Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist. (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33700767)

Osem 12-05-2015 15:12

Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

A welfare and diversity officer has hit out at accusations of racism, stating it is not possible for ethnic minority women to be racist or sexist.

Officer for Goldsmith's student union in New Cross, Bahar Mustafa, was previously criticised for asking white males not to attend an event on diversifying curriculum on April 22.
http://www.newsshopper.co.uk/news/12...t/?ref=mr&lp=1

She's proved herself wrong hasn't she?

Russ 12-05-2015 15:33

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
I've argued with her on Facebook in the past. Utterly barking mad and so far up her own backside she can see the back of her teeth.

Hugh 12-05-2015 15:37

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Of course they can - anyone can be racist and/or sexist.

Being a member of a minority does not give anyone a free pass on being an ass.

Osem 12-05-2015 15:39

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35777456)
Of course they can - anyone can be racist and/or sexist.

Being a member of a minority does not give anyone a free pass on being an ass.

And she's living proof.

Taf 12-05-2015 16:02

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Attacks on white males locally have not been classed as racist even though the attackers were not white and were shouting things that many saw as racist.

Julian 12-05-2015 17:06

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
She would do well to remember she is at school to learn.

Maggy 12-05-2015 17:15

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Everyone of every racial group is capable of racism..However stupidity knows no boundaries.:rolleyes:

Ignitionnet 12-05-2015 17:32

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35777452)
Utterly barking mad and so far up her own backside she can see the back of her teeth.

This seems to apply to large numbers of NUS people. Did she retreat to a safe space where she couldn't be criticised? They do have these in universities now where no dissent or disagreement is allowed.

*Jazz hands*

Chris 12-05-2015 17:59

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
There was a notice up in my student union building, back in the day: "Members and visitors please note. No member of this union shall be discriminated against on the grounds of their ethnicity, gender, their religious or political views, or their sexual orientation."

Which didn't stop some union hack pushing through a motion of "no platform" for "nazis". Not that there were any Nazis on the campus, so far as I could tell.

The irony was completely lost on them, even after several people tried in vain to explain it.

Hom3r 12-05-2015 18:17

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Racism is a one way street.

If I call someone from African descent a Black B. I'm in trouble.

They call me a White B. nothing will happen.

Pierre 12-05-2015 20:52

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35777497)
Racism is a one way street.

If I call someone from African descent a Black B. I'm in trouble.

They call me a White B. nothing will happen.

Why not just call them a *******?

( I honestly didn't expect the swear filter to kick in there, ******* is a legitimate word.)

Jimmy-J 12-05-2015 21:47

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
LOL Remember this?

Osem 12-05-2015 22:07

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Yep, typical hypocrisy. The Labour party is infested with it.

Jimmy-J 12-05-2015 22:39

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Yeah, and the sooner these people, whoever they are? Stop calling their organisations / associations, names like...

Asian Faces
Society of Black lawyers
UK Black Pride
Black Students Union
Black Families Education Support Group
Etc. etc... etc....

...The better!

alanbjames 13-05-2015 00:01

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35777452)
I've argued with her on Facebook in the past. Utterly barking mad and so far up her own backside she can see the back of her teeth.

I had a few words with her after she sent my sons str8 friend a message online pointing out he had gay friends and would go to hell and then went on to attack my son.

Russ 13-05-2015 06:20

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
What she's trying - and failing spectacularly - to say is generally women and BME (Black and minority ethnic) are rarely/never in positions to oppress, so because in her view sexism and racism is only used for the purpose of oppression she and her ilk can never be guilty of it.

In my last exchange with her I pointed out Mugabe and his 'land grab' efforts from white farmers a few years back, honestly I thought her reaction was for entertainment and performance purposes. She went off on one like a woman possessed and some of her followers joined in, they have the attitude of "If you're not 100% with us you're 100% against us". It was getting harder and harder to resist the urge to deliberately wind her up but fortunately I was kicked out of the group.

TheDaddy 13-05-2015 07:04

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Taf (Post 35777460)
Attacks on white males locally have not been classed as racist even though the attackers were not white and were shouting things that many saw as racist.

Indeed, happened to someone I was at school with

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/4460778.stm

Osem 13-05-2015 09:08

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Yes you see people like this employ the faux outrage tactic because they believe it only strengthens their argument. They also tend to equate all sorts of issues which are not linked and attach to them all sorts of hyperbole . It's why these people routinely use words like 'traumatised', 'victimised', 'abused' in connection with events which are actually relatively trivial. In order to pursue their agenda they grossly exaggerate and conflate issues and actually behave in a manner which is not dissimilar to those they say they despise. In their minds anything other that the most vehement opposition works not irrespective of how justified that might be. That's why we routinely hear about people being 'traumatised' by events that once upon a time wouldn't have even made the news.

greeninferno 13-05-2015 09:44

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35777497)
Racism is a one way street.

If I call someone from African descent a Black B. I'm in trouble.

They call me a White B. nothing will happen.

I think the argument would be to get a very good lawyer

Ordinary polis can't be relied upon to know/implement the law properly IMO.

richard s 13-05-2015 10:31

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Should the British whites not call our selves African White Britains in future - I just hate that phrase e.g. African American, etc.

Osem 13-05-2015 16:31

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Oh dear I seems to be getting worse for this poor woman. I'm sure it's all a sexist, racist plot perpetrated by non-ethnic minority women though...

Quote:

A welfare and diversity officer caught up in a racism row could potentially lose her job for tweeting the words “kill all white men” and calling people “white trash”.

Goldsmiths University's officer, Bahar Mustafa has been at the centre of a media storm after banning white men from an event on diversifying the curriculum and stating on camera ethnic minority women cannot be racist.

Students have now started a petition for a vote of no confidence in Ms Mustafa, which would remove her from office.

The petition reads: "The current Welfare and Diversity Officer has used hate speech based on race and gender.

http://www.newsshopper.co.uk/news/12..._/?ref=mr&lp=7

Gary L 13-05-2015 18:53

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jimmy-J (Post 35777547)
Yeah, and the sooner these people, whoever they are? Stop calling their organisations / associations, names like...

Asian Faces
Society of Black lawyers
UK Black Pride
Black Students Union
Black Families Education Support Group
Etc. etc... etc....

...The better!

Yes!
that's one of the roots of it all.

they say that it's about achievement why they use the colour.
(here we go. it's the them and us again)
so if we used the White one. they'll say we're either being racist and all the rest that we could say about them having a non white gang. but we don't.

absolutely bonkers it all is.

Damien 13-05-2015 19:46

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Student unions politics is nuts. It's a playground for aspirating future Labour politicians and fringe activists. Their motions and debates rarely resonate with the wider student body who let them get on with it. Honestly very few students care about these Unions and even the politically motivated students will largely get involved elsewhere.

I remember my Uni had nonsense elections for it and the only vote I remember was when they tried to ban for Coca-Cola on campus for various stupid reasons I cannot remember. Like 99% of the rest of the student body I didn't vote but they did fail to get it passed, I assume 3 or 4 coca-cola addicts turned up and had a majority to vote them done.

They are often bizarrely illiberal as well. Chris mentioned the 'no-platform' policy but this has grown to the stage where they will interrupt and protest speakers they don't like who've been invited by other groups. I don't really have a problem with the Union itself deciding not to invite people to their own private platform - it's their choice - but preventing others from speaking in environments that are nothing to do with you is pretty objectionable behaviour.

Osem 13-05-2015 20:09

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35777707)
Student unions politics is nuts. It's a playground for aspirating future Labour politicians and fringe activists. Their motions and debates rarely resonate with the wider student body who let them get on with it. Honestly very few students care about these Unions and even the politically motivated students will largely get involved elsewhere.

I remember my Uni had nonsense elections for it and the only vote I remember was when they tried to ban for Coca-Cola on campus for various stupid reasons I cannot remember. Like 99% of the rest of the student body I didn't vote but they did fail to get it passed, I assume 3 or 4 coca-cola addicts turned up and had a majority to vote them done.

They are often bizarrely illiberal as well. Chris mentioned the 'no-platform' policy but this has grown to the stage where they will interrupt and protest speakers they don't like who've been invited by other groups. I don't really have a problem with the Union itself deciding not to invite people to their own private platform - it's their choice - but preventing others from speaking in environments that are nothing to do with you is pretty objectionable behaviour.

It was the same at my uni - a militant bunch of idiots who spent far more time causing trouble than studying. Maybe that's why certain unions think it's great to strike on the basis of a paltry turn out. ;)

Damien 13-05-2015 22:18

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35777709)
It was the same at my uni - a militant bunch of idiots who spent far more time causing trouble than studying. Maybe that's why certain unions think it's great to strike on the basis of a paltry turn out. ;)

Wouldn't bother giving these people the attention really. I certainly didn't at uni. It's a world detached from reality. They don't represent the students and the only reason students join is the discount card you get. This case is even bizarre by the already bizarre standards of student unions!

dave6x 13-05-2015 22:23

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35777709)
It was the same at my uni - a militant bunch of idiots who spent far more time causing trouble than studying. Maybe that's why certain unions think it's great to strike on the basis of a paltry turn out. ;)

Your comment brought back distant memories of the LSE Riots! Lots of student unrest there in the 60's, unfortunately I'm old enough to remember the news!

Russ 14-05-2015 05:58

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35777677)
Oh dear I seems to be getting worse for this poor woman. I'm sure it's all a sexist, racist plot perpetrated by non-ethnic minority women though...




http://www.newsshopper.co.uk/news/12..._/?ref=mr&lp=7

Hang on, never mind a "vote of no confidence", why is she not being arrested for inciting racial hatred for the "kill all white men" comment? The fact it was supposedly an in-joke makes no difference at all.

TheDaddy 14-05-2015 06:03

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35777752)
Hang on, never mind a "vote of no confidence", why is she not being arrested for inciting racial hatred for the "kill all white men" comment? The fact it was supposedly an in-joke makes no difference at all.

Perhaps because no one has made a complaint to them...

Pierre 14-05-2015 14:47

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by richard s (Post 35777597)
Should the British whites not call our selves African White Britains in future - I just hate that phrase e.g. African American, etc.

Considering that all humans are descended from the hominids that came out of Africa, then yes, we are equally able to call ourselves African-British.

Stuart 14-05-2015 16:56

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35777456)
Of course they can - anyone can be racist and/or sexist.

Being a member of a minority does not give anyone a free pass on being an ass.

The thing is, there you go introducing facts into an argument.

People are people, and regardless of their colour, gender or any other physical descriptor you care to mention, they can be offensive to other people.

Regarding this lady. I do not know what it's like, but I have a friend who was born in Belgium to a Pakistani father and Belgian mother, is a lady and is therefore arguably an ethnic minority. She also used to work for Goldsmiths and reckons that Goldsmiths is an awful place to work because of things like this.

---------- Post added at 16:56 ---------- Previous post was at 16:40 ----------

From the article:
Quote:

She said: "I, an ethnic minority woman, cannot be racist or sexist towards white men because racism and sexism describes structures of privilege based on race and gender.

"Therefore women of colour and minority genders cannot be racist or sexist since we do not stand to benefit from such a system.
From the OED:
Quote:

racism |ˈreɪsɪz(ə)m|
noun [ mass noun ]
the belief that all members of each race possess characteristics, abilities, or qualities specific to that race, especially so as to distinguish it as inferior or superior to another race or races. theories of racism.
• prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one's own race is superior: a programme to combat racism.
No mention of privilege there. It just mentions the idea of belief that either your race is superior or others inferior to yours.

Quote:

sexism |ˈsɛksɪz(ə)m|
noun [ mass noun ]
prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex. sexism in language is an offensive reminder of the way the culture sees women.
DERIVATIVES
sexist adjective& noun
Again, no mention of privilege, just discrimination based on gender.

No, going on those ACTUAL DEFINITIONS, I would argue she is racist because she is making assumptions about white people based purely on the fact they are white. I would argue that she is sexist because she is making assumptions about men based purely on the fact they are men. Who benefits (assuming anyone does) is irrelevant.

Personally, I try and avoid making judgments on people based purely on their race or gender. I make judgements on people based on how they act toward me.

tweetiepooh 14-05-2015 17:12

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Why back I was coding a patient system for a hospital and part of the stats were to record ethnicity of patients. (Actually useful medically too in some cases).

There are different codes for (simplifying here) British Black and Black British and the distinction is one the patient (or respondent) makes.

(BTW I was not privy to the analysis of the figures. And I wouldn't share them if I was.)

----

There are differences between gender and race, some more obvious. But there is not a difference in value. We should learn to embrace and utilise the differences but never use those differences to denigrate or devalue any group.

Osem 14-05-2015 17:24

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
The thing that always surprises me is that people who feel they (or those they represent) are the victims of some 'ism' or another tend to employ their very own 'isms' when putting forward their case. Odd that and not a little ironic...

TheDaddy 15-06-2015 04:00

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Has the welfare and diversity old bag kept her job? Course she has, we don't have enough harridans making mischief, on the other hand we have loads of Nobel laureate medical scientists that we can afford to lose one for telling pretty poor, unfunny jokes. Surely there is some sort of course he could've go on to learn the error of his ways, perhaps he could've taken said old bag with him to, that'd really learn him, a few hours with her.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2...or-men-in-labs

Russ 06-10-2015 19:15

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2...e_iOSApp_Other

She won't get the sort of punishment a white person would receive if they'd said the same about blacks but at least the police are getting involved.

Ignitionnet 07-10-2015 00:14

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2015/10/33.jpg
https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2015/10/34.jpg

The bit I most enjoyed was her commenting on 'us in the working class'. This from a woman who is 27 and still in university, albeit as the welfare and diversity officer, having recently graduated with that qualification always in demand among employers, an MA in gender and media studies, and who still lives with her parents. For all her rage against the Tories she has absolutely no idea about the impact of their policies having been pleasantly insulated by academia and her parents.

---------- Post added 07-10-2015 at 00:14 ---------- Previous post was 06-10-2015 at 23:50 ----------

I should emphasise that I do not think she should be prosecuted. Unlike her I am a fan of freedom of speech, don't want a censorious society and don't think life should come with a trigger warning.

Hopefully this experience will encourage her to appreciate that what she demands goes both ways.

Osem 17-10-2015 18:49

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

A woman has been arrested after footage appearing to show a racist tirade on a London bus was circulated online.

The video, which has since been removed, shows a pregnant Muslim woman being verbally abused and threatened.

A 36-year-old was arrested on suspicion of a racially aggravated public order offence at her home in Willesden Green on Friday, the Met said.

She was taken into custody at a north London police station, the force said.

The incident happened on 13 October at about 10:30 BST as the bus was travelling along Knatchbull Road, according to police.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-34560277

Quote:

Footage showing a woman's anti-Muslim tirade on a London bus has prompted a discussion about the fact that the abusive woman is black.

The video was filmed on a bus in north-west London and uploaded to Facebook on Wednesday. It starts with a woman in the middle of a rant. She's shouting and swearing at a pregnant Muslim woman, and threatening to kick her in the stomach.

The abusive woman goes on to lob several insults, calling the other woman an Islamic State supporter, a suicide bomber and saying: "go back to your country." At one point the bus driver stops the bus and tries to calm the woman down - to no avail. When the bus starts up again the confrontation escalates. The video was viewed more than 750,000 times before it was taken down or blocked on Friday morning (it's unclear who took it down and why).

Of course, racist monologues directed towards other passengers on public transport and posted to social media are nothing new. But this particular incident stands out because those sharing and commenting have focussed on the fact that the perpetrator of the abuse is black. The woman, who has not been identified, has a London accent, and many comments about the video concentrate on her ethnic origin.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-34549590

Taf 17-10-2015 19:07

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Ah, but they can be anti-islamic ... or the new term "islamaphobic" which means to have an irrational fear of them.

Not such an irrational fear in the near future I reckon.

Damien 18-10-2015 10:32

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
I would say that's worse than what Mustafa tweeted. Free speech doesn't cover directly abusing someone.

Ignitionnet 18-10-2015 13:16

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35803872)
I would say that's worse than what Mustafa tweeted. Free speech doesn't cover directly abusing someone.

Agree on both counts. This episode is a reminder that anyone can engage in bigotry, and be racist even if they aren't a white CIS male.

I do of course run with the dictionary definition of racism rather than the 'sociological' definition Mustafa uses.

Damien 18-10-2015 14:57

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35803899)
Agree on both counts. This episode is a reminder that anyone can engage in bigotry, and be racist even if they aren't a white CIS male.

I do of course run with the dictionary definition of racism rather than the 'sociological' definition Mustafa uses.

I think they would have an easier time if they separated the concepts of racism and institutionalised racism. I don't think many, CF side, can argue that in a broader context that white people have suffered anywhere near as much from racism as minority groups have or that previous injustices still impact upon today.

Jimmy-J 20-10-2015 01:54

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Another racist on a bus, albeit a black male.

Quote:

A thug threw a Turkish migrant's zimmer frame off a London bus after shouting 'go back to your own country' in a shocking Islamophobic rant.

The unidentified man was travelling on a bus thought to be heading towards Tottenham when he began to abuse a pensioner sat across the aisle from him.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...obic-rant.html

Damien 03-11-2015 19:48

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Charges have been dropped: http://www.theguardian.com/world/201...llwhitemen-row

Good. Stupid law, stupid charges. I hope (but doubt) we'll see this communications act revised in future to deal with this attempts at convictions. These can harm peoples' lives.

Russ 03-11-2015 20:34

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
What a nasty evil little woman she is. It's a massive shame the charges are dropped, this will allow people to think that coming out with such rubbish as what she tweeted (plus the whole "I can't be racist/sexist" crap) is acceptable. That will likely lead to further racial tensions and a whole lot more.

Osem 03-11-2015 20:38

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Well that's ok because the targets of her venom and hate were only men...

Damien 03-11-2015 21:02

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35806310)
What a nasty evil little woman she is. It's a massive shame the charges are dropped, this will allow people to think that coming out with such rubbish as what she tweeted (plus the whole "I can't be racist/sexist" crap) is acceptable. That will likely lead to further racial tensions and a whole lot more.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35806311)
Well that's ok because the targets of her venom and hate were only men...

It's not acceptable nor 'ok' but it shouldn't be illegal. It also was clearly not a serious threat in context. People all over Twitter were Tweeting that hashtag in the aftermath of her arrest and didn't get a visit from the police which highlights how stupid her initial arrest was and how poorly implemented this law is.

As for this leading to 'further racial tensions' I seriously doubt it. Most people don't know or care about this level of social justice or identity politics. It mains a subculture confined to the Internet and the more militant parts of Student Union politics.

We all pay far too much attention to the wider, more extreme, proponents of any issue and it doesn't do anyone any good. All it does is cause our reaction to them to become more extreme as well until everyone is just shouting at each other and using words like 'evil' for someone.

You are giving her too much attention and significance than she deserves.

Osem 03-11-2015 21:07

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
I think she's a symptom of a widespread disease, the sufferers of which perceive men as fair game for insults, abuse, biased treatment under the law etc. etc. If a man had said such things people like her would have been up in arms whining about yet more male oppression blah blah blah. That's just my opinion.

Ignitionnet 04-11-2015 09:01

Re: Ethnic minority women can't be racist or sexist.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35806308)

Very good. Even if her horrendous Vice 'interview' or more accurately opportunity to spout her talking points would've won her no fans.

The woman is a symptom of people hanging around the safe space echo chambers that seem a mainstay of university now.

She really needs to get out of there and live in the real world for a while to try and bring some balance into her immature, childish and absurd views.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum