![]() |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
surely the whole point of being the better team is that you have achieved a higher level of skill and fitness.. if you can't be fit for a reply a few days later or go into extra time them you didn't deserve to win.. remember when Stauea Bucharest won the European Cup against Barca.. they played for a 0-0 to win it on pens.. not the sort of thing the fans want to see and not a good for the globl TV audience
if a reply is a draw then have another one.. it happened in the past where teams had to play each other a few times.. the stronger team will win it in the end where as on pens the best team can end up losing.. it takes the skill out of the game |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Penalties make the game exciting. I have never seen a dull penaly shoot-out. Isn't that what football is supposed to be about? Excitement and entertainment?
And penalties do involve the whole team... Especially once they go into sudden death. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Quote:
Another NHL game (good example as NHL playoff games last untill there is a winner) started at 7pm and the winner was scored at 2:25am Ice Hockey is a fast moving sport, people said after the game that at times it looked at the players were moving in slow motion. Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Look at previous World Cups Baggio missed in a final, ordinarily you would put your house on him to score and look at 1990 Argentina played for penalties all the way through to the final, I would never want to see a team use such tactics to get to a final again, let alone be in with a chance of winning it. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Quote:
---------- Post added at 10:58 ---------- Previous post was at 10:56 ---------- Quote:
How that is any less of a lottery I don't know. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
And anyway, even for domestic matches it won't help. Fitness doesn't very much between teams in a similar league. They will tire together, meaning most willbe unable to string passes together and with a lack of running the game will develop into a snail's pace. The strikers will get weaker, but the goalkeeper won't. All this isn't conducive to a good football match. Also are people forgetting the serious impact this can have on a footballer's health? And can players really recooperate in 4 days after playing a 4 hour match? |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
---------- Post added at 11:14 ---------- Previous post was at 11:11 ---------- Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
---------- Post added at 11:19 ---------- Previous post was at 11:17 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Although it isn't such an issue in European matches (although it was commented on in Germany), my other points still stand for local matches. How is that any different to having a couple of decent penalty takers on the bench to bring on at the end of extra time, tbh I don't really have a problem with either, substituions are part of the game.[/QUOTE] |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
What if the best team loses the final because they had to play 300 minutes of football in the semi final whereas a poorer team only played 90? |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
---------- Post added at 11:49 ---------- Previous post was at 11:42 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
just to clarify i wasn't alking abut having a match last for 300 minutes.. i was talking about ending a match after ET and then replaying the match either in the next few days or the next day if possible. that would give people time to recover, maybe not as much as they would like but it would give them some time
if footballers in the 60s could do this and they weren't as fit as today's players then i'm sure we could do this now |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Punky raised a good point earlier. Goalies are going to get less tired than outfield players. Do you not think that the longer the game goes on, the chances of a goal goes down? |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
I think the real point here is that teams would try harder to win the match in ordinary time |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Though, if penalties are a lottery how come the Germans are so good? Their last loss in a penalty shootout was in 1976! |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
The Germans do have a remarkable record but if they were that confident why don't they play for penalties? I have seen occasions when they have been lucky to get penalties but I don't recall them ever playing for them, even when they have been in decline they don't. Sports psychologists would tell us that taking penalties is all about focusing, confidence and self belief maybe the German footballer has these qualities in abundance. You talk of lotteries, but sport in general is a lottery, what I feel we have to do though is find a way to get the best result for the game and whilst it is impractical to do this for every game we should at least be able to do it for the sport's showpiece. In some ways I would say that the goalden goal is more of a lottery than penalties as it could come down to a simple mistake in injury time, or to look at it another way the fear of going into extra time may inspire the players in normal time and I still think it is a better way to decide who is World Champions. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
:confused: Quote:
Compare Germany with Englands record in WC and Euro Shootouts. Germany Won 5 Lost 1 England Won 1 Lost 5 Doesn't look 50/50 to me, looks like something the Germans are good at and the English aren't Yes I'm sure most footballers are great at pens when there is no pressure, but composure is just as important as his first touch. So why should we get rid of them just cause some players can't cope with the pressure. Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
I certainly don't think teams would be cautious in normal time if they had goalden goal extra time, extra time these days is pretty much a complete waste of time, hardly anything ever happens and nobody does anything except wait for penalties. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
And neither is waiting until exhaustion gifts a team a goal.
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
surelt it would be better to have a replay 3 or 4 days which is the same gap between games during a WC anyway and if that ends in a draw after ET then have pens... it's better than just going to pens
in the old days some matches were won on the toss of a coin |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
in 66 there was a replay scheduled for Upton Park a few days later. there was even a programme already made just in case.. as has been the case for a long time until pens came in.. surely they could just say in the rules if no winner is decided then there will be a replay a few days later ok it would be difficult for some of the other matches during the second round onwards |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Anyway, Blatter has changed his tune a bit. It wasn't that long ago he was suggesting that ALL games which end drawn should be settled by a shootout.
---------- Post added at 16:51 ---------- Previous post was at 16:46 ---------- Quote:
If the match is drawn after 120 Minutes, both captains into the centre circle, best of three scissor, paper, stone. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
maybe a game of connect 4 instead believe me it did used to happen.. have to see if i can find some examples just realised we must be the only ones that take any notice of Blatter i'm sure FIFA won't even look into this.. unless they realised a replay would give them more revenue from an extra match on TV and extra ticket and programme sales it won't happen |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
I have posted this idea before, it's a shame I can't remember where I heard it, basically drawn games are decided on how many times the goalkeepers touch the ball (obviously excluding goal kicks, free kicks etc), this would encourage attacking football and discourage back passes also it has the added benefit of giving the fourth referee a job, I am not sure it would be a good idea for a World Cup final but perhaps it's worth looking at, the only downside being if you have Graham Poll as fourth ref ;) |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Bet it would get great viewing figures, though recovering for the next match might be problematic, since the big jessies get groin strain just by lifting their wallets. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Whilst imo it is a shame that first team squads are no longer representative of the fans, I don't think it really matters these days when they get paid so much cash, how can you identify with a player when they earn £100 000 a week regardless of their nationality. The days of players staying with their hometown club all their careers and staying on as a coach are long gone. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
The U's manage their first way win of the season :)
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Blue moon, you started singing too soon... ;)
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
W00t! Back to the top of the Premiership again :D
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Join the "top of the league" club if you wanna :D
(warsaw fans also welcome as are any more man u and forest fans but no cardiff fans allowed because english clubs only) |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
What is going on at West Ham ?
The signing of a couple of high profile players, plus speculation of a takeover, then linked with a takeover from a former bidder, then..... down the table we go. Quote:
---------- Post added at 00:00 ---------- Previous post was yesterday at 23:21 ---------- I predict that Arsenal will win the Champions League trophy in the next couple of seasons, don't ask me how I know :D |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Apparently Tevez is going to be sold in January to Valencia and apparently we are keeping 10 million of the transfer fee. A lot of people got upset when we signed them, look at Bobby Zamora, the leagues top scorer until they arrived, he was on fire putting them in with his thigh, backside etc. also Arsenal bid for Reo Coker on the strength of us signing Macherano so that unsettled him but the real reason imo is that we have missed Dean Ashton more than expected. The best thing for the club is to let the Argentines go and tell the Iranian and his chums to sod off we don't need them, we need the board to be strong and it's possible they will, as what not many people know is we still have members of the Cairns family on the board, their fore fathers started the club as Thames Iron Works. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Would make for some real gung ho stuff in the last part of the match. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Do you think Pardew will leave with this uncertainty going on ? He has said that he wouldn't, but I wouldn't blame him if he did. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Time to be very childish...
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
OOOooooo Matron ! :D
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
No doubt we'll get stuffed, but the chance to see Henry play will make up for it. Its dosent hurt so much to get done in by the World Cup Finalists... On the other hand, if by some miracle (and that it would be) we did manage to scrape a win (for it would be a scrape) - actually - forget it - aint gonna happen. :p: Come on Macedonia! |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
3 mins by the way - impressive! |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
I only took 1 though... :D
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Personally I hope the jocks get through, why just let the English enjoy your humiliation in the qualifiers, when hundreds of millions can do likewise in the finals. :D |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Hey, at least you made it through though right, as you say - brilliant entertainment - i don't know how many beers i laughed into, especially when my prediction came true, which if your interested is well documented in another thread somewhere around here. I can dig it up if you like. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
You know we are ranked fourth in the world now, above the winners of the World Cup :p:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Thought not ! ;) Quote:
Your posts beggar belief sometimes, I thought those kind of opinions were left back in the 1970's. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
1 Attachment(s)
What like this chap :D :p:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Well they are similar the only difference is instead of swinging a claymore he is swigging a special brew :)
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Followed by "Your posts beggar belief sometimes, I thought those kind of opinions were left back in the 1970's." Your comments, your words, your opinions - so who's left in the 1970's? What a :monkey: |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Decisions. decisions, I don't know if I should put my England supporters hat on whilst gloating over the Walse v Slovakia result 1-5 :D or put my Oldham Athletic shirt on for a crafty smirk at the Forest v Scunthorpe Utd result 0-4.:LOL: "Come on you Irons". :p:
PS. Can you name two ex Scunthorpe Utd FC players who were also former England captains? |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Kevin Keegan, Ray Clemence & Ian Botham! ;) |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Hi Gaz, forgot Clemence, but you got the trick one,:tu: :cool:
Jim. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
That's what we get told anyway :D Toshack - numpty. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
No problem, England are playing total carp [sic] come on you Jocks, one nil up against the Frogs.:cool: |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Euro 2008 qualifiers
Wales - Missed Giggs and another nine like him, I felt sorry for Bellamy who was made captain today. (Wales 1 - Slovakia 5) ROI - A few regular players out of the side, but it was only Cyprus after all (Cyprus 5 ROI 2) Northern Ireland - A good result against Denmark even though they were up against a constant attacking Denmark side most of the time. (Denmark 0 - NI 0) England - The only person to come out of the game with any credit was Crouch, Downing is out of his depth, Gerrard is overrated, Lampard is continually ineffective, in fact, the whole team were not playing as a unit. Beckham may have made a difference. (England 0 - Macedonia 0) Scotland - Fantastic result against the French, which is a big scalp. Hogmany will have nothing on this, nice to see Scotland back in the frame so to speak (Scotland 1 France 0) |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
No England jibes today ? I am surprised. ;) Indeed a great result for the jocks, but......... France had three times more of the ball, twice as many shots on target, and twice as many corners............. At least Dick Turpin wore a mask. :disturbd: |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Not to mention all those crooked ball boys
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
Not me i hasten to add. |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
England v Germany U21 second leg in Germany was a cracker, England 1-0 up from the home leg. A German player sent off in the first ten minutes, half the England side booked before half time ( ref was a plonker ). Germans missed a penalty in first half, In case you missed that, THE GERMANS MISSED A PENALTY in the first half. All the Germans playing to the Klinsmann manual, dive,dive,dive.:rolleyes: Second half more bookings and one England player sent off. England under the cosh for most of second half, Theo Walcott comes on as sub and scores two great goals to silence the Krauts, wonderful entertainment, pity we have the seniors to look forward to tomorrow. :(
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
No-one going to mention the England game then? :Sprint:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
We won't mention the England game if you don't mention the Welsh result from Saturday oops:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
why does poor Shaun W-P only ever get 15 minutes? why is there a rather injured looking Ashley Cole still hobbling around? who on earth thought that formation would work? :wtf:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
W00t! :D
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
excellent result England :) :P :walk::dig:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
W0000000000t!! :D
---------- Post added at 21:54 ---------- Previous post was at 21:40 ---------- Reeee-zult :) |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
at the rate England is going its not looking gooood....even Wales has more chance to get into the Euro Cup with their nicely won game against Cyprus.
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Cyprus are wack though.
|
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
In 1 word.............erm............better be careful here..........
CRAP ! :disturbd: |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
it was dire... :redcard:
well done to Wales though :tu: - showing how it should be done. when Steve McClaren first took over, he was all like 'well sven was into structure and keeping the boys in their positions, i'm going to let them have a free-er run' - now look at the mess they're in. how many days training together do the england team get? the legends in the sky match game looked better than the current england team! even the under 21's looked better (how come there are people who are over 21 playing in those teams?!) - Theo Walcott :clap: seems to have the anger of Rooney when he started, something like 'SEE, you should've picked me you ********!' I spent the whole of the world cup yelling 'pick Theo!' at the tv... :shrug: |
Re: Football Talk 2006/2007 Season
Quote:
You have to be under 21 at the start of the qualifying competition to be eligible for the under 21's ;) |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 19:04. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum