Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media TV Service (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33641036)

Mr Angry 09-11-2009 00:08

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Angry (Post 34905892)
Bored already.


Charlie_Bubble 09-11-2009 00:53

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 34906407)
Indeed.
Infringement isn't black and white, nothing in this world is, there's a whole world of gray in between.

Unfortunately, the law is black and white and what you've said on here to attempt to excuse what you do wouldn't hold up in a court.

Chris 09-11-2009 01:10

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Reedy (Post 34906415)
That's a REALLY cheap shot ... For provoking people you should have your mod status taken off you. I'm pretty disgusted by your behaviour and YES, I'm going to report you for it.

OK.

Sirius 09-11-2009 06:25

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34906474)
OK.

I bet your trembling with fear :LOL:

Peter_ 09-11-2009 07:26

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tony_i (Post 34906393)
If it makes you feel better, that's fine.

Where do you get the 'warrior' bit from? And the 'anger'?

Have you seen some of the aggressive illiterate drivel in this thread? Very picky in your moderating, soldier.

Were you bullied at school by any chance?

You do actually realise that even though Chris is a moderator on here that he is still able to post as an ordinary member and when a moderator feels the need to moderate they use bold typeface to indicate that they are posting thus.;)

adzii_nufc 09-11-2009 07:44

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Lol @ Adzii was bragging about having a cloned sky card.. Thanks alot lol Now I Had to go back and tell them it was a hoax and a Subactive Of My making..
Which I dont care if its illegal or not because im not paying over the top for multi-room! I pay for sky.. so im having it where i want it!

I will not sit and Pretend I've never downloaded a movie or streamed something Because I have many of times..

Last week I Paid to see Haloween II this week I downloaded Dead Man Running.. Call the PM and have him spank me?

I dont order movies from sky box office but im a keen WWE and boxing fan.. so last night I paid 15 quid to watch boxing.. Not so long ago it was 15 quid for WWE.. So I pay my fair share aswell as the Occasional download or stream

The most Ive done with VM is tamper with their Shabby Wiring! But Like I've Said And a Few others have said They Dont really care who steals what.. I dont care.. My TV Viewing is Fine

But Let me Also state this.. When these 'Dodgy Boxes' are cut off.. Who will Increase In Customers.. Sky or Virgin?

After this Post Can This Thread Go Back to Being about VM Dodgy Boxes and Not a Debate over What is Right and Wrong In Streaming and Downloads

And I know before you say Sky Multiroom is only a tenner Extra a Month But Im not gonna pay that For them to Do what I've done In 10 Minutes..

Raistlin 09-11-2009 08:44

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Hmmm.....where did I put that Bold pen.....ah, there it is.....

Right you lot, back on topic. Stop the bickering, drop the arguments about the legalities/moralities of downloading, and get back to discussing 'Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?[sic]' or I'll start banging heads together.

Thank you for your cooperation :)


adzii_nufc 09-11-2009 09:18

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob M (Post 34906510)
Hmmm.....where did I put that Bold pen.....ah, there it is.....

Right you lot, back on topic. Stop the bickering, drop the arguments about the legalities/moralities of downloading, and get back to discussing 'Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?[sic]' or I'll start banging heads together.

Thank you for your cooperation :)


Great handwriting for such a bold pen... Bold pen lol? Marker pen?

Felim_Doyle 12-11-2009 12:32

Re: Virgin Media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 34906515)
Great handwriting for such a bold pen... Bold pen lol? Marker pen?

:rolleyes: The pen is mightier than the swear! :rolleyes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob M (Post 34906510)
'Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?[sic]'

Rob M, why the '[sic]'? The only thing I can see wrong with the thread title is the lack of a capital 'M' in Media. Was that it?

adzii_nufc 25-11-2009 18:32

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Well apparently some guys in Middlesborough are close to Finishing Software to crack Nagra 3

If this is true.. what a mess this will be

Sirius 25-11-2009 18:50

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 34915597)
Well apparently some guys in Middlesbrough are close to Finishing Software to crack Nagra 3

If this is true.. what a mess this will be

On related news lead can now be made into gold by a simple process say some guys in Middlesbrough who understand the laws of physic better than Steven Hawkins.

BTW how can guys in Middlesbourgh be hacking N3 when its not in that area according to all the press and forum information that is available ????

N3 has never been hacked and up to now everyone who has tried has failed. I would not be holding my breath over this ********.

BTW considering the ******** you post on another forum and was found out on

Quote:

Lool I swear that aint me! Only other site I use is Cable forum..

However I did kinda Lie about a cloned sky card xD All I did was pretend I lost my original Card and with me updating to sky+HD I got the new box and kept the card and original sky+ box together which of course works as a active sub still :/

I just wanted to cause an uproar

Im not some hacker/conman superman
I take what you have said with a very very large lump of salt

Felim_Doyle 26-11-2009 16:30

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Presumably Nagra 3 is available in Middlesborough from other sources (i.e. various satellite feeds) even if it is not on VM yet.

adzii_nufc 26-11-2009 16:48

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Felim_Doyle (Post 34916103)
Presumably Nagra 3 is available in Middlesborough from other sources (i.e. various satellite feeds) even if it is not on VM yet.


Well i was talking to a guy on Hotmail from down boro way. He tells me they are ready for Nagra 3.

He also told me this.. i know its slightly off topic but someone just tell me this aint possible. A chipped NTL modem he claims to be selling, Surely thats impossible right I mean that would case an outrage. If i talk to him again Ill keep the chat logs for you lot to inspect :)

if anyone wants to do some undercover work Im up for giving you his email lol


Something else that bothers me people who make claims, noone in this world knows nagra 3 will be unbeatable yet everyone acts like its the second coming of jesus, If it works well then it works but if it Does'nt how stupid will you feel then.

I've gave warnings before and again..The guys behind these boxes dont care about anything but money they will make.. to them.. impossible is nothing

zing_deleted 26-11-2009 16:48

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
they are not chipped ffs

I have no doubt myself nagra 3 will eventually get hacked but I think its gonna take a good while

jawbiez 26-11-2009 16:50

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
They are cloned modems.

Nagra 3 aint cracked, middlesborough isn't even a test area AFAIK.

adzii_nufc 26-11-2009 16:51

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zing (Post 34916113)
they are not chipped ffs

I have no doubt myself nagra 3 will eventually get hacked but I think its gonna take a good while


I know lol.. read what i said... CHIPPED MODEM! Its the first time ive ever heard about these things..

Reality or just some crap he's made up?

The boxes are Flashed with firmware is what you meant presumably?

Ahh just read cloned modem.. and this allows him to gain free internet ?

jawbiez 26-11-2009 16:53

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 34916116)
I know lol.. read what i said... CHIPPED MODEM! Its the first time ive ever heard about these things..

Reality or just some crap he's made up?

The boxes are Flashed with firmware is what you meant presumably?

Ahh just read cloned modem.. and this allows him to gain free internet ?

Correct.

The modems wont last much longer either when a new system gets put in place.

adzii_nufc 26-11-2009 16:59

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jawbiez (Post 34916117)
Correct.

The modems wont last much longer either when a new system gets put in place.


Well i've changed my stance from Neutral to against these boxes and any other sh*t like it..

Cloned modems, Free tv

£37 a month for my BB.. and these guys dont pay for zilch

I mean Sky tv with HD packs etc. alone is around 52.00 a month due to go up to 72.00 or so when i get sky broadband to replace VM

Is it just Virgin you can get these modems for.. If so yet another brilliant Flaw in VM's appauling system!

I apoligize for my original stance of not caring about these boxes and whatnot but when there actually stealing the internet to go with it.. thats just insulting

jawbiez 26-11-2009 17:01

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 34916121)
Well i've changed my stance from Neutral to against these boxes and any other sh*t like it..

Cloned modems, Free tv

£37 a month for my BB.. and these guys dont pay for zilch

I mean Sky tv with HD packs etc. alone is around 52.00 a month due to go up to 72.00 or so when i get sky broadband to replace VM

Is it just Virgin you can get these modems for.. If so yet another brilliant Flaw in VM's appauling system!

I apoligize for my original stance of not caring about these boxes and whatnot but when there actually stealing the internet to go with it.. thats just insulting

You can get sky hd for £23 a month and a free hd box.

Yes only on virgin can these modems be cloned.

adzii_nufc 26-11-2009 17:20

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jawbiez (Post 34916123)
You can get sky hd for £23 a month and a free hd box.

Yes only on virgin can these modems be cloned.

Ours comes up to about the 50 mark inc all the packs etc.

Soon to be Sky BB too for only an extra 15 quid pm

So they gain free internet Next someone is gonna say they dont get throttled with speed either :mad:

snowey 26-11-2009 18:13

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jawbiez (Post 34916115)
They are cloned modems.

Nagra 3 aint cracked, middlesborough isn't even a test area AFAIK.

Now !!! it will be... :)

Toto 26-11-2009 18:49

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
I think we're putting too much faith in our Northern friends abilities to crack something that has so far remained intact.

Typical freetard bluster if you ask me.

Derek 26-11-2009 20:09

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Toto (Post 34916193)
I think we're putting too much faith in our Northern friends abilities to crack something that has so far remained intact.

Part of me would like to think that the UK has such talented programmers that they can crack Nagra3 (if that even is what the new system is) in days when it isn't even fully rolled out when the best that Canada/Germany/USA/Spain etc. haven't been able to crack it.

Somehow I doubt it which leaves the options of:
  • VM are using a different system which is easier to crack
  • The people who claim to have cracked it are talking out their bottoms

zing_deleted 26-11-2009 20:18

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Thing is Derek you can never say never. Look at how long its took VM to get to a point where they are ready to roll it out. Look at how much time the boxes have been available? pretty much all the time since the old analogue boxes were actually chipped

Ive seen advanced systems where a certain box is hooked up and connected remotely to a system where a pier who has a powered dish and actually subscribes to loads of different satellite services and then somehow allows the 3rd party boxes to access the content ( admittedly the guy got caught)

Even if it takes 2 or 3 more years to crack it how many more years will it take before VM can beat them again?

Ignitionnet 26-11-2009 20:59

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
VM aren't using plain Nagra 3, they have financial guarantees from Kudelski on the strength of the conditional access system that has been made for them and it remains a fact that no-one has been able to crack even plain Nagra 3.

It would be interesting to see how people in Middlesbrough who don't even have the signals being transmitted to them managed to compromise the CA, and more to the point how they managed to do in a matter of weeks what the rest of the world hasn't been able to do in over 2 years.

I do love reading those boards, where they use various insulting names to describe the cable company. The least they could do is be polite as they steal service.

Sirius 26-11-2009 21:03

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Broadbandings (Post 34916258)
VM aren't using plain Nagra 3, they have financial guarantees from Kudelski on the strength of the conditional access system that has been made for them and it remains a fact that no-one has been able to crack even plain Nagra 3.

It would be interesting to see how people in Middlesbrough who don't even have the signals being transmitted to them managed to compromise the CA, and more to the point how they managed to do in a matter of weeks what the rest of the world hasn't been able to do in over 2 years.

I do love reading those boards, where they use various insulting names to describe the cable company. The least they could do is be polite as they steal service.

I find there site interesting to read on a low IQ sort of level :LOL:

Ignitionnet 26-11-2009 21:07

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 34916260)
I find there site interesting to read on a low IQ sort of level :LOL:

I find the sites lower my IQ so can't spend too long on them.

zing_deleted 26-11-2009 21:09

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
ive got no idea on the subject but I do know saying something will never be cracked gives it an awful long lifespan in which it has to remain secure lol

TheDon 26-11-2009 21:40

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zing (Post 34916234)
Ive seen advanced systems where a certain box is hooked up and connected remotely to a system where a pier who has a powered dish and actually subscribes to loads of different satellite services and then somehow allows the 3rd party boxes to access the content ( admittedly the guy got caught)

Cardsharing, it's pretty trivial to do on near enough any encryption, but it's relatively easy to track down and stop rather than having to fix encryption.

The only type of cardsharing that lasts is between very close groups of friends, you simply cannot have widespread cardsharing as you just have to let the wrong person in for it to be shut down.

Horace 26-11-2009 21:47

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Systems don't tend to be cracked in the way some people imagine. It often involves inside help often either through blackmail or bribery. I'm pretty sure the reason why NDS hasn't fallen is due to better people management and no single person holding enough information to completely break the encryption. Maybe Kudelski have learnt from their previous mistakes in this respect.
To suggest some random person in Middlesbrough has broken this system is ludicrous to say the least, unless they have access to an electron microscope then it isn't going to come from there. Older techniques which I won't mention here don't seem to be working. If VM do switch to N3 or an enhanced version of, then I would guess that IPTV will have taken over long before that system is broken.

Kymmy 26-11-2009 22:14

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Nagra 2 was cracked, in such a way that they could generate daily keys from the main keys, this was different to the old Sky days when videocrypt wasn't cracked instead some disgruntled employee decided to hand out the master keys from which the main keys and daily/user keys are generated :rolleyes:

Look at Sky's current encryption NDS, has been out for years and apart from brief security problems (as Horace mentions) it's soon been patched and is as secure today as it was when it first came out. Nagra3 looks as though it too will stand for a bit and probably in VM's case well into the IPTV era..

Ignitionnet 26-11-2009 22:57

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Horace (Post 34916290)
To suggest some random person in Middlesbrough has broken this system is ludicrous to say the least, unless they have access to an electron microscope then it isn't going to come from there. Older techniques which I won't mention here don't seem to be working. If VM do switch to N3 or an enhanced version of, then I would guess that IPTV will have taken over long before that system is broken.

I would imagine Horace is in part referring to the NDS cracking of the Canal Plus encryption - which involved a team of experts, a lot of money, and 6 months with an electron microscope reverse engineering the card a transistor at a time.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology...media.citynews

But for sure the guys on these forums can break the N3 variation that VM are using. The rest of the world are just stupid amateurs clearly having failed in 2 years to do what these guys have in a couple of months.

Kymmy 26-11-2009 23:24

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
??? Sorry but I always thought the card is just a simple PIC and has nothing to do with the full encryption but is normally just a carrier of the user key/details (which can be encrypted in thier own right and why the card needs changing if the main or master keys are updated) which when combined with the main key enables the decryption of the signal.. If so how can an electron microscope be used when a simple reader will do :rolleyes:

Ignitionnet 27-11-2009 00:08

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 34916329)
??? Sorry but I always thought the card is just a simple PIC and has nothing to do with the full encryption but is normally just a carrier of the user key/details (which can be encrypted in thier own right and why the card needs changing if the main or master keys are updated) which when combined with the main key enables the decryption of the signal.. If so how can an electron microscope be used when a simple reader will do :rolleyes:

The cards decrypt control messages which provide information the box needs to decrypt data, plus they also decrypt the individual subscriber addressable control messages.

Quote:

The data stream is scrambled with an 8-byte secret key, called the control word. Knowing the value of the control word at a given moment is of relatively little value, because it changes very frequently, about every 10 seconds.
Quote:

In order for the receiver to unscramble the data stream, it must be permanently informed about the current value of the control word. In practise, it must be informed slightly in advance, so that no viewing interruption occurs. Encryption is used to protect the control word during transmission to the receiver: the control word is encrypted as an entitlement control message (ECM). The CA subsystem in the receiver will decrypt the control word only when authorised to do so; that authority is sent to the receiver in the form of an entitlement management message (EMM). The EMMs are specific to each subscriber, as identified by the smart card in his receiver, or to groups of subscribers, and are issued much less frequently than ECMs, perhaps at monthly intervals.
http://video.aol.co.uk/video-detail/...ard/1526516239

The reason VM can use Nagra 1 and 3 simultaneously is that the control word will be encrypted with both schemes. It is this control word that the encryption is there to protect, strongly obfuscating / scrambling the actual digital TV signal is easy, it's protecting the control word while simultaneously ensuring that authorised users receive the up to date word every few seconds that's the tough part.

A smartcard has more than enough processing power to decrypt 8 bytes every 10 seconds or so.

The cards hold record of what the customer is authorised to use (which package they are on), and they decrypt control words appropriately to ensure that that subscriber has the access they are authorised for. Reverse engineer what the card holds, how it holds it, and what it does with it and you've just undone the encryption. This is what they will be targetting as the existing dodgy receivers already have the capability to descramble the signals once they have the appropriate keys / algorithms to decrypt the control words as they come down.

nexy33 27-11-2009 06:25

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
All this talented hacking skill in a region of the world famed for hanging monkeys as french spies. who says evolution takes a long time!!!

Hiroki 27-11-2009 14:28

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nexy33 (Post 34916385)
All this talented hacking skill in a region of the world famed for hanging monkeys as french spies. who says evolution takes a long time!!!

Your thinking of Hartlepool.

Middlesbrough are smoggies.

zing_deleted 27-11-2009 15:18

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
did you lot know there were 1100+ successful hack attacks either accessing code or injecting malware on NASA last year? I bet they thought they were secure too lol

Ignitionnet 27-11-2009 16:07

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
NASA website != NASA.

zing_deleted 27-11-2009 16:10

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
no it was NASA the report was in NewScientist

in fact one guy is in the news as the yanks are trying to extradite him http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...91130965502807#

TheDon 27-11-2009 16:27

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zing (Post 34916599)
did you lot know there were 1100+ successful hack attacks either accessing code or injecting malware on NASA last year? I bet they thought they were secure too lol

I'd bet like in most organisations 99% of those are down to NASA employees running malware that they either received in email or from a website.

Gary Mckinnon is also no hacker, he just stumbled on a load of NASA machines that had zero protection and used very basic tools to get onto them. It wasn't some huge security breach because there was no security protecting the machines, all it took was a port scan of NASA's IP range and basic windows networking tools to gain access. If they thought they were secure then they didn't have much of a clue over how their systems were setup as there was no security on them at all, workstations with public IPs and no firewalls are asking for trouble.

Actual hacks that aren't down to user stupidity are extremely rare, and rely on vulnerabilities being found that can be exploited.

You can't find a vulnerability without being able to run the code, which is why to hack a smart card you need to pull it apart layer by layer and examine it with an electron microscope to reverse engineer what the card does and extract the data.

N3 is not going to be hacked by some random people without access to some very sophisticated equipment.

That's not to say it can't be hacked, it probably can be, the more complex something is the more chance it can be hacked, but will it be done by some bloke from Middlesbrough who posts on a forum about stealing cable? Not a chance in hell.

zing_deleted 27-11-2009 16:34

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
but can you tell me it will never be hacked?

Stuart 27-11-2009 16:42

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zing (Post 34916643)
but can you tell me it will never be hacked?

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 34916639)
That's not to say it can't be hacked, it probably can be, the more complex something is the more chance it can be hacked, but will it be done by some bloke from Middlesbrough who posts on a forum about stealing cable? Not a chance in hell.

It probably will be hacked eventually, just not at the moment..

mikkyh 27-11-2009 17:04

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
I hope they do. I HATE people illegally using VMs services with a passion, especially when genuine customers pay so much!

Digital Fanatic 27-11-2009 18:16

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 34916647)
It probably will be hacked eventually, just not at the moment..

and by then everyone will probably be on VM's IPTV network ;)

Saaf_laandon_mo 27-11-2009 19:12

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
What's iptv?

Chris 27-11-2009 19:36

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Internet Protocol Television. More or less like wot drives the iPlayer on your PC.

nexy33 28-11-2009 02:29

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
pretty much on demand vod for all

http://www.cisco.com/en/US/netsol/ns..._category.html

Kymmy 28-11-2009 10:19

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo (Post 34916763)
What's iptv?

http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/11...l#post34917048

adzii_nufc 28-11-2009 13:53

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Im assuming IPTV is video on demand all the time via what device ? a computer ?

Its basically watching anything you want whenever it becomes available?

If not then anyone sum IPTV up in English :angel:

Turkey Machine 28-11-2009 14:01

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
TV channels over internet.

You wanted it simple, that's as simple as it gets.

adzii_nufc 28-11-2009 14:11

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Turkey Machine (Post 34917256)
TV channels over internet.

You wanted it simple, that's as simple as it gets.

Sorry for my Low Intelligence in the TV department lol but I'm assuming it's Similar to the sky player ? Except what your watching is streaming the same time on normal tv?

Kymmy 28-11-2009 15:15

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
More similar to the BT Vision.. ;)

TheDon 28-11-2009 16:00

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
IPTV is not as simple as "TV channels over the internet".

IPTV is a closed system, like the current cable network, but where the traffic is encapsulated into IP streams and routed over IP based devices. This makes it easy to take advantage of multicast rather than broadcast traffic to implement SDV, but it's still running over a closed private network. You can't plug an IPTV STB into any internet connection and have it work, nor can you receive the services on other IP based devices like a PC, you still need to be connected to the providers network.

AT&T's U-Verse service is probably the best example of IPTV around as it offers nearly 400 SD, and over 100 HD channels, all over VDSL.

"TV over the internet" such as Sky player, is Internet TV, an entirely different thing.

Turkey Machine 28-11-2009 18:15

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 34917339)
IPTV is not as simple as "TV channels over the internet".

Not completely, but for the uninitiated, it is.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 34917339)
AT&T's U-Verse service is probably the best example of IPTV around as it offers nearly 400 SD, and over 100 HD channels, all over VDSL.

AKA TV channels over the internet. Better to elaborate that it uses an internet or network connection (cable or DSL) to get the channels, not like a normal cable box in that sense.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 34917339)
"TV over the internet" such as Sky player, is Internet TV, an entirely different thing.

That's like catch-up TV with some live streams thrown in. ;)

TheDon 28-11-2009 20:12

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Turkey Machine (Post 34917427)
AKA TV channels over the internet. Better to elaborate that it uses an internet or network connection (cable or DSL) to get the channels, not like a normal cable box in that sense.

No, it's really not TV channels over the internet by any stretch of the imagination.

The broadcasts do not touch the internet at all, it's all routed across their internal network only on segregated bandwidth.

Saying it's TV channels over the internet is like saying streaming from one pc on your home network to another pc on your home network is streaming over the internet. In neither case is the internet involved, it's all internal network traffic. That the same connection gives you your internet connection is irrelevant.

A lot of people are under the impression that IPTV will mean you can use any internet connection to get the channels, you can't. You have to be connected directly to the providers network as they are NOT sent over the internet.

Internet TV = TV sent over the internet, IPTV = a walled garden where TV is transmitted across an IP network.

beeman 29-11-2009 09:00

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
So in simple terms as the person wanted.

its TV over an intranet ;)

Felim_Doyle 29-11-2009 13:18

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
See IPTV for a description where it states:-

Quote:

Internet Protocol television (IPTV) is a system through which digital television service is delivered using the architecture and networking methods of the Internet Protocol Suite over a packet-switched network infrastructure, e.g., the Internet and broadband Internet access networks, instead of being delivered through traditional radio frequency broadcast, satellite signal, and cable television (CATV) formats.
So it uses the Internet Protocol (IP) but, in VM's case, not over the public network.

I would be interested to know though, if it is going to be on a seperate stream from the broadband traffic coming down the same co-ax cable.

Turkey Machine 29-11-2009 13:29

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
That's going to be a given, they can't give separate TV and phone packages otherwise. ;)

TheDon 29-11-2009 13:30

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Felim_Doyle (Post 34917740)
See IPTV for a description where it states:-

So it uses the Internet Protocol (IP) but, in VM's case, not over the public network.

You've underlined a lot of nice words, but missed out the a couple of important ones, that being:

Quote:

the Internet and broadband Internet access networks
Not the actual internet, but the access networks to those.

Read further down the same page for a complete definition:

Quote:

Historically, many different definitions of IPTV have appeared, including elementary streams over IP networks, transport streams over IP networks and a number of proprietary systems. Although (in Mid 2007) it is premature to say that there is a full consensus of exactly what IPTV should mean, there is no doubt that the most widely used definition today for consumer IPTV is for single or multiple program transport streams (MPTS) which are sourced by the same network operator that owns or directly controls the "last mile" to the consumer's premises. This control over delivery enables a guaranteed quality of service (QOS), and also allows the service provider to offer an enhanced user experience such as better program guide, interactive services etc.

In commercial environments IPTV is widely deployed for distribution of live TV, video playout channels and Video on Demand (VOD) material across LAN or WAN IP network infrastructures, with a controlled QOS.

The official definition approved by the International Telecommunication Union focus group on IPTV (ITU-T FG IPTV) is as follows:
"IPTV is defined as multimedia services such as television/video/audio/text/graphics/data delivered over IP based networks managed to provide the required level of quality of service and experience, security, interactivity and reliability."
The key point in the ITU definition is that the network has to be managed, that means owned by the IPTV provider. You'll struggle to find anyone in the industry refer to IPTV to mean anything but using a privately owned IP network to deliver TV services, anything that touches the internet is referred to as Internet TV.

Quote:

I would be interested to know though, if it is going to be on a seperate stream from the broadband traffic coming down the same co-ax cable.
Yes.
Even in the VDSL systems the bandwidth is entirely segregated from the actual internet traffic.

Oatie 29-11-2009 21:40

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Corrrrrrrr.....I remember 'doing' this tv over DSL, (as it was at the time...even thought DSL was carrying IP), back in the late 90's. 3DSL I seem to recall it was named....twas a triple play offering basically. Was good as well. Hull took our, (when I say 'our' I mean the company I worked for at the time), solution as I recall. Something about Hull and telecoms, (cant remember or be bothered to look up), but the telecom provider up that neck of the woods doesnt have to conform to national regulations in some way or other?

Was proper VoD, (delivered over DSL), but was pretty much telly via IP. Clever stuff at the time. Lost touch with it all now mind.

Going back to the original topic, reckon that N3, (or what people call N3 even though there aint any such thing really), will happen, but will take a while to fully roll out. I've got to admit that I think this may cost Virgin in the long run. Reason behind this thinking is that they will be rolling out IP TV in the not too distant future, which would kill any 'dodgy' boxes. Why not let people who pinch the telly stay on the network, (theyve been there for crikey knows how many years now...one more wont make much difference), and realise some sort of income, then 'bedazzle' them with the IP TV service? Reckon what will happen is that a lot of people will move over to Sky when they lose their telly and stay there?

Just my opinion like, could be totally and utterly wrong, (and not for the first time either).

Ben B 29-11-2009 21:44

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
It could also be that maybe this card change is required for the IPTV to be implemented :shrug: all we can do is speculate until more info or something happening appears

Oatie 29-11-2009 22:08

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben B (Post 34918028)
It could also be that maybe this card change is required for the IPTV to be implemented :shrug: all we can do is speculate until more info or something happening appears

Hmmm.....good point. But, (and I'm speaking with the benefit of a bottle of decent red inside me here.....anythings better than the X bloody factor and Celeb insect munching), IPTV, in my humble opinion would require a new 'box'. IPTV is totally different tech to how your current t.v. piccie is delivered, (or at least it used to be)? I know a bloke who knows everything there is to know about IP TV, (even if he does work for a competitor of Cisco, he does know his *****), and will ask him. Sure that a card change cant 'IP enable' the current set top boxes, (he says ready to be shot down)?

Felim_Doyle 30-11-2009 14:43

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Turkey Machine (Post 34917747)
That's going to be a given, they can't give separate TV and phone packages otherwise. ;)

I'm not sure what the 'phone has to do with it. That comes down the twisted pair copper wires attached to the side of the co-ax to form the siamese twin cable as it's known. I'd have thought that the bandwidth for broadband and IPTV could be shared on the co-ax rather than using distinct frequencies for each IP stream but it is probably not likely given that one will be handled by the cable modem/router and the other by the STB.

---------- Post added at 14:01 ---------- Previous post was at 13:54 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 34917748)
You've underlined a lot of nice words, but missed out the a couple of important ones ...

I didn't intentionally underline anything, they were links in the original text when I copied and pasted it. No emphasis intended. I was just trying to make the distinction between 'the internet', as most people understand it, and 'an internet protocol network' regardless of it's open or closed status or LAN, PAN, WAN etc. nature.

---------- Post added at 14:43 ---------- Previous post was at 14:01 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oatie (Post 34918026)
Something about Hull and telecoms, (cant remember or be bothered to look up), but the telecom provider up that neck of the woods doesnt have to conform to national regulations in some way or other?

:rolleyes: Kingston-Upon-Hull is an autonomous republic enclave within the UK. I'm not even sure it's part of the EU. :rolleyes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oatie (Post 34918026)
Was proper VoD, (delivered over DSL), but was pretty much telly via IP. Clever stuff at the time. Lost touch with it all now mind.

Excusing any inaccuracies, AFIK, BT developed ADSL in the 80s/90s at their Ipswich research centre purely for VoD. Public access to the internet was relatively new then and nobody saw a need for broadband given that dial-up modem speeds were rapidly reaching 9600 baud and beyond. ;) Unfortunately for them, before deregulation, BT's licence did not allow them to compete in the TV or VoD markets and so the technology was shelved until the need for broadband eventually became a reallity.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oatie (Post 34918026)
Going back to the original topic ...

My question is won't conditional access controls still be needed for IPTV? There will still have to be something that decides what the viewer is entitled to watch.

Turkey Machine 30-11-2009 19:35

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Depends if Virgin deploy any conditional access for the IPTV they watch. The advantage is that you can give a certain line from the headend a certain range of "channels" to view, but cheats will always get around it one way or another.

Felim_Doyle 01-12-2009 13:00

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Turkey Machine (Post 34918557)
Depends if Virgin deploy any conditional access for the IPTV they watch. The advantage is that you can give a certain line from the headend a certain range of "channels" to view, but cheats will always get around it one way or another.

Huh?

Scenarios ...

So I have a cable running up to my house but I don't have a VM subscription. I should get nothing, not even the terrestrial five basic 'public service' channels.
I have a basic VM package which anyone with a VM subscription is entitled to view. This should be available to anyone with a suitable STB.
I have a better package (e.g. XL) and possibly some additional packages (e.g. sports, movies). The network needs to control what my STB is allowed to show.

How's it going to work under IPTV? Will there be subscription cards in the box? Will it be controlled from the 'server' end rather than the 'client'? Is it more complicated if I have more than one STB on the same cable?

Kymmy 01-12-2009 16:01

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Last post about new smart cards moved to

http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/11...l-changes.html

TheDon 01-12-2009 16:23

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Felim_Doyle (Post 34918985)
How's it going to work under IPTV? Will there be subscription cards in the box? Will it be controlled from the 'server' end rather than the 'client'? Is it more complicated if I have more than one STB on the same cable?

You'll still have a smartcard in the STB.

Ben B 04-12-2009 17:07

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben B (Post 34918028)
It could also be that maybe this card change is required for the IPTV to be implemented :shrug: all we can do is speculate until more info or something happening appears

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oatie (Post 34918032)
Hmmm.....good point. But, (and I'm speaking with the benefit of a bottle of decent red inside me here.....anythings better than the X bloody factor and Celeb insect munching), IPTV, in my humble opinion would require a new 'box'. IPTV is totally different tech to how your current t.v. piccie is delivered, (or at least it used to be)? I know a bloke who knows everything there is to know about IP TV, (even if he does work for a competitor of Cisco, he does know his *****), and will ask him. Sure that a card change cant 'IP enable' the current set top boxes, (he says ready to be shot down)?

I can (kind of) confirm my speculations about the card change being required from IPTV. Info taken from Help & Info on my STB.

Quote:

Originally Posted by V+ Help & Info
Q: Why are you sending me a new card?
A: We're about to upgrade the technology of your Virgin TV set top box so you can benefit from the good stuff fibre optic technology brings

This suggests my speculations are true to me.

Horace 05-12-2009 19:43

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben B (Post 34921070)
I can (kind of) confirm my speculations about the card change being required from IPTV. Info taken from Help & Info on my STB.



This suggests my speculations are true to me.

That 'help and info' answer is vague to say the least.

SB_07 15-12-2009 20:54

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Some guy on his Twitter has said he's using a chipped box, doubt anything can be done about it right??

"Smokin G-13, originally grown by the CIA. 1 of my favourite strains. Sippin rose. Watchin "Hitman" on a chipped up Virgin box. Life is good."

http://twitter.com/UpNorthMillz

Tony. 15-12-2009 21:54

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SB_07 (Post 34927945)
Some guy on his Twitter has said he's using a chipped box, doubt anything can be done about it right??

"Smokin G-13, originally grown by the CIA. 1 of my favourite strains. Sippin rose. Watchin "Hitman" on a chipped up Virgin box. Life is good."

http://twitter.com/UpNorthMillz

He won't be watching it much longer lol

Quote:

Location OLDHAM, UK

zing_deleted 15-12-2009 22:20

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
but he will still be smoking his G-13 so he most likely wont care to much lol

musicbravo 14-01-2010 19:34

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Looks like smart card change may move to Derby soon. Got home to find box set to 999, which suggests it has had a software update

sniper007 05-03-2010 17:13

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Interesting thread. So basically Nagra 3 rollout involves new smart cards which will stop cable pirates in their tracks? I don't understand how pirates get hold of their dodgey STBs. Is it usually originally down to a breach internally with Virgin employees selling STBs? Or on the black market are there STBs that mimic a virgin box? Also, how many pirates are out there? Are we talking say 100,000 in the UK?

---------- Post added at 17:13 ---------- Previous post was at 16:58 ----------

Wow. I'm shocked. I just did some googling and came accross "another forum" shall we say. It's like the people there think that Virgin (they refer to them as "Vermin") owe them something for nothing. It absolutely fills me with rage. They talk in " txt spk innit m8 " and there is a guy on there that was/is actually contemplating moving from Leeds to Manchester in an attempt to keep recieiving "free tv". Another person on there back in December complained publically that he had just bought LCD flat screens for his kids (one each) for Xmas and that they wouldn't be happy.
Absolute **** on there. Why should we all pay for services they receive free? Does this really spell the end for them and when will the whole country be on the new cards as I have not got a letter about it yet at all.

Stuart 05-03-2010 17:30

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sniper007 (Post 34974930)
Interesting thread. So basically Nagra 3 rollout involves new smart cards which will stop cable pirates in their tracks? I don't understand how pirates get hold of their dodgey STBs. Is it usually originally down to a breach internally with Virgin employees selling STBs? Or on the black market are there STBs that mimic a virgin box? Also, how many pirates are out there? Are we talking say 100,000 in the UK?

It's down to two things:

1) Dodgy boxes. These don't necessarily come from VM employees (although some do). They sometimes come customers who, having had the service legitimately, stop it for some reason. They *should* send the box back, but VM can be a little lax in enforcing this, so a lot of boxes end up on ebay.

2) There are boxes out there that are designed to emulate virgin boxes. We do not allow discussion of specifics about these boxes (such as where/how to get them).

I don't know how many people pirate digital TV. but I do know that it is enought that it caused On Digital to think their PPV football service was far more profitable than it actually was, and caused them to bid far more than they could afford for the premiership footy rights, which ultimately caused them to fold.
Quote:

Wow. I'm shocked. I just did some googling and came accross "another forum" shall we say. It's like the people there think that Virgin (they refer to them as "Vermin") owe them something for nothing. It absolutely fills me with rage. They talk in " txt spk innit m8 " and there is a guy on there that was/is actually contemplating moving from Leeds to Manchester in an attempt to keep recieiving "free tv". Another person on there back in December complained publically that he had just bought LCD flat screens for his kids (one each) for Xmas and that they wouldn't be happy.
Absolute **** on there. Why should we all pay for services they receive free? Does this really spell the end for them and when will the whole country be on the new cards as I have not got a letter about it yet at all.
I think I know the forum you are referring to. It's not a nice place.

tvtimes 05-03-2010 17:33

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sniper007 (Post 34974930)
Interesting thread. So basically Nagra 3 rollout involves new smart cards which will stop cable pirates in their tracks? I don't understand how pirates get hold of their dodgey STBs. Is it usually originally down to a breach internally with Virgin employees selling STBs? Or on the black market are there STBs that mimic a virgin box? Also, how many pirates are out there? Are we talking say 100,000 in the UK?

---------- Post added at 17:13 ---------- Previous post was at 16:58 ----------

Wow. I'm shocked. I just did some googling and came accross "another forum" shall we say. It's like the people there think that Virgin (they refer to them as "Vermin") owe them something for nothing. It absolutely fills me with rage. They talk in " txt spk innit m8 " and there is a guy on there that was/is actually contemplating moving from Leeds to Manchester in an attempt to keep recieiving "free tv". Another person on there back in December complained publically that he had just bought LCD flat screens for his kids (one each) for Xmas and that they wouldn't be happy.
Absolute **** on there. Why should we all pay for services they receive free? Does this really spell the end for them and when will the whole country be on the new cards as I have not got a letter about it yet at all.

Come April they'll be screwed mate. The new Nagra 3 has been around years and years and no-one has managed to crack it. They won't have the choice come april to pay for it or be happy with Freeview pmsl!:D F'ing freeloaders can't wait for them to get their commupence. I was at college the other night and we was talking and it came up in conversation that one of the guys brothers had recently bought one and it had gone down and they could no longer get channels, another three people openly admitted that they also haqve chipped boxes! I couldn't believe it. If 4 people in one class have chipped boxes it mnakes you wonder how readily available they are.

I had a vm tech round a couple of years back and he offered me a chipped modem and a box i said no thanks i don't fancy getting facing a jail term if i get caught! I also know they are available in Wolverhampton market!

Lord Nikon 05-03-2010 17:42

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
I ditched the TV side for a simple reason - I don't actually watch the TV, there's nothing on there I can't get from other sources and too much stuff I don't want to watch.

sniper007 05-03-2010 17:47

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tvtimes (Post 34974941)
Come April they'll be screwed mate. The new Nagra 3 has been around years and years and no-one has managed to crack it. They won't have the choice come april to pay for it or be happy with Freeview pmsl!:D F'ing freeloaders can't wait for them to get their commupence. I was at college the other night and we was talking and it came up in conversation that one of the guys brothers had recently bought one and it had gone down and they could no longer get channels, another three people openly admitted that they also haqve chipped boxes! I couldn't believe it. If 4 people in one class have chipped boxes it mnakes you wonder how readily available they are.

I had a vm tech round a couple of years back and he offered me a chipped modem and a box i said no thanks i don't fancy getting facing a jail term if i get caught! I also know they are available in Wolverhampton market!

Chipped modems as well!? :shocked: Erm...do people get free internet as well then somehow? What about phone lines?

Sirius 05-03-2010 18:01

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
The mighty N3 removes all known thieving *******s that other encryptions missed :LOL:

Lord Nikon 05-03-2010 18:19

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Nothing is unhackable, all it means is that no-one has so far achieved it, at least, not within the public domain. One thing is for sure though, now that it's rolling out more there will be more people trying.

As far as I can see the UK TV channels have achieved a different method of preventing channel hacking. They show very little worth watching.

dilli-theclaw 05-03-2010 18:24

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lord Nikon (Post 34974953)

As far as I can see the UK TV channels have achieved a different method of preventing channel hacking. They show very little worth watching.

You think it was a cunning plan? ;)

tvtimes 05-03-2010 18:33

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sniper007 (Post 34974945)
Chipped modems as well!? :shocked: Erm...do people get free internet as well then somehow? What about phone lines?

I'm afraid so i wish i had got his tech identification number as he said he has a shed full of them!

---------- Post added at 18:33 ---------- Previous post was at 18:28 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lord Nikon (Post 34974953)
Nothing is unhackable, all it means is that no-one has so far achieved it, at least, not within the public domain. One thing is for sure though, now that it's rolling out more there will be more people trying.

As far as I can see the UK TV channels have achieved a different method of preventing channel hacking. They show very little worth watching.

It will take further years for them to manage it if they actually do manage it. There's plenty of other things that have never been hacked. Not everything is hackable. People in Europe have been trying for years to hack it but have been unable to. I imagine by the time they manage it virgin will have increased it subscription base and got some much needed extra revenue from those who had pirate boxes before the switchover.

*sloman* 05-03-2010 20:11

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Got my new cards Tuesday here in Derby so i presume the switch over will happen soon for Derby Area

Digital Fanatic 06-03-2010 10:38

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *sloman* (Post 34975000)
Got my new cards Tuesday here in Derby so i presume the switch over will happen soon for Derby Area

Yep... not long now for all those cable theives :D

newbie1001 06-03-2010 20:40

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Well if Virgin Media were more carefull with their equipment piracy might not be an issue. I have an ntl box and modem in my loft for over 5 years now and no doubt i will have this V+ box,V Box and cable modem for years as well. Contract ended 21st of january and they have made no effort to retrieve the equipment.

Horace 06-03-2010 23:46

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by newbie1001 (Post 34975444)
Well if Virgin Media were more carefull with their equipment piracy might not be an issue. I have an ntl box and modem in my loft for over 5 years now and no doubt i will have this V+ box,V Box and cable modem for years as well. Contract ended 21st of january and they have made no effort to retrieve the equipment.

I agree, VM have their own part to play in the mass piracy in cable , not collecting old equipment and even worse, not disconnecting people from the taps in the cabinet, of course, some determined people may break into the cabinet and reconnect but most won't and it just leaves a live feed asking for non-subbed equipment to be connected.

The points on the age of Nagra 3 made aren't really valid, N3 has only be comprehensively used in the US for just over a year, the US is far more important in this respect than Europe since it's been the source of most of the old Nagra hacks, probably because that market offers the biggest financial return which is important if you're going to invest a few million in breaking an encryption system. European providers have been using it for a similar time period simulcrypted with other open versions or encryption systems.
It often takes 3-5 years of installation before any real progress is made but by all accounts N3 is so dynamic that it may take much longer this time around and by that time card based encryption systems may be deprecated.

Ben B 06-03-2010 23:49

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Horace (Post 34975581)
I agree, VM have their own part to play in the mass piracy in cable , not collecting old equipment and even worse, not disconnecting people from the taps in the cabinet, of course, some determined people may break into the cabinet and reconnect but most won't and it just leaves a live feed asking for non-subbed equipment to be connected.

The points on the age of Nagra 3 made aren't really valid, N3 has only be comprehensively used in the US for just over a year, the US is far more important in this respect than Europe since it's been the source of most of the old Nagra hacks, probably because that market offers the biggest financial return which is important if you're going to invest a few million in breaking an encryption system. European providers have been using it for a similar time period simulcrypted with other open versions or encryption systems.
It often takes 3-5 years of installation before any real progress is made but by all accounts N3 is so dynamic that it may take much longer this time around and by that time card based encryption systems may be deprecated.

And also it will probably be easier for them to make future encryption changes once we are all on the same network

Maggy 07-03-2010 01:25

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Again I ask when is the smart carding supposed to be finished? :erm:

Toto 07-03-2010 07:54

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34975611)
Again I ask when is the smart carding supposed to be finished? :erm:

I'd like to know that too, not had mine here in South Wales.

Sirius 07-03-2010 08:09

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34975611)
Again I ask when is the smart carding supposed to be finished? :erm:

I don't think VM will give out that information for security reasons.

Toto 07-03-2010 12:47

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 34975643)
I don't think VM will give out that information for security reasons.

Why is that a security issue?

Telling punters when the planned roll out of the new cards is due to be completed hardly constitutes a security issue. I think its rather the case they probably don't have a firm date in mind when they hope to complete it.

Maggy 07-03-2010 18:29

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 34975643)
I don't think VM will give out that information for security reasons.

Fairy snuff but it is inconvenient for the ordinary punter..especially as we don't know where we are in the timetable and what happens if we get forgotten and don't get a smart card.How will we know if we have been forgotten? ;)

Unlikely I know but not impossible or unheard of...;)

multiskilled 07-03-2010 18:53

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
As far as I know, messages appear on your stb telling you to insert new smart card before the actual full switch over. So if you haven't received your new card by then a quick call to cs will resolve the situation.

Maggy 07-03-2010 18:59

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by multiskilled (Post 34976015)
As far as I know, messages appear on your stb telling you to insert new smart card before the actual full switch over. So if you haven't received your new card by then a quick call to cs will resolve the situation.

Thank you.:)

aclivity 07-03-2010 22:25

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Toto (Post 34975807)
Why is that a security issue?

Telling punters when the planned roll out of the new cards is due to be completed hardly constitutes a security issue. I think its rather the case they probably don't have a firm date in mind when they hope to complete it.

I can think of a few reasons why VM don't advertise the dates for each region. Part of me hopes there is a cynic in charge of the roll out schedule who likes to read the "dodgy" forums to see "I just bought this new box from a guy in a pub, and now it's stopped working".

If I were in charge of the roll out, I'd keep the schedule quiet for that reason anyway.

Sirius 08-03-2010 06:41

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
They say there is no honour amongst thieves, Has anyone seen the increase in the sale of 3rd party boxes at knock down prices on ebay. You have box traders and those that have been hit already trying to off load there kit to the gullible who have no idea that they are getting ripped off .

:LOL:

Digital Fanatic 08-03-2010 15:04

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 34976252)
They say there is no honour amongst thieves, Has anyone seen the increase in the sale of 3rd party boxes at knock down prices on ebay. You have box traders and those that have been hit already trying to off load there kit to the gullible who have no idea that they are getting ripped off .

:LOL:

:LOL:

Oh dear... you've got to laugh haven't you :D A doorstop is still a doorstop.. even at these knockdown prices :D

Pauls9 08-03-2010 15:15

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Yes, but will I get an SA doorstop or a Samsung doorstop?

Should I go for a V+ doorstop?

It's important, you know...

Kymmy 08-03-2010 16:08

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Could be a Dbox2 doorstop!!

zing_deleted 08-03-2010 16:10

Re: Virgin media possibly getting serious on dodgy boxes?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 34976586)
Could be a Dbox2 doorstop!!

take it we are allowed to mention the names now they are coming to an end then?


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:00.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum