Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   Apple win swipe to unlock patent case (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33685666)

Cobbydaler 16-02-2012 20:32

Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Yet another ridiculous case brought by Apple:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-17058508

The Galaxy S had swipe to unlock in March 2010 when it was launched. This patent wasn't even granted until March 2010.

Patent Link

martyh 16-02-2012 20:44

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
I've just finished reading this on the BBC site and straight away thought just about every touch screen phone has a swipe to unlock feature on it

Stuart 16-02-2012 20:45

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
However, the patent was filed in November 2006. Are patents valid from the date of grant, or the date of the first filing, if granted?

Of course, Samsung could try doing something original. That might stop these cases.

danielf 16-02-2012 20:48

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart (Post 35383103)
However, the patent was filed in November 2006. Are patents valid from the date of grant, or the date of the first filing, if granted?

Of course, Samsung could try doing something original. That might stop these cases.

Perhaps I'm missing something here, but surely swiping the screen is simply the most logical way to unlock a touch screen? What's next, a patent for buttons being pressed? :confused:

Cobbydaler 16-02-2012 20:50

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart (Post 35383103)
However, the patent was filed in November 2006. Are patents valid from the date of grant, or the date of the first filing, if granted?

Of course, Samsung could try doing something original. That might stop these cases.

It wasn't brought against Samsung but against Motorola. I used Samsung as an example of another company using the technology that wasn't litigated against.

Apple could try accepting competition and moving on.

Even Microsoft comes to agreements over patents instead of pursuing litigation willy nilly...

chris9991 16-02-2012 20:50

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Before the iPhone was there any other phone that had a 'swipe' - I seem to recall Apple were first; prior to the iPhone all touchscreen phones/devices had to be waked by pressing a button first

(though I might be wrong on all this)

Stuart 16-02-2012 20:51

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35383105)
Perhaps I'm missing something here, but surely swiping the screen is simply the most logical way to unlock a touch screen? What's next, a patent for buttons being pressed? :confused:

I had three touch screen phones before the iPhone was out. Logical or not, none of them offered a swipe to unlock option.

Then the iPhone did it, and suddenly every phone offered that option.

danielf 16-02-2012 20:54

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart (Post 35383114)
I had three touch screen phones before the iPhone was out. Logical or not, none of them offered a swipe to unlock option.

Then the iPhone did it, and suddenly every phone offered that option.

Yeah, I suppose it's logical when someone's thinks of it, but I wouldn't really call it a technological advance. I'm probably being naive here, but common sense would suggest that granting a patent required a little more innovation than simply using existing features of existing technology?

martyh 16-02-2012 21:10

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35383105)
Perhaps I'm missing something here, but surely swiping the screen is simply the most logical way to unlock a touch screen? What's next, a patent for buttons being pressed? :confused:

Thats what i thought ,i am hard pressed to think of another way of unlocking a touch screen ,my nokia has it too

colin25 16-02-2012 21:29

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
I worry that apple (the company) might claim that edible variety of apples (apple from tree) are transgressing their brand, and demand they are called something else, just in case they invent the edible phone (don't laugh, if they can eat underwear, they can eat anything)

If that happens, i vote for Newton fruit...it just fell from the sky :D

Cobbydaler 16-02-2012 21:34

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35383105)
Perhaps I'm missing something here, but surely swiping the screen is simply the most logical way to unlock a touch screen? What's next, a patent for buttons being pressed? :confused:

Exactly; press button, something happens, patent it...

Touch screen, something happens, patent it...

---------- Post added at 21:34 ---------- Previous post was at 21:30 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by colin25 (Post 35383134)
I worry that apple (the company) might claim that edible variety of apples (apple from tree) are transgressing their brand, and demand they are called something else, just in case they invent the edible phone (don't laugh, if they can eat underwear, they can eat anything)

If that happens, i vote for Newton fruit...it just fell from the sky :D

Unfortunately, they've also got claims in for Granny Smith, Cox's Orange Pippin, Braemar, French Delicious, Golden Delicious...

cookie_365 17-02-2012 18:14

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
This is an example of why I will never, ever buy an Apple product.

danielf 17-02-2012 18:22

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cookie_365 (Post 35383603)
This is an example of why I will never, ever buy an Apple product.

I'm not sure if Apple is to blame here. It seems to me that the rules on what design features are patentable might need looking at. Don't blame businesses for doing what is allowed by the rules.

DocDutch 17-02-2012 19:31

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Daniel it is starting to become a farce though as at the moment apple has probably got more lawyers working for it than research and development types. It is becoming a joke as apple keeps suing over patent breaches for anything possible

what i wish is say Google with the patents they got from motorala really starts to ste them back just as hard

Tezcatlipoca 17-02-2012 19:35

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
As I said in the thread about Apple's profits, it is far from the only company engaging in what appear to be ridiculous patent lawsuits. They are all doing it.

This is from last August. It's probably even more of a mess now...

http://blog.thomsonreuters.com/index...ic-of-the-day/

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2012/02/21.jpg

danielf 17-02-2012 19:54

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DocDutch (Post 35383634)
Daniel it is starting to become a farce though as at the moment apple has probably got more lawyers working for it than research and development types. It is becoming a joke as apple keeps suing over patent breaches for anything possible

what i wish is say Google with the patents they got from motorala really starts to ste them back just as hard

What I'm saying is that if you couldn't patent silly things like the dimensions of a device or the colour of a button, then perhaps patents could serve the role they are meant to serve: to reward R&D rather than to stifle competition.

Anyway: this could be interesting

Quote:

Price of the iPad Name: $55,000 to $2 Billion

SAN FRANCISCO—What's in a name like iPad?

According to a cache of documents that includes emails and a contract, Apple Inc. agreed more than two years ago to buy rights to the iPad trademark in a number of countries from Proview International Holdings Ltd. The price: £35,000 ($55,494 at current exchange rates).


Apple agreed in 2009 to pay Chinese computer-display maker Proview about $55,000 for the iPad trademark but Proview is still claiming ownership of the trademark in China, Don Clark reports on digits. Photo: Getty Images.

The documents, reviewed by Dow Jones Newswires, would seem to bolster Apple's contention that it purchased rights to the iPad name from Proview

But Proview declared Friday that it's sticking by its claim that it still owns the trademark in China, and is seeking unspecified compensation from Apple that a representative of Proview creditors suggested could range as high as $2 billion. A Hong Kong court last year sided with Apple, saying the agreement between Proview and an Apple subsidiary was valid. But a court in mainland China was less supportive.

Cobbydaler 17-02-2012 19:59

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35383643)
Anyway: this could be interesting

Their iPad looks an awful lot like an iMac, so they may be getting sued right back...

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/02/17/proview_ipad/

danielf 17-02-2012 20:02

Re: Apple win swipe to unlock patent case
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 35383647)
Their iPad looks an awful lot like an iMac, so they may be getting sued right back...

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/02/17/proview_ipad/

Wrong colour, and buttons in wrong place. Apple don't stand a chance ;)


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:12.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum