Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons. (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33691495)

Derek 10-01-2013 11:22

Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
You know how the prisons are ridiculously full? Obviously the fat, lazy cops just preying on motorists while waiting for their gold plated pensions are doing something right.

Well to deal with this the government have decided to build a spanking new super prison holding 2,000 inmates. To help pay for this they are closing six older prisons that hold 2,600 inmates.

Quote:

Six prisons in England are to be closed and three more will be partially shut, the Ministry of Justice has announced.

It will result in the loss of 2,600 places in what the statement called "old and uneconomic" prisons and is expected to save £63m per year from the cost of running prisons.

The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) says it also plans to build a new super prison with 2,000 places.

The six prisons that are to close are Bullwood Hall in Essex, Canterbury, Gloucester, Kingston in Portsmouth, Shepton Mallet in Somerset and Shrewsbury.

Prisons in Chelmsford, Hull and Isle of Wight are to be partially closed.
Can anyone else see a potential issue here? Like losing 600 spaces?

Of course the cynic in me is sure that the new 'super' prison wont be run by the private sector... :rolleyes:

Damien 10-01-2013 11:32

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Maybe the private sector can help pay for their prisons by offering inmates 'upgrade' packages that promise bigger cells, nicer beds, full english breakfast and a dedicated guard! Thus saving even more than £63 million a year.

BenMcr 10-01-2013 12:45

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
I know this may not be fashionable thinking, but I thought part of the reason we have many smaller prisons was in part to keep prisoners connected with family and friends that could potentially help them once they were released

Shipping people off to a 'super prison' that could be halfway across the country seems like it could cause issues as if someone hasn't got any support when they get out, what is to stop them falling back into whatever caused them to go to prison in the first place?

And yes I'm aware that this does happen now, but it must happen less than when they changes occur.

Osem 10-01-2013 13:43

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
It's totally consistent isn't it? HMG have long been dealing with the effects of a growing and ageing population by encouraging an influx of immigrants many of whom will stay here, have children and then grow old themselves... :confused: :rolleyes:

Taf 10-01-2013 14:15

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35521479)
It's totally consistent isn't it? HMG have long been dealing with the effects of a growing and ageing population by encouraging an influx of immigrants many of whom will stay here, have children and then grow old themselves... :confused: :rolleyes:

And spend time in our overcrowded prisons?

tizmeinnit 10-01-2013 14:17

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35521418)
Maybe the private sector can help pay for their prisons by offering inmates 'upgrade' packages that promise bigger cells, nicer beds, full english breakfast and a dedicated guard! Thus saving even more than £63 million a year.


I would pay the upgrade if it mean't no one took my cherry lmao

---------- Post added at 13:17 ---------- Previous post was at 13:16 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 35521453)
I know this may not be fashionable thinking, but I thought part of the reason we have many smaller prisons was in part to keep prisoners connected with family and friends that could potentially help them once they were released

Shipping people off to a 'super prison' that could be halfway across the country seems like it could cause issues as if someone hasn't got any support when they get out, what is to stop them falling back into whatever caused them to go to prison in the first place?

And yes I'm aware that this does happen now, but it must happen less than when they changes occur.

they would get a travel warrant home though they would not be expected to stay there

Damien 10-01-2013 14:24

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35521479)
It's totally consistent isn't it? HMG have long been dealing with the effects of a growing and ageing population by encouraging an influx of immigrants many of whom will stay here, have children and then grow old themselves... :confused: :rolleyes:

Well if they pay taxes than this is fine. A lot of people are reaching pension age and there isn't the population to sustain it. As the baby boomer generation reaches retirement age we need more people to pay into the system so that the rest of us can afford their pensions, to redress the population balance.

For all the talk about foreign aid or 'skivers' it's the care and pensions for the elderly that really costs. Got to pay for it somehow...

martyh 10-01-2013 15:14

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 35521453)
I know this may not be fashionable thinking, but I thought part of the reason we have many smaller prisons was in part to keep prisoners connected with family and friends that could potentially help them once they were released

Shipping people off to a 'super prison' that could be halfway across the country seems like it could cause issues as if someone hasn't got any support when they get out, what is to stop them falling back into whatever caused them to go to prison in the first place?

And yes I'm aware that this does happen now, but it must happen less than when they changes occur.

A lifestyle choice ? it is their own choice that they are in prison in the first place all they have to do is make the decision not to back into jail again .

nomadking 10-01-2013 15:17

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35521491)
Well if they pay taxes than this is fine. A lot of people are reaching pension age and there isn't the population to sustain it. As the baby boomer generation reaches retirement age we need more people to pay into the system so that the rest of us can afford their pensions, to redress the population balance.

For all the talk about foreign aid or 'skivers' it's the care and pensions for the elderly that really costs. Got to pay for it somehow...

If x amount of immigrants arrive and pay taxes, it doesn't end up with x more taxpayers.:rolleyes: That taxable income would not be magically generated from thin air, it is taken from elsewhere. Just as the amount of housing, energy generation, health care, water supply, roads etc doesn't suddenly magically increase.

Maggy 10-01-2013 15:26

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
How did this become a discussion on immigration?Let's please deal with the topic at hand and specified in the title.

Gary L 10-01-2013 16:46

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
I bet they leave the shutdown prisons standing long enough to start chucking disabled and poor people into. when they start being a nuisance.

Osem 10-01-2013 16:53

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35521491)
Well if they pay taxes than this is fine. A lot of people are reaching pension age and there isn't the population to sustain it. As the baby boomer generation reaches retirement age we need more people to pay into the system so that the rest of us can afford their pensions, to redress the population balance.

For all the talk about foreign aid or 'skivers' it's the care and pensions for the elderly that really costs. Got to pay for it somehow...

No it isn't. Adding to the population doesn't solve the problem it just makes the problem bigger and becomes a merry-go-round. If migration is going to be the solution to the care/pensions crisis it has to be temporary migration not permanent. We digress anyway... ;)

Surely the best way of controlling our prison population is to persuade people not to go down that route in the first place and even control our population better. Building more and more prisons to hold more and more people isn't sustainable. We may not like the idea of having controls on the number of children we can have but frankly I see it becoming inevitable.

martyh 10-01-2013 17:09

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Probably worth pointing out that along with the new super prison there are 4 new mini prisons being built onto existing prisons

Quote:

as well as the super-prison, there are plans for four new mini-prisons known as houseblocks which could hold up to 1,260 prisoners. These are due to be built at existing prisons in Parc in South Wales, Peterborough in Cambridgeshire, the Mount in Hertfordshire, and Thameside in London.
http://news.sky.com/story/1036053/si...project-begins

v0id 10-01-2013 17:31

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
They should find a tropical island to send all the criminals to :D

Derek 10-01-2013 17:40

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by v0id (Post 35521574)
They should find a tropical island to send all the criminals to :D

How about here?

Maybe not tropical but we could give them a coat to share.

Mick Fisher 10-01-2013 17:47

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek (Post 35521585)
How about here?

Maybe not tropical but we could give them a coat to share.

Gets my vote :D

Osem 10-01-2013 18:13

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek (Post 35521585)
How about here?

Maybe not tropical but we could give them a coat to share.

Or a couple lof mountain sheep to sheer. :D

Anyway I thought that's what Australia is for... :)

Gary L 10-01-2013 18:25

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Got no money.
got money to build a new big prison.
(save 63 million pound a year) peanuts.

got more money to extend existing prisons to house an extra 1,260 prisoners.

are we expecting a mass law breaking spree or something?

Mick Fisher 10-01-2013 18:45

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 35521608)
Got no money.
got money to build a new big prison.
(save 63 million pound a year) peanuts.

got more money to extend existing prisons to house an extra 1,260 prisoners.

are we expecting a mass law breaking spree or something?

Probably :D

Gary L 10-01-2013 20:28

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick Fisher (Post 35521619)
Probably :D

Hugh will tell you I'm right again.
I said this would happen :)

they're on the news talking about it as if it's a matter of urgency. and they say they'll be saving 63 million pounds a year (nobody has asked them how much it's going to cost to build and when will we see a return on our investment)

then they go and tell us that they're making more room as well as the new super prison to tell the courts that there's plenty of room so keep sending them.
(Super prison. in Britain. you never thought you'd hear them 2 words together did you)

it's all scary how nobody can see what's going on. only me :D

Mick Fisher 10-01-2013 21:06

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
You remember that other scam called "care in the community" that's led to God knows how many innocent bystanders being stabbed and assaulted over the years, well if they can keep saving money by closing prisons we might have "incarcerated in the community" along with the associated rise in muggings and burglaries for all those unlucky enough not to live in Secure Mansions or gated communities. :D

Pierre 10-01-2013 23:17

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
If there's one think that needs investment and modernising in this country it's our prisons.

All the old Victorian installations, which is most of them, need bulldozing.

I'd of thought that a new modern facility would be welcomed.

martyh 10-01-2013 23:22

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35521774)
If there's one think that needs investment and modernising in this country it's our prisons.

All the old Victorian installations, which is most of them, need bulldozing.

I'd of thought that a new modern facility would be welcomed.

I agree ,it's a government project that will employ a good few people and doesn't cost an arm and a leg

Cobbydaler 10-01-2013 23:28

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
This is becoming a Daily Fail type thread. Surely it makes sense to decommission older prisons & replace them with newer ones which have better conditions for inmates & better training facilities to help prevent them from re-offending? Admittedly some inmates would be farther from their families, but it's a balance?

Gary L 10-01-2013 23:37

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
My God. we're worrying about prisoners living in old buildings and their living conditions.

I'd be ok about giving them a brand new building to cheer them up a bit. as long as they triple their pocket money and allow them a new iphone and £20 worth of free credit every week.
(it has to roll over as well so they don't feel cheated)

Cobbydaler 10-01-2013 23:41

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 35521789)
My God. we're worrying about prisoners living in old buildings and their living conditions.

I'd be ok about giving them a brand new building to cheer them up a bit. as long as they triple their pocket money and allow them a new iphone and £20 worth of free credit every week.
(it has to roll over as well so they don't feel cheated)

It's also about the cost of maintaining these older prisons...

Gary L 10-01-2013 23:49

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
£63 million pounds a year. which is absolutely nothing in savings compared to what other savings they're making elsewhere.

they just need more prison space to cope for what's coming. that's all.

martyh 10-01-2013 23:51

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 35521789)
My God. we're worrying about prisoners living in old buildings and their living conditions.

I'd be ok about giving them a brand new building to cheer them up a bit. as long as they triple their pocket money and allow them a new iphone and £20 worth of free credit every week.
(it has to roll over as well so they don't feel cheated)

Prisoners cost us enough as it is why should we compound that by constantly forking out good money on ramshackle old buildings and pointless maintenance.
My only problem with this is that it is a government project ,it will be overcosted ,it will overrun on time and cost twice as much as originally quoted apart from that i'm good with it

Osem 11-01-2013 11:34

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35521793)
Prisoners cost us enough as it is why should we compound that by constantly forking out good money on ramshackle old buildings and pointless maintenance.
My only problem with this is that it is a government project ,it will be overcosted ,it will overrun on time and cost twice as much as originally quoted apart from that i'm good with it

...and the civil servants responsible for the inevitable failures will be severely punished by getting moved to another department... :rolleyes:

martyh 14-01-2013 23:29

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
This is why we need new prisons ,must keep the little princesses happy musn't we .

Writing about conditions in Durham prison a prisoner says

Quote:

IT’S got “squalid” conditions, substandard washing facilities and the rooms are “appalling”.
It's not a bloody hotel

Quote:

by far the dirtiest prison I’ve ever been held in”, adding: “We can only shower for five days of the week, the state of the cells is appalling, with no assistance or encouragement from staff to provide cleaning equipment. I haven’t seen a single sterilising tablet since I arrived.”
then try staying out of prison



Quote:

A Prison Service spokesperson said: “All prisoners are encouraged to keep the prison clean and work on repainting cells, cleaning wings and scrubbing graffiti. Cells, laundry facilities and association areas are inspected by senior management at the prison and the Independent Monitoring Board on a regular basis to ensure standards are upheld.”
Trouble is they cannot force the inmates to clean ,they are "encouraged"

Makes me want to puke








Damien 14-01-2013 23:33

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Prisoners' should be entitled to clean conditions at least. It's not a hotel but there are basic sanitary conditions that have to be met. I mean if they're falling into a state of disrepair than that requires building work. If they're just dirty then get the prisoners to clean them.

martyh 14-01-2013 23:39

Re: Government deal with overcrowding in prisons. By closing prisons.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35523236)
Prisoners' should be entitled to clean conditions at least. It's not a hotel but there are basic sanitary conditions that have to be met. I mean if they're falling into a state of disrepair than that requires building work. If they're just dirty then get the prisoners to clean them.

The wing is old but is serviceable ,i have done some work there a few years back (honest it was work ;))It does need pulling down and probably will be soon but in the meantime cleaning the cells is the prisoners responsibility some of the little darlings want a maid service though


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 21:07.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum