Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

I'm not kicking up a fuss.

haven't said they don't

What judgement have I made?
I totally accept it, where have I said I don't.

I just want to know how "jaw Dropping" and "highly racist" the comments were, and in what context they were made, before I decide anything about it.

That seems sensible to me.

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Nobody else on here has either ,you've been babbling on about not having evidence with which to judge her despite the fact that she has already been judged by people who did have the evidence and have the authority to judge her ,it may burst your bubble but you simply are not that important to have the right to judge her ,that is the privilege of UKIP.

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Tosh,

The subject has been posted on a discussion forum.

It's pretty difficult to form an opinion on whether the decision by UKIP to expel her was correct, in correct, a bit over the top etc etc. if we don't know the facts

It's perfectly acceptable to want to know the severity of her crime.

At the moment it's just, "UKIP expel councillor" so what?

He's also totally entitled to have an opinion on it, call it judging if you want, but it's how an opinion is formed, by weighing up the facts judging them and forming an opinion on the matter.

By your measure no one was allowed to form a judgement about the Labour MP in the Flags and White van scandal, it would be purely up to the Labour Party.

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

if i'm not important and just babbling why do you keep coming back for another poke at me? why can't you accept that i will wait until the interview is made public ,or is it bothering you that much that its causing you discomfort .

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

The way i read the OP and it seems most other contributers is that the thread was started as a comment on UKIP losing yet another councillor not as a thread to decide her guilt/innocence ,that has been decided and as yet she has not appealed the decision or commented on the incident.

---------- Post added at 10:36 ---------- Previous post was at 10:32 ----------

Because you're funny

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Not frustrating but it was an opportunity for you to redeem yourself and make some sense.

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

does the comment make you feel as though your closer to achieving your objective ?

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Yes it was, and as we're on a discussion forum, do you not think it is acceptable to discuss around that issue.

One of the points available for discussion would be if we thought UKIP was right to expel her and to do that we would need an analysis of what she said, but we don't have that information.

That is all.

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Would I be correct in assuming you will give everyone else who is accused of the something, no matter what the party/cause/religion, the same benefit of the doubt?

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

So do you think UKIP was right to expell her based on the fact she made jaw dropping racist comments .As far as i can see what she said is irrelavent,she made the comments (whatever they where) and UKIP decided they where that bad it justified immediate expulsion .The only judgement to be made in this thread is whether UKIP are right to expell members they deem to have used racist language

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

feel free to assume what ever you like .

---------- Post added at 11:08 ---------- Previous post was at 11:06 ----------

so you ask a question and then set the ground rules for the answer you want

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

how so ?? ,i've asked a question and given my view to the same question

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Originally Posted by martyh
The only judgement to be made in this thread is whether UKIP are right to expell members they deem to have used racist language

there you go the only judgement any one can make is the one you specify .

no mention of what other members are interested in such as what was said in the interview .etc etc


and now you want ukip judging after ranting about how unimportant i am in wanting evidence before judging the Councillor .

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

Has anyone suggested she's used racist language? A good Ukipper has a pop at gays too don't forget.

Re: Ukip expels councillor Rozanne Duncan for 'jaw-dropping' comments in TV interview
 

I'm not giving her the benefit of the doubt as such, I reserving comment until I know what she said, that's all.

---------- Post added at 11:55 ---------- Previous post was at 11:49 ----------

I don't know, I don't know what she said.

It's a fact she made comments.

How "jaw dropping" they may be is a matter of personal opinion.

I don't think it is, and I'd like to know what she said.

Either way I'd like to know.