![]() |
Multiple abortions
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7306246.stm
Apparently some 30 teenage girls a week are attending clinics for their 2nd or even 3rd abortions :shocked: Surely this somewhat flies in the face of persistent claims by certain pressure groups that abortions aren't being used as a method of contraception and are always taken seriously by women. |
Re: Multiple abortions
yeah we all believed that didnt we
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
It states The statistics, for 2006, showed nearly 15,000 women were having their third or more abortion, while 54 of those had terminated eight or more pregnancies and And of the 54 who had had eight or more abortions, 21 of them were under the age of 30. In fact, the last but one paragraphs state She said the figures suggested that most women having repeat abortions fell pregnant as "a result of contraceptive failure", having "completed their family, rather than any recklessness". "The longer you are sexually active, the more likely you are to have an unwanted pregnancy or experience contraceptive failure." |
Re: Multiple abortions
Exactly, the pill, condoms, coil, injection, implant, even vasectomies can still result in pregnancies.
Interesting how the BBC portrayed the statistics regarding the 54 with 8 or more, rather than stating, as suggested by the quote, that 33 were over 30 years old (ie the majority), they try to put it into the reader's mind the idea that they're being used through recklessness by suggesting youngsters are using it so often, leaving the reader (who's generally lazy) to do the maths. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Demand for abortion is higher in countries with poor sex education and an unhealthy attitude to sexual activity in the young. Try focusing attention on fixing those. |
Re: Multiple abortions
I will get flamed for this but I personally think abortion for any other reason than severe handicapped is tantamount to murder . Abortion for choice imo is just wrong .
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Youngsters around here seem to be very reluctant to have abortions. The 80's phase of teenagers getting pregnant, being a meal ticket passed but now we seem to be going full circle again. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
If we can create them courtesy of a couple of Creamfield tickets or similar,surely we can terminate them just as easily? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Personally I believe abortion is fine if the parents either cant or are not willing to bring the child up. A child with parents that dont want it is more likely (note: not guarenteed) to become a drain on society in one way or another and this world is overpopulated enough as it is. Now I'm wondering whether I'll get flamed. :shocked: Now wheres that flame retardent suit.:D |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
---------- Post added at 20:03 ---------- Previous post was at 20:00 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I'm glad I'm not the one having to come up with the law to make that distinction. |
Re: Multiple abortions
well I know for a fact they still terminate after a foetus is viable. A friend of my ex wife gave birth at 22 weeks and the child survived at that time they still terminated at 24 weeks. I do not know if thats still the case
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I certainly wouldn't leave him to look after a child.:td: |
Re: Multiple abortions
But the birth of this child could turn the girls life around pull her out of her rut and make her a good life. The child could cure cancer or similar for all we know or even help to bring world peace. All that potential could be squatted out by a simple choice. Of course none of that could happen but the point is if the child is killed before it can even be born then its then capable of nothing
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I would lay a fair amount of cash on this guy leaving her within 3 months of the child being born. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Then he will be out of the picture and all the potential is there
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
My own view on abortion is that it's sadly necessary in certain circumstances as already alluded to by others. Quite why, though, in this day and age so many women should need multiple abortions is beyond me. Of course contraceptive failure is a factor but what do they mean by that? A split condom (hardly anyone's fault) or a lack of discipline to take the pill regularly whilst being sexually active (a trifle neglient). In the former case nobody is to blame, not so in the latter in which case any subsequent abortion is surely akin to being a form of contraception of last resort. BBKing - Groups like these: Marie Stopes International, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS), Brook Advisory Services who don't ever seem to come out openly and acknowledge the misuse of abortion in just the same way as anti-abortion groups seem always to deny the genuine grounds for abortion. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
On the other hand she is an attractive and fairly bright teenager, who could meet a guy who wants to work for a living, not scrounge on benefits, sell drugs or steal to feed his drug habit. If she met such a decent person, a child concieved would be likely to have a much better start in life and not turn out like the **** future father she is now with. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Hell man least it will be a few quid that isnt going from your taxes to funding warfare
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Quote:
If your ex-wife's friend's baby is perfectly healthy, then fantastic, she managed to beat the odds, just don't try using her as an argument to suggest that because her baby was ok at 22 weeks, most babies will be. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Update I've just found this which quotes the source: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main...bortion120.xml and this by chance (from 2004): http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main...ixnewstop.html Which doesn't say much for the BPAS's ethics at that time. and this: http://www.prochoiceforum.org.uk/comm65.asp "Nevertheless, today abortion is an essential method of family planning and should be accepted it as such." |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
17 out of every 100 abortions performed at 23 weeks could have survived .... MURDER 39 out of every 100 abortions performed at 24 weeks could have survived .... MURDER Possibly 10 % estimated at your statistics would have suffered no disability so thats 4 or 5 out of every 200 abortions performed at 23 or 24 weeks would have survived with no problems tell me thats not MURDER Tell me this if I was to kill you just 1 person with no physical or mental problem (apart from acute left wing disease ;)) could I possibly get away without a MURDER charge???? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
how right you are zing.:clap::clap: |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I laugh at you calling a staunch Tory supporter "acute left wing" by the way. Have you ever had an abortion Zing? Ever found out that your partner aborted your child? |
Re: Multiple abortions
You say all but 1 so your saying its ok to kill that 1. ffs man 1 is to many 1 in 1.000.000 would be to many
No I have never been involved in abortion but I have a wonderful daughter who keeps me sane here and I have a nearly 4 year old who I have never seen due to relationship issues with her mother however I certainly would rather know she is alive than dead. Have you been involved in abortion? if so is your conscience clear or does it not plague you some nights do you never wake up in a cold sweat thinking about holding that baby nurturing her/him seeing it grow develop its first steps first words??? all quashed cuz maybe you or your partner thought " im not ready"?? Life is the most precious thing you can give to take a human life appalls me and I see a foetus as a life no matter what science you argue. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Does it plague you when you fap one off into a kleenex, or when your partner has her period? Do you wake during the night in a cold sweat wondering what if you hadn't decided not to get pregnant, that stain on the bedsheets would have grown up into a human being, but you chose to prevent that from happened? |
Re: Multiple abortions
what a crock mate well you obviously made your choice between you well done
BTW I have not had a partner for over a year and sperm does not live that long so your little analogy is cow poop. You obvious dipped your wick whether you were one of the unlucky 1% or you didnt take precautions you obviously wasn't "ready" to take responsibility for your actions and decided to just flush it |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
People don't seem to remember that adoption is another viable option. There so many people who can't have children of their own who would be over the moon to adopt a baby.
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
oh look so there is some emotional response to the circumstances you are human afterall ---------- Post added at 09:07 ---------- Previous post was at 09:05 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
It is not easy carrying a baby to term, then breaking the mother/child bond. People don't seem to remember that abortion isn't easy either, it's not a case of "Oh shucks, I'm preggers, oh well, out with the dyson" ---------- Post added at 09:08 ---------- Previous post was at 09:08 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
2 Im a bigot im judgemental and I voice my view how different are we? ;) |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Quote:
We are very different, I'd never come out with the crap you do. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Her family sat down and discussed it sensibly with her and let her make the decision, and she decided that the child should be put up for adoption. She went to hospital to give birth and it was agreed the child would be taken straight away from her. All went well until a do-gooder nurse decided to take the baby to the mother, the bond could then not be broken and she kept the child. All turned out well, but she had a difficult time and had to be supported by her family. I still think the bottom line is that children are optional, and no one should conceive a child if they are not able to support it. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
You call me ignorant but I know enough to know a lot of pregnacies are terminated by pure choice with no other reason other than "im not ready" what happened to you could be different I am ignorant to them facts I just grouped you with the odds if im wrong I apoligise if im not then I dont Just because im pro life does not make my view crap btw it just makes it different to yours |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
My aunt fell pregnant in the 60's and it turned out her partner was married. There was no way she could have brought up her son on her own, so gave him up for adoption. Are you saying that she had no mother/son bond? Of course she did, but she knew he'd more chance of a better life if he was adopted. Thankfully he did, unfortunately many babies given up for adoption grow up in childrens homes and many of them never recover psycholigically. So please, think before you next post. |
Re: Multiple abortions
I am adopted and frequently thank my lucky stars that my "birth mother" did not just decide to have an abortion.
I understand it wouldn't be easy to carry to full term and then give the child away but if the person is not ready to raise a child themselves it should at least be considered, in this day and age I don't think that it is. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Most of us accept why abortion is sometimes sadly necessary even in a first world country with universal access to free contraception however it's still important to ask just why so many abortions are required when it's clear that only a proportion are due to genuine contraceptive failure. I quoted the last paragraph simply because it related directly to the point of this thread and, contrary to what some people still claim, confirms the view of certain groups/people out there view abortion as just another acceptable form of contraception. So far nobody has been able to explain why despite the availability of highly effective methods of contraception so many young women seem to get pregnant more than once and then have abortions risking their own long term health, wellbeing and even fertility by so doing. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
"Highly effective" is not 100%, condoms break, or slip off. The pill isn't always effective, the morning after pills don't always work, even vasectomies can result in pregnancies. As for their health, did you actually read the page you linked to? Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I've already alluded to the fact that contraception isn't foolproof more than once but but how many time is a teenage girl going to be the victim of a split condom, failed pill etc. as compared to the number who are simply just careless, don't fully appreciate the repercussions of what they're doing and then opt for an abortion possibly even not really understanding at the outset what's involved in that? The issue is why are so many young women particualry having repeat abortions. It can't all be down to genuine contraceptive failure so in those cases where it isn't, surely the abortion process can be said to be being used as just another form of contraception. Frankly I'd rather live in a society in which abortion is only used as a method of last resort NOT an alternative for those who've been careless or even negligent. That having been said, I don't expect it's ever going to be possible. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Given how traumatic the abortion process can be (many women find just going to a gynocologist traumatic), do you really think women would prefer to go through that more than once rather than take a pill each day or use a condom? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Also at least the children you mentioned had a chance of life instead of having that chance taken away. Who has the right to choose life or death? you me? the law I dont think so Why do you not line up these children and shoot them it amounts to the same thing |
Re: Multiple abortions
I've never met anyone with the attitude of "Oh well, I can always get an abortion"
---------- Post added at 10:51 ---------- Previous post was at 10:49 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
However, the substantive point that abortion is the extreme end of a spectrum of family planning mechanisms is perfectly valid from a technical standpoint (in terms of stopping people having babies), so if you really want to reduce abortions, increase the effectiveness of the others, by making them more freely available, having better education, research etc. Importing US anti-abortion drivel will have precisely the opposite effect, since it stems entirely from theologically-driven considerations where male control over female sexuality is the ultimate driver, rather than rational considerations of public health and, being an ideology, has substantial fundamental problems when applied to the real world. Just say no. By the way, anyone quoting 'Mad' Nadine Dorries MP is automatically deemed to have lost the argument, by the way - this is highly humorous: http://www.septicisle.info/2008/03/w...myth-when.html This is the calibre of person we're dealing with here. Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Im certainly not saying I hate people who have abortions. I disagree with their stance on the the subject and I certainly feel if a man and a woman have consensual sex and do not take precautions then then should stand by there choice instead of cop out and have an abortion. Sexual morality is not a bad thing imo. I do not truly know what to think on the subject of rape victims falling pregnant I do understand the wish to get it out of her body and if it happened to a partner of mine I would support her wish even though id be unsure about how I truly felt. The same would be said for the severly disabled. But I will never agree thats its right for a healthy woman to give up a healthy baby for choice
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Some forms of contraception* prevent the implantation of a fertilised egg. This is, in effect, a very early termination of pregnancy. Do you also disagree with this? * coil, morning-after pill |
Re: Multiple abortions
Once the egg is fertilized its lifespan would lead to a human if it is allowed to continue so I am against it
The other point of course is if your not in a long term relationship with someone you can trust they do nothing to prevent STIs Sexual morality imo is at an all time low. People go out meet in a pub or club and sleep together that night . Some do not take precautions this is just plain wrong |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Sexual morality is very low on my list of priorities when I am not in a serious relationship. when I was not in a serious relationship I would go out most weekends and pick up a woman, I always used condoms and on one occasion I actually walked away from a woman. I had consumed alcohol and offered to take her home but still had the sense to walk away because the condom machine was empty. Abortion should be dealt with on an individual basis, there's no right or wrong decision. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I used the term 'some people' because in addition to groups like those I referred to there are no doubt others who are in denial about how some people misuse abortion either because they're plain stupid or because it doesn't suit their argument to accept the fact. As for those arguing against abortion per se (who you haven't identifed in your post BTW) - please don't include me in their numbers. I've made it quite clear where I stand and I think what's required is to get to the root of why, despite all the advice, contraception etc. freely available out there, so many people are having multiple abortions. * awaiting your exhaustive list of hate filled anti abortion groups :rolleyes: (not that it will add to your point). ---------- Post added at 13:39 ---------- Previous post was at 13:16 ---------- Quote:
I suspect that if you asked some of these young women if they think like that about abortion when they're in a more reflective mood they'd confirm what you're saying. However, if you did so after, for example, they'd been binge drinking all evening you'd probably get a very different answer. You'd also get a different answer from those who knew the risks and went ahead with unprotected sex on the basis that pregnancy simply wouldn't happen to them or who were pressurised into it by their peers and/or partners. The people I'm referring to and worried about are not those sensible women who make a reasoned choice in difficult circumstances but those who get themselves into the situation through one mistake or another and then have to resort to abortion, all too often more than once. I'd really rather they never got into that sad position once let alone several times and being in denial about the existence of this proportion of women isn't doing anything to help them. |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I know that in an ideal world we would all use contraception, which would work 100% of the time. Sadly, this world is not perfect. People sometimes don't use contraception, or it fails (my friend's baby was concieved thanks largely to a split condom). And yes, I know that family or friends should help, but not everyone is lucky enough to have a family or friends that are willing (or able) to do that. I don't believe abortion is an easy option. Nor do I believe it should be. However, I do believe in some cases, it is a lot easier than the alternative. I also think that we (as a society) need to look at ways we can help women who feel they need to have abortions rather than judging them when they have them. However, if someone is having multiple abortions without medical reasons, then we need to ask why. ---------- Post added at 13:42 ---------- Previous post was at 13:33 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Another question is which is preferable; women having multiple abortions in registered and regulated clinics, or returning to gin and coathangers? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
How many women lost their lives in the 40s, 50s or 60s because of illegal abortions? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
But that depends of the definition of poor . We have social security and housing benefits yes people still struggle but its not like some places in the world. And besides rightly or wrongly a poor woman giving birth gets housed and funded so they do not have to struggle to much so the life for the child I would be say is worth living well anythings better than being dead pretty much for the majority
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Ouch man I feel you trying to force words into my mouth
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Given that people are inherently not responsible, if you are to be believed that multiple abortions are being performed not (as those involved report) on people who are using contraception already, but as a form of primary contraception by women who can't be bothered to use the pill or condoms, then should the responsibility be taken out of their irresponsible hands? Or how can we make them more responsible? (an ideal solution I agree) ---------- Post added at 16:41 ---------- Previous post was at 16:38 ---------- Quote:
Or put a block of wood, about an inch thick inside the right shoe of every man. It'll make them limp you see ;) |
Re: Multiple abortions
Maybe a fine for abortions above 1 . Then if they end up doing themselves an injury with back street abortions or home made ones then afaik tough they should have kept their legs closed
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
I think that one thing the government and/or media could do is increase the amount of coverage the subject gets on TV. Hell, the best programmes on TV covering sex education (in fact the only long running ones), ITV's "The Good Sex Guide" and "The Good Sex Guide Late" got cancelled after a couple of years. AIDS hasn't gone away, but if you looked at the media coverage it (and other STDs) get in this country, you could be forgiven for thinking it has. |
Re: Multiple abortions
At the end of the day people are responsible for their actions and they should be made to take said responsibility. A child is the greatest gift a woman can be given and the love of children is second to none. I have conceded certain cases where abortion is understandable but I will stand by the abortion for choice as being wrong till the bitter end no matter what
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
By they way (off topic, but it is a holiday weekend..) 1. I like your new quotation! 2. My Russian is as good as my Cyrillic - what does your avatar mean? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
I conceded rape later on as for incest well we are all mutants anyway ;)
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Personally, the thought of a scared woman sticking a wire coathanger up herself in the bath doing unknown damage simply because of people with views like yourself Zing, is completely appauling. Not to mention that some of the damage could lead to guarenteed miscarriages (so more children dying) in the future. |
Re: Multiple abortions
I do not care what you think about me and my views and your not going to change my mind .
If you do not look and take precations when crossing the road and you get hit then its tough titties Stop, Look, Listen Stop, Think, Wear a nodder |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Down to poundstretcher for a coathanger and a bottle of gin? |
Re: Multiple abortions
Then your in the unlucky 1%
Unless of course you actually think all these unwanted pregnancies are down to inefficient contraceptive and not just some slapper woman screwing a slapper bloke after a night on the beer and not giving a toss about the consequences cuz they can just arrange a clinic visit Chin chan china man walking down the strand for a joke have a poke feeling very gland. Chin chan china man couldn't give a rap 6 days later clap clap clap |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
well come back with the facts of these women actually saying the precations didnt work and ill answer that
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Lets come back a yard and allow me to challenge your bull plop..
33 out if 54 who had 8 pregnancies were over 30 ok the report actually states nearly 15,000 women had had over 3 During that year women seeking terminations were most likely to have fallen into the 18-to-24 age category. So please where is this most are over 30 crap coming from??? Bare in mind these are incomplete figues as it only covers 3 + terminations so you could double or triple the figures or higher so 100,000 terminations. The labour mp you quote doesnt make sense. She states "This is especially true for women over the age of 25 who don't have specialist services in the way teenagers and young women do." She said the figures suggested that most women having repeat abortions fell pregnant as "a result of contraceptive failure", having "completed their family, rather than any recklessness". But the other figures show most terminations fall in the under 25 range |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
How does women having repeat abortions after contraception has failed them once they've completed their families not make sense to you? It's relatively easy. When mummy and daddy have the children they want, they often don't stop making love (I know in some relationships that happens which causes divorce etc especially if mummy isn't getting what she wants from daddy) but they don't want to have more kids. So they use Mr Contraceptive who helps stop mummy getting pregnant. Unfortunately, Mr Contraceptive isn't 100%, and so if you use him lots and lots you increase the chance of him letting you down. Simple really. |
Re: Multiple abortions
or using the wrong contraceptive maybe after a few goes at the clinic they may have learned what they are using isnt working
I wouldnt say super slappers but I may think they are stupid ---------- Post added at 20:21 ---------- Previous post was at 20:19 ---------- Also the labour mp says these women have completed their familys . Have they not heard of sterilisation? You gonna come back now and say well that can go wrong as it can but still not that often |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
Therefore sterilisation is not an option. If a contraceptive is 99% successful, and you have sex 600 times a year, that's 6 times it failed. Do that over 30 years and that's 180 failures. How exactly is someone stupid for that? |
Re: Multiple abortions
errrrr dude that would require every time it failed to be at the exact right time for fertilisation to result in a pregnancy please stop throwing bull crap figures at me in a lame attempt to dismiss me
---------- Post added at 23:06 ---------- Previous post was at 22:58 ---------- Quote:
Nothing you do or say is going to make me say your right as im sure nothing I do say will convince you I see no point in further debate with you on this subject |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
8 out of 180 is a pretty small number. Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
As I said I see no further reason to debate this with you any longer please feel free to quote me again so you can have the final say on the matter with me I do not mind ---------- Post added at 23:18 ---------- Previous post was at 23:17 ---------- Quote:
That will be Mr X giving it the large as normal ;) |
Re: Multiple abortions
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT. The time now is 18:04. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum