Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Think petrol tax is high right now? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33662371)

Derek 05-03-2010 10:29

Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Thanks to the EU and the Lisbon treaty that wasn't a treaty so we didn't need a referendum even though we were promised one they could be getting even higher.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worl...fuel-levy.html

Quote:

The European Union is drawing up plans for its first direct tax with a "green" levy on petrol, coal and natural gas that could cost British consumers up to £3 billion.
The new tax would lead to direct rises in petrol and energy bills and additional price increases due to higher costs for industry.

nomadking 05-03-2010 10:35

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
IIRC there already is a carbon tax in place, that even applies to nuclear power, and that doesn't really release CO2.

Earl of Bronze 05-03-2010 11:04

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Time, and past time to tell the EU to Foxtrot Oscar me thinks.... :dozey:

Spectato 05-03-2010 12:23

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
It will come as a huge shock to no one, that fuel prices are set to get higher!

Whereas you can appreciate the situation between the Chinese and Americans, squabbling over dwindling resources, it is a bit harder to swallow the blatant profiteering from our own government, and EU.
Okay, we might not save any land or species from the.... *cough*... 'ravages of global-warming', but we can, most definitely, make a schittload of cash from these sukkaz!!

They really need to start thinking along the lines of generating funds through industry, like we did in the good old days.
There's only so much money they can milk from motorists/bill-payers, although obviously they haven't pushed us quite to the limit yet!

I'm going out for a drive, to calm myself down. :mad:

RizzyKing 05-03-2010 13:21

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Great because we in the Uk already get such a damn bargain on this as it is where our government has been taxing us till we bleed for the enviroment for quite a few years now the EU wants it's piece of the pie still trying to balance the books are they :rolleyes:. Way it is going there soon will be no reason to work because you'll be poorer working then doing nothing it's ridiculous and to think one of the main selling points of the EU was that as a block we would be in a better position to negotiate what a joke which is pretty much what the EU is.

papa smurf 05-03-2010 15:50

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
time to point our ballistic missiles at Brussels ,and press the big red button of freedom.

Sirius 05-03-2010 17:44

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Earl of Bronze (Post 34974765)
Time, and past time to tell the EU to Foxtrot Oscar me thinks.... :dozey:


:clap:


Thanks Labour for yet another f up

Jimmy-J 05-03-2010 19:42

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
It's absolutely ridiculous. No wonder there are more and more drivers out there who aren't insuring their vehicles. The fine, if they get caught, is minuscule compared to what they would actually pay for insurance.

I had to sell my car last year, the amount of money I've saved since getting rid of it has been a huge bonus.

Derek 05-03-2010 20:13

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Product 13 (Post 34974968)
The fine, if they get caught

£200 + 6 penalty points. Not exactly small change.

Plus if they get caught the car will probably be towed at a cost of about £120 + £20 a day storage.

Jimmy-J 05-03-2010 20:24

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 34974975)
£200 + 6 penalty points. Not exactly small change.

Plus if they get caught the car will probably be towed at a cost of about £120 + £20 a day storage.

Still, that's going to be peanuts compared to what they would have to pay for insurance.

Hom3r 05-03-2010 20:30

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Earl of Bronze (Post 34974765)
Time, and past time to tell the EU to Foxtrot Oscar me thinks.... :dozey:

Agreed

Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 34974879)
time to point our ballistic missiles at Brussels ,and press the big red button of freedom.

Can I press the button, I lost my job to a Belgian.

Derek 05-03-2010 21:16

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Product 13 (Post 34974980)
Still, that's going to be peanuts compared to what they would have to pay for insurance.

I'm £140 a year for me and 2 other named drivers. :confused:

Fair enough it's a small car and I've got a whole bunch of things going in my favour for getting it cheaper but still well under the fine for no insurance and less chance of losing my license.

papa smurf 05-03-2010 21:20

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 34974985)
Agreed



Can I press the button, I lost my job to a Belgian.

your hired :tu::D

Jimmy-J 05-03-2010 21:35

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 34975004)
I'm £140 a year for me and 2 other named drivers. :confused:

Fair enough it's a small car and I've got a whole bunch of things going in my favour for getting it cheaper but still well under the fine for no insurance and less chance of losing my license.

That's understandable, because it won't be drivers in a similar situation to you that will be driving without insurance, they'll have too much to lose.

Osem 06-03-2010 21:47

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 34974752)
Thanks to the EU and the Lisbon treaty that wasn't a treaty so we didn't need a referendum even though we were promised one.....

You're not suggesting we've been misled are you?... ;)

Derek 06-03-2010 22:53

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 34975451)
You're not suggesting we've been misled are you?... ;)

Our illustrious leaders mislead us? Never! :erm:

I'm surprised they have the time to find new and inventive ways to disappoint the public in between screwing every last penny out the taxpayer whilst asking all of us to take our share of the coming pain.

Hom3r 13-05-2010 17:35

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Well with ant & dec running the country ":rofl:", there was talk on the TV that there will be a rise in VAT taking it from 17.5% to 20%, to pay off the deficiet.

But they were saying something about it NOT going on food so I guess among the target will be fuel.

So if this does happen, all those who voted for the current govenment CANNOT complain.

Hugh 13-05-2010 17:37

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35020884)
Well with ant & dec running the country ":rofl:", there was talk on the TV that there will be a rise in VAT taking it from 17.5% to 20%, to pay off the deficiet.

But they were saying something about it NOT going on food so I guess among the target will be fuel.

So if this does happen, all those who voted for the current govenment CANNOT complain.

Well, at least Mr Bean isn't running the country anymore.....;) (nice to see a happy Mirror reader).

If VAT does go up, I won't complain - we need to balance the books somehow to pay for the NHS, Education, Defence, etc etc - the money fairy doesn't really exist.

Maggy 13-05-2010 17:48

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 35020887)
Well, at least Mr Bean isn't running the country anymore.....;) (nice to see a happy Mirror reader).

If VAT does go up, I won't complain - we need to balance the books somehow to pay for the NHS, Education, Defence, etc etc - the money fairy doesn't really exist.

Well I will 'cos my wages aren't going up.:(

Graham M 13-05-2010 17:50

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35020884)
So if this does happen, all those who voted for the current govenment CANNOT complain.

And I WILL NOT be complaining; the debt needs to be paid somehow, if the supposed raises on the bottom tax allowance goes up to 10k it'll make most people better off anyhow

Xaccers 13-05-2010 17:52

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35020884)
Well with ant & dec running the country ":rofl:", there was talk on the TV that there will be a rise in VAT taking it from 17.5% to 20%, to pay off the deficiet.

But they were saying something about it NOT going on food so I guess among the target will be fuel.

So if this does happen, all those who voted for the current govenment CANNOT complain.

Aw bless.
Food is VAT free (oh how I love running on veg oil).
An increase of the 17.5% VAT rate would not just affect fuel.
Of course this is all guess work by a few non-governmental economists.
Doesn't mean it will happen, doesn't mean it won't.

If it does, I'll be complaining about the mess Labour left us in, not the steps that need to be taken to get us out of it.

Hom3r 13-05-2010 17:52

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 35020887)
Well, at least Mr Bean isn't running the country anymore.....;) (nice to see a happy Mirror reader).

If VAT does go up, I won't complain - we need to balance the books somehow to pay for the NHS, Education, Defence, etc etc - the money fairy doesn't really exist.

So you don't obviously drive.

I nearly cried when I paid my diesl bill, £60:shocked::mad:,the most I have ever spent.

FYI I don't buy newspapers, even if I did the Mirror would be one of them.

haydnwalker 13-05-2010 19:05

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Me and a mate at work figured out, that if we half the amount of troops in Afghanistan (thereby saving lives...) and dropped public spending by 20%/year for 5 years they could just about pay off the deficit.

Afterall... WTF are we doing in Afghanistan anyway... not our war really. We were just bullied into going by the americans. how much does one round cost to fire from an SA80? Or an RPG from a launcher? Or even...how much does it cost to fly Close Air Support in a Tornado/Typhoon for 2 hours? ALOT I'm guessing, money that can be saved imho.

Increasing various taxes and costs just puts businesses out of work, thereby decreasing the amount of people paying tax and increasing the amount of people taking benefits

---------- Post added at 18:05 ---------- Previous post was at 18:03 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35020903)
So you don't obviously drive.

I nearly cried when I paid my diesl bill, £60:shocked::mad:,the most I have ever spent.

You get off lightly Hom3r... My Audi costs me about £80 to fill up...its getting rediculous. And I'm spending £40/week on fuel as I have to use my car at work. I'm glad I get a mileage allowance really because I'd be skint if I didn't

chris9991 13-05-2010 19:09

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
There was talk before the election, that the Tories wanted to have petrol duty be a fixed amount which varied as the untaxed price of petrol fluctuated (there was an article in Auto Express) so that the price on the forecourt would be smoothed. The article did say there was no detailed plans available and it could be expensive to run in public BUT they could reduce petrol duty to offset this

TheNorm 13-05-2010 19:12

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by haydnwalker (Post 35020977)
Me and a mate at work figured out,...

Won't those measures increase unemployment?

Taf 13-05-2010 19:29

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
As we pay excise duty on the petrol then VAT on the cost PLUS the excise duty, a simple way would be to just dump the VAT and have the excise duty only (at a higher rate at first of course to prevent loss of tax).

But I don't suppose our EU friends would like that....

Hom3r 13-05-2010 19:37

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by haydnwalker (Post 35020977)
Me and a mate at work figured out, that if we half the amount of troops in Afghanistan (thereby saving lives...) and dropped public spending by 20%/year for 5 years they could just about pay off the deficit.

Afterall... WTF are we doing in Afghanistan anyway... not our war really. We were just bullied into going by the americans. how much does one round cost to fire from an SA80? Or an RPG from a launcher? Or even...how much does it cost to fly Close Air Support in a Tornado/Typhoon for 2 hours? ALOT I'm guessing, money that can be saved imho.

Increasing various taxes and costs just puts businesses out of work, thereby decreasing the amount of people paying tax and increasing the amount of people taking benefits

---------- Post added at 18:05 ---------- Previous post was at 18:03 ----------



You get off lightly Hom3r... My Audi costs me about £80 to fill up...its getting rediculous. And I'm spending £40/week on fuel as I have to use my car at work. I'm glad I get a mileage allowance really because I'd be skint if I didn't

Well Afganistan is off topic, but if we weren't there they would be hear, proberly doing more 7/7.

Well I never have had the benefit of mileage allowance, other than the occational drive when the pool car was out.

martyh 13-05-2010 19:42

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Taf (Post 35021000)
As we pay excise duty on the petrol then VAT on the cost PLUS the excise duty, a simple way would be to just dump the VAT and have the excise duty only (at a higher rate at first of course to prevent loss of tax).

But I don't suppose our EU friends would like that....


would there be an advantage to tagging the exise duty onto the road fund license ?
i know this has been mooted a few times in the past by various governments but it didn't really get of the ground

Ignitionnet 13-05-2010 20:00

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35020884)
Well with ant & dec running the country ":rofl:", there was talk on the TV that there will be a rise in VAT taking it from 17.5% to 20%, to pay off the deficiet.

But they were saying something about it NOT going on food so I guess among the target will be fuel.

So if this does happen, all those who voted for the current govenment CANNOT complain.

Second post you've made with that exact last paragraph in.

From what I can see people who voted the other way to you aren't complaining. Why? Because we understand, unlike most Labour supporters, that there isn't an endless pot of money to throw at public services and welfare and buy votes. We accept that the bills have to be paid and I'm sorry to inform you that we don't blame the new administration for it - we blame the previous administration that chalked up the deficit that needs paying.

The simple fact is that the economic woes were bad, however even without that Labour were happily chalking up ever increasing deficits that were not sustainable in the long term.

It's what they do, spend and spend and tax and tax and borrow and borrow if they don't feel it politically convenient to tax enough to pay for the spending. They were handed a prosperous economy in surplus and urinated that away throwing money at inefficiently run services, welfare and bribing and expanding their base.

We're not in the state Greece were, but the fact remains either we deal with the deficit as a country or the deficit deals with us by causing us to lose our AAA credit rating and our interest bill go up further increasing the amount of money being spent unproductively and on overheads instead of servicing us the people.

This won't be pleasant, but sadly those who are pragmatic enough to grasp it will accept the need. I appreciate this may well not include many who think that they can live off the state, that it should look after them and all their needs and don't grasp that the money for it has to come from somewhere and their relatively small or non-existent tax bill really doesn't come close to covering it.

Nice try :)

Sirius 13-05-2010 20:32

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35020902)

If it does, I'll be complaining about the mess Labour left us in, not the steps that need to be taken to get us out of it.

Dam right. Its going to take a long time to clear up the mess left by them

Will21st 13-05-2010 20:57

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35021025)
Second post you've made with that exact last paragraph in.

From what I can see people who voted the other way to you aren't complaining. Why? Because we understand, unlike most Labour supporters, that there isn't an endless pot of money to throw at public services and welfare and buy votes.
Snippedy snip snip

:clap::clap:

RizzyKing 13-05-2010 21:06

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Funny isn't it to labour supporters their beloved party did nothing wrong for the thirteen years they held power but they are so happy to have a go at the poor sods that havn't been in for three weeks about this mess. Get real and take off those red tinted specs and see the complete mess that labour have left us all in and all of us are going to have to pay for it oneway or the other. But one consolation for you the majority of the public in this country are so damn short sighted come the next election they will forget who caused all this and will punish those who sorted it out letting the lunatics take over the asylum again.

martyh 13-05-2010 21:18

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35021025)
Second post you've made with that exact last paragraph in.

From what I can see people who voted the other way to you aren't complaining. Why? Because we understand, unlike most Labour supporters, that there isn't an endless pot of money to throw at public services and welfare and buy votes. We accept that the bills have to be paid and I'm sorry to inform you that we don't blame the new administration for it - we blame the previous administration that chalked up the deficit that needs paying.

The simple fact is that the economic woes were bad, however even without that Labour were happily chalking up ever increasing deficits that were not sustainable in the long term.

It's what they do, spend and spend and tax and tax and borrow and borrow if they don't feel it politically convenient to tax enough to pay for the spending. They were handed a prosperous economy in surplus and urinated that away throwing money at inefficiently run services, welfare and bribing and expanding their base.

We're not in the state Greece were, but the fact remains either we deal with the deficit as a country or the deficit deals with us by causing us to lose our AAA credit rating and our interest bill go up further increasing the amount of money being spent unproductively and on overheads instead of servicing us the people.

This won't be pleasant, but sadly those who are pragmatic enough to grasp it will accept the need. I appreciate this may well not include many who think that they can live off the state, that it should look after them and all their needs and don't grasp that the money for it has to come from somewhere and their relatively small or non-existent tax bill really doesn't come close to covering it.

Nice try :)

ok, you've established that labour made a right pigs ear of things and mostly i agree ,you also say that as usual labour have spent,spent and taxed and taxed ,i agree also ,so given that this is true what the hell makes you or the politicians think that the people who pay taxes of any form ,be it vat , income tax ,council tax or any other tax can afford to pay any more .It's ok saying ,but the debt has to be paid back ,yes it has ,but there isn't a limitless pot of money to draw on from the publics wages. Increasing taxes ,taking more of our wages will only create hardship that the state will pay for in the form of wellfair handouts .Other ways of reducing the deficit will have to be found other than taking it of the workers through increased taxes

Hom3r 13-05-2010 21:22

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
The point I'm trying to make is everytime extra cash is need they go "I know lets screw the motorist again".

I know taxes need to be raised, but they have said they cannot put food up as it will affect the poorest. but obviously the poorest don't own cars.

Well the way things are going there will come a point when motorists will snap, and no doubt fuel protest will raise there head and I will join them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35021083)
Funny isn't it to labour supporters their beloved party did nothing wrong for the thirteen years they held power but they are so happy to have a go at the poor sods that havn't been in for three weeks about this mess. Get real and take off those red tinted specs and see the complete mess that labour have left us all in and all of us are going to have to pay for it oneway or the other. But one consolation for you the majority of the public in this country are so damn short sighted come the next election they will forget who caused all this and will punish those who sorted it out letting the lunatics take over the asylum again.

I have never said that Labour where perfect, and my glasses are very clear.

Xaccers 13-05-2010 21:27

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Once again, VAT is not only on fuel! (actually it's not even on my fuel) :D

Ignitionnet 13-05-2010 21:34

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35021097)
Increasing taxes ,taking more of our wages will only create hardship that the state will pay for in the form of wellfair handouts .Other ways of reducing the deficit will have to be found other than taking it of the workers through increased taxes

There has to be a balance of cuts to services and tax increases. Cut services too much it causes hardship through job cuts causing an influx on a job market that might not be able to take the strain, and reduction of services people have come to, right or wrong, rely on. Increase taxes too much it disincentivises work and deters investment.

The Tory plan had the balance shifted more towards cuts than tax increases, Labour's was skewed more towards tax increases, the Lib Dems' was in between the two.

The point is due to the mess we can't have no cuts or no tax increases sadly, it's a balancing act. We'll see if the balance we get from ConLib is the right one.

---------- Post added at 20:34 ---------- Previous post was at 20:32 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35021102)
The point I'm trying to make is everytime extra cash is need they go "I know lets screw the motorist again".

I know taxes need to be raised, but they have said they cannot put food up as it will affect the poorest. but obviously the poorest don't own cars.

Well the way things are going there will come a point when motorists will snap, and no doubt fuel protest will raise there head and I will join them.

I have never said that Labour where perfect, and my glasses are very clear.

There has been no confirmation that it will happen, and no confirmation of how it will happen if it does.

Let's wait and see the specifics before condemning them over a policy they haven't yet announced, eh?

martyh 13-05-2010 21:37

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35021114)
There has to be a balance of cuts to services and tax increases. Cut services too much it causes hardship through job cuts causing an influx on a job market that might not be able to take the strain, and reduction of services people have come to, right or wrong, rely on. Increase taxes too much it disincentivises work and deters investment.

The Tory plan had the balance shifted more towards cuts than tax increases, Labour's was skewed more towards tax increases, the Lib Dems' was in between the two.

The point is due to the mess we can't have no cuts or no tax increases sadly, it's a balancing act. We'll see if the balance we get from ConLib is the right one.

?

and that will be balancing act worthy of Billy Smarts Circus lets hope they get it right ;)

Damien 13-05-2010 21:43

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35021102)
The point I'm trying to make is everytime extra cash is need they go "I know lets screw the motorist again".

I know taxes need to be raised, but they have said they cannot put food up as it will affect the poorest. but obviously the poorest don't own cars.

Well the way things are going there will come a point when motorists will snap, and no doubt fuel protest will raise there head and I will join them.

You probably didn't want to bash the government on motorists the same day that this comes out:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/7720...y-pledges.html

Quote:

Within 24 hours of taking on the portfolio he confirmed the new administration would bring in a "fuel price stabiliser" which would see the taxes reduced if the price of oil rises sharply.
Quote:

However Mr Hammond, who drives a Jaguar, sought to underline the new Government's motorist-friendly credentials confirming a manifesto pledge that there would be no Whitehall cash for new fixed speed cameras.



He said road safety partnerships would have to pay for new devices out of their own funds, even though the Treasury would still pocket the fines.
The new Government will also press ahead with plans to curb the activities of rogue private clamping firms, Mr Hammond added.


---------- Post added at 20:43 ---------- Previous post was at 20:42 ----------

I not sure I agree with all of that though. Speed cameras do seem to work, accidents overall down, accidents near troublespots where cameras are installed way down.

Also road tolls work well in Europe. Awesome roads there.

PeteLockwood 13-05-2010 21:56

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
a fuel price stabiliser is a excellent idea i have been wondering why labour never did this... i dont drive but maybe they could go ahead and use some of this extortionate amount of tax and filling in the millions of potholes ?

Damien 13-05-2010 22:13

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by PeteL (Post 35021141)
a fuel price stabiliser is a excellent idea i have been wondering why labour never did this... i dont drive but maybe they could go ahead and use some of this extortionate amount of tax and filling in the millions of potholes ?

To be fair it is probably hard to manage if you cannot be sure what fuel duty is bringing in. You would have to be running a surplus budget or borrow more...

Hom3r 13-05-2010 22:18

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35021122)

I not sure I agree with all of that though. Speed cameras do seem to work, accidents overall down, accidents near troublespots where cameras are installed way down.

Also road tolls work well in Europe. Awesome roads there.

Well IMHO speed camera are pointless, most sat navs have locations of them in, you can buy devices exclusively for them.

Most people speed upto them then slow down, then speed up after them.

Tuftus 13-05-2010 22:20

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Well i get the bus to work, leaving the car on the drive Monday - Friday.

A 4 week ticket with Arriva online costs me £33.30p so that is less than a weeks fuel in the car.

OK, so i have to walk 10 mins to the bus stop to and from, but otherwise - Win :)

Xaccers 13-05-2010 22:22

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Light up speed limit signs have been shown to be more effective in that people slow down and stay slowed down.

Derek 13-05-2010 22:22

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35021168)
Well IMHO speed camera are pointless, most sat navs have locations of them in, you can buy devices exclusively for them.

They still catch plenty of people going over the limit.

Xaccers 13-05-2010 22:25

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 35021173)
They still catch plenty of people going over the limit.

Which shows that they're not doing their job as a deterrant, and if they're in accident blackspots, if they're not slowing people down, they're not saving lives, so something else needs to be done such as redesigning the road to be safer.

martyh 13-05-2010 22:29

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021172)
Light up speed limit signs have been shown to be more effective in that people slow down and stay slowed down.

very true ,a gentel reminder of the limit is more effective than a good shouting at

---------- Post added at 21:29 ---------- Previous post was at 21:27 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021175)
Which shows that they're not doing their job as a deterrant, and if they're in accident blackspots, if they're not slowing people down, they're not saving lives, so something else needs to be done such as redesigning the road to be safer.

this also is true ,but are they meant as a deterrant or a way of dishing out the punishment more efficiently

Derek 13-05-2010 22:33

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021175)
Which shows that they're not doing their job as a deterrant, and if they're in accident blackspots, if they're not slowing people down, they're not saving lives, so something else needs to be done such as redesigning the road to be safer.

They don't work 100% but very few things do. There is a time and a place for them, just as there is a time and a place for speed bumps etc.

Xaccers 13-05-2010 22:42

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35021178)
this also is true ,but are they meant as a deterrant or a way of dishing out the punishment more efficiently

The honest answer would be "it depends where they are"
Average speed limit SPECS along road works are obviously a good safety device, although if the road conditions allow (ie only one lane closed, no traffic cone slaloms) the should be turned off when the workers aren't there.
Many cameras are placed where they should, but there many which are hidden/obvuscated/on straight flat roads simply designed to make money.

---------- Post added at 21:42 ---------- Previous post was at 21:37 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 35021192)
They don't work 100% but very few things do. There is a time and a place for them, just as there is a time and a place for speed bumps etc.

What I mean is if they're placed somewhere and are bringing in a nice income, showing they're not deterring speeders, then that is a good signal that the road is still going to produce accidents, and as such, other measures should be taken to reduce them.
Something like rumble strips, or road narrowing markings, or straighten the nasty bend, or put up a barrier, chop down that tree etc :)
It is not acceptable for the "safety partnerships" to sit back and make money while road safety hasn't been increased, if you see what I mean.

Have more ANPR cameras instead :)

martyh 13-05-2010 22:46

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021202)
The honest answer would be "it depends where they are"
Average speed limit SPECS along road works are obviously a good safety device, although if the road conditions allow (ie only one lane closed, no traffic cone slaloms) the should be turned off when the workers aren't there.
Many cameras are placed where they should, but there many which are hidden/obvuscated/on straight flat roads simply designed to make money.

---------- Post added at 21:42 ---------- Previous post was at 21:37 ----------



What I mean is if they're placed somewhere and are bringing in a nice income, showing they're not deterring speeders, then that is a good signal that the road is still going to produce accidents, and as such, other measures should be taken to reduce them.
Something like rumble strips, or road narrowing markings, or straighten the nasty bend, or put up a barrier, chop down that tree etc :)
It is not acceptable for the "safety partnerships" to sit back and make money while road safety hasn't been increased, if you see what I mean.

Have more ANPR cameras instead :)

never really thought of it like that ,making money out of accidents/deaths even ...quite distastful when seen in that light

Xaccers 13-05-2010 22:56

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
I am, like most motorists, 100% behind things which have a practical and effective impact on the number of accidents on our roads.
What I will object too, again like most motorists, are things done in the name of safety when they have little of no impact other than on driver's wallets, and are to the detriment of actual safety improvements.

Driving home from Northampton the back way last night there were signs of two cars going off the roads on two bends, into ditches/trees/fields.
There's not even a kerb or bank to stop it, just tarmac then grass, then a drop into the ditch/field.

danielf 13-05-2010 23:11

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35021178)
very true ,a gentel reminder of the limit is more effective than a good shouting at

I quite liked this thing I saw in Spain last year. Speed 'camera' and a set of flashing traffic lights 100 yards down the road. Go to fast, and the light changes to red, so you end up taking longer. I'm not sure how effective it was, but I liked the idea.

Damien 13-05-2010 23:12

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
I think it would be nice to find a way to make driving short distances less economically viable without punishing people who go further than that. I can't really think of a way to make that possible but parents taking their kids to their local school in sodding great land rovers is absurd, how much inner-town/city rush hour traffic is for short journeys?

Now I am on it I would tax such cars heavy anyway. On my daily drive back from the tube there is a road which always has a lot of cars parked on either side. Being a narrow road it leaves little space for traffic to maneuver and you need to take it slowly, find space, and negotiate carefully when meeting traffic. Usually 3 or 4 times until the end of the road. Now imagine a massive land rover (or bigger!!) coming at you in that situation.

I live near London, what possible reason could you have for such a ridiculous car? Last time I checked there was no wild beasts roaming the suburbs, no cross-terrain driving. Just busy streets. You can fit the same amount of people into a nice, large family car. If I had a lot of money to waste on such a monstrosity then I would rather go for a luxury BMW or other such car.

/Rant

gazfan 13-05-2010 23:45

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Vehicle excise duty should be scrapped & the money raised by a levy on fuel used, instead. This would be directly proportional to the vehicle fuel efficiency & the distance travelled.

The 'tax disc' could be replaced by an 'insurance disc' , confirming the legality of the vehicle, including a yearly cross check of the VPN versus the registration to help deter cloning plates?

Xaccers 13-05-2010 23:50

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gazfan (Post 35021281)
Vehicle excise duty should be scrapped & the money raised by a levy on fuel used, instead. This would be directly proportional to the vehicle fuel efficiency & the distance travelled.

The 'tax disc' could be replaced by an 'insurance disc' , confirming the legality of the vehicle, including a yearly cross check of the VPN versus the registration to help deter cloning plates?

I'd go for that, it'd save me over £200 per year :D

gazfan 14-05-2010 00:24

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021283)
I'd go for that, it'd save me over £200 per year :D


LOL - until a mileage check was built into the MOT, anyway :angel:

- and yes, a new car doesn't have an MOT until 3 years old - but would you risk voiding a warranty by running it on bio-diesel to avoid fuel tax ;)

Xaccers 14-05-2010 00:30

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gazfan (Post 35021314)
LOL - until a mileage check was built into the MOT, anyway :angel:

- and yes, a new car doesn't have an MOT until 3 years old - but would you risk voiding a warranty by running it on bio-diesel to avoid fuel tax ;)

Wouldn't let biodiesel get anywhere near my cars.
2000L duty free limit is about 20000 miles on veg.

gazfan 14-05-2010 00:44

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021321)
Wouldn't let biodiesel get anywhere near my cars.
2000L duty free limit is about 20000 miles on veg.

pedant ;) - however don't get me wrong, if subsidies were available for veg or bio-diesel in a 'new' fuel tax regime I'd be in favour, but it should be proportional to miles travelled - and the income should benefit the road transport network - people that use the roads the most should pay the most, and the money gained should be used to improve roads or supply alternatives...,

Naive, I know ;)

Taf 14-05-2010 12:04

Re: Think petrol tax is high right now?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 35021321)
2000L duty free limit is about 20000 miles on veg.

2500L now?

http://www.vegetableoildiesel.co.uk/customs.html

The DVLA themselves have put forward that road tax should be scrapped and the money recovered via a slight increase in fuel tax, and they are obviously right when they say that income would be higher as naughty people without tax disks would have to pay at the pumps. They also floated the idea of a combined MOT/Insurance disk for cars as they hold all that information already.

I find it odd that their ideas are ignored by HMG time and again.... especially now when reduced use of vehicles/more efficient engines = reduced tax to pay = cleaner environment.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum