Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Sport (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=88)
-   -   The anyone but England thread! (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=47882)

TheBlueRaja 17-06-2006 01:12

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
Denial you are in...

Glasgow actually.

Oh and i didnt mention the China / India thing as it was a pointless statement, China and India does not have football as a national sport.

Its a bit like saying India should be good at snowboarding because they have so many people.

Mal 17-06-2006 01:12

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
Denial you are in...

Glasgow actually.

Boom! Boom!

pedantic 17-06-2006 01:47

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
It's interesting how the scottish whine about 1966, and yet TBR has mentioned 1967 enough times in this thread. Double standards eh. ;)

Flobajob 17-06-2006 09:54

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I never insinuated you did say that, i simply pointed out that your bloody media do and continue to ram it down our throats even during games which have bugger all to do with England, I really dont want to know every time Sven has a dump.

So now it's "OUR" media, and you have a problem with them going overboard about "OUR" team ...

Mal 17-06-2006 12:38

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
Denial you are in...

Glasgow actually.

Oh and i didnt mention the China / India thing as it was a pointless statement, China and India does not have football as a national sport.

Its a bit like saying India should be good at snowboarding because they have so many people.

Not really pointless is it though? If it is pointless, it makes your point, useless then. Saying about it is not their national sport is just a weazel out isn't it? What about the USA? Out of the teams at the world cup, they probably have the largest population, yet don't have a chance.

danielf 17-06-2006 12:51

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
<snip> What about the USA? Out of the teams at the world cup, they probably have the largest population, yet don't have a chance.

Great, isn't it? :p:

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 12:55

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flobajob
So now it's "OUR" media, and you have a problem with them going overboard about "OUR" team ...

Don't be fooled, if it were simply a case of media hype they would buy the Scottsman or Daily Record.

ikthius 17-06-2006 13:42

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
slightly off football, I like how it is england and scotland for football, but britain for athletics, cause the english need the scots to do well.
:angel: :D :erm:

ik

EDIT: I am a bit peeved off when I hear about england all the time, after all they are not the only team in teh world cup.

I just hate it getting thrown down my throat and listening to the commentry mention england in every and I mean every game. Why do we need that?

and what amazes me is that they always say who they are going to meet int teh quarter finals and semis and if not finals, they have not got there yet, they probably will not either, god I hope not :angel:

ik

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 13:46

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ikthius
slightly off football, I like how it is england and scotland for football, but britain for athletics, cause the english need the scots to do well.
:angel: :D :erm:

ik

I take it you don't watch the Commonwealth games England 54 gold medals, Scotland and Wales 6 each :D :p:

TheBlueRaja 17-06-2006 13:47

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pedantic
It's interesting how the scottish whine about 1966, and yet TBR has mentioned 1967 enough times in this thread. Double standards eh. ;)

I've mentioned 1967 twice in response to allegations of Scotland being poor.

If thats double standards compared to the English media banging on about 1966 almost daily since 1966 then there's something wrong.

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 13:50

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I've mentioned 1967 twice in response to allegations of Scotland being poor.

If thats double standards compared to the English media banging on about 1966 almost daily since 1966 then there's something wrong.

Hmmm winning one match does compare to winning the World Cup doesn't it :p:

TheBlueRaja 17-06-2006 13:51

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flobajob
So now it's "OUR" media, and you have a problem with them going overboard about "OUR" team ...

Yes,
Your media goes on about England constantly without a single thought about the fact that they broadcast into other countries. Why should we concider ourselves part of the Uk when they dont concider the fact that we are in the UK too.

pedantic 17-06-2006 13:54

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I've mentioned 1967 twice in response to allegations of Scotland being poor.

If thats double standards compared to the English media banging on about 1966 almost daily since 1966 then there's something wrong.

And made full use of those posts, with a child-like attitude I might add.

off the park

off the park

off the park

Look familiar ?

TheBlueRaja 17-06-2006 14:06

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pedantic
And made full use of those posts, with a child-like attitude I might add.

off the park

off the park

off the park

Look familiar ?

Yeah, but it was...

Humped!

Off the park!

Glad you hate it!

---------- Post added at 13:05 ---------- Previous post was at 13:01 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
Hmmm winning one match does compare to winning the World Cup doesn't it :p:

It does when you just humped (off the park) your rivals right after they win the World Cup, right when they are at their supposed peak in terms of football at their own ground, in front of thier own fans even.

For the Tartan Army to come strolling down the road and win a glorious game where we utterly take the p*ss - then yes it quite possibly does compare.

---------- Post added at 13:06 ---------- Previous post was at 13:05 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
Not really pointless is it though? If it is pointless, it makes your point, useless then. Saying about it is not their national sport is just a weazel out isn't it? What about the USA? Out of the teams at the world cup, they probably have the largest population, yet don't have a chance.

FIFA rank them 5th in the World.

pedantic 17-06-2006 14:10

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Glad you hate it!

I never said I hate it.

That would give you exactly what you crave, the "belief" that you can wind me up. As if ! :D

TheBlueRaja 17-06-2006 14:11

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pedantic
I never said I hate it.

That would give you exactly what you crave, the "belief" that you can wind me up. As if ! :D

I know i did.

danielf 17-06-2006 14:12

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
http://www.bbc.co.uk/scotland/sports.../article/0022/

Quote:

Originally Posted by bbc
Put in this perspective, Scotland's victory against England at Wembley, the first game England had lost since becoming World Champions, fits within Scotland's canon of glorious failures, such as the win over Holland in 1978 and 2003, rather than the famous victory it is generally considered to be.

No mention of the subsequent 6-0 thumping in 2003 then :rofl:

pedantic 17-06-2006 14:12

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I know i did.

Add "dillusional" to your cv now. ;)

TheBlueRaja 17-06-2006 14:17

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
http://www.bbc.co.uk/scotland/sports.../article/0022/



No mention of the subsequent 6-0 thumping in 2003 then :rofl:

Funny that being on the BBC website isnt it.

danielf 17-06-2006 14:20

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Funny that being on the BBC website isnt it.

Yes, I do see your point. Sorry for taking the ****** :angel: ;)

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 14:22

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Funny that being on the BBC website isnt it.

Notice you have not disagreed with a single word of it though ;)

pedantic 17-06-2006 14:24

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
Notice you have not disagreed with a single word of it though ;)

:LOL:

Russ 17-06-2006 17:19

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Yes,
Your media goes on about England constantly without a single thought about the fact that they broadcast into other countries. Why should we concider ourselves part of the Uk when they dont concider the fact that we are in the UK too.

:clap:

Stuart 17-06-2006 17:32

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I never insinuated you did say that, i simply pointed out that your bloody media do and continue to ram it down our throats even during games which have bugger all to do with England, I really dont want to know every time Sven has a dump.

Do the Daily Record not cover the Scottish teams then? Do BBC Scotland not cover the Scottish teams? I won't ask about the ITV companies, as from what I can see, they don't seem to bother with local broadcasts anymore.

Same thing with Wales.

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 17:46

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C
Do the Daily Record not cover the Scottish teams then? Do BBC Scotland not cover the Scottish teams? I won't ask about the ITV companies, as from what I can see, they don't seem to bother with local broadcasts anymore.

Same thing with Wales.

The World Cup is the biggest show in town, perhaps if Scotland or Wales ever qualified for it they would recieve equal press, it's hardly fair blaming England just because we are the only home nation there again!

pedantic 17-06-2006 19:01

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C
Do the Daily Record not cover the Scottish teams then? Do BBC Scotland not cover the Scottish teams? I won't ask about the ITV companies, as from what I can see, they don't seem to bother with local broadcasts anymore.

Same thing with Wales.

Shhh ! Don't say that, they'll have nothing to moan about. :D

Russ 17-06-2006 22:58

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
perhaps if Scotland or Wales ever qualified for it they would recieve equal press,

Sorry mate but that's just rubbish, when Wales won the 6 nations two years ago, the coverage we had was nothing like what England gets.

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 23:32

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Sorry mate but that's just rubbish, when Wales won the 6 nations two years ago, the coverage we had was nothing like what England gets.

No one cares about rugby when England wins, it hardly gets blanket coverage

Russ 17-06-2006 23:47

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
No one cares about rugby when England wins, it hardly gets blanket coverage

:rofl:

Come on mate...you're not serious.....right?

You remember when England won the rugby World Cup?? It's all we had for about a week.

ikthius 17-06-2006 23:52

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
and what about when england won the ashes for the first time in, what...... 18 years was it?

end to end coverage.

and we are not a cricketing nation.... except in private schools, but that does not count :D

ik

TheDaddy 17-06-2006 23:56

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
:rofl:

Come on mate...you're not serious.....right?

You remember when England won the rugby World Cup?? It's all we had for about a week.

You are unbelievable that was the World Cup its a bit different, you ask the average bloke on the street if he likes rugby and his likely answer is 'yeah I love the five nations' :erm: , to which you say 'but it's six nations now Italy joined' cue bemused looks ;)

Derek 17-06-2006 23:56

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
And its not like the Ashes were an internationally contested competetion.

So England beat a team from a country about 1/3 of their population for the first time in recent memory and thats the cause of honours and the usual BBC sports personality of the year overload.

ikthius 17-06-2006 23:58

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dezzo
And its not like the Ashes were an internationally contested competetion.

So England beat a team from a country about 1/3 of their size for the first time in recent memory and thats the cause of honours and the usual BBC sports personality of the year overload.

i thought australia was biger than britain? :D

but yes, I get you

ik

Derek 18-06-2006 00:00

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Post edited to make it clearer that the England cricket team has been rubbish for a great number of years ;)

Mal 18-06-2006 00:06

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dezzo
And its not like the Ashes were an internationally contested competetion.

So England beat a team from a country about 1/3 of their population for the first time in recent memory and thats the cause of honours and the usual BBC sports personality of the year overload.

What is it with you Scots about population size? :) I mean it's not like Australia are absolute crap at cricket are they? They get beat by everyone, never world cup winners, never the best team going... ;)

Stuart 18-06-2006 00:14

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
So, how do Scotland do at Cricket?

TheDaddy 18-06-2006 00:15

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C
So, how do Scotland do at Cricket?

I think they are classed as a county not a country ;)

danielf 18-06-2006 00:15

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
It's a bit sad really, that this thread sees more posts than the other one. The world cup is on lads (and lasses)! Your country may or not be in it, but if you like your footie you should be posting in the other thread where we (hopefully) discuss the actual games...

Mal 18-06-2006 00:17

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
It's a bit sad really, that this thread sees more posts than the other one. The world cup is on lads (and lasses)! Your country may or not be in it, but if you like your footie you should be posting in the other thread where we (hopefully) discuss the actual games...

The Scotland fans want to attack us, what do you expect us to do? ;) :D

Derek 18-06-2006 00:22

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C
So, how do Scotland do at Cricket?

We've got better things to do with our time. Instead of cricket we perfect the art of deep frying anything and everything and having the worst record in Europe for a whole host of diseases. :D

At the end of the day I like the England team, I'd quite happily shoot the whole commentary team and the British (cough, *English*, cough) media who manage to turn the rest of the UK off supporting any English team in any meaningful competition knowning if they do win that'll be all thats on TV and Radio for the next week.

Newspaper editor - "Whats that? A huge earthquake in L.A. and it's fallen into the ocean? Put it on page 15, we've got a special on what Wayne Rooney is wearing on the plane home taking up the first 14 pages"

danielf 18-06-2006 00:26

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
The Scotland fans want to attack us, what do you expect us to do? ;) :D

Ignore them, and post your opinions on today's games. You have watched them haven't you? For a country that is supposedly footie mad, I find the lack of posts in the other thread worrying. It's the bloody world cup. It doesn't get any bigger. Get your footie hat on and discuss the actual games!

Mal 18-06-2006 00:32

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Ignore them, and post your opinions on today's games. You have watched them haven't you? For a country that is supposedly footie mad, I find the lack of posts in the other thread worrying. It's the bloody world cup. It doesn't get any bigger. Get your footie hat on and discuss the actual games!

There is rivalry at stake here, you know! ;)

danielf 18-06-2006 00:42

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
There is rivalry at stake here, you know! ;)

So you don't actually watch the matches then? I have to say I'm more than a little disappointed. Could be good though. "England bow out of world cup due to fans having no interest in the actual game"

Mal 18-06-2006 00:43

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
There is rivalry at stake here, you know! ;)

So you don't actually watch the matches then? I have to say I'm more than a little disappointed. Could be good though. "England bow out of world cup due to fans having no interest in the actual game"

:scratch: Where did I say that I didn't watch the matches?

danielf 18-06-2006 00:47

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
:scratch: Where did I say that I didn't watch the matches?

You didn't. I'm just surprised there's no discussion of the actual matches. Just England/Scotland/Wales supporters slagging each other of.

Mal 18-06-2006 01:01

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
You didn't. I'm just surprised there's no discussion of the actual matches.

Different thread though. At least this isn't hijacking the main thread. ;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Just England/Scotland/Wales supporters slagging each other of.

The England fans didn't start this... ;)

---------- Post added at 00:01 ---------- Previous post was yesterday at 23:50 ----------

...and to be honest, me saying that the Italy - USA was an interesting game, would that really have done anything for the other thread?

danielf 18-06-2006 01:04

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Oh, I give up! I thought there were some supporters of the game here. Apparently I was wrong.

Mal 18-06-2006 01:08

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf
Oh, I give up! I thought there were some supporters of the game here. Apparently I was wrong.

Yes I am a supporter of the game. Just because I don't want to post some inane, meaningless post in the main thread, which would get overlooked anyway, doesn't mean otherwise...

I am taking part in the other part of supporting a football team...the banter.

Why have you got Aanvullah in your user title for? From what I gathered from what you have said, it doesn't exactly have a "lets be friends" use.

danielf 18-06-2006 01:30

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal

Why have you got Aanvullah in your user title for? From what I gathered from what you have said, it doesn't exactly have a "lets be friends" use.

Aanvalluh is a phonetic shortcut for "aanvallen" which means nothing more than "attack". It's a chant used by Holland supporters to cheer the team, which is supposed to play attractive footballl. I suppose the best translation of aanvallen is 'forward' There's nothing offensive about it (imo).

pedantic 18-06-2006 02:15

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
The trouble is, the scottish are very bitter, hence the title of this thread. Bitter, with a massive inferiority complex.

But we English like a good chuckle, watching them recruit as many people from the home nations against us as they possibly can. :D

Russ 18-06-2006 10:47

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
You are unbelievable that was the World Cup its a bit different, you ask the average bloke on the street if he likes rugby and his likely answer is 'yeah I love the five nations' :erm: , to which you say 'but it's six nations now Italy joined' cue bemused looks ;)

It's nothing to do with whether people are bothered by rugby or not! The simple fact is when England win any major tournament we get wall to wall coverage - when any other home nation wins all we get is a few pages!

Are you seriously trying to tell me you don't think that happens???

ikthius 18-06-2006 12:43

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pedantic
The trouble is, the scottish are very bitter, hence the title of this thread. Bitter, with a massive inferiority complex.

But we English like a good chuckle, watching them recruit as many people from the home nations against us as they possibly can. :D

lmao, that gave me a laugh

ik

TheDaddy 19-06-2006 00:25

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
It's nothing to do with whether people are bothered by rugby or not! The simple fact is when England win any major tournament we get wall to wall coverage - when any other home nation wins all we get is a few pages!

Are you seriously trying to tell me you don't think that happens???

Your nation has never won any World cups and until they do I guess we will never know ;) :p:

Russ 19-06-2006 00:29

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
Your nation has never won any World cups and until they do I guess we will never know ;) :p:

Well you could have avoided such a cheap cop-out :rolleyes:

Read my post again, I didn't mention the World Cup, I said a major tournament.

In all likelihood being English means that when your team succeeds and the papers are saturated in it, you just consider that to be normal, and not 'excessive' like the rest of us do. However I'm sure our roles would be reversed if Wales were given the same kind of coverage (which will never happen regardless of what any of our teams win).

TheDaddy 19-06-2006 00:39

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
The papers are hardly 'saturated' when we win the Six Nations, things like The Ashes were different because it was for the first time in twenty odd years we had won it, desides if you don't like whats written I am sure there are Welsh National papers.

Russ 19-06-2006 00:46

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
The papers are hardly 'saturated' when we win the Six Nations,

Selective memory then...? :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
things like The Ashes were different because it was for the first time in twenty odd years we had won it, desides if you don't like whats written I am sure there are Welsh National papers.

Yes - and they cover the news in Wales. I want a newspaper which covers the whole of the UK - is that so hard to understand?

carlingman 19-06-2006 00:53

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
And of course not to mention the papers are saturated with Englands recent tour in Rugby as they are doing so well against Australia etc.

:D

More a case of World Chumps not World Champs.

:D

TheDaddy 19-06-2006 01:07

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Selective memory then...? :)

Yes - and they cover the news in Wales. I want a newspaper which covers the whole of the UK - is that so hard to understand?

Newspapers are businesses and like any other business if they don't give the customer what they want they go bust, if enough people shared your views then things would change, maybe that is why I am convinced by your media claims and by the way I want to moan about the bias coverage Scotland recieved in the 1978 World Cup finals especially to their ludicrous claims about winning it :D

---------- Post added at 00:07 ---------- Previous post was at 00:03 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by carlingman
And of course not to mention the papers are saturated with Englands recent tour in Rugby as they are doing so well against Australia etc.

:D

More a case of World Chumps not World Champs.

:D

Seeing as Wales have never won anything that will make you just Chumps then :p: :)

pedantic 19-06-2006 02:11

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Not being funny here, but both Russ and Carlingman support english teams that are not short of good coverage in the press. Both Man U, and Arsenal, are plastered all over the tabloids, week in and week out. What would your response be to your respective rivals, when they bleat on about your dominance in the press I wonder ? Having lived in both Manchester, and East London, I know how it irritates the respective rival clubs. Hence the reason, I find all this talk of press dominance a tad hypocritical.

Russ 19-06-2006 02:39

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pedantic
Not being funny here, but both Russ and Carlingman support english teams that are not short of good coverage in the press. Both Man U, and Arsenal, are plastered all over the tabloids, week in and week out. What would your response be to your respective rivals, when they bleat on about your dominance in the press I wonder ? Having lived in both Manchester, and East London, I know how it irritates the respective rival clubs. Hence the reason, I find all this talk of press dominance a tad hypocritical.

Don't forget I also support a Welsh team ;)

The difference is I don't object to, say Arsenal getting loads of coverage when they win something (if anyone can remember those days ;) ) because they play in a part of the country which gets equal press as Man Utd, Liverpool or anyone else. No matter what Wales do, none of our teams will get the same level of coverage.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy

Seeing as Wales have never won anything that will make you just Chumps then :p: :)

Forgetting the small issue of the 6 Nations Tournament in 2005??

pedantic 19-06-2006 02:54

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Don't forget I also support a Welsh team ;)

And surely the most popular in Wales. ;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
The difference is I don't object to, say Arsenal getting loads of coverage when they win something (if anyone can remember those days ;) )

:LOL:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
No matter what Wales do, none of our teams will get the same level of coverage.

Probably right there, but the "supply and demand" press rule, dictate where the "best coverage" will be unfortunately.

Russ 19-06-2006 09:18

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
And as for as long as that is the case, I will object to it.

SlackDad 19-06-2006 09:41

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
And as for as long as that is the case, I will object to it.

Are there not good quality regional papers in your area that have good national coverage? The Scotsman and Daily Record in Scotland surely do not cover England with such fervour.

Russ 19-06-2006 10:12

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad
Are there not good quality regional papers in your area that have good national coverage? The Scotsman and Daily Record in Scotland surely do not cover England with such fervour.

No there aren't. The closest we have is the Western Mail but it's not my type of paper. Even if there was a Welsh equivalent of the Scotsman we still have the issue of tv coverage too. A percentage of our BBC output is dedicated to Wales but the rest still goes overboard when England win. I pay my licence fee just like anyone else so I don't expect my national team to be swept aside in favour of a story on who England are playing!

SlackDad 19-06-2006 10:30

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
No there aren't. The closest we have is the Western Mail but it's not my type of paper. Even if there was a Welsh equivalent of the Scotsman we still have the issue of tv coverage too. A percentage of our BBC output is dedicated to Wales but the rest still goes overboard when England win. I pay my licence fee just like anyone else so I don't expect my national team to be swept aside in favour of a story on who England are playing!

I guess it's a case of you can't please all the people all the time. This reminds me a bit of BBC Look East in my area where there is a constant complaint that the coverage is Norwich City biased over Ipswich Town.

It must be true that if Wales were in the World Cup then the coverage would be more representative. Moreover - and I'm not being funny - but if the Welsh team had the same level of players and expectation as the England team then the coverage would be more level IMO.

Russ 19-06-2006 10:35

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad
I guess it's a case of you can't please all the people all the time.

It's more a case of "we don't want to please all the people".

Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad
It must be true that if Wales were in the World Cup then the coverage would be more representative. Moreover - and I'm not being funny - but if the Welsh team had the same level of players and expectation as the England team then the coverage would be more level IMO.

That's a possibilty but it's still not fair and equal reporting though is it? That's what I object to. When all the home nations play, regardless of who or what England are doing, I want to hear about Wales first. The national news is just that - national.

SlackDad 19-06-2006 11:07

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
It's more a case of "we don't want to please all the people".



That's a possibilty but it's still not fair and equal reporting though is it? That's what I object to. When all the home nations play, regardless of who or what England are doing, I want to hear about Wales first. The national news is just that - national.

But if national means the UK the team which is in the most important competition or doing the best should by rights be reported on first, regardless of who this is. If England had not qualified for the World Cup but Wales, Scotland, or NI had then I'm sure the coverage would have been extensive.
If you mean national to mean Wales then I agree with you that national coverage should focus on Welsh teams. Does this not happen at all, with Welsh news editions?

Russ 19-06-2006 13:30

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad
But if national means the UK the team which is in the most important competition or doing the best should by rights be reported on first, regardless of who this is.

So are you saying that on any given day when the home nations are playing World Cup or European qualifiers England should automatically be given preference?

As far as I'm concerned if they're all playing in the same tournament or at the same stage the coverage should be equal.

Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad
If England had not qualified for the World Cup but Wales, Scotland, or NI had then I'm sure the coverage would have been extensive

:D

You really believe that?

Quote:

Originally Posted by SlackDad
If you mean national to mean Wales then I agree with you that national coverage should focus on Welsh teams. Does this not happen at all, with Welsh news editions?

With some papers yes.

Flobajob 19-06-2006 14:46

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
I think the media should cater more for the majority in the British Isles, everyone knows that Scotland and Wales will never have a hope in hell of getting anywhere in the World Cup so no-one's interested in hearing about them.

Russ 19-06-2006 14:49

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flobajob
I think the media should cater more for the majority in the British Isles, everyone knows that Scotland and Wales will never have a hope in hell of getting anywhere in the World Cup so no-one's interested in hearing about them.

You've just about gauranteed yourself a pile of gloating PMs when England fail again :D

TheDaddy 19-06-2006 14:52

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Can we get back to the insults and childish one up man ship please

---------- Post added at 13:52 ---------- Previous post was at 13:51 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
You've just about gauranteed yourself a pile of gloating PMs when England fail again :D

Thank you

punky 19-06-2006 14:54

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
As far as I'm concerned if they're all playing in the same tournament or at the same stage the coverage should be equal.

Fair enough, but considering 84% of the UK is English, with 50m as opposed to 3m in Wales and 5m in Scotland. Time is tight and so the majority would have to be catered for. TV coverage etc is a business like any other. I imagine the Angolan population in the UK is pretty small which is why they don't get much coverage here. Anyone showing a English game will get a much bigger slice of the pie due to the population size, than someone showing a Welsh/Scottish game.

Russ 19-06-2006 14:59

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
Can we get back to the insults and childish one up man ship please

---------- Post added at 13:52 ---------- Previous post was at 13:51 ----------



Thank you

I didn't say the PMs will come from me...! My style is a bit more obvious, I wouldn't take it to PM :D

Quote:

Originally Posted by punky
Fair enough, but considering 84% of the UK is English, with 50m as opposed to 3m in Wales and 5m in Scotland. Time is tight and so the majority would have to be catered for. TV coverage etc is a business like any other. I imagine the Angolan population in the UK is pretty small which is why they don't get much coverage here. Anyone showing a English game will get a much bigger slice of the pie due to the population size, than someone showing a Welsh/Scottish game.

And that is why threads like this will appear along with anti-English sentiments when it comes to sport. Sod the little guy, let's just keep the majority happy.

Possibly the only time political correctness goes out of the window eh ;)

Flobajob 19-06-2006 15:02

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
You've just about gauranteed yourself a pile of gloating PMs when England fail again :D

No-one's saying that we're going to win the world cup, the point is, we have a far better team than Wales or Scotland (to be fair, even our local under 5's team could outplay the Welsh national side) and the majority of people in the UK are ENGLISH and are far more interested in hearing about their own team rather than one's that didn't have the skill to even qualify.

punky 19-06-2006 15:08

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
And that is why threads like this will appear along with anti-English sentiments when it comes to sport. Sod the little guy, let's just keep the majority happy.

Possibly the only time political correctness goes out of the window eh ;)

Not so much, sod the little guy, but sod everyone. Companies have to look after themselves first and foremost.

May seem harsh, but there's not a lot you can do about it. Broadcasting companies pay a lot of money for rights and they need to earn the maximum sum possible for the biggest return. Nationality doesn't come into it. The only language understood isn't English or Welsh, but money.

Anyway, if it did happen and the BBC had the rights to them all and all 4 we're playing simultaneously, they'd be nothing to argue over as BBC1 would show the England game, BB1 Wales woudl show the Welsh game, etc...

Also, I seem to recall when two countries in the UK are playing simultaneously on Sky, Sky have screened both matches.

Russ 19-06-2006 15:12

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flobajob
No-one's saying that we're going to win the world cup, the point is, we have a far better team than Wales or Scotland (to be fair, even our local under 5's team could outplay the Welsh national side) and the majority of people in the UK are ENGLISH and are far more interested in hearing about their own team rather than one's that didn't have the skill to even qualify.

So as I said, sod the little guy then. I'm grateful that you're not a good representation of the English people who use this site.

Quote:

Originally Posted by punky
Anyway, if it did happen and the BBC had the rights to them all and all 4 we're playing simultaneously, they'd be nothing to argue over as BBC1 would show the England game, BB1 Wales woudl show the Welsh game, etc...

Yeah that's fine and I don't have a problem with that. But when the day's results were read out on the news, guess who will always be read first?

The national news is NOT the English news - it's the UK news. I'm not saying Wales or Scotland should always be discussed first - that would be unfair. But breaking up the routine so our results were read out first occasionally would be a good start and would send out a great message of equality.

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-06-2006 15:14

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
I don't see what the argument is about. I thought that regional areas of the BBC showed the games that matter to those specific areas. So if Wales were playing an international on same day as ENgland BBC Wales would show the welsh game and BBC england show the england one. Is this not how it works?

Similary when I buy the Sun in Dundee on a saturday the footbal section is all about teh Scottish League, not about the premiership.

So wheres the inequality? Surely it would be more unequal to offer exactly the same amount of coverage irregardless of who has the biggest following.

Russ 19-06-2006 15:21

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo
I don't see what the argument is about. I thought that regional areas of the BBC showed the games that matter to those specific areas. So if Wales were playing an international on same day as ENgland BBC Wales would show the welsh game and BBC england show the england one. Is this not how it works?

I'm assuming you've simply not read any of my posts? In which case I'll go over it again.

I object to England being given preference when it comes to the UK media when the other home nations are also playing.

I also object to the amount of coverage England gets compared to that of the other home nations. If it was confined to England-only publications and broadcasts then I wouldn't care. But this happens in the media which is supposed to cater for the whole of the UK.

SlackDad 19-06-2006 15:36

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
So are you saying that on any given day when the home nations are playing World Cup or European qualifiers England should automatically be given preference?

That's not what I'm saying at all. What I said was that the the team in the UK which is in the most important competition or doing the best should by rights be reported on first, regardless of who this is. Not quite the same as England getting automatic priority.

Quote:

As far as I'm concerned if they're all playing in the same tournament or at the same stage the coverage should be equal.
I've not got a problem with that at all. Not the newspaper's fault this doesn't usually happen.

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-06-2006 15:37

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Can you give examples of the media you're on about? I was always under the impression that each part of the UK has regional news. After all the weather in the news that you see on TV would be localised for Walse would it not? Isnt that the same for sport? (I havent watched the news outside London for ages, hence I am asking)
Anyway if there are more people who follow england watching the news then Id agree why ENgland gets priority coverage. Surely coverage has to match the demand?! If you got no coverage at all, then you'd have a decent argument, but until then its just sounds like sour grapes.

Flobajob 19-06-2006 16:13

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
So as I said, sod the little guy then.

No, sod the team that didn't qualify and aren't playing in the world cup, what on earth do you expect the media to say about them? How much of a glorious failure they were?

Quote:

I'm grateful that you're not a good representation of the English people who use this site.
And let's hope you're not the best representation of the Welsh public, heaven forbid they get considered a nation of people who moan endlessly about something unbelievably trivial.

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-06-2006 16:54

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Maybe Russ will be happy when Treveor McDermott heads the sports bulletin with "Sorry to all you ENgland fans, but we will begin this broadcast by saying how crap the Welsh team are for not qualifying for the World Cup and the same goes to Scotland cause they couldnt beat the Faoroe ISlands...."

Anyway I don't even support England and when they played Scotland (both in footy and rugby), I always wanted the scots to win (underdogs and Kenny Daglish and all that), and I still think Russ is going a bit OTT with his moaning!

Nugget 19-06-2006 17:00

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo
Maybe Russ will be happy when Treveor McDermott heads the sports bulletin with "Sorry to all you ENgland fans, but we will begin this broadcast by saying how crap the Welsh team are for not qualifying for the World Cup and the same goes to Scotland cause they couldnt beat the Faoroe ISlands...."

Anyway I don't even support England and when they played Scotland (both in footy and rugby), I always wanted the scots to win (underdogs and Kenny Daglish and all that), and I still think Russ is going a bit OTT with his moaning!

Well, in fairness, Russ does have a valid point - irrespective of the abilities of the current teams, there is a media bias towards England. I'm not saying it's right or wrong (I explained my opinion waaaaaaaaaaaaay back in this thread), but Russ is right in what he's saying :shrug:

orangebird 19-06-2006 17:06

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Then maybe this topic should've been brought up at another time, not at a time when the world cup is on and England are the only UK team to qualify? :rolleyes:

It seems a bit daft to **** and moan about how much coverage England are getting - the papers are hardly going to make any sales about Scotland or Wales or NI if they're not partcipating, are they? :erm:

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-06-2006 17:06

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
I would say its biased if all national teams had the same level of support. But the reality is more people in the UK support ENgland then any other national team. Additionally (from what Ive heard at the WC) England have one of the highest followings of any of the teams playing. There were 30,000 in the PAraguay game (from an official allocation of 5k). Wouldn't you agree that that level of support warrants the larger share of the coverage.

Nugget 19-06-2006 17:26

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo
I would say its biased if all national teams had the same level of support. But the reality is more people in the UK support ENgland then any other national team. Additionally (from what Ive heard at the WC) England have one of the highest followings of any of the teams playing. There were 30,000 in the PAraguay game (from an official allocation of 5k). Wouldn't you agree that that level of support warrants the larger share of the coverage.

In this instance, I'd agree. However, the way I read what Russ is saying is that, in the event (however un/likely it is) that all 4 Home Nations qualified for the World / European Cup, the media is intrinsically biased towards England - regardless of the population count within the 4 nations, there should be a more liberal split, if for no other reason that the Welsh aren't confined to Wales, just as the English aren't confined to England :)

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-06-2006 17:39

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget
In this instance, I'd agree. However, the way I read what Russ is saying is that, in the event (however un/likely it is) that all 4 Home Nations qualified for the World / European Cup, the media is intrinsically biased towards England - regardless of the population count within the 4 nations, there should be a more liberal split, if for no other reason that the Welsh aren't confined to Wales, just as the English aren't confined to England :)

However since thats not gonna happen (i.e Wales qualifying for the WC) whats the point in arguing, lol ;)

TheDaddy 19-06-2006 17:44

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo
However since thats not gonna happen (i.e Wales qualifying for the WC) whats the point in arguing, lol ;)

According to Russ they did qualify in the 1950's, anyone remember that, no thought not :D :p:

Nugget 19-06-2006 17:51

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy
According to Russ they did qualify in the 1950's, anyone remember that, no thought not :D :p:

1958, I believe ;)

Mind you, I have to say that, given the choice between simply not qualifying, or getting there but being crap and getting knocked out in the Quarter Finals again, I'm not sure which way I'd go :disturbd:

Russ 19-06-2006 18:00

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Seeing as so many of you are completely failing to grasp my very simple point, I'll go over it again.

One last time.

When it is only England playing, it makes sense for them to be given media coverage. No problems there. What I object to is when England have a game (in any competition or even a friendly) the amount of coverage they're given vastly outweights that given to the other home countries when they play.

When all the home nations (or one of them as well as England) are playing, England are given priority in the Uk media. This, as I'm sure you will all agree, is completely unfair.

I pay for my licence like you guys pressumably do, so why should I feel like my national team is being treated like an afterthought on the national news?

There are very few (in fact I can only think of one) Welsh newspapers which report on the whole of the UK and of course we are given much more fair coverage there, but they are not my style of newspaper.

So all in all, The media, as Nugget can see and agree with, is biased towards England. Completely unfair and it's for this reason that threads like this will pop up and also the reason why the rest of us aren't as enthusiastic about England. Nothing to do with jealousy, just the way we are treated.

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-06-2006 18:13

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
I still dont get it......... can we have it one more time Russ.....

TheBlueRaja 19-06-2006 19:16

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
MY GOD!

I go away for a few days and you lot (the Jellied eel lovers) are STILL banging on and on and on in this thread and its specifically not even about you - its about anyone BUT you for god sake.

Talk about Paranoid!

I mean this thread has about 1000 more views than the proper one.... :rofl:

I think you all know your going out soon - and i think your trying to get as much in as possible before you desert this thread in DROVES the minute you flap out the World Cup.

To all the people on here not from that Paranoid land - get behind your team, if Sweden fail, you just get somebody else to support! Enjoy the World Cup for what it is - a laugh at Englands expense!

BRING ON THE ENGLAND!

Larsson, Larsson, Larrson. :hyper:

bhoywonder1967 19-06-2006 19:25

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
....Larsson, Larsson, Larrson. :hyper:

:shocked: Not quite what I would expect from a Bairn!! :p:

What's the odds on the King of Kings for a treble??

Russ 19-06-2006 19:27

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bhoywonder1967
What's the odds on the King of Kings for a treble??

Jesus is in the World Cup?? :eek:

bhoywonder1967 19-06-2006 19:32

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Jesus is in the World Cup?? :eek:

Nope but God is and his name is Henrik Larsson!!! :D

SlackDad 19-06-2006 19:41

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
MY GOD!

I go away for a few days and you lot (the Jellied eel lovers) are STILL banging on and on and on in this thread and its specifically not even about you - its about anyone BUT you for god sake.

Talk about Paranoid!

I mean this thread has about 1000 more views than the proper one.... :rofl:

I think you all know your going out soon - and i think your trying to get as much in as possible before you desert this thread in DROVES the minute you flap out the World Cup.

To all the people on here not from that Paranoid land - get behind your team, if Sweden fail, you just get somebody else to support! Enjoy the World Cup for what it is - a laugh at Englands expense!

BRING ON THE ENGLAND!

Larsson, Larsson, Larrson. :hyper:

How strange :confused:

---------- Post added at 18:41 ---------- Previous post was at 18:38 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Seeing as so many of you are completely failing to grasp my very simple point, I'll go over it again.

One last time.

When it is only England playing, it makes sense for them to be given media coverage. No problems there. What I object to is when England have a game (in any competition or even a friendly) the amount of coverage they're given vastly outweights that given to the other home countries when they play.

When all the home nations (or one of them as well as England) are playing, England are given priority in the Uk media. This, as I'm sure you will all agree, is completely unfair.

I pay for my licence like you guys pressumably do, so why should I feel like my national team is being treated like an afterthought on the national news?

There are very few (in fact I can only think of one) Welsh newspapers which report on the whole of the UK and of course we are given much more fair coverage there, but they are not my style of newspaper.

So all in all, The media, as Nugget can see and agree with, is biased towards England. Completely unfair and it's for this reason that threads like this will pop up and also the reason why the rest of us aren't as enthusiastic about England. Nothing to do with jealousy, just the way we are treated.

Isn't it a bit like complaining that man Utd get more coverage than any team in the lower leagues.

TheBlueRaja 19-06-2006 19:42

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bhoywonder1967
:shocked: Not quite what I would expect from a Bairn!! :p:

What's the odds on the King of Kings for a treble??

Hey, i may not have liked him sticking goals past us, but i sure as hell will do when he bags a few at the expense of the English.

Lets just call it Ying/Yang... :D

bhoywonder1967 19-06-2006 19:46

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Hey, i may not have liked him sticking goals past us, but i sure as hell will do when he bags a few at the expense of the English.

Lets just call it Ying/Yang... :D

Fair enough my friend, welcome to the Henrik Larsson Appreciation Society :)

TheBlueRaja 19-06-2006 19:50

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bhoywonder1967
Fair enough my friend, welcome to the Henrik Larsson Appreciation Society :)

I've been a member for a while to be honest, just because a player plays for an opposing team dosent mean i dont appreciate talent when i see it and he had it in droves.

I also think what he's doing in going back to his local club is a brilliant gesture - i wish more footballers would do that.

bhoywonder1967 19-06-2006 19:54

Re: The anyone but England thread!
 
He has what not a lot of other players don't, Integrity.

He made a promise to return to Helsingborg one day and he's doing just that.

The man's a class act.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum