Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Internet Tax To Fund The BBC! (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33714025)

damien c 23-09-2026 20:34

Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
So I think it's plainly obvious by now, I don't hold back, I say it how it is and if you don't like it well, sorry but it's true and I will not sugar coat things for the sake of the "I don't like the truth it hurts my feelings" crowd.

The BBC has had and still has Liars, Thieves, Rapists and Pedo's working there, who knows how many because we as TV Tax payers have and are funding the cover ups, that have happened and are still happening to this day!

Forgive me if there is a thread for the Tv Tax already, I did look for one but couldn't find it.

It seems though that another think tank/nut job activist group are recommending to scrap the license fee and instead force a tax on the Internet connections for UK Residents!

This is just one source for it: OC3D
https://overclock3d.net/news/misc/11...e-alternative/


Basically it will mean that you have to pay the wages for all the staff at the BBC, including the liars, thieves, rapists, pedophiles and other criminals regardless of whether you want to or not, so long as you have an Internet Connection you will be paying for them!

So the only way if this goes through to not pay for it, is to basically not have the Internet or at least not have an internet connection from the UK as good luck to the power hungry Ofcom telling the likes of Germany and America that they must charge their customers more because they might be accessing content in the UK!

All this to apparently keep producing the "world-class TV" that has killed once great TV Shows like Dr Who and producing content that pays terrorist's for interviews, that produces content that has to be corrected, removed and then have an apology written although that is never fully made public as the false information is quickly removed from the site to avoid public scrutiny.


I will tell you something now, if this does actually come in and get put in place, I will be looking at an Internet source from another country because I will not be paying more for Internet to pay for something that the BBC have no involvement in, the only reason we pay the TV Tax now as it is, is because my Mum refuses to use Plex, Netflix, Prime or Disney+ and instead watches practically nothing but the Movies24 or what ever it is channel, despite the same films being repeated every couple of hours on rotating days.

Mr K 23-09-2026 20:40

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
That suggestion has been around for years. The Daily Fail resurrrected it today as they are a bit lazy and were due another anti BBC 'story'.

We're going to pay one way or another. General taxation seems fair if people don't want the licence fee as its unlike other broadcasters and has a public service remit.

Jaymoss 23-09-2026 20:45

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
never gonna pass. Can not see how it could be legal

damien c 24-09-2026 08:31

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222831)
never gonna pass. Can not see how it could be legal

They get away with stealing money now from people for content they have no involvement in, for doing nothing but existing so this wouldn't be anything new for them.

Since we also have spineless and toothless regulators as well as Governments that were/are spineless and toothless when it comes to the BBC they will just leave them to it and give them what they want.


The problem with the £11 or whatever they decide on though is that it will need to be for all Internet connections, so your car even though technically you cannot use it for TV etc, someone will find a way, then your mobile phone because you can use that, then you smart devices that have a built in sim so in the end you could be looking at upwards of £50 a month depending on number of devices, I am sure the BBC would love that instead of the current mere in their eyes £15 a month, they need the extra money to add to the billions they get from selling shows abroad, they have got to make the money somehow to pay off the victims of their stars and the extortionate salaries they pay them.

The aim of the BBC and the nutjobs like "The Social Market Foundation" is that we all pay for one source of information and that there is only one source of information and that is the BBC and we currently have a Government who is in the process of trying to make that happen, as mentioned a while ago in the OSA Thread.

What I think though is that the Government will just give the BBC another 6 years of being able to charge the TV Tax and then also expand it to cover not just what it does now but basically any media regardless of source and regardless of whether it's live or not.

Jaymoss 24-09-2026 08:34

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Yes they get away with it now but it is an archaic out of date system they keep renewing because they have not come up with a better idea. Taxing people for what has become a necessity instead of a luxury I just do not see it happening

The trying to control information part will not win any party votes as well as the electorate and I have never seen a politician that is not thinking about the next election

damien c 24-09-2026 08:43

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222829)
That suggestion has been around for years. The Daily Fail resurrrected it today as they are a bit lazy and were due another anti BBC 'story'.

We're going to pay one way or another. General taxation seems fair if people don't want the licence fee as its unlike other broadcasters and has a public service remit.

It was resurrected because the "The Social Market Foundation" has done an article about it on their website.

https://www.smf.co.uk/publications/v...c-licence-fee/

Dated 23/09/2026

The problem is, the nutjobs at that place have the ear of the Government because it was founded by the nutjobs in the "Social Democratic Party" so it claims to be "Independent" but then it's founding members are/were members of a political party aimed at destroying the country!

The thing is though, there is going to be even more talk about this sort of thing next year whilst the BBC try to get as much money as possible from people.

Personally I would rather see the BBC ask people to choose if they want to pay for the BBC's services or not via a subscription like Netflix etc but we all know they won't because their funding would drop by more than 50% overnight.

---------- Post added at 08:43 ---------- Previous post was at 08:38 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222840)
Yes they get away with it now but it is an archaic out of date system they keep renewing because they have not come up with a better idea. Taxing people for what has become a necessity instead of a luxury I just do not see it happening

The trying to control information part will not win any party votes as well as the electorate and I have never seen a politician that is not thinking about the next election

They are already doing it, the plans are in place and they are pushing it through.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/p...edia-in-the-uk

It's not just in the UK either, Australia currently ran by the Labour Party have just done the same thing or pushing it through and using the "Childrens Safety" thing to do it.

The Government will control what is reported, how it's reported and when it's reported, what you can see and what you can't by making companies only show what they approve.

So the TV Tax will also be used to fund Government Propaganda broadcasts (already is according to many) and to stop the opposition from being heard or seen.

Jaymoss 24-09-2026 08:47

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
They should just run a business model the same as everyone else who is not sub based and have their funding come from adverts . They would reach more people than any other ad funded service because they have hordes of local national and international stations. It really is not rocket science

---------- Post added at 08:47 ---------- Previous post was at 08:45 ----------

Damion plans for prominence of trusted news services is not "We are going to to give it the BBC. It is plural for a reason there is not only one. Oh my I can not wait for the Highlander Remake.


I am sure I have ADHD hahahaha

Carth 24-09-2026 09:17

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
The Internet, something that has evolved and been pushed so far into our lives that many now can't 'manage' without it.
Is it any wonder that someone, somewhere, was going to see it as a massive source of income (tax haha) and try a cash grab?

Jaymoss 24-09-2026 10:07

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36222845)
The Internet, something that has evolved and been pushed so far into our lives that many now can't 'manage' without it.
Is it any wonder that someone, somewhere, was going to see it as a massive source of income (tax haha) and try a cash grab?

but they are already getting tax on the revenue

Taf 24-09-2026 10:22

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Belgian TV in the Flemish areas was switched to direct taxation for income, whilst the Walloons stuck to an annual licence fee.

The whole country has been pushing the EU towards an internet tax based on usage, but the Eurocrats have been stalling on that for many years.

Anonymouse 24-09-2026 10:22

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
I can't manage without the Internet - I use it for my jobsearching - but I'll be damned if I'll pay any more than I am doing now!

Funding the BBC? The obsolete licence already does that. I won't pay to fund a service I never use. I think that figure of 2% for people without TVs has increased - and will increase further if this madness goes ahead. They'll be shooting themselves in the foot.

Can you get Internet access via another country? If you can, said country is going to have a lot more business.

Carth 24-09-2026 10:45

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Anonymouse (Post 36222848)
I can't manage without the Internet - I use it for my jobsearching - but I'll be damned if I'll pay any more than I am doing now!

Funding the BBC? The obsolete licence already does that. I won't pay to fund a service I never use. I think that figure of 2% for people without TVs has increased - and will increase further if this madness goes ahead. They'll be shooting themselves in the foot.

Can you get Internet access via another country? If you can, said country is going to have a lot more business.

I dare say there are a few that would welcome you with open arms . . of course whether you accept the invitation or not depends on your personal definitions of trust and security ;)

TheDaddy 24-09-2026 10:49

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222843)
They should just run a business model the same as everyone else who is not sub based and have their funding come from adverts . They would reach more people than any other ad funded service because they have hordes of local national and international stations. It really is not rocket science

Actually it's a lot more complicated than that given there is s finite amount of advertising money available, it'd put a lot of tv and radio stations out of business and those local radio stations are shadows of their former selves with listener ship in the tens of people

Hugh 24-09-2026 12:00

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Anonymouse (Post 36222848)
I can't manage without the Internet - I use it for my jobsearching - but I'll be damned if I'll pay any more than I am doing now!

Funding the BBC? The obsolete licence already does that. I won't pay to fund a service I never use. I think that figure of 2% for people without TVs has increased - and will increase further if this madness goes ahead. They'll be shooting themselves in the foot.

Can you get Internet access via another country? If you can, said country is going to have a lot more business.

You may not have fully thought this through - how do you get a connection from your home to another country, to have access via the other country?

There’s always Starlink…

1andrew1 24-09-2026 12:08

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Makes sense as Freeview will shut down in a few years' time. :D

papa smurf 24-09-2026 12:09

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222854)
You may not have fully thought this through - how do you get a connection from your home to another country, to have access via the other country?

There’s always Starlink…

sounds like a problem for AI or someone really clever like donald trump:erm:

is there a lower price for black and white internet

Carth 24-09-2026 12:14

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Would Ireland count as another Country? ;)

https://www.irishtimes.com/business/...-live-1.468438

Quote:

A €12.5 million fibre optic gateway running below the Irish Sea has gone live, offering the shortest available data connection between Ireland and Britain.

The 131km-long CeltixConnect cable – which is owned and operated by Sea Fibre Networks – will provide a high-speed link between Dublin, Manchester and London.
:D :naughty:

papa smurf 24-09-2026 12:17

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
how about pirate broad band broadcasting from the north sea,welcome to Caroline bb

Jaymoss 24-09-2026 12:19

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222859)
how about pirate broad band broadcasting from the north sea,welcome to Caroline bb

order starlink when you are holiday in France bring it back and tell no one haha

papa smurf 24-09-2026 12:23

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222860)
order starlink when you are holiday in France bring it back and tell no one haha

not cost effective

Jaymoss 24-09-2026 12:43

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222861)
not cost effective

no but it was a joke

papa smurf 24-09-2026 12:52

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222863)
no but it was a joke

i'm hoping the internet tax is a joke

Jaymoss 24-09-2026 13:03

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
for once we agree

Carth 24-09-2026 13:05

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222859)
how about pirate broad band broadcasting from the north sea,welcome to Caroline bb

I still listen to Radio Caroline :D

1andrew1 24-09-2026 13:28

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36222866)
I still listen to Radio Caroline :D

Still going strong I see (Radio Caroline that is. ;))

https://www.radiocaroline.co.uk/#home.html

Carth 24-09-2026 15:19

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36222869)
Still going strong I see (Radio Caroline that is. ;))

https://www.radiocaroline.co.uk/#home.html

This is my 'go to' page, 7 day playlist
https://onlineradiobox.com/uk/radiocaroline/playlist/

. . . so I can see what the track was I just heard but didn't catch the name of ;)

Richardr 24-09-2026 20:49

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222831)
never gonna pass. Can not see how it could be legal

Why would it not be legal? There is already 20% VAT on broadband.

jem 24-09-2026 20:51

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222831)
never gonna pass. Can not see how it could be legal

If it is agreed by Parliament, then by definition, it is legal.

Jaymoss 25-09-2026 05:02

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jem (Post 36222899)
If it is agreed by Parliament, then by definition, it is legal.


Errrm no. How many times has government policy found to be unlawful?

Hugh 25-09-2026 05:58

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jem (Post 36222899)
If it is agreed by Parliament, then by definition, it is legal.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222904)
Errrm no. How many times has government policy found to be unlawful?

Two different things…

Jaymoss 25-09-2026 06:13

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222905)
Two different things…

well if you want to correct me educate me ..

Hugh 25-09-2026 07:20

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Build a man a fire, he’s warm for one night - set a man on fire, he’s warm for the rest of his life*

OK, I’ll educate you, but I won’t give you the answer…

If you google "difference between law and government policy UK”, that will provide you the answer.

*T. Pratchett, Jingo

peanut 25-09-2026 07:37

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222909)
Build a man a fire, he’s warm for one night - set a man on fire, he’s warm for the rest of his life*

OK, I’ll educate you, but I won’t give you the answer…

If you google "difference between law and government policy UK”, that will provide you the answer.

*T. Pratchett, Jingo

I googled haughty and pretentious instead.

papa smurf 25-09-2026 07:44

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36222911)
I googled haughty and pretentious instead.

:tu:

Jaymoss 25-09-2026 07:53

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222909)
Build a man a fire, he’s warm for one night - set a man on fire, he’s warm for the rest of his life*

OK, I’ll educate you, but I won’t give you the answer…

If you google "difference between law and government policy UK”, that will provide you the answer.

*T. Pratchett, Jingo

So basically you will say I am wrong and when I ask how I am wrong you decided to speak total BS . What is the point of that? all you have achieved is me keeping my view on this subject and lowering my opinion of you. ( I know you do not care)

---------- Post added at 07:49 ---------- Previous post was at 07:48 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36222911)
I googled haughty and pretentious instead.

yeah 100%

---------- Post added at 07:53 ---------- Previous post was at 07:49 ----------

Just for reference The UK Court of Appeal ruled that anti-protest regulations pushed through by former Home Secretary Suella Braverman were unlawful and void

So it does happen with Law and policy (I can use Google)

Hugh 25-09-2026 08:34

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
1 Attachment(s)
Laws and policies are two different things - a law is passed by legislation, and a policy is how the Government intends to carry out its aims.

The fact that both can be declared unlawful does not make them the same…

https://unifiedcourse.co.uk/differen...on-and-policy/

Quote:

Legislation and policy often sound similar. So people usually think legislation and policy are the same. But the fact is, there’s a day-night difference between them. You can’t understand it properly until you know the difference between legislation and policy. It’s the only way to differentiate the two words. So, what’s the difference?

Legislation is the law. The government and Parliament make it mandatory for everyone to follow it. Laws set the rules that keep people and organisations safe and fair. At the same time, policy is a plan. Governments and organisations write policies to show how they will follow the law.
https://www.cableforum.uk/board/atta...5&d=1790321850

papa smurf 25-09-2026 08:42

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
:dig:

Jaymoss 25-09-2026 09:32

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222917)
Laws and policies are two different things - a law is passed by legislation, and a policy is how the Government intends to carry out its aims.

The fact that both can be declared unlawful does not make them the same…

https://unifiedcourse.co.uk/differen...on-and-policy/



https://www.cableforum.uk/board/atta...5&d=1790321850

Thank you and I bet it did not hurt

Hugh 25-09-2026 10:57

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
You’re welcome, and I apologise for my previous post - it was inappropriate and unnecessary.

papa smurf 25-09-2026 11:28

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
just the one post then, [asking for a friend of a friend ....]

Jaymoss 25-09-2026 11:51

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222925)
You’re welcome, and I apologise for my previous post - it was inappropriate and unnecessary.

Fair play Hugh respect that :-)

jem 25-09-2026 20:20

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222927)
Fair play Hugh respect that :-)

Hopefully to provide some clarification, in the UK Parliament is supreme, what they decide is law, that's it, no ifs or buts, no 'this can't be legal'.

An Act of Parliament is primary legislation, that's it, literally what is stated in the wording of the Act is law - every court has to accept it, every person / institution has to obey it, or else.

Now it is understood that it really isn't possible to cover every eventuality so some laws allow government ministers to make decisions on what is allowed or not. This is called secondary legislation, and this can be called into question by courts.

"Just for reference The UK Court of Appeal ruled that anti-protest regulations pushed through by former Home Secretary Suella Braverman were unlawful and void"

And this is an example of this, the Court rules that Braverman has exceeded her authority and that the primary legislation did not permit her to make such regulations.

Richardr 25-09-2026 20:25

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222904)
Errrm no. How many times has government policy found to be unlawful?

You are saying that an increase in tax on broadband would be unlawful. When has the increase in tax on anything been found illegal?

Jaymoss 25-09-2026 20:56

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Richardr (Post 36222948)
You are saying that an increase in tax on broadband would be unlawful. When has the increase in tax on anything been found illegal?

it is ok I accept I have had it disproven and given the information to correct me. I am happy to learn . You did not add anything

---------- Post added at 20:56 ---------- Previous post was at 20:55 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by jem (Post 36222945)
Hopefully to provide some clarification, in the UK Parliament is supreme, what they decide is law, that's it, no ifs or buts, no 'this can't be legal'.

An Act of Parliament is primary legislation, that's it, literally what is stated in the wording of the Act is law - every court has to accept it, every person / institution has to obey it, or else.

Now it is understood that it really isn't possible to cover every eventuality so some laws allow government ministers to make decisions on what is allowed or not. This is called secondary legislation, and this can be called into question by courts.

"Just for reference The UK Court of Appeal ruled that anti-protest regulations pushed through by former Home Secretary Suella Braverman were unlawful and void"

And this is an example of this, the Court rules that Braverman has exceeded her authority and that the primary legislation did not permit her to make such regulations.

Thanks for the info mate appreciate it

Chris 25-09-2026 23:44

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222863)
no but it was a joke

While acknowledging you were joking …

The reason it wouldn’t work is, I think, because Starlink geolocates you so they’d know you weren’t using it where you said you were. The fact they ask where you’re going to use it when you sign up is, I suspect, enough to suggest they’d stop you doing it.

There is a ‘use anywhere’ version of the service but it’s more expensive, and therefore unlikely to save a UK user anything in comparison to just paying a broadband tax.

---------- Post added at 23:44 ---------- Previous post was at 23:33 ----------

As long as Parliament wills that the UK should have a fully, publicly-funded public service broadcaster, Parliament is going to have to take an interest in whether the way money is collected for this is effective. It has long been a fallacious argument, based on wishful thinking, that if the TV licence became unworkable, then public funding for the BBC would somehow simply just go away. That idea always did fail to understand what ultimately stands behind the TV licence. It is, and always has been, the idea that the UK should have a public service broadcaster for which everyone pays regardless of how much they access it.

“I don’t use the BBC so why should I pay for it” doesn’t answer this argument, because in this sense the BBC is seen as providing a utility, and like all public utilities, we use them to varying degrees or not at all, but through tax we all pay for them. As long as the government of the day continues to view the BBC as a Public Service Broadcaster in these terms, then it is going to start looking at more viable ways for it to be publicly funded.

A broadband tax isn’t as outre as it might first seem, given that in the long run there’s an obvious desire to move to IP-based delivery of broadcast TV in the UK (even if it’s likely to take much longer to get there than some believe).

Jaymoss 26-09-2026 06:27

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
We are in the middle of a cost of living crisis with souring energy bills predicted to rise 25% in January and fuel prices being what they are . Any governement taking serious the increase of a charge for something like the BBC will create uproar. I just do not see it happening

peanut 26-09-2026 07:48

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222967)
We are in the middle of a cost of living crisis with souring energy bills predicted to rise 25% in January and fuel prices being what they are . Any governement taking serious the increase of a charge for something like the BBC will create uproar. I just do not see it happening

I totally get that. But the objection to this is going to be from those that do not pay for their TV licence. Saying you don't watch BBC is a bit contentious at best, or saying don't have a TV (pushing it). If it's cheaper than the licence fee now then there'll be a lot that will agree to it.

But then there's that choice in paying for it than being forced to pay for it is the main point. But I don't know what the internet and a broadband 'tax' has anything to do with the BBC. So basically using this tax as an excuse and nothing more to make people pay it. That is something I don't agree with.

At least this way there's be no more needs to have vans to parked up outside your house with their radars to see if you're watch the BBC, lol.

Jaymoss 26-09-2026 08:05

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Radical idea why not let the public vote on it after all they are civil servants and should be serving those who voted them in . A group of rich out of touch elite making decisions for us without even consulting us

Simple vote do you want to keep the BBC as is or not. Lets me honest the BBC has lost a lot of faith over the last 20 years and the age of unquestioned propaganda is long since gone .

Mr K 26-09-2026 09:51

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222969)
Radical idea why not let the public vote on it after all they are civil servants and should be serving those who voted them in . A group of rich out of touch elite making decisions for us without even consulting us

Simple vote do you want to keep the BBC as is or not. Lets me honest the BBC has lost a lot of faith over the last 20 years and the age of unquestioned propaganda is long since gone .

Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

Jaymoss 26-09-2026 10:05

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222973)
Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

bit different running a country to running a television and radio broadcaster

Paul 26-09-2026 10:10

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222973)
Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

I think that would apply to VAT as well, or any kind of tax.

papa smurf 26-09-2026 10:55

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222973)
Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

do labour voters pay income tax on their benefits, i thought it was the right wingers who worked and paid tax so labour voters didn't have to

Carth 26-09-2026 13:15

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222980)
do labour voters pay income tax on their benefits, i thought it was the right wingers who worked and paid tax so labour voters didn't have to

I've no idea Papa, just be careful you don't mention pensioners in case everyone goes into meltdown ;)

papa smurf 26-09-2026 13:30

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36222984)
I've no idea Papa, just be careful you don't mention pensioners in case everyone goes into meltdown ;)

mr k has triple lock envy so i won't mention the rise in pension

Hugh 26-09-2026 13:37

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222980)
do labour voters pay income tax on their benefits, i thought it was the right wingers who worked and paid tax so labour voters didn't have to

Like many of your "thoughts", it is not congruent with actuality… ;)

papa smurf 26-09-2026 13:39

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222987)
Like many of your "thoughts", it is not congruent with actuality… ;)

you'll be trying to tell us you know a labour voter with a job next

Sirius 26-09-2026 15:41

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222988)
you'll be trying to tell us you know a labour voter with a job next


:LOL::LOL:

Chris 26-09-2026 18:13

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222969)
Radical idea why not let the public vote on it after all they are civil servants and should be serving those who voted them in . A group of rich out of touch elite making decisions for us without even consulting us

Simple vote do you want to keep the BBC as is or not. Lets me honest the BBC has lost a lot of faith over the last 20 years and the age of unquestioned propaganda is long since gone .

The BBC is very much the author of its own misfortune. The endless corporate reads over closing credits, thanking people for paying their TVL, and the seemingly endless variants of that annoying Romesh advert they keep playing, is some indication of how deep in the doo-doo they know they are. Cancelling Ru Paul’s Womanface Minstrel Show is perhaps a small but interesting insight into how they might be starting to realise that their cultural obsessions have been turning people off.

Funding the BBC out of general taxation has long been considered a no-no because it puts the BBC much more directly at the mercy of government which isn’t a good look for a broadcaster that’s supposed to be impartial. The present system allows the BBC to manage collection itself (even though the licence fee money still passes through the government’s general fund on its way to broadcasting house).

A service tax, even a hypothecated one, makes the management and collection of the money an HMRC matter which the BBC might be uncomfortable with. But then again, they’re losing money hand over fist right now, and they’re clearly getting desperate, so who knows what might happen.

Itshim 26-09-2026 19:39

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Really wonder how many presenters they need on a show ie morning live , 6 + . Another bug is at least on BBC Wales one weather forecast followed be another one . Even question why you need someone else to tell you what it is. Also noticed that local channel reports on something ie plane crash on Anglesey.and nation channel then reports the same thing with a different presenter .

damien c 28-09-2026 08:43

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36222968)
I totally get that. But the objection to this is going to be from those that do not pay for their TV licence. Saying you don't watch BBC is a bit contentious at best, or saying don't have a TV (pushing it). If it's cheaper than the licence fee now then there'll be a lot that will agree to it.

But then there's that choice in paying for it than being forced to pay for it is the main point. But I don't know what the internet and a broadband 'tax' has anything to do with the BBC. So basically using this tax as an excuse and nothing more to make people pay it. That is something I don't agree with.

At least this way there's be no more needs to have vans to parked up outside your house with their radars to see if you're watch the BBC, lol.

The "TV TAX" should be for BBC programmes only, and if you don't watch them you should not pay it.

I have never once had anyone answer the question as to why the BBC need to be paid for me watching something that they have had zero involvement in?

That would be like me saying, "you have food in your house, as such you need to pay £200 a year to eat that food, doesn't matter where it came from, who produced it etc, you owe me £200 because you have it", now you might say that is ridiculous but that is exactly what the TV Tax is currently and will be when the clowns allow this "Internet Tax" to be used instead of a "TV Tax".

As it is Burnham has already basically said that by the next election he will be raising taxes even more, so the people in the country already struggling because cost's are increasing because of this clueless clown show of a government, are going to be struggling even more so, because Burnham is going to increase taxes so he can give more money to the people who shouldn't be getting more money!

I think it would be stupid of Labour to do this, but they have done much stupider things so we will just have to wait and see, but it will be interesting to see how many times you have to pay for it, because they may try to add it to each connection which for this house that would £88 a month!

Let's see someone justify £11 per device!

Jaymoss 28-09-2026 09:21

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Where did the £11 per device come from ?

You are only connected to the network once the rest is distributed to devices connected to DHCP you know this

Unless you are thinking it will be added to cellular networks also? this of course is something else that will not happen imo

---------- Post added at 09:21 ---------- Previous post was at 08:58 ----------

According to the daily express the £11 levy is on fixed BB so guess who will dump FTTP and stick with 5G

---------- Post added at 09:21 ---------- Previous post was at 09:21 ----------

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/22...box=1790350667

tweetiepooh 28-09-2026 09:45

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
The BBC should not be funded by any mechanism the government or any other external body has control over.
The license fee, which isn't really that much, covers radio and TV broadcasting and programme making. The point of the license is that it allows the BBC to make programmes that are potentially non-commercially viable (and advertising TV to make sure the BBC doesn't just produce such programming).
As license payers, the BBC is responsible to us, and it it there it has missed the ball. Rising costs mean the BBC feels unable to justify broadcasting some sporting events, and rising production costs unable to want to take chances as much. The BBC also needs to get it courage up and sometimes be unpopular, with both government and populace.

Jaymoss 28-09-2026 09:52

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
I would miss radio 2 that is all

Chris 28-09-2026 11:27

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tweetiepooh (Post 36223047)
The BBC should not be funded by any mechanism the government or any other external body has control over.
The license fee, which isn't really that much, covers radio and TV broadcasting and programme making. The point of the license is that it allows the BBC to make programmes that are potentially non-commercially viable (and advertising TV to make sure the BBC doesn't just produce such programming).
As license payers, the BBC is responsible to us, and it it there it has missed the ball. Rising costs mean the BBC feels unable to justify broadcasting some sporting events, and rising production costs unable to want to take chances as much. The BBC also needs to get it courage up and sometimes be unpopular, with both government and populace.

The BBC’s main problem is that with the rise of multi-channel TV it has become more and more difficult to justify the argument that ‘nobody else is making this’. It has become easier for people to claim they never watch it, and as there are so many rival places you can take out a subscription, the concept of the TV licence as ‘pay once, get everything’ is long since gone.

Channel 4 is relentlessly avant garde, and with only commercial income to support it. Sky Arts has an enviable reputation. Netflix and Apple TV are surprisingly good at making British-focused shows and Apple TV’s line up includes a lot of stuff you might have seen once upon a time on the BBC, back in the day when it had a ton more imagination than it has now (and was producing the likes of Life on Mars and Hustle, and bravely recommissioning Doctor Who as unashamedly family teatime entertainment).

Secondary to this, though still significant, is that the BBC has a very obvious cultural bias that it has long ceased pretending not to have. Its most obvious manifestation of that is its relentless shoehorning of drag queens into its mainstream schedule, which has nothing to do with the cabaret acts of old like Dame Edna or Lily Savage, and everything to do with a conscious attempt to participate in the queering of mainstream culture and entertainment. This same intent manifests in plenty of other ways too which I won’t list here.

There is still a public service argument to be made. The BBC’s funding level allows it to commission more, of a higher quality, than the size of the UK market would otherwise support. It thereby sets a bar commercial challengers are forced to reach with their own prime time content, and facilitates the training and employment of vast numbers of creative professionals who then pop up all over the world, as well as attracting some of the biggest film and TV productions in the world to these shores, where there is talent and infrastructure.

However, what cable and satellite subscriptions couldn’t kill, streaming subscriptions might. The TVL is far too broadly perceived as a subscription which people ought to be able to opt out of. And too many people now do, even though they break the law by doing so. Ultimately in an open democracy laws only work when people consent to be governed by them. When they are wholesale flouted, then government either has to take extreme measures to enforce, or recognise there’s no democratic consent for the law as it stands and come up with something else.

I suspect we are on the cusp of the ‘something else’ - and whatever it looks like, the BBC will still be a universally funded, free to access service at the end of it.

Carth 28-09-2026 11:44

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
From the odd bits of TV I inadvertently catch because her indoors has it on, it seems now to mainly consist of the format:

"let's think of an exciting show where celebrities do stupid things, then get even stupider celebrities to do them"

Itshim 28-09-2026 12:07

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36223054)
From the odd bits of TV I inadvertently catch because her indoo

"let's think of an exciting show where celebrities do stupid things, then get even stupider celebrities to do them"

As it has been for more years than I care to remember. Really wonder if you have to take an intelligence test to appear on a quiz show , failing it gets you on:dunce:

---------- Post added at 12:07 ---------- Previous post was at 12:04 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36222968)
I totally get that. But the objection to this is going to be from those that do not pay for their TV licence. Saying you don't watch BBC is a bit contentious at best, or saying don't have a TV (pushing it). If it's cheaper than the licence fee now then there'll be a lot that will agree to it.

But then there's that choice in paying for it than being forced to pay for it is the main point. But I don't know what the internet and a broadband 'tax' has anything to do with the BBC. So basically using this tax as an excuse and nothing more to make people pay it. That is something I don't agree with.

At least this way there's be no more needs to have vans to parked up outside your house with their radars to see if you're watch the BBC, lol.

Don't use don't pay l am all for that. Don't use ..... Buses , schools , NHS hospitals or GP ( at least up till now) council rubbish collection. Social services , bike lanes , childrens play grounds the list goes on. So yes all for it.

Carth 28-09-2026 12:15

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Itshim (Post 36223059)
<snippety thingy>

Don't use don't pay l am all for that. Don't use ..... Buses , schools , NHS hospitals or GP ( at least up till now) council rubbish collection. Social services , bike lanes , childrens play grounds the list goes on. So yes all for it.

Sounds reasonable to me :Yes:

damien c 28-09-2026 12:33

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223042)
Where did the £11 per device come from ?

You are only connected to the network once the rest is distributed to devices connected to DHCP you know this

Unless you are thinking it will be added to cellular networks also? this of course is something else that will not happen imo

---------- Post added at 09:21 ---------- Previous post was at 08:58 ----------

According to the daily express the £11 levy is on fixed BB so guess who will dump FTTP and stick with 5G

---------- Post added at 09:21 ---------- Previous post was at 09:21 ----------

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/22...box=1790350667

I understand about DHCP and perhaps I should have been clearer.

If they charge the £11 per Internet Connection, so a mobile phone, we have 3 mobile phones all with a data tariff, we then have the normal home broadband, so that is 4 connections, then I have 4x Mobile Sim's that can each be activated to provide data connections to increase bandwidth if needed and also provide internet when the VM connection goes down.


For the average house with 2 adults and 2 kids, that will be 5 connections all charged at £11 extra if it goes the way of "we will just charge all connections".

Tell me who is going to pay £55 extra per month just because they have devices with a data package!

We all know the BBC will try and get as much as possible and we all know this government will roll over and give into what ever a union or totally legit donor will demand so it is quite frankly inevitable.

Jaymoss 28-09-2026 15:02

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Yeah the Express says it is Fixed Broadband which cellular is not so my 5G router would be exempt if that is the case which makes sense

Carth 28-09-2026 15:52

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
I can understand the Government wanting more money (which they'll probably waste on more crap we don't want or need), but why tax the user instead of taxing the provider, after all it's them that dig roads and pavements up and cause disruptions, not us :erm:

jem 28-09-2026 19:46

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36223074)
I can understand the Government wanting more money (which they'll probably waste on more crap we don't want or need), but why tax the user instead of taxing the provider, after all it's them that dig roads and pavements up and cause disruptions, not us :erm:

"but why tax the user instead of taxing the provider, after all it's them that dig roads and pavements up and cause disruptions, not us “

No, no, sorry, you have lost me here. So they tax, (I assume you mean the ISPs) the providers, who will all simply pass that on to their customers by raising prices.

Paul 28-09-2026 23:50

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by damien c (Post 36223041)
Let's see someone justify £11 per device!

No one has to justify that since its never been the claim, it would be £11 per household, or possibly per BB connection, much like the licence now is per household.

damien c 30-09-2026 07:26

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36223100)
No one has to justify that since its never been the claim, it would be £11 per household, or possibly per BB connection, much like the licence now is per household.

That right there is the "£11 per device", again £11 for each mobile phone with a data plan, £11 for each broadband connection, £11 for each tablet with a data plan, £11 for your car if it has a data sim in it.


So if this "internet tax" does come in, to replace the TV Tax let's see how they charge for it and what it does to the economy!

Jaymoss 30-09-2026 07:34

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by damien c (Post 36223180)
That right there is the "£11 per device", again £11 for each mobile phone with a data plan, £11 for each broadband connection, £11 for each tablet with a data plan, £11 for your car if it has a data sim in it.


So if this "internet tax" does come in, to replace the TV Tax let's see how they charge for it and what it does to the economy!

Not a single report I have read has said anything about anything other than taxing a "FIXED" broadband connection. Cellular Data does not count as fixed

damien c 30-09-2026 08:04

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223182)
Not a single report I have read has said anything about anything other than taxing a "FIXED" broadband connection. Cellular Data does not count as fixed

And no where does it say they wouldn't be counted as a "fixed" broadband connection because otherwise, you can just simply get rid of your normal internet which I am sure the ISP's would love and get a 5G mobile phone connected to a router and hey presto no tv tax and no internet tax.

Remember these people steal money for a living, they are already trying to force TV manufacturers to put a iPlayer button on the remote and have it open the iPlayer app when the tv is turned on, so they can force everyone to pay the tv tax.

Jaymoss 30-09-2026 08:52

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Well there is the article I posted that says it is Fixed and the 5G thing I also said when i posted the link to the article that does say Fixed


Broadband is fitted into 2 categories I believe maybe 3 with Starlink Fixed in with a cable and Mobile is well mobile so Mobile broadband by its very definition is not classed as Fixed surely

---------- Post added at 08:52 ---------- Previous post was at 08:48 ----------

iplayer also needs a log in so the app just opening does not mean you are digesting content. If in the unlikely case TVL get a warrant and find the iplayer app on the TV does not prove anything as would removing any internet connection the TV . Just turn up to court and so not let them do it without you being there

Paul 30-09-2026 19:42

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by damien c (Post 36223180)
That right there is the "£11 per device"

What world are you living in ?
Here on Earth we can have many devices per connection, so per connection does not equal per device, not even close.

Carth 30-09-2026 20:13

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Large offices would be paying £5k a month . . or telling everyone to work from home :erm:

damien c 01-10-2026 08:06

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36223230)
What world are you living in ?
Here on Earth we can have many devices per connection, so per connection does not equal per device, not even close.

Sorry I think we are getting crossed wires here and it's more than likely my fault :)


What I mean by device is something which can provide internet to multiple devices.

1 device = 1 modem/router

So a mobile phone can be a modem/router for multiple devices, a tablet with a sim slot can be a modem/router for multiple devices, 4G/5G Modem can obviously be used for multiple devices.

Normal home broadband is a modem/router for multiple devices.

Any device with a sim slot could and will be classed as a device capable of providing a data connection to multiple devices.


Now the whole "Fixed only" thing will change because once people realise it's only "Fixed" connections, they will cancel their BT, Sky, VM etc and move to "mobile" broadband which will then cause the £11 fee to be added to them.


This is the problem, with it and why it will cause riots because as I say who is going to pay such insane prices?

Businesses will more than likely get "bulk discount" because otherwise it's going to cost them thousands if not tens of thousands per month.


Going to be interesting to see how things fall though with this, going forward because it could be another nail in the coffin of Labour if they go with this approach.

Chris 01-10-2026 08:18

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by damien c (Post 36223256)
Sorry I think we are getting crossed wires here and it's more than likely my fault :)


What I mean by device is something which can provide internet to multiple devices.

1 device = 1 modem/router

So a mobile phone can be a modem/router for multiple devices, a tablet with a sim slot can be a modem/router for multiple devices, 4G/5G Modem can obviously be used for multiple devices.

Normal home broadband is a modem/router for multiple devices.

Any device with a sim slot could and will be classed as a device capable of providing a data connection to multiple devices.


Now the whole "Fixed only" thing will change because once people realise it's only "Fixed" connections, they will cancel their BT, Sky, VM etc and move to "mobile" broadband which will then cause the £11 fee to be added to them.


This is the problem, with it and why it will cause riots because as I say who is going to pay such insane prices?

Businesses will more than likely get "bulk discount" because otherwise it's going to cost them thousands if not tens of thousands per month.


Going to be interesting to see how things fall though with this, going forward because it could be another nail in the coffin of Labour if they go with this approach.

I think this is an unlikely scenario.

It has always been the case on this forum that we are over-represented by the sort of technically minded, flexible sort of people who are willing and able to make switches like this in order to get an extra bit of utility (or save a few :2cents: ). But this just doesn’t reflect the attitudes of the overwhelming majority of the population, for whom setting up a home modem/router utilising 5G (and doing it well) is just a leap too far.

In the real world, 5G can’t compete with fibre for sustained download speeds, it can’t compete on cost and it can’t compete on convenience. Doubtless some people will do as you suggest but not nearly enough of them for it to be of concern. Especially as most households are presently paying for a TV licence at £180 a year, and the broadband tax is proposed to cost £132. If this happens it will be sold as a reduction in what we pay for the BBC.

Jaymoss 01-10-2026 08:36

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
2 Attachment(s)
170meg consistent with 300+meg with 80 to 120 meg upload . Been using Lebara 5G mobile as my main internet over 6 months so not quite the case Paul

Think it is perfectly acceptable. Lebara image shows I have downloaded over 1TB per month the last 2 months. I have to rinse and repeat the Lebara £9.98 unlimited deal every 3 months



https://www.cableforum.uk/board/atta...=1790840394://l



https://www.cableforum.uk/board/atta...6&d=1790840740

damien c 01-10-2026 08:59

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
I can reach up to 500Mbp/s on Lebara at my house, £20 a month if you don't get a deal.

I on average though will get 180Mbp/s and am able to game, stream and upload almost identically to my VM 1Gb connection.

So if they add the £11 to the VM connection, I could quite easily switch to my 5G Modem with my GL.Inet router connected to my Dream Machine Pro, but for now as it stands I will stick with the VM.

Chris 01-10-2026 09:39

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by damien c (Post 36223261)
I can reach up to 500Mbp/s on Lebara at my house, £20 a month if you don't get a deal.

I on average though will get 180Mbp/s and am able to game, stream and upload almost identically to my VM 1Gb connection.

So if they add the £11 to the VM connection, I could quite easily switch to my 5G Modem with my GL.Inet router connected to my Dream Machine Pro, but for now as it stands I will stick with the VM.

The point in terms of public policy is this: how many average home internet users do you think have a GL.Inet router connected to a Dream Machine Pro, or any equivalent set-up? Or are prepared to go out and buy the kit and learn how to use it?

Ordinary users simply don’t behave the way hobbyists do. That’s why this policy, if applied only to fixed line broadband, will work just fine.

Jaymoss 01-10-2026 10:00

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223262)
The point in terms of public policy is this: how many average home internet users do you think have a GL.Inet router connected to a Dream Machine Pro, or any equivalent set-up? Or are prepared to go out and buy the kit and learn how to use it?

Ordinary users simply don’t behave the way hobbyists do. That’s why this policy, if applied only to fixed line broadband, will work just fine.

I have taught a few and unlocked Gigacube routers can be bought on ebay for a ton. You literally just plug a sim in and it is exactly the same as any other router. Plenty of people use it on sites and boats etc

damien c 01-10-2026 10:11

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36223262)
The point in terms of public policy is this: how many average home internet users do you think have a GL.Inet router connected to a Dream Machine Pro, or any equivalent set-up? Or are prepared to go out and buy the kit and learn how to use it?

Ordinary users simply don’t behave the way hobbyists do. That’s why this policy, if applied only to fixed line broadband, will work just fine.

The majority won't and won't be bothered to until they potentially start being charged for more than just their BT, Sky, VM etc connection.

Chris 01-10-2026 11:34

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223263)
I have taught a few and unlocked Gigacube routers can be bought on ebay for a ton. You literally just plug a sim in and it is exactly the same as any other router. Plenty of people use it on sites and boats etc

I know how easy it is - because I took the time to read up on how to run a 4G router with external antenna during covid when our rural fixed line broadband couldn’t cope with the whole family on zoom all day. But then when our neighbour wanted to do it I had to sit down and give him a lesson, and then I ended up in a long conversation with someone from the community council which had already piloted a mobile data solution and decided it didn’t work - entirely because they picked the wrong network provider, didn’t know aerial selection and placement was a thing, nor that the hard data that would have facilitated their trial becoming a resounding success is open source and easily accessible, providing of course you have the confidence and sufficient motivation to use it.

Which is the point about boating and camper van people - it’s a self selecting group which is already used to finding innovative solutions to their needs. Not representative of your average home user.

Quote:

Originally Posted by damien c (Post 36223264)
The majority won't and won't be bothered to until they potentially start being charged for more than just their BT, Sky, VM etc connection.

At which point they still won’t change.

Hugh 01-10-2026 12:26

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
If a large number of people start using 5G for Terabyte downloads in an area, I can forecast that the Providers might start changing their T&Cs...

Carth 01-10-2026 12:28

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36223271)
If a large number of people start using 5G for Terabyte downloads in an area, I can forecast that the Providers might start changing their T&Cs...

That's a scenario bound to happen :Yes:

Jaymoss 01-10-2026 15:08

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36223271)
If a large number of people start using 5G for Terabyte downloads in an area, I can forecast that the Providers might start changing their T&Cs...

over a month 4 hours of streaming 4K per day could run up to a TB in a month

---------- Post added at 15:08 ---------- Previous post was at 15:05 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36223272)
That's a scenario bound to happen :Yes:

He did not understand my post or the image singling it down to a TB download when it was over a month as I explained in understandable terms for everyone it is not that much in real terms

Carth 01-10-2026 15:10

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
They'll probably set monthly limits, if you go over you pay more ;)

Jaymoss 01-10-2026 15:14

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36223278)
They'll probably set monthly limits, if you go over you pay more ;)

They used to then capacity grew and now they do not need to. They sell it as a product for whole home broadband .

People just do not understand. They will throttle the speed so there is no contention. Having a household streaming/downloading 1TB over a month is not unusual any more. Bare in mind many Xbox games are over 100 GB each and are downloaded and streaming in 4K which is also common now can use up to 40GB per hour dependant on audio . It is 2026 not 2006

Hugh 01-10-2026 15:50

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223275)
over a month 4 hours of streaming 4K per day could run up to a TB in a month

---------- Post added at 15:08 ---------- Previous post was at 15:05 ----------



He did not understand my post or the image singling it down to a TB download when it was over a month as I explained in understandable terms for everyone it is not that much in real terms

I meant over a month - if you have a couple of hundred people streaming 4k/downloading/gaming at the same time it’s going have a fairly major impact on the local cell…

Jaymoss 01-10-2026 16:43

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
5G is still capable of 10 to 20 Gbps per site so in theory it could handle a good few

---------- Post added at 16:43 ---------- Previous post was at 16:41 ----------

AI seems to think it can handle quite a high number

Anyway in my opinion it will be a viable option if the new tv tax happens

Paul 01-10-2026 20:03

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
First of all you actually have to have access to 5G .. ;)

Jaymoss 01-10-2026 20:19

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36223298)
First of all you actually have to have access to 5G .. ;)

I do not understand the hostility I have received or should I say perceived as it is just text to making a comment about the possibility of a work around for me because to be honest I only care about me and my loved ones who I will help set it up if they need . What is clear though a number of people here's knowledge is a little out of date

Paul 02-10-2026 22:17

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223300)
I do not understand the hostility I have received

The quote has zero hostility in it, so I have no clue what you're going on about.

jem 02-10-2026 22:27

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36223300)
I do not understand the hostility I have received or should I say perceived as it is just text to making a comment about the possibility of a work around for me because to be honest I only care about me and my loved ones who I will help set it up if they need . What is clear though a number of people here's knowledge is a little out of date

I’m not seeing hostility, but rather an acknowledgement that not everywhere has a 5G connection, or even if they theoretically do, in practice it may not be viable.

Jaymoss 03-10-2026 04:40

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
I did say or perceived

According to data available 97% of the country should be able to have a static 5G signal from one of the 4 providers outside. This drops to around 80% indoors again provider dependant. Three say they alone cover 62% of the UK O2 say 70%

So seeing how 5G works where up to 500 people could stream in 4K per node then it is still a very real option for a lot more people than you might think

---------- Post added at 04:40 ---------- Previous post was at 04:35 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36223348)
The quote has zero hostility in it, so I have no clue what you're going on about.

Paul it is the winky face and the ..

You yourself have told me off for ... after a sentence . An ellipsis by its very nature is passive aggressive

Plus as my stats show plenty of people can get 5G


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:20.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum