Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Lifestyle (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   diesel additives ,do they work ? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33663727)

martyh 07-04-2010 20:03

diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
hi , any petrol heads had any experience using additives in diesel to clean the injectors ,do they work? or are they a waste of money
i have a 2002 transit van on 120,000 miles works fine and is serviced regular since i bought it 2 yrs ago so any advice appreciated

the reason i ask is my work partners sprinter is going to cost him £900 for new injectors his van is the same age but a cdi engine

Escapee 07-04-2010 20:42

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996541)
hi , any petrol heads had any experience using additives in diesel to clean the injectors ,do they work? or are they a waste of money
i have a 2002 transit van on 120,000 miles works fine and is serviced regular since i bought it 2 yrs ago so any advice appreciated

the reason i ask is my work partners sprinter is going to cost him £900 for new injectors his van is the same age but a cdi engine

I would ask your local MOT station, these guys usually have a favourite product they swear by.

budwieser 07-04-2010 20:48

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996541)
hi , any petrol heads had any experience using additives in diesel to clean the injectors ,do they work? or are they a waste of money
i have a 2002 transit van on 120,000 miles works fine and is serviced regular since i bought it 2 yrs ago so any advice appreciated

the reason i ask is my work partners sprinter is going to cost him £900 for new injectors his van is the same age but a cdi engine

Change the glow plugs first and get the injectors reconditioned rather than buying new ones.;)

Gary L 07-04-2010 20:58

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Miller's Diesel Power Sport 4 and Forte Advanced Formula Diesel Treatment.

---------- Post added at 20:58 ---------- Previous post was at 20:55 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by budwieser (Post 34996574)
Change the glow plugs first

Glow plugs just start the car :)

alferret 07-04-2010 21:02

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
They do help, well IMO they do.
As long as you get filters & oil changed per manufacturers instructions & use an additive at least every 2 fill ups (one per 50 ltrs) it can make a difference. My mpg has gone up by about 4mpg over the last 3 months, smokes less and runs smoother for a 12yr old oil burner I'm happy.

---------- Post added at 21:02 ---------- Previous post was at 21:00 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996583)
Miller's Diesel Power Sport 4 and Forte Advanced Formula Diesel Treatment.

Where from Gary?

martyh 07-04-2010 21:04

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996583)
Miller's Diesel Power Sport 4 and Forte Advanced Formula Diesel Treatment.

---------- Post added at 20:58 ---------- Previous post was at 20:55 ----------



Glow plugs just start the car :)

millers has been mentioned to me any experience using it ?

Gary L 07-04-2010 21:09

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 34996591)
Where from Gary?

Halfords do the Millers.
http://www.halfords.com/webapp/wcs/s...Id_165750#dtab

Forte is trade only. either Ebay or a garage that has some to sell to you.

---------- Post added at 21:09 ---------- Previous post was at 21:07 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996593)
millers has been mentioned to me any experience using it ?

I don't own diesels. it's what a lot of people rave on about in a couple of motor forums I'm in.

I've used the Forte products in a petrol. they're really good.

budwieser 07-04-2010 21:12

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996583)
Miller's Diesel Power Sport 4 and Forte Advanced Formula Diesel Treatment.

---------- Post added at 20:58 ---------- Previous post was at 20:55 ----------



Glow plugs just start the car :)

I know but if the glow plugs are working well then the fuel starts to burn more efficiently on start up, IE, the engine will start better.. :)
And i agree, Forte diesel injector additive does work really well. But for the mileage of the vehicle i`d suggest getting recon injectors rather than new ones from Ford.

martyh 07-04-2010 21:13

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996595)
Halfords do the Millers.
http://www.halfords.com/webapp/wcs/s...Id_165750#dtab

Forte is trade only. either Ebay or a garage that has some to sell to you.

---------- Post added at 21:09 ---------- Previous post was at 21:07 ----------



I don't own diesels. it's what a lot of people rave on about in a couple of motor forums I'm in.

I've used the Forte products in a petrol. they're really good.

thanks Gary i'll give it a go :tu:

budwieser 07-04-2010 21:20

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996601)
thanks Gary i'll give it a go :tu:

Hello mate, when you put the fuel treatment in, pour 1/2 into the fuel filter and the other half into the tank.;) Gives the injectors a bit of a thorough clean.:)

alferret 07-04-2010 21:29

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996595)

Cheers Bud! due to fill up in a week or so so I'll give it a go for a while. My '98 306 has gone from 45 to 49-50 since Jan this year, if I can squeeze another 2mpg out of it I'll be happy, would be nice to get 700 to the tank :)

martyh 07-04-2010 21:33

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by budwieser (Post 34996607)
Hello mate, when you put the fuel treatment in, pour 1/2 into the fuel filter and the other half into the tank.;) Gives the injectors a bit of a thorough clean.:)

might be worth a go my engine works fine but on 120,000miles it may need a bit of extra tlc ;)

budwieser 07-04-2010 21:36

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996616)
might be worth a go my engine works fine but on 120,000miles it may need a bit of extra tlc ;)

Give it a try mate, i`ve worked in the motor trade for over 24 years now and thats what we do with good results. :)

alferret 12-04-2010 08:14

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Just added a full bottle of Millers, (does treat 10 tank fulls normally) My last mileage was 642 from 57 litres. I'll post back in another 3 weeks or so to say if I have noticed a difference.

Gary L 12-04-2010 09:16

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Don't forget to take into account the pseudo effect :)

alferret 12-04-2010 10:01

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34999540)
Don't forget to take into account the pseudo effect :)

LOL yea, I do average 620+ to the tank. I am hoping for smoother running and a bit more torque lower down in my tired old 306.

Spectato 12-04-2010 12:37

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Got through a 5-litre can of 'Miller's Diesel Power +' on a Passat (that had a secondary 'naughty' ECU program installed -> 180BHP).
Could actually feel the difference on that because it had a lumpy idle and rough spots that were noticeably smoothed by using the Miller's, also by using 'Advanced Diesel' (that seems to have fallen out of fashion with escalating fuel cost).
Very difficult to quantify any actual performance/economy benefits, or benefits to engine health though. :shrug:

Injector cleaners do work (i've 'seen' the results), but I'd use them sparingly.
They must cause some additional wear to delicate diesel fuel pumps along with the cleaning.
Same goes for those caustic oil-change engine flushes!

AbyssUnderground 13-04-2010 12:22

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 34999561)
LOL yea, I do average 620+ to the tank. I am hoping for smoother running and a bit more torque lower down in my tired old 306.

How do you manage that? Is it a turbo or non-turbo 306? I have a 97 XLdt (turbo). Driving like a granny I only managed 550mi from a brimmed tank.

alferret 13-04-2010 18:17

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbyssUnderground (Post 35000444)
How do you manage that? Is it a turbo or non-turbo 306? I have a 97 XLdt (turbo). Driving like a granny I only managed 550mi from a brimmed tank.

I dont even try & I can get 600 to the tank. Mine is a 98 1.9dt (turbo) with <90k on the clock.
Make sure to get the oil & all filters done every 6k (although the fuel filter is good for 24k IIRC it dont cost much more to get that done at the same time every time)

I very rarely go over 3k rpm, I try to change gear at or below 2k rpm so I am using as little boost a possible. My drive consists of 10 miles @ 30mph or under & 20 miles @ 50-60mph per day for my round trip commute & then its round town, driving the kids about, shopping etc.


As to adding the Millers if anyones intrested I have sone 50 miles so far and the first thing I have noticed is less knock (quieter) below 1600 rpm above that I have never had any knocking anyway and even after such a short amount of time of having the additive in the engine seems more responsive so its all good so far.

martyh 13-04-2010 18:26

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 35000664)
I dont even try & I can get 600 to the tank. Mine is a 98 1.9dt (turbo) with <90k on the clock.
Make sure to get the oil & all filters done every 6k (although the fuel filter is good for 24k IIRC it dont cost much more to get that done at the same time every time)

I very rarely go over 3k rpm, I try to change gear at or below 2k rpm so I am using as little boost a possible. My drive consists of 10 miles @ 30mph or under & 20 miles @ 50-60mph per day for my round trip commute & then its round town, driving the kids about, shopping etc.


As to adding the Millers if anyones intrested I have sone 50 miles so far and the first thing I have noticed is less knock (quieter) below 1600 rpm above that I have never had any knocking anyway and even after such a short amount of time of having the additive in the engine seems more responsive so its all good so far.


i put a bottle of redex in my full tank at the weekend ,done 130miles to date and have noticed a difference ,smoother running and a bit more responsive from start .I usually get 400 miles to a tank so i will see if i get any more ,...long weelbase tranny usually carrying 2.5 -3 tonnes on 120,000 miles

AbyssUnderground 13-04-2010 18:41

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 35000664)
I dont even try & I can get 600 to the tank. Mine is a 98 1.9dt (turbo) with <90k on the clock.
Make sure to get the oil & all filters done every 6k (although the fuel filter is good for 24k IIRC it dont cost much more to get that done at the same time every time)

I very rarely go over 3k rpm, I try to change gear at or below 2k rpm so I am using as little boost a possible. My drive consists of 10 miles @ 30mph or under & 20 miles @ 50-60mph per day for my round trip commute & then its round town, driving the kids about, shopping etc.


As to adding the Millers if anyones intrested I have sone 50 miles so far and the first thing I have noticed is less knock (quieter) below 1600 rpm above that I have never had any knocking anyway and even after such a short amount of time of having the additive in the engine seems more responsive so its all good so far.

I have the same model, but 97 and 137k on the clock.

See when I got the 550mi I was playing the 2000RPM game too, so I guess that's the way to go. I change the fuel filter whenever I do the oil, which is every 6000mi or so.

I do about 30mi/day to work and back, and I will admit, I have been flooring it recently so that will have brought the MPG down. Guess it's back to the 2000RPM game then! :)

I know a fair amount about the 306's (thanks to club 306) but one of those was not how to get the best MPG, which is sketchy at best even from the pro's. It's all down to personal experience.

alferret 13-04-2010 18:59

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbyssUnderground (Post 35000683)
Guess it's back to the 2000RPM game then! :)

Grannies gonna love ya lol!

I'm a member of club 306 as well :tu:

AbyssUnderground 13-04-2010 19:06

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Ah, now I look at your name it does ring a bell. Do you use a similar one there? I'm Andy Why :)

alferret 13-04-2010 19:31

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Yea, I use alferret everywhere :D

Hom3r 13-04-2010 19:52

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
In 2008 my 55 plate Mondeo Ghia X 2.o TDCi, had it first major service (36,000) they did some fuel flush on it, and if I'm honest I didn't notice ant difference, but then at on;y 3 years old, there shouldn't be.

I then drove it to Cornwall and back on less than a tank of fuel (60 ltrs), since I left my job and don't do motorway driving, the MPG has plumted to about 38mpg, I was getting 50mpg.

Xaccers 13-04-2010 20:03

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
I once managed 816 miles on a tank full in my first Xantia, 65L tank (though you can squeeze in a bit more than that).
If your XUDs have a bosch fuel pump, then try using some vegetable oil.
Do not do this if you have a LUCAS or direct injection fuel pump!

Running on Veg, Cassy's emissions are much lower.

TheNorm 13-04-2010 20:44

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35000732)
..., Cassy's emissions are much lower.

She is your car, I hope. :erm:

AbyssUnderground 14-04-2010 12:30

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35000732)
I once managed 816 miles on a tank full in my first Xantia, 65L tank (though you can squeeze in a bit more than that).
If your XUDs have a bosch fuel pump, then try using some vegetable oil.
Do not do this if you have a LUCAS or direct injection fuel pump!

Running on Veg, Cassy's emissions are much lower.

You can use veg oil on the lucas or bosch pump, but the bosch likes it more. The lucas tends to have problems when it's cold with the veg oil being too thick for it. Running a 50/50 mix is 100% OK on both.

Xaccers 14-04-2010 13:00

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbyssUnderground (Post 35001039)
You can use veg oil on the lucas or bosch pump, but the bosch likes it more. The lucas tends to have problems when it's cold with the veg oil being too thick for it. Running a 50/50 mix is 100% OK on both.

Lucas will die on veg, how long it takes for that is down to how lucky you are and what % veg you use.
Internally they are completely different.
Of course if your Lucas pump does die, you can always swap it for a bosch (just remember the inector pipes too!)

AbyssUnderground 14-04-2010 13:13

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
You obviously don't know anyone who has tried it then :) Over on the 306 forum lots of people run a 50/50 mix of veg/diesel with no problems on the lucas pump. As I said, the lucas doesn't like pure veg oil but the bosch doesn't mind. The only thing that can go is the seals, and that can happen to any pump running veg oil.

Xaccers 14-04-2010 13:34

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AbyssUnderground (Post 35001070)
You obviously don't know anyone who has tried it then :) Over on the 306 forum lots of people run a 50/50 mix of veg/diesel with no problems on the lucas pump. As I said, the lucas doesn't like pure veg oil but the bosch doesn't mind. The only thing that can go is the seals, and that can happen to any pump running veg oil.

I've had the pumps apart to see why.
Thankfully on the Xantias Lucas was only used on 1.9D's and the 2.1TD with the godawful Epic (we'll give you 110BHP and make it feel like 80!)
If you don't mind your pump failing, then yes, you can get way with running veg through a lucas, but it will fail and not just seals.
That reminds me, Cassy's is starting to weep (but then it is 13 years old and has been running on pretty much 100% veg for the past 80K) so I need to swap it with one of my spares.

alferret 14-04-2010 18:54

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
So where would one (me) get 60ltr of vegiie oil every 3 weeks or so? Whats better, rapeseed or sunflour?

Peter_ 14-04-2010 19:13

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 35001309)
So where would one (me) get 60ltr of vegiie oil every 3 weeks or so? Whats better, rapeseed or sunflour?

Try your local chippie.:D

Xaccers 14-04-2010 20:01

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 35001309)
So where would one (me) get 60ltr of vegiie oil every 3 weeks or so? Whats better, rapeseed or sunflour?

Rapeseed and sunflour are about the same, rapeseed tends to be a bit cheaper while sunflour is a bit thinner.
Corn oil apparently makes your exhaust smell of popcorn rather than chips :D

Costco/Makro are the easiest for buying in bulk.

If you've got the space and a shed with an electric supply, you could use WVO and heat/filter it yourself (use proper filters, not just a j-cloth/pillow)
There are also companies which filter and heat WVO for you, and deliver it in large drums, complete with taps.

In order of safety for your car:
1. SVO
2. WVO that you've thoroughly filtered and heated properly
3. WVO from a 3rd party supplier (there's always the possibility of them getting something wrong).

If you do use WVO, always, always, keep a spare fuel filter in the car!

Also, something that's good to do anyway, lift up the back seat, pop out the fuel sender after attaching long cable ties to the fuel lines so you don't lose them down the side of the tank, and clean the mesh filter as it gets gunked up with dirt etc over the years. Blow through the fuel return line from the pump too, and then refit the fuel lines with new jubilee clips.
Make sure your glow plugs are in good working order, and your leak off pipes between injectors are flexible (if they're hard they're on their way out and will eventually perish letting in air).
Keep simple records for the tax man should he happen to ever pass by.
How they'd ever prove the accuracy of the records I do not know, and neither do they.
Oh and cut with diesel in the cold, not petrol or any other solvents.

On Lucas pumps, the distributor rotor is lubed by the fuel, and veg is too thick so it overheats and welds in it's sleive.

Neil22 16-04-2010 04:03

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996541)
hi , any petrol heads had any experience using additives in diesel to clean the injectors ,do they work? or are they a waste of money
i have a 2002 transit van on 120,000 miles works fine and is serviced regular since i bought it 2 yrs ago so any advice appreciated

the reason i ask is my work partners sprinter is going to cost him £900 for new injectors his van is the same age but a cdi engine


Use 300mil of 2 stroke semi synthetic to every fill up of diesel. This will lubricate your fuel pump and your injectors.

Since the low sulpher diesel diesel was introduced it has caused major problems with the high pressure fuel pumps and injectors due to it's lack of lubricating properties.

This guy on here speaks alot of sense.

http://www.freel2.com/forum/topic878...05f0471596cb5f

Xaccers 16-04-2010 18:51

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
ULSD has lubricants added to it anyway.
Can't see it doing much harm though. Friend of mine who runs his XUD on WVO also pours any waste engine oil/LHM/hydroflush into his tank too. Keeps people from tailgating him :D

martyh 16-04-2010 18:55

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
update

well i've just used a tank of diesel with one bottle of redex and have noticed a difference usually i get approx 400 miles to a tank and now i am on 420miles and the fuel light still hasn't come on engine does run smoother and seem to have a bit more mid range pull

TheNorm 17-04-2010 13:36

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35002652)
... usually i get approx 400 miles to a tank and now i am on 420miles ...

That's a 5% improvement (roughly). Out of interest, how much did you have to pay for the additive?

martyh 17-04-2010 14:43

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheNorm (Post 35003234)
That's a 5% improvement (roughly). Out of interest, how much did you have to pay for the additive?

it was only £3.00 odd from morrisons ,so good value i thought

TheNorm 17-04-2010 15:08

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35003255)
it was only £3.00 odd from morrisons ,so good value i thought

So if you get 20mpg (or is that only me?) you are already ahead.

Keep us posted!

martyh 19-04-2010 15:35

Re: diesel additives ,do they work ?
 
i bought a bottle of Millers additive this week to try on a fresh tank of diesel ,seems much better value for money than redex .1 bottle of Millers cost £12.99(halfords) but it will do 10 50L tanks so i will give that a go


All times are GMT. The time now is 18:02.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum