Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Britain outside the EU (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33709659)

Sephiroth 31-03-2022 21:11

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36117890)
What a cop out, they're all at it so that makes it all right, it's because of attitudes like that things will never change and the infantilisation of British politics will continue, what a pity, never had you down as part of the problem but guess I just thought to highly of you, that was my foolish mistake



It doesn't matter because they won't be held to account but that doesn't mean I'll shut up about it, might be time for you to go back on ignore, your simpering sycophantic ways are mildly annoying

"mildly annoying" maybe - but highly entertaining.

And sometimes, as with COVID, OB is substantially right.

Mad Max 31-03-2022 21:36

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36117861)
If you were fool enough to fall for any promises made by a politician - from either side - then I guess nobody can help you . . . carry on moaning though, because it's apparently good to release that pent up anger and disillusionment ;)

:tu:

OLD BOY 31-03-2022 21:36

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36117890)

It doesn't matter because they won't be held to account but that doesn't mean I'll shut up about it, might be time for you to go back on ignore, your simpering sycophantic ways are mildly annoying

I’m not trying to ‘shut you up’, mate, I’m just making sure that you attribute these comments correctly.

Hugh 31-03-2022 23:35

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36117892)
"mildly annoying" maybe - but highly entertaining.

And sometimes, as with COVID, OB is substantially right.

https://c.tenor.com/9AxpRD2d5d0AAAAM...g-eyes-man.gif

Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36031472)
Yes, it is. The difference being that currently there is no way we can treat it, because it is new. That was the government's concern, and that of governments around the world. The sudden heavy demand for hospital services, concentrated over a few short weeks, was the problem.

There is no doubt that the emergency measures have reduced numbers. I didn't claim that this was not the case. What I am saying is that so far at least, the number of recorded deaths is nowhere near those recorded for seasonal flu. Of course, they are still going up, but we appear to be reaching the peak now. It's a stretch to believe the final figure will be five times what we have now. Double, sure, maybe three times. But five times? Yeah, right!

On the date of the above post, (13th April 2020), there had been 16,393 COVID deaths in the U.K. - the most recent figures for U.K. COVID deaths is 165, 361…

Sephiroth 31-03-2022 23:53

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36117910)
[img]Download Failed (1)[/img]



On the date of the above post, (13th April 2020), there had been 16,393 COVID deaths in the U.K….

FLU DEATHS - and that's with vaccines

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulat...000/2015-11-25

Quote:

Between December 2014 and March 2015 there were 44,000 excess winter deaths, 2.5 times higher than the record low of the previous winter, and the highest number since the winter of 1999/2000 when flu levels were very high.

Hugh 31-03-2022 23:57

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
And in two years we have had 4 times that amount…

https://www.health.org.uk/publicatio...a-proved-wrong

Quote:

In a bad flu year on average around 30,000 people in the UK die from flu and pneumonia, with a loss of around 250,000 life years. This is a sixth of the life years lost to COVID-19.

OLD BOY 01-04-2022 00:55

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36117913)
And in two years we have had 4 times that amount…

https://www.health.org.uk/publicatio...a-proved-wrong

I think you will find we are in a much better situation now. We are not talking about two years ago, or one year ago. We are talking about this year, 2022.

RichardCoulter 07-05-2022 14:30

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Those interested in Brexit might find this programme on Monday interesting:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001740w

It examines what they believe were the origins of Brexit.

Quote:

In this programme Robert returns to the controversial Maastricht Treaty of 1992 which transformed Europe into a political union rather than just an economic one. This unleashed a civil war in the Conservative Party which has echoed down the ages and arguably resulted in Brexit. David Davies MP was in the thick of that battle as Chief Whip to Prime Minister John Major. He takes us back to pivotal moments of that drama when the future of the country hung in the balance and the consequences of which we're living with today.

Itshim 07-05-2022 18:55

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Should never have changed to political

OLD BOY 07-05-2022 20:25

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RichardCoulter (Post 36121466)
Those interested in Brexit might find this programme on Monday interesting:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001740w

It examines what they believe were the origins of Brexit.

I have always thought that this treaty was like a red rag to a bull, and we did not vote for the EU we see today.

1andrew1 08-05-2022 15:50

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
No one's realistically talking about re-joining the EU in the forseeable future.

But as people's disposable income is squeezed, I'm sure we'll start to read more articles like this one, ironically from the pro-Brexit City AM.
Quote:

EU membership vs lost trade: Forget extra NHS cash, Brexit costs Britain £173m every week, or £1m per hour

Studying the latest Office for National Statistics (ONS) data and comparing the UK Government’s annual contributions to the EU versus lost EU exports by examining data for 2018, the last year before pre-Brexit preparations skewed data, and comparing it with 2021 figures, it turns out that far from bringing in £350m a week to lavish on the NHS, the UK as a whole is £9bn out of pocket.
https://www.cityam.com/eu-membership...173m-per-week/

Carth 08-05-2022 16:43

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Usual rubbish spouted by new journo . . well he looks about 20 in his pic.
Anyway, no mention of how Covid (remember that? ) has skewed any financial figures since 2018 . . clickbait article for the gullible, of which there are many :p:

Hugh 08-05-2022 17:21

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36121593)
Usual rubbish spouted by new journo . . well he looks about 20 in his pic.
Anyway, no mention of how Covid (remember that? ) has skewed any financial figures since 2018 . . clickbait article for the gullible, of which there are many :p:

He’s been writing/reporting professionally since 2005…

Chris 08-05-2022 18:37

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36121591)
No one's realistically talking about re-joining the EU in the forseeable future.

But as people's disposable income is squeezed, I'm sure we'll start to read more articles like this one, ironically from the pro-Brexit City AM.

https://www.cityam.com/eu-membership...173m-per-week/

Hmm.

Quote:

Given these figures, the ONS said that the UK Government’s net contribution to the EU – that is, the difference between the money it paid to the EU and the money it received – was £11bn in 2018.
Compare this to the loss in exports to the EU. …
Why? They’re measuring two entirely different things.

One is UK government payments to the EU; the other is (alleged to be) the cost to the entire economy from reduced exports. Apples and pears. Makes a good headline though.

---------- Post added at 17:37 ---------- Previous post was at 17:33 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36121599)
He’s been writing/reporting professionally since 2005…

In which case he ought to know better than to simply regurgitate press releases, which is exactly what has happened here - uncritical parroting of material sent to him by the PR department of an international parcels company. Having been both a journalist and a PR officer, I know exactly how rigorously this has been “researched”.

This is a lazy piece of let’s-get-our-name-in-the-paper PR fluff, picked up by a lazy let’s- sack-this-off-and-get-to-the-pub hack.

Carth 09-05-2022 01:25

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36121609)
<snippety>

In which case he ought to know better than to simply regurgitate press releases, which is exactly what has happened here - uncritical parroting of material sent to him by the PR department of an international parcels company. Having been both a journalist and a PR officer, I know exactly how rigorously this has been “researched”.

This is a lazy piece of let’s-get-our-name-in-the-paper PR fluff, picked up by a lazy let’s- sack-this-off-and-get-to-the-pub hack.

It looks as though I need to work on my phrasing, your descriptive powers certainly put mine to shame :D

Hugh 09-05-2022 13:29

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36121609)
Hmm.



Why? They’re measuring two entirely different things.

One is UK government payments to the EU; the other is (alleged to be) the cost to the entire economy from reduced exports. Apples and pears. Makes a good headline though.

---------- Post added at 17:37 ---------- Previous post was at 17:33 ----------



In which case he ought to know better than to simply regurgitate press releases, which is exactly what has happened here - uncritical parroting of material sent to him by the PR department of an international parcels company. Having been both a journalist and a PR officer, I know exactly how rigorously this has been “researched”.

This is a lazy piece of let’s-get-our-name-in-the-paper PR fluff, picked up by a lazy let’s- sack-this-off-and-get-to-the-pub hack.

Agreed - it was "he looks like a 20 year old" I had disagreement with…

1andrew1 09-05-2022 15:07

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Interesting idea from Macron. To me it makes sense that one size does not fit all, in terms of European co-operation and trade.

Quote:

Emmanuel Macron proposes new, broader European community
Victor Mallet in Paris


French president Emmanuel Macron has proposed a new European community of democracies that would be broader than the EU, and could include non-EU nations such as Ukraine and the post-Brexit UK.

In a speech to the European Parliament in Strasbourg on Monday, Macron said it would take years or even decades for countries such as Ukraine to become EU members, even when they had been accepted as candidates.

“The European Union, given the level of its integration and ambition, cannot be in the short term the only means of structuring the European continent,” he said, recalling that former president François Mitterrand had proposed a European federation that would have included Russia as the Soviet Union collapsed in 1989.

“It’s our historic obligation to respond to that today and to create what I would call a European political community,” Macron said. “This new European organisation would allow European democratic nations adhering to our core values to find a new space for co-operation on politics, security, energy, transport, infrastructure investments and the movement of people, especially the young.”
https://www.ft.com/content/4b4ad184-...a-8e698ab3ec3c

Pierre 09-05-2022 15:47

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36121704)
Interesting idea from Macron. To me it makes sense that one size does not fit all, in terms of European co-operation and trade.


https://www.ft.com/content/4b4ad184-...a-8e698ab3ec3c

You don't want a Marathon? oh, have you tried our new Snickers?

ianch99 09-05-2022 20:23

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36121593)
Usual rubbish spouted by new journo . . well he looks about 20 in his pic.
Anyway, no mention of how Covid (remember that? ) has skewed any financial figures since 2018 . . clickbait article for the gullible, of which there are many :p:

So many indeed. I think gullible is a kind description of those who think Covid is responsible for the crash in EU exports since the beginning of 2020.

Carth 10-05-2022 10:58

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36121777)
So many indeed. I think gullible is a kind description of those who think Covid is responsible for the crash in EU exports since the beginning of 2020.

Who said it was?

Hugh 10-05-2022 13:34

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36121777)
So many indeed. I think gullible is a kind description of those who think Covid is responsible for the crash in EU exports since the beginning of 2020.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36121820)
Who said it was?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36121593)
Usual rubbish spouted by new journo . . well he looks about 20 in his pic.
Anyway, no mention of how Covid (remember that? ) has skewed any financial figures since 2018 . . clickbait article for the gullible, of which there are many :p:


1andrew1 10-05-2022 14:01

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Ouch!

1andrew1 10-05-2022 18:03

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
In the middle of the biggest cost-of-living crisis in most people's lifetime, is this purely political decision really wise when businesses in Northern Ireland are not requesting it?
Quote:

EXC: Liz Truss will move to scrap most of the NI protocol in law next week

While not included in Queen's Speech, legislation unilaterally removing need for Irish Sea checks is written and ready

Ministers have been warned move will spark EU trade war.
https://twitter.com/patrickkmaguire/...06294444441601

Carth 10-05-2022 18:12

Re: Britain outside the EU
 

blah blah . .

Nowhere did I mention "the crash in EU exports since the beginning of 2020."

Just more people putting their own words somewhere because mine didn't fit their argument.

Thankyou :p:

Hugh 10-05-2022 18:16

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

no mention of how Covid (remember that? ) has skewed any financial figures since 2018
Pretty sure that "since 2018" includes "since the beginning of 2020.", as "since 2018" includes 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, and 2022 so far…

Or don’t "financial figures" include EU exports?

Carth 10-05-2022 18:47

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36121885)
Pretty sure that "since 2018" includes "since the beginning of 2020.", as "since 2018" includes 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, and 2022 so far…

Or don’t "financial figures" include EU exports?

Covid had a financial impact in many ways, but certain "young looking" finger on the pulse reporters don't even mention it, instead it must be a Brexit* thing.


*see, nobody mentioned it but I brought it up

1andrew1 10-05-2022 20:41

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
1 Attachment(s)
If Covid only impacted the UK, then this graph might be less concerning.
https://www.cableforum.uk/board/atta...2&d=1652208059

Carth 10-05-2022 21:08

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
sod it, I'm gone

Mick 10-05-2022 23:06

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
"Should the United Kingdom join the EU or stay out of the EU?"

Join 49%
Stay Out 51%

Redfield & Wilton May 3

Damien 10-05-2022 23:30

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
I find that a bit odd. I would have thought that now, once out, there will be quite a few people who voted Remain who don't want to go through the hassle of rejoining.

TheDaddy 10-05-2022 23:32

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 36121928)
"Should the United Kingdom join the EU or stay out of the EU?"

Join 49%
Stay Out 51%

Redfield & Wilton May 3

Think I'm still be a remainer, as in remain outside, what was the point of leaving and enduring the cost and turmoil just to rejoin within no time, just don't expect me to stop moaning about the things that were said to get us out though!

ianch99 11-05-2022 10:28

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
And recent polls the other way:

https://whatukthinks.org/eu/question...uropean-union/

Code:

Join Stay Out
47  40          14 April 2022      Deltapoll
43  38          11 April 2022      YouGov
44  36          11 February 2022  YouGov
42  39          18 January 2022    YouGov
(and so on)


1andrew1 11-05-2022 10:39

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36121931)
Think I'm still be a remainer, as in remain outside, what was the point of leaving and enduring the cost and turmoil just to rejoin within no time, just don't expect me to stop moaning about the things that were said to get us out though!

Although I voted to Remain, I wouldn't vote to re-join tomorrow due to the upheaval as it would be too divisive for the country. I would be keener on a closer relationship though to help our exporters.

Sephiroth 11-05-2022 12:58

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36121950)
Although I voted to Remain, I wouldn't vote to re-join tomorrow due to the upheaval as it would be too divisive for the country. I would be keener on a closer relationship though to help our exporters.

I would prefer our exporters to find additional or alternative markets.

The foolishly signed NI Protocol proves the hold that the EU thinks it has over the UK and we should not be bound further to them.

1andrew1 11-05-2022 13:56

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36121987)
I would prefer our exporters to find additional or alternative markets.

The foolishly signed NI Protocol proves the hold that the EU thinks it has over the UK and we should not be bound further to them.

I suspect the current row is partly due to Truss cuddling up to the Brexiter wing of the Party for when Johnson finally resigns.

TheDaddy 11-05-2022 20:04

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Did Steve Baker really say earlier the oven ready deal he loved at the time of signing was done so under duress

1andrew1 12-05-2022 14:56

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Concerning opinion piece from Adam Posen, president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics and a former member of the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee. Some extracts.

Quote:

Brexit reality bites as stagflation looms

Sometimes, reality bites. The UK outlook for stagflation of rising prices and slowing economic growth this year and next reflects the realities that Brexit has wrought.

Of course, the Covid pandemic, the difficulties of reopening the economy, and now energy and food price surges are not caused by Brexit.

But the UK’s vulnerability to those shocks, and therefore the amplification of their inflation impact, is largely due to Britain’s departure from the EU. This is why the Bank of England will end up having to raise interest rates over the next year more than it forecast this month, and even more than markets have already priced in. Given the very hard Brexit, the Bank of England and the UK economy have been dragged part way back to the 1970s.

By that, the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee is no longer able to look past external economic shocks as they did during the 1992 European Exchange Rate Mechanism exit or 2009 sterling depreciation. In these cases, they had the luxury of setting monetary policy solely in terms of hard domestic forecast data. But after Brexit, the MPC would have to worry more about the “spillover” of international events into inflation expectations.

This is due to a combination of the UK being a smaller economy on its own, less buffered by its integration in the EU, and an erosion of trust in UK governments to run disciplined economic policies. Hence, any shocks are likely to result in higher and more lasting inflation than they did before Brexit...

UK price rises reflect, in part, the idiosyncrasies of Britain’s natural gas and food markets. However, the lack of sourcing supply options for agricultural labour and fuel made those inflationary effects worse and more persistent. Implementing trade barriers and new standards between the UK and the EU single market only compound the problem.
https://www.ft.com/content/34eea151-...9-85bac48d8a4c

Pierre 12-05-2022 15:30

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36122093)
Concerning opinion piece from Adam Posen, president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics and a former member of the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee. Some extracts.


https://www.ft.com/content/34eea151-...9-85bac48d8a4c

That just smacks of a whole lot of opinion, and not much else.

ianch99 12-05-2022 17:41

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36122093)
Concerning opinion piece from Adam Posen, president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics and a former member of the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee. Some extracts.


https://www.ft.com/content/34eea151-...9-85bac48d8a4c

This is really a follow up from his 2017 demolition of the Brexit sunlit uplands: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcIkIz98zXU

Yes, "Gravity" still applies. However, it is just an opinion ;)

1andrew1 20-05-2022 12:39

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
US getting involved now to help resolve Johnson's no-border-in-the-Irish Sea shambles.
Quote:

US delegation arrives in Europe for talks on Northern Ireland and Brexit

Nine-strong team led by close Biden ally will visit Brussels, Dublin and London in significant intervention on division over NI protocol

One of Joe Biden’s closest allies is due to arrive in London on Saturday as part of an influential US congressional delegation seeking to calm tensions over Northern Ireland.

The nine-strong delegation includes Democratic and Republican delegates from the House of Representatives and Senate including members of the powerful ways and means committee chaired by Richard Neal, who will lead the group.

The group was due to land in Brussels early Friday for a series of meetings, including with the European Commission’s vice-president and Brexit commissioner Maroš Šefčovič, to kick off a six-day trip that will also take in Dublin, Kerry and Belfast.

The delegation’s arrival is being seen as a significant intervention by the US, which is acting as co-guarantor of the 1998 Good Friday agreement.

Neal has already made his displeasure known over the government’s plan to draft legislation to remove parts of the Northern Ireland protocol from the Brexit treaty despite warnings it could risk a full trade war with the EU.

But he told the Guardian his mission was to defuse tensions and help broker a UK-EU deal...

After London, the delegation will travel to Dublin to meet the Irish leaders and Belfast to meet Sinn Féin leaders and the DUP leader, Sir Jeffrey Donaldson, whom Neal has met on many occasions.

Their arrival coincides with a warning by Ireland’s deputy prime minister Leo Varadkar that the British position on Brexit was causing such divisions in Northern Ireland it would backfire and “weaken” the union.

“Brexit weakened middle-ground support for the union in Northern Ireland. Unilateral action on the protocol will weaken it even more,” the tanaiste said in an article for the Guardian.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...eland-tensions

Chris 20-05-2022 13:11

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
… and the last thing the republic wants is to be saddled with the tantrum-prone money pit that is Northern Ireland. I can see why Varadkar is worried.

1andrew1 20-05-2022 13:27

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36122977)
… and the last thing the republic wants is to be saddled with the tantrum-prone money pit that is Northern Ireland. I can see why Varadkar is worried.

US getting involved is a bit like your parents getting involved with a fight with your mate. A bit embarrassing for us.

Chris 20-05-2022 13:29

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36122978)
US getting involved is a bit like your parents getting involved with a fight with your mate. A bit embarrassing for us.

No more embarrassing than the US getting involved in the peace process in the first place, or a French Canadian General being asked to verify IRA decommissioning. The US isn’t unilaterally sticking its nose in - it is treaty bound to do so. If you’re embarrassed it’s probably something to do with allowing the Guardian to interpret the world for you. ;)

OLD BOY 20-05-2022 13:48

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36122978)
US getting involved is a bit like your parents getting involved with a fight with your mate. A bit embarrassing for us.

I’m not at all embarrassed, standing up to these ‘great powers’ that are trying to dictate to us and bring us down.

The amendments we are seeking are simply minor adjustments that will make a big difference without undermining the objectives of the protocol. No international laws are under threat.

1andrew1 20-05-2022 16:16

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36122983)
I’m not at all embarrassed, standing up to these ‘great powers’ that are trying to dictate to us and bring us down.

The amendments we are seeking are simply minor adjustments that will make a big difference without undermining the objectives of the protocol. No international laws are under threat.

It's not a great look however you dress it up. There is a mechanism to resolve such issues; Johnson is just pandering to one political party and the whole of the UK is suffering for it. Let's not forget that 60% of the Northern Ireland electorate voted for parties that want to maintain the Northern Ireland Protocol as is and businesses there quite enjoy the benefits of having a foot in the EU market.

When I said the whole of the UK is suffering for it, I am referencing the dispute's very negative impact on the UK's science sector as we are being excluded from the world's biggest research programme.

Quote:

EU blocks UK scientists from €95bn Horizon research programme

Brussels ambassador to London warns row over post-Brexit trade in Northern Ireland is affecting other areas

The EU is blocking British scientists from joining the €95bn Horizon Europe research programme — the world’s biggest — because of the row over post-Brexit trade in Northern Ireland.

The stand-off has alarmed the UK’s university leaders, who have written to British prime minister Boris Johnson pleading with him “to make a personal intervention to break the deadlock” before it is too late. In a letter, seen by the Financial Times, the Russell Group, representing 24 of the UK’s most research-intensive universities, said participation in Horizon was vital in achieving Johnson’s goal of making Britain “a science superpower”. The letter from Tim Bradshaw, chief executive, said Russell Group universities alone had won more than 1,400 European Research Council grants worth €1.8bn, which he said was “more than the whole of France”…

But the Russell Group warned Johnson that the UK being granted associate membership of Horizon was “an integral part” of the country becoming a force in science. It called the programme “the Champions League for research”.’

Separately, Bradshaw wrote to Maroš Šefčovič, EU commissioner in charge of discussions with Britain over the Northern Ireland protocol, to ask him to intervene. “The UK’s full association to Horizon is at risk,” he said.
https://www.ft.com/content/96524f4a-...2-9ae641205e96

Chris 20-05-2022 16:25

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36122999)
It's not a great look however you dress it up. There is a mechanism to resolve such issues; Johnson is just pandering to one political party and the whole of the UK is suffering for it. Let's not forget that 60% of the Northern Ireland electorate voted for parties that want to maintain the Northern Ireland Protocol as is and businesses there quite enjoy the benefits of having a foot in the EU market.

When I said the whole of the UK is suffering for it, I am referencing the dispute's very negative impact on the UK's science sector as we are being excluded from the world's biggest research programme.


https://www.ft.com/content/96524f4a-...2-9ae641205e96

This is the point at which you start sounding like a regime apologist, Andrew.

University research is completely unconnected with the deep sectarian problems that are at the root of the issues HMG has with the NI Protocol. If the EU is making one contingent on the other - or even simply implying a connection - then your uncritical discussion of it is unfortunate to say the least.

jfman 20-05-2022 16:33

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
I’m not sure how sectarianism comes into signing an agreement you’ve no intention of upholding. Unless the Government is once again a victim of circumstance and couldn’t have foreseen what was apparent to everyone else. The inevitability of a nationalist led NI assembly.

Chris 20-05-2022 16:40

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36123004)
I’m not sure how sectarianism comes into signing an agreement you’ve no intention of upholding. Unless the Government is once again a victim of circumstance and couldn’t have foreseen what was apparent to everyone else. The inevitability of a nationalist led NI assembly.

Not sure where you’ve been your entire life but sectarian issues are the entire reason a protocol of some sort was deemed necessary in the first place, owing to the shibboleth of an international frontier on what is, after all, an international frontier between NI and Eire. Everything else that has transpired stems from that root.

jfman 20-05-2022 16:57

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36123007)
Not sure where you’ve been your entire life but sectarian issues are the entire reason a protocol of some sort was deemed necessary in the first place, owing to the shibboleth of an international frontier on what is, after all, an international frontier between NI and Eire. Everything else that has transpired stems from that root.

Given it’s been an issue my entire life it should surely have been foreseeable to the UK Government?

Essentially we have the UK acting as a bad faith actor signing up to a protocol it had no intention of upholding, promising people the magic beans of “technological solutions” only to walk away from the commitments it made to then have the gall to be act completely surprised that others won’t roll over.

1andrew1 20-05-2022 17:45

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36123002)
This is the point at which you start sounding like a regime apologist, Andrew.

University research is completely unconnected with the deep sectarian problems that are at the root of the issues HMG has with the NI Protocol. If the EU is making one contingent on the other - or even simply implying a connection - then your uncritical discussion of it is unfortunate to say the least.

I think you're unrealistic in expecting one body to start going out of its way to sign more agreements with another one, when the last agreement it signed with that body is in danger of not being honoured.

If you have a decorator in who doesn't do what they promised to, you don't normally rush to invite them to decorate another room!

Damien 20-05-2022 19:05

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
For all the talk and bluster on this I still don't understand why the answer isn't one of:
  • Customs border in Ireland
  • Customs border in the Irish Sea
  • Customs Union

We seem to be asking for a version of the third where we're not in a customs union but we say to the EU that really we haven't got different regulatory standards so what's the problem? If we do that then just opt for the full customs union and sort out the problems in Dover as well.

jfman 20-05-2022 19:07

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36123016)
For all the talk and bluster on this I still don't understand why the answer isn't one of:
  • Customs border in Ireland
  • Customs border in the Irish Sea
  • Customs Union

We seem to be asking for a version of the third where we're not in a customs union but we say to the EU that really we haven't got different regulatory standards so what's the problem? If we do that then just opt for the full customs union and sort out the problems in Dover as well.

4: No Northern Ireland.

1andrew1 22-05-2022 10:55

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36123016)
For all the talk and bluster on this I still don't understand why the answer isn't one of:
  • Customs border in Ireland
  • Customs border in the Irish Sea
  • Customs Union

We seem to be asking for a version of the third where we're not in a customs union but we say to the EU that really we haven't got different regulatory standards so what's the problem? If we do that then just opt for the full customs union and sort out the problems in Dover as well.

I think you're right - it's a Customs Union lite whereby we can set our own standards but in practice, won't upset the apple cart by doing so to any significant extent.

1andrew1 22-05-2022 13:15

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
The government's National Audit Office delivers its verdict on how the UK regulators are struggling with their increased workloads.
Quote:

UK regulators face struggle after Brexit as long-term plans may be ‘wasted effort’ watchdog warns

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and Food Standards Agency (FSA) say the loss of data access has negatively affected their ability to assess risks and carry out their work.

The FSA lost access to parts of the Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed (RASFF), which it used to exchange information about food-safety risks and responses across the EU.

Despite the fact the government regularly boasts of its ambition for the UK to be “the best regulated economy in the world”, all three regulators have been forced to turn to international systems using publicly available information and case-by-case arrangements to make up the difference.
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/othe...e3cc9e5fd72b8a
https://www.nao.org.uk/report/regulating-after-eu-exit/

nomadking 22-05-2022 18:09

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
The NI protocol specifies that GB and NI are in the same customs union. Under WTO rules that means no tariffs and restrictions.
The revised NI protocol is "better" than the previous one, in that at least NI has a opportunity to vote on ending it. Before the EU had to agree to it.
So much of the detail was to be left to the Joint Committee, which relies on the EU agreeing to things. That is the real problem.
The only reason for any protocol in the first place is because the IRA says so. Would the US be happy with a situation where there were tariffs and restrictions between Hawaii and California, or Texas and New York?

Chris 22-05-2022 18:24

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36123170)
The government's National Audit Office delivers its verdict on how the UK regulators are struggling with their increased workloads.

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/othe...e3cc9e5fd72b8a
https://www.nao.org.uk/report/regulating-after-eu-exit/

The more I learn about the hidden dependencies inherent in EU membership the more glad I am we’re out.

There is nothing here that can’t be solved via the development of processes that - astonishingly - work well enough for the other 165 countries of the world. So much of the hand-wringing nonsense we read on here really is afflicted by a weird sort of reverse exceptionalism in which the UK is somehow uniquely incapable of coping with its status as a non-member of the EU, despite this being the normal state of affairs for the vast majority of the planet.

Mick 23-05-2022 20:02

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
BREAKING: UK to Start Legislating Against Brexit Deal Within Three Weeks

Quote:

The UK aims to introduce its controversial bill to override parts of the Brexit deal it negotiated with the European Union within the next three weeks, Northern Ireland Secretary Brandon Lewis has signaled.

Parliament is not sitting next week and officials in charge of legislation are eyeing the fortnight following June 6. There is then a six-week window for the bill to pass the lower House of Commons before Parliament breaks for its summer vacation, planned for July 20.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...uthor_15116245

jfman 23-05-2022 20:49

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
It’s almost like there’s an uncomfortable story we need to displace from the front page of the Mail and Express tomorrow.

ianch99 24-05-2022 09:44

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
"Get Inflation Done" :) A clear & present Brexit bonus:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FTHYn_LX...png&name=small

Core Inflation: definition

Sephiroth 24-05-2022 10:09

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
What’s your point, Ian? I imagine that you’re indicating that the UK would be “better off” inside the EU.

That conveniently omits the fact that we are no longer under Brussels’ thumb. With a competent government (and Labour would not be that), all the economic stuff can be put right. But will it? Still no reason to be in the EU.

1andrew1 24-05-2022 10:24

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36123352)
What’s your point, Ian? I imagine that you’re indicating that the UK would be “better off” inside the EU.

That conveniently omits the fact that we are no longer under Brussels’ thumb. With a competent government (and Labour would not be that), all the economic stuff can be put right. But will it? Still no reason to be in the EU.

I think you're in danger of heading into Kim Jong-un reality levels if you think that only one party can form a competent government.

ianch99 24-05-2022 10:27

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36123352)
What’s your point, Ian? I imagine that you’re indicating that the UK would be “better off” inside the EU.

That conveniently omits the fact that we are no longer under Brussels’ thumb. With a competent government (and Labour would not be that), all the economic stuff can be put right. But will it? Still no reason to be in the EU.

I am surprised I have to spell it out: we were told over & over again that we would be financially better off out of the EU when all the evidence said otherwise. It is important that the liars are held to account.

It is delusion that "all the economic stuff can be put right", at least in the next decade. Economic gravity + hard Brexit says otherwise. These are the hard facts and always have been. Ideology won over Economics and Ideology won't keep you warm at night or feed your children.

papa smurf 24-05-2022 10:36

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36123354)
I am surprised I have to spell it out: we were told over & over again that we would be financially better off out of the EU when all the evidence said otherwise. It is important that the liars are held to account.

It is delusion that "all the economic stuff can be put right", at least in the next decade. Economic gravity + hard Brexit says otherwise. These are the hard facts and always have been. Ideology won over Economics and Ideology won't keep you warm at night or feed your children.

How are you finding it over there in EU land, do you regret leaving the UK? are you having a better life over there?

Sephiroth 24-05-2022 11:33

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36123353)
I think you're in danger of heading into Kim Jong-un reality levels if you think that only one party can form a competent government.

Kim Jong-Un is taking it a bit too far, Andrew. I never said that any one party could govern well. But the Conservatives could judging by Thatcher. Just needs the right leader.


---------- Post added at 10:33 ---------- Previous post was at 10:30 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36123354)
I am surprised I have to spell it out: we were told over & over again that we would be financially better off out of the EU when all the evidence said otherwise. It is important that the liars are held to account.

It is delusion that "all the economic stuff can be put right", at least in the next decade. Economic gravity + hard Brexit says otherwise. These are the hard facts and always have been. Ideology won over Economics and Ideology won't keep you warm at night or feed your children.

Beg to differ, Ian. Btw, in my book sovereignty trumps ideology and in a country like the UK, business will set the economy right. A bungling government, however, fuels your argument.


1andrew1 24-05-2022 12:06

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36123363)
Kim Jong-Un is taking it a bit too far, Andrew. I never said that any one party could govern well. But the Conservatives could judging by Thatcher. Just needs the right leader.

All three main parties have formed competent governments in the past. No reason why this can't happen in the future.

Sephiroth 24-05-2022 12:11

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36123369)
All three main parties have formed competent governments in the past. No reason why this can't happen in the future.

Agreed so long as it’s not Labour! I did aaprove of the recent coalition.

1andrew1 24-05-2022 13:30

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Cranswick, one of the UK’s largest pork producers, has called for government action to save the pig industry after feed price rises added to labour shortages to place farmers under “unsustainable strain”.

A jump in cereal prices of more than 50 per cent after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine pushed up the price of feed, which accounts for most of the cost of raising a pig. This had added to problems in the sector caused by post-Brexit shortages of skilled butchers, said Cranswick.
https://www.ft.com/content/dd73ad4f-...3-ace218a5157f

Sephiroth 24-05-2022 14:39

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
These little digs keep on coming. Corollary to the foregoing is that we shouldn’t have left the EU because of the shortage of butchers and the like.

Btw, there is no shortage of plumbers in my area.

BenMcr 24-05-2022 14:46

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36123392)
Corollary to the foregoing is that we shouldn’t have left the EU because of the shortage of butchers and the like.

Or maybe, if you know you're going to leave the EU, you make sure you can continue to get the workforce required before you do, or put plans in place to train more people up where expected shortages will happen.

Sephiroth 24-05-2022 17:22

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36123393)
Or maybe, if you know you're going to leave the EU, you make sure you can continue to get the workforce required before you do, or put plans in place to train more people up where expected shortages will happen.

Pie in the sky given the divorce process.

TheDaddy 24-05-2022 17:33

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36123416)
Pie in the sky given the divorce process.

Meh, it's what we wanted

Mad Max 24-05-2022 19:42

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36123417)
Meh, it's what we wanted

What, pie? :D

pip08456 24-05-2022 22:25

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36123392)
These little digs keep on coming. Corollary to the foregoing is that we shouldn’t have left the EU because of the shortage of butchers and the like.

Btw, there is no shortage of plumbers in my area.

From experience firstly with my then gilrlfriend's father.

He was a small(ish) pig breeder and when they were farrowing used to be up 24/7, I used to spell him occaisionally when I was there but he insisted no longer than an hour, that enabled him to get at least a little shuteye. . That was UK law at the time, check daily on the animals you are breeding to ensure their health and safety (not the eact wording), he had no problem with that, the more piglets that survived, the more profit he made.(for British bacon production.)

Other than the 7-14 days they were expected to farrow (give birth) they were free range, most were in and out in less than 10 days. There was a very good reason for it. But that's a different story.

At the time I was being trained to be a qualified slaughterman (as well as a master butcher with a family firm). I worked 7 days a week to get my certificate as a slaughterman and more time to become a master butcher.

Now a question for you. Why is my exgirlfriend's Father no longer breeding pigs and why I am no longer recognised as a "Master Butcher". I know some Supermarket chains claim to have one but that is BS I could bury everyone of them after all these years and all because of the EEC morphing from an economic Union into a political one.

I bet you've never heard of British Bacon because you've only ever seen Danish.

Rant over.

ianch99 06-06-2022 19:38

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
It is not often you can actually see the race to the bottom:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FUT1USDX...png&name=small

Sephiroth 06-06-2022 19:58

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 36123476)
From experience firstly with my then gilrlfriend's father.

He was a small(ish) pig breeder and when they were farrowing used to be up 24/7, I used to spell him occaisionally when I was there but he insisted no longer than an hour, that enabled him to get at least a little shuteye. . That was UK law at the time, check daily on the animals you are breeding to ensure their health and safety (not the eact wording), he had no problem with that, the more piglets that survived, the more profit he made.(for British bacon production.)

Other than the 7-14 days they were expected to farrow (give birth) they were free range, most were in and out in less than 10 days. There was a very good reason for it. But that's a different story.

At the time I was being trained to be a qualified slaughterman (as well as a master butcher with a family firm). I worked 7 days a week to get my certificate as a slaughterman and more time to become a master butcher.

Now a question for you. Why is my exgirlfriend's Father no longer breeding pigs and why I am no longer recognised as a "Master Butcher". I know some Supermarket chains claim to have one but that is BS I could bury everyone of them after all these years and all because of the EEC morphing from an economic Union into a political one.

I bet you've never heard of British Bacon because you've only ever seen Danish.

Rant over.


Never eaten Danish bacon in the UK. Only ate Danish bacon in Poland.

OLD BOY 06-06-2022 20:06

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36123353)
I think you're in danger of heading into Kim Jong-un reality levels if you think that only one party can form a competent government.

The Conservatives did under Maggie Thatcher. Labour was in a hopeless mess and MT got us out of the one that Labour left her.

jfman 07-06-2022 00:25

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36124566)
The Conservatives did under Maggie Thatcher. Labour was in a hopeless mess and MT got us out of the one that Labour left her.

:D:D:D

Itshim 07-06-2022 18:50

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 36123476)
From experience firstly with my then gilrlfriend's father.

He was a small(ish) pig breeder and when they were farrowing used to be up 24/7, I used to spell him occaisionally when I was there but he insisted no longer than an hour, that enabled him to get at least a little shuteye. . That was UK law at the time, check daily on the animals you are breeding to ensure their health and safety (not the eact wording), he had no problem with that, the more piglets that survived, the more profit he made.(for British bacon production.)

Other than the 7-14 days they were expected to farrow (give birth) they were free range, most were in and out in less than 10 days. There was a very good reason for it. But that's a different story.

At the time I was being trained to be a qualified slaughterman (as well as a master butcher with a family firm). I worked 7 days a week to get my certificate as a slaughterman and more time to become a master butcher.

Now a question for you. Why is my exgirlfriend's Father no longer breeding pigs and why I am no longer recognised as a "Master Butcher". I know some Supermarket chains claim to have one but that is BS I could bury everyone of them after all these years and all because of the EEC morphing from an economic Union into a political one.

I bet you've never heard of British Bacon because you've only ever seen Danish.

Rant over.

Try Aldi you'll find it there. In fact the pork joints were also British which more then you can say for Asda ,last time l looked there's were German :erm:

BenMcr 08-06-2022 00:16

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 36123476)
I bet you've never heard of British Bacon because you've only ever seen Danish

Most of this seems pretty British to me

https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/SearchResults/bacon

Sephiroth 08-06-2022 08:11

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 36124694)
Most of this seems pretty British to me

https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/SearchResults/bacon


Seems like Waitrose are fully British on Bacon.

https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/b...con_and_gammon


papa smurf 08-06-2022 08:17

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36124700)

Seems like Waitrose are fully British on Bacon.

https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/b...con_and_gammon


i seem to recall pig welfare issues with danish pigs that put the British public off Danish bacon.

BenMcr 08-06-2022 10:07

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 36123476)
I bet you've never heard of British Bacon because you've only ever seen Danish.

Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36124701)
i seem to recall pig welfare issues with danish pigs that put the British public off Danish bacon.

These two statements then contradict each other a bit then.

When the Co-op switched they specifically said it was to support British farmers, there is nothing to say it was down to any quality concerns

http://www.npa-uk.org.uk/NPA_welcome...ish_bacon.html

Quote:

Jo Whitfield, Co-op retail chief executive, said: “British consumers will be shocked to see how meat imports have grown while at the same time retailers hang out the bunting and claim to back British farmers.

"Only the Co-op offers 100% British fresh meat all year round and not just in the meat cabinet but also in our sandwiches, our pies and our ready meals.


---------- Post added at 09:07 ---------- Previous post was at 09:03 ----------

Unfortunately more recently it's been going in the opposite direction for some

https://www.thegrocer.co.uk/sourcing...667711.article

Quote:

However, some individual retailers appear to have more work to do, with Asda showing a fall from 44% to 36% for its bacon, while the percentage of British ham it sold fell from 40% to 26%. Iceland’s British bacon facings fell from 11% of its offering in March 2021 to zero in March 2022, while Lidl also saw a big drop in British bacon availability, from 47% to 29%.

ianch99 08-06-2022 12:05

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36124700)

Seems like Waitrose are fully British on Bacon.

https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/b...con_and_gammon


I understand the gammon part but bacon still comes in from the EU, right?

tweetiepooh 08-06-2022 12:47

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
I try to buy meat from the farmer's market which we used to have the biggest in the UK. But since the council resited it it's been dwindling and cost/effort have meant most meat sellers have now dropped out either just from the market but I know one who is no longer doing retail at all.
It's a shame as quality is usually much better than the major retailers and you can get cuts that the big boys are interested in. Plus you are supporting the producers directly. And I've found prices are often better than the supermarkets for equivalent quality.


(And they do sell bacon - nice dry cured, smoked bacon.)

Dave42 08-06-2022 15:34

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Breaking news: Economic growth in the UK will grind to a halt next year with only Russia, hobbled by western sanctions, performing worse among the G20 leading economies, the OECD forecast on Wednesday

https://twitter.com/FinancialTimes/s...65573920333824

ianch99 08-06-2022 16:15

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave42 (Post 36124728)
Breaking news: Economic growth in the UK will grind to a halt next year with only Russia, hobbled by western sanctions, performing worse among the G20 leading economies, the OECD forecast on Wednesday

https://twitter.com/FinancialTimes/s...65573920333824

Yes, proceeding as planned and as forecast. Who knew? ;)

jonbxx 08-06-2022 16:43

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Bacon is one of the fun 'rules of origin' cases where British bacon might not be what it seems. The pork used to make bacon can come from anywhere. Once it is cured, the country of curing is the origin so 'British' bacon might not be made from British pigs.

There has recently been a wave of Swine Fever in Europe so there was a glut of pork on the market as farmers slaughtered their herds before they got infected and respective governments did it for them. If you bacon doesn't specifically say the pork came from British farms, the meat could have come from anywhere..

1andrew1 08-06-2022 16:59

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36124730)
Yes, proceeding as planned and as forecast. Who knew? ;)

Yeah, but I keep on getting told that Johnson got the major calls right. :confused:

nomadking 08-06-2022 19:06

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Comparing growth like that is misleading.That is why it is used.:rolleyes:
We've already had previous growth and the others are catching up to a similar overall level.
Link
Quote:

It means the UK will go from the second-fastest growing economy in the G7 group of industrial nations to the slowest growing in 2023.
What would be the situation if you compared prior to that point to one next year?
EG If X has an increase of 2% first year and 1% the next, and Y has an increase of 1% first year and 2% the next, they are comparable overall. Yet Y has a larger increase in the 2nd year, when looked at in isolation.

1andrew1 08-06-2022 19:21

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36124736)
Comparing growth like that is misleading.That is why it is used.:rolleyes:
We've already had previous growth and the others are catching up to a similar overall level.
Link
What would be the situation if you compared prior to that point to one next year?
EG If X has an increase of 2% first year and 1% the next, and Y has an increase of 1% first year and 2% the next, they are comparable overall. Yet Y has a larger increase in the 2nd year, when looked at in isolation.

Not sure that playing the OECD victim card works. They don't have it in for the UK.

nomadking 08-06-2022 19:41

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36124737)
Not sure that playing the OECD victim card works. They don't have it in for the UK.

So my theoretical example isn't valid?:rolleyes: What's the betting, if the earlier UK figure had been low, but the later one was high, the media would be making the same point as me? It's easy to have high growth, if you're starting from a lower start point.

1andrew1 08-06-2022 22:37

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36124738)
So my theoretical example isn't valid?:rolleyes: What's the betting, if the earlier UK figure had been low, but the later one was high, the media would be making the same point as me? It's easy to have high growth, if you're starting from a lower start point.

I didn't give it any attention but happy to if you insist.

I don't want to be too harsh but it's hard to sugarcoat this one. Without real life data which exists, it's just a fantasy post.

nomadking 08-06-2022 22:54

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36124746)
I didn't give it any attention but happy to if you insist.

I don't want to be too harsh but it's hard to sugarcoat this one. Without real life data which exists, it's just a fantasy post.

Are you saying that my theoretical example doesn't have a real life equivalent? Ridiculously unlikely in the extreme.
As I pointed out, the UK was 2nd in the G7 at one point. That means 5 other countries were lower. If any of them are now higher, that would be a real life example of my point.

Link

Quote:

For 2021 as a whole, UK GDP growth was 7.4%. This was the highest in the G7. The UK had the largest decline in GDP among the G7 in 2020 (-9.3%) and its relatively strong performance in 2021 was to some degree a recovery from weakness in 2020.
Please note that headline GDP growth figures across countries are not 100% comparable. For example, the UK takes a different approach to others in calculating output in the education and health sectors. This has resulted in the UK’s GDP growth figures being lower in 2020, and higher in 2021 (as this effect unwinds), compared with other G7 economies than they otherwise would have been.

1andrew1 08-06-2022 23:40

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
A sensible comparison would be a graph of the G7 GDP per country from Feb 2020 to Feb 2022.
Predictions for 2023 are obviously just that and I hope they are wrong for the UK. But labour shortages are causing inflation and we are also less self-sufficient in energy than many of our peers so the predictions have a robust basis.

TheDaddy 09-06-2022 10:36

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave42 (Post 36124728)
Breaking news: Economic growth in the UK will grind to a halt next year with only Russia, hobbled by western sanctions, performing worse among the G20 leading economies, the OECD forecast on Wednesday

https://twitter.com/FinancialTimes/s...65573920333824

Two areas of UK are predicted to grow, London and N Ireland...

1andrew1 09-06-2022 11:05

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36124767)
Two areas of UK are predicted to grow, London and N Ireland...

Brexit making levelling up even harder as the gap between London and most of the country widens.

TheDaddy 09-06-2022 11:19

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36124768)
Brexit making levelling up even harder as the gap between London and most of the country widens.

Funny, I focused more on N Ireland being the other growth area, London is a given but why is N Ireland growing, could it be because it's in the single market...

jfman 09-06-2022 15:04

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Boris warning higher wages mean higher inflation.

So the high skill, high wage economy was another lie?

Jaymoss 09-06-2022 15:21

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36124785)
Boris warning higher wages mean higher inflation.

So the high skill, high wage economy was another lie?

Be surprised when they tell the truth not when they lie, that is the way to deal with all politicians

TheDaddy 09-06-2022 15:43

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36124785)
Boris warning higher wages mean higher inflation.

So the high skill, high wage economy was another lie?

How much skill does it take to mop a floor or push a letter through a post box, you can't pay high wages to everyone and those jobs still need doing

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36124786)
Be surprised when they tell the truth not when they lie, that is the way to deal with all politicians

And letting them get away with it via cop outs such as this is why we're in this mess, besides which even if you accept politicians lie you wouldn't expect every single thing they said would be questionable like it is with bozo


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 17:12.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum