Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Internet Tax To Fund The BBC! (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33714025)

Jaymoss 26-09-2026 06:27

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
We are in the middle of a cost of living crisis with souring energy bills predicted to rise 25% in January and fuel prices being what they are . Any governement taking serious the increase of a charge for something like the BBC will create uproar. I just do not see it happening

peanut 26-09-2026 07:48

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222967)
We are in the middle of a cost of living crisis with souring energy bills predicted to rise 25% in January and fuel prices being what they are . Any governement taking serious the increase of a charge for something like the BBC will create uproar. I just do not see it happening

I totally get that. But the objection to this is going to be from those that do not pay for their TV licence. Saying you don't watch BBC is a bit contentious at best, or saying don't have a TV (pushing it). If it's cheaper than the licence fee now then there'll be a lot that will agree to it.

But then there's that choice in paying for it than being forced to pay for it is the main point. But I don't know what the internet and a broadband 'tax' has anything to do with the BBC. So basically using this tax as an excuse and nothing more to make people pay it. That is something I don't agree with.

At least this way there's be no more needs to have vans to parked up outside your house with their radars to see if you're watch the BBC, lol.

Jaymoss 26-09-2026 08:05

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Radical idea why not let the public vote on it after all they are civil servants and should be serving those who voted them in . A group of rich out of touch elite making decisions for us without even consulting us

Simple vote do you want to keep the BBC as is or not. Lets me honest the BBC has lost a lot of faith over the last 20 years and the age of unquestioned propaganda is long since gone .

Mr K 26-09-2026 09:51

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222969)
Radical idea why not let the public vote on it after all they are civil servants and should be serving those who voted them in . A group of rich out of touch elite making decisions for us without even consulting us

Simple vote do you want to keep the BBC as is or not. Lets me honest the BBC has lost a lot of faith over the last 20 years and the age of unquestioned propaganda is long since gone .

Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

Jaymoss 26-09-2026 10:05

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222973)
Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

bit different running a country to running a television and radio broadcaster

Paul 26-09-2026 10:10

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222973)
Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

I think that would apply to VAT as well, or any kind of tax.

papa smurf 26-09-2026 10:55

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36222973)
Give them a vote on income tax too. Guess which way they'd vote?

do labour voters pay income tax on their benefits, i thought it was the right wingers who worked and paid tax so labour voters didn't have to

Carth 26-09-2026 13:15

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222980)
do labour voters pay income tax on their benefits, i thought it was the right wingers who worked and paid tax so labour voters didn't have to

I've no idea Papa, just be careful you don't mention pensioners in case everyone goes into meltdown ;)

papa smurf 26-09-2026 13:30

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36222984)
I've no idea Papa, just be careful you don't mention pensioners in case everyone goes into meltdown ;)

mr k has triple lock envy so i won't mention the rise in pension

Hugh 26-09-2026 13:37

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222980)
do labour voters pay income tax on their benefits, i thought it was the right wingers who worked and paid tax so labour voters didn't have to

Like many of your "thoughts", it is not congruent with actuality… ;)

papa smurf 26-09-2026 13:39

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36222987)
Like many of your "thoughts", it is not congruent with actuality… ;)

you'll be trying to tell us you know a labour voter with a job next

Sirius 26-09-2026 15:41

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36222988)
you'll be trying to tell us you know a labour voter with a job next


:LOL::LOL:

Chris 26-09-2026 18:13

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36222969)
Radical idea why not let the public vote on it after all they are civil servants and should be serving those who voted them in . A group of rich out of touch elite making decisions for us without even consulting us

Simple vote do you want to keep the BBC as is or not. Lets me honest the BBC has lost a lot of faith over the last 20 years and the age of unquestioned propaganda is long since gone .

The BBC is very much the author of its own misfortune. The endless corporate reads over closing credits, thanking people for paying their TVL, and the seemingly endless variants of that annoying Romesh advert they keep playing, is some indication of how deep in the doo-doo they know they are. Cancelling Ru Paul’s Womanface Minstrel Show is perhaps a small but interesting insight into how they might be starting to realise that their cultural obsessions have been turning people off.

Funding the BBC out of general taxation has long been considered a no-no because it puts the BBC much more directly at the mercy of government which isn’t a good look for a broadcaster that’s supposed to be impartial. The present system allows the BBC to manage collection itself (even though the licence fee money still passes through the government’s general fund on its way to broadcasting house).

A service tax, even a hypothecated one, makes the management and collection of the money an HMRC matter which the BBC might be uncomfortable with. But then again, they’re losing money hand over fist right now, and they’re clearly getting desperate, so who knows what might happen.

Itshim 26-09-2026 19:39

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Really wonder how many presenters they need on a show ie morning live , 6 + . Another bug is at least on BBC Wales one weather forecast followed be another one . Even question why you need someone else to tell you what it is. Also noticed that local channel reports on something ie plane crash on Anglesey.and nation channel then reports the same thing with a different presenter .

damien c 28-09-2026 08:43

Re: Internet Tax To Fund The BBC!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 36222968)
I totally get that. But the objection to this is going to be from those that do not pay for their TV licence. Saying you don't watch BBC is a bit contentious at best, or saying don't have a TV (pushing it). If it's cheaper than the licence fee now then there'll be a lot that will agree to it.

But then there's that choice in paying for it than being forced to pay for it is the main point. But I don't know what the internet and a broadband 'tax' has anything to do with the BBC. So basically using this tax as an excuse and nothing more to make people pay it. That is something I don't agree with.

At least this way there's be no more needs to have vans to parked up outside your house with their radars to see if you're watch the BBC, lol.

The "TV TAX" should be for BBC programmes only, and if you don't watch them you should not pay it.

I have never once had anyone answer the question as to why the BBC need to be paid for me watching something that they have had zero involvement in?

That would be like me saying, "you have food in your house, as such you need to pay £200 a year to eat that food, doesn't matter where it came from, who produced it etc, you owe me £200 because you have it", now you might say that is ridiculous but that is exactly what the TV Tax is currently and will be when the clowns allow this "Internet Tax" to be used instead of a "TV Tax".

As it is Burnham has already basically said that by the next election he will be raising taxes even more, so the people in the country already struggling because cost's are increasing because of this clueless clown show of a government, are going to be struggling even more so, because Burnham is going to increase taxes so he can give more money to the people who shouldn't be getting more money!

I think it would be stupid of Labour to do this, but they have done much stupider things so we will just have to wait and see, but it will be interesting to see how many times you have to pay for it, because they may try to add it to each connection which for this house that would £88 a month!

Let's see someone justify £11 per device!


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:33.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum