Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General IT Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   DVD writers (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=12423)

bonzoe 16-05-2004 16:40

DVD writers
 
Hi, I'm thinking of getting a DVD writer. I have a few questions:
1) What is the dominant format?
2) Are there any compatibility issues betwen formats (I guess there are)?
3) Any recommendations for a writer?

Thanks

SMHarman 16-05-2004 16:44

Re: DVD writers
 
1) +R and -R are both fairly dominant. +RAM is far more specialised.
2) All three require a compatible player to read the disk, otherwise it's like trying to get a PC to read a mac formatted floppy. Most are now +/- multiread.
-R is normally the most compatible for TV DVD boxes.
3) Pioneer / Sony / NEC / Panasonic (has RAM) are all good to start with.

kronas 16-05-2004 16:55

Re: DVD writers
 
personally i would recommend a -/+ r combined drive and the pionner models are excellent for compatability and reliability.

paulyoung666 16-05-2004 17:08

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman
1) +R and -R are both fairly dominant. +RAM is far more specialised.
2) All three require a compatible player to read the disk, otherwise it's like trying to get a PC to read a mac formatted floppy. Most are now +/- multiread.
-R is normally the most compatible for TV DVD boxes.
3) Pioneer / Sony / NEC / Panasonic (has RAM) are all good to start with.


i thought +r was the most compatible , never mind , at the price they are now they are virtually throwaway items , get a dual or including ram one :)

punky 16-05-2004 17:30

Re: DVD writers
 
SMH said it all pretty well, but i'd just add that a DVD-RAM disk is just like a removable hard disk, but can only be read by a DVD-RAM drive, and they are few and far between. Also, -R tends to be cheaper so more heavily used/easier to find disks for.

I've got the NEC 2500. Burns great, no coasters so far, even with the dirt cheap Ritek disks. It's reading isn't so good though, but for burning it is probably the best. I'd recommend it if you already have a good DVD reader in the computer already. Best for reading/writing balance is the Pioneer A06/A07. Pioneer has managed to turn it into a dual layer (9 gig on 1 CD side) burner by altering the firmware, so even if they don't release it, some clever bloke will probably release hacked firware for it, therefore future proofing it.

Defiant 16-05-2004 18:16

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
at the price they are now they are virtually throwaway items , get a dual or including ram one :)

Thats because there loosing the race for domination ;)

The - brand is winning so far

Matth 16-05-2004 21:04

Re: DVD writers
 
The ND2500 appears to be hackable for dual layer support, at least, the CD/DVD forums seem to be full of converting 2500 to 2510 with a firmware hack - does it make a GOOD dual layer writer though, not quite so certain.

check out www.cdrinfo.com - they've reviewed quite a number of them.

Tricky 16-05-2004 22:24

Re: DVD writers
 
- Media tends to be a little cheaper I've found
I personally use two devices:
Sony DRU500A which seems to do every format under the sun!
HP DVD Writer??? that only does +

I have had compatibility issues with the - Media on one device (not listed above) but I ain't saying which!

andygrif 17-05-2004 10:22

Re: DVD writers
 
I'm waiting on the new Plextor PX-712 - which is the first drive to burn at 12 speed. I may not actually buy it, but hopefully when it's introduced it will lower the cost of the PX-708 (8 speed) drive which always does very well in every review.

sherer 17-05-2004 11:20

Re: DVD writers
 
can anyone explain the difference between the Pioneer A07 and DVR107.. they both seem to be the same but abit different in price.. apart from quicker speed what do you get for buying a dearer model..

can't find any in blue though and i got a blue case if anyone knows a made that sells in this colour let me know..

altis 17-05-2004 11:56

Re: DVD writers
 
This document describes the five different formats (although some of the info is a bit old):
http://homepage.ntlworld.com/altisuk/temp/dvdformat.pdf

For a cheap drive that supports ALL formats try this (currently £50.75 + delivery and VAT from Scan - and often available in 'Today Only' deals):
http://www.lge.co.uk/mod_perl/go.pl/...oduct_uid=2741

punky 17-05-2004 12:11

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sherer
can anyone explain the difference between the Pioneer A07 and DVR107.. they both seem to be the same but abit different in price.. apart from quicker speed what do you get for buying a dearer model..

can't find any in blue though and i got a blue case if anyone knows a made that sells in this colour let me know..

The 107 is what is called retail. It is an all inclusive kit. You get software with it, mounting screws everything. The A07 is what is called OEM. It is for advanced people that build computers, and is literally just the bare drive. No software, screws, cables, etc.

Mr_love_monkey 17-05-2004 12:14

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
(currently £50.75 + delivery and VAT from Scan - and often available in 'Today Only' deals)

Scan have currently got a week long special on DVD writers. might be worth taking a look

sherer 17-05-2004 12:17

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
This document describes the five different formats (although some of the info is a bit old):
http://homepage.ntlworld.com/altisuk/temp/dvdformat.pdf

For a cheap drive that supports ALL formats try this (currently £50.75 + delivery and VAT from Scan - and often available in 'Today Only' deals):
http://www.lge.co.uk/mod_perl/go.pl/...oduct_uid=2741

thanks for the link.. gone for the LG one on scan.. saw that cheaper elsewhere but you get the discs and nero etc with scan and this does RAM as well. not sure if i will use all of that but looked like the best deal..

bonzoe 17-05-2004 20:00

Re: DVD writers
 
Thanks everyone, interesting reading

sherer 18-05-2004 09:49

Re: DVD writers
 
my LB +- /RAM drive arrived today.. it's an OEM version which is fine as i've got IDE cables and have a screwless case. Will install it over the next few days and let you know what i think

blackthorn 18-05-2004 13:15

Re: DVD writers
 
I`ve noticed a lot of these OEM writers out there and they are a lot cheaper but what I want to know is, exactly what will I need to install one in my pc. I`ve got a spare bay and when I looked inside my pc, the ide cable that goes to the drive that I`ve already got has a spur coming off it.

sherer 18-05-2004 13:27

Re: DVD writers
 
basically OEM is what the manufacturers buy.. it's just the drive itself.. no screws.. no cables.. no software etc.. you can run 2 drives off one IDE cable with the spur you have noticed.. just set one to master one to slave.. it's quicker to use a seperate IDE cable but your motherboard might not have any spare slots.. you will need to get the screws to put it in the slot.. most cases come with spares if not i'm sure you can take one out and take to a DIY shop and get some.. you will need to get the burning software some places sell these with the OEM version but most don't so be carefull..

SMHarman 18-05-2004 13:35

Re: DVD writers
 
Any drivers you need can be downloaded from the manufacturers site. If you are replacing a CD drive then you already have all the screws etc.

OEM stands for Original Equipment Manufacturer.

blackthorn 18-05-2004 13:35

Re: DVD writers
 
Thanks, as I`ve already got burning software, Nero and Sonic recordnow, all I need then are screws, which I can take out of an old scrap pc that I`ve got upstairs.
Cheers.

altis 28-05-2004 16:50

Re: DVD writers
 
*** Update Update ***

Check out the Hitachi / LG GSA-4120B available from Scan for £68 + delivery + VAT.

Quote:

Write
[DVD-R] : 2x, 4x CLV, 8x ZCLV
[DVD-RW] : 1x, 2x, 4x CLV
[DVD-RAM] : 2x, 3x ZCLV, 3x-5x PCAV (Ver.2.1)
[DVD+R] : SL - 2.4x, 4x CLV, 8x, 12x ZCLV; DL - 2.4x CLV
[DVD+RW] : 2.4x, 4x CLV
[CD-R] : 4x, 8x, 16x CLV, 24x, 32x, 40x ZCLV
[CD-RW] : 4x, 8x, 10x, 16x CLV, 24x ZCLV
Read
[DVD-R/RW/ROM] : 10x/8x/16x Max.
[DVD-RAM(Ver.2.1)] : 2x, 3x ZCLV, 3x-5x PCAV
[DVD+R/+RW] : SL - 10x Max. DL - 8x Max. / 8x Max.
[CD-R/RW/ROM] : 40x Max.
...and dual-layer too!

paulyoung666 28-05-2004 17:15

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by altis
*** Update Update ***

Check out the Hitachi / LG GSA-4120B available from Scan for £68 + delivery + VAT.


...and dual-layer too!


dual layer for that price :Yikes: , me wonders how pcworld manage to charge a seemingly rip off £150 for a sony dual layer writer :shocked:

Juan 29-05-2004 23:22

Re: DVD writers
 
Can any1 recommend the best value media for a NEC 1300A to burn mpeg's etc 2 play on a TV DVD player. I've Been looking on Ebuyer , they've got 25 Infiniti white top DVD-R's for just under a tenner; but I'm unsure whether its worth paying the extra for Verbatim disks - seen a 5 pack of DVD-R's for £3 in the 'The Computer Shop'.

cheers

Edit:
Ebuyer link doesn't work 4 some reason
http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...=ASC&offset=30

bbwannabe 29-05-2004 23:38

Re: DVD writers
 
Get your media from Blankdiscshop.co.uk. Highly recommended. I can't recommend what type of media you should get for your burner, sorry. But ritek and ridata or ridisc should be ok.

Pea-Pod 30-05-2004 00:14

Re: DVD writers
 
Is dual layer better then? From reading what I have so far, I think I too will go for the LG one from Scan, it's OEM but hopefully I can get the screws and download all necessary drives from the manufactorers website, I've got burning software also. Very usefull thread this one.

bbwannabe 30-05-2004 00:18

Re: DVD writers
 
personally id be happy to wait for a dual layer, but not till the speed of its burning picks up. From what i recall the fastest burn time for a full dual layer is something around 80 minutes!!! (Im hoping thats wrong).
Anyway for me its still early, and unless your backing up movies without either cutting bits out or reducing quality to fit onto a single dvd, theres not much else.

Till then im gonna get a pioneer 107 :)

Pea-Pod 31-05-2004 17:42

Re: DVD writers
 
I still can't decide between the LG 4120BB OEM Ivory DUAL LAYER DVD-Writer or the Pioneer 107 :confused:

Tristan 31-05-2004 19:07

Re: DVD writers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bbwannabe
personally id be happy to wait for a dual layer, but not till the speed of its burning picks up. From what i recall the fastest burn time for a full dual layer is something around 80 minutes!!! (Im hoping thats wrong).

If it is the case, then it's far more likely to be a media limitation than a drive limitation.

The first CD writers were limited by the computers that ran them; it took a comparatively large amount of horsepower to be able to calculate all the error correction and stuff needed for a CD, and of course any burner needs a constant stream of data or you've got a coaster on your hands. Since then, computers have got much more powerful, memory has got cheaper (so CD writers can have built-in caches) and the situation has improved to such a degree that you can write a CD at 52 speed (52 times standard audio CD speed being roughly the fastest you can spin a CD without the g-forces warping it too much to make it readable).

It's taken a while for the media to catch up though. A recordable CD is in simple terms a thin layer of very special material sandwiched between two layers of transparent plastic. This material is special because it has the property that when you fire a laser of a particular frequency at it, it will melt and chrystalise in a different way, thus changing the reflective properties. CD-RWs are even cleverer, because they'll change back again if you fire a different frequency at them. The difficulty has been in the chemistry of finding a material that will change over in the incredibly brief laser flash of a 52x burn. I think the best they're up to now is 48x, and that's probably the best there'll ever be now that the focus has changed to DVDs.

I think it's probably the chemistry that kept 8x burners from the market for so long. DVDs spin much faster and have far smaller pits than CDs, making the task more difficult. Four a dual-layered device, you'd need effectively 4 chemical states for every pit on the DVD... well, you can see the difficulty.


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:00.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum