Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Other ISPs Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=63)
-   -   Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33638724)

Ignitionnet 16-09-2008 00:18

Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
It's been drawn to my attention that there is no longer a Fair Use Policy for Sky's up to 16Mbit Max Broadband service, which runs over ADSL2+ and is a tenner on top of a Sky TV package.

References to a Fair Use Policy in the Terms and Conditions for the Max product have been removed, making it a truly, totally unlimited service.

Just a heads up for those who really like their Linux ISOs :angel:

Graham M 16-09-2008 00:25

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
According to Sky's Usage Policies Page

"If you subscribe to a Product that does not have a Usage Cap, our Fair Use Policy (“FUP”) will apply to you and anybody that you allow to use Sky Broadband. "

http://www.sky.com/portal/site/skyco...ontentid=59710

Ignitionnet 16-09-2008 00:37

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Removed from T+Cs:

http://packages.sky.com/terms/terms_...and.aspx#usage

Notes on traffic management on Connect package added. T+Cs have been updated usage policy document hasn't I guess.

Gary L 16-09-2008 01:01

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
In todays broadband market, this move is going to earn them thousands of new customers. I wonder if VM are scratching their heads and perspiring heavily now :D

Maggy 16-09-2008 01:39

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Let us hope so...leave more space for those of us who stay...;)

Gary L 16-09-2008 01:55

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34638146)
Let us hope so...leave more space for those of us who stay...;)

I'm trying to think of the wording they will use in the next ad campaign after everyone goes to SKY. Virgin, the most talked about restricted ISP in the UK. Join today! please.

Enuff 16-09-2008 02:13

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34638157)
I'm trying to think of the wording they will use in the next ad campaign after everyone goes to SKY. Virgin, the most talked about restricted ISP in the UK. Join today! please.

They're the only virgin I know of that use a cap.

Gary L 16-09-2008 02:29

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Enuff (Post 34638160)
They're the only virgin I know of that use a cap.


And will swallow any mans money in return for a download.

frogstamper 16-09-2008 02:51

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
If I were an ad-man at Sky now I'd be hoping that Virgin Media do run an ad campaign promoting their new 50mb service with world champion 100m runner Usain Bolt.
Think of the fun they could have, they could run a campaign along the lines of the hare and the tortoise, they could say sign up Paula Radcliff and then mock up a race between her and Bolt.
At first Bolt leaves Paula behind, only to be caught up and over-taken in the long run, Sky could then come up with some pithy remark like, "At Sky you too can keep on going, or join Virgin and shoot your Bolt".:)

Paul K 16-09-2008 07:00

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
It's definately been removed, wether they go all out to make it part of their ad campaign I don't know but at this point in time Sky ADSL Max package has no FUP and it is intended to make that part of the selling point of it along with the £10 per month price tag.

Graham M 16-09-2008 10:08

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
And it's a very nice price tag, but don't they charge like £70 for activation and if you don't have an active BT line it'll cost you £129 for BT to put one in :|

xspeedyx 16-09-2008 10:48

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
What if the removal of the FUP means a hard cap coming in lol

Maggy 16-09-2008 10:55

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Well I won't be joining anyone because I hate BT more than I hate VM...and I'll never have them back as a phone provider.:erm:

Ignitionnet 16-09-2008 11:49

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham M (Post 34638203)
And it's a very nice price tag, but don't they charge like £70 for activation and if you don't have an active BT line it'll cost you £129 for BT to put one in :|

AFAIK they charge nothing for activation on the max pack, and I have to admit I've never had to pay that charge for a BT line despite having moved 6 or 7 times.

---------- Post added at 10:49 ---------- Previous post was at 10:48 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34638230)
What if the removal of the FUP means a hard cap coming in lol

It's only been removed from the top pack, there's no hard cap coming in.

Enuff 16-09-2008 13:05

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Isn't it best to be patient and wait a month or so before jumping into a 12 month contract with another ISP?.

Chrysalis 16-09-2008 13:58

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
sky can afford to do so, first off when they got hold of easynet there was an aweful lot of spare capacity, from what I hear even with the customer count they got now there is still tons of spare capacity. A few areas have congested local VP's to the dslam but I believe it only to be a few.

The other difference is, sky are not bothered about making money on broadband, its simply a way for them to retain tv customers. They expect losses and are happy to subsidise it.

Sort of like asda's new payg package, it is the most competitive on the market, if its making a profit it will be small but it attracts people to their stores.

PeteTheMusicGuy 16-09-2008 14:27

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
As ths is Sky I think i'm going to wait and see what happens

xspeedyx 16-09-2008 15:10

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
The main thing is they havent offical annouced this so I doubt they want a whole load of customers to know this

Paul K 16-09-2008 15:27

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Latest News box on
http://www.sky.com/portal/site/skycom/skyhelpcentre
Quote:

Unlimited Broadband-no fair use policy

September 2008

Unlimited Broadband-no fair use policy
Sky Broadband Max is the perfect choice if you like watching TV shows streamed straight to your computer, downloading films and music or online gaming. Unlike other broadband providers, we don’t have a fair use policy, so you never have to worry about how much you upload or download, or how long you spend online. See our Sky Broadband Max page for more information.

Don't forget that you get all these FREE with Sky Broadband:
· A wireless router (worth £50) for access around your home
· 12 months’ online protection with McAfee® Internet Security Suite
· Sky Email and Tools suite with 10 @Sky.com email addresses so you can keep in touch, store files, share your photos and organise your life online
No doubt there will be something in the next magazine or advert run.

Ignitionnet 16-09-2008 19:38

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Sky have apparently now joined VM as a 'truly unlimited ISP' :rolleyes:

Tezcatlipoca 16-09-2008 20:25

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
No STM / shaping / throttling with Sky though ;)

[Well, unless you have "Connect", in which case blame BT]

mikejones_uk 16-09-2008 21:59

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Does anyone believe this [Sky's unlimited usage ] is **really** sustainable over the long term? I'm personally skepticle, but would be happy to be proven wrong.

CrowmanUK 16-09-2008 22:57

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
You only need to pay the 129 quid charge if the property has never had a bt line in ever, I had to get one as we moved to a new house 2 years back and there was nothing here, I thought if you did have to pay the 129 quid charge though that Sky would refund that money to you if you joined a certain package, not 100% sure but I thought it was on this forum somewhere.

chickendippers 16-09-2008 23:56

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mikejones_uk (Post 34638541)
Does anyone believe this [Sky's unlimited usage ] is **really** sustainable over the long term? I'm personally skepticle, but would be happy to be proven wrong.

Precisely; there's no such thing as unlimited, this is why I prefer plusnet for my ADSL who acknowledge this, provide fair limits and are up-front about it.

Matth 17-09-2008 01:04

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
You CAN have unlimited, just so long as not too many users are complete plonkers with it. There is a difference between "I don't want a limit" and "I'm going to hammer it like hell all the time".

The other mitigating factor for Sky, is that you have to have at least a minimum subscription package, so what they lose on the broadband, is made up to a degree on the TV service, as unlike Virginmedia, you cannot just have Sky broadband.

So it costs £27 per month, with 1 Sky mix and their top broadband (up to 16Mb, unlimited) - BT line required, and if the rental is still £10.50, that takes it to £37.50

Virgin XL Broadband with Phone line is £31 (ongoing price cheaper when taken with a phone line than without), but does not include Sky mix (even a single mix is more channels than TV:M, even if that does get thrown in - TV:M is essentially just freeview on cable)

NewsreadeR 17-09-2008 02:40

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by chickendippers (Post 34638637)
Precisely; there's no such thing as unlimited, this is why I prefer plusnet for my ADSL who acknowledge this, provide fair limits and are up-front about it.

iirc Plusnet were one of the first ISP's to advertise unlimited, then when all the freeloaders went to them, they pulled it.

£39.99 a month with 2mb and all you could download, when I were with them.

Alas, now Plusnet will just say 'It was an error when we advertised unlimited'

Now Plusnet try to blind you with why you cannot have unlimited. On Sky MAX it is ;) and its cheaper than PN. - oh... and faster!

chickendippers 17-09-2008 09:47

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NewsreadeR (Post 34638688)
Now Plusnet try to blind you with why you cannot have unlimited. On Sky MAX it is ;) and its cheaper than PN. - oh... and faster!

Damn you and your unbundled exchange *shakes fist* :p:

Kymmy 17-09-2008 11:02

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NewsreadeR (Post 34638688)
iirc Plusnet were one of the first ISP's to advertise unlimited, then when all the freeloaders went to them, they pulled it.!

Freeloaders??? Or just customers who want what was advertised???

Gary L 17-09-2008 11:38

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by chickendippers (Post 34638637)
Precisely; there's no such thing as unlimited,

We have Virgin Media to blame for that. they insisted that they were the only supplier to be unlimited but gave us STM. now Sky are saying this is what unlimited really means.

BenMcr 17-09-2008 14:45

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matth (Post 34638665)
You CAN have unlimited, just so long as not too many users are complete plonkers with it. There is a difference between "I don't want a limit" and "I'm going to hammer it like hell all the time".

That is precisely the problem with advertising any connection as 'unlimited', people are going to hammer it like hell all the time because they can.

You can't start advertising something as unlimited, then be surprised when people use it as such!

Ignitionnet 17-09-2008 15:06

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quite agree.

http://allyours.virginmedia.com/html...nd/mother.html
http://allyours.virginmedia.com/html...t/bb_deal.html
http://allyours.virginmedia.com/html.../benefits.html

etc

No download limits†

You get unlimited° downloads as a basic right, so you can load up on music, films...whatever you're into

† Acceptable usage policy applies.

;)

NewsreadeR 17-09-2008 16:06

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 34638747)
Freeloaders??? Or just customers who want what was advertised???

Back in those days, the only people who wanted unlimited were those who wanted music from the old Napster, and Films etc - I would even go as far as those who knew about piracy etc.

Nowadays, there are so many legal uses for downloading tonnes of content, that everybody wants to go unlimited.

Don't get me wrong, people should get unlimited, if that's what is advertised.

---------- Post added at 15:06 ---------- Previous post was at 15:04 ----------

Sky have now confirmed this.

We have removed the Fair Usage Policy (FUP) from our Sky Broadband Max product. Customers have told us that they want "unlimited" broadband to be exactly that, so we’ve acted on their feedback. We believe that we are now the only major broadband provider to offer truly "unlimited" broadband. What this means is that, if you’re a Sky Broadband Max customer, means you're free to download as much as you want, whenever you want.

As well as transparency, we know that customers really care about getting consistent, reliable download speeds. One of the biggest gripes with some broadband providers is the capping of speeds during peak times, otherwise known as traffic shaping. We have a high-capacity network that is designed to carry huge amounts of traffic without congestion. So we’re also making a commitment to customers taking our Base, Mid or Max products that we will not slow down their connection speeds at peak times.


http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/09/17/sky_fair_use/

And we broke the original story here:

http://www.skyuser.co.uk/forum/sky-n...unlimited.html

And then promptly emailed The Register, TBB, and ISPreview to tell them.

Xan 17-09-2008 16:39

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Great job sky.Only last night i was downloading warhammer and after 3gb (total download 9.5gb) my connection dropped to 550k hope VM does something if not im off :)

NewsreadeR 17-09-2008 17:14

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Sky have now just posted this:

http://www.skyuser.co.uk/forum/sky-n...band-team.html

adrian1971 17-09-2008 19:31

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
da question is how long will it last ? sounds just like another stunt to me

xspeedyx 17-09-2008 19:53

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
It could be but I can see its a move to try and over take Virgin the mother of call crappy stm'd broadband

Graham M 17-09-2008 20:09

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
This looks like quite an attractive product now, I already have Sky TV but no BT phone line (it was chopped off at the wall by Nynex...) is there any chance I can get the BT line reinstalled FOC?

Tezcatlipoca 17-09-2008 20:14

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
I've read posts at SkyUser from people who actually had the BT line installation paid for / refunded by Sky.

e.g.

http://www.skyuser.co.uk/forum/sky-s...n-charges.html


Not sure if they still do it though.

Maggy 18-09-2008 10:31

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34638999)
It could be but I can see its a move to try and over take Virgin the mother of call crappy stm'd broadband

Are you implying that Sky would take on the job?I bet they would love to but it won't happen because it would be that dreaded phrase...a monopoly. :erm:

xspeedyx 18-09-2008 13:33

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
monopoly is not having a better product

Maggy 18-09-2008 13:35

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34639321)
monopoly is not having a better product

and having no competition so you can charge what you like...;)

eth01 18-09-2008 23:39

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34638237)
Well I won't be joining anyone because I hate BT more than I hate VM...and I'll never have them back as a phone provider.:erm:

you generally "hate" most things, the reason being because ... ?

Chrysalis 19-09-2008 00:25

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mikejones_uk (Post 34638541)
Does anyone believe this [Sky's unlimited usage ] is **really** sustainable over the long term? I'm personally skepticle, but would be happy to be proven wrong.

probably yes. My reasons below.

sky do not have the same costs and financial demands of other isps utilising adsl. They have their own LLU network which is massively cheaper than using BT's network (approx 10% of cost), bear in mind sky customers on sky connect (bt network) are 40 gig limited and shaped.

they have no need to make a profit as the broadband is to keep people subscribed to lucrative tv contracts.

the easynet network even before sky brought it was massive and is the 2nd biggest in the country, bigger than VM's. So sky have a bigger network with a 3rd of the customers, work that one out.

This announcement technically changes very little, some people think a lot of heavy users are suddenly going to join sky. Those users are probably already there as its been well known for ages that sky have never enforced the FUP anyway so before the announcement people treated it as unlimited anyway.

Fact is sky are a odd one out, they do actually have a proper capacity network to handle its demands, and it would be nice if other isps followed suit. Sky also want and expect people to use heavy bandwidth to download films etc.

---------- Post added at 23:25 ---------- Previous post was at 23:00 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34639323)
and having no competition so you can charge what you like...;)

its funny people see sky as poor because of monopoly tendencies but consider their tv service is superior to VM's and now the broadband is unrivalled in terms of what you can download, BE a close rival but still have the FUP on paper.

One thing you can almost garuantuee from competition is reduced prices, but usually quality of service doesnt come. Which is why the past 2 or 3 years have been horrific with broadband cost cutting everywhere.

Maggy 19-09-2008 00:26

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by eth01 (Post 34639676)
you generally "hate" most things, the reason being because ... ?

Experience!!They were absolutely poo when I was a subscriber and the service was abysmal.Good enough for you?

weemax 19-09-2008 11:17

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham M (Post 34638203)
And it's a very nice price tag, but don't they charge like £70 for activation and if you don't have an active BT line it'll cost you £129 for BT to put one in :|

I did have a dial tone & BT still wanted £124 to "activate me". "Doubt not" i said :)

Hence i am now here...

Fatec 19-09-2008 12:02

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrysalis (Post 34639691)
probably yes. My reasons below.

sky do not have the same costs and financial demands of other isps utilising adsl. They have their own LLU network which is massively cheaper than using BT's network (approx 10% of cost), bear in mind sky customers on sky connect (bt network) are 40 gig limited and shaped.

they have no need to make a profit as the broadband is to keep people subscribed to lucrative tv contracts.

the easynet network even before sky brought it was massive and is the 2nd biggest in the country, bigger than VM's. So sky have a bigger network with a 3rd of the customers, work that one out.

This announcement technically changes very little, some people think a lot of heavy users are suddenly going to join sky. Those users are probably already there as its been well known for ages that sky have never enforced the FUP anyway so before the announcement people treated it as unlimited anyway.

Fact is sky are a odd one out, they do actually have a proper capacity network to handle its demands, and it would be nice if other isps followed suit. Sky also want and expect people to use heavy bandwidth to download films etc.

---------- Post added at 23:25 ---------- Previous post was at 23:00 ----------



its funny people see sky as poor because of monopoly tendencies but consider their tv service is superior to VM's and now the broadband is unrivalled in terms of what you can download, BE a close rival but still have the FUP on paper.

One thing you can almost garuantuee from competition is reduced prices, but usually quality of service doesnt come. Which is why the past 2 or 3 years have been horrific with broadband cost cutting everywhere.

:clap::clap:

Now all we need is UKO to swap over to annex a (which is happening sometime in the future, i believe) and then sky...Make VM look crap (like it is), let the good times roll :)

LondonRoad 19-09-2008 12:19

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Response from VM:

http://www.techradar.com/news/networ...-claims-466936

Ignitionnet 19-09-2008 12:40

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by harmitage (Post 34639822)

The response is predictably laughable.

Actually the entire article is laughable.

Quote:

Sky may well suggest that traffic management is tantamount to limitation, but the Virgin Media spokesman insists that this is in place to protect other users.

"We operate an open and transparent traffic management policy designed to ensure that the majority of customers enjoy a high quality online experience and remain unaffected by a small minority of extremely heavy users," added the spokesperson.
What on earth does why VM employ STM have to do with it being a limited service or not, and who is this so called expert Michael Philips? This would be the 'expert' who doesn't know how ADSL works. He seems to be an expert in offering his opinion on broadband services but I can't see just why he is an 'expert' as in I can't see where he's worked in the industry, but would welcome some more information. He appears to be a guy who happens to be offering his opinion on broadband services right now and previously could have been offering it on toasters, and would probably be better suited sticking to them looking at some of the rubbish he passes off as technical advice: http://www.broadbandchoices.co.uk/wh...tio180208.html

Quote:

"We will never cut off any customer for heavy use, however if their use impacts the service for other customers we will temporarily reduce their download speeds during peak usage periods.
Not true. Whether a person's usage impacts the service for other customers or not both download and upload speeds are reduced, and it's not just during 'peak usage periods' at all.

xspeedyx 19-09-2008 17:04

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
"We operate an open and transparent traffic management policy designed to ensure that the majority of customers enjoy a high quality online experience and remain unaffected by a small minority of extremely heavy users," added the spokesperson.

I must be a extremely user with that 3 gig I downloaded LOL whatever VM

Gary L 19-09-2008 18:01

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by harmitage (Post 34639822)

What a load of rollocks.
Why can't they just admit that yes SKY are truly unlimited and we're not, and the introduction of all these restrictions we impose on our customers will now result in us losing thousands of our customers to SKY who has no limits what so ever.

adrian1971 19-09-2008 18:05

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
and i dont think it will take to long to start loosing customers, especially once the flyers start rolling out in the tv mags and that. and with be testing the 40mb adsl things can only get better......:)

xspeedyx 19-09-2008 19:12

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Sings *Another ISP bites the dust* do do do *Another ISP bites the dust* man I could win xfactor

joglynne 19-09-2008 19:48

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Being a member of this forum can, i feel, give us an unrealistic view of how we think customers will react to this latest statement by a VM representative, and that's if the average customer even sees it.

I have several neighbours and friends who have never realised that STM exists let alone get upset about it. As long as they can do what they want they appear quite satisfied by the service they receive. When I speak to them they are all surprised that I consider there to be any problems with their VM BB. The odd one has commentated about the 'pauses' they experience when watching things but they have just dismissed the problem as being "the way the internet works".

IMOP I doubt whether there will be any mass exodus as I believe that those customers on a TV/BB/Phone package will consider changing suppliers to be too much hassle when what they think are seeing and hearing appears to be just a war of words between competing suppliers.

adrian1971 19-09-2008 20:28

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
i disagree. when you go for a loan you go for the lowest a.p.r, the same can only be said for everything else, its all about value fo money,when i joined vm there were no restrictions, which is why i signed up. now there is restrictions. if knowing they were going to cap your speed in the first place i would have looked around a little more.
i dont know what sky charge or anything but i guessing its somewhere in the same region we paying now,((and vm dont get sky one anymore))
saying that i do think vm still have one of the best bb services around. its just a pitty they cant see that, the bills slowly creep up but they still dont upgrade to keep inline with other isp's

xspeedyx 19-09-2008 20:29

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
I see some heavy downloaders leaving if they get a good speed so they can just hammer the connection like people that left VM for BE as the upload is higher

Griffin 19-09-2008 20:32

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
I think Sky have upped the ante with the new regulations coming in. In theory they will be the only isp who can claim unlimited, as the definition of unlimited is without restriction or limits of any kind. Throttling is after all a form of limitation no matter how you look at it

Hugh 19-09-2008 20:51

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
How can it be unlimited, if it has an upper limit on the speed? ;)

xspeedyx 19-09-2008 21:21

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
This has been said many times before war its best to say they dont mointor your usage and you are able to download as much as you can depent on your speed and they will slow you down by using a cap or traffic management

Gary L 19-09-2008 21:31

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
With the credit crunch we are in now people will think about saving money more than they did before. you have to look at the price you are paying for what you have at the moment and compare it to what is available at the moment.
a lot of people want to hammer their connections without being told they will be punished if they do. SKY will not be punishing this group of people.
some people might even go for SKY's offer because of the way that SKY will market it.

a lot of people might just want to leave Virgin for having STM and SKY doesn't have anything at all.

Hugh 19-09-2008 21:52

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Here's hoping.......

xspeedyx 20-09-2008 00:32

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34640019)
With the credit crunch we are in now people will think about saving money more than they did before. you have to look at the price you are paying for what you have at the moment and compare it to what is available at the moment.
a lot of people want to hammer their connections without being told they will be punished if they do. SKY will not be punishing this group of people.
some people might even go for SKY's offer because of the way that SKY will market it.

a lot of people might just want to leave Virgin for having STM and SKY doesn't have anything at all.

Considering you hate Virgin Media why aint you left Gary?

Gary L 20-09-2008 01:43

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34640114)
Considering you hate Virgin Media why aint you left Gary?

I'm a masochist with a Smart car.

xspeedyx 20-09-2008 12:42

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
ok you wanna type that in english this time

Fatec 20-09-2008 12:44

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34640253)
ok you wanna type that in english this time

*Someone who takes pleasure from recieving pain, who has a nice car.

Gary L 20-09-2008 12:55

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TraxData2 (Post 34640255)
*Someone who takes pleasure from recieving pain, who has a nice car.

Exactly. don't know which part of it confused him so much :D

Maggy 20-09-2008 13:35

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrysalis (Post 34639691)



its funny people see sky as poor because of monopoly tendencies but consider their tv service is superior to VM's

Err no!It's because Sky have the monopoly of more money to outbid for the successful programs from under the noses of their competitors and they do this by charging more for the product..So my sister who loves cricket (strange woman) can never see England play because she can't afford Sky's prices as an OAP.

xspeedyx 20-09-2008 13:38

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34640261)
Exactly. don't know which part of it confused him so much :D


Its been a long day and I have moaning customers is my ear may have been you gary lol :angel:

Ignitionnet 20-09-2008 13:58

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34640278)
Err no!It's because Sky have the monopoly of more money to outbid for the successful programs from under the noses of their competitors and they do this by charging more for the product..So my sister who loves cricket (strange woman) can never see England play because she can't afford Sky's prices as an OAP.

Umm all those programs were until the spat last year available to Virgin Media customers, and Sky Sports is available to any broadcaster that wants it as it's part of the rate card? :confused:

Have you used Sky recently? It's great, it does cool stuff like not taking ages to change channels and has a fast and responsive EPG, you can actually surf the channels without spending about 3 weeks over it. Red button works and is fast doing it, how cool is that?

Virgin's EPG is atrocious, Virgin's STB software is atrocious, you can see where Virgin have been multiplexing streams to cram as much as possible onto the network as picture quality on various channels is noticeably poorer, and I am looking forward to getting back to Sky. About the only thing I'll even consider missing from VM TV is VoD and even that was substandard with pixellation on various programmes and subtitles missing on BBCi.

Anyway that's my opinion, along with my explanation why. Virgin's TV is a poor relation to Sky in every way apart from having VoD in my opinion. Nothing at all to do with cost or where the cricket, which is also available on VMTV, is broadcast. If people didn't pay the prices Sky wouldn't charge them, so while your friend might not be able to afford them, which is unfortunate, clearly on the whole the product does sell at those prices.

EDIT: Incidentally Sky don't even decide what they charge Virgin Media, et al, for Sky Sports and Sky Movies, Ofcom do. Perhaps you should complain to them about the prices.

Maggy 20-09-2008 14:39

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Broadbandings (Post 34640292)
Umm all those programs were until the spat last year available to Virgin Media customers, and Sky Sports is available to any broadcaster that wants it as it's part of the rate card? :confused:

Have you used Sky recently? It's great, it does cool stuff like not taking ages to change channels and has a fast and responsive EPG, you can actually surf the channels without spending about 3 weeks over it. Red button works and is fast doing it, how cool is that?

Virgin's EPG is atrocious, Virgin's STB software is atrocious, you can see where Virgin have been multiplexing streams to cram as much as possible onto the network as picture quality on various channels is noticeably poorer, and I am looking forward to getting back to Sky. About the only thing I'll even consider missing from VM TV is VoD and even that was substandard with pixellation on various programmes and subtitles missing on BBCi.

Anyway that's my opinion, along with my explanation why. Virgin's TV is a poor relation to Sky in every way apart from having VoD in my opinion. Nothing at all to do with cost or where the cricket, which is also available on VMTV, is broadcast. If people didn't pay the prices Sky wouldn't charge them, so while your friend might not be able to afford them, which is unfortunate, clearly on the whole the product does sell at those prices.

EDIT: Incidentally Sky don't even decide what they charge Virgin Media, et al, for Sky Sports and Sky Movies, Ofcom do. Perhaps you should complain to them about the prices.

My 'friend' is my sister and our beef as is everyone elses that the supporters of the English cricket team that can't afford to pay Sky's prices were cheated by the system that originally allowed English Cricket to be shown on the available 'FREE' channels until Sky outbid the BBC and others for the rights...This is the danger of a monopoly.

Anyway why would my sister complain to VM?They are not available in Newcastle.:rolleyes: It's Sky for the cricket or it's no one.

Ignitionnet 20-09-2008 15:42

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
No-one held a gun to the ECB's head and told them to sell to Sky, they chose to sell to them to make maximum profit.

Is it worth mentioning that the BBC didn't even bid for the TV rights?

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2008...ortsrights.bbc

Quote:

"The BBC is astonished at the comments from the ECB," said a spokeswoman for BBC Sport.

"We have always said that any bid for live test cricket is subject to value for money and ability to schedule. In our view neither of these criteria were met," she added.

"We have consistently argued that not having cricket as a listed event puts it out of reach of all terrestrial broadcasters. This is the ECB's choice and they are entitled to it. It is absurd to blame the BBC for this outcome."
Also VM are available in Newcastle, or parts of it anyway, ex-Telewest.

Maggy 20-09-2008 15:44

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Broadbandings (Post 34640322)
No-one held a gun to the ECB's head and told them to sell to Sky, they chose to sell to them to make maximum profit.

Is it worth mentioning that the BBC didn't even bid for the TV rights?

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2008...ortsrights.bbc



Also VM are available in Newcastle, or parts of it anyway, ex-Telewest.

Well obviously not for my sister who would love to be able to have cable broadband...

Ignitionnet 20-09-2008 15:50

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quite.

Chrysalis 22-09-2008 16:16

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TraxData2 (Post 34639816)
:clap::clap:

Now all we need is UKO to swap over to annex a (which is happening sometime in the future, i believe) and then sky...Make VM look crap (like it is), let the good times roll :)

I guess you mean annex M :)

yeah I agree ukonline will have it in a matter of time, possibly followed by sky.

---------- Post added at 15:11 ---------- Previous post was at 15:07 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Broadbandings (Post 34639825)
The response is predictably laughable.

Actually the entire article is laughable.



heh I wonder whos payroll this guy is on.

Quote:

A leading expert in UK broadband has told Techradar that he feels Sky's claim of being the first major 'unlimited' package provider is rhetoric.

"Obviously we welcome any removal of small print, but there is still one 'get out of jail card' among all the public relations rhetoric," said Michael Phillips of BroadbandChoices.co.uk.

"Sky still says that any excessive behaviour – and they give the example of someone using his account to send spam mail – could lead to them being suspended from the network.

"So there is still something in place to protect the network. I think all the ISPs are playing semantics here with the 'unlimited' claims.

"I don't feel that Sky are offering anything more than the likes of Be or O2 have been offering for a while now."
Suspended for sending spam is nothing to do with bandwidth limits thats just internet abuse. He picked out the names of BE and O2 who havent enforced FUP's but he fails to mention BT,VM and a a few other isps do enforce FUP's and so sky is different, of course sky is the only isp to not have a FUP alongside its unlimited so this expert is not such an expert at all.

---------- Post added at 15:16 ---------- Previous post was at 15:11 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 34640008)
How can it be unlimited, if it has an upper limit on the speed? ;)

it can when the speed is defined.

unlimited up to 8meg for example means unlimited except for the speed.

unlimited subject to FUP technically is the same but many isps have the FUP hidden and in small print, alongside undisclosed traffic shaping. Far more worse.

The difference between them is on the former, you can have the line worked 24/7 with no consequence, the latter the isp on its end throttles you back and may send you a heavy use letter breaching a hidden FUP limit.

Fatec 22-09-2008 16:19

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrysalis (Post 34641092)
I guess you mean annex M :)

Oops, i should of corrected that :dunce:

Quote:

yeah I agree ukonline will have it in a matter of time, possibly followed by sky.
From what i know they are trialing it, though not all areas currently support it.

Must ask Dan how it's coming along ;)

Chrysalis 22-09-2008 16:20

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34640278)
Err no!It's because Sky have the monopoly of more money to outbid for the successful programs from under the noses of their competitors and they do this by charging more for the product..So my sister who loves cricket (strange woman) can never see England play because she can't afford Sky's prices as an OAP.

Everytime I have rang sky saying I have to downgrade due to financial reasons they discount my bill, they are understanding in that respect. I dont ring every month doing that as would be abusive only if I genuinly need to make the cutback, the discounts tend to last 3-6 months tho. End of the day it is a commercial product sky have the right to charge what they wish, sky's tv service is better overall (exception signal during extreme weather), me as a customer dont care how they get there just the fact its better. Of course sky invest billions into their tv programming, I expect many times more than VM's budget. Meanwhile good old ntl/VM who refuse to invest upgrading my analogue area to digital, charge more for less channels that have no interactivity.

xspeedyx 22-09-2008 16:20

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
The only problem I can see from this is if alot of users start hammering the connection and cause congestion but as Sky said there will be no congestion

Fatec 22-09-2008 16:21

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34641098)
The only problem I can see from this is if alot of users start hammering the connection and cause congestion but as Sky said there will be no congestion

Wont matter, easynets network is HUGE.

Can hammer it 24/7, wouldnt matter.

Chrysalis 22-09-2008 16:23

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34640306)
My 'friend' is my sister and our beef as is everyone elses that the supporters of the English cricket team that can't afford to pay Sky's prices were cheated by the system that originally allowed English Cricket to be shown on the available 'FREE' channels until Sky outbid the BBC and others for the rights...This is the danger of a monopoly.

Anyway why would my sister complain to VM?They are not available in Newcastle.:rolleyes: It's Sky for the cricket or it's no one.

some would argue the bbc had a effective monopoly, with their superior funding via tax. As setanta have shown sky can be outbid if someone is prepared to do so.

Maggy 22-09-2008 16:28

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrysalis (Post 34641102)
some would argue the bbc had a effective monopoly, with their superior funding via tax. As setanta have shown sky can be outbid if someone is prepared to do so.

Even with their funding they cannot compete with Sky's coffers..mainly because they cannot wantonly throw away the money they get from you and me without finding that their funding will be cut drastically for misuse...

Anyway this is getting well away from the topic now..I would suggest starting a separate thread about these issues except we have already seen enough of them become extremely contentious in the past.;)

Chris 22-09-2008 16:29

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Topic, please. ;)

Feel free to start another thread about the ECB's comments over the weekend, though, I think they deserve an airing, and some scrutiny. :)

xspeedyx 22-09-2008 19:56

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TraxData2 (Post 34641099)
Wont matter, easynets network is HUGE.

Can hammer it 24/7, wouldnt matter.

So easynets network could handle few hundred thousands customer downloading @ 2mb - 16mb full whack 24/7 dont really think so

Ignitionnet 24-09-2008 11:10

Re: Sky Remove Fair Use Policy From Max Broadband
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by darthlinux (Post 34641194)
So easynets network could handle few hundred thousands customer downloading @ 2mb - 16mb full whack 24/7 dont really think so

Quick reminder that unlike cable Sky have no per node limits but per exchange, so doesn't take 2 customers on the top tier to saturate an area.

The routers that Sky use in the core can route 92Tbit/s fully loaded, the transmission network is 80 wavelength DWDM so has a present capacity of 3.2Tbit/s per fibre, and each exchange can be backhauled with multiple 10Gbit/s ethernet if need be going into 40Gbit/slot routers which then go into the 92Tbit / chassis core routers.

All of this apart from the fibre network is scaleable. If an exchange runs out of bandwidth add a new 10GbE backhaul and/or switch, add a new line card and/or router further down the chain, and the fibre network will be in big bundles so is likewise a non-issue.

So if the money's there Sky can do pretty much whatever they want to.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:12.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum