Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Point taken, but when they cant fight back it stinks :td:

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

The very worst will be if we are seen to run away..Lets us leave by all means but on our own terms and to a ratified timetable.Of course if the Iraqi government asks us to leave earlier than the timetable... ;)

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

No way, we should have never gone in in the first place, such a needless loss of life on all sides but now we are there, we stay. We ****ed the country up even more then under Saddam (or to a greater degree, the Americans) so we stay until it stabilises to a point where its own government can be left to take full control. Yes, there may of been oppression under Saddam and all the pro-war, pro-bush nuts, exclaim the official line that removing him from power was a good alternative to WMD but if we just left now we are leaving the door open for Al-Zakawi and other retards to take advantage of all those who are desperate and have been through dispair and create an equally bad situation as before.

You can't just lay waste to a country then leave, and if you didn't like the scenes yesterday, well to be frank, welcome to war. Its not all fine and dandy for the people with the bigger bombs, people are going to get hurt on all sides. Pictures like those yesterday just stir up emotion like seen here.

If we don't want it turning into the next failure that is Afghanistan; a breeding ground for terrorists then we have to stay. With Saddam gone, and our forces gone, it'll be a haven for Al Qaeda. The campaign isn't finished, it isn't finished until there is a working government and working law and order.

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

No I dont think so Orior, certainly the vistors will write history as they see it. But no matter what official historians try to tell us, the truth of most conflicts will out eventually. Time needs to pass before an unbiased opinion of any historical even can truely be written, but eventually the dogma of victors and loosers will fall away and ''hopefully'' a truer understanding of events can be recorded....

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Quite. But since we're talking about the two most media-savvy and manipulative Governments on the planet, don't you think they could get the truth out, if the truth was that the country was 'getting back on its feet'? What is this great unspoken truth that illustrates how the country is 'getting back on its feet'?

Instead we have got what turn out to be a succession of lies ('we're going in to disarm Saddam of his WMDs','the insurgency is a small number of ex-regime elements','the insurgency will stop when we capture Saddam','We're going in to stop terrorism','things will get better after the election','things will get better after the constitution is ratified','100,000 police have been trained','We have no differences with the Iraqi Government'). Given that history, anything coming out of Washington and London needs to be taken with a hefty pinch of salt.

You can't argue with the graph of US deaths, which has steepened over time (despite the greater security around US forces), indicating that the country is getting progressively more violent.

Who are, er, part of the media. Bias can swing both ways (ask Fox News). And if capturing insurgents is what you celebrate two and a half years after the invasion (while ignoring the body count back in Baghdad), that's really rather indicative of how low expectations now are ('beacon of democracy' hopes replaced by 'hope the civil war isn't too bad after we pull out and that Iran isn't running too much of the country').

An Iraqi film maker writes in the Grauniad today:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story...575416,00.html

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

It seems like the military action was carried out without serious consideration given to what to do in the aftermath.

The flattening of the prison was something I'd have expected from the Yanks, but not the Brits. There will be militants using that and twisting it so that it becomes a symbol of "Westerner's interference" and just ignoring Iraqis.

Allowing loads of other prisoners to escape was stupid too.

As for whether the troops should come out, of course they should. Their job is now largely done. If a presence is needed, it should be clearly working with the Iraqi military - units paired up so that you have the benefits of Western experience and technology with Iraqi cultural and geographical knowledge.

Remember the story about a group of Military Policemen (MPs) who were trapped in a police station by a mob of Iraqis? And the sergeant who refused to leave his men despite a way out being shown to him? I knew him. Simon Hamilton-Jewell was a member of the judo club I went to down South. Despite showing incredible restraint, and eventually surrendering, Simon and his army colleagues were murdered. My father went to HJ's funeral.

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Listen up i have lost family in iraq because both our country and america can't leave well enough alone. Unless they come over here killing like Hitler did stay out the way and get our troops back.
And as for Northern Ireland come on its been going on since 1983 and will continue to go on until the bueracrats get out.

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Sorry but N.I has been going on for a lot longer, ive no doubt a date will soon be posted.
And sorry about your lost family.

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Just checked on history site sorry you are right got onenumber wrong its been happening N.I since 1953.

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

More like 1641, or thereabouts.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/timelin...sh_rebel.shtml

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

We aren't referring to when they came over here to help the scots and William Wallace more along the lines of since our beloved country tried to enforce our criminal justice system as is it and rules on education and religions etc which given by the britannia encyclopedia website is 1953 if you like you can talk to my Nan on the matter she is 89 and was born and raised in Ireland for 35 of those years

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Troops went in in 1969 (this time). You could go back to the 12th century when the Normans invaded (my ancestors) if you wanted to be pedantic - British military meddling in Ireland has gone on for centuries (partly from the occasionally legitimate fear that the island would be used by other enemies of Britain, which hasn't been the case since 1945 (one benefit of the EU, I suppose - the French are hardly likely to respond to spats over the CAP by sending troops to Dublin).

As for flattening the prison, I'd expect nothing less of a British commander who thinks his troops are in danger. It's what soldiers do. It does, however, rather jar with the 'things are getting better and it's all a media con' line being spun by the politicians - it's more like something you'd see in Sierra Leone than a fledgling democracy 'getting back on its feet'. Proper countries don't need heavily armed SAS lads in mufti running around trying to find out what the bad guys are doing.

? Heavily armed, are they? Those paperclips can give you a nasty nick when used in the right hands.

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Crikey - you ever heard of punctuation?

The FACT is that the IRA has been around at least since 1916, so you're still way off.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_Republican_Army

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

I suppose - the French are hardly likely to respond to spats over the CAP by sending troops to Dublin).
The french couldn't beat us at a game of war if they tried i mean come it wasn't so long ago they complained about the paramount channel playing Sharpe and sharpe's sword for nearly a month because it showed them as yellow bellies

Re: Is it time to pull British troops out of Iraq?
 

Yellow bellies who conquered most of continental Europe under one of the greatest military leaders ever.