Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33675407)

papa smurf 27-02-2011 09:08

poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right parties if they gave up violence'




A total of 48 per cent said that they would support a group that vowed to crack down on immigration and Islamic extremists.
They would also restrict the building of mosques and order the flag of St George or the Union Jack be flown on all public buildings.


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...#ixzz1F9W7dhHh

would you support one of these organisations if they mended their ways ?

Kymmy 27-02-2011 09:16

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Violence isn't the main issue though..

Yes something needs to be done about immigration especially with unemployment rising but that doesn;t mean to stop all immigration that some of these parties advocate.

Terrorism is never welcome yet these groups seem to want to clamp down on a certain religion just because some of them are extremists..

As far as the flag the Union Jack yes it should be flown on all public buildings but that's a case of pride in the United Kingdom and nothing to do with immigration, religion or building practices :rolleyes:

Seems to me that they're grasping at straws and it would be interesting to see the locations/demographic of the poll and exactly what other questions were asked at the same time as leading questions can change the answer to the next question.

papa smurf 27-02-2011 09:31

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
i'm personally rather upset with the whole election/political system -its built on false promises /lies and never seems to tackle the issues that bother the average person in the street , i think the uk is broken and needs fixing just not sure how to go about doing it ,but i think if some things don't change then people will turn to extreme politics to get it sorted .

RizzyKing 27-02-2011 09:34

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Really would take this with a pinch of salt and having worked in market research in the past i know how well they can manipulate both the question and the questioner to achieve the desired outcome for the company or group that employs them.

Ignitionnet 27-02-2011 10:17

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
No chance in hell.

Immigration does need controls however it is absolutely required to an extent - we're not producing enough babies to have a work force large enough to cover baby boomer pensions and health care.

Mandating flying a flag on public buildings I don't regard as being necessary - however I do get the idea and watered down to remove the apparent politically correct stigma that some bodies invent it would be workable.

I will never vote 'far-right'. There's a good reason why it's called 'far'.

Oh and most of the time these groups are not far-right, they are authoritarian-left. Nazi = National Socialist party ya know. No idea why this misconception is spread that xenophobia and racism are far-right traits.

danielf 27-02-2011 10:23

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35182987)

Oh and most of the time these groups are not far-right, they are authoritarian-left. Nazi = National Socialist party ya know. No idea why this misconception is spread that xenophobia and racism are far-right traits.

The simple fact that they called themselves Socialist doesn't mean they were left-wing...

Maggy 27-02-2011 10:31

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
I'd have to be cold and dead before I'd vote for them.

Ignitionnet 27-02-2011 10:33

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35182990)
The simple fact that they called themselves Socialist doesn't mean they were left-wing...

No, their centrally planned economy and extensive state spending did.

Interesting, it's fine to tar the right with the the same label as fascists but tarring the left with the same label as nazis isn't.

Fascism isn't mutually exclusive with socialism or corporatism and fascists of both flavours have been around.

Seen the BNP manifesto?

Quote:

“A brief skim through BNP manifesto literature brings to light proposals for the following: large increases in state pensions; more money for the NHS; improved worker protection; state ownership of key industries.
Doesn't sound particularly right wing to me - YMMV.

---------- Post added at 11:33 ---------- Previous post was at 11:32 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35182994)
I'd have to be cold and dead before I'd for them.

Given how lax we are about electoral fraud in some cases that is a possibility in the, hopefully distant, future Maggy.

danielf 27-02-2011 10:37

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35182996)
No, their centrally planned economy and extensive state spending did.

Interesting, it's fine to tar the right with the the same label as fascists but tarring the left with the same label as nazis isn't.

Fascism isn't mutually exclusive with socialism or corporatism and fascists of both flavours have been around.

Seen the BNP manifesto?



Doesn't sound particularly right wing to me - YMMV.

They were Totalitarian alright, and we all know that you get Totalitarian regimes and the left and right. To claim they were left-wing is laughable though, and frankly I'm extremely surprised that you'd sign up to such utter rollocks.

Ignitionnet 27-02-2011 10:49

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35183003)
They were Totalitarian alright, and we all know that you get Totalitarian regimes and the left and right. To claim they were left-wing is laughable though, and frankly I'm extremely surprised that you'd sign up to such utter rollocks.

Why is it any more laughable than calling them right wing?

You're protesting strongly but not actually explaining why it is such 'utter rollocks'.

They flirted with elements of both but a centrally planned economy is what it is. As far as I'm aware the idea that fascism is far-right by default is quite dead now.

Will21st 27-02-2011 11:36

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35182990)
The simple fact that they called themselves Socialist doesn't mean they were left-wing...

No,but both left- and right-wing want to control our lives,albeit from opposite ends... or seemingly opposite ends.
Socialism is a common trait they share... reason enogh for me to dislike both,and to be Libertarian!

Hom3r 27-02-2011 11:44

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
I feel to many people come here for free hand outs, this should STOP.

People fleeing death in there country is different.

We need to look after people who were born here first, and thay should take top poirity.

Ignitionnet 27-02-2011 11:51

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35183041)
I feel to many people come here for free hand outs, this should STOP.

People fleeing death in there country is different.

We need to look after people who were born here first, and thay should take top poirity.

How do you propose we do that without immigration to balance out the boomers that are nearing retirement Hom3r?

The major issue is that some resources are disproportionately confined to a small subset who also make the rules to preserve their ownership of the resources, this creates many issues in its own right.

Economic migration is absolutely required either way. We should also sort out our own stock of idle *******s who've never worked and women whose aspiration in life consists of being welfare munching baby factories before whining about people coming here to work.

Will21st 27-02-2011 12:03

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35183041)
I feel to many people come here for free hand outs, this should STOP.

People fleeing death in there country is different.

We need to look after people who were born here first, and thay should take top poirity.

Well,the left has tried to put so much shame into feeling and being British,they made it politically incorrect to look after our own first.Doing so has nothing to do with being right-wing and causes less resentment,IMO.

---------- Post added at 13:03 ---------- Previous post was at 12:58 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35183054)
How do you propose we do that without immigration to balance out the boomers that are nearing retirement Hom3r?

The major issue is that some resources are disproportionately confined to a small subset who also make the rules to preserve their ownership of the resources, this creates many issues in its own right.

Economic migration is absolutely required either way. We should also sort out our own stock of idle *******s who've never worked and women whose aspiration in life consists of being welfare munching baby factories before whining about people coming here to work.

Agreed on all points.
I think I have said this before,but I do believe the poor stay poor through their own behaviour,values and general way of life.

Ignitionnet 27-02-2011 12:10

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Will21st (Post 35183057)
I think I have said this before,but I do believe the poor stay poor through their own behaviour,values and general way of life.

I can easily believe that in many, though not all, cases that's entirely accurate which is a shame.

It's one of the shortcomings of attempts to redistribute wealth through taxation and welfare rather than it being social security.

Will21st 27-02-2011 12:57

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35183063)
I can easily believe that in many, though not all, cases that's entirely accurate which is a shame.

It's one of the shortcomings of attempts to redistribute wealth through taxation and welfare rather than it being social security.

Yup,I was poor for a good few years,until I gradually realised that It was my own poor behaviour that kept me where I was... Glad I learned that lesson :)

I also believe that there is no help but self help.However,if you help yourself,you will be helped by others.

Sirius 27-02-2011 13:11

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35182994)
I'd have to be cold and dead before I'd vote for them.

Same here.

Gary L 27-02-2011 13:14

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35183114)
Same here.

But you're vote wouldn't count?

Hugh 27-02-2011 13:36

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
The actual quote (re 48%) is
Quote:

A total of 48 per cent said they would either ‘definitely support’ or ‘consider supporting’ a party with such an agenda, if it shunned violence and fascist imagery.
Would be useful to see the actual figure of how many would "definitely support".....

Sirius 27-02-2011 13:41

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 35183117)
But you're vote wouldn't count?

Then that makes me happy, I could never vote for a bunch of knuckle dragging idiots like the BNP and i certainly don't support the EDL or UAF thugs

Hugh 27-02-2011 13:53

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Amazing what you can find, if you dig a little beyond the headlines.

Here is where the survey came from - Fear and HOPE, and the full report gets released tomorrow.

When go to the page, you get rolling quotes, one of which is
Quote:

Over two thirds say "English Nationalist Extremists" and "Muslim Extremists" are as bad as each other
Strange - that wasn't reported in the DM article......

TheNorm 27-02-2011 14:06

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35182987)
...we're not producing enough babies to have a work force large enough to cover baby boomer pensions and health care....

This is an "inconvenient truth" - we need immigrants, and their babies, if Britain is to maintain a reasonable standard of living for the increasing numbers of those who retire (and live long in retirement).

Quote:

...Oh and most of the time these groups are not far-right, they are authoritarian-left. Nazi = National Socialist party ya know. No idea why this misconception is spread that xenophobia and racism are far-right traits.
Very good point. "Right wing" should mean less government, less of the "nanny state" politics.

martyh 27-02-2011 14:17

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35183147)
Amazing what you can find, if you dig a little beyond the headlines.

Here is where the survey came from - Fear and HOPE, and the full report gets released tomorrow.

When go to the page, you get rolling quotes, one of which is Strange - that wasn't reported in the DM article......


I've just had a look on the Populous site for the full survey ,unfortunately it hasn't been posted there yet but i will definately have a look tommorrow and see exactly what the questions were and what the results were ,i have a idea that the DM have cherry picked questions and answers

nomadking 27-02-2011 14:30

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
The fact that 'The Observer' and 'The Independent' also don't report the item 'Daily/Sunday Mail' is accused of censoring, shows where the problem is.

From 'The Guardian/Observer'
Quote:

According to the survey, 39% of Asian Britons, 34% of white Britons and 21% of black Britons wanted all immigration into the UK to be stopped permanently, or at least until the economy improved. And 43% of Asian Britons, 63% of white Britons and 17% of black Britons agreed with the statement that "immigration into Britain has been a bad thing for the country".
So that means a higher percentage of Asian Britons than White Britons want immigration stopped completely.

Hugh 27-02-2011 14:59

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
At least they had the courtesy to their readers to include the word "consider", rather than the conflation of "considering" and "would" that the Mail undertook....

re British Asian/stopping immigration, the caveat is quite important
Quote:

or at least until the economy improved
It very rarely is black and white, in so many different ways.....

Tezcatlipoca 27-02-2011 15:04

Re: poll says-Half of Britain 'would vote for far-Right
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 35182958)
Violence isn't the main issue though..

Yes. Having racist policies is also a bit of a sticking point, I think!


Sadly, though, many people don't seem to see that, & are just sucked in by the "tough talk" on immigration & Islamic extremism.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:53.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum