Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Television (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=110)
-   -   life on mars (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=40701)

daz300 04-04-2007 21:37

Re: life on mars
 
Ashes To Ashes

LIFE On Mars may be ending as we know it but there’s good news for fans of the hit TV drama set in 1973.
BBC1 bosses today confirmed they are developing a spin-off show – also to be named after a David Bowie song – which could be filmed in Manchester next year.
Ashes To Ashes is set in the 1980s and is due to feature some cast members from the original show

link: http://blogs.manchestereveningnews.c...that_1981.html

Mal 04-04-2007 22:04

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daz300 (Post 34268240)
Ashes To Ashes

LIFE On Mars may be ending as we know it but there’s good news for fans of the hit TV drama set in 1973.
BBC1 bosses today confirmed they are developing a spin-off show – also to be named after a David Bowie song – which could be filmed in Manchester next year.
Ashes To Ashes is set in the 1980s and is due to feature some cast members from the original show

link: http://blogs.manchestereveningnews.c...that_1981.html

That article is from October 2006 ;) I wonder if there is anymore news on it...

Cobbydaler 04-04-2007 22:13

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal (Post 34268266)
That article is from October 2006 ;) I wonder if there is anymore news on it...

From the Wikipedia entry:

Quote:

In December 2006, it was reported that the BBC had commissioned a Life on Mars spin-off series, to be titled Ashes to Ashes... Julie Gardner confirmed that the spin-off was to be produced during an interview for BBC Radio Wales in March 2007

Mal 04-04-2007 22:44

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 34268273)
From the Wikipedia entry:

I was wondering if there was any more news, other than it is in the pipeline, like who is going to be in it, what is going to be like... :)

sir_drinks_alot 05-04-2007 01:06

Re: life on mars
 
Have you seen the trailer for the last episode ! wow it's going to be one hell Of a episode !

Halcyon 10-04-2007 01:01

Re: life on mars
 
Calling all Life On Mars fans.......

Get home early, Cancel anything already planned, and prepare for a night of quality TV......this is going to be one hell of an episode.
Let's hope it's a good one to end on !!!

Monday, 9:00pm BBC1 - FINAL EPISODE OF LIFE ON MARS

sir_drinks_alot 10-04-2007 09:19

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Halcyon (Post 34271379)

Monday, 9:00pm BBC1 - FINAL EPISODE OF LIFE ON MARS

Oh no i've only gone amd missed it shame it was not on tuesday @ 9 ;)

Chris 10-04-2007 09:39

Re: life on mars
 
It's about time we paid tribute to those little gems that helped make Life on Mars what it is - ladies and gentlemen, I invite you to post a list of your favourite Gene Huntisms. :D

My recent favourite:
As genuine as a tranny's fanny

And one for further discussion - do we think that 'this investigation is moving at the speed of a spastic in a magnet factory' was perhaps a leeeeeetle too close to the bone, even given the 1970s context?

orangebird 10-04-2007 09:47

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34271453)
It's about time we paid tribute to those little gems that helped make Life on Mars what it is - ladies and gentlemen, I invite you to post a list of your favourite Gene Huntisms. :D

My recent favourite:
As genuine as a tranny's fanny

And one for further discussion - do we think that 'this investigation is moving at the speed of a spastic in a magnet factory' was perhaps a leeeeeetle too close to the bone, even given the 1970s context?

You can't have it both ways - why is it funny to take the mickey out of transsexuals, but not spastics?

A lot of it is very close to the bone, but that's how it was in the 70's and I for one am glad that todays overwhelming PC directive hasn't affected a brilliant bit of television. :tu:

Chris 10-04-2007 09:57

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by orangebird (Post 34271457)
You can't have it both ways - why is it funny to take the mickey out of transsexuals, but not spastics?

A lot of it is very close to the bone, but that's how it was in the 70's and I for one am glad that todays overwhelming PC directive hasn't affected a brilliant bit of television. :tu:

A very good point. To what extent do we only laugh at the things we haven't been banned from laughing at?

I'm not sure they're quite the same in this case though. In the one case the metal leg braces are necessary medical intervention, in the other the surgery is elective ... however I don't want to get in to over-analyzing.

Another recent selection:
More fingers in pies than a leper on a cookery course
as nervous as a very small nun at a penguin shoot

orangebird 10-04-2007 10:00

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34271461)
<snip>
as nervous as a very small nun at a penguin shoot

Indeed - LMAO at that one. :D

Although, I'd never laughed so much as I did when they did the little 'Trumpton' style intro the other week. :rofl:

Cobbydaler 10-04-2007 10:12

Re: life on mars
 
'You are surrounded by armed b*stards!' :D

Agree on the intro...

'Listen, you. I can just about handle you, driving like a p*ssed-up crack-head, and treating women like bean-bags, but I'm going to say this once, and once only: stay out of Camberwick Green!' :)

Halcyon 10-04-2007 10:19

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sir_drinks_alot (Post 34271440)
Oh no i've only gone amd missed it shame it was not on tuesday @ 9 ;)

:dunce: I shouldn't be posting late at night...... TUESDAY it is.
Can't wait for tonight.

punky 10-04-2007 18:18

Re: life on mars
 
My fav:

"If I was worried as you, I wouldn't fart for ****ing myself"

Chris 10-04-2007 20:55

Re: life on mars
 
Tea is brewed, Easter egg is perched on the arm of the sofa ... here we go! :hyper:

peanut 10-04-2007 21:05

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34271453)
And one for further discussion - do we think that 'this investigation is moving at the speed of a spastic in a magnet factory' was perhaps a leeeeeetle too close to the bone, even given the 1970s context?

Take that as bad then you've conformed to the PC brigade. What was right in those day was right, you shouldn't or can't question them now. Just that fact you now think it's a little close to the bone and that you can't take it in context means just that. I say you because of the way you mentioned it 'leeeeetle', it was emphasized which 'could' mean you object.

In fact I'd rather be back in that era than the big bro, pc, lemming/sheep society of today.

"Blacks, they all look the same" sounds sooo bad today, but was soo right then, it just not out of context of those times.

Am I now a racist?? :rolleyes: lol.

The series was pure class and well done BBC for letting it go out on a high.

Chris 10-04-2007 21:59

Re: life on mars
 
Utter, utter, utter class. I challenge any American re-make to end as deliciously ambiguous as that did.

Russ 10-04-2007 21:59

Re: life on mars
 
What an anticlimax :(

MovedGoalPosts 10-04-2007 21:59

Re: life on mars
 
Absolutely excellent, but I suspect my head hurts more than Sam Tyler's now :erm:

Chris 10-04-2007 22:01

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ B (Post 34272074)
What an anticlimax :(

You have got to be kidding! This was a piece of classic TV, and you were there to see it! We'll be arguing about what the ending meant in the pub for decades!

Russ 10-04-2007 22:04

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34272078)
You have got to be kidding! This was a piece of classic TV, and you were there to see it! We'll be arguing about what the ending meant in the pub for decades!

And what's the point of that? Why not give us an ending which would really have thrown the cat amongst the pigeons by getting the modern-day Tyler meeting up with his aged 70's colleagues?

homealone 10-04-2007 22:06

Re: life on mars
 
brilliant, loved it, the series has been a class above - and they all live happily ever after ;)

yaypandas 10-04-2007 22:07

Re: life on mars
 
they should have ended the series when he jumped off the roof, the ending was tacky.

SMG 10-04-2007 22:08

Re: life on mars
 
Just about to settle down & watch it. (Recorded it). The one liners are brilliant, the "tyranny's fanny" one was superb. There was one about "As much use as Liberace`s cock" something or other, wish I could remember it, laughed my ar*e off.

Nugget 10-04-2007 22:10

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by homealone (Post 34272083)
brilliant, loved it, the series has been a class above - and they all live happily ever after ;)

Well, apart from Ray, whose new missus turns out to be a raging feminist, and rips his danglers off after about 5 minutes :D

Top class TV - absolute classic. I loved the bit at the end:

Sam: You shouldn't be driving.
Gene: Well, I am... (you just know he's thinking 'sod off, you nancy' :D )

---------- Post added at 22:10 ---------- Previous post was at 22:09 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by yaypandas (Post 34272085)
they should have ended the series when he jumped off the roof, the ending was tacky.

But that would have left us with even more questions. No way was that tacky - by leaving it ambiguous, it actually makes us think about it. Bit of a shock for this day and age...

daz300 10-04-2007 22:10

Re: life on mars
 
100% class

Gene Hunt: Anything happens to this motor, I'll come 'round your houses and stamp on all your toys. Got it? Good kids.
they are all here : http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Life_on_Mars

daz300

Stephen 10-04-2007 22:15

Re: life on mars
 
WTF???

So is he back in a coma after jumping off the roof then?

or when he walked to the light did he even wake up in 2006/7??

I had read that the writers said they would give it a clear cut ending so that they could not make a new series. All they did was drive off. That clearly leaves it open for more??

My head hurts after watching that!

iadom 10-04-2007 22:18

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DarthYoda (Post 34272102)

That clearly leaves it open for more??

Nowt wrong with that, :cool:

Jim.

Saaf_laandon_mo 10-04-2007 22:19

Re: life on mars
 
Well I hope he never goes back to the present time, and i doubly I hope we have a new totally un-PC cop show with those 5.

Chris 10-04-2007 22:22

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ B (Post 34272080)
And what's the point of that? Why not give us an ending which would really have thrown the cat amongst the pigeons by getting the modern-day Tyler meeting up with his aged 70's colleagues?

That wouldn't have thrown any cats anywhere. Virtually everyone has worked through that scenario in their heads or in forum threads like this one almost since the first series started. It would hardly have been an original ending.

They have ended it in such a way that it is going to be *extremely* difficult to explain it without leaving any loose ends. Honest, this is a classic. I predict the 'Life on Mars question' will become a modern TV phenomenon.

My thinking so far hinges on the DCI/Surgeon. Who was more believable as a 'real' person? DCI Frank Morgan or Mr Frank Morgan?

Stephen 10-04-2007 22:24

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iadom (Post 34272109)
Nowt wrong with that, :cool:

Jim.

I never said there was.

However the creater had said the ending would mean there was no chance of it returning!

peanut 10-04-2007 22:25

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DarthYoda (Post 34272120)
I never said there was.

However the creater had said the ending would mean there was no chance of it returning!

Take the 'what if' sci fi element out if it as that's now over and what have you left, the 'Sweeney', and that's already been done.

MovedGoalPosts 10-04-2007 22:27

Re: life on mars
 
It would be very difficult for it to return as we now know the one of tow possibilities for the conundrum as to why he was there. Which you choose to believe is up to you. He was in a coma, and has jumped back into it, or he had amnesia, and was dreaming of the future. Neither needs further explanation.

Russ 10-04-2007 22:27

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34272117)
That wouldn't have thrown any cats anywhere. Virtually everyone has worked through that scenario in their heads or in forum threads like this one almost since the first series started. It would hardly have been an original ending.

It might not have been an original ending but it would have left more questions and imagination. And as for being extremely difficult to explain, bringing someone from deep within Tyler's mind in to reality, wouldn't that be difficult to explain, instead of "oh, he's back in another coma"?

peanut 10-04-2007 22:30

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob (Post 34272124)
It would be very difficult for it to return as we now know the one of tow possibilities for the conundrum as to why he was there. Which you choose to believe is up to you. He was in a coma, and has jumped back into it, or he had amnesia, and was dreaming of the future. Neither needs further explanation.

Dreaming of the future? He must be a prophet if that was the case then. Explain Robocop et al.

Chris 10-04-2007 22:34

Re: life on mars
 
A tidbit lifted from a forum Mrs T frequents:

Quote:

Frank Morgan played the Wizard of Oz in the 1939 film. Gene has nicknamed Sam 'Dorothy' before now... And someone else has already mentioned that Ray needs a heart, Chris needs a brain, Annie needs courage and Sam needs to get home.
:spin:

peanut 10-04-2007 22:36

Re: life on mars
 
Hence he called him 'Dorethy' in the last episode.

Chris 10-04-2007 22:36

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanutkp (Post 34272127)
Dreaming of the future? He must be a prophet if that was the case then. Explain Robocop et al.

This is sci fi. Take your pick from 1,001 possible solutions, or invent your own and make it 1,002. :D

homealone 10-04-2007 22:36

Re: life on mars
 
the key word was enigmatic ;), in my opinion :)

peanut 10-04-2007 22:37

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34272136)
This is sci fi. Take your pick from 1,001 possible solutions, or invent your own and make it 1,002. :D

Not the 'One of Two' possibilities then as quoted, lol.

Chris 10-04-2007 22:42

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanutkp (Post 34272138)
Not the 'One of Two' possibilities then as quoted, lol.

Definitely not. Another lift from another forum thread:

Was the testcard girl switching off Sam's life at the very end?

peanut 10-04-2007 22:44

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34272142)
Definitely not. Another lift from another forum thread:

Was the testcard girl switching off Sam's life at the very end?

Exactly, I was only answering Rob's post as in what he said was flawed.

SMG 10-04-2007 23:34

Re: life on mars
 
Thought it was a good ending, it clearly left it open for a "new" series. Perhaps a spin off with Sam & the Gene policing old Salford. If the writers have any sense that is.

Mal 10-04-2007 23:37

Re: life on mars
 
Now with the possibility of a sequel, Ashes to Ashes, featuring Gene Hunt, it's going to be a major story line to get a figment of Sam's imagination (yes, that's the way that I have took it ;) ) to go off on his own, without Sam. Can someone go off and do there own thing, in Sam's brain?

homealone 10-04-2007 23:39

Re: life on mars
 
end it now, imo, it has had an huge impact, please let us not lose that edge ;)

Cobbydaler 10-04-2007 23:53

Re: life on mars
 
Ashes to Ashes is definitely happening. Ashley Pharoah said on Radio 5 this afternoon that shooting was starting later this year...

Mal 10-04-2007 23:56

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 34272201)
Ashes to Ashes is definitely happening. Ashley Pharoah said on Radio 5 this afternoon that shooting was starting later this year...

I heard that Gene goes off to London. I don't know if that is right or not, but how???

Chris 11-04-2007 00:05

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal (Post 34272203)
I heard that Gene goes off to London. I don't know if that is right or not, but how???

Do us all a favour and get a copy of the Manchester Evening News tomorrow - apparently they have an exclusive interview.

http://blogs.manchestereveningnews.c..._to_ashes.html

Tezcatlipoca 11-04-2007 02:48

Re: life on mars
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/6542633.stm

"Life on Mars sequel jumps to '80s"

Quote:

A sequel to TV drama Life on Mars is to be made with the action moving to the 1980s, it has been confirmed.

The announcement was made as the second and final series of Life on Mars - in which a modern police officer was trapped in 1973 - came to an end.

The sequel, Ashes to Ashes, will see Philip Glenister return as DCI Gene Hunt - but this time in London in 1981.

He will be joined by a female detective from the 21st Century who is stuck in the past after an accident.

(snip)

Jane Featherstone, executive producer for TV production company Kudos, said the search was on for DCI Hunt's new "sexy sidekick".

"It's a touch of Moonlighting teamed with a measure of Miami Vice," she said.


:confused: :rolleyes:

Maggy 11-04-2007 02:52

Re: life on mars
 
Nice that for once a series is not allowed to drag on and on and finishes on a high and gets people thinking.:tu:

Reminds me of The Prisoner in that respect.Short,well written episodes and series that finished ambiguously and everyone was discussing it down the pub for days...if not decades later. :)

sir_drinks_alot 11-04-2007 09:29

Re: life on mars
 
Why can't thay just leave it alone :cry5:

Cobbydaler 11-04-2007 10:40

Re: life on mars
 
The Answers...

Supposedly ;)

sherer 11-04-2007 10:59

Re: life on mars
 
have to say the more I hear about Ashes to Ashes the less I like it.. again it's someone in the present going into a coma and ten going back in time

it's too similar to LOM and will end up being like a rubbish sequel.. why not just use Gene Hunt and all the others and then put them in the 80s and leave it at that

banjo 11-04-2007 11:45

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 34272342)
The Answers...

Supposedly ;)


Thanks for that link :) I was and still am a little bemused, brilliant show, wish Sam hadn't gone out the way he did.

Halcyon 11-04-2007 11:50

Re: life on mars
 
Absolutely Briliant !!! 100% Quality !

This was one of the best TV series in history !!!
The ending was amazing.
I kept on wondering when it was going to end. Especially with the music coming in several times, I thought that was it.
eg. When he saw the light in the tunnel, when he was walking around in the present, or when he jumped off the roof.
It just kept on going on and on and I was really happy when he came back to 1973 again.


Quote:

Originally Posted by yaypandas (Post 34272085)
they should have ended the series when he jumped off the roof, the ending was tacky.

I have to disagree. Too many TV shows end in this mystery style where you never find out an ending or have to work it out yourself. Here, there was a conclusion.

I'm really glad that Sam and Annie got together in the end. It was about time they kissed.

A few little things that I wondered about....

Why did Sam not tell Morgan about Ipod's and Mobile phones, Computers, when trying to tell him he was from the future....Had he forgotten about these things ?
If he is now back in 1973, what happens to his thoughts about the modern world.
A few episodes back he persuaded the girl to keep the baby who once born and grown up becomes a police officer and dates Sam.
By the time she is old enough, Sam will be much older so who will it be that she will be dating ? Is there another Sam Tyler ?
Or will this have changed history and they will no longer meet.


Overall, excellent TV !!! I loved it.

Horace 11-04-2007 11:58

Re: life on mars
 
I'm optimistic for Ashes to Ashes, Gene Hunt is a great character and can easily carry a series.
I loved the ended of LOM although I was shocked at first and couldn't really get my head around it..but it makes sense and as the article Cobbydaler linked to states, Sam living back in 2007 back to the boring drudge of modern day police work seemed very out of place considering what the character had gone through, a very unorthodox ending and something Hollywood would never have had the balls to do. The testcard girl at the end was pure genius.

I really hope this series is recognised by BAFTA. I hardly watch regular TV apart from catching the news but I've had a weekly appointment with BBC1 for every episode. Something I haven't done for a very long time.

sir_drinks_alot 11-04-2007 12:22

Re: life on mars
 
The one thing i will miss more than anything els is that beautiful beautiful Ford Cortina it was so much a part of the show :(



RIP cortina we we hardly knew thy :(

http://www.americancarsuk.com/Previo...naDSCF0015.jpg

Cobbydaler 11-04-2007 12:49

Re: life on mars
 
He's going to have an original Audi Quattro in Ashes to Ashes.... :)

Chris 11-04-2007 13:28

Re: life on mars
 
According to the lead writer, as interviewed by the Manchester Evening News:

1. Sam really was in a coma. He really did wake up. Then he committed suicide.
2. His return to 1973 occurs during the last couple of minutes of his real life, which is in 2006. However as it's a dream or coma state, who's to say how many years Sam may have back in the 1970s before he actually dies? The implication is he might live a lifetime in those moments.
3. The testcard girl was only supposed to symbolise 'the end', as in the end of Life on Mars, nothing more subtle than that.
4. The female DCI who is to appear in Ashes to Ashes is a psych profiler who has read the report Sam gave on his return to work in 2006 (we saw him briefly with a dictaphone right near the end) - including all he had to say about Gene Hunt. She is going to have an accident and end up in 1981 working with ... Gene Hunt. The new series will explore in more detail exactly who, or what, Gene is and what he symbolises.

Halcyon 11-04-2007 14:35

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Horace (Post 34272413)
I really hope this series is recognised by BAFTA.



"John Simm" - Nominated for Best Actor.

"Life On Mars" - Nominated for Best Drama

"Life On Mars" - Nominated for Audience Award.

Horace 12-04-2007 18:19

Re: life on mars
 
I already know about the nominations, I meant win one :p.

Halcyon 12-04-2007 19:03

Re: life on mars
 
Yeah, let's hope it is recognised for the quality Tv that it is and for the great acting talent. :tu:

sir_drinks_alot 12-04-2007 21:34

Re: life on mars
 
This really has been one of the best tv show's of the last 20 years if only thay made more show's that are as good as this !

Chris 12-04-2007 22:19

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sir_drinks_alot (Post 34273944)
This really has been one of the best tv show's of the last 20 years if only thay made more show's that are as good as this !

Well, there is every reason to hope that the next series is going to be as good. The fact that they have been willing to take the format to a different city and a different decade (and give it a new title) while keeping the same basic premise at the core, is a good sign. If they had reneged on their promise not to do a third series of Life on Mars I'd have been worried, it would just have gone on and on and got wierd like Quantum Leap did.

cimt 15-04-2007 01:43

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34274011)
Well, there is every reason to hope that the next series is going to be as good. The fact that they have been willing to take the format to a different city and a different decade (and give it a new title) while keeping the same basic premise at the core, is a good sign. If they had reneged on their promise not to do a third series of Life on Mars I'd have been worried, it would just have gone on and on and got wierd like Quantum Leap did.

Beware, the Americans are killing off Life on Mars by making their own version, only it's based in 1972, not 1973. Are they deffo's making a series 3? Coz the ending of series 2 makes it look like there's gunna be more series'. Also on the BBC website it said it wouldn't be the last of Sam Tyler, is that an indication for a new series?

Mal 15-04-2007 01:50

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cimt (Post 34275652)
Beware, the Americans are killing off Life on Mars by making their own version, only it's based in 1972, not 1973. Are they deffo's making a series 3? Coz the ending of series 2 makes it look like there's gunna be more series'. Also on the BBC website it said it wouldn't be the last of Sam Tyler, is that an indication for a new series?

I don't see why the Americans doing a remake would kill off Life on Mars, but according to the IMDB, production has been put on hold, for whatever reason.

According to the blogs, linked to earlier in this thread, there isn't going to be 3rd series, but a spin off, not involving Sam Tyler. Have a look in this thread for other links.

cimt 15-04-2007 02:06

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal (Post 34275653)
I don't see why the Americans doing a remake would kill off Life on Mars, but according to the IMDB, production has been put on hold, for whatever reason.

According to the blogs, linked to earlier in this thread, there isn't going to be 3rd series, but a spin off, not involving Sam Tyler. Have a look in this thread for other links.

Well there's no need for them to remake it is there? Apparantly the actors who played Sam and Hunt got asked to starr in it, but they said no.

Chris 15-04-2007 14:47

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cimt (Post 34275652)
Beware, the Americans are killing off Life on Mars by making their own version, only it's based in 1972, not 1973. Are they deffo's making a series 3? Coz the ending of series 2 makes it look like there's gunna be more series'. Also on the BBC website it said it wouldn't be the last of Sam Tyler, is that an indication for a new series?

The US TV audience is notoriously less accepting of 'foreign' TV than we are over here. It is therefore quite common for production companies to sell the idea to the Yanks rather than the programme itself. In some cases I think it's a real shame, but in the case of Life on Mars, what enjoyment would a general US audience get out of the backdrop being 1970s Manchester? It doesn't mean anything to them.

Their TV tradition is very rich in this area, they have Kojak, Colombo, Starsky and Hutch ... they have more than enough 70s cop cliches to draw on without having to make do with ours.

And seeing as all those shows travelled over here much more readily than the likes of The Professionals did over there, I think ironically a British audience would probably warm to an American remake. I'd quite like to see it, anyway, if it ever gets made!

cimt 15-04-2007 16:27

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34275918)
The US TV audience is notoriously less accepting of 'foreign' TV than we are over here. It is therefore quite common for production companies to sell the idea to the Yanks rather than the programme itself. In some cases I think it's a real shame, but in the case of Life on Mars, what enjoyment would a general US audience get out of the backdrop being 1970s Manchester? It doesn't mean anything to them.

Their TV tradition is very rich in this area, they have Kojak, Colombo, Starsky and Hutch ... they have more than enough 70s cop cliches to draw on without having to make do with ours.

And seeing as all those shows travelled over here much more readily than the likes of The Professionals did over there, I think ironically a British audience would probably warm to an American remake. I'd quite like to see it, anyway, if it ever gets made!

Ah ok, I see why now then. I'm sure it can't be as good as the UK version? :erm:

Damien 16-04-2007 12:29

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cimt (Post 34275957)
Ah ok, I see why now then. I'm sure it can't be as good as the UK version? :erm:

America makes very good TV. I imagine it would be quite good but different to our version. Just like The Office became a different program in America after the first season

Chris 16-04-2007 13:00

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34276550)
America makes very good TV. I imagine it would be quite good but different to our version. Just like The Office became a different program in America after the first season

They also make some awful rubbish. In the late 80s, they bought the outlines to an excellent British black comedy called Dear John. They completely missed the point. Likewise when they re-made Men Behaving Badly and One Foot in the Grave. They just don't understand how we can find filth and tragedy hilarious. It doesn't compute, and what comes out the other end can, from a British point of view, appear sanitized and dull.

By that measure, The American Office should have been a disaster as well, but the one episode I got round to watching was actually ok ...

TheDaddy 16-04-2007 13:09

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34276586)
They also make some awful rubbish. In the late 80s, they bought the outlines to an excellent British black comedy called Dear John. They completely missed the point. Likewise when they re-made Men Behaving Badly and One Foot in the Grave. They just don't understand how we can find filth and tragedy hilarious. It doesn't compute, and what comes out the other end can, from a British point of view, appear sanitized and dull.

By that measure, The American Office should have been a disaster as well, but the one episode I got round to watching was actually ok ...

You are right Dear John was hilarious and they ruined it, I haven't seen the US equivalent of the others so can't comment

sherer 16-04-2007 13:10

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34276586)
They also make some awful rubbish. In the late 80s, they bought the outlines to an excellent British black comedy called Dear John. They completely missed the point. Likewise when they re-made Men Behaving Badly and One Foot in the Grave. They just don't understand how we can find filth and tragedy hilarious. It doesn't compute, and what comes out the other end can, from a British point of view, appear sanitized and dull.

By that measure, The American Office should have been a disaster as well, but the one episode I got round to watching was actually ok ...

well don't forget with the amount of channels they have out there they are bound to produce a lot of rubbish.. mind you Celeb Love Island, Celeb Wrestling we have just as much rubbish as they do

American's make TV for American's and so not having their upbringing and culture it is bound to be a bit hit and miss on us

Damien 16-04-2007 22:31

Re: life on mars
 
They have done really well in recent years though. So many decent dramas and comedys from the States now.

Chris 16-04-2007 22:35

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34277169)
They have done really well in recent years though. So many decent dramas and comedys from the States now.

And so many more that you don't see, and won't ever see unless you go over there and have the misfortune to be stuck in a hotel room for a couple of nights with nothing to do ... thank goodness. Believe me, you shouldn't judge the overall quality of US TV by the extremely small sample you see over here on Sky etc. It is the cream of the crop and not at all representative.

Damien 16-04-2007 23:08

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris T (Post 34277175)
And so many more that you don't see, and won't ever see unless you go over there and have the misfortune to be stuck in a hotel room for a couple of nights with nothing to do ... thank goodness. Believe me, you shouldn't judge the overall quality of US TV by the extremely small sample you see over here on Sky etc. It is the cream of the crop and not at all representative.

Well I also aquire a few that dont come over here such as the Wire ;)

Anyway same could be said of TV here. At the moment we have Doctor Who, Peep Show and a few others but how often do we have good programs on the TV here that is British and not a reality show or a 'haha your all gonna die poor and alone!!!' type programs.

Halcyon 17-04-2007 10:42

Re: life on mars
 
Other TV series from the same company as "Life On Mars" have been quality birish TV..............eg. Spooks and Hustle

Damien 19-04-2007 22:40

Re: life on mars
 
It seems the Ashes to Ashes is so close to Life On Mars that maybe they wanted to continue it but John Simm did not so they needed to find a new way to carry on. I not sure how it willl work with a female and Gene Hunt.

Cobbydaler 19-04-2007 22:47

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34279672)
It seems the Ashes to Ashes is so close to Life On Mars that maybe they wanted to continue it but John Simm did not so they needed to find a new way to carry on. I not sure how it willl work with a female and Gene Hunt.

If the writers have any talent it should be brilliant...

His sexist 70s/80s attitudes vs a 21st century woman!

TheDaddy 19-04-2007 22:51

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 34279678)
If the writers have any talent it should be brilliant...

His sexist 70s/80s attitudes vs a 21st century woman!

Wonder how he'll cope with Thatcherism, I think he'll like her

alferret 22-04-2007 19:51

Re: life on mars
 
I have just got to the end of L-O-M. It is without doubt the best TV series I have had the privelage to watch in many, many years. It almost makes the license fee acceptable.

I will be going back to it to watch it again, to see all the twists and turns missed first time around.

Looking forward to Ashes to Ashes :)

TheDaddy 18-05-2008 22:30

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34276550)
America makes very good TV. I imagine it would be quite good but different to our version. Just like The Office became a different program in America after the first season

Here is your chance to find out, it don't look good from what I read but the trailer is so so imo

http://www.darkhorizons.com/news08/080516a.php

cimt 18-05-2008 22:40

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34555087)
Here is your chance to find out, it don't look good from what I read but the trailer is so so imo

http://www.darkhorizons.com/news08/080516a.php

It looks like it'll be crap... The fact that the 2 main characters are Irish is stupid. I'm sure there was an American who would of suited Sam or Gene? Let's hope I'm wrong.

SMHarman 19-05-2008 18:34

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cimt (Post 34555096)
It looks like it'll be crap... The fact that the 2 main characters are Irish is stupid. I'm sure there was an American who would of suited Sam or Gene? Let's hope I'm wrong.

I'll caveat this with the fact that I can't see the trailer but being as much of the law enforcement in many cities of the US is Irish immigrant decendancy it kinda makes sense.

Marge 19-05-2008 18:40

Re: life on mars
 
Where's the real Gene Hunt and the cortinas :eek: What about the copshop aka Stopford House in Stockport, nah can't see it being a hit :erm:

Maggy 19-05-2008 19:07

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman (Post 34555621)
I'll caveat this with the fact that I can't see the trailer but being as much of the law enforcement in many cities of the US is Irish immigrant decendancy it kinda makes sense.


Yes but it will make a nonsense of the IRA episode...;)

SMHarman 19-05-2008 20:24

Re: life on mars
 
Surely all the scripts will be rewritten around events in US policing history, not UK! It's not Red Dwarf style scifi where it is fantasy future.

Maggy 19-05-2008 23:22

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SMHarman (Post 34555739)
Surely all the scripts will be rewritten around events in US policing history, not UK! It's not Red Dwarf style scifi where it is fantasy future.

Yeah I suppose so...but I doubt it's going to have anything like the same impact..There wasn't a lot of terrorism in the US during the 70's.

Cobbydaler 20-05-2008 00:06

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Incognitas (Post 34555910)
Yeah I suppose so...but I doubt it's going to have anything like the same impact..There wasn't a lot of terrorism in the US during the 70's.

Perhaps there'll be a Weatherman link...

Maggy 20-05-2008 15:51

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 34555939)
Perhaps there'll be a Weatherman link...

Yeah but most of their activities were not against 'civilians' unlike the IRA campaigns and as a consequence the level of anger as shown by Gene Hunt may not ring as true..but what do I know? Could be it will be brilliant just like all the other US crossovers such as Ab Fab,Till Death Do Us Part,Steptoe and Son.

Personally I think that if a US audience can't accept the original then you might as well forget it.How can we constantly take what is good on our screens and try and change it to fit other tastes and still have it work as well as the original?

I know there are lots of Americans who get the originals.There are fans in the US of such shows as Red Dwarf,Blackadder and Ab Fab in their original British humour.There is no need to alter anything to fit a perceived American mentality.

If we can accept American shows like Frasier then I'm sure they can accept ours.

Chris 21-05-2008 09:41

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Incognitas (Post 34556273)
Yeah but most of their activities were not against 'civilians' unlike the IRA campaigns and as a consequence the level of anger as shown by Gene Hunt may not ring as true..but what do I know? Could be it will be brilliant just like all the other US crossovers such as Ab Fab,Till Death Do Us Part,Steptoe and Son.

Personally I think that if a US audience can't accept the original then you might as well forget it.How can we constantly take what is good on our screens and try and change it to fit other tastes and still have it work as well as the original?

I know there are lots of Americans who get the originals.There are fans in the US of such shows as Red Dwarf,Blackadder and Ab Fab in their original British humour.There is no need to alter anything to fit a perceived American mentality.

If we can accept American shows like Frasier then I'm sure they can accept ours.

Your average American is far less accommodating of cultural diversity, which is sad considering how culturally diverse they are as a nation within themselves. They tend to have quite narrow tastes when it comes to TV.

I don't think it matters too much, because it means we can sell our telly to them twice - once to the minor networks who buy it 'as made', and again to the more major networks who buy the concept and re-make it.

The only thinf that niggles me is that most Americans watching such a re-make have any idea that the show originated outside the US, thus reinforcing their notion that they are the only ones making decent TV.

mouqeet 21-05-2008 16:58

Re: life on mars
 
must be fun ;)

cimt 20-06-2008 01:49

Re: life on mars
 
:sleep: A badly acted pilot. The actors just don't suit the roles... Also, some of the settings look very fake. I can't see it being a ratings winner like the UK version... :rolleyes:

kangaroosterrier 01-07-2008 03:16

Re: life on mars
 
Bought the first season of the UK version last week and only just finished episode 8. I feel it was a marvelous ending to the story, better than what most anyone following the series could have imagined. Not sure I would want to see the second season though... The ending to the first season being as good as it was. Am I wrong? How does season 2 compare to the first?
Would like to see Ashes To Ashes though, feel it should work.

Chris 01-07-2008 13:31

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kangaroosterrier (Post 34588624)
Bought the first season of the UK version last week and only just finished episode 8. I feel it was a marvelous ending to the story, better than what most anyone following the series could have imagined. Not sure I would want to see the second season though... The ending to the first season being as good as it was. Am I wrong? How does season 2 compare to the first?
Would like to see Ashes To Ashes though, feel it should work.

Ashes to Ashes certainly isn't disappointing, although the interplay between Gene Hunt and our new time traveller, Alex Drake, is quite different to that between Hunt and Sam Tyler, which makes for a somewhat different TV show, so just because you like one doesn't mean you'll like the other - it would depend what you really liked about Life on Mars.

All in all I really enjoyed it though. They made a lot out of the fact that Alex Drake, who is a police psychologist, had read Sam's report into his 1970s adventures and so believes she knows exactly what's going on. She treats her experience in a totally different way to him, which is refreshing because it means they avoid simply re-treading Life on Mars.

I'd say go ahead and get it.

kangaroosterrier 02-07-2008 11:01

Re: life on mars
 
I enjoyed the juxtaposition between old and new policing methods, the music, how they had the older Sam's involvement influence his father leaving the younger Sam and his mother 33 years earlier, and the fact that I knew none of the actors.

Ashes To Ashes is not yet available on DVD here in SA, but soon as it is I'll be biting--sink my bicuspids into the spin-off...

Am still interested in knowing how season 2 of Life On Mars compares to the first. I don't want to watch it and feel it took something away from the impact of the first season.

Stephen 02-07-2008 11:13

Re: life on mars
 
Season 2 adds a lot to the overall story and explores Sam Tyler in more depth especially as he is still trying to work out what is going on and it is totally worth watching.

Derek 02-07-2008 11:30

Re: life on mars
 
And the overall ending to the show is superb.

cimt 02-07-2008 11:36

Re: life on mars
 
Has anyone watched the US pilot yet then?

kangaroosterrier 02-07-2008 12:31

Re: life on mars
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 34589862)
Season 2 adds a lot to the overall story and explores Sam Tyler in more depth especially as he is still trying to work out what is going on and it is totally worth watching.

Thanks, will get season 2 then while I wait for Ashes To Ashes to come out on DVD.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:58.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum