Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General IT Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   el-cheapo computers (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=15515)

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 10:55

el-cheapo computers
 
i have been set the task of building a sort of file server for our little network next year. obviously cost is a major issue here, all we really want is a barebones system with lots and lots of storage (optical drive isn't even really needed here).

is it worth going down the line of el-cheapo components to do this, or would these be likely to burn out under constant access (media streaming over the network 24/7)? would it just be better to buy more "quality" components that have a better shelf life, with a higher outlay but longer-lastingness?

thoughts anyone? :angel:

Electrolyte01 29-07-2004 11:05

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
I would get a more quality component, less quality ones always fail quicker for me, SeaGate on the other hand, none of the drives I have had from them have failed yet and there also quite cheap. :)

Just a thought, I'm not the best here :D

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 11:08

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
oh i use maxtor drives, i know enough from past experience to stay away from el-cheapness where hard drives are concerened...

no hitachi deathstars either ;) my laptop runs one and it is very loud when i try to sleep at night, it out-loudnesses the cpu fan... can't be good :erm:

i was thinking more for PSU, motherboard, memory... since all it will ever be doing is streaming things, top of the range speed isnt needed so i am looking to cut corners as much as i can ;)

Bifta 29-07-2004 11:08

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
i have been set the task of building a sort of file server for our little network next year. obviously cost is a major issue here, all we really want is a barebones system with lots and lots of storage (optical drive isn't even really needed here).

is it worth going down the line of el-cheapo components to do this, or would these be likely to burn out under constant access (media streaming over the network 24/7)? would it just be better to buy more "quality" components that have a better shelf life, with a higher outlay but longer-lastingness?

thoughts anyone? :angel:

Skimp on everything but the drives (don't use cheap maxtors), all the components no matter what the cost only have a 1 years manufacturers warranty and at least if your processor/motherboard or whatever dies you can replaced them and still have all your data.

ian@huth 29-07-2004 11:13

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Skimp on everything but the drives (don't use cheap maxtors), all the components no matter what the cost only have a 1 years manufacturers warranty and at least if your processor/motherboard or whatever dies you can replaced them and still have all your data.

A lot of HDDs have a 3 year warranty with some, Seagate for example, moving to 5 year warranties. A warranty doesn't protect your data though, so make sure you do.

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 11:14

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
and now i feel silly, cos i said i always use maxtors and dont skimp, but maxtors are cheap and nasty... but they have never failed on me :blush:

Electrolyte01 29-07-2004 11:16

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Well I have a Syntax SV266A, excellent support when needed, also have a AMD Duron 1800 and 512 DDR memory plugged into it. The motherboard cost me £20 off Ebuyer, and was easy to install. I would recommend Syntax for cheap motherboards :)

Not sure about PSU's though, only using the one I got free with my case. Ebuyers cheap memory is good aswell, fast, reliable, no problems.

Any one else got any other companies that are cheap and good? :D

altis 29-07-2004 11:27

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Keep your eyes peeled on eBay and elsewhere for an MSI MS-6347 motherboard. These include on board U160 SCSI but only support Athlon Thunderbirds up to 1.4GHz - so more hunting required. Head over to Scan and get a Fujitsu 15Krpm U160 drive. When it's all together stick Windows 95 OSR2.5 on it - no, that's no joke - it's very small, very fast and very reliable.

This makes an ideal file server - I know, I've done it!

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 11:28

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
scsi... ima scared... never used that before. is it any harder to use than good old plug 'n' play IDE?

altis 29-07-2004 11:39

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
It's fantastic, I've been using it for years. In the PC in front of me I only have an LS-120 super-floppy on an IDE interface. Everything else, DVD-RAM, CD burner, Xyratex removable HDD, 2x18GB 15Krpm HDD and 1x73GB 10Krpm HDD are all on SCSI.

The only thing to be wary of is there are basicly 2 different types of SCSI interface (and umpteen different types of connector). Don't mix devices with different types of interface on the same cable and you won't lose performance.

Ultra devices generally use a 68-way ribbon cable. The connectors are 'D' shaped so you can't put them in upside down and you can have up to 15 drives on one cable. Non-ultra devices generally use a 50-way ribbon and you can have up to 7 drives on one cable.

Electrolyte01 29-07-2004 11:39

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Do you really need a SCSI? Is it JUST streaming media to the internet?

philip.j.fry 29-07-2004 11:39

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
scsi... ima scared... never used that before. is it any harder to use than good old plug 'n' play IDE?

Not really. One idea might be to look on ebay for some older cheaper Sun machines (Sparc stations). You should be able to pick up a few of these quite reasonably, whack in some new bigger drives if needed and then set up Solaris (costs money) or Linux (free), set up Samba or NFS and you're in business :)

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 11:50

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Electrolyte
Do you really need a SCSI? Is it JUST streaming media to the internet?

i don't *really* need it...

the machine will be used to store all our collective media (umpteen thousand cds and dvds) and then plugged into our network so we can all stream off wahtever we want whenever we want...

i am even looking to make it even more cheapness by dispensing with the monitor and maybe even keyboard and mouse, just borrowing someone's to install OS and requried things, and then just remote-accessing into it to sort things out from my laptop...

my ebuyer playing-around-with-session has come up with the following so far...any suggestions to make it *even cheaper*? (the storage is not a *great* issue at the moment, 200gb will be alright until payday...)


Superflower SF-702T1-BK ATX Case in Black With Side Window No PSU 056708 £13.99 £13.99

Ebuyer AC Power Lead (Kettle Type) Suitable for ATX PSU 020293 £0.99 £0.99

Ebuyer 400 Watt PSU P4 Ready 030288 £8.99 £8.99

Pcchips KT266A SKT A DDR AGP Sound LAN USB 2.0 Retail Box 059335 £12.99 £12.99

AMD DURON 1600 266FSB CPU - OEM 052134 £22.94 £22.94

Ebuyer 256MB DDR266 PC2100 Extra Value RAM 020929 £17.99 £17.99

Coolermaster CP5-6J31C Socket A Upto XP3000 AMD Approved
040758 £4.50 £4.50

Seagate ST3200822A Barracuda 7200.7 Plus 200gb Ultra ATA/100 7200rpm 8mb Cache 059736 £71.48 £71.48

SubTotal: £158.86 VAT: £27.84 Total: £186.70

Electrolyte01 29-07-2004 12:04

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Ebuyer 256mb DDR266, I have that, and also the PCChipes KT266A WHICH is REALLY the Syntax SV266A. AMD Duron 1600, for a few £ extra you can get the 1800. Oh by the way, if you get that board and a Duron, you need to update the BIOS if you want it to detect the Duron correctly. I had to update my BIOS so it actually said "AMD Duron 1800" not "Unknown CPU 1.8GHZ".

Great motherboard though, memory is good too :)

Gareth 29-07-2004 12:16

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
That mobo doesn't have any on-board grafx, so you'll need to add a cheapo card. No need to be extravagent, but you will need one, unless you have an old one lying around collecting dust.

timewarrior2001 29-07-2004 12:37

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
I agree with Bifta (for once :D )

Cheap as possible but buy decent drives with a good 3 or 5 year warranty.

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 12:41

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GDW1975
That mobo doesn't have any on-board grafx, so you'll need to add a cheapo card. No need to be extravagent, but you will need one, unless you have an old one lying around collecting dust.

oh yeh, forgot about that. that will add maybe another £50 on... still, that is a really cheap system... :D

timewarrior2001 29-07-2004 12:46

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
oh yeh, forgot about that. that will add maybe another £50 on... still, that is a really cheap system... :D

£50 for a cheapo GFX card????

look on ebuyer....


Pine SIS 315 AGP 4X 32MB VGA Retail Box


£14.12
£16.60 inc VAT



164 in stock (Usually ships same day)
QuickFind: 55029 (1 review)
Mfr part#: PVS04ABRHG

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 12:48

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by timewarrior2001
£50 for a cheapo GFX card????

look on ebuyer....


Pine SIS 315 AGP 4X 32MB VGA Retail Box


£14.12
£16.60 inc VAT



164 in stock (Usually ships same day)
QuickFind: 55029 (1 review)
Mfr part#: PVS04ABRHG

ok dont make me look like a fool :blush: i was guessing and didnt look... the last card i bought was a FX5200 so i was basing it on what i paid for that ;)

timewarrior2001 29-07-2004 12:51

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
ok dont make me look like a fool :blush: i was guessing and didnt look... the last card i bought was a FX5200 so i was basing it on what i paid for that ;)

Lol I bought one of them too, for about the same price, i guess I am qualified to call you a fool lmao :p:

poolking 29-07-2004 12:55

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
The only thing I hate about ebuyer is that for some of their stuff they use Initial City Link as their courier, their drivers are notoriously lazy when it comes to delivery, sometimes they'll attempt to deliver knock the door and don't give you enough time to answer before they disappear.

OldGeezer 29-07-2004 13:01

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
And stick a bare bones Linux system on it (free) - don't pay for an OS.

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 13:04

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OldGeezer
And stick a bare bones Linux system on it (free) - don't pay for an OS.

i tried red hat once not too long ago... im since scared of linux...what is good for an idiot's file server?

Electrolyte01 29-07-2004 13:06

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
ManDrake is much easier to use than RedHat ;)

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 13:18

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
does linux cope well with interacting with windows machines? (all other machines on the network will be windows).

i know it doesnt cope with ntfs well, but say for the average windows user, downloading a file and wanting to store it on the file server.... how easy would that be to work, cos of the different file systems etc?

ZrByte 29-07-2004 13:32

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Laptops dont use Deskstars, they use travelstars.
I have three different travelstar drives, 2x 10gb & 1x 40gb and they are all nice, quiet and reliable.
I also have 1x 120GB deskstar can't remember if it is 180GXP or 120GXP and that has been working great in my machine (Wich doubles up as a file server) my machine runs 24/7 and has done so since I had this drive installed over a year and a half ago.

So there :p:

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 13:34

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZrByte
Laptops dont use Deskstars, they use travelstars.
I have three different travelstar drives, 2x 10gb & 1x 40gb and they are all nice, quiet and reliable.
I also have 1x 120GB deskstar can't remember if it is 180GXP or 120GXP and that has been working great in my machine (Wich doubles up as a file server) my machine runs 24/7 and has done so since I had this drive installed over a year and a half ago.

So there :p:

oh stop being picky... ive a good mind to red-blob you for sticking you tongue out ;)

fine, i have a hitchati TRAVELSTAR that is louder than my cpu fan :p:

philip.j.fry 29-07-2004 13:37

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
does linux cope well with interacting with windows machines? (all other machines on the network will be windows).

i know it doesnt cope with ntfs well, but say for the average windows user, downloading a file and wanting to store it on the file server.... how easy would that be to work, cos of the different file systems etc?

Yes, it copes well :) All you need to do is install
Samba (Open Source, i.e. free) then all of your windows machines will be able to access the file server wih no problems. The filesystem that you choose on the file server can then be anything you choose and doesn't have to be NTFS (IBM's JFS seems to score well in benchmarks).

I really would reccomend using a Linux distro as you can switch off all unessential things like the GUI and have easy remote access via SSH.

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 14:10

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by philip.j.fry
Yes, it copes well :) All you need to do is install
Samba (Open Source, i.e. free) then all of your windows machines will be able to access the file server wih no problems. The filesystem that you choose on the file server can then be anything you choose and doesn't have to be NTFS (IBM's JFS seems to score well in benchmarks).

I really would reccomend using a Linux distro as you can switch off all unessential things like the GUI and have easy remote access via SSH.

hehe "unessential GUI"... i dont quite think i am ready to play around in command lines and terminals yet... :erm: too much of that was involved when i played with red hat a short while ago, it just gave me a headache :(

is mandrake free then, or do i have to pay? (bearing in mind i only have a craptacular internet connection for the forseeable future)...

poolking 29-07-2004 14:25

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Why don't get some kind person on here to burn some ISOs for you and then get them to post them to you? :)

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 14:31

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by poolking
Why don't get some kind person on here to burn some ISOs for you and then get them to post them to you? :)

beacuse no one on here likes me :mis: hehe ;)

philip.j.fry 29-07-2004 14:34

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
hehe "unessential GUI"... i dont quite think i am ready to play around in command lines and terminals yet... :erm: too much of that was involved when i played with red hat a short while ago, it just gave me a headache :(

You can switch it on and off easily, so when you're configuring the server you can switch it on and turn it off again when you don't need it. X-Windows is also network ready so you can use it remotely from a windows machine running an X terminal.

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 14:35

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by philip.j.fry
You can switch it on and off easily, so when you're configuring the server you can switch it on and turn it off again when you don't need it. X-Windows is also network ready so you can use it remotely from a windows machine running an X terminal.

lol..... you don't know me, even the simplest tasks can turn bad...

last time i played in linux i got it stuck at the command line interface and nothing on earth short of a reset would get it back into a graphical interface :disturbd:

philip.j.fry 29-07-2004 14:42

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
lol..... you don't know me, even the simplest tasks can turn bad...

last time i played in linux i got it stuck at the command line interface and nothing on earth short of a reset would get it back into a graphical interface :disturbd:

startx then ctrl-alt-backspace to get out :D

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 14:46

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by philip.j.fry
startx then ctrl-alt-backspace to get out :D

blergh cleverclogs :fit::Peace:

altis 29-07-2004 15:00

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Windows 95 OSR2.5 - small, cheap, fast, realiable and very familliar ;)

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 15:02

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
Windows 95 OSR2.5 - small, cheap, fast, realiable and very familliar ;)

you already said that, spammer :p:

ZrByte 29-07-2004 15:12

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
Windows 95 OSR2.5 - small, cheap, fast, realiable and very familliar ;)

Last time I used windows 95 it was OSR something I dont know if it was 2.5, it was poor for networking if used with any NT machine tried to access it (2k & XP in particular).

OldGeezer 29-07-2004 15:15

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by philip.j.fry
You can switch it on and off easily, so when you're configuring the server you can switch it on and turn it off again when you don't need it. X-Windows is also network ready so you can use it remotely from a windows machine running an X terminal.

Or alternatively access the whole linux desktop via VNC using the VNC XServer plugin.

altis 29-07-2004 15:24

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZrByte
Last time I used windows 95 it was OSR something I dont know if it was 2.5, it was poor for networking if used with any NT machine tried to access it (2k & XP in particular).

I have limited experience of 2K and XP but we have accessed the W95 fileserver from an XP laptop quite happily.

Millay 29-07-2004 16:23

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Hi my advice is take two options....

buy a second hand server from ebay, costs max should be able to pick one up for £300 put some more hard disks in you dont need high speed processors to serve files even if there media files. you just want fast hard disks.

Alternative, buy a decent power supply, and get a mobo that suspportts SATA and get a big sata drive, apart from PSU and harddrive i would g ofor value value value components.

I say get a decent PSU as you will be running this unit under considerable load 24/7/365 you wdont want heat power problems etc...

Also id advise running win xp as your OS simply for stability and its support for bigger disks and the NTFS file system...

just my 2pence worth

ZrByte 29-07-2004 16:28

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Millay
Hi my advice is take two options....

buy a second hand server from ebay, costs max should be able to pick one up for £300 put some more hard disks in you dont need high speed processors to serve files even if there media files. you just want fast hard disks.

Alternative, buy a decent power supply, and get a mobo that suspportts SATA and get a big sata drive, apart from PSU and harddrive i would g ofor value value value components.

I say get a decent PSU as you will be running this unit under considerable load 24/7/365 you wdont want heat power problems etc...

Also id advise running win xp as your OS simply for stability and its support for bigger disks and the NTFS file system...

just my 2pence worth

Also wortt not skimping on the motherboard, you dont need to get an uber expensive one, just not a dirt cheap one.
One thing that can really bring down a server is a flaky motherboard ;)

Millay 29-07-2004 17:11

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZrByte
flaky motherboard ;)

Yea motherboards with flakes on are worrying... strange joke ....


Yea i reckon you needent send more than £45 for a mobo with SATA, just steer clear of PC Chips £20 mobos lol

Shaun 29-07-2004 17:15

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
because no one on here likes me :mis: hehe ;)


If you need some ISO's downloading then give me a shout and I'll post them to you :)

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 17:54

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dellwear
If you need some ISO's downloading then give me a shout and I'll post them to you :)

thanks for the offer but tis fine, i have a university friend who getting them for me :)

Shaun 29-07-2004 18:00

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Stones
thanks for the offer but tis fine, i have a university friend who getting them for me :)

:tu:

Matth 29-07-2004 21:29

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Well, of the cheap case/PSU, I'd be inclined to go for a case WITH PSU - in the alternatives, there's an ATX WITH 400w PSU for l;ess than the price of the pair, and the PSU can't be any worse than an Ebuyer generic.
http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...duct_uid=56984

Mind you, in a machine that will run for a sustained perios, maybe the power supply is one area that a bit more money should be spent on

http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...duct_uid=43547 - Antec, quite a good name, but check the reviews - it seems they can disgrace themselves just as readily as a no-name.

Enermax is another name to look out for - Their 365W model will easily beat no-name 400w offerings.


You may also want to look at a motherboard with RAID - a very good idea for a fileserver.

Dave Stones 29-07-2004 22:09

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matth
Well, of the cheap case/PSU, I'd be inclined to go for a case WITH PSU - in the alternatives, there's an ATX WITH 400w PSU for l;ess than the price of the pair, and the PSU can't be any worse than an Ebuyer generic.
http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...duct_uid=56984

Mind you, in a machine that will run for a sustained perios, maybe the power supply is one area that a bit more money should be spent on

http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...duct_uid=43547 - Antec, quite a good name, but check the reviews - it seems they can disgrace themselves just as readily as a no-name.

Enermax is another name to look out for - Their 365W model will easily beat no-name 400w offerings.


You may also want to look at a motherboard with RAID - a very good idea for a fileserver.

have taken your suggestions on board, but no way on this earth would i have a case that colour... :erm:

Matth 30-07-2004 18:35

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...duct_uid=60388 - alright then, Grey and silver with 400w - and free shipping - can you build an entire system with free shipping items?

Seriously though, reliability of a combined case/PSU at these sort of prices, is as questionable as that of a generic PSU.

It may be worth looking at "overclocking stores" for a PSU, and I'd be inclined to favour a design with a single LARGE inside fan - 92mm or larger, as it should be less likely to suffer a stalled/choked fan

altis 04-08-2004 16:54

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
How about a Buffalo 120GB wired/wireless NAS for £155 + vat?

http://www.scan.co.uk/todayonly/

ZrByte 04-08-2004 20:22

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
How about a Buffalo 120GB wired/wireless NAS for £155 + vat?

http://www.scan.co.uk/todayonly/

Now thats impressive, just the sort of thing I was looking for, the only thing that doesnt sound too good is it says that it is all done through a web browser, if they are just reffering to configuration (Wich I hope they are) that good, if they mean needing a web browser for copying files then thats a bit pants.

altis 04-08-2004 21:11

Re: el-cheapo computers
 
Looks like you can access it just like a normal server share.

Drill down 'til you find the manual:
http://www.buffalotech.com/products/...?categoryid=10


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:03.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum