there should be a single Palestinian state on the land presently occupied by Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.

TheDaddy 05-10-2026 16:24

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223442)
Maybe they do. That would be a fair point, if that’s what they actually meant.

But if you think that’s what they mean by ‘Zionism is racism’ you’re wilfully deceiving yourself. The text of the motion is in the public domain. Green Party policy is that there should be a single Palestinian state on the land presently occupied by Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.

Isn't that exactly what Netanyahu and his policy currently is, a single Israeli state on the land presently occupied by Israel, Gaza and the West Bank

Chris 05-10-2026 16:34

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36223463)
Isn't that exactly what Netanyahu and his policy currently is, a single Israeli state on the land presently occupied by Israel, Gaza and the West Bank

It is, and it is equally wrong. Not sure what your point is?

TheDaddy 05-10-2026 19:38

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223464)
It is, and it is equally wrong. Not sure what your point is?

It's not equally wrong at all, a minor political party with a Jewish leader saying something a bit controversial doesn't equate to the suppression of an entire population, the killing of journalists, medical staff and a complete disregard of international law, we are getting our priorities completely wrong here imho, that government and its leaders need holding to account and to feel the pressure of international disgust at their actions daily until they stop, it suits them for people to get distracted by a bunch of tofu knitting environmentalists (nice line btw) saying something silly

Paul 05-10-2026 19:43

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Ummm, you said they were equal.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
Isn't that exactly what Netanyahu and his policy currently is

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris
It is, and it is equally wrong.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
It's not equally wrong at all

If they are exactly the same, they must be equally wrong.

TheDaddy 06-10-2026 08:05

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36223481)
Ummm, you said they were equal.




If they are exactly the same, they must be equally wrong.

Except one is an inconsequential Jewish politician in Britain with no power to enforce a Palestinian state or even influence the situation there and the other is a wanted criminal, actually brazenly ensuring there can only be one state, to me that's a world of difference but of course ymmv, happy to clarify for you

papa smurf 06-10-2026 09:37

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
would i be right in saying this was not Polanski's idea and he didn't actually vote for it ?

Damien 06-10-2026 10:38

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36223498)
would i be right in saying this was not Polanski's idea and he didn't actually vote for it ?

Yes. He didn't want the motion tabled at all and wanted an amendment which explicitly stated Jewish people would not be targeted for attending synagogues added, that amendement didn't pass.

Polanski didn't vote or campaign either way. He ignored it entirely to go and campaign in Holborn ahead of the by-election this Thursday there. He clearly didn't want to get involved at all, despite being the leader of the party, which is quite something.

He just doesn't want to make any hard decisions or get involved. Baffling.

Chris 06-10-2026 10:44

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36223499)
Yes. He didn't want the motion tabled at all and wanted an amendment which explicitly stated Jewish people would not be targeted for attending synagogues added, that amendement didn't pass.

Polanski didn't vote or campaign either way. He ignored it entirely to go and campaign in Holborn ahead of the by-election this Thursday there. He clearly didn't want to get involved at all, despite being the leader of the party, which is quite something.

He just doesn't want to make any hard decisions or get involved. Baffling.

Polanski is a useful idiot who is being used by a bunch of raging anti-semites to Jew-wash their agenda into some form of respectability.

---------- Post added at 10:44 ---------- Previous post was at 10:41 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36223495)
Except one is an inconsequential Jewish politician in Britain with no power to enforce a Palestinian state or even influence the situation there and the other is a wanted criminal, actually brazenly ensuring there can only be one state, to me that's a world of difference but of course ymmv, happy to clarify for you

Again, if only Polanski had come up with this idea you might have a point, but he didn’t. Nor did his party.

‘From the river to the sea’ isn’t just a catchy slogan. It is the broadly held belief within Palestinianism - shared by Hamas, though, notably, not the PA in the West Bank - that Israel is entirely illegitimate and only one state, a Palestinian one, should exist.

The fact that Polanski and the Greens are not able to implement their Palestinian one-state solution while Netanyahu is having a go at implementing his does not magnify nor diminish the wrongness of either position.

TheDaddy 06-10-2026 14:50

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36223499)

He just doesn't want to make any hard decisions or get involved. Baffling.

Weak leadership, can't abide by it, get it wrong we're all human but don't abrogate responsibility

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223500)
Again, if only Polanski had come up with this idea you might have a point, but he didn’t. Nor did his party.

‘From the river to the sea’ isn’t just a catchy slogan. It is the broadly held belief within Palestinianism - shared by Hamas, though, notably, not the PA in the West Bank - that Israel is entirely illegitimate and only one state, a Palestinian one, should exist.

The fact that Polanski and the Greens are not able to implement their Palestinian one-state solution while Netanyahu is having a go at implementing his does not magnify nor diminish the wrongness of either position.

We're not going to agree here Chris, whilst technically in a literal definition of words sense, what they've said is the same, the reality for the people that have to live through it, those definitions are entire Worlds apart

Carth 06-10-2026 15:51

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
People can call one set or the other racist, war mongers, or even religious nut jobs, it won't stop things that have been (and will probably continue) happening for years.

Makes me wonder if that region should have been better used for Nuclear bomb tests back in the 40's :erm:

Damien 06-10-2026 16:01

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36223505)
Weak leadership, can't abide by it, get it wrong we're all human but don't abrogate responsibility

Not sure he'll last long. The shine was coming off anyway. He is too online and gets into trouble for liking dodgy Tweets or randomly spouting out things. He is also very America-brained and imports a lot of American left-wing phrasing or policy into the UK - even if it isn't relevant.

He seems to copy a lot of what Mamdani does, but Mamdani has a political philosophy behind his politics. Polanski seems to be cosplaying as a left-wing populist without having done the thinking. It's like he is an LLM trained on left-wing Twitter posts.

The other issue is that the Greens have a one-member, one-vote policy. They have few safeguards around it and allow people to vote as soon as they become a member. It's ripe for Entryism. When Labour had this, they still had enough structures and people with the political know-how to eventually defeat it.

As I understand it, a lot of the traditional Greens wanted, at the very least, the safeguarding amendment to pass, if not the entire policy to be defeated. But they were outnumbered.

jfman 06-10-2026 17:35

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Some applications of Zionism are undoubtedly racist the “we just want somewhere safe” application is extremely narrow, the expansionist biblical Israel being a maximalist interpretation.

Either way what this motion does is allows activists in the Green Party to remove officials who don’t agree with “party policy” culminating in the deselection of candidates who don’t agree with it. Andy Wightman, a former MSP in the Scottish Greens, ostracised for not bowing to the gender cult has posted about this on X.

Where does someone go these days if they don’t have a view on the Middle East, think men are men, and just don’t want nuclear power, want clean oceans and less fossil fuel consumption?

Paul 06-10-2026 21:30

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36223495)
to me that's a world of difference but of course ymmv, happy to clarify for you

Milage has nothing to do with it.
You said they were equal, and in the next post they are different. So which was it ?

Chris 06-10-2026 22:26

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36223514)
Some applications of Zionism are undoubtedly racist the “we just want somewhere safe” application is extremely narrow, the expansionist biblical Israel being a maximalist interpretation.

Either way what this motion does is allows activists in the Green Party to remove officials who don’t agree with “party policy” culminating in the deselection of candidates who don’t agree with it. Andy Wightman, a former MSP in the Scottish Greens, ostracised for not bowing to the gender cult has posted about this on X.

Where does someone go these days if they don’t have a view on the Middle East, think men are men, and just don’t want nuclear power, want clean oceans and less fossil fuel consumption?

Well quite. There are Zionists and there are Zionists, just as there are Calvinists and there are Calvinists. Political and religious ideologies are often broad churches.

Helpfully, the Green Party motion is abundantly clear on its definition of Zionism. The document they passed is here:

https://static1.squarespace.com/stat...c+A5+amend.pdf

And helpfully, you only have to read the 4-line synopsis at the top to understand without any doubt that the Green Party of England and Wales has adopted, as its official policy, to advocate for the abolition of the entire state of Israel and the establishment of a State of Palestine on all of that territory.

TheDaddy 06-10-2026 23:56

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36223522)
Milage has nothing to do with it.
You said they were equal, and in the next post they are different. So which was it ?

The words are equal but the meaning is dramatically different, ones words are inconsequential to pretty much everyone and the others has dire consequences for millions of people, that's why the milage varies, it's word games to some, life and death to others

Dude111 07-10-2026 06:42

It muse be hard to keep someone out of a whole country!

Paul 07-10-2026 17:48

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Not really, I would think the only practical ways in are closely monitored.

Damien 08-10-2026 08:54

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Yeah, I doubt Israel has an issue with border control.

1andrew1 08-10-2026 13:07

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36223499)
He just doesn't want to make any hard decisions or get involved. Baffling.

Exactly.

If he's going to survive as leader of the Green Party, he's going to have to grow up and start acting as a leader and not just as a regular member. As that's what he'll likely become at this rate.

Chris 09-10-2026 17:54

Re: Zack Polanski gets banned from Israel
 
Well, he crashed and burned in Holborn. Not even close.

Their spin operation has been banging on all day about how much they increased their vote, but it’s a by election, the seat was held by the party of government, and 8 weeks ago everyone thought it was worth a punt on him doing it.

Fortunately for the residents of Holborn and St Pancras, the vote came a week after the Green Party of E&W showed everyone how utterly bat-!!!! Crazy they are. Bullet well and truly dodged.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:39.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum