Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Drones ground flights at Gatwick (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33707190)

Hugh 20-12-2018 13:00

Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-46623754
Quote:

Tens of thousands of passengers have been disrupted by drones flying over one of the UK's busiest airports.

Gatwick's runway has been shut since Wednesday night, when two devices were seen flying over the perimeter fence.

The airport said a drone had been spotted "in the last hour" and the runway would not open "until it was safe to do so".

About 110,000 passengers on 760 flights were due to fly on Thursday. Disruption could last "several days".

Those due to travel have been told to check the status of their flight, while Easyjet told its passengers not to go to Gatwick if their flights have been cancelled.

Gatwick Airport: Live updates
Sussex Police said it was not terror-related but a "deliberate act" of disruption.

Mr_love_monkey 20-12-2018 13:16

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Wow.

Smart people out there.

denphone 20-12-2018 13:24

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Sadly has been a problem which has been been worrying airport authorities and other authorities for a while and they need to start taking it far more seriously then they have up to now.

OLD BOY 20-12-2018 13:35

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35976177)
Sadly has been a problem which has been been worrying airport authorities and other authorities for a while and they need to start taking it far more seriously then they have up to now.

Agreed. The law is remarkably lax in this area. I have always had concerns about individuals being able to own drones. Only organisations should be permitted to do this, and under licence.

Paul 20-12-2018 14:35

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 35976179)
Agreed. The law is remarkably lax in this area. I have always had concerns about individuals being able to own drones. Only organisations should be permitted to do this, and under licence.

Woooah, thats way too draconian, we are not a police state (yet).

(and no, I dont fly them, or have any interest in them).

heero_yuy 20-12-2018 14:43

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
There are already plenty of laws in place about endangering aircraft that can be applied with up to 5 years imprisonment for offenders. Such laws have already been used to prosecute loonies with laser pens.

Larger drones already have GPS fencing in their software that prevents them being used within 1 mile of an airport, though there are groups such as the pilots union that want this distance increased to 5 miles as is common on the continent.

Real problem is the smaller "toy" drones that have no restrictions in their software and can easilly fly out of range of their controller.

ianch99 20-12-2018 15:55

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Can the control frequencies be jammed I wonder? I guess they have thought of this ..

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 16:26

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 35976188)
Can the control frequencies be jammed I wonder? I guess they have thought of this ..

If it's an industrial grade UAV then it could be flying autonomously with a pre-programmed flight plan.

What goes up must come down though.

Hugh 20-12-2018 16:26

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 35976188)
Can the control frequencies be jammed I wonder? I guess they have thought of this ..

Yes, but the drone owner can change the preset frequencies, or it could just be pre-programmed with way-points, so not need any linkage to the controller.

OLD BOY 20-12-2018 16:37

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul M (Post 35976181)
Woooah, thats way too draconian, we are not a police state (yet).

(and no, I dont fly them, or have any interest in them).

When you consider the many ways these machines can be misused and pose a deadly threat, I don't think it is draconian at all. We made do without them before, we can do so again.

This case is alerting us to how ill thought out this whole idea is.

denphone 20-12-2018 16:47

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Military to be deployed at Gatwick.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...b02fb91ff06bf8

Quote:

The defence secretary, Gavin Williamson, has just told reporters the armed forces will be deployed at Gatwick although he has declined to specify in what capacity

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 16:57

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Even if the thing is being controlled in realtime, Baldock (Ofcom) have remote monitoring heads all over the place down there. If they can isolate the signal from the command unit then that presents a nice, juicy target for a bit of triangulation.

Those toy drones like the DJI Phantom operate on similar frequencies to wifi networks so you'd be lucky to get more than a mile or so range from them.

If this is a professional unit as the reports suggest then it'll probably be operating on the de-regulated short range device frequency allocation around 458MHz. Maximum legal output on that band is 100 milliwats which is more than enough for 5-10KM. You can even buy illegal radio units from those online Chinese junk marts which claim 20KM+ range.

Taf 20-12-2018 18:26

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
When I was a lad it was kites that caused problems for aircraft, Barry Island beach is on the approach flight path for Cardiff Wales Airport, and kites would often "invade" that space.

Now I see numerous drones of all sizes there.

---------- Post added at 18:26 ---------- Previous post was at 18:24 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 35976188)
Can the control frequencies be jammed I wonder? I guess they have thought of this ..

They don't bother trying to jam control frequeancies, they blast the internal circuitry with microwaves. I would have though all airports would have that facility by now.

Paul 20-12-2018 19:33

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 35976206)
When you consider the many ways these machines can be misused and pose a deadly threat, I don't think it is draconian at all. We made do without them before, we can do so again.

This case is alerting us to how ill thought out this whole idea is.

You can misuse pretty much anything if you want, and we did without aeroplanes at one time, thats just a nonsense argument.

Hom3r 20-12-2018 19:33

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Find out where the Signal's coming from, and send the SAS to kick the door it.

Hugh 20-12-2018 19:51

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
The knock-on effects are impacting on the other side of the Atlantic - my bro-in-law is flying from Newark tonight, landing in Manchester tomorrow morning (staying with us over Christmas), and his UA flight has been delayed by 90 minutes, and UA offered to buy back his seat (he used UA Airmiles to book it), to re-sell it on as people on other US airlines that fly into Gatwick are trying to get seats to other airports in the U.K..

---------- Post added at 19:51 ---------- Previous post was at 19:49 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35976246)
Find out where the Signal's coming from, and send the SAS to kick the door it.

Unfortunately, if they’ve changed the transmission frequency, it could be very difficult to find the transmission and triangulate on it, especially as it takes more than a few minutes to triangulate a transmission from a mobile location, especially if it’s a low power transmission.

Hom3r 20-12-2018 19:53

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Gatwick is to stay shut until at leat 6am tomorrow.

Well the culprity better have very deep pockets.

Mr_love_monkey 20-12-2018 20:00

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35976250)
Gatwick is to stay shut until at leat 6am tomorrow.

Wow.

Do we know how many drones it is? - the BBC quoted someone as saying 'A significant number' - if I remember rightly.

denphone 20-12-2018 20:04

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35976250)
Gatwick is to stay shut until at leat 6am tomorrow.

Well the culprity better have very deep pockets.

The busiest travel day of the year tomorrow so if it continues well into tomorrow then there will be even more chaos.


Quote:

Gatwick: Passengers should not come to the airport on Friday.

Quote:

Gatwick has advised passengers not to come to the airport for the foreseeable future including tomorrow, Sky News is reporting
Quote:

Ryanair flights to operate from London Stansted instead of Gatwick tomorrow

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 20:31

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_love_monkey (Post 35976252)
Wow.

Do we know how many drones it is? - the BBC quoted someone as saying 'A significant number' - if I remember rightly.

Two apparently

"Earlier, he said the drones could not be shot down because of the risk posed by stray bullets. Officers from Surrey and Sussex police forces have been scouring the perimeter to try to catch the operators of two drones. Sussex police said there was no indication that the ongoing incident was terrorism-related."

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...drone-sighting

Hugh 20-12-2018 20:42

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Well, if the bullets miss, gravity is not our friend - and even if they hit it, they would have to do a FOD sweep if it was near the runway or gates.

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 20:47

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Judging by the speed of the things if the video posted by the Daily Fail is anything to go by they would be incredibly difficult to hit even by an experienced marksman.

Chinook landed at Redhill a few hours ago (not something you see every day!). Looks like it came from Waddo so wonder what they're planning.

denphone 20-12-2018 20:53

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Lord Harris who led a independent review highlighted the potential for drones to be used to disrupt flights.

Quote:

He tells Radio 4's PM programme that there has been a "complacency" towards drones, calling on the government to use current technology which "sends the drones back to the sender ...or makes them spiral very slowly down to the ground".

Hugh 20-12-2018 21:10

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35976261)
Judging by the speed of the things if the video posted by the Daily Fail is anything to go by they would be incredibly difficult to hit even by an experienced marksman.

Chinook landed at Redhill a few hours ago (not something you see every day!). Looks like it came from Waddo so wonder what they're planning.

That’s the main ISTAR base now, isn’t it?

Interesting...

(can’t see them sending a Reaper over Gatwick, can you?)

Update - just remembered, 54SU is based at RAF Digby, a couple of miles away from Wadders. Their job is to, and I quote, "provide processing, exploitation, and dissemination of all UK air-derived electronic surveillance data".

The drone jockeys’ time is running out.

Mick 20-12-2018 21:19

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 35976206)
When you consider the many ways these machines can be misused and pose a deadly threat, I don't think it is draconian at all. We made do without them before, we can do so again.

This case is alerting us to how ill thought out this whole idea is.

I fly drones as a hobby in a totally legal way and have been doing so for a couple of years now.

It doesn't matter how many laws, rules you can can come up with, there will always be idiots who does not care about the rules.

The cheaper toy drones do not fly for longer periods, do not come with GPS position flying, so the pilot really needs to have good control for the drone to stay in the air.

I at one point owned 5 drones, ranging from the small to professional standard - the mid range to professional ones have GPS and the professional ones, have GPS fencing which does not allow the pilot to fly any where near an Airport but you will always have some who can circumvent the software locks and get around this.

The issue here is that the Pilot of these drones at Gatwick, can be absolutely miles away, one of the drones I have can fly 7 KM away, however, UK law says to fly legally, the drone must always be in line of sight, these pilots of these drones at Gatwick will be flying with First Person View with either a Screen or Virtual Goggles. They won't be anywhere near the Airport, probably sat in a van or some other vehicle in a forest somewhere.

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 21:21

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35976267)
That’s the main ISTAR base now, isn’t it?

Interesting...

(can’t see them sending a Reaper over Gatwick, can you?)

Yes it sure is. All of our ISTAR assets are there including the Reapers and that clunky old thing we bought from the Yanks ;)

Now funny you should mention that. There's a block of airspace: TMA1 just to the East of Gatwick with an upper level of 19,500ft. Now just above that up to 25,000ft is where the Reapers normally operate.

I've been watching for the past few hours (on Flightradar24 and *cough* something else) anything around that block between FL240 and FL260 vectored further North parallel with the M25 so it does make you wonder.

Damien 20-12-2018 21:25

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
So it's illegal to fly a drone further than you can see it? Why do they sell ones with such long ranges? Also what happens if something happens to the drone? I've never got one cos i'ld be afraid of it falling and hitting someone.

---------- Post added at 22:25 ---------- Previous post was at 22:23 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35976267)
That’s the main ISTAR base now, isn’t it?

Interesting...

(can’t see them sending a Reaper over Gatwick, can you?)

Update - just remembered, 54SU is based at RAF Digby, a couple of miles away from Wadders. Their job is to, and I quote, "provide processing, exploitation, and dissemination of all UK air-derived electronic surveillance data".

The drone jockeys’ time is running out.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35976270)
Yes it sure is. All of our ISTAR assets are there including the Reapers and that clunky old thing we bought from the Yanks ;)

Now funny you should mention that. There's a block of airspace: TMA1 just to the East of Gatwick with an upper level of 19,500ft. Now just above that up to 25,000ft is where the Reapers normally operate.

I've been watching for the past few hours (on Flightradar24 and *cough* something else) anything around that block between FL240 and FL260 vectored further North parallel with the M25 so it does make you wonder.

What are you talking about? :dunce:

Hugh 20-12-2018 21:31

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35976271)
So it's illegal to fly a drone further than you can see it? Why do they sell ones with such long ranges? Also what happens if something happens to the drone? I've never got one cos i'ld be afraid of it falling and hitting someone.

---------- Post added at 22:25 ---------- Previous post was at 22:23 ----------





What are you talking about? :dunce:

We have people based in Raf Waddington in Lincolnshire whose job is to fly Reaper drones over Syria and other places to ruin people’s days, which are backed up by Electronic Intelligence collection planes, such as the Sentry or Rivet Joint planes. 54SU (based a couple of miles from Wadders) is tasked with intercepting, collecting, and analysing U.K. airborne electronic information (transmissions between aircraft and ground).

Besides delivering unexpected surprise packages to insurgents, Reapers also have extensive electronic intelligence collection capabilities, which interpreted by the people from 54SU, will help pinpoint the rapscallions location.

(All this is surmise, obvs., based on previous knowledge and gossip from ex-colleagues)

Damien 20-12-2018 21:35

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
So they can track both the drones themselves and the radio signals? Why wouldn't they fly these over Gatwick? It's not as if the airport is being used right now....

Hugh 20-12-2018 21:43

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35976276)
So they can track both the drones themselves and the radio signals? Why wouldn't they fly these over Gatwick? It's not as if the airport is being used right now....

As the old saying goes, it’s not that simple (I worked with a previous incarnation of thes guys when I was at RAF Digby, and their predecessors did the same thing on the West/East German border during the Cold War, but without UAVs).

If they are using waypoints to move the drones about, there will be very little communication between drones and ground station, and what there is, could be low-powered. If they are guiding them, they could be moving around (in a van, as Mick said) - it’s unfortunately not like the movies - it takes time to find the signal (could be frequency hopping), and then you have to triangulate where the ground station signal is coming from.

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 21:55

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
If they can find out what frequency the ground station is transmitting on and what the signal looks like on the spectrum display that's their best bet. Pretty much the RF equivalent of a ballistics analysis.

Not sure that any of those off the shelf drone control radio systems are frequency agile like a military comms terminal would be but the transmitters in 2.4GHz and 5GHz type approved systems are very low powered.

The systems which operate on lower frequencies are far more powerful, travel for longer distances and are not as susceptible to interference by obstacles etc. There would be far more likelihood of being able to triangulate this type of signal.

Mick 20-12-2018 22:00

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35976271)
So it's illegal to fly a drone further than you can see it? Why do they sell ones with such long ranges? Also what happens if something happens to the drone? I've never got one cos i'ld be afraid of it falling and hitting someone

The ones with huge ranges cost a lot of money over £1,000 and for professional and commercial use, generally the professionally ones are aimed at Licensed operators who can, as long as they have permission to do so from the Civil Aviation Authority, fly above the legal distances for standard recreational users.

The thing to be aware of, recreational drone flying, you're not suppose to fly them over large crowds of people or be in close proximity to buildings. I fly mine in areas that are allowed, like large parks and playing fields.

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 22:10

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Guardian are reporting that drone has been spotted in the last hour.

I've been watching what's going on in the vicinity and at 21:30 one of the Easyjet aircraft on the ground started up on ground power and switched it's transponder on announcing itself to Flightradar24.

Makes you wonder if this is what numb nuts is using as a prelude to kicking off the mischief.

Chris 20-12-2018 22:12

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35976246)
Find out where the Signal's coming from, and send the SAS to kick the door it.

I’m pretty sure the SAS are on site already, attached to whatever specialist unit has been sent in to deal with these drones.

The fact that this is still ongoing after 24 hours and el gov is confident it is not terror related says to me that they think this is a state actor (i.e. Russia). It’s inconceivable that some pale and pasty social misfit would still be at it right now.

The fact that the BBC isn’t even speculating in these terms suggests to me that they’ve been handed a DA notice.

Mick 20-12-2018 22:22

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35976291)
I’m pretty sure the SAS are on site already, attached to whatever specialist unit has been sent in to deal with these drones.

The fact that this is still ongoing after 24 hours and el gov is confident it is not terror related says to me that they think this is a state actor (i.e. Russia). It’s inconceivable that some pale and pasty social misfit would still be at it right now.

The fact that the BBC isn’t even speculating in these terms suggests to me that they’ve been handed a DA notice.

They say it's an Industrial model drone - well, I know of a few and the pale faced misfit won't be able to just buy one of these and then begin to jail break it and buy all the kit that goes with it, unless they got a spare ten grand and then some.

It's either one of these https://store.dji.com/shop/industria...=menu_products

Or...

https://store.dji.com/shop/inspire-s...=menu_products

Just look at the cost of these 2 above.

DJI - the leading drone manufacturer around the world, their software blocks pilots from flying in a No Fly Zone - that's an Airport. But they are saying, the pilots have hacked the drones to circumvent the locks that prevent the flying in or near to Airports.

Hugh 20-12-2018 22:26

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35976290)
Guardian are reporting that drone has been spotted in the last hour.

I've been watching what's going on in the vicinity and at 21:30 one of the Easyjet aircraft on the ground started up on ground power and switched it's transponder on announcing itself to Flightradar24.

Makes you wonder if this is what numb nuts is using as a prelude to kicking off the mischief.

Decoy?

The Chinook could have brought a couple of the 54SU ‘plain clothes’ vans which could be cruising the area...

jfman 20-12-2018 22:27

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35976293)
Decoy?

I was just thinking the same. Try to flush it out.

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 22:29

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Probably. It's just started up again on ground power.

Announcing itself as the Alicante flight: EZY24QY

Mick 20-12-2018 22:48

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 35976294)
I was just thinking the same. Try to flush it out.

To do what lol ? - This drone can travel very fast and if they have hacked it, they have probably changed the speed parameters on it as well and it can travel at any height too. No Marksman is going to shoot something down that's hundreds of feet above a commercial zone.

My hunch is that the pilots are in a vehicle, miles away from the Airport and moving around thwarting all efforts to get a true position because signal keeps changing and moving and the drone is navigating on Pre-set Way points.

Hugh 20-12-2018 22:52

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976296)
To do what lol ? - This drone can travel very fast and if they have hacked it, they have probably changed the speed parameters on it as well and it can travel at any height too. No Marksman is going to shoot something down that's hundreds of feet above a commercial zone.

My hunch is that the pilots are in a vehicle, miles away from the Airport and moving around thwarting all efforts to get a true position because signal keeps changing and moving and the drone is navigating on Pre-set Way points.

I think they will have a Military, probably RAF, Electronics Intelligence intercept unit nearby, to track the signal sources.

jfman 20-12-2018 22:57

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976296)
To do what lol ? - This drone can travel very fast and if they have hacked it, they have probably changed the speed parameters on it as well and it can travel at any height too. No Marksman is going to shoot something down that's hundreds of feet above a commercial zone.

My hunch is that the pilots are in a vehicle, miles away from the Airport and moving around thwarting all efforts to get a true position because signal keeps changing and moving and the drone is navigating on Pre-set Way points.

If they can anticipate when the drone will appear by prompting it to do a flyover this might give them new information. It might not, but they are probably better inviting it than reacting.

Obviously identifying it taking off or landing would be a huge (though unlikely) win. I don’t know what military resources could help in this area.

They have said they are considering options to shoot it down although I agree with you it’s unlikely.

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 23:00

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Looks like there's a positioning flight rolling out for take-off. Be interesting to see what that brings.

A positioning flight is a non-passenger route where a crew move aircraft between locations.

Chris 20-12-2018 23:05

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Is it a positioning flight, or does it just look like one?

Uncle Peter 20-12-2018 23:08

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35976305)
Is it a positioning flight, or does it just look like one?

It just looks like one as it appears to be taxying back to the stand ;)

It could of course be a rejected take-off though. Hard to say as it's just a moving icon on a screen.

JPAC 21-12-2018 00:00

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
News reports "With most drones the batteries will last for only 20 minutes", suggests more than one operator and most modern drones just won't fly near an airport, the GPS won't allow it. Weird.

Mick 21-12-2018 01:19

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
These industrial Drones will have dual battery packs, which will basically allow the drone to fly for the best part of an hour or more before being required to land, they will also return to home whenever the drone detects the batteries are becoming depleted and they’re smart enough to know how much battery juice they need to get home with.

TheDaddy 21-12-2018 01:24

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Other half is going to Lapland in 2 hours, has to drive to Gatwick, check in and then get a coach to Stansted, I hope comeuppance is winging its way towards the perpetrators and that it's bitter medicine

denphone 21-12-2018 05:53

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Hopefully things will start to improve throughout today after the chaos of yesterday.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...d-flights-live

Quote:

It appears we have our first flight on track to land at Gatwick in more than 24 hours.
It is China Eastern Airlines flight MU201 from Shanghai to Gatwick. It is an Airbus A330-243 and its estimated time of arrivals is 5:59am.
Quote:

More promising news from British Airways, who say “the airport is back open and the majority of flights operating as scheduled”.

JPAC 21-12-2018 08:23

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
So, with no crims or drones found, someone is taking a risk re-opening Gatwick. Some are blaming tree huggers as a protest, they could easily move on to Heathrow or elsewhere.

denphone 21-12-2018 08:27

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JPAC (Post 35976340)
So, with no crims or drones found, someone is taking a risk re-opening Gatwick. Some are blaming tree huggers as a protest, they could easily move on to Heathrow or elsewhere.

Yep now that they know that they have brought Gatwick airport to a total standstill for over a day there are over 40 other airports one could conceivable target as well of which there are 5 in London alone.

jfman 21-12-2018 08:34

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JPAC (Post 35976340)
So, with no crims or drones found, someone is taking a risk re-opening Gatwick. Some are blaming tree huggers as a protest, they could easily move on to Heathrow or elsewhere.

It’s almost certainly not playing out as portrayed in the media.

heero_yuy 21-12-2018 09:29

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Whoever is using the drone must have the technical knowledge to disable the GPS geofencing. Speculation is that the control is being done over the 4G/5G phone network so unless the authorities can actually capture the drone to discover the mobile identity the culprit(s) will get away with it.

Even then the SIM could be untracable back to a purchaser.

Damien 21-12-2018 09:59

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976287)
The ones with huge ranges cost a lot of money over £1,000 and for professional and commercial use, generally the professionally ones are aimed at Licensed operators who can, as long as they have permission to do so from the Civil Aviation Authority, fly above the legal distances for standard recreational users.

The thing to be aware of, recreational drone flying, you're not suppose to fly them over large crowds of people or be in close proximity to buildings. I fly mine in areas that are allowed, like large parks and playing fields.

So I can't get one to scout out the traffic on my route to the station in the morning then :D

Mick 21-12-2018 15:07

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35976352)
So I can't get one to scout out the traffic on my route to the station in the morning then :D

Not if you wish to have an on the spot fine handed down to you, your equipment confiscated from the police ;) , they are getting more powers to tackle irresponsible drone pilots.

But some people calling for extra laws, the idiots flying the ones at Gatwick, won't care for them and are just spoiling the hobby for those who do respect the rules and laws attached to drone flying.

papa smurf 21-12-2018 15:12

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
How high are these drones flying over the airport.

Mick 21-12-2018 15:28

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35976348)
Whoever is using the drone must have the technical knowledge to disable the GPS geofencing. Speculation is that the control is being done over the 4G/5G phone network so unless the authorities can actually capture the drone to discover the mobile identity the culprit(s) will get away with it.

Even then the SIM could be untracable back to a purchaser.

If it's a sophisticated drone then it will contain components which may hold account information. DJI drones require account registration to fly them through an APP.

It could also be a custom built drone that will hold no information.

---------- Post added at 15:28 ---------- Previous post was at 15:24 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 35976409)
How high are these drones flying over the airport.

How long is a piece of string?

It's not unheard but they can fly 1000's of Metres in the air, at these heights, they will not even appear to be a dot in the sky. Even at 100 M it will just barely be visible, it will be like trying to shoot at a Blue bottle 10 M away.

papa smurf 21-12-2018 15:42

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976413)
If it's a sophisticated drone then it will contain components which may hold account information. DJI drones require account registration to fly them through an APP.

It could also be a custom built drone that will hold no information.

---------- Post added at 15:28 ---------- Previous post was at 15:24 ----------



How long is a piece of string?

It's not unheard but they can fly 1000's of Metres in the air, at these heights, they will not even appear to be a dot in the sky. Even at 100 M it will just barely be visible, it will be like trying to shoot at a Blue bottle 10 M away.

My thinking was if they are flying up to 300 mtrs they can be taken down with a shot gun with out the fear of harming anyone on the ground.

Hugh 21-12-2018 15:58

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 35976419)
My thinking was if they are flying up to 300 mtrs they can be taken down with a shot gun with out the fear of harming anyone on the ground.

But that would create the likelyhood of FOD (Foreign Object Damage) to aircraft using the runway - a jet engine with some fragments getting sucked in a high speed is sub-optimal.

(it can take hours to do a FOD walk on a runway - I've taken part in some before, and it's basically a long line of people very close together walking up and down the runway for a couple of hours to clear any fragments off).

Uncle Peter 21-12-2018 17:02

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
You'd be lucky if there was enough kinetic energy in a spread of pellets to take down a drone in the 50-100 yard range

A slug at 300 yards maybe but good luck hitting a fast moving drone at that range.

heero_yuy 21-12-2018 17:28

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Breaking: Gatwick on hold due to suspected drone sighting.

https://twitter.com/ReutersUK?ref_sr...Ctwgr%5Eauthor

papa smurf 21-12-2018 17:37

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35976439)
You'd be lucky if there was enough kinetic energy in a spread of pellets to take down a drone in the 50-100 yard range

A slug at 300 yards maybe but good luck hitting a fast moving drone at that range.

They stop geese and ducks [so i am told ;)]

---------- Post added at 17:37 ---------- Previous post was at 17:36 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35976450)
Breaking: Gatwick on hold due to suspected drone sighting.

https://twitter.com/ReutersUK?ref_sr...Ctwgr%5Eauthor

This is getting silly now.

denphone 21-12-2018 17:41

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
So basically airports are at the whim of these drones unless they develop technologies that can stop them getting within a certain radius of a airport.

papa smurf 21-12-2018 17:43

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35976460)
So basically airports are at the whim of these drones unless they develop technologies that can stop them getting within a certain radius of a airport.

I read earlier that such technology was installed today.

Hom3r 21-12-2018 17:44

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
OK the parties over when they catch this terrorist, sell everything he ownes to the lowet bider and lock them up the rest of their life.

denphone 21-12-2018 17:45

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 35976461)
I read earlier that such technology was installed today.

Well if the reports are true it ain't working.

papa smurf 21-12-2018 17:48

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35976465)
Well if the reports are true it ain't working.

I can't find the story now,not sure where i read it ,but it was said to be an Israeli anti drone system.

found it
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...twick-UAV.html


https://www.timesofisrael.com/uk-arm...ondon-airport/

denphone 21-12-2018 17:50

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 35976466)
I can't find the story now,not sure where i read it ,but it was said to be an Israeli anti drone system.

Apparently they put up a drone tracking system this morning at Gatwick.

Kursk 21-12-2018 17:56

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
It may not be the purpose of these drones but there are those that feel that aviation is a contributor to climate change, pollution, destruction of the ozone layer.

These are things that won't significantly impact on anyone reading this but it might be that our kids curse our profligacy.

Don't shoot me - just sayin' :)

nomadking 21-12-2018 18:00

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35976467)
Apparently they put up a drone tracking system this morning at Gatwick.

Even if they try to track where it came from, it is inevitable that the final part of the return journey will be obscured from the system's "view".

heero_yuy 21-12-2018 18:04

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Anybody who's technically savvy enough to break the Geofencing will no doubt have considered all tracking and jamming approaches.

papa smurf 21-12-2018 18:12

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kursk (Post 35976469)
It may not be the purpose of these drones but there are those that feel that aviation is a contributor to climate change, pollution, destruction of the ozone layer.

These are things that won't significantly impact on anyone reading this but it might be that our kids curse our profligacy.

Don't shoot me - just sayin' :)

I am one of those that feel that aviation is a contributor to climate change, pollution, all in the name of cheap holidays - just sayin'

---------- Post added at 18:12 ---------- Previous post was at 18:07 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35976472)
Anybody who's technically savvy enough to break the Geofencing will no doubt have considered all tracking and jamming approaches.

Probably turn out to be a 14 year old nerd with a home built drone flying it from his bedroom.

heero_yuy 21-12-2018 18:19

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Quote from papa smurf:


Probably turn out to be a 14 year old nerd with a home built drone flying it from his bedroom.
Wouldn't surprise me at all. Treating it like some video game.

Uncle Peter 21-12-2018 18:24

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Looks like they're back in business at the moment. Aurigny flight to Guernsey just taken off

pip08456 21-12-2018 18:30

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 35976439)
You'd be lucky if there was enough kinetic energy in a spread of pellets to take down a drone in the 50-100 yard range

A slug at 300 yards maybe but good luck hitting a fast moving drone at that range.

Police snipers had a go at it (or them)

Quote:

London’s Gatwick Airport suspended flights on Friday just hours after reopening following a 36-hour closure which stranded more than 100,000 Christmas travellers when a mystery saboteur used drones to play cat-and-mouse with police snipers.
https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-br..._medium=Social

denphone 22-12-2018 05:52

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Two arrests made in relation to ‘criminal use of drones’, police say.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...ion-of-airport

Quote:

Two people have been arrested in connection with the “criminal use of drones” which has caused widespread disruption to flights at Gatwick airport, police have said.
Quote:

In a statement released in the early hours of Saturday, Sussex police said the arrests were made just after 10pm on Friday night.

TheDaddy 22-12-2018 08:03

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35976463)
OK the parties over when they catch this terrorist, sell everything he ownes to the lowet bider and lock them up the rest of their life.

Sounds reasonable although possibly a little bit to lenient, btw however much is in the twerps wallet, I bid that for all he owns

Mr K 22-12-2018 10:31

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Can you get these drone things in Argos ? ;)

techguyone 22-12-2018 11:32

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
1 Attachment(s)
They just need counter drone technology, something like this...

Ken W 22-12-2018 13:05

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 35976519)
Can you get these drone things in Argos ? ;)


Yes ARGOS sell them, as do PC World and many other shops.

papa smurf 22-12-2018 13:51

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 35976519)
Can you get these drone things in Argos ? ;)

yes and you just need a basic knowledge of left/right - up/down -and the thing you'll never master in/out;)

Uncle Peter 22-12-2018 16:58

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
1 Attachment(s)
Knew it

Attachment 27678

Hom3r 22-12-2018 17:22

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 35976519)
Can you get these drone things in Argos ? ;)


No, these are pro Drones.

But with some knowledge you just need the motors, lightweight tubing, decent RC batteries & electronics, you can buold your own one, no GPS fencing etc.

Dare I say a Raspberry Pi at the heart.

OK I've very simplified it but Google/Youtube is a powerfull tool.

SnoopZ 22-12-2018 17:26

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35976581)
No, these are pro Drones.

But with some knowledge you just need the motors, lightweight tubing, decent RC batteries & electronics, you can buold your own one, no GPS fencing etc.

Dare I say a Raspberry Pi at the heart.

OK I've very simplified it but Google/Youtube is a powerfull tool.

Argos do sell pro drones, if the price is anything to go by, here is 1 costing £1589.


https://www.argos.co.uk/product/8083603

Mick 22-12-2018 17:34

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SnoopZ (Post 35976582)
Argos do sell pro drones, if the price is anything to go by, here is 1 costing £1589.


https://www.argos.co.uk/product/8083603

They do not sell the Industrial drones costing over £5,000 and up.

nashville 22-12-2018 17:39

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
These two culprits should be severely punished for the trouble and heartache and money they have caused people. Hope there is no soft touch for them or there will be an outcry. As one we lady on the news said " Hang them "

Mick 22-12-2018 17:52

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nashville (Post 35976589)
These two culprits should be severely punished for the trouble and heartache and money they have caused people. Hope there is no soft touch for them or there will be an outcry. As one we lady on the news said " Hang them "

LOL - we don't hang child killers, if they were to start hanging people pissing about at an airport with drones, I think that would be a bigger outcry.

By all means - the judicial system should throw the book at them, however, they have highlighted very weak defense systems at UK Airports.

denphone 22-12-2018 17:59

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976595)
LOL - we don't hang child killers, if they were to start hanging people pissing about at an airport with drones, I think that would be a bigger outcry.

By all means - the judicial system should throw the book at them, however, they have highlighted very weak defense systems at UK Airports.

Pretty much spot on.:tu:

1andrew1 22-12-2018 18:03

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
I think Chris Grayling (Transport Secretary) said the maximum term is five years' imprisonment. I don't know if any other charges can be added to the charge sheet.

The Government was going to introduce some stronger legislation but hasn't got the capacity to do so.
Quote:

Transport secretary Chris Grayling delayed anti-drone legislation due to Brexit
Civil servants could not draft new regulations because of the UK's EU exit
Airline pilots slammed the government for failing to take the threat seriously
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...xit-chaos.html

Mr K 22-12-2018 19:50

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 35976603)
I think Chris Grayling (Transport Secretary) said the maximum term is five years' imprisonment. I don't know if any other charges can be added to the charge sheet.

The Government was going to introduce some stronger legislation but hasn't got the capacity to do so.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...xit-chaos.html

But will they be able to get their money back from Argos for the drone ?

denphone 22-12-2018 19:56

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 35976473)

Probably turn out to be a 14 year old nerd with a home built drone flying it from his bedroom.

2 grown adults..

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...cal-police-say

Mr K 22-12-2018 20:01

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35976652)

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/201...uple-revealed/

I'm a bit wary about naming people, assuming 'we've got them' before they've been charged, ( this goes for any arrest). His boss says he was at work during these attacks, just hope they've not made a panic arrest.

heero_yuy 23-12-2018 08:11

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
The police have to be seen to be doing something. The fact that they're all running round like headless chickens because somebody out there is much brighter than they are doesn't go down well with the proles.

1andrew1 23-12-2018 11:31

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 35976654)
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/201...uple-revealed/

I'm a bit wary about naming people, assuming 'we've got them' before they've been charged, ( this goes for any arrest). His boss says he was at work during these attacks, just hope they've not made a panic arrest.

Your wisdom has proved itself. The Police say that the couple are no longer suspects and have been released without charges.
Quote:

Sussex Police Detective Chief Superintendent Jason Tingley said: "Both people have fully co-operated with our enquiries and I am satisfied that they are no longer suspects in the drone incidents at Gatwick.
"It is important to remember that when people are arrested in an effort to make further enquiries it does not mean that they are guilty of an offence and Sussex Police would not seek to make their identity public.
https://news.sky.com/story/pair-arre...harge-11589961

denphone 23-12-2018 11:32

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Gatwick drones pair 'no longer suspects'

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-englan...n=bbc_breaking

Mick 23-12-2018 11:56

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 35976654)
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/201...uple-revealed/

I'm a bit wary about naming people, assuming 'we've got them' before they've been charged, ( this goes for any arrest). His boss says he was at work during these attacks, just hope they've not made a panic arrest.

Exactly, their names and pictures have been plastered all over the place and you got people demanding them to be hanged, think that’s a valid reason we don’t have the death penalty in this country.

denphone 23-12-2018 12:09

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976710)
Exactly, their names and pictures have been plastered all over the place and you got people demanding them to be hanged, think that’s a valid reason we don’t have the death penalty in this country.

Just looking at some of those front page headlines it is very depressing how quickly it develops into the lynch mob mentality.:(

Mr_love_monkey 23-12-2018 12:33

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976710)
Exactly, their names and pictures have been plastered all over the place and you got people demanding them to be hanged, think that’s a valid reason we don’t have the death penalty in this country.

I would imagine the 'evidence' was their next door neighbour calling in saying "The guy next door flies drones, and he was out yesterday, and has a van - oh and he also keeps parking in 'my' space on the road."

Mick 23-12-2018 12:56

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35976711)
Just looking at some of those front page headlines it is very depressing how quickly it develops into the lynch mob mentality.:(

And if I was the couple - I would read every one and look for a potential case of libel and initiate a lawsuit against them.

This has a hint of the "Cliff Richard" saga all over again - the media never learns.

denphone 23-12-2018 13:02

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35976718)
And if I was the couple - I would read every one and look for a potential case of libel and initiate a lawsuit against them.

This has a hint of the "Cliff Richard" saga all over again - the media never learns.

Indeed there are plenty of lawyers out there who would very willing to help them look for a potential case of libel and initiate a lawsuit against them.

l am all for freedom of the media but it seems to happen time after time and l think the time is right now for proper regulation rather then this oh so weak media self regulation.

Mick 23-12-2018 17:02

Re: Drones ground flights at Gatwick
 
BREAKING: Police tell BBC News that they cannot discount the possibility that there may have been no drone at all.

This incident is growing more bizarre by the hour....


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 18:45.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum