Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33659204)

martyh 26-07-2010 20:21

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
if that's the case we could all claim freebies from our companies
unite aren't doing themselves any favours are they ,any support they had from the public will go up in a puff of aviation fumes

Damien 26-07-2010 20:24

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
If I understand correctly you are only prevented from firing someone due to strike action if your singling them out. It's ok to fire the entire lot? So why can't they do that and employ staff from other airlines who will presumably be quick to train, security cleared, and jump at the chance to move to the highest paying employer?

It's not as if this industrial action will end any time soon maybe it's time to bite the unpleasant bullet.

---------- Post added at 21:24 ---------- Previous post was at 21:23 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35062899)
if that's the case we could all claim freebies from our companies
unite aren't doing themselves any favours are they ,any support they had from the public will go up in a puff of aviation fumes

The day their ban on striking was overturned they rode past my office (it's not too far from the high court) in a open top bus cheering and waving unite flags. :rolleyes:

Hom3r 26-07-2010 20:30

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Sorry but they are extracting the urine, its time the termination of employment started.

Greed in this employment market has to end NOW.

frogstamper 26-07-2010 20:35

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Seems to me that when disputes become this intractable both sides should replace their chief negotiators, by this stage its only human nature that it has become personal with neither side wanting to lose face.

martyh 26-07-2010 20:41

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by frogstamper (Post 35062909)
Seems to me that when disputes become this intractable both sides should replace their chief negotiators, by this stage its only human nature that it has become personal with neither side wanting to lose face.

don't we still have ACAS? or aren't they involved ?

Sirius 26-07-2010 20:42

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35062912)
don't we still have ACAS? or aren't they involved ?

On that same page there was this which seems to confirm there still involved

Quote:

The union also announced it will meet BA for fresh talks at the conciliation service Acas next week in an attempt to break the deadlocked dispute.

martyh 26-07-2010 20:51

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35062914)
On that same page there was this which seems to confirm there still involved

that'll learn me to not read links :dunce:

mayby they should have been bought in earlier or is that considered humiliation by BA/unite?

Cobbydaler 26-07-2010 20:55

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Even if you only dip into it, this mammoth thread is an eye opener...

TheDaddy 27-07-2010 14:36

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35062901)
If I understand correctly you are only prevented from firing someone due to strike action if your singling them out. It's ok to fire the entire lot?

Is this a joke? If they did that then they would be singling out an entire group of employees.

---------- Post added at 15:36 ---------- Previous post was at 15:35 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35062892)
If they do use Human rights over this it just dilutes the human rights act even further

How so? There is a sepcific article that relates to being in a Union and not being victimised for lawfully striking.

punky 27-07-2010 14:44

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35062901)
If I understand correctly you are only prevented from firing someone due to strike action if your singling them out. It's ok to fire the entire lot? So why can't they do that and employ staff from other airlines who will presumably be quick to train, security cleared, and jump at the chance to move to the highest paying employer?

It's not as if this industrial action will end any time soon maybe it's time to bite the unpleasant bullet.

As I understand it you can only fire people for striking if the strike was not legal in the first place. This makes sense as in any circumstances if you are supposed to be working and don't you'll face the sack.

I don't know all the laws but for a strike to be legal then certain things must happen. Intention to strike has to be given in advance. Members must be balloted, etc. Once a strike is organised legally, then you can't be fired.

If however you decide to strike without doing all that (i.e. if you decide to do it spontaneously - called a wildcat strike) then some/all can be fired.

however if you do fire some and not others you can be sure lawyers would be eyeing up some discrimination lawsuits regardless who you fire.

frogstamper 28-07-2010 00:10

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
As far as I understand where all sides presently stand, the initial dispute and sticking points have been sorted, its just this withdrawal of travel perks which seem to be the stumbling block.
I really don't understand why Willy Walsh has taken this action, it was never a part of the original dispute it appears to be a malicious action on Walsh's part.
Whatever airline you work for they all have generous staff discounts, partly because if you are flexible when you travel this perk costs the airline absolutely bupkiss.
So surely the question is has Walsh got an ulterior motive? either way the airline is suffering, losing millions and more importantly losing prestige.
Its worth remembering we are not talking about far left militants here, these are educated men and women who genuinely believe they have a fair grevance.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien
If I understand correctly you are only prevented from firing someone due to strike action if your singling them out. It's ok to fire the entire lot? So why can't they do that and employ staff from other airlines who will presumably be quick to train, security cleared, and jump at the chance to move to the highest paying employer?

It's not as if this industrial action will end any time soon maybe it's time to bite the unpleasant bullet.

I can hardly believe that you of all people Damien believe the answer to a strike is to sack the entire workforce if management fails to get its way, holy crap why not go back to Victorian work practices?:shocked:

martyh 30-07-2010 11:07

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35064797)
There is of course the nuclear button: Fold the company and then re-launch it as BA-2010 with brand new contracts of employment.

There is a lesson from history here:



Wapping dispute. Wiki

I believe the new TUPE regulations(2006) may cover that one although it is a bit of a grey area

Hom3r 30-07-2010 11:11

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by frogstamper (Post 35063582)
I can hardly believe that you of all people Damien believe the answer to a strike is to sack the entire workforce if management fails to get its way, holy crap why not go back to Victorian work practices?:shocked:

In a time were unemployment is rising, employees not recieving pay rises or taking pay cuts, and worst case losing there jobs.

Do you think that BA should back down then?

They should count themselves bloody lucky to have a job. IMHO BA should say "Strike and your fired".

martyh 30-07-2010 11:32

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35064803)
In a time were unemployment is rising, employees not recieving pay rises or taking pay cuts, and worst case losing there jobs.

Do you think that BA should back down then?

They should count themselves bloody lucky to have a job. IMHO BA should say "Strike and your fired".

wether you agree with the strike or not in these times employees rights have to protected more than ever .Empoyers know that they have plenty of unemployed people out there to choose from so the threat of sacking is hanging over empoyees heads all the time and quite frankly an awfull lot of companies are readily using that threat to remove bonuses and force people to take pay cuts

Strike and your fired is not an option for BA or any company

TheDaddy 30-07-2010 15:02

Re: British Airways cabin crew vote for Christmas strike
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35064803)
In a time were unemployment is rising, employees not recieving pay rises or taking pay cuts, and worst case losing there jobs.

Do you think that BA should back down then?

They should count themselves bloody lucky to have a job. IMHO BA should say "Strike and your fired".

Perhaps they do count themselves lucky which is why they are fighting to keep their jobs and conditions. Got any other opinions, like scrapping health and saftey in the work place or employing minors?


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:25.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum