Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   ID cards rethink to be unveiled (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33629520)

Sirius 06-03-2008 09:39

ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
So the Government has decided to put even more data at risk and package it in a small easy to lose device. No doubt the Lib Dems will sit on the fence over this one as well, Lets face it just like Europe this is important enough to require a vote in the house.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7280495.stm

Problem with the unelected pretender Brown is that he says one thing and then does the opposite. Therefor the fact he hinted this

Quote:

Prime Minister Gordon Brown hinted earlier this year that the scheme may not be compulsory for UK nationals but suggestions of a U-turn were denied.
Does not fill me with a warm feeling of trust :LOL:

Mick Fisher 06-03-2008 09:54

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Yet more privacy intrusion, where will it end, perhaps getting rid of this DUD government will be start.

As a lifelong socialist it hurts me to say it. But then again 'New Labour' has never been the 'Real Deal' has it.

If only there was a realistic alternative that looked to be, even slightly, worth voting for. :rolleyes:

Osem 06-03-2008 10:14

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Rumour has it that Bliar and his cohorts originally gained their inspiration for New Labour from the 'Invasion of the Body Snatchers".... :D

BBKing 06-03-2008 10:32

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

No doubt the Lib Dems will sit on the fence over this one as well
What are you bloody on about, the Lib Dems have been at the forefront of the campaign against ID cards from the start!

http://www.libdems.org.uk/noidcards/

Anyway, I've always been of the view that the ID cards plan was unworkable, so it's nice to see it being chipped away at. My Get An Irish Passport plan is looking good...

Osem 06-03-2008 10:36

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501198)
...the Lib Dems have been at the forefront of the campaign against ID cards from the start!

http://www.libdems.org.uk/noidcards/

Only because they weren't sure which of their ID's they should use in their application..... :D

BBKing 06-03-2008 10:38

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Is that an attempt to make the party look bigger, two IDs per MP?

Osem 06-03-2008 10:43

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501207)
two IDs per MP?

Some say the Lib-Dems have more ID's than that.... I couldn't comment :D

BBKing 06-03-2008 11:13

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Leafing through this proposal, it seems that if you renew your British passport post-2011 you'll have trot along to one of their enrollment centres for the biometric wossnames. I think I'll be renewing my passport a bit before that, or just getting the Irish one. Not sure how they're going to force ID card enrollment on those people who don't need a UK passport but aren't foreigners, baggage handlers etc. I suspect a staged series of attempts to make life impossible without one, unless you're rich or a criminal*.

* Neither of whom need to get a job or a bank account, one suspects.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 12:01

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
An Irish passport? Now there's an idea BB, get the passport, wait for the BNP to come into power, claim your £50K and leave the country, then come back once the country has become bankrupt and live like a King off the money you made :D

BBKing 06-03-2008 13:11

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
I might exercise my right of return to Israel if the BNP come to power. Seek political asylum there for a more peaceful life. Of course, the BNP like the nice Aryan Irish* but not the dirty foreign Jews. Still, no one said Nazi wannabes have to make sense.

* who count as 'indigenous British', for some reason. Not sure the Irish see it that way, they've spent several centuries fighting not to be considered British, after all.

Osem 06-03-2008 13:38

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501288)
Still, no one said Nazi wannabes have to make sense.

....and what a sad indictment of the political situation in Britain it is that a growing number of people are considering voting for them!

BBKing 06-03-2008 14:07

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Growing number of morons, more like. 'I'm unrepresented in British politics and I feel my country is no longer my own, so I'm going to vote for idiots with a track record in failing to represent their constituents and a foreign political ideology so completely alien to British history and values that we spent five years and hundreds of thousands of lives fighting it tooth and nail'. Yeah, great idea. Big up the white working class.

Osem 06-03-2008 14:14

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501355)
Growing number of morons, more like. 'I'm unrepresented in British politics and I feel my country is no longer my own, so I'm going to vote for idiots with a track record in failing to represent their constituents and a foreign political ideology so completely alien to British history and values that we spent five years and hundreds of thousands of lives fighting it tooth and nail'. Yeah, great idea. Big up the white working class.

You can call them what you like - morons would certainly make up a fair proportion and that'd count for the electorate at any election I'm sure, but then there'll also be those who will vote BNP so simply to make a point to the other parties.

RizzyKing 06-03-2008 14:35

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
While i am no fan of the BNP i think it is a **** party pure and simple calling all it's supporters moron's may be playing into their hands. While they might not be the brightest bulb in the room they do attract people that are disenfranchised much like the nazi party in the 1930's and for that reason we should see them as a threat.

As for ID cards yes of course go for it i mean the last few months have been so kind to the government and it's data storage pracices i would have no problem having everything in one neat tidy and easy to lose package :rolleyes:.

Osem 06-03-2008 14:37

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 34501380)
As for ID cards yes of course go for it i mean the last few months have been so kind to the government and it's data storage pracices i would have no problem having everything in one neat tidy and easy to lose package :rolleyes:.

Yeah you really couldn't make it up could you? :mad:

RizzyKing 06-03-2008 14:43

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Stupid thing is i used to support the ID card idea but after the last few months how can any sane person be happy with the thought of it. Only this government with it's complete arrogance and disregard for the british public could even think about carrying on with the scheme. Yeah so glad GB took over cause since then i really has changed and i think we do stand a real chance of getting rid of these moron's posthaste.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 15:23

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
ID cards could be introduced to be useful in day to day life, secure and therefore help tackle certain crimes etc.
Unfortunately, the first step towards this needs to be showing that you're a responsible and trustworthy government with a track record of ensuring what is planned is actually delivered, and of course Labour have fallen at this first hurdle.

jkat 06-03-2008 16:05

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
what happens when we are made to carry id cards at all times, this is what worries me??:erm:

RizzyKing 06-03-2008 16:14

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
In principle i have no major problem with the idea of an ID card and having to carry it all the time wouldn't bother me either. But until we have a government that has shown a lot more competency then this one at holding onto data securely then i am not prepared to support an ID card. Labour only has itself to blame for this and it can't even harp back to the previous administration that still gets trotted out now and then.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 16:18

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jkat (Post 34501446)
what happens when we are made to carry id cards at all times, this is what worries me??:erm:

The way to do it is to make them voluntary, but make them so useful everyone would want one.

Imagine a single card, used for driving license, passport, debit/credit card (you pop it in the machine, it asks you which account you want to use, then for 4 digits from a 6 or 8 digit pin number), store loyalty card etc.

BBKing 06-03-2008 16:33

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
OK, Xac, I'm imagining that. Now I'm imagining someone nicking it...

Quote:

having to carry it all the time wouldn't bother me either
Would it bother you that the police now have to spend their time investigating law abiding citizens to make sure they have their papers in order, instead of, say, preventing and investigating crime?

Anyway, I ain't carrying no ID card. What Jacqui Smith has said today pretty much rules out the idea of much of the population having one until life is made sufficiently intolerable. Happy at the idea of our tax money paying for Home Office bureaucrats to make our life intolerable until we pay them for a piece of plastic? I'm bloody not.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 17:06

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501471)
OK, Xac, I'm imagining that. Now I'm imagining someone nicking it...

Ok, so they have a card with your name on it, and your photo, just like a photo driving license.

If you're thinking access to your credit cards etc, even if they watched over your shoulder, they'd have to do so for several transactions to get your full pin number.
Add biometrics to the mix, such as what they have at Ben Gurin airport, and not only would they need your card and your pin, but also your hand.
Change the pin for a word and only ask for a few leters, and you're even less likely to have it broken.

Compare that with what people have today.
A wallet, with all those cards, which can easily be copied and used as there are no secure back end checks.

Are you saying you'd prefer what amounts to a single low security device (wallet full of low security cards) to protect your finances than one high security device?

Remember, I'm not talking about the proposed ID scheme, after all that thing will have more holes in it than swiss cheese, but a properly planned and executed ID card scheme.

Hom3r 06-03-2008 17:10

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
I'll be getting one then!

I will come under airport worker

Osem 06-03-2008 17:11

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501471)
Would it bother you that the police now have to spend their time investigating law abiding citizens to make sure they have their papers in order, instead of, say, preventing ... crime?

I digress but do they do much of that anymore? I thought modern policing was more about meeting targets for 'solving' crimes committed than actually deterring people from offending in the first place...

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 17:14

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501421)
ID cards could be introduced to be useful in day to day life, secure and therefore help tackle certain crimes etc.
Unfortunately, the first step towards this needs to be showing that you're a responsible and trustworthy government with a track record of ensuring what is planned is actually delivered, and of course Labour have fallen at this first hurdle.

well you certainly swallowed the propaganda beautifully.

Let me explain something. Not only are they putting fingerprinting machines in schools and CCTV in the Toilets to prepare kids for the global police state were moving into So that when they grow older they will just see them things as the norm as they get introduced into society.

They are also using these i.d cards as a stepping stone to introduce control over all the products you buy n purchase. Crime is the most dumbest thing people talk about when it comes to i.d cards.

Even einstien said, peace does not come about through force, thats a dictatorship it comes through peace.

Any crime commited is only because of the mind state of the person and how ever u want to act like its there fault most people i know who have commited crimes grew out of it when they realised there was more to life, but the lack of what was happening was being put into reality with no understanding of how to make real money other than slave labour and us youngers are wise to that. We arent willing to waste our lives away in a dead end coorporation job for a **** bag company to make millions off us while paying us 6 pound an hour. Never gonna get anywhere and thats realistic hence i do business.

The point is These i.d cards are the beginning of the global control next stage is the microchips. They will give you an excuse to introduce everything.

and you'll just accept it because they use the words "security, criminals" in the same sentance. Stop accepting the propaganda and review history repeating itself.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 17:16

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501505)
well you certainly swallowed the propaganda beautifully.

Let me explain something. Not only are they putting fingerprinting machines in schools and CCTV in the Toilets to prepare kids for the global police state were moving into So that when they grow older they will just see them things as the norm as they get introduced into society.

They are also using these i.d cards as a stepping stone to introduce control over all the products you buy n purchase. Crime is the most dumbest thing people talk about when it comes to i.d cards.

Even einstien said, peace does not come about through force, thats a dictatorship it comes through peace.

Any crime commited is only because of the mind state of the person and how ever u want to act like its there fault most people i know who have commited crimes grew out of it when they realised there was more to life, but the lack of what was happening was being put into reality with no understanding of how to make real money other than slave labour and us youngers are wise to that. We arent willing to waste our lives away in a dead end coorporation job for a **** bag company to make millions off us while paying us 6 pound an hour. Never gonna get anywhere and thats realistic hence i do business.

The point is These i.d cards are the beginning of the global control next stage is the microchips. They will give you an excuse to introduce everything.

and you'll just accept it because they use the words "security, criminals" in the same sentance. Stop accepting the propaganda and review history repeating itself.

You didn't actually read my post did you?

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 17:20

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 34501503)
I digress but do they do much of that anymore? I thought modern policing was more about meeting targets for 'solving' crimes committed than actually deterring people from offending in the first place...

only way u lower crime rates, is make people see the light, Stop the corruption, Stop forcing kids into one direction which is just 9-5 work for coorporations waste your life away n do nothing.

We wanna live our lives these guys just want us as cattle its clear.

People turn to crime some because of there friends, some because of there environment.

But what ever way u wanna see it, its because of there SITUATION they have been placed in that made them turn to crime and who can you blame for the condition of the environment only those who mould the minds.

Schools done educate on reality n know kid wants a teacher like a mini hitler screaming at him hes just gonna despise it even more.

The problem is most you older guys your answer to everything is get the government to lock people up which is what makes you clueless about how the world works.

You wanna lock people up you start locking up the people who control this world the bloodlines rockefellers, n these begging politicians who sold there soul years ago.

---------- Post added at 16:19 ---------- Previous post was at 16:17 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501471)
OK, Xac, I'm imagining that. Now I'm imagining someone nicking it...



Would it bother you that the police now have to spend their time investigating law abiding citizens to make sure they have their papers in order, instead of, say, preventing and investigating crime?

Anyway, I ain't carrying no ID card. What Jacqui Smith has said today pretty much rules out the idea of much of the population having one until life is made sufficiently intolerable. Happy at the idea of our tax money paying for Home Office bureaucrats to make our life intolerable until we pay them for a piece of plastic? I'm bloody not.

Thats it, paying tax so we can loose more freedoms, be more controlled and basically move closer towards george orwells mimicry of a 1984 type society.

---------- Post added at 16:20 ---------- Previous post was at 16:19 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501508)
You didn't actually read my post did you?

i quoted the wrong person ignore that.

Damien 06-03-2008 17:23

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Schools done educate on reality n know kid wants a teacher like a mini hitler screaming at him hes just gonna despise it even more.
Obviously it's not the only thing they don't educate on...

Shaun 06-03-2008 17:29

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501207)
Is that an attempt to make the party look bigger, two IDs per MP?

I thought Ian and Duncan were in the Tory party? :scratch:

Xaccers 06-03-2008 17:33

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34501520)
Obviously it's not the only thing they don't educate on...

I'm sorry, I just couldn't resist

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2008/03/57.jpg

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 17:37

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34501520)
Obviously it's not the only thing they don't educate on...

i type so fast, im allowed spelling errors. + only fools point out irrelivant spelling mistakes such as that. so

EDIT - Derek S : Link removed

---------- Post added at 16:37 ---------- Previous post was at 16:36 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501529)

atleast that cat reads unlike you.

Derek 06-03-2008 17:38

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501471)
Would it bother you that the police now have to spend their time investigating law abiding citizens to make sure they have their papers in order, instead of, say, preventing and investigating crime?

Well they have to spend a considerable amount of time checking that law abiding citizens are actually law abiding citizens and not criminals giving dingy details already.
Still seeing some of the intravenous drug using citizens don't tend to bother with personal hygiene I don't think them not carrying an ID card would bother them. If you get jailed for not carrying one there isn't any places left and fines imposed wouldn't get paid.

I think it's a good idea. I just don't trust this government to implement it without making a complete hash of things.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 17:39

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501532)
i type so fast, im allowed spelling errors. + only fools point out irrelivant spelling mistakes such as that. so

Removed

---------- Post added at 16:37 ---------- Previous post was at 16:36 ----------



atleast that cat reads unlike you.


I read links too, such as the one above which you're trying to use to get people to log out of CF should they follow it. Not that it would succeed.

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 17:43

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 34501535)
Well they have to spend a considerable amount of time checking that law abiding citizens are actually law abiding citizens and not criminals giving dingy details already.
Still seeing some of the intravenous drug using citizens don't tend to bother with personal hygiene I don't think them not carrying an ID card would bother them. If you get jailed for not carrying one there isn't any places left and fines imposed wouldn't get paid.

I think it's a good idea. I just don't trust this government to implement it without making a complete hash of things.

the thing people need to understand. I.D cards are a breech of your rights n freedom + clearly the more they can take the **** they obviously will if you accept this like nothing the microchips will follow soon after, dunno about you but i was born a free human with my own basic human rights and ambitions and abilities, skills and talents. All of what are being breeched and abused by a government who is on puppet strings producing products rather than humans with there own minds to think freely n express thereselves uniquely....

http://www.inkedblog.com/archives/im...3/barcode1.jpg

and the reason its happening is because the older generations dont seem to give two toss's or know how the system runs in the slightest and the younger generation are more lost than hurley, lock n them.

---------- Post added at 16:43 ---------- Previous post was at 16:43 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501537)
I read links too, such as the one above which you're trying to use to get people to log out of CF should they follow it. Not that it would succeed.

make a lame comment recieve a lame answer.

Derek 06-03-2008 17:47

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501541)
make a lame comment recieve a lame answer.

If you can't contribute anything meaningful to the discussion don't bother contributing at all.

And DO NOT post another link to log people out of the board

Nugget 06-03-2008 17:48

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501532)
i type so fast, im allowed spelling errors. + only fools point out irrelivant spelling mistakes such as that. so

EDIT - Derek S : Link removed

Mind you, it takes a special type of mind to make a spelling mistake in a post criticising somebody who pointed out a spelling mistake...

freezin 06-03-2008 18:39

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Once the state was the servant of the people, but now it's becoming the master of the people. Never have the British people had to explain themselves to the state unless the state had grounds for suspicion. That relationship has been rebalanced.

And it's all fine under a benign government. However, I don't believe this government is benign enough to merit that kind of trust, and I'm certainly not prepared to believe that all future governments will be.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 18:43

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501591)
Once the state was the servant of the people.

Since when?

papa smurf 06-03-2008 18:46

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501597)
Since when?

when you were just a twinkle in your dadys eye[ the good old days]

RizzyKing 06-03-2008 18:51

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
A lot of countries have ID cards and so far i havn't read about the chip implanting program so pardon me if i see that as paranoid BS. BB while some have a slanted view of the police i don't and if i am not doing anything wrong i certainly wouldn't expect to be stopped by a police oifficer. It is not the card i am opposed too it is this government trying to implement it with the record they have.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 18:58

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 34501602)
when you were just a twinkle in your dadys eye[ the good old days]

Rose tinted glasses? Can I borrow them on Mondays? :D

People have always been the servants of the state.
People cannot control government.
They can vote them in and out, but once in power, they're firmly in a position of governance.
Look at the referendum vote, all parties said they'd hold one, Labour and LibDem whips ordered their members to tow the party line rather than vote how their constituants would have wanted.

freezin 06-03-2008 19:08

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501597)
Since when?

Probably since the 1950s. Since then the state has amassed itself all sorts of new powers over the people, from gaining more than 200 extra ways to enter private homes (from the 10 it had before) to infringing on the right to free speech and peaceful protest, to having to report in whenever changing address for ID card purposes, etc, etc, etc.

We have laws that are now drafted so broadly, individuals have little protection against officials behaving officiously or vindictively.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 19:14

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501637)
Probably since the 1950s. Since then the state has amassed itself all sorts of new powers over the people, from gaining more than 200 extra ways to enter private homes (from the 10 it had before) to infringing on the right to free speech and peaceful protest, to having to report in whenever changing address for ID card purposes, etc, etc, etc.

We have laws that are now drafted so broadly, individuals have little protection against officials behaving officiously or vindictively.

The state wasn't the servant of the people back in the 50's, nor before.
Don't forget, in the 50's there were ID cards...

ginge51 06-03-2008 19:20

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
This is pathetic.
What gets me most is "the conspiracy theories" what everyone was going on about.
They were laughing about 2-3 years back when people from the "conspiracey theries " side said that governments in Europe and U.S.A were trying to implement these,aswell as body chi[ps in the future.
It's about fxxxxxg time us lazy axx people get off our backsides and tell the idiots in government(aledgedly there to serve us,not the other way around :dozey:) that we don't want certain things and if they try and force this without a public vote we should protest on mass.
Them "conspiracy theories" said years back this was going to happen,yet everyone laughed in their faces,now look It's all true.
I certainly don't want this card crap,i should be able to go,do,say anything i want to a certain extent.
Pathetic.
Btw....
I wonder who will get the rough end of the straw on this in the long run?
Will it be the working class?................
Will it be the mp's and there entourage who made this happen?
Will the royals have to carry this?
I think i know what/who will be targeted here?

Madness.

freezin 06-03-2008 19:26

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501648)
The state wasn't the servant of the people back in the 50's, nor before.
Don't forget, in the 50's there were ID cards...

It was a lot more so then than it's been evolving into since. I'd say that's an indisputable fact. And ID cards were abolished in the 1952 (having only been required from 1939). Government responded to the pressure, unlike now.

Xaccers 06-03-2008 19:38

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501667)
It was a lot more so then than it's been evolving into since. I'd say that's an indisputable fact. And ID cards were abolished in the 1952 (having only been required from 1939). Government responded to the pressure, unlike now.

Government responded to the law, the law that the state had implimented, not the people.

The idea that a government or state should be the servant of it's people is a nice one, but it's just an idea. A servant cannot govern.

ginge51 06-03-2008 19:47

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
We have the most retarded government going,end of.
The idiots are aledgedly labour,the "peoples" party.
Yet "the people"have very,very little if no say whatsoever on big matter or laws that are about to come in place.
No wonder world governmen5ts are so corrupt,they have way to much power and involvement in everything.
God only knows what Britain will be like if labour get another 4 years?

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 19:51

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget (Post 34501545)
Mind you, it takes a special type of mind to make a spelling mistake in a post criticising somebody who pointed out a spelling mistake...

or someone who doesnt spend there life on a forum and actually runs business's....

---------- Post added at 18:50 ---------- Previous post was at 18:49 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Derek S (Post 34501544)
If you can't contribute anything meaningful to the discussion don't bother contributing at all.

And DO NOT post another link to log people out of the board

sounds a bit double standards but what ever.

---------- Post added at 18:51 ---------- Previous post was at 18:50 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501623)
Rose tinted glasses? Can I borrow them on Mondays? :D

People have always been the servants of the state.
People cannot control government.
They can vote them in and out, but once in power, they're firmly in a position of governance.
Look at the referendum vote, all parties said they'd hold one, Labour and LibDem whips ordered their members to tow the party line rather than vote how their constituants would have wanted.

the fact is governments were created FOR the people. The idea of a democracy is that we have a say.

We have none of these things, the government just do what they want n we come along for the ride.

and the majority just do what there told to do because there weak minded.

Russ 06-03-2008 19:53

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501691)
or someone who doesnt spend there life on a forum and actually runs business's....

'Businesses'.

shawty 06-03-2008 19:58

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
I do what I want within the law, always have (only 23) always will, never been into trouble, never get the attention of the Police, been searched once in the street when the Police had reports of 3 young lads (was about 15 at the time) breaking into cars, had no problem with this, on my way within 5 minutes. Glad they were doing there job.

I predict I will go on in life like this with ID cards or not, I dont see what all the fuss is about (on the side of the big brother type thing) I can carry on doing what Im doing, I dont think the government will give two flying toots that Im buying condoms and cookies from Asda or a pizza from Pizza Hut.

People said the same about CCTV when it was first introduced. Id rather have CCTV at the end of my street rather than not. I want to see who it actually is scratching peoples cars and knocking the wing mirrors off.

The big brother believers are pathetic in my opinion. If you are doing nothing wrong, no one cares what you are doing.

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 20:04

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ B (Post 34501699)
'Businesses'.

since when was spelling on an internet forum relevant.... Your lucky im not speaking pure slang to you old timers.

Russ 06-03-2008 20:06

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501710)
since when was spelling on an internet forum relevant....

It's only relevant when you're correcting someone else's spelling mistakes.[/quote]

Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501710)
Your lucky im not speaking pure slang to you old timers.

And I'm glad. I don't understand 'txt spk'.

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 20:11

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shawty (Post 34501702)
I do what I want within the law, always have (only 23) always will, never been into trouble, never get the attention of the Police, been searched once in the street when the Police had reports of 3 young lads (was about 15 at the time) breaking into cars, had no problem with this, on my way within 5 minutes. Glad they were doing there job.

I predict I will go on in life like this with ID cards or not, I dont see what all the fuss is about (on the side of the big brother type thing) I can carry on doing what Im doing, I dont think the government will give two flying toots that Im buying condoms and cookies from Asda or a pizza from Pizza Hut.

People said the same about CCTV when it was first introduced. Id rather have CCTV at the end of my street rather than not. I want to see who it actually is scratching peoples cars and knocking the wing mirrors off.

The big brother believers are pathetic in my opinion. If you are doing nothing wrong, no one cares what you are doing.

just because you have no value for your human rights, privacy, do not call others pathetic who do care.

Ive already explained crime is the product of poverty and lack of understanding. Which is brought about by school, nothing to do, lack of education at school on REAL LIFE and a whole host of other things.

In my areas there literally nothing to do its just absulote logic that kids are gonna mess around n do what ever on the streets because everything costs more than these kids can afford. So thats there fault is it?

secondly the CCTV is stepping it up its called monitoring its so you get use to it so as they bring in more n more you will just accept it as normal. Kids in my old school nowadays have fingerprint scanners to get there food (which have probably already stolen there DNA and fingerprints and now the authorities have them).

and if you really think they care about what you buy you really are foolish.

These are called stepping stones. They've done it all through history.

Microchip in the passport was the first step then they started mentionining i.d cards and talking about the VERICHIP on live national mainstream news and the "benefits" of it.

Some of you guys i question are you a lab rat to be tested or are you a free human?

Also the law is changing my friend when does the time come when the law breaches your human rights. It already has mine because im youth and youth's are treated like **** by old bill. Just a pure fact and dont come out with your stereotyping to back them "oh your probably looking suspicious or doing something wrong" because if police work of stereotyping and discrimination.....i guess that says alot about the UK n the mentalities supporting the police...

---------- Post added at 19:11 ---------- Previous post was at 19:10 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ B (Post 34501712)
It's only relevant when you're correcting someone else's spelling mistakes.

i wasnt correcting anyone mistakes..

And I'm glad. I don't understand 'txt spk'.[/QUOTE]

that is not slang, that is shortened words for text messages, i never use that.

shawty 06-03-2008 20:41

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501720)
just because you have no value for your human rights, privacy, do not call others pathetic who do care.

Why? Im allowed an opinion aint I?

Quote:

Ive already explained crime is the product of poverty and lack of understanding. Which is brought about by school, nothing to do, lack of education at school on REAL LIFE and a whole host of other things.
And that some Humans are just not right in the head. Crime can happen from people who had a good up brining, went to private school, got a good education and they can still turn to crime.

Quote:

In my areas there literally nothing to do its just absulote logic that kids are gonna mess around n do what ever on the streets because everything costs more than these kids can afford. So thats there fault is it?
Do things actually cost more, if they do its surely not by much.

Bowling, Cinema, fishing, football, swimming, cricket, tennis, squash, pool, snooker, dancing, ballet, fencing, computer games, running, hiking, camping, arcades, skating, rock climbing (indoors and outdoors), biking, cooking, you get the jist.

Yes, it is there fault, most of what I listed is free.

Quote:

secondly the CCTV is stepping it up its called monitoring its so you get use to it so as they bring in more n more you will just accept it as normal. Kids in my old school nowadays have fingerprint scanners to get there food (which have probably already stolen there DNA and fingerprints and now the authorities have them).
Who do you think you are, why do you think your so important that everyone wants to spy on you? I will say something now, unless your comiting a crime, then the government with their CCTV couldnt give a toss that you drive a Ford and shop at Tesco. They are there for our safety, how many cases do you think would be shot out of court if it wasnt for CCTV.

Quote:

and if you really think they care about what you buy you really are foolish.
They dont, thats what the whole point is. You put yourself so high up on your pedistal that you are paranoid about your privacy, which when you think about, unless you are doing something illegal, they dont care what you are doing, pick your nose infront of one, you might give the CCTV operator a quick giggle, its not like anything else will happen.

Quote:

These are called stepping stones. They've done it all through history.
Its called looking out for the saftey of Humans. If the Human race was perfect, we wouldnt need all this anyway, so we can really only blame 'ourselfs' really.

Quote:

Microchip in the passport was the first step then they started mentionining i.d cards and talking about the VERICHIP on live national mainstream news and the "benefits" of it.
But, and again, if your not doing anything illegal, then they are not bothered where you shop what car you drive and wither you use your little or big finger to pick your nose.

Quote:

Some of you guys i question are you a lab rat to be tested or are you a free human?
Im doing exactly the same thing I was years ago and I will continue to do what Im doing for years to come. CCTV, ID cards and the such wont change this, because Im doing nothing wrong, hence they couldnt give a toss about me.

Quote:

Also the law is changing my friend when does the time come when the law breaches your human rights. It already has mine because im youth and youth's are treated like **** by old bill. Just a pure fact and dont come out with your stereotyping to back them "oh your probably looking suspicious or doing something wrong" because if police work of stereotyping and discrimination.....i guess that says alot about the UK n the mentalities supporting the police...
They are doing their job. Ive been searched because we were 3 young lads walking the street at night. If you are doing nothing wrong, you are gone within 5 minutes. The youth of today (the trouble causing ones) want a good kick up the backside and its only right that the Police have the rights and powers to stop people that look suspicious, its gone on for years and will carry on to do so for the forseable future. 9 times out 0f 10 (not actuall fingures) they might get it wrong, but for the 1 time they dont get it wrong, it might save someone being robbed/knifed/shot/beat up, why do you have a problem with this.

papa smurf 06-03-2008 20:48

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
well i can say id cards wont change my life, cos this old timer wont be having one big scottish brother can shove it where the sun dont shine

THESHAOLIN1 06-03-2008 20:55

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shawty (Post 34501756)
Why? Im allowed an opinion aint I?



And that some Humans are just not right in the head. Crime can happen from people who had a good up brining, went to private school, got a good education and they can still turn to crime.

of corse of corse but...

"An opinion is not neccessarily correct just because your willing to die for it" - Oscar Wilde.

and yeah crime is varied but it all leads back to the same thing always those who control you n the way they run things + the mentality thats fed to the majority.


Do things actually cost more, if they do its surely not by much.

Bowling, Cinema, fishing, football, swimming, cricket, tennis, squash, pool, snooker, dancing, ballet, fencing, computer games, running, hiking, camping, arcades, skating, rock climbing (indoors and outdoors), biking, cooking, you get the jist.

Yes, it is there fault, most of what I listed is free.

lol @ free i dunno where your from mate maybe in your little village of friendly people but it certainly isnt that way or free here. And about do things cost more....i thought that was logic.



Who do you think you are, why do you think your so important that everyone wants to spy on you? I will say something now, unless your comiting a crime, then the government with their CCTV couldnt give a toss that you drive a Ford and shop at Tesco. They are there for our safety, how many cases do you think would be shot out of court if it wasnt for CCTV.

who do you think you are? you dont even value your own privacy or human rights but then call others who do pathetic?

and no its called breeching your privacy, enforcing more laws which take away freedoms that is a dictatorship last time i review definitions. Its got nothing to do with being a criminal give people an inch they'll take a mile before u know it it will go levels way beyond that crimes only gonna get worse using force will not change anything, the way were going the whole of uk will be some kind of super prison for people with the middle class stuck up people (holding the same mentalities as you) will just walk around thinking its benefiting them to be a total n utter bar coded followed, tracked and lacking freedoms slave.

To remove a problem you have to go to the source of it, which means CCTV, more police, More Force, More weapons, More prisons will not solve **** all.




They dont, thats what the whole point is. You put yourself so high up on your pedistal that you are paranoid about your privacy, which when you think about, unless you are doing something illegal, they dont care what you are doing, pick your nose infront of one, you might give the CCTV operator a quick giggle, its not like anything else will happen.



Its called looking out for the saftey of Humans. If the Human race was perfect, we wouldnt need all this anyway, so we can really only blame 'ourselfs' really.



But, and again, if your not doing anything illegal, then they are not bothered where you shop what car you drive and wither you use your little or big finger to pick your nose.



Im doing exactly the same thing I was years ago and I will continue to do what Im doing for years to come. CCTV, ID cards and the such wont change this, because Im doing nothing wrong, hence they couldnt give a toss about me.



They are doing their job. Ive been searched because we were 3 young lads walking the street at night. If you are doing nothing wrong, you are gone within 5 minutes. The youth of today (the trouble causing ones) want a good kick up the backside and its only right that the Police have the rights and powers to stop people that look suspicious, its gone on for years and will carry on to do so for the forseable future. 9 times out 0f 10 (not actuall fingures) they might get it wrong, but for the 1 time they dont get it wrong, it might save someone being robbed/knifed/shot/beat up, why do you have a problem with this.

As for the other questions im about to go out so ive not got time to reply but if you seriously think police stop u n it takes 5 minutes your delirious, ive been stopped hundreds of time i spend alot of days in east london and alot of days in my hometown southend. Police breech my privacy all day everyday there not heroes there just **** bags with miniscule amount of power and abuse it as would alot of humans given a bit of power. Some think there helping the community and i can clearly see are not bad people but they dont realise what there supporting is not a solution its just a cycle.

Thats what the police systems about which is why guys like you who support it from all angles, n have the nerve to call guys pathetic who DO giva **** about there freedoms n human rights seriously have no worthyness of being called a free spirited human.

I myself will never have my rights breeched and you and police officers will know where they stand with me. I would die for my human rights gladly because without them lifes not worth living anyhow unless your happy being a slave personally not me.

in a few years time as the police state gets more n more, you will see why it was a bad idea, n people like me will be way gone out of this country to leave you to pick up the pieces. Alot of police are freemasons they care not for you and i know guys who are in the police aged over 30 and they verify this for me all the time.

---------- Post added at 19:55 ---------- Previous post was at 19:53 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 34501764)
well i can say id cards wont change my life, cos this old timer wont be having one big scottish brother can shove it where the sun dont shine

agreed, even my old man said there taking the **** n hes not having one.

I love how the youngers these days seem to think authority has a right to tell you how to live your life.

Guys have forgotten who they are.

RizzyKing 06-03-2008 20:56

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
THESHAOLIN while you are entitled to your opinion so is everyone else so maybe bear that in mind for a more pleasant forum experience. As for the information that an ID card would hold 95% of it is already out there anyway and if as you say you run a business well more of your info is out there already. An ID card is not an automatic step towards implanting RFID chips as some have suggested and in a way i feel sorry for this and any other government as people want security they say they want control over immigration but a national ID card oh my god no my privacy it's stupid you want something you have to give a little.

shawty 06-03-2008 21:03

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501772)
As for the other questions im about to go out so ive not got time to reply but if you seriously think police stop u n it takes 5 minutes your delirious, ive been stopped hundreds of time i spend alot of days in east london and alot of days in my hometown southend. Police breech my privacy all day everyday there not heroes there just **** bags with miniscule amount of power and abuse it as would alot of humans given a bit of power. Some think there helping the community and i can clearly see are not bad people but they dont realise what there supporting is not a solution its just a cycle.

Thats what the police systems about which is why guys like you who support it from all angles, n have the nerve to call guys pathetic who DO giva **** about there freedoms n human rights seriously have no worthyness of being called a free spirited human.

I myself will never have my rights breeched and you and police officers will know where they stand with me. I would die for my human rights gladly because without them lifes not worth living anyhow unless your happy being a slave personally not me.

in a few years time as the police state gets more n more, you will see why it was a bad idea, n people like me will be way gone out of this country to leave you to pick up the pieces. Alot of police are freemasons they care not for you and i know guys who are in the police aged over 30 and they verify this for me all the time.

---------- Post added at 19:55 ---------- Previous post was at 19:53 ----------



agreed, even my old man said there taking the **** n hes not having one.

I love how the youngers these days seem to think authority has a right to tell you how to live your life.

Guys have forgotten who they are.

Why dont you stop and think for a second. What privacy are you losing out on?

Do nothing wrong, they dont care what you do or who you are. Hence your free to do whatever you want. It seems people ahve to moan just to moan these days, without even thinking about it. Get in a stress over it if you want, nothings going to change in my life and the way I live it wether we have CCTV or ID cards. People who think this country is like big brother are delusional to me. We have gathered the government dont care where you shop or what car you drive.

Nugget 06-03-2008 21:17

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501772)
<snip>ive been stopped hundreds of times<snip>

Erm, at risk of appearing rude, but if you've been stopped 'hundreds of times', it rather suggests that you've been doing something that you shouldn't have been. I actually can't think of a better argument in support of ID cards...

BBKing 06-03-2008 21:20

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

<snip>ive been stopped hundreds of times<snip>
I didn't know they'd brought in an offence of being boring in a built up area during the hours of daylight.

Nugget 06-03-2008 21:23

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBKing (Post 34501798)
I didn't know they'd brought in an offence of being boring in a built up area during the hours of daylight.


Shhhh, it's a conspiracy - they'll all want one :shocked:

freezin 06-03-2008 21:32

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501683)
Government responded to the law, the law that the state had implimented, not the people.

The idea that a government or state should be the servant of it's people is a nice one, but it's just an idea. A servant cannot govern.

And the law was changed BECAUSE of pressure from the people. Organisations as quaint as the National Housewives' League demonstrated against ID cards (they burned their ID cards in protest outside parliament) and their intrusions into private life.

It's not just an idea; it was the way it was. The "servant" governed with the consent of the people under threat of being ousted to make way for a more popular party if it did not. Do you trust this government? Do you think future governments will be trustworthy? Do you?

Nugget 06-03-2008 21:34

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501810)
And the law was changed BECAUSE of pressure from the people. Organisations as quaint as the National Housewives' League demonstrated against ID cards (they burned their ID cards in protest outside parliament) and their intrusions into private life.

It's not just an idea; it was the way it was. The "servant" governed with the consent of the people under threat of being ousted to make way for a more popular party if it did not. Do you trust this government? Do you think future governments will be trustworthy? Do you?

Far more trustworthy than those in Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Zimbabwe or, whisper it, Russia. At least ours was democratically elected...

freezin 06-03-2008 21:37

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 34501776)
As for the information that an ID card would hold 95% of it is already out there anyway and if as you say you run a business well more of your info is out there already. An ID card is not an automatic step towards implanting RFID chips as some have suggested and in a way i feel sorry for this and any other government as people want security they say they want control over immigration but a national ID card oh my god no my privacy it's stupid you want something you have to give a little.

But on the National Identity Register it would all be held in one place, open to fraud and lax procedures, and available to a whole host of people at almost the touch of a button.

Quote:

An ID card is not an automatic step towards implanting RFID chips as some have suggested and in a way i feel sorry for this and any other government as people want security they say they want control over immigration but a national ID card oh my god no my privacy it's stupid you want something you have to give a little.
People want good government of which security is just a part, and I really don't see how ID cards will help improve anything for the public, though it will make a mint for the companies given the contracts. And as for ID cards controlling immigration - is that a joke?

Do you trust this government, and future governments, too?

---------- Post added at 20:37 ---------- Previous post was at 20:34 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget (Post 34501813)
Far more trustworthy than those in Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Zimbabwe or, whisper it, Russia. At least ours was democratically elected...

Governance in the UK is on the slide though. It's ironic that the government wants to impose democratic government on Afghanistan when it has done so much to undermine our own democracy.

Nugget 06-03-2008 21:43

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501814)
Governance in the UK is on the slide though. It's ironic that the government wants to impose democratic government on Afghanistan when it has done so much to undermine our own democracy.

Governance may be on the slide, but we all have it our power to do something about it - an election is due next year, so we can vote 'em out. Unfortunately, the electorate in this country suffer from collective apathy (what is it? 40-odd per cent turnout?), so the old saying comes in - if you can't be bothered to vote, don't expect to be allowed to whine about it...

Mind you, at least we have a choice of who to vote for here :shrug:

RizzyKing 06-03-2008 21:53

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
No i am not saying it will help immigration but that is a constant want from the people and it won't hurt will it??. While i don't like the invasions of privacy that seem to happen everyday being realistic what can we do to stop them when many of us are a bit hypocritical about it. I mean we shout and scream about privacy then sign upto a storecard for incentives so shopping is not private anymore. As for losing the data if you had read what i said i would not in anyway trust this shambles of a government to have an ID card. I want to be convinced that if and when it comes in we have the infrastructure and policy's in it's handling in place so that none of us need worry on that aspect.

freezin 06-03-2008 22:05

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget (Post 34501822)
Governance may be on the slide, but we all have it our power to do something about it - an election is due next year, so we can vote 'em out. Unfortunately, the electorate in this country suffer from collective apathy (what is it? 40-odd per cent turnout?), so the old saying comes in - if you can't be bothered to vote, don't expect to be allowed to whine about it...

Mind you, at least we have a choice of who to vote for here :shrug:

It was just over 60% turnout at the last election. And apathy does unfortunately rule. But I don't think you can blame those who didn't vote too much. They don't see much of a difference in what's on offer ... "they're all the same" is the common excuse. And there is a lot of truth in that.

We need a less naive, more enquiring electorate, and they need to hear an honest political debate. There's not much chance of that happening.

---------- Post added at 21:05 ---------- Previous post was at 20:56 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 34501832)
No i am not saying it will help immigration but that is a constant want from the people and it won't hurt will it??. While i don't like the invasions of privacy that seem to happen everyday being realistic what can we do to stop them when many of us are a bit hypocritical about it. I mean we shout and scream about privacy then sign upto a storecard for incentives so shopping is not private anymore. As for losing the data if you had read what i said i would not in anyway trust this shambles of a government to have an ID card. I want to be convinced that if and when it comes in we have the infrastructure and policy's in it's handling in place so that none of us need worry on that aspect.

I don't think the invasion of privacy is worth that! And the difference between store cards and national ID cards is obvious, one is voluntary and can be ended, and the other is not. The store card holder keeps his card for as long as it suits him. The ID card holder keeps his card for as long as it suits the state.

I DID read what you had said. It just didn't seem to balance with your support for ID cards. And the question remains - Do you trust future governments? That's important imo because once brought in, I would say there is no chance of getting rid of them. But if you are against ID cards until such a time that we have a trustworthy government, ok fine!

jkat 06-03-2008 22:41

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
"youve got nothing to fear" keep hearing this a lot recently or words to that effect lol :erm:

shawty 06-03-2008 22:58

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jkat (Post 34501851)
"youve got nothing to fear" keep hearing this a lot recently or words to that effect lol :erm:

Well its fact. Talking about the people who like to brand about big brother a lot. Bringing in CCTV, bringing in ID cards, will not change the way I live or do things due to the fact the government are not bothered were I shop or what car I drive or waht finger I use to pick my nose. The people that should be worrying are the people who do illegal things. Anyway, what privacy? As soon as you open your house door and step out in the real world, how can you have privacy?

Tezcatlipoca 06-03-2008 23:16

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Even ignoring the privacy, civil liberties, and "Big Brother" aspects of the ID Cards scheme (& more importantly, the National ID Register), I do not see how anyone could possibly be in favour of an ID card scheme such as this when it is being brought about by our current incompetent Government.

How many massive Government IT projects have had cost overruns? [and how many have actually delivered what was promised?]

How many times have we read stories regarding yet another data cock-up (HMRC Benefit data, DVLA, etc.)?


Can anyone seriously trust this Goverment to actually successfully implement & run such a grandiose scheme as this? Really?


And when you do then couple that with all the civil liberties issues, and with the complete & utter lack of any actual justifiable need for ID Cards & the ID Database (how many times now has the Govt changed its tune over exactly what the purpose is?), I really fail to understand how anyone could possibly be in favour of this harebrained scheme.


Quote:

Originally Posted by jkat (Post 34501851)
"youve got nothing to fear" keep hearing this a lot recently or words to that effect lol :erm:



Quote:

Originally Posted by Martin Niemoller
When the Nazis came for the communists,
I remained silent;
I was not a communist.

When they locked up the social democrats,
I remained silent;
I was not a social democrat.

When they came for the trade unionists,
I did not speak out;
I was not a trade unionist.

When they came for the Jews,
I remained silent;
I wasn't a Jew.

When they came for me,
there was no one left to speak out.


Nugget 06-03-2008 23:18

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shawty (Post 34501861)
Well its fact. Talking about the people who like to brand about big brother a lot. Bringing in CCTV, bringing in ID cards, will not change the way I live or do things due to the fact the government are not bothered were I shop or what car I drive or waht finger I use to pick my nose. The people that should be worrying are the people who do illegal things. Anyway, what privacy? As soon as you open your house door and step out in the real world, how can you have privacy?

Stop it - I find myself agreeing with you, and I'm not sure I like it :D

Tezcatlipoca 06-03-2008 23:21

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget (Post 34501822)
Unfortunately, the electorate in this country suffer from collective apathy

I've always thought of it more as "collective stupidity"... ;)

freezin 06-03-2008 23:29

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shawty (Post 34501861)
Well its fact. Talking about the people who like to brand about big brother a lot. Bringing in CCTV, bringing in ID cards, will not change the way I live or do things due to the fact the government are not bothered were I shop or what car I drive or waht finger I use to pick my nose. The people that should be worrying are the people who do illegal things. Anyway, what privacy? As soon as you open your house door and step out in the real world, how can you have privacy?

How do you know that this infringement of civil liberties will not change the way you live? The government is most definitely interested in what kind of car you drive, not to mention what your diet is like, whether you smoke and or drink, and where you stand on moral issues and the like. And if you're OK with all of that, what happens if future governments are interested in things that are not OK with you?

The people who "do illegal things" are the ones who are likely to be the least worried about ID cards. They're not going to be lining up like good little citizens to have their biometrics taken, are they?

Xaccers 06-03-2008 23:33

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501810)
And the law was changed BECAUSE of pressure from the people. Organisations as quaint as the National Housewives' League demonstrated against ID cards (they burned their ID cards in protest outside parliament) and their intrusions into private life.

It's not just an idea; it was the way it was. The "servant" governed with the consent of the people under threat of being ousted to make way for a more popular party if it did not. Do you trust this government? Do you think future governments will be trustworthy? Do you?

Pretty sure it was down to there no longer being a state of emergency, therefore no legal requirement for ID cards.
Had the government been able to show there was still a state of emergency, then ID cards would have continued to be legally required.

shawty 06-03-2008 23:56

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget (Post 34501874)
Stop it - I find myself agreeing with you, and I'm not sure I like it :D

Sorry, thats all I can say, haha.

---------- Post added at 22:56 ---------- Previous post was at 22:41 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501882)
How do you know that this infringement of civil liberties will not change the way you live? The government is most definitely interested in what kind of car you drive, not to mention what your diet is like, whether you smoke and or drink, and where you stand on moral issues and the like. And if you're OK with all of that, what happens if future governments are interested in things that are not OK with you?

The people who "do illegal things" are the ones who are likely to be the least worried about ID cards. They're not going to be lining up like good little citizens to have their biometrics taken, are they?

Because we live in a Country where big brother type things will not happen. In 25 years time, in 50 years time, we will find ourselfs (well not me) saying the same thing. Im also afraid to say if the NHS know if I do or dont smoke/drink and they know what my diet is like, I dont care if the gorverment know or not. Im telling you now, the goverment dont care what car I drive, why would they be bothered about it, if they were, they would have to be bothered on everybodys cars, how many is that? They are only bothered about cars that are being used illegally and such things like that. They dont care Im jumping in my Ford to drive to tesco, why would they.

If drinking alcohol ever became illegal, I wouldnt blame the gorverment, Id blame the people who cant control themselves on a night out. Middlesbrough isnt the best of places at the best of times, on the night time its horrendous due to the drug takers/drinkers not being able to handle themselves and the prostitutes.

Its time we stand up and stop blaming the goverment for everything, sure they are the cause of somethings, the only thing I see with this Country though is people cant lay the blame on themselves or their friends.

I bet, given the chance of running this Country, most people wouldnt know where to stand or what to do and even if they did, does not mean its going to be succesful.

Ive always said that for the 'average' person, they (the different paties trying to get in to run the country) are all as bad as each other. We would be know better/worse off either way because they always find another way to gain money from us.

I think some people need to sit up and all though we are not the best Country in the world, we are certainly not the worst, not by a long shot and some people need to think themselves lucky that we can sit here and actually talk about and maybe do something about the policies the goverment want to bring in.

freezin 07-03-2008 00:03

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501887)
Pretty sure it was down to there no longer being a state of emergency, therefore no legal requirement for ID cards.
Had the government been able to show there was still a state of emergency, then ID cards would have continued to be legally required.

The protests started because there was no state of emergency. To its credit, the government of Winston Churchill scrapped the cards soon after winning the 1951 General Election.

Xaccers 07-03-2008 00:16

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freezin (Post 34501906)
The protests started because there was no state of emergency. To its credit, the government of Winston Churchill scrapped the cards soon after winning the 1951 General Election.

Scapped due to a judge deciding that there was no state of emergency, and therefore no requirement for ID cards, not because of public protests.

It's like saying the governments decision to allow the first 2500L of biofuel to be tax free was due to public protest, not due to it otherwise breaching the Kyoto treaty or costing HMRC too much to process tiny sums of duty payments.

THESHAOLIN1 07-03-2008 03:03

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 34501776)
THESHAOLIN while you are entitled to your opinion so is everyone else so maybe bear that in mind for a more pleasant forum experience. As for the information that an ID card would hold 95% of it is already out there anyway and if as you say you run a business well more of your info is out there already. An ID card is not an automatic step towards implanting RFID chips as some have suggested and in a way i feel sorry for this and any other government as people want security they say they want control over immigration but a national ID card oh my god no my privacy it's stupid you want something you have to give a little.


you must be in a dream if you think a card gives you security.

The only threat to any of our lives is the ones who control us. They are creating the division, the segregation.

And before 9/11 which led to the war in iraq the world was a much better place and i can clearly visibly see this.

As for the passports they've already got the RFID chips in, i wouldnt be surprised if these cards have the same its not about tracking with me, its the fact i know its a stepping stone.

And no you dont give a little to tyrants who have murdered over 50,000 people in just iraq alone. You dont give anything to them.

People on this forum lack so much information about what the governments in history have been known for doing.

Even in roman times governments have never worked they abuse power and its not because they abuse it, its because there not working for us and the people who own them have very different agenda's.

I bet most of you would line up to get microchipped.

---------- Post added at 02:03 ---------- Previous post was at 02:00 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501648)
The state wasn't the servant of the people back in the 50's, nor before.
Don't forget, in the 50's there were ID cards...

yes they were are you for real?

Governments job is for the people they are there for us.

If you want a dictatorship off to china you go.

Xaccers 07-03-2008 04:08

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501980)
Governments job is for the people they are there for us.

You keep believing that, I hope it makes you feel warm and cosy.
Personally, I'll stick with looking at the evidence, which clearly shows that most governments are in it for themselves and their "friends" but not the people.
Sure, sometimes their actions benefit people, but that's normally just a happy coincidence.
Take the HMRC decision on removing tax from biofuels up to 2500L a year.
Your warm and fuzzy view of the government being for the people would suggest they did it to help reduce people's fuel bills and encourage carbon neutral energy production.
In reality it was because it cost more per duty payment than the payment itself for non-professional biofuel producers (like myself) and the government was in breach of the Kyoto treaty by making renewable fuels more expensive than fossil fuels.
So the government introduced the 2500L limit to exclude non-professional biofuel producers and thus save money, and also bring it's policies in line with the Kyoto treaty.
The happy coincidence is that the action saves me approx £1000 a year in fuel costs.

THESHAOLIN1 07-03-2008 04:21

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34502003)
You keep believing that, I hope it makes you feel warm and cosy.
Personally, I'll stick with looking at the evidence, which clearly shows that most governments are in it for themselves and their "friends" but not the people.
Sure, sometimes their actions benefit people, but that's normally just a happy coincidence.
Take the HMRC decision on removing tax from biofuels up to 2500L a year.
Your warm and fuzzy view of the government being for the people would suggest they did it to help reduce people's fuel bills and encourage carbon neutral energy production.
In reality it was because it cost more per duty payment than the payment itself for non-professional biofuel producers (like myself) and the government was in breach of the Kyoto treaty by making renewable fuels more expensive than fossil fuels.
So the government introduced the 2500L limit to exclude non-professional biofuel producers and thus save money, and also bring it's policies in line with the Kyoto treaty.
The happy coincidence is that the action saves me approx £1000 a year in fuel costs.

thats the truth corse there not in it for the people, that is what governments were created for, i think someone missed a few history lessons.

but what i mean is there original purpose was exactly that, to be there for the people.

They are defying that n thus they must be removed

and stop waffling on about some bullshit aswell n be relevant.

i'm more against the governments in control than im sure anyone on this site.

Xaccers 07-03-2008 04:30

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502007)
thats the truth corse there not in it for the people, that is what governments were created for, i think someone missed a few history lessons.

but what i mean is there original purpose was exactly that, to be there for the people.

They are defying that n thus they must be removed

and stop waffling on about some bullshit aswell n be relevant.

i'm more against the governments in control than im sure anyone on this site.

Yes, it does appear that you missed a few history lessons.
Perhaps you should take another look at the history of British governments, specifically who's government it is.
From your other posts, you won't like the answer.

THESHAOLIN1 07-03-2008 05:53

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34502008)
Yes, it does appear that you missed a few history lessons.
Perhaps you should take another look at the history of British governments, specifically who's government it is.
From your other posts, you won't like the answer.

clearly not, im talking about back in rome, the purpose of a government leading all the way upto the modern day has been twisted.

We have been made to look upto authority as god of our reality while believing and being told we have freedom while they slowly take it away from us.

I assure i know history better than most. If you cant speak to me about sumeria i suggest its you who gets the history lesson.

As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.

Druchii 07-03-2008 08:10

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
clearly not, im talking about back in rome, the purpose of a government leading all the way upto the modern day has been twisted.

We have been made to look upto authority as god of our reality while believing and being told we have freedom while they slowly take it away from us.

I assure i know history better than most. If you cant speak to me about sumeria i suggest its you who gets the history lesson.

As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.

Mmmhmm, go study it some more them. Xaccers is onto something you are not going to like.

Oh, and 1 million years? I'd not hesitate in saying things were not recorded back then, and as such any events are open for interpretation.

freezin 07-03-2008 09:37

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34501915)
Scapped due to a judge deciding that there was no state of emergency, and therefore no requirement for ID cards, not because of public protests.

Not quite. In 1951 Lord Chief Justice, Lord Goddard ruled that the police could not demand that individuals show their ID cards if it was not relevant to the purposes for which the card was adopted. Widespread discussion of the ruling led to the repeal of the National Registration Act in 1952 and the end of ID cards until now. Public protest played a big part.

BBKing 07-03-2008 09:47

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Public protest played a big part.
So, IIRC, did direct refusal to show the card by members of the public. The lesson to learn is that the existence of ID cards alters the relationship between the public and police in a thoroughly un-British way.

freezin 07-03-2008 09:48

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shawty (Post 34501891)
Because we live in a Country where big brother type things will not happen. In 25 years time, in 50 years time, we will find ourselfs (well not me) saying the same thing. Im also afraid to say if the NHS know if I do or dont smoke/drink and they know what my diet is like, I dont care if the gorverment know or not. Im telling you now, the goverment dont care what car I drive, why would they be bothered about it, if they were, they would have to be bothered on everybodys cars, how many is that? They are only bothered about cars that are being used illegally and such things like that. They dont care Im jumping in my Ford to drive to tesco, why would they.

If drinking alcohol ever became illegal, I wouldnt blame the gorverment, Id blame the people who cant control themselves on a night out. Middlesbrough isnt the best of places at the best of times, on the night time its horrendous due to the drug takers/drinkers not being able to handle themselves and the prostitutes.

Its time we stand up and stop blaming the goverment for everything, sure they are the cause of somethings, the only thing I see with this Country though is people cant lay the blame on themselves or their friends.

I bet, given the chance of running this Country, most people wouldnt know where to stand or what to do and even if they did, does not mean its going to be succesful.

Ive always said that for the 'average' person, they (the different paties trying to get in to run the country) are all as bad as each other. We would be know better/worse off either way because they always find another way to gain money from us.

I think some people need to sit up and all though we are not the best Country in the world, we are certainly not the worst, not by a long shot and some people need to think themselves lucky that we can sit here and actually talk about and maybe do something about the policies the goverment want to bring in.

You actually really do think all future British governments will be trustworthy? Sorry, but I find your attitude incredibly complacent. We are already living in an evolving big brother state, but you're obviously a good little citizen who will never do anything the state doesn't approve of. But if any of your descendants ever do, there might be no one left to speak up for them. :shrug:

I'm not blaming the government for everything, but one thing I do blame them for using the tax system against everyone instead of dealing effectively with the people causing the problems. We're not politicians; it's not our job to run the country, but nevertheless imo our parliamentary politicians have become arrogant and remote from those they are supposed to serve.

You're wrong. All parties are not all as bad as each other. Don't judge them all by the standards employed by the parties with bodies on green benches. And when the countries someone can compare us favourably to are "Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Zimbabwe or, whisper it, Russia" you know how low we have sunk.

BBKing 07-03-2008 10:04

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.
I suggest you look up the etymology of the word 'prehistoric' sometime, if we're going to be sharing knowledge so liberally.

lostandconfused 07-03-2008 10:20

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)

I assure i know history better than most. If you cant speak to me about sumeria i suggest its you who gets the history lesson.

As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.

Those books again eh?:erm:

tweetypie/8 07-03-2008 10:37

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 34501168)
So the Government has decided to put even more data at risk and package it in a small easy to lose device. No doubt the Lib Dems will sit on the fence over this one as well, Lets face it just like Europe this is important enough to require a vote in the house.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7280495.stm

Problem with the unelected pretender Brown is that he says one thing and then does the opposite. Therefor the fact he hinted this



Does not fill me with a warm feeling of trust :LOL:

i cant understand what all the fuss is about,here in n.ireland we have always had photographic id on our driving licences and in the bad old days of bombings were asked regularly for id and were subject to body searches and had no choice in the matter.

TheNorm 07-03-2008 10:58

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34501980)
...I bet most of you would line up to get microchipped.....

I'd be first in the queue. By the way, you seem to be confusing "wanting to live in a dictatorship" with "making good use of technology".

Quote:

Originally Posted by tweetypie/8 (Post 34502099)
i cant understand what all the fuss is about,here in n.ireland we have always had photographic id on our driving licences and in the bad old days of bombings were asked regularly for id and were subject to body searches and had no choice in the matter.

Well I wouldn't want to be asked to show my ID every time I took a walk in Hyde Park, but there are many instances where the technology can be put to good use. When I've been pulled over by the police while driving, they've asked to see my driving licence, which I never carry around. In London you can make small purchases just by swiping a card over a reader in a shop - no need for a PIN or a signature. What a brilliant idea! I have to carry around lots of keys, which is simply archaic. Swipe cards are useful, but again you have to carry them around and there is a risk you might lose them.

An implanted microchip would be much more convenient.

Osem 07-03-2008 11:13

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.

Which planet are you referring to? The one you're on or the one we're on?

Nugget 07-03-2008 11:32

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
I assure i know history better than most. If you cant speak to me about sumeria i suggest its you who gets the history lesson.

As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.

I'll speak to you about Sumer (capital 'S' by the way). I'm not too sure about Sumeria, what with the fact that it's never existed. 'Sumerian' would be the descriptive of someone who came from Sumer, so maybe you've got a little confused. What do you want to know?

Oh, and I have to admit that I'm impressed - your understanding of history appears to surpass the existance of homo sapiens by about 800 000 years. Quite a feat, although it does rather explain your inability to construct a coherent argument...

Damien 07-03-2008 11:35

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.
So you know all of History, impressive.

Hugh 07-03-2008 12:35

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
clearly not, im talking about back in rome, the purpose of a government leading all the way upto the modern day has been twisted.

Ah, the Roman government - do you mean the Roman Republic or the Roman Empire (which was a dictatorship)?

Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
We have been made to look upto authority as god of our reality while believing and being told we have freedom while they slowly take it away from us.

You may have been made to do this, old son, but most of us on this forum (imho) haven't / don't.

Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
I assure i know history better than most. If you cant speak to me about sumeria i suggest its you who gets the history lesson.

Better than most...
History professors?
History teachers?
Babies in nappies?
I think you may find that reading the National Enquirer and Conspiracies Weekly does not count as being qualified as a "history expert".
btw, did you personally know Sargon the Great? (see my comment below)

Quote:

Originally Posted by THESHAOLIN1 (Post 34502017)
As my understanding of history reaches way past 1 million years of this planet.

Oooooooookayyyyyyy, then - if I read this correctly, you are an immortal being or a deity/xenomorph walking amongst humanity, spreading your message (well, spreading something, anyway ;) ) - or do you come from an race of beings with advanced technology, who have mastered suspended animation (but not spell-checking), and you just defrost for a couple of days every century to see how far mankind has advanced, in order to harvest us for our organs? (I wouldn't take Mr_love_monkey's if I were you, oh Great One - they have been mostly abused or unused).

TheNorm 07-03-2008 12:42

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 34502183)
... or do you come from an race of beings with advanced technology, who have mastered suspended animation (but not spell-checking), and you just defrost for a couple of days every century to see how far mankind has advanced?

Sounds familiar. Apart from the spell-checking bit. Which book is that from?

Stuart 07-03-2008 12:53

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
OK, the old ID cards thing again... Possibly time to re-iterate my views..

While what I do is legal, and mostly of no interest to anyone apart from me, my family and friends, I am uncomfortable with ID cards. For a couple of reasons:

1) I like the freedom to wander off somewhere and have no one be able to find out who I am without my permission.
2) This government hasn't been entirely successful at keeping the data they have secure. Bearing that in mind, I don't think it a good idea to give them more.

TheNorm 07-03-2008 13:02

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 34502194)
... Possibly time to re-iterate my views....

I'm not disagreeing with you (not yet anyway ;)) but your points raise two further points:

1. If you wander off in a city you will be filmed by many, many CCTV cameras. Without your permission being asked.

2. The government already holds a great deal of data about you. I don't think ID cards will add to that.

BBKing 07-03-2008 13:11

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Rather overlooked in the whole grim farrago was a report, cunningly released yesterday when everyone was looking the other way, which completely undercuts the entire scheme. Basically it says there is a need for a voluntary ID scheme from a *consumer* viewpoint, to prove ID at banks etc., but this is incompatible with the massive compulsory centralised database idea which is what the Government are clinging on to and trying to force people into (e.g. you can't work in certain industries without one, which is as far from voluntary, consumer-led as you can get).

Quote:

At an early stage, we recognised that consumers constitute the common ground between the public and private sectors. And our focus switched from "ID management" to "ID assurance". The expression "ID management" suggests data sharing and database consolidation, concepts which principally serve the interests of the owner of the database, for example the Government or the banks. Whereas we think of “ID assurance” as a consumer-led concept, a process that meets an important consumer need without necessarily providing any spin-off benefits to the owner of any database. This distinction is fundamental. An ID system built primarily to deliver high levels of assurance for consumers and to command their trust has little in common with one inspired mainly by the ambitions of its owner. In the case of the former, consumers will extend use both across the population and in terms of applications such as travel and banking. While almost inevitably the opposite is true for systems principally designed to save costs and to transfer or share data.
I think that counts as 'opening a can of whup-ass'.

http://p10.hostingprod.com/@spyblog....sby_repor.html

Stuart 07-03-2008 13:15

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheNorm (Post 34502204)
I'm not disagreeing with you (not yet anyway ;)) but your points raise two further points:

1. If you wander off in a city you will be filmed by many, many CCTV cameras. Without your permission being asked.

True, however, unless there have been great advances in face recognition (which, last time I checked was about 50-60% accurate), they still won't know who I am..
Quote:

2. The government already holds a great deal of data about you. I don't think ID cards will add to that.
True. Beyond some biometric data, the card itself won't add much, although if the data is stored on the card, I hope they aren't RFID cards. Don't really like the idea of someone being able to steal my data just by holding a reciever near me (as has been demonstrated with the US RFID passport system).

However, the main objection I have is that we appear to be moving toward being a police state, because of some percieved threat from terrorism.

TheNorm 07-03-2008 13:25

Re: ID cards rethink to be unveiled
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 34502213)
...the main objection I have is that we appear to be moving toward being a police state, because of some percieved threat from terrorism.

The use of ID cards, by themselves, does not mean that Britain will become a "police state". Much more worrying is the eroding of rights of free speech and public assembly.

I'm all for it if means I only have to carry one card instead of passport, drivers licence, staff ID, security swipe card, Oyster card, etc, etc.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 14:13.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are Cable Forum