Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media News Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   More port blocking (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=4037)

Lord Nikon 26-11-2003 04:56

Re: More port blocking
 
Personally I think NTL should have an Opt-in principle as regards port blocking...
if you WANT them to port block, then they will, but you should also be able to opt for them NOT to block ports

Karl Prince 26-11-2003 17:45

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Myron
Ah, here is the best bit. A very polite note stating the issue that ISP's are blocking ports and that the firmware in all of their routers will be affected by this issue.

.....maybe LinkSys's software engineers will put in an option to allow the owner of the router to reserve inbound ports? Well, techincally not reserve, but an exclusion list.

:angel:

Such a good idea, that I emailed it to Linksys on the 8th of November (2003).

Not heard a thing back though.

One thing I mentioned, which would have a similar effect in an earlier post would be to forward the blocked ports to a nul address, stopping them being used to create outbound connections. Big downside is it makes these ports look apparently open, plus there are only ten rules in total, for people (like me) with email and web servers, don't have a lot to play with.

But back to your suggestion, if all the Linksys users email then maybe there would be more joy...

Alan Waddington 27-11-2003 09:03

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Karl Prince
Such a good idea, that I emailed it to Linksys on the 8th of November (2003).

Not heard a thing back though.

One thing I mentioned, which would have a similar effect in an earlier post would be to forward the blocked ports to a nul address, stopping them being used to create outbound connections. Big downside is it makes these ports look apparently open, plus there are only ten rules in total, for people (like me) with email and web servers, don't have a lot to play with.

But back to your suggestion, if all the Linksys users email then maybe there would be more joy...

Interesting thought on the port forwarding. It seems likely that the implementation forwards all packets received on the port, which suggests that it must also be reserved as an outgoing port. If the ports are forwarded to an IP address on the internal network that is not used, then surely the result is the same as dropping unaccepted packets, which is part of what happens when 'Block WAN Request' is enabled (i think).


Quote:

BLOCK WAN REQUEST: This feature is designed to prevent users from attacking your network through the internet. When Block WAN Request is enabled, the Router will drop both the unaccepted TCP request and ICMP packets from WAN site. The hacker will not find the Router by pinging the WAN IP address. Select ''Enable'' to enable this feature.
Thus using the forwarding feature does look promising as a workaround.

Alan Waddington 27-11-2003 09:24

Re: More port blocking
 
After more research it appears that early versions of linksys firmware do not in fact reserve the ports. So unless this has been fixed in later firmware versions, the port forwarding technique won't work.

See bug report: http://www.dslreports.com/faq/4808

Alan Waddington 27-11-2003 10:28

Re: More port blocking
 
I've forwarded ports 1024-5000 to nowhere & things are still working. Maybe the bugs fixed, or maybe the router hasn't cycled round to that part of the range yet. I can't see anything specific in linksys's firmware revision history about fixing this bug.

I suppose i could try forwarding a much bigger range to see if things fall over then.

[edit now forwarding 1024 - 65000 - this only leaves about 500 ports available - & we're still going - maybe the bugs fixed in later firmware - I'm using 1.44.2]

Any thoughts anyone?

[edit - or even better... Experiment with port forwarding on your router & report back on whether using a large range blocks internet access & the firmware version number]

Alan

Paul 27-11-2003 12:30

Re: More port blocking
 
Can you just clarify for me - the port forwarding you mention is for incoming traffic, not outgoing ?

Alan Waddington 27-11-2003 16:12

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
Can you just clarify for me - the port forwarding you mention is for incoming traffic, not outgoing ?

Yes it's the incoming port forwarding. The concept proposed by Karl earlier in the thread is that the router should reserve any outgoing ports which are subject to redirection incoming. This is because if router uses such a port as an outgoing port, then incoming packets would be incorrectly forwarded.

However there appears to be a bug in linksys s/w release 1.39 in that the forwarded ports are not reserved. However I cannot duplicate the problem with s/w release 1.44.2, so perhaps this is fixed.

It would be nice to reserve the ports NTL has blocked, but I am hoping for some second opinions on this before getting my hopes up too much.

[edit i have now forwarded the entire range 1024 - 65535 and still have internet access - somehow i don't think the linksys is reserving any ports - perhaps the NAT table takes priority over the forwarding table - i.e. It looks like this isn't working ]

Alan

Paul 27-11-2003 16:30

Re: More port blocking
 
Right, I agree it would (should) do this on forwarded ports unless it uses internal state information to remember what IP's it has made outgoing connections to [on the forwarded ports] and uses this information to bypass the forwarding when getting packets back.

This is not uncommon in more expensive firewall / Nat software.

Alan Waddington 27-11-2003 16:34

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
Right, I agree it would (should) do this on forwarded ports unless it uses internal state information to remember what IP's it has made outgoing connections to [on the forwarded ports] and uses this information to bypass the forwarding when getting packets back.

This is not uncommon in more expensive firewall / Nat software.

I think you are right - Oh well it was worth a try.


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:01.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum