Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33712422)

Paul 12-01-2024 02:13

US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
I think everyone saw this coming.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/worl...anada-67952029

Quote:

President Biden says the strikes are in response to Houthi attacks on ships in the Red Sea since November
Quote:

Royal Air Force warplanes helped carry out the "targeted strikes" against military facilities, says PM Rishi Sunak

Dude111 12-01-2024 06:44

I think its just aweful!!!

noel43 12-01-2024 09:42

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dude111 (Post 36168113)
I think its just aweful!!!

As usual we will do what the US wants us to do.

Mr K 12-01-2024 09:57

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by noel43 (Post 36168115)
As usual we will do what the US wants us to do.

Both in an election year, a good patriotic conflict is what's needed to divert he electorate. Worked many times.

Pierre 12-01-2024 10:22

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
I would have liked to have seen a more international effort. I know some nations provided background support but the issue in the Red Sea affects all western nations.

Shipping has been greatly affected which impacts all of us, not least Egypt, which will lose revenue from the Suez Canal.

This response has been wrapped up in a self defence narrative because US/UK naval ships have been targeted

jfman 12-01-2024 10:43

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36168116)
Both in an election year, a good patriotic conflict is what's needed to divert he electorate. Worked many times.

Tale as old as time.

joglynne 12-01-2024 12:53

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Interesting, though predictable , updates added to Paul's original link.

Chris 12-01-2024 14:09

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36168116)
Both in an election year, a good patriotic conflict is what's needed to divert he electorate. Worked many times.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168118)
Tale as old as time.

Terribly obliging of those Houthi chaps to start firing missiles into the Red Sea. Wonder if they’re Tory donors?

jfman 12-01-2024 14:54

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36168122)
Terribly obliging of those Houthi chaps to start firing missiles into the Red Sea. Wonder if they’re Tory donors?

Timing is everything. As is the option of not joining America’s next hapless crusade in the Middle East.

Chris 12-01-2024 15:01

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168123)
Timing is everything. As is the option of not joining America’s next hapless crusade in the Middle East.

As I said. It’s almost as if every Wa’eed-2 is a donation-in-kind to the Tory election chest. I wonder if they’ll have to update the rules so incoming munitions aimed at civilian ships and the Royal Navy have to be declared as fundraising.

Damien 12-01-2024 15:03

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168123)
Timing is everything. As is the option of not joining America’s next hapless crusade in the Middle East.

Alternatively, the Houthis could not attack civilian ships.

jfman 12-01-2024 15:09

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36168125)
Alternatively, the Houthis could not attack civilian ships.

They certainly could - but that doesn’t detract from it being a political choice by our Government to participate in joint military action with the Americans against them. Just as it’s a political choice for those Governments in NATO and around the world who do not.

Post office pardons, trips to Ukraine to fund our military industrial complex some more. Things are looking up for Rishi.

Sirius 12-01-2024 15:14

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
In addition i see an upsurge in the sale of tinfoil. Many hats will be created :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFNO2sSW-mU

1andrew1 12-01-2024 15:18

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Some sobering commentary from Sky News. It does seem to me a risky strategy and it's notable that other Western nations have not rushed to join the UK and US.
Quote:

But there are several good reasons why the escalation may be counterproductive and dangerous.

Are the Houthis likely to be deterred by these attacks? Ask the Saudis. They have tried for eight years to use military force to control and deter them with little success.

The Houthis are a determined and resilient fighting force, nimble and fleet-footed in the deserts of Yemen. The assets they have deployed against international shipping are mobile.

It is not like striking a conventional Arab force like Saddam Hussein's in the Gulf War, for instance. Their guerilla fighters will most likely keep one stage ahead of the aerial campaign to destroy them.

Instead they are likely to escalate their activity in retaliation with the continuing support of Iran. That could lead to attacks elsewhere in ways Western military planners have not anticipated.

Most worrying though the intervention draws Britain and America closer to a confrontation with the Houthis' Iranian patrons.

They are now directly fighting Iranian allies. That is an ominous development for the Middle East.

The challenge with military offensives is always keeping them contained. One thing often leads to another.

Iran most likely still wants to stay on the sidelines playing mischief and using surrogates in this regional conflict. But the laws of unintended consequences always apply in conflict.

Miscalculations and mistakes can lead to escalation and take events in unpredictable directions. And there is always the danger of the ayatollahs' other proxy militia, Hezbollah, escalating from sparring with Israel to full-scale war over their shared border.

Was last night's action and more to come necessary?

The Houthis say their Red Sea attacks have been in protest at Israel's offensive in Gaza and the deaths of thousands of Palestinians there.

A ceasefire in Gaza would likely end their attacks on ships and the launching of cruise missiles aimed at Israel.

But the British and Americans say Israel has a right to continue fighting until Hamas is neutralised even if they are increasingly alarmed at the excessive number of civilians being killed.

Britain and America will insist this action is surgical and aimed solely at making the Red Sea safe again.

But that is not how millions across the region will see it. To them, Western countries are now using military force to support Israel and allow its bloody Gaza offensive to continue

There is still no clear sense from Israel when their war aims will be achieved. The war in Gaza has no end in sight and its repercussions are becoming more and more grave across the region. The contagion is unlikely to end here.
https://news.sky.com/story/strikes-a...-iran-13046631

Chris 12-01-2024 15:29

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168127)
They certainly could - but that doesn’t detract from it being a political choice by our Government to participate in joint military action with the Americans against them. Just as it’s a political choice for those Governments in NATO and around the world who do not.

Post office pardons, trips to Ukraine to fund our military industrial complex some more. Things are looking up for Rishi.

The Post Office I’ll give you. Something that was recently very difficult and down to the appeals court is suddenly solvable via once-in-a-lifetime legislation. Fairly obvious electioneering.

As for the rest of it … interest in freedom-of-navigation issues is longstanding UK foreign policy. From the Armilla Patrol in the Persian Gulf in the 1980s and 90s, to sailing a carrier through the South China Sea or patrolling off the coast of Somalia or in the Caribbean Sea to deter piracy, it’s manifestly just what we do. In the present situation the severely heightened threat is obvious, as is the necessary response.

And no, our involvement in Ukraine has nothing to do with promoting our military industrial complex or whatever else you’ve been inhaling on hard-left Xitter. Such nonsense belongs in the Socialist Worker or similar profoundly unserious publications. If you want to understand the UK’s approach to Ukraine you would be better off listening to what Russia’s near-neighbours in Eastern Europe and the Baltic have to say on the subject. We have been listening to them and taking their warnings rather more seriously than most of Europe or indeed the US.

I grant you, our Prime Miniature will be thinking that footage of him touring Ukraine or ordering the RN into action will play well with the electorate, but the suggestion that this is why he’s doing it doesn’t stand up to even a microsecond’s actual thought.

---------- Post added at 14:29 ---------- Previous post was at 14:20 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36168131)
Some sobering commentary from Sky News. It does seem to me a risky strategy and it's notable that other Western nations have not rushed to join the UK and US.

https://news.sky.com/story/strikes-a...-iran-13046631

Other Western nations

1. Don’t have very big navies
2. Those that do (France) don’t like putting them under US operational command
3. Don’t have anti-air capabilities anything like as sophisticated as the UK’s T-45 destroyers, whose initial design concept was informed by real, hard earned experience of the only serious naval war since WW2 (the Falklands)
4. For the most part feared that the US’s proposed rules of engagement were too timid and liable to lead to heightened risk of damage even to well defended naval vessels.

Note that the ‘final straw’ swarm attack on Tuesday was repelled by 3 US destroyers, a US aircraft carrier and 1 RN destroyer (HMS Diamond) which took down around a third of the incoming ordnance all by itself. We do it because we can. Most others can’t.

jfman 12-01-2024 15:42

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
There’s nothing “hard left” about the reality that investment in the Ukraine war machine for us (like for the Americans) results in the vast majority of the money flowing back to us.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...-b2477472.html

It’s literally there in black and white. Money goes to Ukraine to purchase drones. We manufacture drones. There’s no conspiracy theory involved.

Similarly American politicians are on record about the value of the investment in Ukraine that returns to American shores in terms of jobs, specifically weapons manufacturers.

Chris 12-01-2024 15:45

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168137)
There’s nothing “hard left” about the reality that investment in the Ukraine war machine for us (like for the Americans) results in the vast majority of the money flowing back to us.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...-b2477472.html

It’s literally there in black and white. Money goes to Ukraine to purchase drones. We manufacture drones. There’s no conspiracy theory involved.

Similarly American politicians are on record about the value of the investment in Ukraine that returns to American shores in terms of jobs, specifically weapons manufacturers.

“Money is being spent with UK arms manufacturers” is a fact.

“We are involved in Ukraine so we can spend money with UK arms manufacturers” is a conspiracy theory.

It is difficult to understand your claim that Sunak is making “trips to Ukraine to fund our military industrial complex” in any way other than indulging in that conspiracy theory.

jfman 12-01-2024 16:02

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36168138)
“Money is being spent with UK arms manufacturers” is a fact.

“We are involved in Ukraine so we can spend money with UK arms manufacturers” is a conspiracy theory.

It is difficult to understand your claim that Sunak is making “trips to Ukraine to fund our military industrial complex” in any way other than indulging in that conspiracy theory.

If it’s helpful happy to revise to trip that funds our military industrial complex.

Either way he’s there for the PR.

Edit: I’ve just realised my 10,000th post was earlier in the thread. :D

Sirius 12-01-2024 16:31

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168139)
If it’s helpful happy to revise to trip that funds our military industrial complex.

Either way he’s there for the PR.

Edit: I’ve just realised my 10,000th post was earlier in the thread. :D

Congratulations on your 10,000th post, you win a role of tinfoil :)

pip08456 12-01-2024 20:32

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 36168140)
Congratulations on your 10,000th post, you win a role of tinfoil :)

Oh come on Sirius, surely it deserves 2 rolls of extra wide tin foil at least.

nomadking 12-01-2024 21:37

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Bit puzzled as to how attacking ships wasn't an escalation. Same with Oct 7th attacks by Hamas. How much non-escalation escalating is to be allowed before any response?
If somebody hits you when trying to incite a response, and don't get one, they will keep hitting more frequently and harder until they get one.

Gavin78 13-01-2024 05:46

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36168147)
Bit puzzled as to how attacking ships wasn't an escalation. Same with Oct 7th attacks by Hamas. How much non-escalation escalating is to be allowed before any response?
If somebody hits you when trying to incite a response, and don't get one, they will keep hitting more frequently and harder until they get one.

I agree, they decided to start firing at military ships at this point I don't see why there shouldn't be a response back.

nomadking 13-01-2024 09:21

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gavin78 (Post 36168150)
I agree, they decided to start firing at military ships at this point I don't see why there shouldn't be a response back.

They were attacking civilian ships, which don't have the ability to defend themselves.

Dude111 13-01-2024 10:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by noel43
As usual we will do what the US wants us to do.

Terrible to get you guys involved..... THE US SHOULDNT EVEN BE INVOLVED :mad:

The US think they own the world and its sickening!!

nomadking 13-01-2024 11:41

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dude111 (Post 36168153)
Terrible to get you guys involved..... THE US SHOULDNT EVEN BE INVOLVED :mad:

The US think they own the world and its sickening!!

The Houthi attacks are on international shipping. Who else is going to deal with that? China?

TheDaddy 13-01-2024 11:59

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36168132)

I grant you, our Prime Miniature will be thinking that footage of him touring Ukraine or ordering the RN into action will play well with the electorate, but the suggestion that this is why he’s doing it doesn’t stand up to even a microsecond’s actual thought.

Kind of does when the prime miniature squeaked his rationale for the strikes was because the Houti's were damaging peoples shopping :spin:

Also the precise strikes he mentioned killed 5 people apparently, 73 missiles launched and 5 dead, we could teach Israel a thing or two or they could teach us a thing or two :shrug:

Chris 13-01-2024 12:51

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36168160)
Kind of does when the prime miniature squeaked his rationale for the strikes was because the Houti's were damaging peoples shopping :spin:

Also the precise strikes he mentioned killed 5 people apparently, 73 missiles launched and 5 dead, we could teach Israel a thing or two or they could teach us a thing or two :shrug:

So, to flip it on its head, do you believe that the Houthi regime should have been allowed to continue firing missiles at civilian shipping in the Red Sea unopposed?

TheDaddy 13-01-2024 13:03

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36168163)
So, to flip it on its head, do you believe that the Houthi regime should have been allowed to continue firing missiles at civilian shipping in the Red Sea unopposed?

I've not said that or intimated that anywhere so lets flip it back to that great statesman and his concerns about damaged shopping, marvellous isn't it, he can stop the Houti's small boats thousands of miles away but can't stop ones 20 miles away :rolleyes:

Paul 13-01-2024 15:53

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36168164)
he can stop the Houti's small boats thousands of miles away but can't stop ones 20 miles away :rolleyes:

Well, they could use the same method, but I suspect you (and others) might complain if they stopped the "ones 20 miles away" with missiles & air strikes. :erm:

TheDaddy 13-01-2024 16:39

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36168166)
Well, they could use the same method, but I suspect you (and others) might complain if they stopped the "ones 20 miles away" with missiles & air strikes. :erm:

If they were damaging shopping then they'd fully deserve it and I wouldn't give a hoot(i)

nomadking 13-01-2024 17:54

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36168160)
Kind of does when the prime miniature squeaked his rationale for the strikes was because the Houti's were damaging peoples shopping :spin:

Also the precise strikes he mentioned killed 5 people apparently, 73 missiles launched and 5 dead, we could teach Israel a thing or two or they could teach us a thing or two :shrug:

The ships maybe slow-moving, but they are still moving and the missiles/drones are launched a long distance away. Food and energy in the form of oil and LNG, also are affected.They narrowly missed an oil tanker.

Mick 13-01-2024 18:32

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168127)
They certainly could - but that doesn’t detract from it being a political choice by our Government to participate in joint military action with the Americans against them. Just as it’s a political choice for those Governments in NATO and around the world who do not.

Post office pardons, trips to Ukraine to fund our military industrial complex some more. Things are looking up for Rishi.

A political choice?

So let’s just keep letting those arse-holes, fire on our ships then, unchecked & unchallenged, goodness me, pathetic. :rolleyes:

jfman 13-01-2024 19:05

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 36168173)
A political choice?

So let’s just keep letting those arse-holes, fire on our ships then, unchecked & unchallenged, goodness me, pathetic. :rolleyes:

That’s not what I said and you know it.

nomadking 13-01-2024 19:11

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168174)
That’s not what I said and you know it.

Really?
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36168127)
They certainly could - but that doesn’t detract from it being a political choice by our Government to participate in joint military action with the Americans against them. Just as it’s a political choice for those Governments in NATO and around the world who do not.

Post office pardons, trips to Ukraine to fund our military industrial complex some more. Things are looking up for Rishi.


jfman 13-01-2024 19:16

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36168175)
Really?

Yes, specifically his suggestion:

“So let’s just keep letting those arse-holes, fire on our ships then, unchecked & unchallenged, goodness me, pathetic.”

Nowhere did I suggest taking no action. My cynicism is principally around timing, and being the typical US poodle.

Mr K 13-01-2024 19:59

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
What's Norway or Uzbekistan doing about it all, that's what I want to know.

Chris 13-01-2024 20:18

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36168178)
What's Norway or Uzbekistan doing about it all, that's what I want to know.

Norway: providing unspecified support to the international naval patrol. Also protesting vigorously at the targeting of a Norway flagged ship on 12 December.

Uzbekistan: Landlocked, so :shrug:

Dude111 14-01-2024 00:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking
The Houthi attacks are on international shipping. Who else is going to deal with that? China?

Ya you have a point.........

It shouldnt be happening at all!!

Gavin78 14-01-2024 00:28

Re: US and UK launch strikes against Houthi rebels
 
What you all mean to say is the rest of the world stands by and watches as usual while the UK and USA have to sort everything out while all the other toothless countries shout from the sidelines.

I personally hope the Houthi rebels get a right pasting.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:48.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum