Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ... (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33681455)

Chris 28-09-2011 14:08

Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
...and is severely annoyed that it can't, because of an inconvenient little thing called the National Veto. The UK Treasury has stated that it will resist any attempt to impose a Europe-wide tax on institutional transactions between banks, not least because up to 80% of the revenue generated by any such tax would come from activity in London.

No matter, in the undemocratic world of European bureucracy, the "constraints of unanimity" could be circumvented by "further changes to the Treaty of Lisbon". So says Jose Manuel Barroso, some Portuguese bloke none of us ever voted into a position where he can either impose taxes on us, or for that matter a position where he can threaten to change the rules in his favour if we try to stop him imposing taxes on us.

More astonishing Euro-arrogance here:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-15090761

martyh 28-09-2011 14:32

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
We should be grateful for the opportunity to give the EU more money ,damn cheek if you ask me us even having a veto ,we should ,without further delay renounce all sovereign rights and accept our new overlords

RizzyKing 28-09-2011 14:48

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
How about a tax on hot air the EU could solve the eurozone debt crisis in a matter of weeks. Seriously how long is it going to take for any politician to have the backbone to give the UK people what they want and allow us to vote on leaving this discredited, corrupt institution. Lets just get to a free trade zone in europe with us having decent relations with our european neighbours because we choose too not because some stuffed shirt tells us all we have to get along.

As far as i am concerned the federal EU dream is simply not realistic and most people in europe are starting to realise that and oppose the idea and the institution. Just making us all one continent won't solve the old problems some think it will if anything i think it will make nationalism worse then it is now, no free trade yes, cooperation in some things yes but federal system and things being decided\run from brussels or by a federal EU i would rather chew my limbs off.

martyh 28-09-2011 14:57

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
according to sky news on tv now ,france and germany are going to go ahead with it anyway regardless of what we do and Bill Gates(in his role as adviser to the g20) says it's a good idea ...so there you go

Chris 28-09-2011 15:19

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
To be fair, even the UK Treasury admits it's a decent idea in principle - *if* it's implemented globally, by international treaty. Gates will be supporting the notion on that basis, I should imagine.

France and Germany can do whatever they want. If they want to go on paying for Greece's party, more fool them.

martyh 28-09-2011 15:27

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
so if i understand this correctly ,the idea behind implementing such a tax would be to make sure there is enough money in the Euro pot to bail out countries that may default on loans ...like greece ?

Chris 28-09-2011 15:40

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
I believe that's the idea, yes. And Barroso would like it if he could impose that on the UK whether the UK likes it or not. Thankfully we still have a veto on tax issues so he can't. But that simply has him thinking that he would like to re-open the Lisbon treaty for renegotiation in order to try to remove the veto on tax.

... all of which means we very much need the Coalition legislation that will guarantee us a referendum on all future treaty negotiations as soon as possible.

Sirius 28-09-2011 15:41

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
So the Germans could not rule Europe by force so now they will do it via a political system and as is the norm the french role over and help them. Sooner we have the vote and leave the better. I never voted to be part of this why should i have to suffer. We need all the money in this country.

Ignitionnet 28-09-2011 15:55

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35306492)
I believe that's the idea, yes. And Barroso would like it if he could impose that on the UK whether the UK likes it or not. Thankfully we still have a veto on tax issues so he can't. But that simply has him thinking that he would like to re-open the Lisbon treaty for renegotiation in order to try to remove the veto on tax.

... all of which means we very much need the Coalition legislation that will guarantee us a referendum on all future treaty negotiations as soon as possible.

That legislation is going to have various Liberal Democrat sourced holes in it to ensure that referenda can be avoided.

One half of the coalition threaten to stomp their foot if the other half attempts to use the current European situation in our national interest so I've my doubts that we'll get a cast iron referendum guarantee.

Sirius 28-09-2011 15:59

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35306498)
That legislation is going to have various Liberal Democrat sourced holes in it to ensure that referenda can be avoided.

One half of the coalition threaten to stomp their foot if the other half attempts to use the current European situation in our national interest so I've my doubts that we'll get a cast iron referendum guarantee.

Sod a referandum lets do as the EU does and just do it any way, Mr Cameron grow a pair and get us OUT

martyh 28-09-2011 16:32

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35306492)
I believe that's the idea, yes. And Barroso would like it if he could impose that on the UK whether the UK likes it or not. Thankfully we still have a veto on tax issues so he can't. But that simply has him thinking that he would like to re-open the Lisbon treaty for renegotiation in order to try to remove the veto on tax.

... all of which means we very much need the Coalition legislation that will guarantee us a referendum on all future treaty negotiations as soon as possible.

well in principle i'm all for it as long as everybody does it and the money raised is shared proportionally back into the EU countries not just swallowed up in the Euro financial black hole and given to every country with a begging bowl and dodgy budget ,it could provide some much needed extra finance provided by banks who contributed to the mess we are in now .

Sirius 28-09-2011 16:38

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35306541)
well in principle i'm all for it as long as everybody does it and the money raised is shared proportionally back into the EU countries not just swallowed up in the Euro financial black hole and given to every country with a begging bowl and dodgy budget ,it could provide some much needed extra finance provided by banks who contributed to the mess we are in now .

Is this balanced across all the EU countries or is it just a few that will pay the main amount whilst the rest pay next to or sod all ????

Chris 28-09-2011 16:40

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
It's a percentage charged on every transaction where at least one of the institutions is within the EU. Seeing as 80% of institutional financial transactions within the EU occur in London .... well, do the maths. :erm: :D

martyh 28-09-2011 16:44

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35306547)
Is this balanced across all the EU countries or is it just a few that will pay the main amount whilst the rest pay next to or sod all ????

well as chris said earlier 80% of these transactions go through london so in theory our financial center would be contributing a huge ammount ,so under my idea we would get back the bulk of the money as it would be proportionally shared out .That is only my idea though ,the reality is that such a europe wide tax would be eaten up by poor countries or those incapable of budgeting their finances ...like greece.
Our financial institutions would pay the bulk of the tax and we as a country would see little or no benefit

Sirius 28-09-2011 16:46

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35306549)
It's a percentage charged on every transaction where at least one of the institutions is within the EU. Seeing as 80% of institutional financial transactions within the EU occur in London .... well, do the maths. :erm: :D

So yet again we are crapped on by the EU. We fund the loser countries, What cracks me up is some think its the best thing since sliced bread to be a member of these money grabbing con men in Europe.

I just wished Cameron had a pair and gave us a vote to leave.

---------- Post added at 17:46 ---------- Previous post was at 17:44 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35306555)
Our financial institutions would pay the bulk of the tax and we as a country would see little or no benefit

So then not the sort of system we need to be involved in.

martyh 28-09-2011 17:00

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35306556)


So then not the sort of system we need to be involved in.

as it stands no ...unless of course you vote me to be the Emperor of Europe ,then i would annex the nice parts of Europe to Britain and declare France and Germany illegal ,and sink Greece so they couldn't trouble us anymore :D

Sirius 28-09-2011 18:06

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35306584)
as it stands no ...unless of course you vote me to be the Emperor of Europe ,then i would annex the nice parts of Europe to Britain and declare France and Germany illegal ,and sink Greece so they couldn't trouble us anymore :D

You get my vote :D

Russ 28-09-2011 18:08

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
The government will "resist" these taxes from the EU.

So, lots of fist-shaking whilst being able to do nothing about Eurocrats going ahead with it anyway.

Sirius 28-09-2011 18:09

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35306628)
The government will "resist" these taxes from the EU.

So, lots of fist-shaking whilst being able to do nothing about Eurocrats going ahead with it anyway.

I say resist them to the point of leaving and never rejoining

martyh 28-09-2011 18:19

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35306631)
I say resist them to the point of leaving and never rejoining

In my new world you can be the "stupid country sorter outer " :D

Sirius 28-09-2011 18:21

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35306636)
In my new world you can be the "stupid country sorter outer " :D

To i get to push the big red button

martyh 28-09-2011 18:30

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35306637)
To i get to push the big red button

at least once a week and twice in the case of Belgium ..i insist :D

Maggy 28-09-2011 19:07

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
And our contribution will be larger than other countries in the EU because that's what we signed up to..:erm:

Ignitionnet 28-09-2011 19:23

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
I'm waiting on Nick Clegg to come and tell us it's a fantastic idea, wonderful for Europe and Britain, well, 40% of our exports (and 50% of our imports but let's ignore that bit) are from Europe, though of course this would change without the European tariffs.

Bit like the Common Fisheries Policy, Common Agricultural Policy, free movement of people, etc.

Clegg and his crew of Eurosycophants I'm sure will have some excuse why this is great.

Just as an idea of how sycophantic they are there's a group in the European Parliament - the Union of European Federalists. Its President is a Liberal Democrat MEP.

He loves this.

Sirius 28-09-2011 19:26

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35306691)
And our contribution will be larger than other countries in the EU because that's what we signed up to..:erm:

Dont include me in that signing bit, I want nothing to do with the EU

Chris 29-09-2011 09:13

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Dan Hannan for Prime Minister ...

How is it that this country's most recognisable Euro-MPs are also the arch-sceptics? :D

---------- Post added at 10:13 ---------- Previous post was at 09:51 ----------

Nigel Farage puts the boot in:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii0Yc...layer_embedded

Ignitionnet 29-09-2011 10:05

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Nice one Chris, my friend Andrew Duff, so obviously anti-British and Euro-sycophantic popped in with a question there I see - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii0Yc...ailpage#t=275s

Russ 29-09-2011 10:15

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Ah Nigel Farage, I was almost sold on him, going by that clip. Until I remembered him making such a plank of himself on Have I Got News For You.

Chris 29-09-2011 10:18

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
That just means he's a genuine politician. It's their job to make a plank of themselves on HIGNFY. ;)

Russ 29-09-2011 10:21

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Well yeah but there's good plank and bad plank when it comes to that show and it was the negative for him. He was doing that "I'll ask the questions that the public really want answering!!" thing however he was in a charisma-vacuum at the time and no-one had any interest in (or idea of) what he was talking about.

You know, UKIP style.

Ignitionnet 29-09-2011 10:30

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 35306930)
Well yeah but there's good plank and bad plank when it comes to that show and it was the negative for him. He was doing that "I'll ask the questions that the public really want answering!!" thing however he was in a charisma-vacuum at the time and no-one had any interest in (or idea of) what he was talking about.

You know, UKIP style.

Given the shower of excrement from the mainstream 3 parties it's no wonder he's gaining popularity.

deadite66 29-09-2011 10:56

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35306453)
"further changes to the Treaty of Lisbon"

Oh Cameron will sign that, politicians love signing things in front of their peers makes them feel important.

Ignitionnet 29-09-2011 13:11

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by deadite66 (Post 35306946)
Oh Cameron will sign that, politicians love signing things in front of their peers makes them feel important.

Nick Clegg will be touching himself at the prospect of conceding more powers to Europe. The stuttering wonder Andrew Duff will be proclaiming it a great day and mocking the little Englanders.

Cameron will tell us that we the public just don't understand and gleefully sign it.

After finding a way to weasel out of giving us a referendum of course. Democracy is such an inconvenience within the European project but easily avoided and failing that perverted - the EU can use money paid by member states to flood them with propaganda on the rare occasions they do get to vote on such things.

Chris 29-09-2011 13:48

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35307028)
Nick Clegg will be touching himself at the prospect of conceding more powers to Europe. The stuttering wonder Andrew Duff will be proclaiming it a great day and mocking the little Englanders.

Yes, I noticed that Quisling getting his say in at the end of Farrage's video. How sad.

Ignitionnet 29-09-2011 13:53

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35307053)
Yes, I noticed that Quisling getting his say in at the end of Farrage's video. How sad.

You have to love our representatives in the European Parliament putting down their own constituents and country in order to promote the European project. I refuse, purely due to their overwhelming desire to sell us out in Europe, to vote Liberal Democrat in anything again. They've gone from Pro-EU to downright sycophantic. Whatever else they do and however good Vince Cable is as a domestic MP I can't give my vote to a man who rolls his eyes at any criticism of the EU or is within a party that is desperate to get us into the Euro - still.

Chris 29-09-2011 14:03

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Cable in Government is a bumbling fool. TBH I'm glad he's there right now as it is putting to bed some of the starry-eyed nonsense along the lines of 'best chancellor we'll never have' that was doing the rounds prior to the 2010 election. The Lib Dems are performing a useful function right now, lending additional legitimacy to a Government at a time when hard decisions need to be taken (granted, you have said in the past they're not taking all the decisions they should be, but hey ho).

All being well, come 2015 we will have constituencies redrawn so that the level of support required in order to get elected is more or less the same in each, and we will have a Liberal Democrat Party that has shown itself to be an incompetent bunch no longer deserving a place at the top table. All of which, I hope, will mean a true, full Conservative administration from 2015 to 2020.

... and as an aside, based on Ed Millipede's performance with Nick Robinson yesterday, there's little sign of him transforming himself, or Liebour, into a credible contender by 2015. The ship being tugged into Birkenhead docks over Ed's left shoulder was more interesting to watch. Total and utter lack of charisma, credibility, believability, you name it, he's not got it.

Anyway, to return to the topic, I wonder what Dan Hannan's chances of getting a seat in the Mother of all Parliaments is. I'd love to see more of him in public life and there is no question that if the British public are ever going to be motivated enough to complain about Europe loud enough for our politicians to take note, they are going to need a domestic cheerleader ... and one not encumbered with the 'negative plank' image that Russ says Nigel Farrage has got. :D

Ignitionnet 29-09-2011 15:51

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
The idea of Dan Hannan as an MP scares Cameron witless I imagine. He is probably concerned enough at Hannan being in the European Parliament let alone him being the centrepiece of his EU-sceptic MPs in Parliament.

I took care to write EU-sceptic rather than Euro-sceptic there as it seems to be a convenient line of attack for EU-sycophants to accuse anyone sceptical over the ever growing tendrils of the EU of being anti-Europe which of course the overwhelming majority are not.

Ignitionnet 04-10-2011 12:26

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
If this is to be believed this may all be somewhat academic.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtcX7...mbedded#t=181s

Chris 04-10-2011 13:44

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Who on earth is that bloke?

Russ 04-10-2011 13:49

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Someone incredibly smug and annoying...

Damien 04-10-2011 15:52

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35309882)
If this is to be believed this may all be somewhat academic.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtcX7...mbedded#t=181s

I would be worried if the EU tried to impose that guy on us! :erm: Is he serious or meant to be for comic effect?

Ignitionnet 04-10-2011 15:52

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Keiser

Dai 04-10-2011 17:54

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35309997)
Is he serious or meant to be for comic effect?

"Throughout Keiser's shows he has been known for making predictions:

* In the September 2004 issue of The Ecologist magazine, Keiser correctly predicted the 2008 collapse of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac when he wrote, "My guess is that the two stocks that look the likeliest to implode at the hands of derivative-wielding Wall Street financial types (and other fundamentalists) preying on a US economy made weak by cheap money are Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac."
* In 2006 he correctly predicted that sub-prime mortgage-backed securities would be the cause of recession by 2008.
* In 2007 he correctly predicted the break-down of Iceland's economy in 2008."

.. sounds pretty serious to me.

Damien 04-10-2011 18:12

Re: Europe wants to impose financial transaction taxes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaiNasty (Post 35310089)
"Throughout Keiser's shows he has been known for making predictions:

* In the September 2004 issue of The Ecologist magazine, Keiser correctly predicted the 2008 collapse of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac when he wrote, "My guess is that the two stocks that look the likeliest to implode at the hands of derivative-wielding Wall Street financial types (and other fundamentalists) preying on a US economy made weak by cheap money are Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac."
* In 2006 he correctly predicted that sub-prime mortgage-backed securities would be the cause of recession by 2008.
* In 2007 he correctly predicted the break-down of Iceland's economy in 2008."

.. sounds pretty serious to me.

Impressive. If true. Depends how many predictions he makes and the way he makes them.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:12.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum