Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Andy Burnham’s chronicles (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33713884)

Hugh 23-07-2026 17:56

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
"glorified"?

When was that?

thenry 23-07-2026 18:14

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Maybe not quite glorified :o: more so said with conviction ;)

Hugh 23-07-2026 19:45

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by thenry (Post 36220113)
Maybe not quite glorified :o: more so said with conviction ;)

When?

thenry 23-07-2026 19:49

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36220115)
When?

Knock yourself out

https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=mahmood+40%25+prison

jem 23-07-2026 20:18

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
OK look not glorified but rather proposed an answer to the issue that there are only ‘x' number of places in prisons with ‘y’ number of people being given custodial sentences.

Something has to give.

Prisons have two functions, punishment (I’m sure it’s not pleasant being locked up), and security, removing a dangerous person from society, so he or she can’t harm anyone else. The latter is a given, but the former, are their alternatives to prison as a punishment?

Now I’m certainly not saying that someone convicted of murdering a family gets a sentence of ‘painting a few walls’; but is there has to be somewhere in between prison and a fine. And I don't know what that might be.

Or, follow the US model and build and staff a lot more prisons.

Hugh 23-07-2026 20:54

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by thenry (Post 36220116)

Nice try, but no cigar…

https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2026/07/2.gif

papa smurf 24-07-2026 08:08

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
this no 10 north is a bit misleading as far as i can see manchester is further south than cleethorpes which is in the east midlands,it's just a con to work from home,no 10 north should be in newcastle

Hugh 24-07-2026 09:09

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
York - it’s further north than Cleethorpes, and it’s less than two hours by train…

Anyway, fun fact - Edinburgh is further to the West than Newcastle… :)

TheDaddy 24-07-2026 10:31

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jem (Post 36220117)
OK look not glorified but rather proposed an answer to the issue that there are only ‘x' number of places in prisons with ‘y’ number of people being given custodial sentences.

Something has to give.

Prisons have two functions, punishment (I’m sure it’s not pleasant being locked up), and security, removing a dangerous person from society, so he or she can’t harm anyone else. The latter is a given, but the former, are their alternatives to prison as a punishment?

Now I’m certainly not saying that someone convicted of murdering a family gets a sentence of ‘painting a few walls’; but is there has to be somewhere in between prison and a fine. And I don't know what that might be.

Or, follow the US model and build and staff a lot more prisons.


No one sane would follow the US model on prisons anymore than they would on healthcare, where the system is designed to disincentivies rehabilitation and reform over profit, where the prisons actually make people worse after they have entered just to ensure they keep coming back.

Personally I wouldn't let anyone out of prison here who couldn't read or write, what chance does anyone have of achieving anything without these basic skills (unless they have learning disabilities or such like) and I think it might be best to increase sentences no more of this 3 or 6 months business, I'm sure that studies proved if you want to tackle recidivism the sentence has to be 2 years +, no more of this revolving door nonsense.

Carth 24-07-2026 10:34

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Hands up anyone that thinks there's a faint possibility HS2 will now get back on track (ha) for the Manchester connection

papa smurf 24-07-2026 11:47

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36220137)
Hands up anyone that thinks there's a faint possibility HS2 will now get back on track (ha) for the Manchester connection

we need all our money to import and care for andys armada of mega dingy migrants,and doorway dwelling junkies,not to mention what coronation street norf will cost

RichardCoulter 25-07-2026 01:37

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
I've always wondered why, for lower level crimes & non violent offenders who aren't addicted to drugs etc, why they don't effectively put them under house arrest? With the use of tags/spot checks, they are still deprived of their liberty & inconvenienced at little financial cost to society.

Perhaps they could be allowed to go out to work, for medical appointments etc, but nothing more.

Hom3r 25-07-2026 16:53

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
He came to The Hare Inn, in Harlow last week, where he announced the 20% cut in tax for pubs etc

1andrew1 26-07-2026 19:57

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36220139)
we need all our money to import and care for andys armada of mega dingy migrants,and doorway dwelling junkies,not to mention what coronation street norf will cost

Record low number of people coming in small boats to date this year. Starmer delivered in two years what the Conservative Party failed to achieve in 14. He was ineffective in getting his message out. Burnham seems to be a far better communicator so I'm sure we'll be hearing about this success in due course.

I'm not sure how tackling the homeless issue will fare and I thought that was an unusual policy to feature first. Tackling the cost of living seemed more in tune with voters' most pressing concerns.

Jaymoss 27-07-2026 08:27

Re: Andy Burnham’s chronicles
 
Has his plans to possibly scrap council tax and stamp duty in favour of a tax on property or land @ 0.48% of value.

I do not see how this works for anyone. Stamp duty lost has to be made up so renters who do not own will have to be paying towards the loss and buyers who have already paid stamp duty will essentially be paying it again over and over


https://www.express.co.uk/news/polit...tax-new-charge


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:50.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum