Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General IT Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Hard drive noise (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=14793)

Damien 13-07-2004 18:05

Hard drive noise
 
Right I own a 17inch Powerbook.

The hard drive is 80gb Hitachi hard drive and it is making really
loud noises all of a sudden. It sounds like its Wirring around
really really fast and the on-screen movement slows down
drasticlty when this happens.

I took it to apple when it done this a few months ago and they couldnt
find a problem so nothing was done and then when i got it back I didnt
find a problem so it fixed itself though long periods of inactivty or
when it was being taken to london the Drive got nudged?

Anyone know what it is?

ANyone know how to fix it?

ZrByte 13-07-2004 18:11

Re: Hard drive noise
 
The noise alone would just indicate that the bearing has gone, not a lot you can do really though this wouldnt affect the functionality of the drive.
Since your drive slows down when this happens I would say it sounds like the drive motor is slipping, in wich case the drive will probably just give up soon :(

Damien 13-07-2004 18:18

Re: Hard drive noise
 
But this happened months ago then nothing happened. Also the drive works and although it slows down it is not as drastic as the slow down experanced a few months ago.

Bloody apple hard drive going down right away

swoop101 13-07-2004 18:18

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Two things

1 back up quick

2 replace

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 18:21

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by swoop101
Two things

1 back up quick

2 replace



sage advice i reckon , it sounds as though it is on the way out big style :erm:

Damien 13-07-2004 18:23

Re: Hard drive noise
 
its a laptop its not as simple

It fixed it self a while ago why didnt it give up then

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 18:26

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
its a laptop its not as simple

It fixed it self a while ago why didnt it give up then


is the hard drive removable ????????? , if it is then you can get a cable to make it fit into a regular pc , ghost it onto a normal hard drive and away you go , if it isnt then :erm:

Damien 13-07-2004 18:28

Re: Hard drive noise
 
I can back up my stuff thats no problem its just the huge problem with taking the laptop to a apple place

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 18:30

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
I can back up my stuff thats no problem its just the huge problem with taking the laptop to a apple place



so its not removable then , i must admit to not being 'up' on apple gear :erm: , i reckon you are stuffed then , it is out of warranty isnt it ?????????

Damien 13-07-2004 18:31

Re: Hard drive noise
 
no its new, still in warranty.

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 18:33

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
no its new, still in warranty.



so go and beat them around the head with it , not literally though :erm: , it sounds as though you are getting the p!ss taken out of you , how far away is the nearest apple place from you ???????? , or , where did you buy it from , dont they want to know ??????????

Damien 13-07-2004 18:44

Re: Hard drive noise
 
They couldnt find a problem when i took it them a few months ago and then it worked fine when i got it back? Its only started again now

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 18:46

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
They couldnt find a problem when i took it them a few months ago and then it worked fine when i got it back? Its only started again now


so take it back then , surely they must realise you aint going back to them for the good of your health , its not like you are trying to get a refund out of them are you , all you want is a working usable machine :)

ZrByte 13-07-2004 18:50

Re: Hard drive noise
 
PCs are strange things, sometimes a problem will manifest quickly, sometimes it will subtly work its way in, it looks like you have the latter type of problem.
Though it hasnt broken yet you might not have a lot of options, I think you will have to wait until it blows before they will even entertain replacing it.
With your laptop beeing so new I assume it has a CD writer though, just make sure you keep everything backed up (Do it daily) and then when it blo0ws you wont lose much :)

Damien 13-07-2004 18:55

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Backing up is not a problem

1. When this happens the drive sounds like it is speeding up and then there is slow down

2. ONLY happens when being used i.e the laptop will run for days without any noise but heavy use will slow it down and cause noise. Unlike last time when i stop using it the noise will stop and use can carry on

3. Unlike last time the computer works fine, last time it would fail to start and the slow down would be so incredible nothing would work. Here the slow down meaning stuff like the UI is a bit delayed.

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 18:57

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Backing up is not a problem

1. When this happens the drive sounds like it is speeding up and then there is slow down

2. ONLY happens when being used i.e the laptop will run for days without any noise but heavy use will slow it down and cause noise. Unlike last time when i stop using it the noise will stop and use can carry on

3. Unlike last time the computer works fine, last time it would fail to start and the slow down would be so incredible nothing would work. Here the slow down meaning stuff like the UI is a bit delayed.


so demonstrate that to them :)

Damien 13-07-2004 19:00

Re: Hard drive noise
 
the problem wont happen when i take it them most likely

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 19:04

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
the problem wont happen when i take it them most likely



ok then is it insured :erm:

Damien 13-07-2004 19:06

Re: Hard drive noise
 
lol yeah

Screw that. THere must be some other way to repair this

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 19:10

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
lol yeah

Screw that. THere must be some other way to repair this


yeah , it was a bit tongue in cheek , mind you if you dont keep at them then they are going to get away with it and come end of warranty time YOU are gonna be the one with the problem :erm: , was it bought on a credit card , if it was then i thought you might have had some protection built in from the credit company , then again i might be talking total and utter *****e :erm: :erm: :erm:

Damien 13-07-2004 19:12

Re: Hard drive noise
 
doesnt run out until 1st march. So i will be able to get a good idea by then.

If the problem oes slove it self by friday i will take it down

Damien 13-07-2004 20:02

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Anyone have any ideas?

I tell you next time its a alienware laptop

Paul K 13-07-2004 20:13

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Anyway of recording the noise it makes on a tape recorder or mobile phone?

paulyoung666 13-07-2004 20:15

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul
Anyway of recording the noise it makes on a tape recorder or mobile phone?


or maybe a camcorder showing what happens on screen as well as picking up the sound :)

Stuartbe 13-07-2004 20:18

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Just a thought !

Check the event logs and see if there are any errors listed. It seems a bit strange that the hard drive would slow the pc down like that unless it was reading or writing from the drive at the time of the slowdown.

It may be worth checking the cpu cooling fan as if the fan is dodgey then the cpu may be overheating and slowing the system down ( a lot of cpu's will clock down if they start to overheat )

I may be barking up the wrong tree in the wrong forrest but its worth checking. Is the laptop unusualy hot when this happens ?

Damien 13-07-2004 20:33

Re: Hard drive noise
 
you may be on to something as i mentioned before it only show it-self when there is user actvity NOT when it is not is use. As i am typing this no noise but if i use to start itunes and surf web it will start again

Paul K 13-07-2004 20:36

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Think Stuart is right, you need to try and pinpoint the source of the sound, it could just be a dirty fan.

Damien 13-07-2004 20:39

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Let me get this right. when usage increases the fan will start working to cool the hard drive more? if the fan is dirty then that causes the noise

Paul K 13-07-2004 20:40

Re: Hard drive noise
 
The fan speed will increase to cool the CPU etc so it may be a dodgy fan causing an increase in noise when the cpu is under load. Have you got a piece of benchmarking software you can run to stress the unit to see if the noise is linked to CPU load or just hard drive access?

Stuartbe 13-07-2004 20:41

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
Let me get this right. when usage increases the fan will start working to cool the hard drive more? if the fan is dirty then that causes the noise

The fan will just cool the cpu as far as I know. I may be wrong as I am not an apple techie...

I think its worth check out anyway.. Next time the noise starts listen at the air oulet ( usualy at the back ) and see if it is very loud there.

From what you are saying about running the web and Itunes it does sound more like the hard drive as both of there operations will access the hdd.

Paul K 13-07-2004 20:47

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Is the hard drive not SMART enabled or come with any diagnostic software at all?

Damien 13-07-2004 20:50

Re: Hard drive noise
 
yeah it is the HD. I just checked but there is a air vent right next to it so its confusing

roger_smith 13-07-2004 20:51

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Damien, you tried the Hardware test disc that came with your Powerbook?

Paul K 13-07-2004 20:52

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Do you know the exact model of hard drive in there at all?

Damien 13-07-2004 20:57

Re: Hard drive noise
 
tried hardware text came out fine and it is a hitachi HD not sure of the exact model

Paul K 13-07-2004 21:03

Re: Hard drive noise
 
From
http://www.hitachigst.com/hdd/support/macfaqs.htm
Quote:

We do not provide any diagnostic or installation software for Macintosh systems. Apple provides a Drive Setup utility that comes with the operating system. The Macintosh operating system also includes a diagnostic utility called Disk First Aid. Disk First Aid is located in the same utility folder as Drive Setup. Also, there are other third party companies that provide diagnostic and installation software for Macintosh systems. See your Macintosh system documentation for more information about installing disk drives and running diagnostics.

Damien 13-07-2004 21:07

Re: Hard drive noise
 
none of the software stuff works

roger_smith 13-07-2004 21:29

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Try asking on the apple discussion forums http://discussions.info.apple.com/, personnally im stumpted, maybe youve just ended up with a bad egg as it were?

edit, lol just checked myself, he just posted on there :)

Damien 13-07-2004 21:33

Re: Hard drive noise
 
i think it may be the fan, how can i clear it

roger_smith 13-07-2004 21:37

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Theres a vent there right?
Can you shine a light there and see if its spinning smoothly?

Damien 29-07-2004 20:38

Re: Hard drive noise
 
NEW Development!

Ok, the problem has got worse but heres the thing, If i shake the laptop lightly (or even just gently tip it left and then right) the noise stops and the laptop works fine for a few mintues but then the noise starts again :( but what could it mean that tipping it sloves the problem for a bit?

SMHarman 03-08-2004 17:34

Re: Hard drive noise
 
Fan or something spinning with a dodgy bearing.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:59.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum