![]() |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Yep, hence the $100,00 fine and no action against the results..
You though ask f1 fans and 99% of them will say that yes it was a form of coded team orders, even the ferrari fans can't deny it ;) Look at the scripted responses from the drivers after the race.. Just remember that the fans bring in the revenue, make them lose interest and the sport suffers ;) |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
The fans pay money back to the cuircuit, most of which are half full this season. IF a circuit makes any money then 10% has to go back to FOM. Well you and me and anyone who isn't dead can see this was team orders, but you can also see how they never actually told Massa to move over just told him the car behind was quicker. As such it will be a driver decision. I've seen this in other championships where team orders are banned and all the time it is a "driver decision" and not a team order. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
You have to be very naive if you think team orders don't go on with other teams.
Earlier this year when Button had a go at Hamilton and Hamilton got the lead back he was told to back off and not overtake. Or should I say he was told to "conserve Fuel" ;) Alonso, at this stage, has the strongest chance of winning the title and Massa will have to support him. Let us not forget that Raikonnen had to play 2nd fiddle to Massa a couple of years ago when Massa was in the strongest position to win the title. It's a team sport, and you can't get away from team orders. It's the way it has always been |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
The fan is the bottom line, the same in any sport or even the entertainment industry |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Yep they race as there's still many, many, many more TV fans.. Just because the track is inaccessible the TV isn;t.. Remove though what the fans want and the fans walk whether it be from the track, TV, radio, mechandise.. As I said no fans no racing..
How much income is derived from football ticket sales compared with sponsorship, merchandising, TV rights..etc ;) |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
The problem with team orders is racing is more exciting *if* drivers take some risks. If one driver is ordered to slow down (however indirectly), where is the excitement? If people want to see that, they might as well hang around their local road and watch the cars there. It'll be a lot cheaper and will be as exciting. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
millions of people watch throughout the world and team orders won't change that. Even after a row of boring races it doesn't affect the viewing figures much.
Passing has been made almost impossible in recent years and we still see good viewing figures |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Nearly nine million people watched Jensen Button win his title back in October last year. This is because the competition was exciting. This year's British Grand Prix was watched by only four and half million (half of those who watched in October), because there was, comparatively, nothing exciting to watch.
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
I wonder what the world wide figures are??
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
I can't find anything on global figures, but here is two thousand and eight's viewing figures. I haven't checked to see which ones were the boring ones, but I do seem to remember that Australia was nothing more than a procession.
http://www.f1fanatic.co.uk/f1-inform...ience-figures/ 16 March 2008 Australian Grand Prix** 3,900,000 23 March 2008 Malaysian Grand Prix* (<2.81m) 06 April 2008 Bahrain Grand Prix 3,580,000 27 April 2008 Spanish Grand Prix 3,510,000 11 May 2008 Turkish Grand Prix* (<2.9m) 25 May 2008 Monaco Grand Prix 3,980,000 08 June 2008 Canadian Grand Prix 3,990,000 22 June 2008 French Grand Prix 3,350,000 4 July 2008 British Grand Prix 4,530,000 20 July 2008 German Grand Prix 3,190,000 3 August 2008 Hungarian Grand Prix 3,880,000 24 August 2008 European Grand Prix (<3m) 7 September 2008 Belgian Grand Prix 3,870,000 14 September 2008 Italian Grand Prix 3,550,000 28 September 2008 Singapore Grand Prix 3,950,000 12 October 2008 Japanese Grand Prix* (<3.25m) 19 October 2008 Chinese Grand Prix* (<3.47m) 2 November 2008 Brazilian Grand Prix 9,080,000) *Did not rank among the top 30 programmes on ITV1 that week. **’As live’ replay I haven't checked to see which ones were the boring ones, but I do seem to remember that Australia was nothing more than a procession and there was a drop of almost one million viewers for the next race. There were nine million viewers for Brazil, because of the tension being built with the battle between Hamilton and Massa; a jump of almost six million from the previous race and almost two million more than the previous year's final round. Pretty conclusive in proving that British viewers, at least, find excitment compelling viewing. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Yes but it was crystal clear to even deaf people, that they where telling him to the the spainard through, even more so the Rob said sorry. In his post race interview his smile said "you know it was a team order". Had it ben closer in the points and only a few races left, and the team had worded as a psoosible fault, I doubt it would have been queried. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Yes this is all discussed before the race and working for the team and wanting to stay with the team he knows full well what they are saying and what he has to do. If they take action over this then there are plenty of other times this season the same thing has happened lower down the order or teams telling drivers to ease off, save fuel etc. As long as they can use the line we didn't give a direct order I think they will get away with it |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Saying something is one thing, saying something and getting an immediate repsonse from it with a subsequent apology from the person saying it is another. Also they haven;t got away with it.. They have been fined and it has been referred higher up than just the race stewards
I wonder if they'll perhaps consider banning two way comms soon and purely have it as one way (driver to pit) with perhaps just an acknoledgement signal in return |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Can't see them having one way radio as then the teams can't tell drivers about problems with the car or other dangers. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
And how did they do it before radios... Oh they used the pit-board ;)
I see that Eddie has now put in his 2pence worth.. To me the whole point about watching the race is that you never know what's gonna happen. If they introduce team orders then you can predict a race when it's about half way through.. For example in this race Massa would have let Alfonso through a lot earlier then would have acted like a block to Vettel. It simple should not have happened, If Alofonso wanted to win then he should have driven like a winner.. Instead he drove like a 2nd placer who then spat out his dummy and was given a win that he shouldn't have had.. Totally spoiled the race for a lot of people |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
To be honest in the past few years once the first stop was out of the way you could guess the order at the end too. In fact without this happening you would be hard press to remember anything from this race in a few weeks time. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
I'm talking about the year after when Hamilton won the title, the roles were reversed in Ferrari and Massa was given the nod to go against Hamilton, and Kimi who was world champion effectively became the no.2 driver. Massa was seconds from winning it too. He's had his shot at the title and he'll probably get another shot too, but He should just get on with it and support Alonso this year. The team have made it clear that's who they're backing |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
---------- Post added at 16:45 ---------- Previous post was at 16:43 ---------- Quote:
---------- Post added at 16:48 ---------- Previous post was at 16:45 ---------- Quote:
---------- Post added at 16:54 ---------- Previous post was at 16:48 ---------- Quote:
I was watching with Flyboy9, even he understood the meaning of "OK...so....Fernando is faster than you....can you confirm you understood that message?" |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Ferrari now have a competitive car, and with only 8 races left they have decided to back Alonso. I see nothing wrong with that. Quote:
It's the rule that needs to be removed. Nearly all teams have No.1 & No.2 drivers. Even if they say they don't..............ask Mark Webber................. [/quote] This is not a team sport, in the same sense as a football match. [/quote] No but it is in the same sense as say a cycling team, were the team are there to support their main rider. Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
A slap in the face to Massa and really a way of telling him that he won;t be allowed to win a race... Is there any point in him driving??
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
The same way Irvine did for Schumacher, Barachello did for Schumacher, Massa did for Raikonnen and Raikonnen did for Massa. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Oh I don't deny that, but in the end it is simply against the rules.. and rightly so ;)
Anyone read the top gear thread as they did a great report (iplayer link last 10 minutes)on Senna showing some fantastic driving in the 80's which was when I got interested in F1.. In those days team orders might have been used but it never shown, these days the racing is that clinical that team orders do impact the enjoyment of the race which is probably why they are banned :) On other subject last night on BBC2 there was a documentary on the 1955 LeMans crash (iplayer link) and tonight there's Richard Hammond talking to Stirling Moss (11pm-ish) they've both probably been on before but still great watching. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Telling someone that they've got to slow down to let the slower driver past. It ruins the race, it's against the spirit of racing........infact, it's not racing. It becomes a carefully managed stage show, akin to WWE.
Alonso has firmly expressed his true colours with this, Crashgate at Renault, The spying saga at McLaren, and now this. He's a arrogant <insert expleetive> that acts like a spoilt brat. Renault - makes out that he had no part in his team mates crash McLaren - Ron called his bluff, Alonso though he could get what he wanted by threatening the team. Now that backfired on him slightly didn't it. Ferrari - Let's face it, not the cleanest team on the planet, with a history of willingness to forget all about one driver in favour of another, must have looked a dream ticket for Alonso, they make good bed fellows for each other |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
In F1 you have a team of mechanics, designers, and drivers all working for the same goal. to win the drivers championship (yes there is the constructors title but that's not the No.1 goal.) |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
When Hamilton won the championship, Ferrari won the constructors title. I don't recall seeing loads of pictures, or adverts, sponorships about ferrari, massa and raikonnen that year. It was all Hamilton. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Ferrari are 100% to blame for the rule being there anyway, as it was them that broke the "gentleman's agreement" of team orders in 2002, with a place swap which was not championship critical. When one driver is way back, with no or only a very slim chance, then everyone watching understood and agreed when called on to relinquish a place to the driver with more chance.
And doesn't trouble follow Alonso around? |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
It certainly does. He was right at the centre of Ferrarigate.
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
The usual boring Hungary F1 GP isn;t so boring after all....
:D |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Should Schuey bet a ban in the next race, for that very very danger move on Barrichello |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
For that move he really should be seriously dealt with, he could have very easily created a serious accident.
Schumacher should have stayed retired, he was already know for dirty tricks but now he's having to rely on them more and more ---------- Post added at 15:25 ---------- Previous post was at 15:03 ---------- Rubens has asked for the publics' opinions on his twitter account whether he or schumacher was in the right. Let's give him out support :) http://twitter.com/rubarrichello |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
I think that Schumacher is trying to kill someone before he retires just for the notoriety it will bring him, he should be banned from all remaining races this season which might make him retire for good.:mad:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
10 place grid penalty for Schummi in the next race, also $50k fines for Renault and Mercedes for unsafe release in the pit lane (Kubica crashing into Sutil and Rosberg with a loose wheel)
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
I think Renault were unfairly punished, the lollypop man was reacting to a tyre bouncing down the track. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Fantastic quote on SkyTV Germany
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
A CF thread to look at ;)
http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/30...one-these.html |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
f1 has been brilliant this year.
i like button and hamilton to do well but i want alonso to win the championship this year and wouldnt mind shummacher getting a few more points. i hope the beebs coverage goes hd soon. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
As for HD coverage, Grand Prix are filmed by local TV production companies, most of which (all?) don't use HD equipment. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
maybe next year well see a few hd races. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Bernies not letting the moths out of his wallet them.
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
I have a theory on why Schmacher is behaving the way he is. I think that he wants to be banned, so that he can save face. He has not been performing to the promised level, or what was expected of him and he might be worried about being dropped. However, if he is banned, he won't need to be dropped, he will have the excuse of, "hey, I was a bad boy and got banned, cool huh?"
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Quote:
BBC Sport |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Times/TV for Belgium is as follows
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
the current Merc car wasn't design for him and works in a totally different way to how he likes a car to work. Think this shows the main problem with F1, that even a driver as good as MS can't drive around a problem in a car but can only be on the limit when the aero works how he wants. Next year with new tyres and a car designed for him we will see if he still has it or not |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Results of first practice in the rain
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
2nd practice times
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Final Practice times though rain soon fell at the end just as cars were on their soft tyres
Quote:
---------- Post added at 13:05 ---------- Previous post was at 11:33 ---------- Not a good start for Rosberg and Petrov. Rosberg needed a gearbox change after last practice so will endure a 5 place drop on the grid and Petrov overcooked a corner in the second minute of the first qualifying session so it's been red flagged at 18:02 left on the clock whilst they remove his car. Of course Schummy has a 10 place drop for his dangerous Ruben's move |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
The toy thrower is 10th :D
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Yep, just in front of the cheat who was 11th and is now 21st :D
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Going to be interesting if Alonso catches up to Massa, will Massa have to let him pass or will he ignore the order.
Looks like Red Bull are using a different front wing, it doesn't appear to be as near to the ground now, even when the car is stood, me thinks that is why the front wing passed the FIA inspection today. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
hmm rain
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Great race, lots of excitment and a great win by Lewis.
Result = 1st Lewis H 2nd Mark W 3rd Robert K Booby prize goes to Vettel and best attacking move goes to Rubens on Alfonso :D |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Shame about Jenson, he did well to get to p2 only to be nerfed off, could of kept his championship alive but I fear it's over for him now. Also pleased Webber outraced Vettel.
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
wonder how many people will say vettel should retire now ? We get these comments about MS but Vettel has had two crashes this year and made a few errors last year too
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
The Flexi-wing controversy continues..
http://www.jamesallenonf1.com/2010/0...el-hit-button/ When you watch the onboard from Vettel you can clearly see the wing deflect on the left side as he dips out of Button's wake, surely must unsettle the car? |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Be prepared for in depth tech talk, especially on the ignition retard and exhaust gas diffuser issues. :) Cheers |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
The first tentative steps taken by an F1 car around the Korean GP circuit, Red Bull car, driven by Karun Chandhok.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iD5jHiTK_pA |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
2011 season race calendar.
13/03 Bahrain - 27/03 Aust - 10/04 Malaysia - 17/4 China - 08/05 Turkey - 22/05 Spain - 29/05 Monaco - 12/06 Canada - 26/06 Europe - 10/07 Britain - 24/07 Germany - 31/07 Hungary - 28/08 Belgium - 11/09 Italy - 25/09 Singapore - 09/10 Japan - 16/10 Korea - 30/10 India - 13/11 Abu Dhabi - 27/11 Brazil. No 13th team for the grid either. Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Ferrari escape further punishment
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Ferrari seem to have escaped any further punishment.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/moto...ne/8964502.stm Beaten to it ;) |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Well FIA does stand for Ferrari International Assistance.
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
I wonder what the entry requirements were?
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
So basically, it works like this: Every team other that Ferrari obey the rules and get punished if they break them. When Ferarri break the rules, that rule then get's put forward as a candidate to be got rid of, as it's obviously an inpedement to Ferarri, which obviously just isn't on at all. Ferrari = Arrogant team which get's away with everything Alonso = Arrogant driver who get's away with everything What a perfect marriage! |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Common sense has prevailed and the rule is due to be looked at and probably removed at the next meeting anyway. To punish a team over a rule you are about to remove would also be stupid. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
They didn't single out Ferrari, instead Ferrari singled out themselves with that rediculous radio traffic :rolleyes:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Nope, they were guilty of the offence, perhaps like many other teams, unlike the other teams they were just stupid enough to get caught by their own public actions
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
If Button lost speed because of Alonso then isn't it unfair that Alonso takes over?
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Didn't get a chance to watch much of the Monza race.. I did though see Lewis go out (nice to see a driver hold up his hands and say "Yep, my fault")
News for next year is that Lotus has ended their contract with Cosworth and will run Renault engines next year, will be interesting to see how competitive they become after the switch especially if they keep Jano and Hieki as drivers http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/moto...ne/8993100.stm |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Was suprised to see Vettel lasting so long on the option tires...
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
I think Button just went too far on the downforce setup and should have taken a bit of rear wing out just not as much as the others |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Not seen this posted anywhere yet:
Formula 1 sponsors form alliance Unsurprisingly, Bernie thinks they're "silly"... |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Is it me, or is it increasingly obvious that the main thing holding F1 back is Bernie Ecclestone?
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Most say there's two people holding back F1.. One of them is Bernie, the other used to be Max Mosely but is now Jean Todt
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Bernie should have retired ages ago. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
But without sponsorship would the sport exist in it's popular format ;)
It's like TV, how long do you think that ITV/C4/C5 could survive without adverts... so surely the advertisment companies should have some say in the sport.. What is needed is a happy compromise |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
the advertisers pay for exposure. Does that mean Embassy should have some say in changing the rules of snooker as they sponsor that ?
The advertisers are in the sport for exposure, as soon as that has run it's course they will pull out. Why should they have any say, they are fuly aware of what sport they are in when they pay to sponsor a car. |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
I am pretty sure that there would a lot of other sponsors willing to replace them.
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
They're not talking about race rule changes, they're talking about decisions that effect their brands..
Quote:
|
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
Quote:
Or should the cars go slower so they can be seen better ? |
Re: Formula 1 2010 Season [may contain real time spoilers]
There's a lot more to sponsorship details than just the livery of the cars within a race :rolleyes:
|
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:11. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are Cable Forum