![]() |
BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
What do we reckon? If Virgin/BBC fail to bring this to Tivo in time for the Olympics it will deny Tivo viewers the majority of BBC Olympic coverage.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
The BBC red button will arrive before the olympics and will be rolled out in April with the 24 streams for the games coming quickly afterwards.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
I trust Denphone to have the correct answer.
However I am off to the States when it is on. So I really don`t care. Yes I planned it as such. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Sky to launch 48 new channels for the Olympics on their EPG (which can be recorded too)
http://corporate.sky.com/media/press...mpics_channels |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Yes, 24 streams of each channel in both HD and SD = 48 channels that will appear on the EPG. No spin, just facts. Or do VM not include all their +1 channels when giving a total channel count ;)
Which all can be recorded, unlike the VM TiVo App which is all VM have announced who have so far left out their non-TiVo userbase. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Can the other boxes have all those streams? Just asking as not technical chap.... thanks folks.....
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Seeing the BBC have released info today, and SKY have made a press release I'd imagine Virgin will follow suit either today or tomorrow with a statement to clarify their position.
Key questions to I'd like to see Virgin clarify to their customers in a statement, based on SKY’s press release: SKY Say: “More than 10 million Sky homes will be able to watch the 2012 London Olympics through two dozen brand new BBC channels” To Virgin: Will you be making all of these new channels available to your 4 million TV customers, without upgrading to TiVo? SKY Say: “Sky homes will be able to view the channels via the Sky EPG, Sky+ homes will be able to record the coverage to watch at a time that suits them” To Virgin: Will Virgin customers with V+ or TiVO be able to record the coverage? SKY Say: “As with the rest of the HD channels on the Sky platform, the new channels will be broadcast in 1080i and in wide-screen to enhance the viewing experience.” To Virgin: Will your HD coverage be broadcast in 1080i? SKY Say: “The Sky+ Remote Record option also allows customers to set their Sky+ or Sky+HD box to record from mobile devices or the web.” To Virgin: Will TiVo customers be able to remote record? SKY Say: “The channels are free-to-air and available to any Sky home, and do not require a subscription. To Virgin: If the channels do launch separately from TivO, will customers on the M package be able to access the channels? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
"The service will also be available through the free-to-air platform Freesat and to Virgin Media customers who have a TiVo set-top box. More announcements from other providers are expected soon"
From the Guardian I stand corrected |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Yes, a total of 48 because each one is in both SD and HD. Just wanting to clarify that Sky are not getting any more channels than VM. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Theres more to the PR than the headline, see my edited post incase you have not actually read the article.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
48 new channels will be launched on their EPG |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
So that`s 24 channels broadcasting in HD & SD giving 48 channels on the EPG. Do we agree :confused: :Peaceman: "Lies, damn lies, & statistics" - or "spin" in today`s terms both fit the bill in this case I think. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
VM always made it clear, did they not, that only Tivo customers will have access to all the Olympic games streams. The Guardian article underlines this. It is my guess that those who are not prepared to pay for Tivo will have what Freeviewers will have - BBC1, BBC3 and the two Red Button streams. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Right, clever by Sky. They are going to show the streams as individual channels therefore allowing them to be recorded. Having a squizz at all the info regarding TIVO i couldn't see if there will be an ability to record off our Red Button App... can someone clarify.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
VM did always make it clear that only TiVo customers will have access to all Olympic streams. This however was announced back in December prior to any suggestion other TV platforms would be launching the streams as stand alone channels, available for free to all their customers. Oh and recordable too. I've got TiVo and V+ in my bedroom. I want to be able to record events that I can't watch live and I don't want to be restricted to where I watch them in my house. I'm yet to see any posts in this forum today to suggest the arrangement Virgin has with the BBC for the Olympics via TiVo is any anyway better than what Freesat and SKY are delivering. Can anyone truthfully say what has been announced today paints Virgins plans in a good light? Why can't Virgin deliver what their customers deserve? Why are they only catering to 12% of their TV customer base? Virgin are hiding BBC content behind a paywall by insisting only TiVo customers can get access. Gold medal goes to SKY, as per usual. Virgin end up outside the medals wondering what went wrong taking flack from their own customers, as per usual. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
---------- Post added at 18:10 ---------- Previous post was at 18:08 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
I think I'll stop ranting and allow time for events to unfold. I'm sure Virgin will come good on this. I just can't see how M+, L and XL customers without TiVo, who pay substantial monthly subscriptions to Virgin, would be expected to be happy receiving the same coverage that's being served up on Freeview free of charge. The following quote from the BBC website appears promising: "Mr Mosey said the BBC had agreed with Sky and Freesat to show the live streams across 24 channels, with more announcements from other providers expected soon." However further down in the article: "However Mr Mosey added: "Not every platform will be able to accommodate such a huge technical offer, which amounts to 48 channels in total if you count 24 SD (Standard Definition) plus 24 HD." Lets hope he is referring to platforms such as BT Vision etc... I'm picturing SKY's summer add campaign already. The only place to watch Euro 2012, London 2012 and F1 in HD this summer. Take our HD package this summer and for a limited amount of time enjoy up to 84 HD channels! I thought it was Virgin who were gunning for between 80 to 90 HD channels. I think, if you route around the internet, SKY will become the worlds biggest provider of linear HD channels this summer. Let's hope that Usain Bolt can help Virgin "Keep Up" with SKY in terms of Olympic HD channels. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
UPDATE: We've now heard from Virgin Media which has confirmed it will be offering all of its TiVo subscribers the 24 live HD streams through the new BBC Sport application we first wrote about at the end of last year. The app will be accessible through the proprietary BBC/TiVo Red Button service, and will aggregate all of the content so that it's selectable from the one place.
Found here http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/4514...24-hd-channels |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
that's as we thought.
Does anyone know how many streams they will make available to those who will not pay extra for the Tivo box? As I said earlier, my best guess is the two streams which will be available to those with Freeview, and nothing more as they'll use this as another way to try to persuade people to get Tivo. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
What will now be availale for V box customers hasn't yet been announced
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Thank you for that Ben.
---------- Post added at 20:16 ---------- Previous post was at 20:15 ---------- Incidentally, I wonder what Smallworld Cable will end up doing - ie will these 24 streams be available to Smallworld subscribers? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
All streams are free to all of SKY's 10,000,000 customers. Even people with an old dish without a subscription will get access. All streams are free to Freesat's 2,000,000 customers. Freeview will be offering the exact same content as Virgin customers who are on M+, L and XL without TiVo however Virgin customers, as we stand just now, will be paying a subscription to access the material where as Freeview is completely free to view. Virgin customers who want to access all the streams, as we stand just now, will need at least the M+ package with TiVo costing £18.00 per month without the ability to record the streams. All streams will be made available to just 450,000 of Virgins television subscribers. How can Virgin spin this to look like a good deal. The Olympics are huge, especially when they are hosted within our country, and have attracted some of the biggest TV audiences of all time. Why would people think of joining Virgin, just for full access to the games when they can get it for free elsewhere. Even current Virgin customers, without TiVo, who are out of contract must surely see the value of going elsewhere for their Olympic fix. For me Virgin are trying to push TiVo onto their customers way too hard. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
You are making assumptions. There has been NO confirmation as to what V box customers will or will not get.
How about waiting for facts? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
I've got TiVo and V+ and would much rather have linear channels on both. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
For instance
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/8b87379a-7...#axzz1r0Vwuykj Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Except by the looks of the FT announcement, Sky are coughing up for the BBC to provide the streams - because that's the only way to get them to Sky's customers
Up till now, the BBC have been fairly clear that the streams would be IPTV based only, so I reckon that is what Virgin have been preparing So they have to be sure of what they can do with the streams before they can announce anything |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
I think my post is a fair assessment of how things currently look, until Virgin confirm to their non-TiVo customers otherwise. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
That said, of course an early announcement might stop some people getting Freesat in. But perhaps there's a good reason for not announcing right now. Like the deal isn't finalised or something. Of course, if they did announce now and then couldn't make the deal (or whatever) you'd soon be berating them for not delivering on promises. So they can't keep you happy either way, can they?! |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
They should understand that not everyone wants Tivo (regardless of the price) or on demand. Many people just like to sit in front of their TV and select a programme of interest by scrolling up and down the channels. ---------- Post added at 21:13 ---------- Previous post was at 20:58 ---------- Quote:
I do agree that VM are trying overly to persuade their customers to get Tivo, and pay the costs which come with it, which shouldn't come as a massive surprise. They will see one way of doing this is to provide content which is only available if you have Tivo, or to put it another way, deprive content to those who will not pay for Tivo. The 24-stream Olympics coverage could well be the first major example of this. It's very possible that in the near future VM may start to provide new on demand content and future new linear channels only to Tivo customers and/or may start to remove existing channels and on demand content for those who haven't upgraded to Tivo. All speculation I know but remember that the chief executive did suggest that he wants every single customer to have Tivo in a few years time so they've got to find ways to make this happen. It's worth recalling how Sky managed to get its entire customer base to scrap analogue and get digital in just a few short years. They did two things. One was to make it almost free to upgrade (IIRC you just paid for installation) and the other was to slowly run down the analogue service by removing channels from Sky analogue a few at a time. It worked for Sky so why wouldn't it work for VM regarding getting everyone using Tivo? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
And if VM don't produce recordable streams when Sky and Freesat do, then VM have seriously lost the plot. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
To get back on topic "BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?" I've got to say it needs to be a massive yes on the back of the announcement from SKY and Freesat. Imagine if the BBC Red Button doesn't launch in time.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Just a thought, If this is going to be via the BBC red button & as I read it it will be.
Why would it not work on The V+ red BBC button ? which shows the things I want added to the mythical TiVo BBC red button? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
BBC Red Button on the V box can only access VoD or linear channels, so Virgin have specifically add them for it to work |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
So, as common sense suggests, it is merely technical limitations - and not a conspiracy to get everyone on a Tivo - as to why this stuff can't be done on the older boxes. Who'da thunk it? (Except maybe those with common sense and not something against VM!)
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Can some please explain ( This is NOT a dig) the difference between the multi-screen that my V+ has on the BBC red button ( think Wimbledon as a case in point or the Red zone from BBC Wales Sport ) & the screens to be offered for the Olympics?
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
They can cope - but only if Virgin add the other screens as actual channels on the platform which also needs to cope
For TiVo the app just needs to talk to a BBC server somewhere |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Sky are prepared to go the extra mile for all their customers to watch all the streams from the BBC. I do hope that VM will see that it would be in their interest to do the same. From the many discussions on here I have been told that there is plenty of bandwidth available on the VM network to enable them to do it. Lets wait and see.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Masters starts tomorrow. Sky have full 4 day coverage. BBC starts on Sat but the Red button has Amen Corner. Dont have Sky sports, have Tivo, don't have Red Button = very poor from Virgin Media.
Still underwhelmed with my Tivo Service. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
During the Tennis(and for that matter pro 12 rugby) the BBC red button on Freeview & my V+ offers a choice of screens. Are you saying ( no offense) that this is different. I must add here that this is more curiosity than any interest in the Olympics. As I intend to be out of the country for the whole time it is on !! :D |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Most BBC Red Button events have no more than 4 alternative screens, so Virgin will have the option of these already to go whenever they are required. For the Olympics this is going to be up to 24 screens, which means Virgin have to plan and add extra screens that the V boxes can recieve.
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Media boys blog has suggetsed VM haven't actually struck a deal for all the 24/48 streams??? This can't be right, i thought it was a done deal.
PLUS can anyone i.e SPIDERPLANT give us a clue as to IF Virgin Media will give us the opportunity of recording the streams :) |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Track & record :dozey: |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Because Sky have stumped up the cash the BBC will now also run them as broadcast streams on satellite - which as the BBC can't do exclusive deals Virgin should then also have an option to carry them |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
The trouble is now Sky viewers can record individual "streams" VM viewers will want to do the same. As i can't see VM adding 24/48 new channels how hard would it be to write software which allows us to record each Olympic App stream? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
As for writing an app. The recording tuners on TiVo aren't designed to pick up video via the broadband connection as far as I know, because there is no need. So they can't see the output, wouldn't have a channel to tune to or have EPG timings |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Thanks again Ben. I hope now Sky have decided on individual channels, VM will follow suit... i have my doubts though.
As for VM's deal, I saw this. http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/media/ne...satellite.html Virgin Media has already announced that it will offer all the BBC's 24 live streams via its TiVo converged television service, as part of a deal agreed with the corporation in December last year. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Surely Virgin can't be happy with these developments. When the deal was announced back in December for a Tivo app to cover all Olympic streams it looked like the content and footage would be exclusive to Virgin customers with TiVo, and very much looked like a major coup for Virgin.
If Virgin end up offering all the streams as linear channels to their customers, regardless of what Virgin TV box they have, won't this cost Virgin even more money and greatly devalue the TiVo app they are currently working on? |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
I don't think there was any question of them being exclusive, but TiVo is only paid-TV STBs that can get them (and probably one of few in total) ---------- Post added at 18:44 ---------- Previous post was at 18:42 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
VM need to get recordable linear channels. People are fed up with Sky beating them hands down for TV channels and to pass up on these extra channels would be an own goal, irrespective of the fact that V+ users won't get them all unless they are linear channels. I hope VM aren't using this to drive up Tivo demand, because if they are, they deserve to get defectors to Sky or Freesat. And even with Tivo, as it currently stands, there is no way to record the events when people are at work. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
As far as youview is concerned it was supposed to launch early this year ,but it has gone quiet. Even if it does launch it does not give much time for the equipment to get to market in time for the Olympics. |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
There still 4 MONTHS until the Olympics starts, in case anyone had forgotten. ---------- Post added at 19:30 ---------- Previous post was at 19:28 ---------- and one DAY since the Sky announcement |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
I appreciate what you're saying Ben, It just gets a tad annoying that Sky seem to always get the jump on these sorts of announcements.
Anyway I would like, if they could, any VM employee who reads these forums to express the (i think common) view from this forum to VM that we would like the Olympic threads to be linear as well as App based so we can record them. Ta :) |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Just as Virgin knew in December (and announced then too), that they would have access to the extra Olympic streams that the BBC had offered them for TiVo |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
No
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
But Virgin aren't going to announce something just to fit in with Sky's schedule |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Seems the natives are getting restless again;)
Viva le revolution!!! :D Just in general Virgin as usual getting the PR all wrong. Really don't like what they're doing just now:( |
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Virgins managements track record is poor, So much so that most people do not trust anything they say. Lets face it on delivering ( ie "basic" programmes not extras) Virgin are at least second best if not third - I go to Freeserve for red button services some times !!!!
|
Re: BBC Red Button - will it arrive before the Olympics?
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT. The time now is 02:38. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum