Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33711123)

Chris 22-06-2022 10:48

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36125944)
Don't agree with his politics but I've found Mick Lynch a fantastic performer in the interviews I've seen.

He's unflustered, doesn't rise to baiting, doesn't get angry, seems to knows his facts and makes interviewers appear out of their depth by just doing the interviews very well.

Even Arthur Scargill was capable of giving a measured, thoughtful performance under forensic TV interview. Here’s a good example from 1984, worth watching in full (albeit difficult to follow given the technicalities of coal mining in Britain are no longer part of everyday discourse :D )

Nevertheless, put him on a picket line and he would scream and shout like the Trot he was (presumably still is).

Scargill was at least explicit about his desire to bring down a democratically elected government. Mick Lynch just seems content to do his bit to kick Boris while he’s down, and while it’s hard not to be sympathetic with that aim, the fact is it’s not his job to play politics or hold the country to ransom.

Incidentally, if you think resurrecting Scargill and the miners’ strike is a bit OTT, you should listen to the opening interviews on yesterday’s WatO on BBC R4. Their academic talking head managed to drop ‘Thatcherism’ and ‘Scargill’ into the debate within his first 30 seconds.

papa smurf 22-06-2022 11:05

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
talking of Scargill

he's on the picket line aged 84

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...Y-reports.html

Mick 22-06-2022 11:13

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36125948)
Even Arthur Scargill was capable of giving a measured, thoughtful performance under forensic TV interview. Here’s a good example from 1984, worth watching in full (albeit difficult to follow given the technicalities of coal mining in Britain are no longer part of everyday discourse :D )

Nevertheless, put him on a picket line and he would scream and shout like the Trot he was (presumably still is).

Scargill was at least explicit about his desire to bring down a democratically elected government. Mick Lynch just seems content to do his bit to kick Boris while he’s down, and while it’s hard not to be sympathetic with that aim, the fact is it’s not his job to play politics or hold the country to ransom.

Incidentally, if you think resurrecting Scargill and the miners’ strike is a bit OTT, you should listen to the opening interviews on yesterday’s WatO on BBC R4. Their academic talking head managed to drop ‘Thatcherism’ and ‘Scargill’ into the debate within his first 30 seconds.

Scargill was pictured on the picket lines yesterday, I do believe. Will have to dig for the pic…

---------- Post added at 11:06 ---------- Previous post was at 11:05 ----------

Here: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/u...-b2106228.html

---------- Post added at 11:13 ---------- Previous post was at 11:06 ----------

Beaten to it by papa don’t preach. :D

nomadking 22-06-2022 11:28

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy (Post 36125896)
Everybody in the public sector and transport stepped up during the pandemic. They all deserve to be treated with respect when seeking to ensure that they can pay their way after the huge increases across the board for food,fuel and other daily expenses that the entire country is currently facing. Everyone who did what was asked of them during the past 2 years deserve that consideration irrespective of what industry they work for.

So there were no food supplies etc? A whole bunch of people still worked.
If the costs go up, then inflation goes up, which in turn leads to wages going up. If the recent cost increases are allowed to drift out of the inflation figures(after a year), then the economy will be better than having an inflationary spiral. Even the Unions knew that in the late 1970s.
Have the £150 council tax rebate and the £400 energy bill rebate been taken into account with wage demands? Are the media reporting that?

mrmistoffelees 22-06-2022 11:37

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36125942)
His salary is £89,962, with Employers' NI contributions of £11,590 and pension contributions of £23,334....

Never understood why the right wing tabloids include Employers' NI Contribution - the employee doesn't benefit from these...

is the £89k before or after the pension contributions ? I'll bet they're salary sacrifice.......

Hom3r 22-06-2022 11:52

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmistoffelees (Post 36125957)
Is the £89k before or after the pension contributions ? I'll bet they're salary sacrifice.......


IIRC pensions are deducted before tax then you get taxed, my last job did this.

mrmistoffelees 22-06-2022 12:54

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 36125960)
IIRC pensions are deducted before tax then you get taxed, my last job did this.


Can be both, mine are salary sacrificed but there's an option available for you not to do that (but why would you)

IF the employer is matching his % contributions that's a hefty pension pot.....

jfman 22-06-2022 13:01

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36125948)
play politics

If the working conditions of the members of trade union in either publicly owned, or heavily subsidised, industries aren’t political what is?

If the Government want a high skilled, high wage economy why is the intention for public sector workers to be exempt from enjoying the benefits?

nomadking 22-06-2022 13:16

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36125967)
If the working conditions of the members of trade union in either publicly owned, or heavily subsidised, industries aren’t political what is?

If the Government want a high skilled, high wage economy why is the intention for public sector workers to be exempt from enjoying the benefits?

How would an inflationary spiral help anyone?:rolleyes:

Have they suddenly become more highly skilled? Have they suddenly become more productive?

mrmistoffelees 22-06-2022 13:21

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36125968)
How would an inflationary spiral help anyone?:rolleyes:

Have they suddenly become more highly skilled? Have they suddenly become more productive?

Are you a people manager ?

jfman 22-06-2022 13:25

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36125968)
How would an inflationary spiral help anyone?:rolleyes:

It wouldn’t, but why should preventing it fall disproportionately on some workers?

Quote:

Have they suddenly become more highly skilled? Have they suddenly become more productive?
That’s irrelevant. The entirely mythical Tory high wage, high skilled economy drives up wages for all workers due to the reduced supply of “unskilled” workers creating competitive pressure (dare I even say inflationary pressure) for employers.

nomadking 22-06-2022 13:57

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36125970)
It wouldn’t, but why should preventing it fall disproportionately on some workers?



That’s irrelevant. The entirely mythical Tory high wage, high skilled economy drives up wages for all workers due to the reduced supply of “unskilled” workers creating competitive pressure (dare I even say inflationary pressure) for employers.

The claim was for creating NEW "high wage, high skilled" types of jobs, NOT existing ones.

How is it falling disproportionately on them?
If it's a "mythical Tory" thing, why isn't it also a mythical Labour, Lib Dem, or SNP thing?:confused:

jfman 22-06-2022 14:37

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36125980)
The claim was for creating NEW "high wage, high skilled" types of jobs, NOT existing ones.

A two tier economy then, high profits offshored while everyone left has meagre pay rises eroded by eye watering levels of inflation. Gotcha.

Quote:

How is it falling disproportionately on them?
If it's a "mythical Tory" thing, why isn't it also a mythical Labour, Lib Dem, or SNP thing?:confused:
Everything is mythical in the Lib Dem manifesto. I’m not sure you’re point it’s the Government’s job to govern and deliver on it’s commitments. It’s just really hard to see how they plan to achieve it as they drive down real terms wages and living standards by the fastest amount in decades.

Chris 22-06-2022 16:15

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 36125967)
If the working conditions of the members of trade union in either publicly owned, or heavily subsidised, industries aren’t political what is?

If the Government want a high skilled, high wage economy why is the intention for public sector workers to be exempt from enjoying the benefits?

I addressed the railways management structure and political oversight in an earlier post. In brief, Network Rail and its regulator are designed to keep politicians at arms length, with input only at the strategic planning level. No cabinet minister has a place at the pay bargaining table and Mick Lynch is just trying to rock it like the 1970s by pretending otherwise. Network Rail is not British Rail.

ianch99 22-06-2022 16:22

Re: RMT announce Rail strikes are on for this week
 
It is clear now that this whole strike story is actively welcomed by the Government. Imagine deliberately encouraging pain & disruption for partisan political purposes.

The Transport Secretary has refused to get involved in the discussions leading up to this strike. I would argue he has a duty of obligation to do so and to actively pursue a route of mediation.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 13:48.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum