Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   UPDATED: British Prosecutors: 2 Russian Nationals Identified as Novichok Suspects. (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33706119)

1andrew1 21-03-2018 22:13

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 35941455)
But Trump's already congratulated Putin even when told not to.

Agreed. They should both up their games. Not sure Boris's approach is working though, bringing Hitler into the occasion is a tad extreme and will unite Russians behind Putin.

TheDaddy 22-03-2018 02:17

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35941000)
Your talking scale i was talking about personality type and while thankfully it's highly unlikely Putin will get to the scale of stalin he is very much a similar personality and is dragging down a great nation full of good people. I genuinely do worry about what he will do if he feels threatened internally and thinks he may lose his position as I'm sure there are many horrific things that will come out when he's gone.

When it's on his scale it's hard to see beyond anything else, with good reason.

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 35941456)
Agreed. They should both up their games. Not sure Boris's approach is working though, bringing Hitler into the occasion is a tad extreme and will unite Russians behind Putin.

Very poor analogy to have used imo and can only impact our cause negatively on a number of levels

Carth 22-03-2018 15:31

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
I'm sure if I used a Hitler analogy in a meeting at work I'd be in big trouble, possibly even sacked.

denphone 22-03-2018 15:38

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 35941456)
Agreed. They should both up their games. Not sure Boris's approach is working though, bringing Hitler into the occasion is a tad extreme and will unite Russians behind Putin.

Indeed there is no comparison between the two as although what Russia has done is reprehensible and indefensible it bears absolutely no comparison on what Adolf Hitler was guilty of.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler

OLD BOY 22-03-2018 19:11

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 35940955)
Stalin was responsible for the deaths of up to 50 million people and exiled entire ethnic groups to gulags in Siberia, Putin has many faults and has committed many horrific crimes I'm sure but the two aren't in the same league, they're not even playing the same game and imo to say different is pure sensationalism that detracts from actually holding Putin to account

Putin hasn't finished ruling Russia just yet - plenty of time to match that score. Hopefully, the media spotlight, sanctions and some ingenious politics will keep him more contained than Stalin was.

It's too early to judge Putin on just how murderous he might be. Just wait until he gets old and grumpy. :erm:

RizzyKing 22-03-2018 20:41

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
It's important to understand what is happening within Russia state media daily puts out ridiculous stories of the west acting aggressively towards Russia and actively working to bring Russia down. History is being sanitised the gulags being a prime example and gulag type camps being promoted as a solution to the problems within Russia which basically includes anyone that doesn't support Putin. Putin is working very hard in creating a bunker mentality on a national scale and whipping up hatred of the west and there is no longer any media to question or contradict the state media. The increase in accidents and trumped up charges against political opponents is extremely worryingly and wider closing down of freedoms of the Russian people is also a cause of concern.

As of now the majority of Russians are not buying into it but under a constant barrage of propaganda and the increasing fear of questioning Putin it's not hard to see how many will eventually buckle under the pressure. We in the west need to make better efforts at putting our side of the story out there and truthfully report events involving Russia that is never told within Russia and we definately have to up our game on social media as right now the Russians are running rings round the west.

jonbxx 23-03-2018 08:53

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 35941456)
Agreed. They should both up their games. Not sure Boris's approach is working though, bringing Hitler into the occasion is a tad extreme and will unite Russians behind Putin.

Agreed. The Second World War had a cataclysmic effect on the Soviet Union. Estimates vary but most are agreed that over 20,000,000 died during WWII or in other words, over 13% of the population. The collective folk memory of WWII is still very raw in Russia. In contrast, the UK lost just over 450,000 people or less than 1%.

To compare any Russian to Hitler is either deeply provocative or ignorant of history. Either way, the anger will be very strong

OLD BOY 23-03-2018 09:57

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jonbxx (Post 35941579)
Agreed. The Second World War had a cataclysmic effect on the Soviet Union. Estimates vary but most are agreed that over 20,000,000 died during WWII or in other words, over 13% of the population. The collective folk memory of WWII is still very raw in Russia. In contrast, the UK lost just over 450,000 people or less than 1%.

To compare any Russian to Hitler is either deeply provocative or ignorant of history. Either way, the anger will be very strong

As is our anger regarding the attempted murder of two of our citizens.

RizzyKing 23-03-2018 16:25

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Boris needs to learn to think before he opens that trap of his rather then prove the old adage of keeping silent and let people think your an idiot rather then talking and confirm it, how much longer May is going to let the buffoon carry on in a job he is clearly not suited for is anyone's guess shame the royal court did away with jesters boris would be perfect for that.

1andrew1 23-03-2018 17:33

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35941622)
Boris needs to learn to think before he opens that trap of his rather then prove the old adage of keeping silent and let people think your an idiot rather then talking and confirm it, how much longer May is going to let the buffoon carry on in a job he is clearly not suited for is anyone's guess shame the royal court did away with jesters boris would be perfect for that.

Nicely put. :)

heero_yuy 23-03-2018 17:52

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
I wonder if there's a version of Godwin's Law for foreign secretaries that prattle on for too long?

pip08456 23-03-2018 17:58

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35941633)
I wonder if there's a version of Godwin's Law for foreign secretaries that prattle on for too long?

If there isn't there should be.

Mick 26-03-2018 14:28

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
BREAKING: U.S President Donald Trump expels 60 Russian diplomats in a coordinated worldwide response to the Nerve Attack in Salisbury. France, Germany, Netherlands, Latvia, Poland and others have announced expulsions of Russian diplomats.

https://news.sky.com/story/live-trum...oning-11304952

---------- Post added at 14:28 ---------- Previous post was at 14:21 ----------

Trump has also ordered the closure of the Russian Consulate in Seattle.

Damien 26-03-2018 14:47

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35941839)
BREAKING: U.S President Donald Trump expels 60 Russian diplomats in a coordinated worldwide response to the Nerve Attack in Salisbury. France, Germany, Netherlands, Latvia, Poland and others have announced expulsions of Russian diplomats.

https://news.sky.com/story/live-trum...oning-11304952

---------- Post added at 14:28 ---------- Previous post was at 14:21 ----------

Trump has also ordered the closure of the Russian Consulate in Seattle.

Good.

I don't Russia expected such a united response from the West. They assumed the US and Europe wouldn't want to get involved.

Mick 26-03-2018 15:32

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
The message being conveyed: ‘The World stands United with Great Britain.’

Canada to expel Russians, who they have identified as Russian Intelligence officials who have interfered in Canada elections.

---------- Post added at 15:32 ---------- Previous post was at 14:52 ----------

Latest from Kremlin: Spokesman from Kremlin says President Putin will make a Final Response to all the Russian expulsions currently happening around the World...

Damien 26-03-2018 15:40

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Credit to May for the Diplomatic achievement as well as Trump and all for following though.

Carth 26-03-2018 15:42

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35941843)
The message being conveyed: ‘The World stands United with Great Britain.’

Let me correct that for you Mick ;)

The message being conveyed: 'The worlds economies are in deep doo doo, we need a confrontation with a major power to get our industries back on track . . and reduce the population to manageable levels once again. War with Korea may take things a little too far, but a good old fashioned scrap with Russia will be ok.'

:D :D

Mick 26-03-2018 16:15

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
The Russians come out with a lot of bullshit.... Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman has just said:

"This is a provocative gesture"

and also remarks, "UK is trying to use Brexit to whip up support of solidarity with the EU."

---------- Post added at 16:15 ---------- Previous post was at 15:48 ----------

So far.... 100 Russian diplomats expelled from 18 countries across the world. The largest collective expulsion of Russian intelligence officers in history.

Hugh 26-03-2018 16:29

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35941847)
Let me correct that for you Mick ;)

The message being conveyed: 'The worlds economies are in deep doo doo, we need a confrontation with a major power to get our industries back on track . . and reduce the population to manageable levels once again. War with Korea may take things a little too far, but a good old fashioned scrap with Russia will be ok.'

:D :D

Your grasp of geopolitics is "interesting"...

So, you think that the major western posers are more likely (in your mind) to have a war with the 3rd most (in armed forces terms, but 2nd in Nuclear weapons, including 1600 ICBMs) powerful country in the world, than a bankrupt starving country that has a handful of nukes?

As I said, "interesting" :erm:

Carth 26-03-2018 16:44

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Oh I certainly have a different view than most Hugh :)

I ask myself which is most likely to hit the big red button . . Putin or Kim Sun Ying Tang Po (or whatever his name is) :D

OLD BOY 26-03-2018 18:48

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35941846)
Credit to May for the Diplomatic achievement as well as Trump and all for following though.

I agree, Theresa May has come a long way from a few months ago when the EU cold shouldered her very rudely.

I think we should build on this not only with more financial restrictions to hurt Russia, but also with a message that we would much prefer to be friends with Russia, and when they are ready to talk about being more responsible members of the world community, we will not only look at reversing these restrictions, but also build new business/trade arrangements for mutual benefit.

Russia really does need to learn that friendship will bring them better results than their hitherto hostile approach.

Uncle Peter 26-03-2018 19:12

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Putin would be doing himself great favours by distancing himself from the minister of lies and fantasy: Vladislav Surkov. It would come as no surprise if he had significant input into the current debacle: Think Ukraine crisis, pro-russian "separatists" (special operations troops and mercenaries in other words), South Ossetia etc.

Much of what we see from outside Russia is a product of Putin's apparatus attempting to consolidate power in a very broken political system where in-fighting among various factions outside of the public eye threatens his grip on power. Surkov is one of the main people Putin listens to but unfortunately for him, this will end up being the start his undoing.

pip08456 26-03-2018 21:49

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Iceland announces diplomatic boycott of 2018 World Cup in Russia

https://sputniknews.com/worldcup-201...cott-worldcup/

Mr K 26-03-2018 22:24

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 35941885)
Iceland announces diplomatic boycott of 2018 World Cup in Russia

https://sputniknews.com/worldcup-201...cott-worldcup/

If only Iceland had boycotted Euro 2016 ;)

I think the Ruskies may have miscalculated. It's good we still have friends in the EU despite everything. As for Trump, good on him for once, I'm sure trying to bury a certain porn stars revelations from the headlines are purely coincidental.

denphone 03-04-2018 16:37

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Porton Down scientists are unable to verify the 'precise source of novichok'

Quote:

British scientists at Porton Down have not been able to establish where the novichok nerve agent used to poison Sergei and Yulia Skripal was made, it has emerged.
Quote:

He explained that establishing its origin required “other inputs”, some of them intelligence-based, that the government has access to.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...ce-of-novichok

Gavin78 03-04-2018 18:45

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Perhaps we've been a little too forward with Russia?

denphone 03-04-2018 18:53

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gavin78 (Post 35942491)
Perhaps we've been a little too forward perhaps with Russia?

l always like to see everything come out in the wash before forming a firm conclusion about things.

Gavin78 03-04-2018 19:02

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Well I suppose we have known for weeks that they weren't able to say who did it? other than what the poison was. However there must have been enough evidence to present to the nations that have expelled Russian diplomats for them to do it?

It will be interesting to see what happens over the next week or 2

OLD BOY 03-04-2018 19:07

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35942492)
l always like to see everything come out in the wash before forming a firm conclusion about things.

Best not to form a view at this point in time then, Den. They say they have not 'yet' established where it came from. They are talking about incontrovertial evidence.

I don't think there is much doubt though, do you?

Mick 03-04-2018 19:51

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Of course, Russia is jumping on this news. But it does not in any way put them in the clear. We’ve obviously shared some other intelligence that Porton Down is not privy to, with our allies.

RizzyKing 04-04-2018 05:17

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
The public is not going to get all the information on this for a very long time if ever and the porton statement could simply mean they don't know which facility it was manufactured at or stored at and certainly doesn't mean Russia are clear of any involvement in this incident.

Carth 04-04-2018 15:03

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35942544)
. . and certainly doesn't mean Russia are clear of any involvement in this incident.

. . or a few more Countries if using that argument ;)

Mick 04-04-2018 16:10

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Porton Down did it's job to identify what the substance was.

It's the intelligence services job to identify where it came from and they obviously have intel to say what, which we will never see.

I see Jeremy Corbyn is jumping on the Russia defense bandwagon, anything for him to deflect the racisim/Anti-Jewish sentiment going on in the Labour Party.

Mick 04-04-2018 19:14

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
BREAKING: Russia’s proposals at OPCW DEFEATED.

Quote:

The international community has once again stood with Britain in the face of Russian attempts to obscure the truth of the Skripal case.

At today’s special session of the Executive Council in The Hague called by Russia, Russia proposed a joint UK-Russia inquiry into the attempted murder in Salisbury. Russia demanded this session before the OPCW has completed its technical assistance to the UK. Russia’s proposal for a joint investigation was robustly defeated, receiving only six votes from the 41-strong Executive Council. Russia is continuing its diversionary tactics by asking now for an emergency session of the UN Security Council tomorrow, again without waiting for the OPCW to do its work.
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/f...posals-at-opcw

Mr K 04-04-2018 19:48

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35942606)
Porton Down did it's job to identify what the substance was.

It's the intelligence services job to identify where it came from and they obviously have intel to say what, which we will never see.

I see Jeremy Corbyn is jumping on the Russia defense bandwagon, anything for him to deflect the racisim/Anti-Jewish sentiment going on in the Labour Party.


That's the problem with scientists they just tell it how it is with no regard to the political and media narrative.

P.S it's 'Defence' Mick, you've been reading too many US sites ;)

Hugh 04-04-2018 21:23

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 35942635)
That's the problem with scientists they just tell it how it is with no regard to the political and media narrative.

P.S it's 'Defence' Mick, you've been reading too many US sites ;)

Try not to be a Richard, there’s a good fellow...

RizzyKing 05-04-2018 10:08

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
No Carth novichok is an all Russian creation and apart from small samples held by other facilities for work on a vaccine only Russia has significant stocks of it. Even if it were a commonplace agent only one country has a reason to have used it in the way it was but i suppose if you want you can go with the "Russia didn't do it" approach im sure that attitude will deliver the truth.

Carth 05-04-2018 14:57

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Doesn't matter who has 'stocks' of it, quite a few countries have the means to produce it.

I'd guess the amount used in the attack doesn't come anywhere near needing a 'stockpile' of the stuff either.

I'm not saying Russia didn't do it, and I'm not saying they did. Until I hear of clear and irrefutable proof I'll keep an open mind thanks ;)

There's a reason we no longer have the death penalty here, something to do with circumstantial evidence and motive proving an innocent as guilty . . with no way back.

Mick 05-04-2018 21:12

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
BREAKING: Russia warns U.K. tonight at the Emergency UN Security Council meeting it asked to convene that ‘they are playing with fire’ and ‘they will be sorry.’

Damien 05-04-2018 23:16

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Blah blah blah. Hardly making themselves seem innocent.

RizzyKing 05-04-2018 23:43

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
The rhetoric is getting a little silly and likely no coincidence i suppose that a number of recent YouTube videos have been highlighting a nuclear attack on the UK by Russia from the social media departments within the FSB and ministry of foreign affairs. Completely stupid videos that talk in terms of a massive Russian strike with no counter attack by us but then these videos like those in the past have been on the more fantastic sensationalist side of reality.

Mick 10-04-2018 13:38

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Russian Embassy in London states any secret resettlement of the Skripals will be treated as an "Abduction or forced isolation".

OLD BOY 10-04-2018 16:06

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35943222)
Russian Embassy in London states any secret resettlement of the Skripals will be treated as an "Abduction or forced isolation".

I think we should remind Russia that we don't send anyone in this country to Siberia in their pyjamas.

papa smurf 10-04-2018 16:17

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35943222)
Russian Embassy in London states any secret resettlement of the Skripals will be treated as an "Abduction or forced isolation".

obviously the ruski's want them back so they can finish the murder attempt.

RizzyKing 10-04-2018 21:28

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
I'll wait for vlad (man of peace) Putin's next speech about nuclear war in response to not getting his own way as that seems to be the norm these days.

Gavin78 10-04-2018 22:30

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Russia vetoes Syria chemical weapons inquiry

https://news.sky.com/story/live-syri...trump-11324985

Mick 11-04-2018 20:20

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
BREAKING: Yulia Skripal has said in a statement that her father is still "seriously ill" and that she is still suffering ill effects from the Nerve Agent and has shunned any assistance from the Russian Embassy, by saying she does "not wish to avail myself" to them.

https://news.sky.com/story/yulia-skr...bassy-11326800

Mick 12-04-2018 12:09

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
BREAKING: Independent chemical weapons scientists have confirmed that novichok was used in the attempted murder of former Russian spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia.

Mick 13-04-2018 18:16

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Latest: Russia has released their own 8,000 word report in to the Skripals case and state "They are being kept in forced detention or false imprisonment."

Even if remotely true, I suppose it's better than being DEAD by their (Russia's) own hands. :rolleyes:

OLD BOY 13-04-2018 18:43

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35943564)
Latest: Russia has released their own 8,000 word report in to the Skripals case and state "They are being kept in forced detention or false imprisonment."

Even if remotely true, I suppose it's better than being DEAD by their (Russia's) own hands. :rolleyes:

They really should not judge us by their own behaviour.

RizzyKing 13-04-2018 21:16

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Well in Russia's defence those are the two options when the authorities are involved in Russia so easy for them to mistake protective custody for what they do. Russia's responses lately on this and the Syria attack are not doing them any favours but it is doing what Putin wants getting bad press outside of Russia that he can claim are attacks on Russia by the evil west within Russia he's simply trying to cement his position.

Carth 15-04-2018 23:00

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Another twist to the tale, or more fake news from Russia?

http://www.business-standard.com/art...1500029_1.html

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov claimed on Saturday that the toxin used to poison former double agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia, was BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory.

You'd have thought, no matter what, that the media would be spending a fortune on contacting the Lab concerned for confirmation or denial . . with denial being their choice result so they could point fingers and shout 'liars' even louder :shrug:

It has gone rather quiet since the two victims made (are making) amazing recoveries, and I tend to doubt the old adage that 'no news is good news' :D

oh, just a disclaimer on the article: (This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

1andrew1 16-04-2018 00:51

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943756)
Another twist to the tale, or more fake news from Russia?

http://www.business-standard.com/art...1500029_1.html

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov claimed on Saturday that the toxin used to poison former double agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia, was BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory.

You'd have thought, no matter what, that the media would be spending a fortune on contacting the Lab concerned for confirmation or denial . . with denial being their choice result so they could point fingers and shout 'liars' even louder :shrug:

It has gone rather quiet since the two victims made (are making) amazing recoveries, and I tend to doubt the old adage that 'no news is good news' :D

oh, just a disclaimer on the article: (This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

As the name of the lab is not mentioned, I doubt little credibility can be attached to the article.

Hugh 16-04-2018 11:24

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943756)
Another twist to the tale, or more fake news from Russia?

http://www.business-standard.com/art...1500029_1.html

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov claimed on Saturday that the toxin used to poison former double agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia, was BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory.

You'd have thought, no matter what, that the media would be spending a fortune on contacting the Lab concerned for confirmation or denial . . with denial being their choice result so they could point fingers and shout 'liars' even louder :shrug:

It has gone rather quiet since the two victims made (are making) amazing recoveries, and I tend to doubt the old adage that 'no news is good news' :D

oh, just a disclaimer on the article: (This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

Would that be the same Russians who said they had investigated the alleged Chemical attack in Doumas and concluded there hadn’t been one, then a day or two later said that the Chemical attack in Doumas had probably been done by British-backed forces?

Damien 16-04-2018 11:36

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943756)
Another twist to the tale, or more fake news from Russia?

http://www.business-standard.com/art...1500029_1.html

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov claimed on Saturday that the toxin used to poison former double agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia, was BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory.

You'd have thought, no matter what, that the media would be spending a fortune on contacting the Lab concerned for confirmation or denial . . with denial being their choice result so they could point fingers and shout 'liars' even louder :shrug:

It has gone rather quiet since the two victims made (are making) amazing recoveries, and I tend to doubt the old adage that 'no news is good news' :D

oh, just a disclaimer on the article: (This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

The Lab itself has poured cold water on this Russian lie: https://twitter.com/SpiezLab/status/985243574123057152

Carth 16-04-2018 15:33

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35943791)
The Lab itself has poured cold water on this Russian lie: https://twitter.com/SpiezLab/status/985243574123057152

You aren't reading it right, the lab has confirmed that novichok was present - which isn't in doubt - but made no mention of other toxins that may have also been present.

Quite often it's not what they say, but what they don't say.

Hugh 16-04-2018 17:18

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943816)
You aren't reading it right, the lab has confirmed that novichok was present - which isn't in doubt - but made no mention of other toxins that may have also been present.

Quite often it's not what they say, but what they don't say.

So, the fact that they didn't confirm that Plutonium wasn't present, means it may have been?

Carth 17-04-2018 00:33

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
'sigh'

the article mentioned BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory

you said your tweet from the lab has poured cold water on this Russian lie

nowhere in that tweet did it deny the existence of BZ toxin

do you see what I mean ;)

pip08456 17-04-2018 01:16

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943877)
'sigh'

the article mentioned BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory

you said your tweet from the lab has poured cold water on this Russian lie

nowhere in that tweet did it deny the existence of BZ toxin

do you see what I mean ;)

The lab has neither confirmed nor denied anything in the tweet.

It is one of the designated labs that is contracted by OPCW. Quite rightly they have stated only OPCW can comment.

They've also advised to wait for the OPCW Executive meeting on 18th April.

Any article published before then can only be supposition.

Maggy 17-04-2018 08:57

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35943820)
So, the fact that they didn't confirm that Plutonium wasn't present, means it may have been?

:tu:

---------- Post added at 08:57 ---------- Previous post was at 08:57 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 35943878)
The lab has neither confirmed nor denied anything in the tweet.

It is one of the designated labs that is contracted by OPCW. Quite rightly they have stated only OPCW can comment.

They've also advised to wait for the OPCW Executive meeting on 18th April.

Any article published before then can only be supposition.

:tu:

RizzyKing 17-04-2018 12:12

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Carth your stretching nearly as much as the Russian's with this line of argument and given the lab has stated they confirmed the use of novichok and it was novichok that caused the health of the two people in question to suffer what else might have been present is irrelevant as it didn't inflict the harm.

pip08456 17-04-2018 12:38

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35943942)
Carth your stretching nearly as much as the Russian's with this line of argument and given the lab has stated they confirmed the use of novichok and it was novichok that caused the health of the two people in question to suffer what else might have been present is irrelevant as it didn't inflict the harm.

Please link to where the lab has confirmed anything other than "We have no doubt that Porton Down has identified Novichock."

RizzyKing 17-04-2018 13:11

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
They are supporting Porton Down i could have worded it better but you don't support something untrue and certainly wouldn't express support if other agents were present that might have been responsible.

pip08456 17-04-2018 13:34

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35943956)
They are supporting Porton Down i could have worded it better but you don't support something untrue and certainly wouldn't express support if other agents were present that might have been responsible.

Yes Rizzy, you could have worded it better.;)

All the lab has stated is they "have no doubt" PD found Novichok that does not mean no other agents were found.

As I said earlier, the lab is contracted by OPCW and it is up to OPCW and no-one else to release those findings.

We will find out tomorrow if any other agent has been found. Until then anything else is just speculation. Nothing more, nothing less.

Carth 17-04-2018 15:03

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 35943962)
All the lab has stated is they "have no doubt" PD found Novichok that does not mean no other agents were found.


We will find out tomorrow if any other agent has been found. Until then anything else is just speculation. Nothing more, nothing less.

Cheers Pip, I'm pleased someone else can see that hardly anything is 'confirmed' apart from Novichok was found to be present.

Speculation and wild shots in the dark from all quarters until more is disclosed.

pip08456 17-04-2018 15:08

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
We should find out tomorrow if the OPCW releases the content of the findings.

Hugh 17-04-2018 19:44

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943877)
'sigh'

the article mentioned BZ toxin, as confirmed by a Swiss laboratory

you said your tweet from the lab has poured cold water on this Russian lie

nowhere in that tweet did it deny the existence of BZ toxin

do you see what I mean ;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35943975)
Cheers Pip, I'm pleased someone else can see that hardly anything is 'confirmed' apart from Novichok was found to be present.

Speculation and wild shots in the dark from all quarters until more is disclosed.

Irony, thy name is Carth...:D

Carth 17-04-2018 20:34

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 35944036)
Irony, thy name is Carth...:D

yeah :D I could have had a great career in politics or the media ;)

Damien 18-04-2018 13:35

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
https://twitter.com/EliotHiggins/sta...83417847508992

Quote:

The OPCW confirms BZ in samples relating to the Skripal poisoning were positive control samples, not from the site of the attack. This means, yet again, the Russian government has been caught lying about a chemical attack.
https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2018/04/7.jpg

Carth 18-04-2018 15:27

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
There we go then, now everyone knows how & why traces of BZ were found.

In my view it makes nobody a liar as BZ is confirmed to be present - just as the Russian bloke said ;)

Damien 18-04-2018 15:53

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35944138)
There we go then, now everyone knows how & why traces of BZ were found.

In my view it makes nobody a liar as BZ is confirmed to be present - just as the Russian bloke said ;)

They would have known why it was there.

pip08456 18-04-2018 20:05

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35944138)
There we go then, now everyone knows how & why traces of BZ were found.

In my view it makes nobody a liar as BZ is confirmed to be present - just as the Russian bloke said ;)

What planet are you on Carth? BZ was present in the control sample prepared by the Labs, not in the sample collected from the scene.


From the report.
Quote:

10 The results of analysis by the OPCW designated laboratories of environmental and
biomedical samples collected by the OPCW team confirm the findings of the United
Kingdom relating to the identity of the toxic chemical that was used in Salisbury and
severely injured three people.
11. The TAV team notes that the toxic chemical was of high purity. The latter is
concluded from the almost complete absence of impurities.

Carth 18-04-2018 20:59

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
To be honest I've no idea what planet I'm on, it certainly isn't the one I grew up on.

I'm too old for this game so yep, the Russians did it . . . along with getting Trump elected, Brexit vote success, and the Accrington promotion . . .





. . although Brexit could have been an own goal ;)


*wanders off to find stronger beer* :D

Carth 30-04-2018 19:53

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
So . . .

yet another fascinating series let down by its lack of continuity :D

It's like getting absorbed in a really good book, only to find the last chapter is missing

:dig:

I don't suppose anyone has found any updated info?

Mick 04-05-2018 13:44

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
BREAKING: OPCW Release Statement on Amount of Nerve Agent used in Salisbury was that the OPCW Technical Assistance Visit team concluded that the chemical substance found was of high purity, persistent and resistant to weather conditions.:

Quote:

THE HAGUE, Netherlands — 4 May 2018 — In response to questions from the media, the OPCW Spokesperson stated that the OPCW would not be able to estimate or determine the amount of the nerve agent that was used in Salisbury on 4 March 2018. The quantity should probably be characterised in milligrams. However, the analysis of samples collected by the OPCW Technical Assistance Visit team concluded that the chemical substance found was of high purity, persistent and resistant to weather conditions.
https://www.opcw.org/news/article/op...-in-salisbury/

Carth 04-05-2018 14:57

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
This is getting embarrassing. . . high purity, persistent and resistant to weather conditions. . . people should be dead if everything said about this 'nerve agent' is to be believed.

RizzyKing 04-05-2018 19:05

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Depends exactly how engineered it was Carth and the more complex the engineering of it the less facilities are capable of producing it this information may seem vague but it just narrowed the list of facilities it could have come from.

Carth 18-05-2018 23:25

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
If anyone is still remotely interested in this, Sergei Skripal was released from hospital today.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...sbury-hospital


“But let’s not forget, the fact that all three victims of this incident have been discharged from hospital does not alter the fact this was a brazen and reckless attack - attempted murder - using an illegal chemical weapon.”

sorry bud, already forgotten and gathering dust in a locker somewhere :rolleyes:

OLD BOY 20-05-2018 18:52

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35947295)
If anyone is still remotely interested in this, Sergei Skripal was released from hospital today.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/...sbury-hospital


“But let’s not forget, the fact that all three victims of this incident have been discharged from hospital does not alter the fact this was a brazen and reckless attack - attempted murder - using an illegal chemical weapon.”

sorry bud, already forgotten and gathering dust in a locker somewhere :rolleyes:

A bit complacent... :sleep:

RizzyKing 21-05-2018 07:46

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Investigation is still continuing on this it hasn't just been dropped because the media have moved onto other things.

denphone 04-07-2018 13:05

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Two collapse near Russian spy poisoning site.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-englan...shire-44707052

Quote:

A man and woman are in a critical condition after being exposed to an unknown substance, which counter terrorism officers are investigating.

nomadking 04-07-2018 13:08

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 35952919)
Two collapse near Russian spy poisoning site.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-englan...shire-44707052

Not sure I'd call 10 miles, "near". In fact Porton Down is nearer, at just 5 miles away. Coincidence?

Damien 04-07-2018 13:18

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
It's a bit weird if it's not some sort of spread from the original poisoning.

nomadking 04-07-2018 13:21

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35952925)
It's a bit weird if it's not some sort of spread from the original poisoning.

It's even weirder that Porton Down is so near to both sites.

heero_yuy 04-07-2018 13:21

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
I heard that the house was a newly built unit so it *could* be building product residues or even a carbon monoxide leak.

It's easy for the mass media to make 2+2 = 5

denphone 04-07-2018 13:27

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35952928)
I heard that the house was a newly built unit so it *could* be building product residues or even a carbon monoxide leak.

It's easy for the mass media to make 2+2 = 5

Indeed they do that all the time as banner headlines tend to come before the true facts.

Damien 04-07-2018 13:30

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 35952927)
It's even weirder that Porton Down is so near to both sites.

Maybe but I don't see how these substances could travel that distance without being detected.

Damien 04-07-2018 22:01

Re: New UK-Russia Tensions after Ex-Russian Spy Poisoned in Salisbury
 
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-44719639

Same nerve agent.

Mick 04-07-2018 23:43

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
According to reports - The couple in the Amesbury Incident are believed to have been in Salisbury on Friday and on roads that had been sealed off during the Skripal poisoning. Have this British couple been unfortunate enough to have been contaminated from left over residue of the Russian Novichok Nerve Agent in Salisbury?

Home Secretary, Sajid Javid, is to host an emergency Cobra meeting tomorrow morning.

TheDaddy 04-07-2018 23:59

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35952982)
According to reports - The couple in the Amesbury Incident are believed to have been in Salisbury on Friday and on roads that had been sealed off during the Skripal poisoning. Have this British couple been unfortunate enough to have been contaminated from left over residue of the Russian Novichok Nerve Agent in Salisbury?

Home Secretary, Sajid Javid, is to host an emergency Cobra meeting tomorrow morning.

Or were one or both of them responsible for the original poisoning

Damien 05-07-2018 07:16

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Are these substances even able to survive outside that long?

adzii_nufc 05-07-2018 07:27

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Likely that they've come in contact with the poorly disposed of source container. That would ensure it survived in adverse conditions. Other suggestions are tainted items that again have been poorly disposed of.

Be nothing to confirm until they've retraced their actions. If there's anything left to confirm that is.

TheDaddy 05-07-2018 07:46

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 35952993)
Likely that they've come in contact with the poorly disposed of source container. That would ensure it survived in adverse conditions. Other suggestions are tainted items that again have been poorly disposed of.

Be nothing to confirm until they've retraced their actions. If there's anything left to confirm that is.

Sounds plausible, you've got to question the competence of the assassins though to poorly dispose of such evidence, mind you they have proven to be inept already, four people poisoned and thankfully no fatalities

adzii_nufc 05-07-2018 07:57

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 35952998)
Sounds plausible, you've got to question the competence of the assassins though to poorly dispose of such evidence, mind you they have proven to be inept already, four people poisoned and thankfully no fatalities

Strangely enough they're both known drug users. Many possibilities here.

I did like yours however. Would be a juicy conspiracy if they were the would be assassins and the Russians have come back to tie up the botched job.

Damien 05-07-2018 08:21

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
It doesn't make that much sense for this to be a targeted attack from Russia unless there is some information we're missing which is why the contamination is probably the most likely scenario.

Other options would be Russian misdirection to sow doubt on the original poisoning or that it wasn't Russia and someone in running around Wiltshire with Novichok and just coincidentally the first people they targeted just happened to be Russian spies. Neither of which are plausible I don't think.

Mick 05-07-2018 09:09

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35952992)
Are these substances even able to survive outside that long?

From what I recall of the Salisbury findings, the Novichok is completely weather proof, so that is extremely likely that that a prior contaminated source, has survived, despite a decontamination effort that was done back in April and they may have missed that source.

Makes no sense why two British citizens were targeted in this latest incident.

nomadking 05-07-2018 10:49

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Quote:

Novichok, a resilient and resistant nerve agent developed by the Soviet Union in the 1970s and 1980s, takes effect within minutes,
So how were they both affected the next day and simultaneously?

Hugh 05-07-2018 15:14

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 35953015)
So how were they both affected the next day and simultaneously?

First one, then the other when it got passed on?

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-44727191
Quote:

It acts quickest when ingested or inhaled and more slowly when contact is made through skin exposure.

Novichok is designed to be persistent - it neither evaporates nor decomposes quickly.

Mr K 05-07-2018 18:14

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
England v Russia is a World Cup fixture bound to happen now...

Mick 08-07-2018 22:24

Re: UPDATED: New Novichok Poisoning Incident in Amesbury, Wiltshire.
 
BREAKING: Dawn Sturgess, who was exposed to novichok in Amesbury, has DIED.

https://news.sky.com/story/dawn-stur...-dies-11430667


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum