Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5 (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33689760)

wakkaday 17-09-2012 16:41

is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
they have the best deal.

im with orange and t-mobile.
orange upgrade is pathetic as i might aswell get a new contract...

so i am thinking of 3 network

i knew a few years ago people said their signal was poor etc, is this still the case?

Russ 17-09-2012 16:51

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Yes, if you're in one of the areas where their signal is poor. If you're lucky to live in one of the areas with a good signal then you're in luck.

Tezcatlipoca 17-09-2012 19:07

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
My contract is up in a month or two, and I'm seriously considering ditching O2 for Three.

Easily the best deal for a pay monthly iPhone 5 compared to the other networks. Also the chance of LTE in a year when Three starts using the spectrum it bought from EE.

paulsouth 17-09-2012 19:26

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matt D (Post 35475208)
My contract is up in a month or two, and I'm seriously considering ditching O2 for Three.

Easily the best deal for a pay monthly iPhone 5 compared to the other networks. Also the chance of LTE in a year when Three starts using the spectrum it bought from EE.

to be honest depends where u are?
where i live its bloddy fast.. infact its quicker than virgin media..

GrimUpNorth 17-09-2012 19:53

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulsouth (Post 35475219)
to be honest depends where u are?
where i live its bloddy fast.. infact its quicker than virgin media..

Now that doesn't surprise me coming from you.

Cheers

Grim

wakkaday 17-09-2012 21:32

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
im disapointed with the upgrade offers for iphone5. you may aswell get a new contract..

v0id 17-09-2012 21:34

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
You don't have to go to Orange to upgrade.
I usually just peruse the carphone warehouse website for a cheap deal, plus their handsets come unbranded unlike with Orange, with their Orange branding all over them

DJSADERS 17-09-2012 21:41

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
i use three with the Samsung Galaxy SII and i think it's good, never really had any signal problems

qasdfdsaq 17-09-2012 22:18

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
If you're on Orange already you'd have to be pretty desperate to save money to move to 3.

Most likely threatening to leave will get you a better deal out of your current network.

As for 3 - there's absolutely no advantage to their network these days (they lost most of that with the T-Mobile merger). Coverage you'll be better on EE, capacity you'll be better on EE, reliability you'll be better on EE, and not to mention the iPhone 5 will (supposedly) not work on 4G on any network other EE anytime soon and will only ever work if they turn off parts of their 2G or 3G networks.

Stephen 17-09-2012 23:36

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
I have mobile broadband with Three and get great signal everywhere. Speeds are great too.

Years ago when they first launched their coverage wasn't good but its really good these days.

Tezcatlipoca 18-09-2012 00:14

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulsouth (Post 35475219)
to be honest depends where u are?
where i live its bloddy fast.. infact its quicker than virgin media..

Cambridge. The Three postcode checker alleges I'll have a great signal at home and work.

Quote:

Originally Posted by wakkaday (Post 35475271)
im disapointed with the upgrade offers for iphone5. you may aswell get a new contract..

I don't think upgrade offers have ever been great for the iPhone... Or even what you could call "offers".

Quote:

Originally Posted by v0id (Post 35475272)
You don't have to go to Orange to upgrade.
I usually just peruse the carphone warehouse website for a cheap deal, plus their handsets come unbranded unlike with Orange, with their Orange branding all over them

No branding issues with the iPhone.

Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35475292)
If you're on Orange already you'd have to be pretty desperate to save money to move to 3.

Most likely threatening to leave will get you a better deal out of your current network.

As for 3 - there's absolutely no advantage to their network these days (they lost most of that with the T-Mobile merger). Coverage you'll be better on EE, capacity you'll be better on EE, reliability you'll be better on EE, and not to mention the iPhone 5 will (supposedly) not work on 4G on any network other EE anytime soon and will only ever work if they turn off parts of their 2G or 3G networks.

No supposedly about it.

The iPhone 5 supports LTE bands 1, 3 and 5.

EE will be using band 3 (1800MHz). Three will eventually be able to use it, as it bought some of EE's spectrum, but not until September 2013.

The bands being auctioned by Ofcom for LTE are not 1, 3, or 5. No matter what O2 and the rest end up with, the iPhone 5's LTE won't support it.

If/when Ofcom ever allows band 1 (2.1GHz) to be re-farmed for LTE we'll probably be on the iPhone 7S... by then there'd hopefully be wider LTE support anyway!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-19586067

wwe 18-09-2012 13:54

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
I've been with 3 for nearly 10 years never had an problem with the signal or any thing else

AndyCambs 18-09-2012 20:00

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
I had an iPhone 3S with Orange and when the contract was up, tried to negotiate a price so the down payment was the same as Three offered. I was told to go to Three (in as many words).
Three offered unlimited downloads and tethering is no additional fee. Useful when the broadband connection fails and you can still work from home albeit reduced capacity!
So apart from just about double minutes and unlimited downloads for the same monthly price, the downpayment was less than half price of Orange.

Network - I've actually found that Three were better around my area (and on the train journey to London) where Virgin Mobile and Orange always had a black spot.
I'll probably stay with Three when this contract is up.

qasdfdsaq 19-09-2012 00:09

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matt D (Post 35475325)
No supposedly about it.

The iPhone 5 supports LTE bands 1, 3 and 5.

EE will be using band 3 (1800MHz). Three will eventually be able to use it, as it bought some of EE's spectrum, but not until September 2013.

The bands being auctioned by Ofcom for LTE are not 1, 3, or 5. No matter what O2 and the rest end up with, the iPhone 5's LTE won't support it.

If/when Ofcom ever allows band 1 (2.1GHz) to be re-farmed for LTE we'll probably be on the iPhone 7S... by then there'd hopefully be wider LTE support anyway!

Not entirely true. O2 and Vodafone also own 1800Mhz (band 3) spectrum and could use it for LTE if they wanted to, same goes for 2.1Ghz (band 1). It took barely a year for the 900/1800 LTE refarming to get approved, I suspect any attempt to get 2.1Ghz approved will be even faster given that every network owns spectrum in the band.

As for the phone itself, there are already variants that support LTE on bands 4, 9, 13, 17, and 15, and in the US it's pretty much standard for manufacturers to make phones specifically tailored to each individual provider's frequencies - nothing to stop them doing that in Europe as well.

But in any case none of this is going to be happening particularly soon.

Matthew 19-09-2012 23:53

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
From a data view 3 are great, never used for voice.

I find Orange to be best priced for myself or a phone contract.

qasdfdsaq 20-09-2012 11:16

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
For data I find 3 pathetically congested in some areas (64kbit/s if you're lucky) whereas T-Orange is better for both data coverage and data speed.

Tezcatlipoca 20-09-2012 19:18

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
I had O2 unlock my iPhone this week so that I could test Three's coverage etc. via a PAYG SIM.

Got the SIM today. Good signal at home, just need to try it out at work and a couple of other places.

qasdfdsaq 21-09-2012 01:09

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Just remember they've disabled 2G data in most places and are progressively turning off 2G entirely in many.

Uncle Peter 22-09-2012 21:40

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Aye tis hit and miss. Utter crap in Central London particularly around the major railway stations. Not signal wise but speed wise.

Vieil Homme 22-09-2012 22:24

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wakkaday (Post 35475145)
they have the best deal.

im with orange and t-mobile.
orange upgrade is pathetic as i might aswell get a new contract...

so i am thinking of 3 network

i knew a few years ago people said their signal was poor etc, is this still the case?

Depends on your area but at Kent Uni Orange/T-mobile and 02 are quite bad but 3 network shines through and the data is quite fast. Same around Letchworth area so my daughter is made-up she has a phone she can use and is real happy with the deal she got from 3 for an iPhone 4s

Best thing is get a free 3 sim and try it out

qasdfdsaq 23-09-2012 00:15

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
T-Mobile and 3 have the same coverage, except on 3 you don't get the added benefit of Orange 3G and T-Mobile 2G

paulsouth 23-09-2012 04:43

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wakkaday (Post 35475145)
they have the best deal.

im with orange and t-mobile.
orange upgrade is pathetic as i might aswell get a new contract...

so i am thinking of 3 network

i knew a few years ago people said their signal was poor etc, is this still the case?

to be honest,it depends on the area u live in..
honest truth.. o2 are better than 3.
they been running for years..
but i find the 3 internet dongle is better than o2.
being real..it depends where u live..

Vieil Homme 23-09-2012 07:34

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35477047)
T-Mobile and 3 have the same coverage, except on 3 you don't get the added benefit of Orange 3G and T-Mobile 2G

:confused: both Orange and T-mobile give you 3G and there is talk of 2G being turned off. I am on T-mobile and in my area the switching works well on 3G and I can switch off 3G giving me 2G :confused: I am ;)

richard1960 23-09-2012 09:44

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
I am with three and have been for 4 years never really had a signal problem except on the Norfolk Broads but all mobile providers have problems in North Norfolk.!

Other then that great value i have just upgraded with them on the one plan with a Smasung Galaxy 2, 2,000 mimutes,5,000 texts,unlimited broadband including tethering £25 a month even Virgin Mobile with their VM customer discount could not beat that price.:)

qasdfdsaq 23-09-2012 20:56

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Vieil Homme (Post 35477062)
:confused: both Orange and T-mobile give you 3G and there is talk of 2G being turned off. I am on T-mobile and in my area the switching works well on 3G and I can switch off 3G giving me 2G :confused: I am ;)

Nobody except 3 is turning off 2G, and that's only because they have to pay through the ears for it.

Orange/T-Mobile will be upgrading all 2G transmitters to 3G but will not be turning off 2G any time in the next decade.

Vieil Homme 23-09-2012 21:15

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qasdfdsaq (Post 35477283)
Nobody except 3 is turning off 2G, and that's only because they have to pay through the ears for it.

Orange/T-Mobile will be upgrading all 2G transmitters to 3G but will not be turning off 2G any time in the next decade.

Sorry for the silly question but if T-mobile/Orange are upgrading all 2G tansmitters to 3G how will they run the 2G network :confused:

Secondly why is the 2G network still needed as most people are running smart phones ??

mike24 23-09-2012 23:32

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
I used to be on 3 but found out, when using the web, could not relied upon to work all of the time.

qasdfdsaq 24-09-2012 15:10

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Vieil Homme (Post 35477288)
Sorry for the silly question but if T-mobile/Orange are upgrading all 2G tansmitters to 3G how will they run the 2G network :confused:

Secondly why is the 2G network still needed as most people are running smart phones ??

The same way they do now. They run both 3G and 2G on the same transmitter at the same time. When you upgrade a transmitter to 3G you add 3G to it, you do not remove 2G.

Most people are not running smartphones. Even on smartphones, 2G is more power efficient for phone calls.

richard1960 25-09-2012 20:42

Re: is 3 uk network any good? thinking of getting an iphone 5
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mike24 (Post 35477313)
I used to be on 3 but found out, when using the web, could not relied upon to work all of the time.

I think that applies to all mobile networks from time to time depending which area you are in that is not particular to just three.

In my area T Mobile/Orange is particuarly bad for the web.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:08.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum