Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33646961)

piggy 10-03-2009 18:45

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
its not the teachers fault, if she wasnt trained to deal with autistic children then she or the child should be removed from the classroom, and some of the comments in this thread are extremely ott, you would think the child had been murdered!

zing_deleted 10-03-2009 18:59

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by piggy (Post 34749411)
its not the teachers fault, if she wasnt trained to deal with autistic children then she or the child should be removed from the classroom, and some of the comments in this thread are extremely ott, you would think the child had been murdered!


so you would not mind if a teacher seriously distressed your child then?

nomadking 10-03-2009 19:02

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zinglebarb (Post 34749438)
so you would not mind if a teacher seriously distressed your child then?

The child was already distressed.

Russ 10-03-2009 19:03

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by piggy (Post 34749411)
its not the teachers fault, if she wasnt trained to deal with autistic children then she or the child should be removed from the classroom,

The child, by law, has to be there. The teaching assistant does not. I think perhaps the wrong one was removed from that class.

zing_deleted 10-03-2009 19:05

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 34749441)
The child was already distressed.

yeah and what happened made the child worse

nomadking 10-03-2009 19:07

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zinglebarb (Post 34749447)
yeah and what happened made the child worse

But even the experts indicate that there was no way of predicting that.

zing_deleted 10-03-2009 19:10

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
These teachers and helpers had no training so they had no chance. The schooling system in the country sucks

CHiLL 10-03-2009 19:31

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
I had a friend who I went to school with who had a younger brother who suffered from autism. Their parents sent the older lad to my school, but didn't see the school fit enough for the younger brother to attend. It wasn't equipped to deal with special needs, even though it claimed it was, plus bullying was a huge factor, as it was particularly bad in this school.

regardless of whether that school did or did not have sufficient resources to treat special needs, they should never have resorted to 'shutting them in a tiny room'. The teacher should have been sacked and the school reviewed.

piggy 10-03-2009 19:41

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zinglebarb (Post 34749461)
These teachers and helpers had no training so they had no chance. The schooling system in the country sucks

thats my point!:tu:

Maggy 10-03-2009 20:29

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zinglebarb (Post 34749461)
These teachers and helpers had no training so they had no chance. The schooling system in the country sucks

It's going to suck even more with teacher training down to 6 months.

zing_deleted 10-03-2009 20:33

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34749565)
It's going to suck even more with teacher training down to 6 months.


yeah I noticed that thread. I can see there being quite a few problems in the future

Maggy 10-03-2009 21:35

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zinglebarb (Post 34749572)
yeah I noticed that thread. I can see there being quite a few problems in the future

Especially when it comes to inclusion of vulnerable children with learning difficulties...:mad:

Osem 10-03-2009 21:39

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 34749454)
But even the experts indicate that there was no way of predicting that.

How is it that the staff I've come across over the years have managed to either predict (and hence avoid) or cope with behaviour far more severe than this without resorting to shutting distressed children in rooms on their own?

Dealing with autism certainly isn't a science and but anyone who's working closely with an autistic child for any significant period of time should a) have been given guidance about that child, their needs and their reactions to certain situations and b) gained sufficient first hand knowledge of that child to know what to do in situations like these which are not exactly unknown in schools. The reaction to what should have been a relatively trivial incident was as callous as it was unprofessional.

Maggy 10-03-2009 21:43

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 34749652)
How is it that the staff I've come across over the years have managed to either predict (and hence avoid) or cope with behaviour far more severe than this without resorting to shutting distressed children in rooms on their own?

Dealing with autism certainly isn't a science and but anyone who's working closely with an autistic child for any significant period of time should a) have been given guidance about that child, their needs and their reactions to certain situations and b) gained sufficient first hand knowledge of that child to know what to do in situations like these which are not exactly unknown in schools.

Well I haven't had any such training and neither have most of the average teachers I come into contact with..in fact I've never come across an autistic student in any secondary school.

Osem 10-03-2009 21:53

Re: teacher shut autistic girl a tiny room
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34749657)
Well I haven't had any such training and neither have most of the average teachers I come into contact with..in fact I've never come across an autistic student in any secondary school.

In the borough in which I live there are very many autistic children in mainstream schools both at primary and secondary level. Of course the more severely affected children tend to be in special units or special schools but as these continue to close, so it will be the case that more mainstream teachers come into contact with autistic pupils. Given the severe lack of SEN resources I wouldn't be surprised to learn that a school with no autistic pupils didn't have any staff trained to deal with them. Having said that anyone dealing with autistic children in the classroom ought to have received information about that child and have the basic skills sufficient for them to be able to cope with and adapt to their needs.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 13:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum