Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33664005)

bjorkiii 21-04-2010 12:55

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
:o: Oooh i like the personal touch :D When you typed garry it was as if your sat here beside me :o: Oooh best damp myself down with a wet lettuce.

Stuart 21-04-2010 12:57

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35005280)
So does my wife, and I wouldn't trust her on making judgments about volcanic eruptions :)

The problem is, the Met Office are, and (if the register's article I posted a link to above is correct), they are basing their model on little actual data.

Bluffdemon 21-04-2010 13:00

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
just been on hold to ryanair for 1hr at 10p a min and still got nowhere , low cost airline making shed loads on their phone number typical , where there is a crisis there is money to be made :-(((

superbiatch 21-04-2010 13:13

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 35005281)
And do we actually believe bjorkiii's emotive meanderings about him making the decision on his own, or would it have been discussed at an operational board meeting, informed by expert advice?

I'm happy to go with that and travel next week. The way i see it if there was any possibility of safety being at risk, the airlines would not put themselves in a vulnerable position.

bjorkiii 21-04-2010 13:15

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
He owes a lot of money to littlewoods catologue co i heard he ordered 4 cardigans last september and is 12 weeks behind :o:, these rumours are probly hearsay but you just never know.

Hugh 21-04-2010 13:22

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bjorkiii (Post 35005283)
:o: Oooh i like the personal touch :D When you typed garry it was as if your sat here beside me :o: Oooh best damp myself down with a wet lettuce.

If I have made your day better in any way, my time here has not been in vain - happy to have helped make you happy. :)

Pay it forward.;)

---------- Post added at 12:22 ---------- Previous post was at 12:19 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by bjorkiii (Post 35005297)
He owes a lot of money to littlewoods catologue co i heard he ordered 4 cardigans last september and is 12 weeks behind :o:, these rumours are probly hearsay but you just never know.

http://blog.beliefnet.com/beyondblue...atry-couch.gif

moiraf100 21-04-2010 14:07

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Daughter is now booked on a flight to leave Melbourne on 4th May.
Is staying in Sydney until Friday, then flying out to New Zealand on Air Miles to stay with friends for 6 days, then flying back to Melbourne to stay with more friends before she comes home.
She wanted to go to NZ in a couple of years anyway, so she's saved some pennies now :-)
All's well that ends well.

budwieser 21-04-2010 14:56

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Just got back from Terminal 4. I`ve got my beauties back again and i`m Very Very Happy. Many thanks to Etihad Airlines for the way they treated my girls and the others on her flight. Amazing.:tu::nworthy:

joglynne 21-04-2010 15:51

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
So pleased to hear that they are home safe with you budwieser. I know it's been a worry to have them stuck away from you no matter how comfortable their extended holiday proved to be. :)

budwieser 21-04-2010 16:58

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joglynne (Post 35005357)
So pleased to hear that they are home safe with you budwieser. I know it's been a worry to have them stuck away from you no matter how comfortable their extended holiday proved to be. :)

:):):):)

Flyboy 21-04-2010 18:17

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 35005279)
No, but he does have an MBA, Garry, and part of that (and being the CEO of a large company) is about risk assessment/mitigation ;)

Not to cast a shadow on this, but the specualtion that the Polish president "encouraged" the pilot of his plane to land in bad weather, could be described as a similar scenario. I wouldn't put it past Walsh to "bully" someone into declaring the skies are safe.

Hom3r 21-04-2010 18:33

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Just seen two jets at low level over my town bound for Stansted

Maggy 21-04-2010 18:48

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005413)
Not to cast a shadow on this, but the specualtion that the Polish president "encouraged" the pilot of his plane to land in bad weather, could be described as a similar scenario. I wouldn't put it past Walsh to "bully" someone into declaring the skies are safe.

The fact that planes are landing and taking off with no problems thus far seems to bear out the facts and the suggestion that anyone has been bullied to ignore safety precautions seems speculative.

moiraf100 21-04-2010 18:50

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
@ budwieser :-)

martyh 21-04-2010 18:55

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005413)
Not to cast a shadow on this, but the specualtion that the Polish president "encouraged" the pilot of his plane to land in bad weather, could be described as a similar scenario. I wouldn't put it past Walsh to "bully" someone into declaring the skies are safe.

are the airlines carrying out extra checks and inspections of the planes because surely even if they catch the remnants of the ash cloud it could still damage engine parts over a period of time some short haul planes will do 3 or 4 trips a day into Europe and damage could have a cumulative effect

Hugh 21-04-2010 19:08

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005413)
Not to cast a shadow on this, but the specualtion that the Polish president "encouraged" the pilot of his plane to land in bad weather, could be described as a similar scenario. I wouldn't put it past Walsh to "bully" someone into declaring the skies are safe.

What is the difference between bully and "bully"?

I am sure the BALPA would be out the door faster than a speeding bullet if they had any hint of pressure on a pilot to fly in unsafe conditions, don't you? (especially after their protest march against BA in 2008).

budwieser 21-04-2010 20:49

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by moiraf100 (Post 35005440)
@ budwieser :-)

Thank you me darlin`:);)

Tinky 21-04-2010 22:47

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Just had a phone call from Mr Tink he's on his way back from Exeter Airport yipeee !!!:hyper::hyper::hyper::hyper::luv::luv: :):):):)

Hom3r 21-04-2010 23:01

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Get a nice cuppa tea and his favourite food ready :)

joglynne 21-04-2010 23:11

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
... and a big hug. :D

So happy for you Tinky. :hugs:

Stuart 21-04-2010 23:23

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005413)
Not to cast a shadow on this, but the specualtion that the Polish president "encouraged" the pilot of his plane to land in bad weather, could be described as a similar scenario. I wouldn't put it past Walsh to "bully" someone into declaring the skies are safe.

Think about this logically.. If they lose a plane, how much would it cost to replace? About two to three hundred million dollars (http://www.boeing.com/commercial/prices/ ) for a 747.

Now add in the costs for the inevitable legal actions (which depending on which country the action takes place in may include punitive damages). This will cost millions.

Now multiply that by the number of flights that each airline makes in one day (which can be hundreds)

Finally, factor in the damage caused to their reputation when people start thinking that the airline was willing to risk their lives to save a few pounds..

That kind of loss of reputation bankrupted Pan Am (then one of the largest airlines) after Lockerbie.

Now, do you *really* think the airlines would risk all that cost to save a few £million?

Hom3r 21-04-2010 23:59

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 35005592)
Think about this logically.. If they lose a plane, how much would it cost to replace? About two to three hundred million dollars (http://www.boeing.com/commercial/prices/ ) for a 747.

Now add in the costs for the inevitable legal actions (which depending on which country the action takes place in may include punitive damages). This will cost millions.

Now multiply that by the number of flights that each airline makes in one day (which can be hundreds)

Finally, factor in the damage caused to their reputation when people start thinking that the airline was willing to risk their lives to save a few pounds..

That kind of loss of reputation bankrupted Pan Am (then one of the largest airlines) after Lockerbie.

Now, do you *really* think the airlines would risk all that cost to save a few £million?

What I know from working within the aviation industry is like this.

A plane crashes somewhere in the world, and it is found a minor fault in a planes system is to blame.

The A/C reg makers (EASA / FAA / CAA etc) make the decision to either a mandatory fix, or recommendation.

Say the fix is a recommendation, the airline looks at it and says the fix on all the affected A/C will cost £250 million (yes that is possible), but the risk of another plane crashing is very slim, and if one does go down it would cost in payouts £200 milion, they would chose the latter.


The cost I quoted can happen, bearing in mind that a 737 has approx 2 million parts, and some of these aren't cheap. I had to purchase a CMM which was less than 40 pages and cost £5,000.

---------- Post added at 22:52 ---------- Previous post was at 22:43 ----------

CMM = Component Maintenance Manual

---------- Post added at 22:58 ---------- Previous post was at 22:52 ----------

Where I worked they have 3 versions of the BAe-146 they are:

-200QT
-300QT

-200QC

There was an Aircaft Maintenace Manual for each type (Luckly the QTs used the same manual, as the only difference was the length.)

The QC (quick change) was a frieghter/Passenger varient.

So I had to maintain two sets of manuals each was 20 volumes and each volume was approx 5" thick.

Each set cost around £80,000 to buy and another annual payment of £15,000.

---------- Post added at 22:59 ---------- Previous post was at 22:58 ----------

Final point though

you are far safer flying than you are driving

Flyboy 22-04-2010 00:25

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 35005592)
Think about this logically.. If they lose a plane, how much would it cost to replace? About two to three hundred million dollars (http://www.boeing.com/commercial/prices/ ) for a 747.

Now add in the costs for the inevitable legal actions (which depending on which country the action takes place in may include punitive damages). This will cost millions.

Now multiply that by the number of flights that each airline makes in one day (which can be hundreds)

Finally, factor in the damage caused to their reputation when people start thinking that the airline was willing to risk their lives to save a few pounds..

That kind of loss of reputation bankrupted Pan Am (then one of the largest airlines) after Lockerbie.

Now, do you *really* think the airlines would risk all that cost to save a few £million?

Yes, I know, I was just being flippant. But, bearing in mind Walsh's arrogance, it does have ring of truth about it. ;)

Stuart 22-04-2010 00:26

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Unfortunately, assuming that the predicted path of the Ash cloud was (or is) correct, then the chances of planes crashing increase massively..

I would have thought it was certainly enough that the airlines would put up with losing the odd few million a day, rather than the cost of a new aircraft (or even a few).

Ben B 22-04-2010 00:28

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Even if there was a 1% chance of the planes crashing nobody would want to fly so it must all be safe otherwise the planes would still be grounded now.

Stuart 22-04-2010 00:30

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005645)
Yes, I know, I was just being flippant. But, bearing in mind Walsh's arrogance, it does have ring of truth about it. ;)

Actually, that wasn't aimed at you specifically. It was more a general reply. I've heard a few people make the point that they thought that the airlines bullied the authorities into opening up the airways. I don't think they would have unless they thought there was a good chance that NATS was incorrect to close our airspace.

Hom3r 22-04-2010 11:08

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Breaking news

Ryan Air has backed down and will pay passengers

no link yet.

Chris 22-04-2010 11:17

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Breaking news: Just discovered that some old friends of ours got a lift home from Spain aboard HMS Albion. I am very, very, very jealous. :cry:

---------- Post added at 10:17 ---------- Previous post was at 10:16 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35005812)
Breaking news

Ryan Air has backed down and will pay passengers

no link yet.

Of course they're going to pay. Refusing to pay was about as likely to happen as charging passengers to use the toilet. O'Leary and his mob will say or do anything to get column inches.

Stuart 22-04-2010 11:20

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35005815)
Breaking news: Just discovered that some old friends of ours got a lift home from Spain aboard HMS Albion. I am very, very, very jealous. :cry:

Although it's likely that a lot of the interesting parts of the ship will be covered by the Official Secrets Act..

xpod 22-04-2010 11:24

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Well, i cant say the lack of flights had any direct effect on us although it did for a couple of cousins back up in Scotland. Either way though it`s sure nice to look back up in the sky on a lovely clear day like today and see all those Scottish Saltires the planes leave behind as they criss cross each others paths.:)

Derek 22-04-2010 11:24

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hom3r (Post 35005812)
Ryan Air has backed down and will pay passengers

Of course to claim you need to call a premium rate number for 15 minutes in order to get a claim form which needs to be completed in triplicate with your own blood. :erm:

Chris 22-04-2010 11:32

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 35005819)
Although it's likely that a lot of the interesting parts of the ship will be covered by the Official Secrets Act..

As a former CCF cadet I can say with some authority ... there's actually very little they won't let you see. Last time I had a tour around a warship (admittedly a good few years ago now), we went right round the Ops room. The only instructions were, don't touch any buttons, and don't try to peep underneath the consoles that were covered. Those were the secret ones. :D

Most of a warship is corridors, store-rooms and messes.

Kymmy 22-04-2010 13:01

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Link for the RyanAir turnaround

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8636461.stm

Pierre 22-04-2010 13:06

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

However it later issued a statement saying it would comply with the EU rules and would refund passengers for "reasonably-receipted expenses".

Ryanair boss Michael O'Leary told the BBC passengers would not receive extra compensation for the inconvenience and the airline would seek to recover its costs - up to 40m euros (£35m) - from the EU "which closed the airspace".
I'm with the Airlines on this.

Flyboy 22-04-2010 13:58

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35005815)
Breaking news: Just discovered that some old friends of ours got a lift home from Spain aboard HMS Albion. I am very, very, very jealous. :cry:

---------- Post added at 10:17 ---------- Previous post was at 10:16 ----------



Of course they're going to pay. Refusing to pay was about as likely to happen as charging passengers to use the toilet. O'Leary and his mob will say or do anything to get column inches.

But I strongly belive they will fight every single claim they receive. The are also likely to charge customers for processing claims, as well.

---------- Post added at 12:58 ---------- Previous post was at 12:56 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35005874)
I'm with the Airlines on this.

What part of that are you with. That they should not have closed the airspace?

Tuftus 22-04-2010 14:15

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005887)
What part of that are you with. That they should not have closed the airspace?

I was going to ask the very same question, surely business' have insurance for this kind of thing, then again they would just come back and say 'Act of God' - not covered mate.

bjorkiii 22-04-2010 14:51

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Did ryan go to the same school as willie w :D got visions of them sending their kids, relations etc birthday cards with terms and conditions on the back

Hugh 22-04-2010 14:57

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
No, he didn't

martyh 22-04-2010 15:22

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
I don't think the airlines should have to pay a penny in compensation i don't think anyone should have to pay any compensation ,refunds for not flying yes ,expenses because the airspace was shut no .The whole affair was very unfair on the airlines and a gross overreaction .

Flyboy 22-04-2010 15:24

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
I don't think the safety of millions of people is an overreaction.

martyh 22-04-2010 15:37

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005939)
I don't think the safety of millions of people is an overreaction.

oh come on flyboy airplanes fly through ash clouds all the time only the realy dense ones will cause a airplane to drop out of the sky .

Pierre 22-04-2010 15:53

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005887)
But I strongly belive they will fight every single claim they receive. The are also likely to charge customers for processing claims, as well.

---------- Post added at 12:58 ---------- Previous post was at 12:56 ----------



What part of that are you with. That they should not have closed the airspace?

That they shouldn't have to pay exhorbitant compensations costs.

Flyboy 22-04-2010 16:05

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35005946)
oh come on flyboy airplanes fly through ash clouds all the time only the realy dense ones will cause a airplane to drop out of the sky .

Aeroplanes do not fly through ash clouds all the time. They are quite rare, especially in this part of the world. The cloud does not have to be very dense for glass deposits to form on jet turbine blades. This is why the aircraft were grounded in the first place.

---------- Post added at 15:05 ---------- Previous post was at 15:05 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35005948)
That they shouldn't have to pay exhorbitant compensations costs.

No one is asking them to pay exorbitant compensation to anyone, only what is reasonable.

Pierre 22-04-2010 16:21

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005950)
No one is asking them to pay exorbitant compensation to anyone, only what is reasonable.

Well if someone has bought a £40 flight ticket, but can then potentially reclaim 5 days hotels and meals costs. I consider that unreasonable.

Stuart 22-04-2010 16:35

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005939)
I don't think the safety of millions of people is an overreaction.

No, that isn't. The length of the closure was, however. Especially as it seems the closure was based on a limited amount of data about the ash.

gazzae 22-04-2010 16:44

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
If a flight is cancelled or you cannot get on the flight due to the airline, i.e. overbooking, crew strikes etc then the airline should have responsibility to find you hotels, meals etc
If it is cancelled due to something outside their control i.e. natural disaster, ATC strike then they should not have to provide hotels, food etc.

After all how can an airline like easyjet factor in the possibility of having to pay for 15,000 hotel rooms and meals for up to 5 days to their business plan. You can say they have insurance, but insurance costs money.

danielf 22-04-2010 16:45

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart C (Post 35005969)
No, that isn't. The length of the closure was, however. Especially as it seems the closure was based on a limited amount of data about the ash.

I thought the closure was based on (seemingly) overly strict international regulations which have since been relaxed?

In the meantime:

Quote:

Training flights on RAF Typhoons in Lincolnshire have been suspended after ash deposits were found in one aircraft's engines.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8637978.stm

Saaf_laandon_mo 22-04-2010 16:50

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Landed in luton from lisbon just over am hour ago. Was supposed to have been on a flight to gatwick on sunday and the next available flight into a proper london airport was not till next week.
Easyjet put up all its stranded passengers in lisbon in a 5 star hotel, with meals so it wasn't too bad. I did speak to some BA PASSENGERS who were only provided accommodation for 3 days, after which they were on their own.

martyh 22-04-2010 16:51

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35005950)
Aeroplanes do not fly through ash clouds all the time. They are quite rare, especially in this part of the world. The cloud does not have to be very dense for glass deposits to form on jet turbine blades. This is why the aircraft were grounded in the first place.

---------- Post added at 15:05 ---------- Previous post was at 15:05 ----------



No one is asking them to pay exorbitant compensation to anyone, only what is reasonable.


FLyboy ,the ash clouds from any volcano stay in the upper atmosphere for years circling the globe for decades ,heavier particles sink to the ground within a few days ,so if your trying to tell me that planes do not encounter ash from volcanoes on a regular basis then that is rubbish
As i said only the concentrated ash is capable of scouring the screen or shutting down an engine .Most pilots on this forum
http://www.pprune.org/private-flying...-merged-7.html cannot understand the thinking behind closing the air space in the way it has been done ,even they say that there has been some major ass covering simply because there is no data available from the met office as to how dense this cloud is ,they can't understand why they weren't allowed to fly lower

a typical quote from a pilot

Quote:

It's all a storm in a teacup. It has now gotten so far out of hand that they won't admit they were wrong.
Still it has been amazing flying for us over the last few days!!
and another

Quote:

It is a stupid lawyer-ish over-reaction. I am sure there is zero risk to any aviation anywhere in Europe - so long as the plume coming out of the volcano is avoided (which is easy; everybody knows where that is).

The amazing thing is that the airspace owners have been able to shut everything down without having evidence of the risk to aircraft and without even making an apparent effort to find out. I reckon they are going to get sued big-time by the airlines. I hope they do get sued.
and another disillusioned pilot

Quote:

If you are able to fly in UK you are lucky. I have just spoken to the duty officer at the Danish CAA and they said the only thing flying in Denmark are the birds.
I flew round the cloud VFR on Thursday fron BIRK and was in severe clear all the way to Danish boundary but was forced to divert.
Been sitting under clear blue skies ever since. Can see my destination! Totally unjustifiable overreaction. Problem is they can't backtrack now without being seen to be alarmist. Bird Flu, Salmonella, Mad Cow disease, WMD all come to mind.
Director of safety at Danish CAA not working today as it is Sunday.
Who are these guys?
like i said a gross overreaction

Maggy 22-04-2010 17:03

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Frankly the whole point is moot as planes are still taking of and landing perfectly safely in the same conditions that applied during the ban.

So Flyboy why bother arguing the point? Why not agree to disagree?:shrug:

martyh 22-04-2010 17:23

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35005988)
Frankly the whole point is moot as planes are still taking of and landing perfectly safely in the same conditions that applied during the ban.

So Flyboy why bother arguing the point? Why not agree to disagree?:shrug:

because that would negate the point of the discussion aspects of this forum :rolleyes:;)

iFrankie 22-04-2010 17:24

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Slightly off topic But isn't this pic amazing of the volcano

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2010/04/28.jpg

martyh 22-04-2010 17:27

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iFrankie (Post 35006002)
Slightly off topic But isn't this pic amazing of the volcano

https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2010/04/28.jpg

thats a beautiful picture ,wonder if the plane that took it fell out of the sky

Maggy 22-04-2010 17:30

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35006000)
because that would negate the point of the discussion aspects of this forum :rolleyes:;)

DISCUSSION!

More like arguing for the sake of arguing..Just like a bunch of teenagers that try to chop logic so as to get their own way or point of view accepted.

Adults however learn to compromise and sometimes compromise means just accepting you cannot change the facts or someone's opinion.

So who is going to walk away first?

danielf 22-04-2010 17:33

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35006007)
Adults however learn to compromise and sometimes compromise means just accepting you cannot change the facts or someone's opinion.

You're clearly not paying any attention to the Election Campaign then :erm:

martyh 22-04-2010 17:45

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35006007)
DISCUSSION!

More like arguing for the sake of arguing..Just like a bunch of teenagers that try to chop logic so as to get their own way or point of view accepted.

Adults however learn to compromise and sometimes compromise means just accepting you cannot change the facts or someone's opinion.

So who is going to walk away first?

Maggie with all respect the whole point of a discussion forum is to discuss and that by it's nature will mean some people disagree with other people .You think we should all agree to disagree most people here don't ...it's called a difference of opinion and it is allowed and it would be a very boring forum if we all agreed to disagree

so i would ask with all respect to stop jumping on people who disagree with other people

Maggy 22-04-2010 18:14

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35006014)
Maggie with all respect the whole point of a discussion forum is to discuss and that by it's nature will mean some people disagree with other people .You think we should all agree to disagree most people here don't ...it's called a difference of opinion and it is allowed and it would be a very boring forum if we all agreed to disagree

so i would ask with all respect to stop jumping on people who disagree with other people

I get that this is a discussion board, I'm really not that stupid.

I asked at what point will the argu errr debate/discussion stop because Flyboy does have a reputation of keeping up an argument long after he has lost it...;)

Now you might think that's me being heavy handed but the point is eventually people get fed up,get cross and then the trouble starts..I'm just trying to head it off.;)

martyh 22-04-2010 18:20

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35006043)
I get that this is a discussion board, I'm really not that stupid.

I asked at what point will the argu errr debate/discussion stop because Flyboy does have a reputation of keeping up an argument long after he has lost it...;)

Now you might think that's me being heavy handed but the point is eventually people get fed up,get cross and then the trouble starts..I'm just trying to head it off.;)

i take your point and realise you have job to do ,i wouldn't allow anyone on this forum to get to me to such an extent where personal attacks are the only recourse ;)

it's only a forum ..

Flyboy 22-04-2010 18:25

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35005962)
Well if someone has bought a £40 flight ticket, but can then potentially reclaim 5 days hotels and meals costs. I consider that unreasonable.

Perhaps you do, but the law disagrees with you and more importantly Michael O'Leary.

---------- Post added at 17:25 ---------- Previous post was at 17:23 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by gazzae (Post 35005977)
If a flight is cancelled or you cannot get on the flight due to the airline, i.e. overbooking, crew strikes etc then the airline should have responsibility to find you hotels, meals etc
If it is cancelled due to something outside their control i.e. natural disaster, ATC strike then they should not have to provide hotels, food etc.

After all how can an airline like easyjet factor in the possibility of having to pay for 15,000 hotel rooms and meals for up to 5 days to their business plan. You can say they have insurance, but insurance costs money.

Which is the risk all businesses take when they factor their cost/price modeling. If they have saved a few quid without buying insurance, then that is their problem. It is the risk every business has to accept.

Pierre 22-04-2010 18:44

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35006049)
Perhaps you do, but the law disagrees with you and more importantly Michael O'Leary

Well the law actually states that the airlines should reimburse "REASONABLE" costs. It doesn't go into state what is deemed as reasonable and that is open to interpretation, and I would go so far as to say that if you've bought a cheap ticket with a budget airline, then what is deemed reasonable would be different to say buying a 1st class BA ticket.

In any event I was only expressing my opinion that I thought, in this instance, the law was wrong. Perhaps in helping the debate, you may decide to tell why YOU think the law is right, or wrong, instead of glibly telling me what the law says as I already know that, thanks

martyh 22-04-2010 18:45

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35006049)
Perhaps you do, but the law disagrees with you and more importantly Michael O'Leary.

and this is a very contentious point ,why should airlines be forced to pay compensation to passengers over and above the cost of the ticket?
after all coach train and ferry operators don't ,they only have to reimburse the cost of the ticket .I am pleased Michael O'Leary has done a "sort" of u turn and said only reasonable costs will be reimbursed in line with passenger rights legislation.

Mr Angry 22-04-2010 18:48

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35006069)
and this is a very contentious point ,why should airlines be forced to pay compensation to passengers over and above the cost of the ticket?

Errr...because it's the law?

The easy way to have sorted all of this out, and have a profound effect on the psyche of the British electorate, would have been for Gordon Brown to have declared that stranded travellers would have had additional monies made available to them, whether by way of credit limit increases or availability of funds in their accounts, and that any additional accrued expenses would be written off / paid by the banks.

Job done, sorted.

martyh 22-04-2010 18:53

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Angry (Post 35006071)
The easy way to have sorted all of this out, and have a profound effect on the psyche of the British electorate, would have been for Gordon Brown to have declared that stranded travellers would have had additional monies made available to them, whether by way of credit limit increases or availability of funds in their accounts and that any additional accrued expenses would be written off / paid by the banks.

Job done, sorted.

well that would have done the trick ,but an easier way would have been to use the fleet of private aircraft (GA traffic) and the raf troop carriers to bring people home these were not grounded and continued to fly throughout the crisis ...suffering no damage

alferret 22-04-2010 18:56

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 35006043)

I asked at what point will the argu errr debate/discussion stop because Flyboy does have a reputation of keeping up an argument long after he has lost it...;)

Tis true, I can attest to that ;)

Getting back to whether or not the CAA & NATS were overly agressive with the lenght of the ban I have to agree with others that IMO there was little chance of an accident happening due to dispersal rates of the ash by the time it reached UK and northern European air space.
Back in '82 when the famed plane lost all engines it was because it flew directly into the volcanic ash plume and not your usual common garden variety ash cloud.

It has been pointed out on many web sites by those that have been testing for the ash cloud that they can not test for density only that there is some ash in the atmosphere. There are 10's of thousands of cubic kilometers of air above Europe the north atlantic and the north sea. 90% or more of ejecta returns to earth within a few hundred miles of the eruption, the rest gets thinned out by the prevailing winds, by the time it reached mainland UK\Europe I would say (and this is my guess) that there was around 1 or 2 particles @ <2mm per cubic metre and once the initial eruption had taken place and the main body of the ash cloud had reached Eurozone airspace then 24-36hrs later the sky's could have been re opened. Obviously safety has to be taken into account and the CAA & NATS took it to the limits that they saw fit.
The above is just my opinion and is what I have gleened from TV\T'interweb\papers and a dose of common sense (mine though)


As for payments for accommodation & food whilst being stuck somewhere due to the closure I think that there should be a limit to the amount one can claim per meal and per night. Its not difficult to get 3 squares a day for about £20 anywhere in Europe and further afield, the same as its not difficult to find a room for £50 a night. I can see where companies like Ryanair come from when they get a bill for £700-£1000 from someone who's ticket cost them £30.
If you buy a budget ticket expect budget accommodation and food, if your ticket is business class or above expect to be treated as such and have a higher claim.
If your on a package holiday then your tour operator will look after you.


Again just my opinion.

Mr Angry 22-04-2010 18:56

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35006074)
well that would have done the trick ,but an easier way would have been to use the fleet of private aircraft (GA traffic) and the raf troop carriers to bring people home these were not grounded and continued to fly throughout the crisis ...suffering no damage

But that would be like the act of a "nanny state" - we can't be having that now, can we?

martyh 22-04-2010 19:00

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mr angry (Post 35006078)
but that would be like the act of a "nanny state" - we can't be having that now, can we?

lol:d

Saaf_laandon_mo 22-04-2010 19:29

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Not everyone books a budget airline because of cost. I booked easyjet because it was the only one who's flights suited my travel requirements.
The ec regulations state what a airline is liable for if planes are cancelled or grounded. I'd say an airline not insuring itself against this risk is taking a bit of a gamble.

Hom3r 22-04-2010 19:42

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by alferret (Post 35006077)
As for payments for accommodation & food whilst being stuck somewhere due to the closure I think that there should be a limit to the amount one can claim per meal and per night. Its not difficult to get 3 squares a day for about £20 anywhere in Europe and further afield, the same as its not difficult to find a room for £50 a night. I can see where companies like Ryanair come from when they get a bill for £700-£1000 from someone who's ticket cost them £30.
If you buy a budget ticket expect budget accommodation and food, if your ticket is business class or above expect to be treated as such and have a higher claim.
If your on a package holiday then your tour operator will look after you.


Again just my opinion.


Well when I was last in Europe I could easily spend £30 on an evening meal, and that was then expensive option on the menu. Plus what if the resturants don't do kid options, so a family of 4 could easily spend £100 on an evening meal.

Plus the fact some hotels were charging in some cases 4 times the normal price.

I stayed in a 3 star hotel and that was £150 per night and included breakfast free, i was allowed £15 for noon meal and £40 for evening including a drink which could be booze.

Thank god I was on 100% expences.

gazzae 22-04-2010 20:49

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 35006049)
Which is the risk all businesses take when they factor their cost/price modeling. If they have saved a few quid without buying insurance, then that is their problem. It is the risk every business has to accept.

Yes, but incase you haven't noticed insurance has this habit of increasing when you claim on it.
I work for a large manufacturing company. We ensure that our processes are as safe as possible and this cuts down on any claims against us, keeping the premiums low and our costs down. How can an airline keep premiums low and costs if they are forced to claim huge amounts for factors totally outside their control?

Ignitionnet 23-04-2010 18:05

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Q: What's the difference between Eyjafjallajoekull and Cheryl Cole?
A: Eyjafjallajoekull has been blowing Ash this week.

danielf 23-04-2010 18:08

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ignitionnet (Post 35006932)
Q: What's the difference between Eyjafjallajoekull and Cheryl Cole?
A: Eyjafjallajoekull has been blowing Ash this week.

I bet you'd get very few laughs if you said that to someone's face ;)

TheDaddy 23-04-2010 18:19

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danielf (Post 35006934)
I bet you'd get very few laughs if you said that to someone's face ;)

I dunno listening to news readers trying to pronounce Eyjafjallajoekull all week has given me quite a few laughs.....

alferret 23-04-2010 23:00

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Ah its easy to pronounce just say


http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...%C3%B6kull.ogg

Oh n turn up your sound, it helps.

Horace 27-04-2010 14:23

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
As an epilogue to this story :

Quote:

A visualisation of the northern European airspace returning to use after being closed due to volcanic ash. Due to varying ash density across Europe, the first flights can be seen in some areas on the 18th and by the 20th everywhere is open.
http://vimeo.com/11205494

If you watch the North East coast of Scotland early on I believe those must be helicopter flights to oil rigs, there's also one or two flights in the UK during the shutdown, probably military or air ambulance flights.

Keep your eye on London!

moiraf100 29-04-2010 13:26

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Just bumping the thread as some of us may still have loved ones who aren't home yet.
My daughter is now back in Melbourne after hopping over to Auckland while waiting for her 4th of May flight home :-)

zaax 02-05-2010 02:02

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Now the weather is coming from the North will we have volcanic dust problem again?

Earl of Bronze 02-05-2010 02:28

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zaax (Post 35012124)
Now the weather is coming from the North will we have volcanic dust problem again?

Depends if the volcano is still erupting throught melt water.

Hom3r 03-05-2010 20:30

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
SECONDS OUT, ROUND TWO.

DING DING

http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/UK-...Irish_Airspace

LSainsbury 03-05-2010 22:13

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

The Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) has imposed a no-fly zone over Ireland until at least 1pm tomorrow after the Volcanic Ash Advice Centre (VAAC) said a plume of ash is threatening to drift across the country.

The skies over parts of Scotland have also been closed tonight as a precaution after an increased concentration of volcanic ash was detected in the atmosphere, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) said.
Breaking: Sky News

alferret 03-05-2010 22:24

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
I do hope this is a blip and the area's where fligts are cancelled doesnt spread to UK mainland as were due to fly out Saturday, but hey ho what will be will be.

http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporat.../index.html#D1

wwe 04-05-2010 01:32

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
i thught the volcano has stopped as they not been on news for a while then it was then saying its heding back over to ireland and they stopped planes from taking off

Sasha222 04-05-2010 02:07

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Ya we might not have any planes taking of from cork Mayo Dublin and cant remember where else. Its because of whichever way the wind is blowing. Thank god I dont fly anywhere but pity the poeple who have to or who have hols planned

Maggy 04-05-2010 08:24

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/8658738.stm

Quote:

All flights in and out of Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic have been grounded from 0700 BST because of fresh risks from volcanic ash.
Airspace over the Outer Hebrides in Scotland were closed earlier, affecting operations from Stornoway, Tiree, Barra and Benbecula.
Flights in the rest of the UK are operating as normal.

Stuart 04-05-2010 10:54

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wwe (Post 35013621)
i thught the volcano has stopped as they not been on news for a while then it was then saying its heding back over to ireland and they stopped planes from taking off

Eruptions tend to go on for weeks or months. The only reason they allowed UK airspace to reopen is because we didn't get as much ash headed our way as they thought we would. That could change, however, if the wind changes.

moiraf100 04-05-2010 18:51

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
My daughter is finally on her way home :-)
She should be landing at Heathrow just before 9 this evening.

Hom3r 04-05-2010 21:20

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
BREAKING NEWS:

Airspace over Scotland and Northern Ireland closed from 0700 tomorrow by ash cloud

Kymmy 05-05-2010 14:15

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
And now the vultures descend

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/8662097.stm

Chris 05-05-2010 20:19

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
aah ... advance fee fraud. Known in Nigeria as a 419 scam.

moiraf100 05-05-2010 21:41

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Daughter landed last night. Straight to the hospital as BF suffering from Cellulitis and ............ hypothermia.

alferret 06-05-2010 07:14

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
All airports are expected to be open as of 7am today :)






Quote:

Originally Posted by moiraf100 (Post 35014810)
Daughter landed last night. Straight to the hospital as BF suffering from Cellulitis and ............ hypothermia.

Not good, hope all is ok.

Maggy 09-05-2010 15:46

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8670560.stm

Quote:

UK air passengers are facing further disruption from a volcanic ash cloud that has affected European flights.
Most of northern Italy's airports are closed until at least midday, and France, Switzerland, and northern Portugal have also been affected.
Quote:

Six airports in the north of Scotland have closed. Flights from the UK to Spain, France, Switzerland and Portugal have been grounded.

Chris 09-05-2010 21:01

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
1 Attachment(s)
We had a fine, bright yellow powder dusted over our car last night:

http://www.cableforum.co.uk/board/at...1&d=1273431605

This was shot with super-macro, so the grains are a lot smaller than they appear here. For scale, the diagonal line running across the picture is a dried-up raindrop, and is about 1cm wide.

Maggy 11-05-2010 21:23

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8674704.stm

Quote:

Safety rules governing flights in UK and Irish airspace have been eased following the Iceland volcano, the Civil Aviation Authority has announced.
It said it had cleared the way for more flights by lifting the 60-mile no-fly buffer zone imposed around dense ash.
hurray!

Chris 12-05-2010 10:21

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
We're still getting a slow but constant dusting with bright yellow ash. The car is filthy. :(

Tuftus 12-05-2010 12:23

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 35019821)
We're still getting a slow but constant dusting with bright yellow ash. The car is filthy. :(

My car had a sandy coloured layer of dust on it last week, the annoying thing was it was washed at the weekend and not used since i get the bus to work.

joglynne 15-05-2010 10:03

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
Quote:

Huge swathe of Europe grounded by Iceland volcano ash as Eurostar and ferries see passenger numbers soar
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...assengers.html ... and now to add to traverles misery apparently Eurostar services have been suspended

Quote:

Disruption due to broken down train.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/travelnews/public/eurostar.shtml

Well it doesn't look like our friends will be getting home from their holidays to-day as hoped. Their plane had been cancelled twice before they decided to travel up to Paris to get the train, managed to get tickets yesterday morning on this mornings train and now this has been cancelled with no information on when services will be resumed. :(

Add .. just seen the BBC news and apparently the suspension is by the Tunnel operators and due to a CO2 sensor reading in the tunnels.

Chris 15-05-2010 17:11

Re: Airports closed as volcanic ash drifts toward UK
 
The reading triggered a fire alarm, but it was a false positive. Still, better safe than sorry ...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 14:01.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum