![]() |
Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Apparently, the chances are, you wouldn't be able to..
http://www.engadget.com/2008/03/03/a...ter-cable-and/ That's an old article, but it seems an engineer ran a test with twelve audiophiles. Then, unbeknown to the subjects, he soldered plugs onto coat hangers, and replaced the monster audio cables with them. No one spotted the difference. |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Analogue sources, cables can matter.
Digital sources, cables don't matter. Monster are famous for their monster cable demos in shops to have one TV running a monster HDMI cable, and the other running from composite cables. They used to have the demos in currys and comet all the time. One of the currys staff tried to use it as a reason for me to shell out over £100 on a hdmi cable, strangely they refused my offer of swapping the composite cables for a no-brand hdmi cable and if there was still a visible difference I'd happily buy one. The high end cable market is nothing more than a con. It used to have some uses, but in the age of digital interconnects it's none other than snake oil. |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
If you want good well controlled bass performance in particular you need an amplifier with a high damping factor, and then you need to connect that amplifier to the speakers with very low resistance cabling to ensure that damping factor is preserved and that you maintain the tightly controlled bass performance you have paid good money for. In most circumstances good old 2.5mm mains cable is perfectly adequate to achieve this! If you're happy with sloppy bass then ignore this advice! :shrug: |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Last time I checked, speakers were an analogue connection, therefore covered by the "Analogue sources, cables can matter" at the start of my post.
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
I have bought a DVI Monster 800 (400?) cable worth £200 in Comet one for £20 :D
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Ive bought a monster Ethernet cable, I get 1ms ping now,...
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
The funny thing is none of them use Monster cable. Most of the large ones use standard 2.5mm mains cable to connect the speakers. |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
I got sucked into the 'oxy free' cables hype :o: still look at them differently :erm:
|
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
Even the cheapest crappy Ebay DVI cable of equivalent length costs £3-6 and I disagree on your opinion that cables do not matter with digital signal. They don't matter in terms of picture quality but a crappy cable will often result in a complete lack of any picture whatsoever. |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Quote:
It's actually part of monsters sales technique, offer cables at £rofl, then when people see them at £lol they think they're getting a bargain so snap them up when they're STILL getting ripped off. Even the cheapest crappy cable will give you a picture with no breakup. The HDMI spec is very forgiving especially over cable lengths that most people use (1.8m being the most popular cable length). When you start going longer you have to spend a bit more, but still no where near what the monster sponsored retailers want you to spend (because when you buy a tv from the likes of comet the only thing they really make money on is the cables and warrenties). |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Although signal may not vary the build can so if the cable is moved around or plugged/unplugged a "better" cable may last longer. Sometimes they "feel" better to which can be useful in some circumstances, again if the cable is moved to manipulated or needs to go round corners sharply on into tight spaces. Finally the looks can be important if they will remain visible.
That said there is a level above which a fool and his money... |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
http://www.roger-russell.com/wire/wire.htm - Wow - gets truly frigtening when some charlatans actually claim that the AC wiring can make a difference too.
One key point to note, on screw or spring contacts, cleaning (or replacing with clean wire) can make a difference. For made-up cables with connectors, the quality of the making up is probably more important than the cable. For video and fast data, the cable does need to meet the specifications required for impedance, crosstalk etc. For instance, the extending USB cable from 99pstore is ONLY good for USB1 speeds (and even then, probably violates the specification), while being completely uselesss for high speed. An extreme example, but a counter to the "cable doesn't make a difference for data" argument. I guess really, there are 4 levels of cable. 1. Junk - flawed, low quality, out of specification 2. Adequate - cables that meet specification 3. Excellent - meet specification, has decent stran reliefs and well made 4. Insane - targeted at people who can be relieved of large sums of money for cables with fancy brand names |
Re: Can you tell the difference between Monster Audio cable and a coat hanger?
Cables can matter.....
I would for example prefer a more shielded cable to stop any inteference or noise if the cables are placed in close proximity to other cables or power cables. I don't agree with spending tonnes of money but wouldnt go for the cheapest. These are very good and a lot cheaper than some shop baught similar cables, the guy does them custom made for you... http://www.chunkycables.co.uk/ |
| All times are GMT. The time now is 11:59. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum