Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33677359)

Barewolf 04-05-2011 17:32

Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
I have recently bought a Cannon Rebel T1i, and I purchased a Cannon EFS 55-250mm Lens which is a telephoto lens and apparently highly recommended.


My problem is that I m not happy with the zoom capability of the lens. For £750 I want to be able to see a flea 100 foot away, where as with this, I can only zoom in about 3x.


Take a look at these pictures....


Picture 1 - This is with absalutely no Zoom. On Auto Mode, From My Window, 130ft Away, Using the 55-250 Lens.


http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g1...a/IMG_3419.jpg



Picture 2 - Is fully zoomed using the 55-250mm.


http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g1...a/IMG_3420.jpg


Now, I know that DSLR camera's are not bridge camera's, where Bridge camera's use Digital Zoom up to 32x.



However, Most bridge camera's come with Optical Zooms of up to 36x, and judging by this lens for the T1i, it only appears to zoom about 3x. Surely this is wrong?


I'm a bit miffed at this to say the least, I expected a far better zoom considering the price. Is it just me or what?

Please help.......

Taf 04-05-2011 17:56

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Those pics look about right for a 55-250mm zoom lens.

When buying lenses I ALWAYS took the camera body to the shop to try them out first. Was that not an option for you?

peanut 04-05-2011 17:59

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
They look like they've been resized at 100% of the full photo. You should zoom in to 50-100% of the original and then crop.

Taf 04-05-2011 18:06

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
This is what I get with my very old Sony MVC-CD1000 camera (6-60mm 20x optical zoom)

http://homepage.ntlworld.com/taf.parsons/wide.jpg

http://homepage.ntlworld.com/taf.parsons/tele.jpg

Barewolf 04-05-2011 18:18

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
I didnt test it at the shop first, but I expected that a Telephoto lens would allow me to really zoom into the subject, where as I have found this lens is actually a 10x zoom lens, hardly worth £150.

I'm wondering if i've made a mistake purchasing a DSLR, and perhaps should have bought a Bridge camera like PowerShot SX30 IS, with 35x optical zoom.

peanut 04-05-2011 19:07

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
1 Attachment(s)
This was taken about 4-5 metres away, cropped at 100%, using a 200mm lens.

I think you're doing something wrong in post process.

Stephen 04-05-2011 19:13

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
It seems like you don't really understand the lens types.

spiderplant 04-05-2011 21:15

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35228847)
They look like they've been resized at 100% of the full photo. You should zoom in to 50-100% of the original and then crop.

peanut hits nail on head. With a good lens and good sensor you'll get a lot more than you'd get with a bridge.

As an example, look at this that I posted in Clickers Corner last week, taken with a 200mm lens on a Canon 60D. Then look at the first attachment below - that's how the original uncropped picture looked (obviously I've resized it here because it was huge).

Now compare with the second picture, which is the best I could do with my old bridge (Canon S2IS - 12x optical zoom and 4x digital zoom; 5MP sensor). The moon is zoomed to roughly the same size, but there's nothing like the same detail. That's the DSLR difference.

LSainsbury 04-05-2011 21:21

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Don't forget that lens on that body is actually 88-400mm.

What do you want? A better zoom? Then you have a to buy a longer lens.

spiderplant 04-05-2011 21:24

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LSainsbury (Post 35229031)
What do you want? A better zoom? Then you have a to buy a longer lens.

Or a teleconverter is the budget option

LSainsbury 04-05-2011 21:36

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by spiderplant (Post 35229038)
Or a teleconverter is the budget option


Don't you lose the AF ability with them or are the EF contacts connected through?

spiderplant 04-05-2011 21:51

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
It varies, depending on the TC, lens and camera. Do your research before buying.

Barewolf 04-05-2011 23:52

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
so taking the picture then cropping will get me the result?, fgorgive me, i'm new to this

peanut 05-05-2011 06:08

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35229150)
so taking the picture then cropping will get me the result?, fgorgive me, i'm new to this

Something here just don't add up.

LSainsbury 05-05-2011 07:41

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35229186)
Something here just don't add up.

Yeah - agreed with that - is he possibly thinking optical zoom will get digital zoom results on a DSLR?

---------- Post added at 07:41 ---------- Previous post was at 07:35 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35228864)
I didnt test it at the shop first, but I expected that a Telephoto lens would allow me to really zoom into the subject, where as I have found this lens is actually a 10x zoom lens, hardly worth £150.

BTW - I have this lens as well - £150 for this lens is very good value although it is at the cheep end of the lens range.

Why don't you go and buy one of these - should sort you out! :D

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...011/05/115.jpg

Scary 05-05-2011 08:09

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
i would advise anyone who is looking at getting any equipment or a new camera to do it now as the prices for everything are about to sky rocket because of what has happend in japan, a memo has been sent to all camera stores about all the major players I.E Sony Cannon Fujitsu Nikon, that there running low components for the production of cameras and lenses and that they have a five year plan to get back on track.

Barewolf 05-05-2011 09:26

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LSainsbury (Post 35229200)
Yeah - agreed with that - is he possibly thinking optical zoom will get digital zoom results on a DSLR?

---------- Post added at 07:41 ---------- Previous post was at 07:35 ----------



BTW - I have this lens as well - £150 for this lens is very good value although it is at the cheep end of the lens range.

Why don't you go and buy one of these - should sort you out! :D

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...011/05/115.jpg

Basically yes, I'm trying to get the kind of zoom that I can get with a bridge 36x Optical zoom, I assumed a telephoto lens would give me this result.

Because I havent done my research, and misleading photo's taken with the lens, I assumed 55-250 was 5.5x and 25x zoom. Dont ask me why, As I said, I havent researched enough.

It now appears the only way I can get these results is with a 800mm lens, and a very large wad of cash.

I'm a bit gutted to say the least

Taf 05-05-2011 11:09

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Another thing to consider with long lenses is aperture. The longer the lens, the more light is required or faster response film/sensor.

Using really long lenses can end up like taking a pic of a black cat in a coal hole at midnight despite it being a bright day.

Unless you have £thousands to spend on a lens.

spiderplant 05-05-2011 18:13

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35229150)
so taking the picture then cropping will get me the result?, fgorgive me, i'm new to this

Let's try it. Put the original of your 250mm picture (or better still, the RAW/.CR2 file if you have it) on website and post a link. I'll see how much can be "zoomed" and still be acceptable.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35229249)
Because I havent done my research, and misleading photo's taken with the lens, I assumed 55-250 was 5.5x and 25x zoom.

The 'x zoom' notation used for compact and bridge cameras tells you the ratio of longest to shortest focal lengths, but doesn't actually tell you what these focal lengths are. For example, the "12x optical zoom" on my S2IS is 6mm - 72mm. So even at max zoom, I've only got a 72mm lens on the S2IS compared with 200mm on the DSLR.

However, the sensor in the S2IS is less than a tenth the size of the one in my DSLR. So at 72mm the moon takes up a larger percentage of the picture area than a 200mm lens does on the DSLR, but the DSLR captures a bigger slab of sky in more detail. I then crop out the parts I don't want on the PC.

LSainsbury 05-05-2011 18:26

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by spiderplant (Post 35229690)
The 'x zoom' notation used for compact and bridge cameras tells you the ratio of longest to shortest focal lengths, but doesn't actually tell you what these focal lengths are. For example, the "12x optical zoom" on my S2IS is 6mm - 72mm. So even at max zoom, I've only got a 72mm lens on the S2IS compared with 200mm on the DSLR.

However, the sensor in the S2IS is less than a tenth the size of the one in my DSLR. So at 72mm the moon takes up a larger percentage of the picture area than a 200mm lens does on the DSLR, but the DSLR captures a bigger slab of sky in more detail. I then crop out the parts I don't want on the PC.


Well explained - I was also trying to figure how to word it but I think you got it better than I could.

Barewolf 07-05-2011 10:47

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
I think I get it. Ive managed to crop some images and they look ok, I guess its going to take some time getting used to the process.

---------- Post added at 10:47 ---------- Previous post was at 10:23 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35230803)
I think I get it. Ive managed to crop some images and they look ok, I guess its going to take some time getting used to the process.

After reading replies I managed to get these shots on Thursday, I then cropped the 2nd image for my Final result.

I still cant get my desired Zoom by cropping, but I guess thats because i'm not used to DSLR Cameras.

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g1...a/IMG_3463.jpg

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g1.../IMG_3463a.jpg

LSainsbury 07-05-2011 10:51

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Top link 3463.jpg is broken - nothing wrong with the 3463a.jpg - would be nice to see the original though! :tu:

Barewolf 07-05-2011 10:52

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LSainsbury (Post 35230835)
Top link 3463.jpg is broken - nothing wrong with the 3463a.jpg - would be nice to see the original though! :tu:


seems to work for me, did you refresh?

peanut 07-05-2011 10:54

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
What I find helpful is that you (try) to keep the same aspect ratio when cropping. In Photoshop, select all, then select - transform selection, then holding shift down drag a corner to the size or portion of the photo you're want to crop. (You can rotate the box to suit as well). Then select crop.

Try uploading a untouched raw photo, taken at the full 250mm as suggested by Spiderplant.

Barewolf 07-05-2011 10:58

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35230840)
What I find helpful is that you (try) to keep the same aspect ratio when cropping. In Photoshop, select all, then select - transform selection, then holding shift down drag a corner to the size or portion of the photo you're want to crop. Then select crop.

Try uploading a untouched raw photo, taken at the full 250mm as suggested by Spiderplant.


The image of the Cheetah was taken at 250mm, but I didnt take it in RAW format. I dont fully understand RAW format, but I also don't know how I would upload a RAW format as it isnt viewable, so I doubt photobucket would let me upload it.

I will try your suggestion about cropping though ;)

peanut 07-05-2011 11:01

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35230842)
The image of the Cheetah was taken at 250mm, but I didnt take it in RAW format. I dont fully understand RAW format, but I also don't know how I would upload a RAW format as it isnt viewable, so I doubt photobucket would let me upload it.

I will try your suggestion about cropping though ;)

Then try to upload the 100% photo before any resizing.

Barewolf 07-05-2011 11:01

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Just tried the crop as you suggested and it did work better than the way I was doing it, cheers peanut :)

---------- Post added at 11:01 ---------- Previous post was at 11:01 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35230844)
Then try to upload the 100% photo before any resizing.


The 1st image of the cheetah is the 100% image, i didnt crop that, only the second image

peanut 07-05-2011 11:04

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35230845)
The 1st image of the cheetah is the 100% image, i didnt crop that, only the second image

So you haven't resized it at all then? Just uploaded as it came off the camera? Or does photobucket resize it for you? I haven't used photobucket so I wouldn't know.

If it is as it is from the camera then you've got it on the wrong setting.

Are your photos this size when you take them off. http://images.digitalcamerainfo.com/...1I-sample1.jpg

Barewolf 07-05-2011 11:13

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35230847)
So you haven't resized it at all then? Just uploaded as it came off the camera? Or does photobucket resize it for you? I haven't used photobucket so I wouldn't know.

If it is as it is from the camera then you've got it on the wrong setting.


The original image was Large Fine Detail (5.6mb), I put it into Photoshop 1st then saved it which took it to 800kb, then I uploaded it to Photobucket.

I presume that it was my mistake because I saved it after photoshop.

I can upload one straight from the camera, heres a link to photobucket of some emu's, the original file is 6.1mb straight from the camera un-touched.

http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g1...a/IMG_3540.jpg

---------- Post added at 11:13 ---------- Previous post was at 11:11 ----------

and looking at the emu it seems photobucket has resized it

techguyone 07-05-2011 11:20

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
I believe photobucket resizes, to avoid anyone loading in 10000000000000000000000x 10000000000000000000 pics

spiderplant 07-05-2011 11:24

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Do you have free webspace from your ISP, Barewolf? You could put full-size JPEGs or RAWs there.

Barewolf 07-05-2011 11:53

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
im with talk talk at the minute and i have no idea, ive tried flickr but they seem to adjust the size also.

Angua 07-05-2011 12:05

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
RAW allows better quality for your pictures processing before uploading in Jpeg to the web. Would recommend This book to learn more about post processing.

Photobucket tends to resize pictures where Flikr allows "as is" providing it is within the MB allowance if you do not have a paid account. However you do have a choice of size to view.

spiderplant 07-05-2011 12:24

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35230907)
im with talk talk at the minute and i have no idea,

You do http://help.talktalk.co.uk/app/answe...ce/r_id/113152
But with a 15MB limit, you'll barely get one RAW or two JPEGs there.

You could try something like www.4shared.com who give you 10GB for free.

peanut 07-05-2011 12:28

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Have a look at the differences between 18-200mm here. And the last 2 images are the same photo but cropped.

18mm No Crop

55mm No Crop

200mm No Crop

200mm Same Pic but Cropped

All taken from the same spot, about 8-9m away.

Barewolf 07-05-2011 13:36

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
I will check that 10gb Site out, thanks for that. And thanks for the pics Peanut, I think I understand what I'm doing wrong now :)

LSainsbury 07-05-2011 13:41

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35230842)
I dont fully understand RAW format...


Think of it as a "digital negative" - it's the image from the sensor without any of the in-camera processing applied to it.

JPGs are inferior to RAW in a sense.

I always shot in RAW + JPG now - but there are pro and cons of doing this - you just have to weigh up it the pros outweigh the cons for you use.

Angua 07-05-2011 13:50

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Easier just to take them all in RAW then only process the ones worth keeping.

LSainsbury 07-05-2011 14:03

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Angua (Post 35231003)
Easier just to take them all in RAW then only process the ones worth keeping.


I like to see a "preview" of the final result - hence RAW + JPG. :)

Taf 07-05-2011 14:03

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
RAW is only OK if you have a LOT of memory, but then again some cameras wind up the JPG compression so that artifacts ruin the picture. Whatever happened to PNG?

LSainsbury 07-05-2011 14:06

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Whist on the subject of cropping photos...

What's the best method to crop an area but keeping the same size and aspect ratio?

...Using Adobe Elements 9....

Barewolf 07-05-2011 14:19

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
I managed to join 4shared and upload a photo of something I cooked for Breakfast, It looks like its the 100% un touched image off the Camera.

http://www.4shared.com/photo/fALmgD_i/_MG_3683.html

LSainsbury 07-05-2011 14:26

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35231028)
...something I cooked for Breakfast...


What the hell is that??? Looks like it's laden with cheese!!

Barewolf 07-05-2011 14:35

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LSainsbury (Post 35231033)
What the hell is that??? Looks like it's laden with cheese!!

Its a Vegetable Egg Flan, Its only got a bit of cheese on :)

craigj2k12 07-05-2011 15:44

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LSainsbury (Post 35231033)
What the hell is that??? Looks like it's laden with cheese!!

dont look like bin laden to me

spiderplant 07-05-2011 17:24

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35231028)
I managed to join 4shared and upload a photo of something I cooked for Breakfast, It looks like its the 100% un touched image off the Camera.

http://www.4shared.com/photo/fALmgD_i/_MG_3683.html

Not a lot wrong with that. Feeling hungry now.

You could try a larger aperture. At f18 diffraction will affect sharpness (see examples at bottom of http://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/diffraction.htm). As a bonus the ISO will decrease and you'll get less noise.

Barewolf 07-05-2011 22:06

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by spiderplant (Post 35231167)
Not a lot wrong with that. Feeling hungry now.

You could try a larger aperture. At f18 diffraction will affect sharpness (see examples at bottom of http://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/diffraction.htm). As a bonus the ISO will decrease and you'll get less noise.


thanks for that spiderplant, looks interesting, i will read up and test it out when it stops raining.

Angua 08-05-2011 07:58

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LSainsbury (Post 35231009)
I like to see a "preview" of the final result - hence RAW + JPG. :)

We just use Adobe Bridge.

Jon T 08-05-2011 08:42

Re: Photography Question - DSLR v Bridge
 
There's loads of programs that'll read RAW so you can preview. I've got Photoshop CS3 that does it no problem, but Irfanview will view RAW as well and is also free, has a program called "thumbnails" which will give you an explorer like view all the image files in a given directory.

http://www.irfanview.com/


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:51.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum