Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Black Lives Matter (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33709106)

Maggy 14-06-2020 11:59

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
The problem now seems to be that we are arguing about statues and not about actually addressing the ways to deal with racial discrimination here and in THIS time.

pip08456 14-06-2020 12:40

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Protesters demand removal of Mahatma Gandhi statue in England.

https://nypost.com/2020/06/13/protes...ue-in-england/

Hom3r 14-06-2020 13:00

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
one piece of irony.


Some of these's protesters are wearing clothing made in sweat shops in modern day slavery.

Maggy 14-06-2020 13:21

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
This is the problem with the internet.Everything eventually ends up at whataboutism.:rolleyes:

downquark1 14-06-2020 14:52

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy (Post 36039744)
The problem now seems to be that we are arguing about statues and not about actually addressing the ways to deal with racial discrimination here and in THIS time.

The argument has been deliberately unmoored from reality. The UK police is not the US police and have little in way of similarity so they are suddenly under unfair scrutiny. People generally do protest about police brutality but nobody really cares about the statues of 18th century philanthropists except critical race theorists who want to undo the enlightenment.

In the US the officer has been charged with second degree murder and the other police with accessory to murder. Any realistic reform would certainly be taken seriously (such as perhaps mandatory body cameras) however they are just arguing about abolishing the police all together which is naturally provocative to anyone who isn't an anarchist.

Pierre 14-06-2020 15:23

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Give it another week or so, and it will have all moved on. Premier League starts next weekend.

Nobody is really bothered about Corona Virus anymore, the Dominic Cummings malarkey has been completely overtaken by events to inconsequential now. At piers Morgan has shut up about that finally.

The BLM protests have just shown themselves to be people that wanted have a good old scrap and break a few things, not actually change anything.

A couple of more weeks and with lock down over they can get back to knifing each other, I doubt there’ll be any protests when that all starts again.

jfman 14-06-2020 16:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
The poison that is English nationalism won't go away though, it'll just manifest itself in another way until England solves it's identity crisis. It's jealousy at other cultures taking pride in their own identity remains unresolved.

papa smurf 14-06-2020 17:06

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36039756)
The poison that is English nationalism won't go away though, it'll just manifest itself in another way until England solves it's identity crisis. It's jealousy at other cultures taking pride in their own identity remains unresolved.

I get the feeling you don't like the English.

jfman 14-06-2020 17:11

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36039757)
I get the feeling you don't like the English.

I like English people. However English nationalism on parade yesterday is utter poison. A mix of bile and hatred that I'm sure most reasonable people would consider appalling.

The thing is it's not 'for' anything, it doesn't convey a positive image of the English or British identity. Other than it resists others right to their identity - but that's reflective of the national psyche being grounded in centuries of oppressing and exploiting other identities and culture across the globe.

papa smurf 14-06-2020 17:16

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36039758)
I like English people. However English nationalism on parade yesterday is utter poison. A mix of bile and hatred that I'm sure most reasonable people would consider appalling.

The thing is it's not 'for' anything, it doesn't convey a positive image of the English or British identity. Other than it resists others right to their identity - but that's reflective of the national psyche being grounded in centuries of oppressing and exploiting other identities and culture across the globe.

Have you seen the Scotts when they go tribal,not exactly loved up are they.

jfman 14-06-2020 17:18

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36039759)
Have you seen the Scotts when they go tribal,not exactly loved up are they.

Tends to be due to a clash between British and Irish culture though when they do. :)

papa smurf 14-06-2020 17:20

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36039760)
Tends to be due to a clash between British and Irish culture though when they do. :)

Obviously it'll be someone else's fault.

jfman 14-06-2020 17:25

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36039761)
Obviously it'll be someone else's fault.

I don't understand... Most scenes in Scotland similar to those seen yesterday in London (Nazi salutes, etc) tend to be football related. One set of particularly confused individuals like the Nazi salute/Israel flag combo to be really out there...

papa smurf 14-06-2020 17:31

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36039762)
I don't understand... Most scenes in Scotland similar to those seen yesterday in London (Nazi salutes, etc) tend to be football related. One set of particularly confused individuals like the Nazi salute/Israel flag combo to be really out there...

bit of National pride there then.
Yesterday's mob were just rent a mob footy hooligans,we had the same crap here in cleethorpes all singing football songs and nazi saluting the police,it was just like a normal match day for most of them without the footy.

Julian 14-06-2020 17:40

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2020/06/3.jpg

I wonder how Prince William feels..........:erm:

papa smurf 14-06-2020 18:21

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Thugs pelt missiles as hundreds gather to 'protect' Sir Robert Peel statue under threat
HUNDREDS of people gathered to protect the statue of former prime minister and Metropolitan Police founder Sir Robert Peel in Scotland

Police - with their batons drawn - were forced to form a line across the street after missiles were launched between the two groups of demonstrators.

Police were able to stop the two groups from clashing with those looking to see the statue removed were forced back up North Hanover Street.


https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/12...cotland-latest


Elsewhere in Scotland, the words "racist king BLM" were sprayed in white paint on the plinth of the Robert the Bruce statue at the Battle of Bannockburn site in Stirling.

jfman 14-06-2020 18:51

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Rangers fans go out looking for a fight might be a more credible headline. It’s been a sore 9 years after all.

Again a sad group of people with no positive cultural identity to share with the rest of the world.

Pierre 14-06-2020 18:58

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
It seems the “English” are not allowed to have an identity. Personally, I am comfortable in my white, straight, male identity. I’ve never racially abused anyone, or sexually abused or harassed anyone. I’ve always tried to be a nice person, not always managed it.

If I have “white privilege” so be it, it’s an accident of birth, I won’t apologise for it.

There is enough legislation in this country to ensure everybody is treated fairly by the law.

So I will get on with my life.

jfman 14-06-2020 19:05

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36039769)
It seems the “English” are not allowed to have an identity. Personally, I am comfortable in my white, straight, male identity. I’ve never racially abused anyone, or sexually abused or harassed anyone. I’ve always tried to be a nice person, not always managed it.

If I have “white privilege” so be it, it’s an accident of birth, I won’t apologise for it.

There is enough legislation in this country to ensure everybody is treated fairly by the law.

So I will get on with my life.

Of course England is allowed to have an identity. My point is that it doesn’t have one - which leads to thugs embracing it and acting against anyone trying to develop their own positive one for themselves based on their own backgrounds. Be that the BAME communities, Scots, Irish, Welsh.

The notion of English identity got lost to a British one. Then the Empire crumbled. Creating a fragile national psyche threatened by seemingly anything innocuous.

I’d love England to develop a positive, outgoing, welcoming cultural identity for itself that it’s proud of. That gives it the confidence to not be threatened by others. And one that respectable people took ownership of, not absolute thugs.

nomadking 14-06-2020 19:39

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36039770)
Of course England is allowed to have an identity. My point is that it doesn’t have one - which leads to thugs embracing it and acting against anyone trying to develop their own positive one for themselves based on their own backgrounds. Be that the BAME communities, Scots, Irish, Welsh.

The notion of English identity got lost to a British one. Then the Empire crumbled. Creating a fragile national psyche threatened by seemingly anything innocuous.

I’d love England to develop a positive, outgoing, welcoming cultural identity for itself that it’s proud of. That gives it the confidence to not be threatened by others. And one that respectable people took ownership of, not absolute thugs.

Good luck with opening an English Cultural centre.:rolleyes: Never be allowed. Every other sort is allowed and often gets public funding. The English have been described as a mongrel race. You can't get that way unless you are NOT racist. By definition, it is those that are "racially pure" that are racist.
BBC2 9:50pm
Quote:

Reggie Yates: Life and Death in Chicago
The broadcaster travels to Chicago to investigate gun crime in President Obama's adopted hometown to find out why so many of the victims are young African-American men. He hears first-hand the accusations of police brutality, but after attending the aftermath of a shooting, and the funeral of a young black man, he comes to realise an even bigger problem is the majority of killings are perpetrated by African-Americans living in the city's poorest neighbourhoods.


---------- Post added at 18:39 ---------- Previous post was at 18:27 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039729)

So in all the instances portrayed in films and TV dramas, it's never a response that is returned to a Nazi?

Taf 14-06-2020 19:44

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Apparently short hair and being ex-military makes you an instant racist in the eyes of socialists (especially corbynistas) and anti-establishment types.

And if you post videos from African Americans (or "blacks" as they now wish to be known) who are slagging-off antifa and BLM, THEY are racist and so are you for posting them.

And discussing the many murders of white farmers by black gangs with machetes in South Africa (it still goes on) then you are "missing the point" as it's not black people in constant danger.

Neither is State racism in Malaysia against those of Chinese or Indian descent is "not something we should care about".

And 500 years of slavery and murder by Turks of white eastern Europeans is "ancient history".

These white Europeans people need to read a bit and stop flocking together to rant about white Europeans being the only racists on Earth.

Hugh 14-06-2020 19:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039771)
Good luck with opening an English Cultural centre.:rolleyes: Never be allowed. Every other sort is allowed and often gets public funding. The English have been described as a mongrel race. You can't get that way unless you are NOT racist. By definition, it is those that are "racially pure" that are racist.
BBC2 9:50pm


---------- Post added at 18:39 ---------- Previous post was at 18:27 ----------


So in all the instances portrayed in films and TV dramas, it's never a response that is returned to a Nazi?

You may wish to move your goalposts a little more subtly... ;)

From
Quote:

The thing about Nazi salutes, is that they should also be seen as calling the other side a Nazi.
to
Quote:

So in all the instances portrayed in films and TV dramas, it's never a response that is returned to a Nazi?
is one helluva shift; who were the far-right thugs around the Cenotaph yesterday responding to - the statues, if the police?*

Well done for trying, though... ;)

*I must have missed the police giving Nazi salutes.

BenMcr 14-06-2020 19:58

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039771)
Good luck with opening an English Cultural centre.:rolleyes: Never be allowed.

And what would those contain if you did that aren't already part of most British historical and societal institutions?

That's a serious question by the way.

nomadking 14-06-2020 20:14

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039777)
You may wish to move your goalposts a little more subtly... ;)

From

to

is one helluva shift; who were the far-right thugs around the Cenotaph yesterday responding to - the statues, if the police?*

Well done for trying, though... ;)

*I must have missed the police giving Nazi salutes.

What else would be the point of giving a nazi salute, other than to say, "you(ie the others) are bunch of nazis". Do other protesters never, ever, proclaim in one way or another that the other side is a X?



My point is that the person returning a salute of any kind, isn't necessarily supporting it.

jfman 14-06-2020 20:24

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Who are they returning it to???

BenMcr 14-06-2020 20:26

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039779)
What else would be the point of giving a nazi salute, other than to say, "you(ie the others) are bunch of nazis". Do other protesters never, ever, proclaim in one way or another that the other side is a X?

My point is that the person returning a salute of any kind, isn't necessarily supporting it.

What on earth is that logic?

In the current world the only people that use it are doing so to signal their own affiliation. In historical context is was imposed by the Nazis on those they ruled.

There is a reason it's illegal in German and Austria and can be illegal in the UK.

nomadking 14-06-2020 20:26

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039778)
And what would those contain if you did that aren't already part of most British historical and societal institutions?

That's a serious question by the way.

Completely irrelevant, of course. If anything there is potentially too much to choose from, but how much would be allowed nowadays? Then again what is in the others, that isn't inherently racist, and is from a foreign country, and relatively recent.

Centres are allowed and promoted for every other group. That is where those other groups congregate and close themselves off(and possibly get COVID-19). They are only interested in their community, and not the community.

BenMcr 14-06-2020 20:36

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039782)
Centres are allowed and promoted for every other group. That is where those other groups congregate and close themselves off(and possibly get COVID-19). They are only interested in their community, and not the community.

Most centres you are referring to are usually for those that have come to the UK and allows them to meet others from similar backgrounds and stay connected. They rarely are closing themselves off, but are sharing a background that others have not experienced.

The same can be true for other societal clubs like political affiliation clubs e.g. Conservative clubs or Labour clubs. It's also true of things like the Bullingdon club or many of the private members clubs in London and elsewhere.

nomadking 14-06-2020 20:45

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039781)
What on earth is that logic?

In the current world the only people that use it are doing so to signal their own affiliation. In historical context is was imposed by the Nazis on those they ruled.

There is a reason it's illegal in German and Austria and can be illegal in the UK.

Any "affiliation" to a side is indicated by presence.:rolleyes:
You can be(and people have) extradited to Germany or Austria for giving an opinion, yet when other countries want to extradite for more serious crimes(eg China/Hong Kong, Roman Polanksi), it's nothing doing.



So, do other protesters, NEVER, EVER, proclaim in one way or another that the other side is a X?

BenMcr 14-06-2020 20:47

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039785)
Any "affiliation" to a side is indicated by presence.:rolleyes:
You can be(and people have) extradited to Germany or Austria for giving an opinion, yet when other countries want to extradite for more serious crimes(eg China/Hong Kong, Roman Polanksi), it's nothing doing.

That's more to do with appropriate extradition agreements than anything we're talking about here.
Quote:

So, do other protesters, NEVER, EVER, proclaim in one way or another that the other side is a X?
Find me an example where ANYONE protesting against Nazis or neo-Nazis have used any symbols of those groups to proclaim that they are Nazis

nomadking 14-06-2020 21:04

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039784)
Most centres you are referring to are usually for those that have come to the UK and allows them to meet others from similar backgrounds and stay connected. They rarely are closing themselves off, but are sharing a background that others have not experienced.

The same can be true for other societal clubs like political affiliation clubs e.g. Conservative clubs or Labour clubs. It's also true of things like the Bullingdon club or many of the private members clubs in London and elsewhere.

Why not join the community centres for THE community, rather than create one just for THEIR community. By definition, they are the racists.


Did you see the Darcus Howe documentary a while back, "Who you calling a ..."? Full of non-white people disparaging other non-white people, eg Afro-Caribbeans slagging off Somalis. When white people complain about the SAME thing, they are called racist.:confused:


Why should there be an "Asian Cricket Club of the Year"(2019 winner Mount Cricket Club in Batley, West Yorkshire, members mostly Muslim) in the UK? Countless other examples where participation is racially based.

Damien 14-06-2020 21:09

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36039769)
It seems the “English” are not allowed to have an identity. Personally, I am comfortable in my white, straight, male identity. I’ve never racially abused anyone, or sexually abused or harassed anyone. I’ve always tried to be a nice person, not always managed it.

I am English and I have an identity. I mean I consider it more British since I think that's the culture I grew up in, the nation's various cultures mix is so strong that I don't think of anything as especially English rather than British.

nomadking 14-06-2020 21:11

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039786)
That's more to do with appropriate extradition agreements than anything we're talking about here.
Find me an example where ANYONE protesting against Nazis or neo-Nazis have used any symbols of those groups to proclaim that they are Nazis

I used the term "X", meaning "X" could represent a variety of things. Are you saying nobody held up a banner saying that the police are "X"?

BenMcr 14-06-2020 21:29

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039787)
Why not join the community centres for THE community, rather than create one just for THEIR community. By definition, they are the racists.

Most do where they exist as far as I'm aware. You can part of THE community whilst also being connected to YOUR community and history. Unsurprisingly it happens in many different countries:
https://www.expatica.com/es/living/i...groups-105841/
Quote:

Make new friends by browsing through our list of groups and expat clubs in Spain, from sports groups to social and family gatherings.
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039787)
Did you see the Darcus Howe documentary a while back, "Who you calling a ..."? Full of non-white people disparaging other non-white people, eg Afro-Caribbeans slagging off Somalis. When white people complain about the SAME thing, they are called racist.:confused:

It's called racism then too, so there is no excuse. For instance:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_Africa
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039787)
Why should there be an "Asian Cricket Club of the Year"(2019 winner Mount Cricket Club in Batley, West Yorkshire, members mostly Muslim) in the UK? Countless other examples where participation is racially based.

Why shouldn't there be? As I said before, you can be part of your community whilst still being able to have links to your own background and history.
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039789)
I used the term "X", meaning "X" could represent a variety of things. Are you saying nobody held up a banner saying that the police are "X"?

Using the Nazi salute and using words are not the same thing and cannot be equated. What you said was:
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039779)
What else would be the point of giving a nazi salute, other than to say, "you(ie the others) are bunch of nazis".

So when has ANYONE use a Nazi salute other than to indicate they themselves are Nazis or sympathise with that cause.

Mr K 14-06-2020 22:56

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039790)
Most do where they exist as far as I'm aware. You can part of THE community whilst also being connected to YOUR community and history. Unsurprisingly it happens in many different countries:
https://www.expatica.com/es/living/i...groups-105841/

It's called racism then too, so there is no excuse. For instance:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_Africa
Why shouldn't there be? As I said before, you can be part of your community whilst still being able to have links to your own background and history.Using the Nazi salute and using words are not the same thing and cannot be equated. What you said was:
So when has ANYONE use a Nazi salute other than to indicate they themselves are Nazis or sympathise with that cause.

I think you'll have to forgive Nomadking. Linked up thinking is hard sometimes.

The violence yesterday was down to right wing bored football fans with nothing better to do, any excuse will do for them. Whereas the BLM protests have been over whelmingly peaceful.

Hugh 14-06-2020 23:16

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36039779)
What else would be the point of giving a nazi salute, other than to say, "you(ie the others) are bunch of nazis". Do other protesters never, ever, proclaim in one way or another that the other side is a X?



My point is that the person returning a salute of any kind, isn't necessarily supporting it.

Maybe they’re giving a Nazi salute because they’re Nazis, and they weren’t returning it to anyone - you’re not just grasping at straws here, you have a whole bale in your possession.

(Occam’s razor and all that...).

Paul 14-06-2020 23:29

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Good grief, can we move on from Nazi salutes, its getting way off topic now.

tweetiepooh 15-06-2020 11:04

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
From experience in other countries - ex-pat Brits (usually English) form communities to isolate themselves from the locals and make a little England in the sun.

Other communities from centres to help people integrate as well as keeping some of their culture going and they usually welcome the wider community in to share that culture and build bridges and understanding. (Yes sometimes these can become little ghettos too.)

As a Christian I view all people as equally valuable and loved by God so should be loved by me also. Some are easier to love than others. And I'm not saying that we simply accept "bad" behaviour, we should speak up for those who are oppressed or being attacked.

Maggy 15-06-2020 12:13

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tweetiepooh (Post 36039828)
From experience in other countries - ex-pat Brits (usually English) form communities to isolate themselves from the locals and make a little England in the sun.

Other communities from centres to help people integrate as well as keeping some of their culture going and they usually welcome the wider community in to share that culture and build bridges and understanding. (Yes sometimes these can become little ghettos too.)

As a Christian I view all people as equally valuable and loved by God so should be loved by me also. Some are easier to love than others. And I'm not saying that we simply accept "bad" behaviour, we should speak up for those who are oppressed or being attacked.

I saw the colonial viewpoint as a child in Nigeria..Luckily it wasn't my parent's viewpoint and I had far more fun with my little Nigerian friends than I ever did with my white peers.

ianch99 15-06-2020 15:06

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy (Post 36039744)
The problem now seems to be that we are arguing about statues and not about actually addressing the ways to deal with racial discrimination here and in THIS time.

This post summarises perfectly the current situation. The right are deliberately playing the emotive patriotism card:

Quote:

the Prime Minister promises to fight "with every breath in his body" any attempt to remove the statue of Winston Churchill from Parliament Square
There is no mainstream campaign to remove Churchill's statue as far as I know. What this aims to do is to divert and water down any real discussion about racism in this country. The BLM inspired marches are not about tearing down statues, they are about the recognition of the real racism that black & asian people face in today's Britain. The fact that the Leave campaign, aided and abetted by the right wing MSM, played on these latent racist traits just adds to the problem.

Of course the Left never learn. While it was appropriate given the futile polite requests to remove the Colston statue over the years, that the statue was pulled down, it should have stopped there. Instead, the small in number militant Left chose to encourage a simplistic and childish approach to criticise any statue that had a link to slavery in the past. This naive thinking just plays into the hands of the right and allows them to misdirect anger & concern and escape the serious conversation they should be engaged in.

At the end of the day, statues are there to celebrate the life & achievements of the individual. If, in a modern context, that person has very little cause to be celebrated and moreover, is a visceral reminder of past evil deeds then there is a good case for it to be consigned to a museum.

Taking down a statue is not "whitewashing history". Many great men & women of history often have a dark side. This should be taken into consideration when put alongside the good. The judgement is, more often that not, nuanced and not the simplistic sloganing that the militant Left employ.

Take Churchill for example, he was, in his younger years a racist as were many of his peers. He was culpable in contributing to the causes of the Famine in Bengal in WWII. How much personal liability he had is very much debated by historians but he was involved. That said, you need to research and understand the history of the person and the period they lived in before you can make a serious judgment. Something the militant Left are incapable of doing it seems.

Going back to Colston, this quote from a letter to a newspaper sums up why his statue needed to be removed:

Quote:

"I suggest Bristol replaces Edward Colston with a different statue every day to honour an individual whom Colston “shipped”. It would be 233 years before plinth became empty again. That is the enormity of the man’s inhumanity."

Paul 15-06-2020 15:58

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039867)
There is no mainstream campaign to remove Churchill's statue as far as I know.

Mainstream is a matter of opinion I guess, google 'Topple the Racists'

Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039867)
While it was appropriate given the futile polite requests to remove the Colston statue over the years, that the statue was pulled down, it should have stopped there.

Of course its not appropriate, its mob rule and vandalism.
You cant just go destoying statues you dont agree with becasue someone else disagrees with you or refuses.

ianch99 15-06-2020 18:04

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36039868)
Mainstream is a matter of opinion I guess, google 'Topple the Racists'


Of course its not appropriate, its mob rule and vandalism.
You cant just go destoying statues you dont agree with becasue someone else disagrees with you or refuses.

Maybe your definition of mainstream is different to mine. I don't Google an overloaded phrase to form my opinions.

There have been many events over the course of history when "breaking the law" has proved, in hindsight, to be validated. I suspect this will prove to be one of them. This article is interesting and can provide the context behind the removal:

https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/news/b...edward-4211771

Quote:

"We don't have to condone vandalism to recognise cruelty and injustice," said Mr Ferguson in the hours after the statue was toppled.

"I now regret us not removing the Colston statue when I was Mayor to place it in Bristol Museum with full historical narrative - even though it would have been flying in the face of majority Bristol opinion," he added.

And Mr Ferguson was not wrong.

heero_yuy 15-06-2020 18:38

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Quote from The Sun: The Guardian is facing calls to “shut down” for hypocrisy after backing BLM protests when it branded Abraham Lincoln “abhorrent” in the US Civil War.

Originally called the Manchester Guardian, the paper was founded in 1821 by John Edward Taylor using profits from a cotton plantation that used slaves.

After his death in 1844, the paper is said to have then demanded Manchester’s cotton workers be forced back into work.

Now with a growing backlash against statues linked to slavery and racism, hundreds have signed a petition taking aim at the Guardian's history.

The petition to shut the paper down has been organised by novelist Tony Parsons, who tweeted: “Shameful links to slave-owning Confederate south. Built on the profits of cotton fields. Shut down The Guardian Newspaper.”

During the US Civil War the paper had sided with the southern Confederates against President Lincoln who wanted to abolish slavery.
As yea sow, so shall yea reap.

Maggy 15-06-2020 18:43

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
If we take a closer look at the previous owners of some of our historic paper publications I'm pretty sure we would find some very dubious outlooks and opinions that are seen as being offensive in the modern age.

BenMcr 15-06-2020 18:51

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 36039887)
As yea sow, so shall yea reap.

None of the people employed by the Guardian today expressed those opinions, and its owners are The Scott Trust which is named after the editor and owner who took the paper national and liberal over 100 years ago.

You can go back within living memory for plenty of other papers in the UK for some very abhorrent views and attitudes. There is a reason no-one in Liverpool buys The Sun to this day.

ianch99 15-06-2020 18:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy (Post 36039888)
If we take a closer look at the previous owners of some of our historic paper publications I'm pretty sure we would find some very dubious outlooks and opinions that are seen as being offensive in the modern age.

I quite agree. The Guardian thing is another desperate attempt to divert discussion. You will find the House of Lords is stuffed with Peers who made their family wealth from dubious means e.g. slavery, etc. If you follow the Sun's logic, we need to go after them as well :)

It is not what the Guardian said 150 years ago, it is what is says today that matters. In contrast, Colston is the same vile human being today as he was all those years ago.

daveeb 15-06-2020 19:10

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039891)
None of the people employed by the Guardian today expressed those opinions, and its owners are The Scott Trust which is named after the editor and owner who took the paper national and liberal over 100 years ago.

You can go back within living memory for plenty of other papers in the UK for some very abhorrent views and attitudes. There is a reason no-one in Liverpool buys The Sun to this day.


:tu: Indeed. They tried giving it away once and that didn't go very well.

papa smurf 15-06-2020 19:28

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039892)
I quite agree. The Guardian thing is another desperate attempt to divert discussion. You will find the House of Lords is stuffed with Peers who made their family wealth from dubious means e.g. slavery, etc. If you follow the Sun's logic, we need to go after them as well :)

It is not what the Guardian said 150 years ago, it is what is says today that matters. In contrast, Colston is the same vile human being today as he was all those years ago.

He's dead and turned to dust.

Taf 15-06-2020 20:06

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36039790)
What you said was:
So when has ANYONE use a Nazi salute other than to indicate they themselves are Nazis or sympathise with that cause.

Just before the (supposed right wing) guy ended up on the floor, but was then picked up and carried to safety by a member of blm in London..

OLD BOY 15-06-2020 20:47

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039892)
I quite agree. The Guardian thing is another desperate attempt to divert discussion. You will find the House of Lords is stuffed with Peers who made their family wealth from dubious means e.g. slavery, etc. If you follow the Sun's logic, we need to go after them as well :)

It is not what the Guardian said 150 years ago, it is what is says today that matters. In contrast, Colston is the same vile human being today as he was all those years ago.

As slavery was abolished in 1833, there are no peers who have 'made' their money through slavery. They are old, yes, but not that old! :rofl:

Hugh 15-06-2020 20:50

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36039903)
As slavery was abolished in 1833, there are no peers who have 'made' their money through slavery. They are old, yes, but not that old! :rofl:

That is under the assumption that each generation of Peers starts of afresh, not using the money from the generations before...

<narrator>"that doesn't happen"

Paul 15-06-2020 20:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039892)
I quite agree. The Guardian thing is another desperate attempt to divert discussion.

It is not what the Guardian said 150 years ago, it is what is says today that matters. In contrast, Colston is the same vile human being today as he was all those years ago.

Wow, you're two faced logic is just unbelieveable.
The founder of the Guardian is also the same human being he was back then.
By following your logic, either the statue should have been left alone, or the Guardian closed.

Btw, the "vile" human being also did a lot of good on his death.
Quote:

On his death in 1721, he bequeathed his wealth to charities and his legacy can still be seen on Bristol's streets, memorials and buildings.

OLD BOY 15-06-2020 21:02

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039905)
That is under the assumption that each generation of Peers starts of afresh, not using the money from the generations before...

<narrator>"that doesn't happen"

In which case, they've inherited it, not made it.

---------- Post added at 20:02 ---------- Previous post was at 20:00 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36039909)
Wow, you're two faced logic is just unbelieveable.
The founder of the Guardian is also the same human being he was back then.
By following your logic, either the statue should have been left alone, or the Guardian closed.

Btw, the "vile" human being also did a lot of good on his death.



And that's why the statue is there. It's nowt to do with slavery.

Hugh 15-06-2020 21:05

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36039910)
In which case, they've inherited it, not made it.

---------- Post added at 20:02 ---------- Previous post was at 20:00 ----------


[/B]
And that's why the statue is there. It's nowt to do with slavery.

And used the inheritance to create more wealth - without the starting point, they would not have the wealth they now earn.


Not far from me - Harewood House
Quote:

The ground that Harewood House was built on was bought by Henry Lascelles in 1738, using money from the West Indian sugar trade. The money came from owning plantations, slaves, ships and warehouses, a fact that was pervasive throughout British society at the time, with many of the great institutions; the Church, banks, artistic and educational establishments – either created or greatly enhanced during that period.

Henry was involved in every aspect of the sugar trade, which might now be called vertical integration and however abhorrent the nature of his business, he was a very astute businessman, who became one of the richest men in England.

Damien 15-06-2020 21:37

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36039909)

Btw, the "vile" human being also did a lot of good on his death.

On the other hand that was with money largely made from slavery. You shouldn't get to be remembered as a good person because some of the money you used by transporting, selling and killing human beings is given to charity. His company used to brand slaves with a hot iron so that they were clearly 'theirs' and thousands of them died in transportation. The statue effectively ignores that because the money went to Bristol.

Pierre 15-06-2020 22:39

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
When are we going to destroy all the statues and memorials of Egyptian Pharoahs ?

I’m marching on the Sphinx tomorrow to burn it down.

How much do they earn each year in tourism dollars ofF the back Of the slaves that built the pyramids.......( it was aliens actually but ssh)

Paul 15-06-2020 23:09

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36039917)
You shouldn't get to be remembered as a good person because some of the money you used by transporting, selling and killing human beings is given to charity.

The fact remains that he did what he did, and a lot of people have benefited from it. The statue was not erected to celebrate his evil deeds, nor were schools and streets so named. I would venture that very few people with statues have zero skeletons in their closet. History is what it is.

---------- Post added at 22:09 ---------- Previous post was at 22:08 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36039921)
I’m marching on the Sphinx tomorrow to burn it down.

There are, I believe, reports (or theories) that slaves were not in fact used to build it or the pyramids, either way, good luck burning down solid stone, it will take some doing.

ianch99 15-06-2020 23:20

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36039909)
Wow, you're two faced logic is just unbelieveable.
The founder of the Guardian is also the same human being he was back then.
By following your logic, either the statue should have been left alone, or the Guardian closed.

Btw, the "vile" human being also did a lot of good on his death.

Oh dear ..

So, I see .. it is ok to traffic in human cargo, killing many, as long as you make lots of money and give some of it away. Got it ..

---------- Post added at 22:20 ---------- Previous post was at 22:18 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039905)
That is under the assumption that each generation of Peers starts of afresh, not using the money from the generations before...

<narrator>"that doesn't happen"

It is clear OB knew that .. he was just making mischief :)

Julian 15-06-2020 23:33

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36039921)
When are we going to destroy all the statues and memorials of Egyptian Pharoahs ?

I’m marching on the Sphinx tomorrow to burn it down.

How much do they earn each year in tourism dollars ofF the back Of the slaves that built the pyramids.......( it was aliens actually but ssh)

Closer to home what about the rubble strewn across Salisbury Plain.

They should demolish it and use the gravel to build the badly needed by-pass.

Damien 15-06-2020 23:52

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36039923)
The fact remains that he did what he did, and a lot of people have benefited from it. The statue was not erected to celebrate his evil deeds, nor were schools and streets so named. I would venture that very few people with statues have zero skeletons in their closet. History is what it is.[

It wasn't erected to celebrate his evil deeds but the good deeds he did do were funded by that slavery.

I think that's different to someone who's good deeds are unconnected to why there are honoured. George Washington owned slaves, but the Washington Monument exists to honour him as a Founding Father, Leader of the Patriot Army and the first US President.

So that's where I think a key difference lies, especially since all historical figures will likely be tainted by the period of the history they lived in. The question we should ask is what did they do and did the good outweigh the bad? Churchill? Absolutely yes, the good outweighs the bad.

Does Colston's charity outweigh slavery? I don't think so.

But going back to what I said many pages ago, and to reference Pierre's point about the pyramids, maybe the better thing to do is put new information up saying where the money that built those buildings in Bristol came from.

This is who Colston is, this is what he did with the money and this is where that money came from kind of a thing.

1andrew1 15-06-2020 23:59

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36039923)
There are, I believe, reports (or theories) that slaves were not in fact used to build it or the pyramids, either way, good luck burning down solid stone, it will take some doing.

Yes, some links here:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-e...6091E720100110
https://www.egypttoday.com/Article/4...laves%E2%80%99

downquark1 16-06-2020 07:45

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
The pyramids are a bad example but there are others that can be used across history. Romans, Ottermans, mongolian structures.

OLD BOY 16-06-2020 08:40

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039913)
And used the inheritance to create more wealth - without the starting point, they would not have the wealth they now earn.


Not far from me - Harewood House

So he inherited the wealth, that's not his fault. You can't pin the slavery on him. We are not responsible for the sins of our forefathers, and life goes on.

I feel the movement has been hijacked by these violent protesters. It's about police violence against black people in the US, not freaking statues. :no:

papa smurf 16-06-2020 09:16

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
If one could make money from self righteous indignation there would be a couple of millionaires on these pages;)

ianch99 16-06-2020 09:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36039941)
If one could make money from self righteous indignation there would be a couple of millionaires on these pages;)

Can I borrow some money? ;)

---------- Post added at 08:54 ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Julian (Post 36039930)
Closer to home what about the rubble strewn across Salisbury Plain.

They should demolish it and use the gravel to build the badly needed by-pass.

Err .. what would they bypassing if they demolished it?

papa smurf 16-06-2020 09:58

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039944)
Can I borrow some money? ;)

---------- Post added at 08:54 ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 ----------



Err .. what would they bypassing if they demolished it?

You must be rich beyond the dreams of avarice:rolleyes:

Hugh 16-06-2020 10:26

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36039941)
If one could make money from self righteous indignation there would be a couple of millionaires on these pages;)

Totally agree - all this fuss over one statue...

---------- Post added at 09:26 ---------- Previous post was at 09:24 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36039940)
So he inherited the wealth, that's not his fault. You can't pin the slavery on him. We are not responsible for the sins of our forefathers, and life goes on.

I feel the movement has been hijacked by these violent protesters. It's about police violence against black people in the US, not freaking statues. :no:

That’s not what the U.K. BLM movement’s about, no matter how many times you say it...

downquark1 16-06-2020 10:40

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039950)
That’s not what the U.K. BLM movement’s about, no matter how many times you say it...

How many people in the movement have degrees in "communications"?

papa smurf 16-06-2020 10:44

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36039921)
When are we going to destroy all the statues and memorials of Egyptian Pharoahs ?

I’m marching on the Sphinx tomorrow to burn it down.

How much do they earn each year in tourism dollars ofF the back Of the slaves that built the pyramids.......( it was aliens actually but ssh)

I'm a bit worried about the jolly Fisherman statue at skeggy:)

Pierre 16-06-2020 11:11

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36039932)

The original post was tongue in cheek, anyway.

[off topic]Any one that claims to know how or why the pyramids were built is talking out their backside. We don't know why or how they were built and probably never will[/off topic]

now back to the BLM nonsense.

tweetiepooh 16-06-2020 11:11

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
What about John Newton who was a slaver then became a Christian, was convicted of that trade and changed? He penned the hymn Amazing Grace, do we rip that out of the hymnal because it likely wouldn't have been written without his experience as a slaver?

Some of these slavers and owners of slaves made their wealth that way and then changed and left wealth to charities not as "penance" (can't buy you way into heaven) but to demonstrate that change or even just to benefit the community.

Pierre 16-06-2020 11:22

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Somebody get the ouija Board out so we can help this lady.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFNhFFSd1rw

figgyburn 16-06-2020 11:35

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
https://www.indy100.com/article/fion...racist-9568041

Another loony lefty.Give it a rest.

Russ 16-06-2020 12:04

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36039940)
We are not responsible for the sins of our forefathers

Admittedly I've not read much of this thread but here's something that often vexes me. To the best of my knowledge I've not displayed racial attitudes to anyone. True, the Indian woman I was with for 10 years, I cannot stand the very fabric of her being but that's for a number of reasons, none of which are anywhere connected to her race. In fact we have a mixed race son together but that's all going off the point I'm making.

This could be down to my own perception, I accept that's a possibility but recently it has felt as if I (and other whites) ought to feel some sort of shame or embarrassment etc due to the racist attitudes and actions of some of my forefathers who may (or may not, I don't know much about them) have been racist, kept slaves etc. All of which would be abhorrent behaviour but is not something I feel I ought to apologise for, or display shame etc.

It wasn't me, and had I been around in those days I cannot imagine myself treating another human so disgustingly purely based on their race.

Pierre 16-06-2020 13:02

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 36039971)
my forefathers who may (or may not, I don't know much about them) have been racist, kept slaves etc. All of which would be abhorrent behaviour but is not something I feel I ought to apologise for, or display shame etc.

It wasn't me, and had I been around in those days I cannot imagine myself treating another human so disgustingly purely based on their race.

A point I made earlier in the thread and also my position on the matter.

OLD BOY 16-06-2020 14:06

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36039950)
Totally agree - all this fuss over one statue...

---------- Post added at 09:26 ---------- Previous post was at 09:24 ----------

That’s not what the U.K. BLM movement’s about, no matter how many times you say it...

My support is for the US BLM. The British version was meant to be about discrimination by British police.

The statue wreckers are the anarchists who are just looking for aggro.

---------- Post added at 13:06 ---------- Previous post was at 13:03 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 36039971)
Admittedly I've not read much of this thread but here's something that often vexes me. To the best of my knowledge I've not displayed racial attitudes to anyone. True, the Indian woman I was with for 10 years, I cannot stand the very fabric of her being but that's for a number of reasons, none of which are anywhere connected to her race. In fact we have a mixed race son together but that's all going off the point I'm making.

This could be down to my own perception, I accept that's a possibility but recently it has felt as if I (and other whites) ought to feel some sort of shame or embarrassment etc due to the racist attitudes and actions of some of my forefathers who may (or may not, I don't know much about them) have been racist, kept slaves etc. All of which would be abhorrent behaviour but is not something I feel I ought to apologise for, or display shame etc.

It wasn't me, and had I been around in those days I cannot imagine myself treating another human so disgustingly purely based on their race.

I agree, Russ. I think people are running out of ideas on what to protest about! It's all getting rather tiresome.

Damien 16-06-2020 14:55

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 36039971)
This could be down to my own perception, I accept that's a possibility but recently it has felt as if I (and other whites) ought to feel some sort of shame or embarrassment etc due to the racist attitudes and actions of some of my forefathers who may (or may not, I don't know much about them) have been racist, kept slaves etc. All of which would be abhorrent behaviour but is not something I feel I ought to apologise for, or display shame etc.

It isn't about feeling personal shame but rather a recognition it happened. The main argument activists have isn't that white people should feel guilty but to have a greater understanding that it happened, that is was really bad and that consequences of racism linger.

Even over this statue debate there is a lot of 'he did some good things, he did some bad things' but that seems to underplay just how bad those things where. It does still seem like we're resistant to properly confront that part of British history, handwaving it away.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 36039971)
It wasn't me, and had I been around in those days I cannot imagine myself treating another human so disgustingly purely based on their race.

You probably would. As I probably would. As most people would have and did. You are conditioned by the society that you grew up in. Few people are ever actively railing against what is considered normal at any one time in history. Even in the last 100-150 years there was a time when it was only a small minority who argued women should have the vote, or that homosexuality should be legal and within our lifetime it was a majority opinion that gay marriage should be illegal.

The interesting thing with that thought is what do we consider acceptable now that we won't in 50, 100, 200 years?

OLD BOY 16-06-2020 15:10

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36039989)
It isn't about feeling personal shame but rather a recognition it happened. The main argument activists have isn't that white people should feel guilty but to have a greater understanding that it happened, that is was really bad and that consequences of racism linger.

Even over this statue debate there is a lot of 'he did some good things, he did some bad things' but that seems to underplay just how bad those things where. It does still seem like we're resistant to properly confront that part of British history, handwaving it away.

Are you honestly saying that people didn't know there was slavery all those years ago? I certainly did, and I dare say you did, too. It is no secret, it is in the past, and it has not directly affected any living person.

The big thing now that we should be concentrating on is ironing out the inequalities, which 50 years on from the Race Discrimination Act, still persist today.

The concentration on slavery and choice of words people use are little more than devices to change the subject. There is no excuse for treating black people differently for no good reason and people need to learn that. However, given the attitude of some people towards race equality legislation ("Why are they getting more privileges than me?") and Black Lives Matter ("All lives matter"), perhaps we need to ditch existing legislation for all groups and simply have equality legislation that applies to everyone. People might get it then.

BenMcr 16-06-2020 16:08

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36039992)
perhaps we need to ditch existing legislation for all groups and simply have equality legislation that applies to everyone. People might get it then.

The US have supposedly had that since 1964 - not sure it's really worked out that way though.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964
Quote:

The Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Pub.L. 88–352, 78 Stat. 241, enacted July 2, 1964) is a landmark civil rights and labor law in the United States that outlaws discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex,[a] or national origin.[4]

ianch99 16-06-2020 16:20

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
I think that people being more interested in getting angry about statues rather than the wider issue of racism itself sort of validates the whole debate.

From my point of view, the damage to Colston statue was, on balance, merited. The others are not ..

Russ 16-06-2020 16:59

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36039989)


You probably would. As I probably would. As most people would have and did.

Whereas I see what you're trying to say, I much prefer to be judged/assessed on what I did rather than what I might or probably have done.

For example, we have met and I considered you to be a top lad. But you're an English football fan, should I have assumed you'd have been a knuckle-dragging hooligan? Of course not.

Damien 16-06-2020 17:38

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 36040006)
Whereas I see what you're trying to say, I much prefer to be judged/assessed on what I did rather than what I might or probably have done..

It's not a judgement on you though, it's a judgement on what society was like then.

Julian 16-06-2020 18:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36039944)
Can I borrow some money? ;)

---------- Post added at 08:54 ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 ----------



Err .. what would they bypassing if they demolished it?

The single carriageway A303 there. :)

richard s 16-06-2020 20:25

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by figgyburn (Post 36039966)
https://www.indy100.com/article/fion...racist-9568041

Another loony lefty.Give it a rest.




I am really surprised she has not complained about the PG Tips adverts.




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z5em8lQAcvg

Maggy 16-06-2020 23:56

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
So anyone got any definite suggestions on how we address the issue of racism here and now..apart from removing statues because I think we need to do far more to address the issue.

Carth 17-06-2020 04:40

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy (Post 36040036)
So anyone got any definite suggestions on how we address the issue of racism here and now..apart from removing statues because I think we need to do far more to address the issue.


A meteor strike might do it, as long as nobody survives.

Anything less drastic than that won't work

papa smurf 17-06-2020 09:33

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy (Post 36040036)
So anyone got any definite suggestions on how we address the issue of racism here and now..apart from removing statues because I think we need to do far more to address the issue.

Just be nice to each other,it's not that hard to be inofensive,it's all down to the individual,laws won't work neither will marches /vandalism and kneeling ,it's all down to what's inside people love or hate, nurture the love or live a twisted life hating anyone different from you :shrug:

denphone 17-06-2020 09:54

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36040050)
Just be nice to each other,it's not that hard to be inofensive,it's all down to the individual,laws won't work neither will marches /vandalism and kneeling ,it's all down to what's inside people love or hate, nurture the love or live a twisted life hating anyone different from you :shrug:

Its also about educating people in a wider context about our history and not airbrushing parts out of it which are deeply inconvenient.

peanut 17-06-2020 10:16

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
It'll only get worse because people just to woke and get too offended by the smallest of things that suit any agenda.

Carth 17-06-2020 11:45

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36040061)
It'll only get worse because people just to woke and get too offended by the smallest of things that suit any agenda.

:Yes:

mrmistoffelees 17-06-2020 12:02

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36040061)
It'll only get worse because people just to woke and get too offended by the smallest of things that suit any agenda.

Yes, we should just do nothing, Or, how about we could revert back to 18th, 19th or even early 20th century practices? That would solve the issues.


Seriously, go and give your heard a shake.

peanut 17-06-2020 12:04

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmistoffelees (Post 36040083)
Yes, we should just do nothing, Or, how about we could revert back to 18th, 19th or even early 20th century practices? That would solve the issues.


Seriously, go and give your heard a shake.

Can't quite see what your reply has to do with my comment.

mrmistoffelees 17-06-2020 12:08

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36040086)
Can't quite see what your reply has to do with my comment.


Attempting to say that it will be the fault of people who are in your words 'to woke' if the situation deteriorates is a ridiculous statement.

papa smurf 17-06-2020 12:10

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36040086)
Can't quite see what your reply has to do with my comment.

It is a huge over reaction.

mrmistoffelees 17-06-2020 12:11

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36040088)
It is a huge over reaction.


Potentially, but only in response to an idiotic statement.

papa smurf 17-06-2020 12:13

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmistoffelees (Post 36040089)
Potentially, but only in response to an idiotic statement.

There you go again,you should try counting slowly to 100 before replying;)

mrmistoffelees 17-06-2020 12:19

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36040090)
There you go again,you should try counting slowly to 100 before replying;)

Nothing over the top at all.

The current issue's aren't being caused by people being 'to woke' nor would a further deterioration be able to to be attributed to being 'to woke' either.

There's currently a refusal to listen or hear (to some degree, from all 'sides') which is impacting and will continue to impact the change that needs to be made.

Carth 17-06-2020 12:24

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmistoffelees (Post 36040089)
Potentially, but only in response to an idiotic statement.

Nothing idiotic about a statement that suggests there will always be certain people who complain and feel aggrieved at a 'percieved' injustice . . often something so inconsequential that it goes unnoticed apart from those actively looking for such occurences.

If some people have a mindset that they're always picked on, then that's how they will go through life . . . dragging similar minded folk along with them.


edit: post in question =
Quote:

It'll only get worse because people just to woke and get too offended by the smallest of things that suit any agenda.

mrmistoffelees 17-06-2020 12:26

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36040096)
Nothing idiotic about a statement that suggests there will always be certain people who complain and feel aggrieved at a 'percieved' injustice . . often something so inconsequential that it goes unnoticed apart from those actively looking for such occurences.

If some people have a mindset that they're always picked on, then that's how they will go through life . . . dragging similar minded folk along with them.

Apart from the fact the situation isn't 'perceived'

Carth 17-06-2020 12:28

Re: Black Lives Matter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmistoffelees (Post 36040098)
Apart from the fact the situation isn't 'perceived'


Read the posts again, you're proving a point :p:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 00:40.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum