Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media News Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   More port blocking (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=4037)

fraz 09-11-2003 18:19

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
I expect there are only a few people affected, as NTL's FAQs say, but now you are shifting the debate away from the point you tried (unsuccessfully as it happens) to make earlier.

Originally you asked, 'have you even noticed?' Pem's answer to that is clearly 'yes'. You can't just go changing the question when your original point proves wobbly.

Pem hasn't actually clarified whether he is talking about access via the internet or via an internal LAN.

If its the former then there are better alternatives available , if its the latter then he's not affected.

Paul 09-11-2003 18:46

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by fraz
Not being funny but how many people 'knowingly' use Windows File & Printer Sharing over a public network (your internal network wont be affected by the blocking) especially when there are more secure alternatives such as FTP or SCP for transferring files etc across the internet.

:LOL: - You think FTP is more secure than Windows File Sharing, I hope you don't work for NTL Technical Support ;)
To clear up any mis-understanding, Yes I am referring to connecting to other machines over the Internet, not on an internal Lan.
How I connect to them it is my choice, they are all windows machines and the data is not confidential in any manner, windows file sharing is the easyest method and has served my well for 5+ years thank you.

fraz 09-11-2003 19:03

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
:LOL: - You think FTP is more secure than Windows File Sharing, I hope you don't work for NTL Technical Support ;)
To clear up any mis-understanding, Yes I am referring to connecting to other machines over the Internet, not on an internal Lan.
How I connect to them it is my choice, they are all windows machines and the data is not confidential in any manner, windows file sharing is the easyest method and has served my well for 5+ years thank you.

It all depends on how well set up the server is :) Personally I use SCP to transfer files rather than FTP but that's a different story.

It appears that you may well be on of the unfortunate small number who may be affected although there are many ISPs (certainly Zen does, Telewest did for a while, not sure about BT and in the US it's becoming more common place) now that are blocking Netbios on the public network and indeed it is something which I believe Microsoft themselves have advised ISPs to do.

Myron 22-11-2003 23:53

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
If they block ALL 139, 445 then I will lose the ability to connect to my remote computer shares, that is a big loss of service to me.

If you can, use a tunnelled connection into your computer.

Paul 23-11-2003 00:03

Re: More port blocking
 
ATM - the evidence would seem to suggest thay have used a bit of common sense and only blocked incoming connection requests on the offending ports - i.e. I can still connect to my servers but my firewall logs suggest that incoming traffic on those ports has been blocked.

Myron 23-11-2003 00:33

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
ATM - the evidence would seem to suggest thay have used a bit of common sense and only blocked incoming connection requests on the offending ports - i.e. I can still connect to my servers but my firewall logs suggest that incoming traffic on those ports has been blocked.

As long as the reply ports are not blocked and only unsolicited/unexpected inbound connections to blocked ports are dropped.

trebor 23-11-2003 10:28

Re: More port blocking
 
sorry if this has already been asked/answered, but I couldn't see it anywhere.
so if ntl are blocking ports are they going to post a list of which ports are blocked, so people can work around the problem. does anybody know what ports are blocked?
is there any way to find out which ones are blocked?

thanks

Paul 23-11-2003 13:32

Re: More port blocking
 
Well the original article we were discussing was posted on .com so it's inaccessible now :rolleyes:

I just tried to look on community but that seems dead again as well :confused:

homealone 23-11-2003 13:47

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by trebor
sorry if this has already been asked/answered, but I couldn't see it anywhere.
so if ntl are blocking ports are they going to post a list of which ports are blocked, so people can work around the problem. does anybody know what ports are blocked?
is there any way to find out which ones are blocked?

thanks

hi trebor

totally from memory so I may be wrong, but I think it is ports 135. 137, 139, 445 & any over 1200.

trebor 23-11-2003 14:16

Re: More port blocking
 
would that explain why online games have started having problems. e.g ut2k3 uses ports 7777, 7778, 7787, 7788, 28900, 28902

Paul 23-11-2003 14:26

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by homealone
hi trebor

totally from memory so I may be wrong, but I think it is ports 135. 137, 139, 445 & any over 1200.

I can assure you it is not anything over 1200 !! That would stop thousands of applicaions working.

As I recall it was 135, 137, 138, 139, 445, 1433, 1434 & port in the 27xxx range that sub seven uses (can't remember it exactly).

Myron 23-11-2003 14:35

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by trebor
would that explain why online games have started having problems. e.g ut2k3 uses ports 7777, 7778, 7787, 7788, 28900, 28902

You could try using a SOCKS proxy, if one could be found.

homealone 23-11-2003 14:50

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pem
I can assure you it is not anything over 1200 !! That would stop thousands of applicaions working.

As I recall it was 135, 137, 138, 139, 445, 1433, 1434 & port in the 27xxx range that sub seven uses (can't remember it exactly).

thanks pem - said I might be wrong, :dunce: :)

Myron 23-11-2003 14:58

Re: More port blocking
 
Here is an RFC:

NTL could do with blocking inbound connections to port 17300. It seems the hackers are trying to get their revenge. My router is recording quite an increase in connection attempts to TCP port 17300 from various IP addresses.

The problem is that port blocking is not really an answer. There will come a point where so many ports will be blocked that it will be becoming impossible to use the Internet.

I was rediculed for the suggestions some months ago, but really NTL should upgrade their UBR's or firewalls so the customer has some basic contol over what can connect to his/her equipment.

By default every inbound port should be blocked. This would not be a problem because reply ports will not be blocked. Routers already so this and have been doing this for years. Un-educated users, I think, would not touch these options. 'cos they don't know how it all works.

The customer would be given three simple options that can be changed at any time.

Option 1: Block all inbound connections, unless to a reply port.
Option 2: Block all inbound connections selected by NTL.
Option 3: Block all inbound connections only for ports 135, 137, 139 and 445.

Any customer that would select option 3 would automatically be put on NTL's watch list so any suspicious traffic would be looked by at NTL's network operations centre and appropriate action taken.

Just three simple filter sets that can be defined network wide and each customer could choose only one of them. You would not want to allow the customer to define their own filter sets as then it will be totally unmanagable and the memory and processing power of the router might now be enough.

The option suggested here would work as it already implemented as option 3 in the suggestion above.

Paul 23-11-2003 15:59

Re: More port blocking
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by homealone
thanks pem - said I might be wrong, :dunce: :)

LOL, you were close, just that tiny (kill everything !) error :D


Edit: FFS why can't every forum have the same smilies ... Grrrrrrr ......


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:01.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum