Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33701471)

Jimmy-J 26-09-2015 22:25

RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

A hospital has apologised after an RAF sergeant was asked to move out of sight of other patients in case his uniform caused offence.
Aircraft engineer Mark Prendeville was relocated twice by hospital staff who said his uniform “might upset people” because “we have all kinds of different cultures coming in”.
Link

TheDaddy 27-09-2015 01:51

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
What cultures do they mean specifically that would be upset?

denphone 27-09-2015 02:46

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Pathetic.

Osem 27-09-2015 08:14

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
IMHO if the presence of someone who serves our country and is in uniform is 'upsetting' then it's those who're being 'upset' who have the problem. Maybe they ought to moved out of harm's way and if they don't feel comfortable they have the option of going elsewhere so as not to be so troubled...

Gary L 27-09-2015 08:58

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
They should reverse it.
pretend he's a different culture person in whatever clothes he's wearing and ask him to go and stand somewhere where nobody can see him. because he might offend somebody.

or better still he should ask that the different culture person who is offended by him is moved somewhere else so he doesn't have to look at him, her or them.

this country is pathetic. we're all mad. we're a laughing stock. we let people walk all over us. we get used for our money. we're too PC. we are weak.

Taf 27-09-2015 10:35

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
I think serving military, in fact ex-military, should not have to queue but be offered priority treatment.

Hugh 27-09-2015 11:01

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
From the original link
Quote:

spokesman for East Kent University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust said: "A member of the armed forces in uniform attended our A&E and was asked by a member of staff if he wanted to sit inside the department rather than the waiting room.

"This employee was acting in good faith because previously, there had been an altercation between a member of the public and a different member of the armed forces in uniform."

The hospital trust is "absolutely clear that members of Her Majesty's armed forces, whether in uniform or not, should not be treated any differently to any other person,” the spokesman added.

nomadking 27-09-2015 11:18

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
He was moved on TWICE by TWO different people, He was moved "out of sight" of others rather than to a more advantageous or comfortable location.
Quote:

He told The Telegraph: “One of the staff asked him if he would stand around the corner so he wouldn’t be seen by other people in case it may upset them because he was in uniform.
He went round the corner not to make a fuss but then another member of staff asked him to move again in case anyone saw him because he was in uniform.”
He wasn't wearing a more official looking type of uniform, so are non-military personnel wearing camouflage items or a "Help for Heroes" T-shirt also be hidden from view?
Quote:

He was wearing a camouflage combat uniform.
Can we all now object to the wearing of certain "uniforms", or do only the views of certain groups count?

Osem 27-09-2015 11:28

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
The article mentions a previous altercation but so what? Was the forces member involved on that occasion the cause of the incident? Either way should it affect the way hospital staff deal with forces personnel? Would the staff ask a black man, a veiled muslim woman or breastfeeding mum to move had there been a previous altercation with someone or other or would they deal with those who have the big issue?

I think this incident has probably been blown out of proportion and there may well have been good intent at the heart of it but we cannot allow people who're 'offended' to determine decision making in this way. On this occasion there was no incident, just staff who felt, for one reason or another, that doing this might prevent an something happening. Maybe that says something about them and their perceptions, maybe not...

Hom3r 27-09-2015 11:31

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
IMHO if you are offended by a British serviceman in uniform in a British hospital then I have this to say. (Swear mode off)

1) Go to another hospital

2) Go to the airport/port and leave or emigrate, and sod off to some country that gives a flying fig about your offense

(Swear mode on)

Gary L 27-09-2015 11:46

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
The trouble with being offended by everything is that you get away with a lot of things because people eventually get too scared to question your behaviour incase you are offended.

obviously if you're not of that different culture then they don't care whether you're offended.

but seriously. if you are offended by the British. then as recommended.. go somewhere else.

alanbjames 27-09-2015 13:03

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
why not just put a pair of PJs on him hence no longer in uniform.

JoelTheSuperior 27-09-2015 13:19

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
In fairness the article states that he was wearing a camouflage combat uniform. Now, I think that treating him should take much higher priority over causing a fuss over what he's wearing, but I can imagine how people might be a bit startled if they saw that, especially if they've come from somewhere where they say, may have a bit of a negative association with that clothing.

With that said, I try to ignore these news stories, simply because I get the feeling that they're more or less designed to make people angry above all else.

Osem 27-09-2015 13:38

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
The guy was in hospital having been injured, not on a drunken night out. Why would anyone feel threatened or upset by that and if they are maybe it'd be fairer to ask them to go and sit somewhere else just in case other things are upsetting too. Would it be fair for someone who's had a bad time at the hands of the police, for example, to be able to determine how other police officers in uniform are dealt with simply because they feel uncomfortable or even hostile towards them?

Carlos Carboni 27-09-2015 14:02

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
In Israel, a guy came in uniform with his gun for lunch (IDF guys always have their guns with them). The Hotel asked him to take it out of sight and change his clothes....

Do surgeons go around in their overalls? lifeguards in their swimsuits? both save lives.... (for a minute, picture Pamela Anderson walking around in a hospital.) :D

I live near Aldershot, the military doctors do not wear uniforms and the soldiers do not wear uniform at the hospital; Frimley Park and Aldershot is shared with civilians. But injured soldiers in Frimley Park A&E, of course come in uniform and there is no problem. Sandhurst military personnel is not allowed in pubs/restaurants in uniform.

Saying that, this guy, Mark Prendeville, was injured at the training field, he had to be there in uniform, as the priority was to treat his burns and definitely not to change his clothes! The hospital staff was out of order, his burns was the priority.

It's a matter of etiquette/protocol, nothing to do with military haters!

techguyone 27-09-2015 14:03

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelTheSuperior (Post 35800469)
but I can imagine how people might be a bit startled if they saw that, especially if they've come from somewhere where they say, may have a bit of a negative association with that clothing.

With that said, you've succeeded in making me angry.

'bit startled' ? It's a hospital.

I'm getting a bit of a negative association with all the hand wringers who are effectively destroying our Country, and even more so with those who seemingly live to be offended at something, everything, nothing but must be kept happy at all costs.

You couldn't make it up, more and more I'm convinced I'm in an alternative WTF Earth, it isn't the one I remember.

Ramrod 27-09-2015 14:43

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carlos Carboni (Post 35800472)
Sandhurst military personnel is not allowed in pubs/restaurants in uniform.

Well they should be allowed. :(

dave6x 27-09-2015 15:19

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
So we have a member of our NATIONAL Armed Forces who turned up in uniform to be treated in a NATIONAL Health Service hospital!

Anyone who has a problem with it or is offended by it is welcome to leave and pay for treatment privately!

Osem 27-09-2015 15:32

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
If someone's injured, possibly seriously, whilst wearing their uniform are we really going to have to ask them to get changed into civvies just in case someone might be offended? This really is nonsense.

Carlos Carboni 27-09-2015 16:22

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ramrod (Post 35800478)
Well they should be allowed. :(

It is actually MoD regulations that service personnel cannot go to licensed premises in uniform.

See for example

http://www.raf.mod.uk/rafcms/mediafi...866A594026.pdf
Quote:

113. Occasions on which Uniform is Not to be Worn.
(1) On leave.
(2) Visits to licensed premises (including when not consuming alcohol), except
when specifically approved by the Chain of Command.

Ramrod 27-09-2015 18:36

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carlos Carboni (Post 35800489)
It is actually MoD regulations that service personnel cannot go to licensed premises in uniform.

See for example

http://www.raf.mod.uk/rafcms/mediafi...866A594026.pdf

Shouldn't be that way

dave6x 27-09-2015 19:00

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
I don't judge anyone on race, creed, colour, religion, etc., however, hypothetically speaking, say I was to be sitting in the same hospital opposite a woman wearing a niqab or a burka and I found that deeply offensive, would the hospital staff ask her to move? I suspect not, and I would probably be accused with being racist!

Taf 27-09-2015 19:13

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dave6x (Post 35800507)
I don't judge anyone on race, creed, colour, religion, etc., however, hypothetically speaking, say I was to be sitting in the same hospital opposite a woman wearing a niqab or a burka and I found that deeply offensive, would the hospital staff ask her to move? I suspect not, and I would probably be accused with being racist!

Sadly quite true. :(

Osem 27-09-2015 19:41

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Clearly some people feel it's OK to be more sensitive to some feelings than others.

Carlos Carboni 27-09-2015 20:09

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dave6x (Post 35800507)
I don't judge anyone on race, creed, colour, religion, etc., however, hypothetically speaking, say I was to be sitting in the same hospital opposite a woman wearing a niqab or a burka and I found that deeply offensive, would the hospital staff ask her to move? I suspect not, and I would probably be accused with being racist!

Be more specific: Hijab with uniform or without?

MOD regs state (see above link):

Hijabs.
Muslim females may wear Hijabs of the approved pattern and
colour under their uniform headdress except when operational,
training or health and safety considerations dictate otherwise.
It is worn without cap badge under the hat outdoors and without
hat indoors. The hijab is to be worn in such a way that rank slides are visible at all times.

Racist+ un-patriotic :confused:

Maggy 27-09-2015 20:20

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelTheSuperior (Post 35800469)
In fairness the article states that he was wearing a camouflage combat uniform. Now, I think that treating him should take much higher priority over causing a fuss over what he's wearing, but I can imagine how people might be a bit startled if they saw that, especially if they've come from somewhere where they say, may have a bit of a negative association with that clothing.

With that said, I try to ignore these news stories, simply because I get the feeling that they're more or less designed to make people angry above all else.

:tu:

---------- Post added at 21:20 ---------- Previous post was at 21:16 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ramrod (Post 35800501)
Shouldn't be that way

I suspect it's a hangover from the 'troubles' in NI..Off duty servicemen were advised not to wear uniform..

dave6x 27-09-2015 20:25

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carlos Carboni (Post 35800518)
Be more specific: Hijab with uniform or without?

MOD regs state (see above link):

Hijabs.
Muslim females may wear Hijabs of the approved pattern and
colour under their uniform headdress except when operational,
training or health and safety considerations dictate otherwise.
It is worn without cap badge under the hat outdoors and without
hat indoors. The hijab is to be worn in such a way that rank slides are visible at all times.

Racist+ un-patriotic :confused:

My hypothesis stated a niqab or burka, not a hijab, and my assumption was that it would be worn by a civilian Muslim female and not in a military context. Your reference makes no mention of Muslim headdress other than the hijab.

See Link

Carlos Carboni 27-09-2015 20:38

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dave6x (Post 35800527)
My hypothesis stated a niqab or burka, not a hijab, and my assumption was that it would be worn by a civilian Muslim female and not in a military context. Your reference makes no mention of Muslim headdress other than the hijab.

See Link


It was a joke :)

Also, I thought hijab and niqab was the same thing --apologies, I did not know the fine differences between burka, hijab, chador and niqa--now I do.

dave6x 27-09-2015 20:45

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carlos Carboni (Post 35800531)
It was a joke :)

Also, I thought hijab and niqab was the same thing --apologies, I did not know the fine differences between burka, hijab, chador and niqa--now I do.

No problem, although I know some people do feel intimidated when confronted by a person in a niqab or burka.

Hugh 27-09-2015 20:46

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35800519)
:tu:

---------- Post added at 21:20 ---------- Previous post was at 21:16 ----------



I suspect it's a hangover from the 'troubles' in NI..Off duty servicemen were advised not to wear uniform..

I think it's mainly about "behaviour that may bring the Armed Forces into disrepute".

Maggy 27-09-2015 22:16

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35800534)
I think it's mainly about "behaviour that may bring the Armed Forces into disrepute".

Well that's what my OH had to consider during his naval service years..

blackthorn 28-09-2015 06:41

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Long gone are the days of hitchhiking in uniform or with a cap tied to a bag. I used to hitch weekends from Faslane to Liverpool with a cap on my bag, when I`d used all my travel warrants up. Never failed to get a lift.

Uncle Peter 28-09-2015 10:11

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35800534)
I think it's mainly about "behaviour that may bring the Armed Forces into disrepute".

When I was based in London 20 odd years ago many of the pubs around Petty France/Victoria St used to have hastily scrawled signs pinned up outside: "No Forces" or "No Squaddies" due to various episodes of enthusiastic behaviour around the other clientele ;)

These days "No MP's" would be more appropriate, starting with the HoC bar ;)

Hugh 28-09-2015 10:22

Re: RAF sergeant in uniform moved by hospital to avoid offending other patients
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by blackthorn (Post 35800556)
Long gone are the days of hitchhiking in uniform or with a cap tied to a bag. I used to hitch weekends from Faslane to Liverpool with a cap on my bag, when I`d used all my travel warrants up. Never failed to get a lift.

I used to do that in the 70's, and then a general order came out forbidding it, due to the risks involved....


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:49.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum