Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33711723)

Paul 20-02-2023 22:33

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36146456)
Actually both Sky and ITV may be in breach of the Editors’ Code, clauses 3 and 4 (dealing with harassment and intrusion into grief, respectively). The fact that the family have spoken to the press in the past confers no obligation on them to speak in future and no right for journalists to pursue them. And, if asked not to continue pursuing and questioning, journalists must stop. There would have to be an overwhelming public interest argument to justify their continuing, which they absolutely will not be able to prove against the backdrop of a bereaved family asking for space in the hours after a body was discovered. Especially when intrusive, amateurish investigations are already a feature of this case. Sky and ITV had better hope the family are suitably mollified by the good kicking meted out on their behalf by the BBC this afternoon.

Yes, I expected you to be along to defend them. ;)
My view is not changed, as far as I'm concerned this has made this into a national media event, with their help, its no good complaining about it at this stage, is just a little too late. "There would have to be an overwhelming public interest argument to justify their continuing" - it seems to me there was one - 170,000 people disappear every year, and yet this was turned into a national story.

Chris 20-02-2023 22:38

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146459)
Yes, I expected you to be along to defend them. ;)
My view is not changed, as far as I'm concerned this has made this into a national media event, with their help, its no good complaining about it at this stage, is just a little too late. "There would have to be an overwhelming public interest argument to justify their continuing" - it seems to me there was one - 170,000 people disappear every year, and yet this was turned into a national story.

When employed as a journalist, adherence to the editors’ code was part of my contract of employment. So yes, naturally I’m aware of what it says and, having done more ‘death knocks’ than I care to remember, am personally aware of just how distressing even that first approach to a bereaved family can be for them, before they’ve even considered having to ask reporters to leave them alone (thereby leaving us technically free to do so, with due sensitivity).

Oddly enough these provisions were enough to keep all the other major news outlets away, at least in the immediate aftermath of Nicola’s body being discovered. Sky and ITV are the outliers here.

1andrew1 20-02-2023 23:07

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146459)
Yes, I expected you to be along to defend them. ;)
My view is not changed, as far as I'm concerned this has made this into a national media event, with their help, its no good complaining about it at this stage, is just a little too late. "There would have to be an overwhelming public interest argument to justify their continuing" - it seems to me there was one - 170,000 people disappear every year, and yet this was turned into a national story.

Speaking to the media dies not give them permission to contact you when they want to, whatever your state of distress and your explicit requests not to.

I wouldn't blame the family for trying to raise awareness of her disappearance in the hope that she would be found alive. It's the responsible thing to do.

In this context, I can't see that there is a public interest exemption. Public interest concerns matters like energy pricing, the running of local councils, congestion zones, etc. It's not about how often a missing person story appears in the news or the number of sightseers.

Paul 20-02-2023 23:23

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36146469)
Speaking to the media dies not give them permission to contact you when they want to

Of course it does.

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36146469)
In this context, I can't see that there is a public interest exemption. Public interest concerns matters like energy pricing, the running of local councils, congestion zones, etc. It's not about how often a missing person story appears in the news or the number of sightseers.

You see what you want to see. ;) You cant go making a media fuss and then complain when the media tries to contact you.

Chris 20-02-2023 23:43

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146475)
Of course it does.

You need to make a distinction between what you think is reasonable behaviour and how journalists are obliged to behave via their industry code of practice.

Your opinion, obviously, is yours - you may well think it’s obvious that the family’s prior contact with journalists gives those journalists the right to behave as some of them have over the past 24 hours.

However, in terms of the code of conduct they are held accountable to - it empirically does not.

1andrew1 20-02-2023 23:51

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146475)
Of course it does.

You see what you want to see. ;) You cant go making a media fuss and then complain when the media tries to contact you.

I'm not sure appealing for witnesses to someone's disappearance can be called a fuss!

Nor should appealing for witnesses give the media a 24/7 direct line to you. You don't sell your entire personal rights forever to the media when you do that.

Paul 21-02-2023 00:11

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Not really. :angel:

They specifically complained about the media "making contact" with them.
Given that a body had been found [unidentified at the time] then its perfectly reasonable that they would want to speak to them.
That contact was presumably refused, and that was that, since they dont say anyone continued to hassle them, only that they "contacted them".

Yes, its very unfortunate how this ended [and sadly it went as everyone expected] and its terrible for for her children.
However, as far as I'm concerned, the "family" are just lashing out at the media for doing their job, when there really was no need to do so.
[ Not even just the media, they also attack members of the public for "accusing their dad of wrongdoing, misquoted and vilified friends and family" ].
Not sure what thats about, Ive seen this is the news every day for 3 weeks and not seen him accused of anything.

Anyway, I'm not going to spend hours going over this, we can agree to disagree. Thats life.

---------- Post added at 23:11 ---------- Previous post was at 23:10 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36146479)
I'm not sure appealing for witnesses to someone's disappearance can be called a fuss! .

Stick to politics Andrew.

1andrew1 21-02-2023 00:26

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146481)
Stick to politics Andrew.

It's unfair to my fellow forum contributors to limit my contributions to just one area. ;)

Maggy 21-02-2023 10:36

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 36146432)
Stop watching or reading it and as if by magic they will

I don't.I buy no newspapers and I avoid TV news as much as possible apart from watching local TV news(for local news).24 hour news channels are/was a big mistake IMHO.

Chris 21-02-2023 13:24

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
It’s not looking great for ITV or Sky this morning.

The former editor of the Sunday Telegraph, Baroness Wheatcroft, has gone on the Today programme this morning to demand the press regulator look into their conduct. Meanwhile, the former Editor-in-Chief of ITN, Stewart Purvis, believes if ITV and Sky thought they had a decent defence against the allegations of unwarranted intrusion they would have aired it by now.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-englan...shire-64713045

RichardCoulter 21-02-2023 14:39

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 36146326)
Of course if you're a conspiracy theorist how long has the body actually been in the river?

I guess the autopsy will answer that.

Hopefully it will as, if there was any foul play involved, the person responsible needs to be caught.

If she had mental health problems or had been drinking she may simply have jumped in or her dog might have pulled her in.

An accident as opposed to suicide or foul play would probably provide her family with a crumb of comfort.

Mythica 21-02-2023 14:59

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146475)
Of course it does.

You see what you want to see. ;) You cant go making a media fuss and then complain when the media tries to contact you.

Celebrities using the media to get famous does not give the media the right to hound them in their private life.

Getting the media involved to help in a missing person case does not give the media the right to pester the family.

ianch99 21-02-2023 15:32

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
I find this whole saga very weird. Totally unhealthy obsession by all sorts of people: news outlets, social media, etc.

I feel so sorry for the family.

RichardCoulter 21-02-2023 16:14

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ianch99 (Post 36146521)
I find this whole saga very weird. Totally unhealthy obsession by all sorts of people: news outlets, social media, etc.

I feel so sorry for the family.

I think the case received more attention/interest than other missing persons cases because of the unique circumstances of her dissappearnce.

My heart goes out for her family too.

ianch99 21-02-2023 18:13

Re: Nicola Bulley disappearance: police find body in river
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36146459)
Yes, I expected you to be along to defend them. ;)
My view is not changed, as far as I'm concerned this has made this into a national media event, with their help, its no good complaining about it at this stage, is just a little too late. "There would have to be an overwhelming public interest argument to justify their continuing" - it seems to me there was one - 170,000 people disappear every year, and yet this was turned into a national story.

I feel that this is the essential point here. There are so many missing people and this one gets all this airtime, personal intrusion, etc. So wrong. Feels more like a Victorian freak show ...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 21:13.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum