Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General IT Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Photo Stitching (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=11693)

gary_580 28-04-2004 23:04

Photo Stitching
 
Can anyone recommend any good photo stitching software. Software to stitch a panoranic scene together.

The photostich that Canon produce is trying to be too automated and doesnt work too well

Bifta 28-04-2004 23:29

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
Can anyone recommend any good photo stitching software. Software to stitch a panoranic scene together.

The photostich that Canon produce is trying to be too automated and doesnt work too well

I found the Canon one pretty tasty, especially if I took all the photo's on a motorized tripod :D It's the only one I've used unfortunately so couldn't really recommend any others.

gary_580 28-04-2004 23:34

Re: Photo Stitching
 
i found the joins to be a bit dodgy at times. Some are ok but some are poor.

Tried PTGui which looks good as you can specify the match points. Just seemed to crop the picture badly

ian@huth 28-04-2004 23:41

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
I found the Canon one pretty tasty, especially if I took all the photo's on a motorized tripod :D It's the only one I've used unfortunately so couldn't really recommend any others.

You really do need a tripod to make panoramic scenes as it is virtually impossible to hold a camera in a position that enables all perspectives to align properly without one.

Tezcatlipoca 28-04-2004 23:48

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
Can anyone recommend any good photo stitching software. Software to stitch a panoranic scene together.

The photostich that Canon produce is trying to be too automated and doesnt work too well

I've not really had any problems with the Canon one, but...

Adobe Photoshop Elements 2 has a photo merge function to create panoramic pics.

It's a lot cheaper than it's big brother, Photoshop CS, & IMO is a very good step up from the ArcSoft PhotoImpression (?) software you get with a Canon digicam.

gary_580 29-04-2004 10:00

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tezcatlipoca
I've not really had any problems with the Canon one, but...

Adobe Photoshop Elements 2 has a photo merge function to create panoramic pics.

It's a lot cheaper than it's big brother, Photoshop CS, & IMO is a very good step up from the ArcSoft PhotoImpression (?) software you get with a Canon digicam.


Thanks for that, Photoshop elements 2 came with the camera. Never thought to look to see if it did stitching. I'll take a look tonight

altis 29-04-2004 10:10

Re: Photo Stitching
 
I use Corel Photo-Paint and a lot of jiggling by hand. It's very time consuming and not very professional. You can see some of the results on my website.

PC Pro have recently reviewed Stitcher 4 by Realviz, it looks very good but is pricey - £250 + vat!

andygrif 29-04-2004 11:20

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Another vote for Photoshop Elements....very sinple and excellent results.

Tezcatlipoca 29-04-2004 13:26

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
Thanks for that, Photoshop elements 2 came with the camera. Never thought to look to see if it did stitching. I'll take a look tonight

You got PSE with the camera? Cool. Good deal? I got it seperately. It's a great prog. Not as featured as "proper" Photoshop, but still great for someone like me.

What camera do you have, btw?

Bifta 29-04-2004 13:30

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Just wondering, does Photoshop CS do stitching? (p.s. I've also just got a new camera, flogged my Canon A80 and bought a Canon Powershot G5, very nice, very chunky)

SMHarman 29-04-2004 13:51

Re: Photo Stitching
 
The cannon CD has some stiching software on it. DUnno how good it is though.

gary_580 29-04-2004 13:59

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman
The cannon CD has some stiching software on it. DUnno how good it is though.

As stated in the forst post in the thread

"The photostich that Canon produce is trying to be too automated and doesnt work too well"

gary_580 29-04-2004 14:00

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tezcatlipoca
You got PSE with the camera? Cool. Good deal? I got it seperately. It's a great prog. Not as featured as "proper" Photoshop, but still great for someone like me.

What camera do you have, btw?

Canon D300 (Rebel)

gary_580 29-04-2004 14:02

Re: Photo Stitching
 
i tried Photoshop elements 2 and the megre process. Results werent brilliant either. The skyline was all jagged. Maybe it was my poor panning that caused it

Bifta 29-04-2004 14:02

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
Canon D300 (Rebel)

Nice camera!

SMHarman 29-04-2004 14:03

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
As stated in the forst post in the thread

"The photostich that Canon produce is trying to be too automated and doesnt work too well"

:dunce:

gary_580 29-04-2004 14:09

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Nice camera!


BTW i got it from www.7dayshop.com

Would recommend them. Cheapest uk based price. Yes based in Guernsey, but you get a good price, good service, free delivery and NO import tax

Bifta 29-04-2004 14:18

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
BTW i got it from www.7dayshop.com

Would recommend them. Cheapest uk based price. Yes based in Guernsey, but you get a good price, good service, free delivery and NO import tax

\

599! That's a damn good price, I paid 429 for the G5 :( I should have waited until next payday and bought the 300D instead, mind you Jessops do a 30 day money back, no quibble guarantee so I'll test the G5 out on Sunday, if it's crap I'll take it back

gary_580 29-04-2004 15:09

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
\

599! That's a damn good price, I paid 429 for the G5 :( I should have waited until next payday and bought the 300D instead, mind you Jessops do a 30 day money back, no quibble guarantee so I'll test the G5 out on Sunday, if it's crap I'll take it back


ive got a powershot s40 that ive had for a couple of years and i thought it was good (until i tried the 300D). Tried it will a 300mm lense which is affectivey a 480mm lense on this camera, the light was low but the results were AMAZING managed.

My advice? Take it back to Jessops!!!

dont forget 599 is the body only price

Bifta 29-04-2004 15:13

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
ive got a powershot s40 that ive had for a couple of years and i thought it was good (until i tried the 300D). Tried it will a 300mm lense which is affectivey a 480mm lense on this camera, the light was low but the results were AMAZING managed.

My advice? Take it back to Jessops!!!

dont forget 599 is the body only price

The wha? Does that mean it includes no innards or just no lense? I've already found an issue with the G5 :( taking photo's with the flash in wide angle causes a shadow in the bottom right of the photo, did a quick mooch round for reviews of the camera and it turns out other's have the same problem, it also manages to create nasty purple halo's around lights with night shots, but the A80 did exactly the same. The A80 though was perfect for day time/low light scenery shots which is mainly what I used it for, not sure I can stretch to (or get away with) buying an E300 yet.

gary_580 29-04-2004 16:04

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
The wha? Does that mean it includes no innards or just no lense? I've already found an issue with the G5 :( taking photo's with the flash in wide angle causes a shadow in the bottom right of the photo, did a quick mooch round for reviews of the camera and it turns out other's have the same problem, it also manages to create nasty purple halo's around lights with night shots, but the A80 did exactly the same. The A80 though was perfect for day time/low light scenery shots which is mainly what I used it for, not sure I can stretch to (or get away with) buying an E300 yet.


Yes body only means it has no lens. They sell it like this as it accepts the EF lenses which if you have a Canon SLR like i do, the lenses fit the D300 body.

However as the focal length is multiplied by 1.6 the 18mm to whatever it is lens that comes with it is very useful as this makes a 30mm to whatever lens

JediMaster 29-04-2004 16:17

Re: Photo Stitching
 
I have had this FREE with my Chepo Camera :pp

http://www.ulead.com/cool360/runme.htm

Does the JOB for me..
Simple & cheap

Tezcatlipoca 29-04-2004 19:44

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
Just wondering, does Photoshop CS do stitching?

Yep -

"Top Ten Favourite New Features in Photoshop CS"

Quote:

2) Photomerge Feature in Photoshop CS
Previously introduced in Photoshop Elements, the Photomerge features has been brought over to Photoshop CS and enhanced to accomodate much larger images. Photomerge automatically arranges and seamlessly combines multiple images to create a panorama.
Quote:

(p.s. I've also just got a new camera, flogged my Canon A80 and bought a Canon Powershot G5, very nice, very chunky)
Ooh, nice. I've still got an A70. Had it for about a year. Probably get a new digicam (Canon again) later this year.


Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
Canon D300 (Rebel)


Mmmmm :drool: :D


Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
BTW i got it from www.7dayshop.com

Would recommend them. Cheapest uk based price. Yes based in Guernsey, but you get a good price, good service, free delivery and NO import tax

Cheers. I'll add that to my favourites :)



Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
ive got a powershot s40 that ive had for a couple of years and i thought it was good (until i tried the 300D). Tried it will a 300mm lense which is affectivey a 480mm lense on this camera, the light was low but the results were AMAZING managed.

Cool.

I don't think I'd stretch to a 300D, but I may go for an S50 at some point.

Quote:

My advice? Take it back to Jessops!!!
...and don't get anything else from them ;)

Maggy 29-04-2004 19:58

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Damn! I did once have a tutorial for this for Photoshop but as usual I can't find it.I'll keep looking.

Incog.

Sipowicz 29-04-2004 20:17

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bifta
The wha? Does that mean it includes no innards or just no lense? I've already found an issue with the G5 :( taking photo's with the flash in wide angle causes a shadow in the bottom right of the photo, did a quick mooch round for reviews of the camera and it turns out other's have the same problem, it also manages to create nasty purple halo's around lights with night shots, but the A80 did exactly the same. The A80 though was perfect for day time/low light scenery shots which is mainly what I used it for, not sure I can stretch to (or get away with) buying an E300 yet.

The "halo" effect is also known as "Purple fringeing" and is common amongst some digicams. The G5 is a super camera and was top of my list for a compact digital camera, but I took the plunge and went for the EOS10D. It uses the same image processor as the 300D, but puts it all into a tougher body with a greater degree of customisation of its features, hence the higher price. That said, if you do not want that sophistication, then the 300D is an excellent choice. I have handled the 300D and find it smaller than the 35mm cameras I am used to handling, but they do offer an extended battery grip, that holds 2 batteries and offers a vertical shutter release. It doe smake it easier to hold (but heavier!)
Our friends at 7dayshop also offer clone batteries for these cameras (the 10D, 300D and the G5 use the same battery) at very good prices. The official Canon BP511 will set you back @£55. The clones will cost £15 each. I have 2 of them and have had no problems.

Matth 29-04-2004 20:48

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Another Panorama tools based frontend
http://hugin.sourceforge.net/


Check out the tutorials
http://hugin.sourceforge.net/tutorials/index.shtml

gary_580 29-04-2004 22:03

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sipowicz
Our friends at 7dayshop also offer clone batteries for these cameras (the 10D, 300D and the G5 use the same battery) at very good prices. The official Canon BP511 will set you back @£55. The clones will cost £15 each. I have 2 of them and have had no problems.

i bought clone batteries from www.mydigitaldiscount.com there $10.99 for the 1400 mAh ones so last long than the originals. Carriage is $22.00 so its not generally woth ordering them. However the Sandisk Extreme compactflash cards are a very good price of about $210 so worth buying batteries then. Also placed order with them on Tuesday (theyre in New York), they dispatch by UPS and i had the stuff in my hands on Thursday which i thought was VERY impressive

gary_580 29-04-2004 22:05

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matth
Another Panorama tools based frontend
http://hugin.sourceforge.net/


Check out the tutorials
http://hugin.sourceforge.net/tutorials/index.shtml


Looks the same as PTGui

Sipowicz 29-04-2004 22:33

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gary_580
i bought clone batteries from www.mydigitaldiscount.com Also placed order with them on Tuesday (theyre in New York), they dispatch by UPS and i had the stuff in my hands on Thursday which i thought was VERY impressive

Very I'd say!

I did find that my 10D does not like the cheaper CF cards (Integral is the brand) I use Sandisk without any problems whatsoever!

Bifta 30-04-2004 00:00

Re: Photo Stitching
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sipowicz
The "halo" effect is also known as "Purple fringeing"

Or Chromatic Abberation (though, I'm not sure if that's the american spelling). It's bloody annoying, Derry looks really impressive if you look down to the quay from the new Foyle Bridge at night, but try and take a picture and the amount of street/building lights totally ruins it for Canon cameras. I was going to buy a Sony DSC-F717, the shape put me off initially, I grew to like it after looking at several photo's of it, and ordered it from pixmania last night, they then emailed me and told me I'd have to head 3 or 4 miles into town, find a fax machine and fax a copy of a recent utility bill to some french fax number ... I then cancelled the order, drove into town and bought the G5 from Jessops, so far I'm a bit unimpressed, the lens obscures half of the damn viewfinder!

altis 06-05-2004 18:27

Re: Photo Stitching
 
1 Attachment(s)
If you're interested in stitching then you may want to check out the work of Lawrence George Giles.

His exhibition of 50+ stiched photographs of britain's piers is currently on show at Blackpool (opposite the funfair). These pictures are stunning. You can't see the joins and, often, the same person will appear several times in the same photograph - recommended.


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:09.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum