![]() |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
bit o/t (well a lot but i'm bored now ;-) ) but if we had the death penalty stefan kisko would be dead and 31 years later someone else wouldn't have been arrested on suspicion of murder: http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/cri...cle1959045.ece
---------- Post added at 20:51 ---------- Previous post was at 20:48 ---------- ps. if the un deems the invasion of iraq as illegal, are deaths caused by it war crimes or just ordinary crimes because an illegal war isnt a war but an act of terrorism? all very confusing. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
With the breach of the UN resolutions, the ceasfire at the end of GW1 is negated so that war started up again. Therefore the war itself was not illegal. Incidently, remind us again how that march you hold so dear would have removed Saddam from power if it had been successful? |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
"If what Ms Beckett was saying had an ounce of truth about it then you can rest assured that those coalition forces who have witnessed the harder edge of Iraqi justice first hand would think twice the next time they pick up a weapon about what, if any, immunity they might be afforded in the event that they are accused of such crimes." Nowhere, despite the phrasing of your question which brought about the above answer did I "..suggest(ed) that her statement that its right that Saddam should face Iraqi justice will demoralise our troops". Her statement was ""It is right that those accused of such crimes against the Iraqi people* should face Iraqi justice." * therein there is no specific reference to Saddam Hussein. One can therefore assume that "those accused", in much the same way as the royal "we" is employed, would encompass all of "those accused". Order 17 was an agreement brought about under the auspices of the Coalition Provisional Authority (no longer an executive power since the formation of the Government). Since July the Iraqi national security adviser Mowaffaq al-Rubaie has been voiciferous in his objection to the continuance of Order 17 and has stated "There is no way we can accept CPA Order 17 anymore." His argument, which has been gaining creedence in the Iraqi parliament over the last three months, is that Iraqi justice cannot be seen to be fair and impartial for Iraqis when coalition troops are afforded the comfort blanket of their own national justice system in preference to same . Hardly a rocket science debate. Beckett's comment has thrown fuel on an already smouldering fire of discontent amongst ordinary Iraqis, security personnel and parliamentarians. I am already hearing that there have been requests for clarification from quarters much closer to the conflict than us (hence my posting on the matter). As I said, I'm done with this. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Its catch-22.
If you say the Iraqis shouldn't have their own way, then you're enforcing your own values on them which apparently is why they are p***ed off (nothing to do with a 1,300 year old grudge.) If you say the Iraqis should have their own way, then you're barbaric and medieval. Either way, you're screwed. Must check The Guardian at some point to see which way I am supposed to think. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
You spend WAYYYYY to much time thinking about this stuff.
Evil Man, soon to be dead man. Simple! :D |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
The fact is she didn't - and people on the ground in the thick of operations want to know why, exactly. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
Write to her and find out for them, although I suggest you don't use the title I gave her, MP of incompetence might make your correspondance go astray as there are so many in the goverment who could answer to that title! |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
I'll save the writing to her for a while yet - she seems to be having trouble enough with her spoken english without me compounding her misery.;-) Punky, there's no harm in wading in at all. I'm merely contending, based on the facts available to me, that this "faux pas", if indeed that is all that it is / was, is causing some very considerable consternation and worry among troops and contractors currently serving in Iraq. I'm away. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
"I dont want to go kill those children" (children i guess being the youngish terrorists, around 15 as opposed to 5 or what have you, but still) ****ed me right off, He joined the army so he goes where the government sends him and the paper chose the most emotional part of the interview |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Interesting comment from the excellent Medialens on the press response to Saddam's trial.
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Just had a breaking news thingie from CNN news, he's going to be executed today.
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
What is it about 24 hours news?they have to invent new forms of hyperbole because they cannot stop trying to be more and more exciting, unfortunately they just end up making news dull and tedious through repitition.:rolleyes: |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Just heard on news he has been executed
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
ok so they've got rid of the head honcho if the news is to be believed, but what about all the others?
im sure saddam didnt personally authorise all of the killings that went on, he wouldnt have any time to enjoy his many wives or the shiny gold bathrooms. do the people in his administration get the same treatment or do they get a lesser sentance beacause they were acting in his name? im not calling for a witchunt of anyone that ever knew him to executed but clearly his government should be investigated and treated in the same way? |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
BBC News website is announcing that he has been hanged. May well make him a martyr - pin-up for all the Middle Eastern nutters.
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
They could keep him locked up for ever. It's barbaric to hang a man.
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
:eek:
BBC News have just shown a clip of him being put in the gallows :erm: He looks so calm.... |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
A man desperately in need of putting down, good riddance. Shame they didn't just throw a grenade into the hole he was hiding in...
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Indeed. He was given more than he gave to any of the thousands of victims. He will get a marked grave = more than some of his victims. His death will be fairly quick = more than most of his victims. His family will know what happened to him = more than most of his victims families. I will not share a tear for the barbaric monster unlike the hand wringing do gooders who would have seen him go unpunished. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
Yes i think we are equal. Eye for an Eye, Tooth for a Tooth seen that before have we by any chance ? |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
Trust me if you say it they will come :) |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
There's no question that he was barbaric. But if you're going to be the one to bring the 'eye for an eye' argument in to this, do you really consider hanging to be 'barbaric'?
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
It's as if the New Testament never happened....... |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
The winner in all this........ the media and the weapons manufacturers :( |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
I just think he was badly in need of being put down......much like pol pot, hitler stalin etc...
I'm now waiting for the inevitable conspiracy theories to start up: 'saddam not really executed.....had plastic surgery and is living in south america....etc....' :D |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Not in the way it was done. He would just have strung someone up and let them die by strangulation very slowly over anything up to 30 Min's. The way his executioner did it made sure it was quick, Something Saddam would not have allowed his victims. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Lets face it the unadulterated video will no doubt make it onto a few websites and youtube ;) |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
:LOL: Give it a week and he will be said to have opened a restaurant in London selling Iraqi food. |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
I see the muppet Bush saying it was a great day for justice and exiled Iraqi calling for us all to celebrate, well tbh I don't find much joy in someone's death even if they are a monster and I certainly don't think it very appropriate for someone who calls themselves a Christian to say its a great day, mind you this is the bloke who 'doesn't regret a single death sentence I (Bush) signed' |
Re: Saddam To Be Hanged
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
I'm sure the full version will find its way to the web soon enough..
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Not really, if it's fit enough to be shown on tv then generally it's ok for CF.
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
it doesn't show you much, just him getting the rope round his neck, thats it, I bet his masked hangmen, all apologised all the way through it.
ik |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Will hanging him improve matters? I dont think so.
How about all the innocent people killed by joint bombing by america and britain? are we to see bush/blair led to the gallows? unfortunately not :( |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
flawed trial......however killing him has achieved???? so hes dead what now ? we know civil war has been happening for a while now in iraq, this will just inflame things even further, bring more hatred towards western countries...
im not going to blame people (civillians) for the backlash, on the news all you hear is crimes against humanity, but clear cut evidence, i have not read any, personally, its ok saying hes charged with this and that but real credible evidence ? ---------- Post added at 12:18 ---------- Previous post was at 12:17 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
As for the rest of that drivel about me 'liking to see people suffer' I'll just just refer you to my previous posts on this subject and the death penalty in general and wonder what you hope to achieve by insulting others |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
And you did insult me when you said this, you like to see humans suffer |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
He looked totally broken and confused going to the gallows........seemed to be playing close attention to the executor :sleep:
Tables totally reversed !!!! |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Quote:
You also say you aren't happy, however, there are plenty of Iraqis, who both escaped or survived Saddam who say they are very happy, I don't think I behgrudge them that. Also, Saddam has no followers. Saddam oppressed the Sunnis like he opressed everyone else. They are just bloodthirsty sickos who are using Saddam as an excuse. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Either way it's all fine and dandy now, Iraqis are dancing in the streets exchanging flowers and kisses and the coalition forces will be home on Wednesday. Oh, wait... |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Just a word to the wise, should the footage of him being hanged make it online, any links to it posted here will NOT be permitted.
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Of course there are already some that are saying the Iraqi's didn't deal with it them themselves and that they got their hanging through forgoing due process Saddam had no followers, I beg to differ there a lot of people did very well out of his rule and the Americans have already said they expect an increase in violence because of this, so yet more innocent people are going to die because of him |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Will have to find some other video to leak then :naughty: :Sprint: :) |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
---------- Post added at 14:59 ---------- Previous post was at 14:54 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Interestingly enough though I have just seen a BBC report that states no foreigners were present at the execution, that isn't what was said on U.S. tv last night, so who knows, I hope you are right although weren't there several flaws with the trial about the presumption of guilt and allowing the defence council to cross examine? |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Dead or alive he is still always going to be a martyr to some.
Whatever had been decided in the way of sentencing would have upset and annoyed some. He would always be a focus for the malcontents if he was still alive just as he will be now he is dead. The only thing that has been gained is that the Iraqi nation will see that they can make and decide what the laws will be in their own country and that they can take command of where they will now go as a nation.This will hopefully give them the confidence that they can make it as a unified country provided they can learn to stand up to those of Saddam's ilk who are at present trying to undermine the country's and people's confidence in themselves. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
I'd just like to know why the Foreign Secretary is seemingly fine to acknowledge the process of somebody who has been lawfully killed by a state, when this country has a firm policy against capital punishment?
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Presumably because he wasn't tried and punished in this country.
Even if the criminal was a British citizen then |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
What goes around, comes around.:tu: |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Saddam deserved to be punished for his crimes - of that there is no doubt. Perhaps (a particularly public) death wasn't the smartest move to reflect a new democracy but the means justified the end. Let's not delude ourselves into believing this is some sort of manifestation of impartial democracy - it's anything but. Two prime fact(or)s are that the trial judge was a Kurd who had lost relatives in the incident for which Hussein was found guilty, hardly a stoic basis for impartiality. Al-Maliki lived in exile for many years under a death threat courtesy of Hussein - again hardly a sound basis to suggest impartiality. Either way he is dead but the suicide bombings and all the other madness still remain. It will be interesting to see if the trial for the gassing of the Kurds proceeds (conveniently without his damning testimony - obviously). I'm a great believer in, and advocate of, civilized democracy but there's something telling in Russ's earlier post regarding the posting of links to any video footage of the actual hanging. With true democracy comes responsibility. If true Iraqi democracy entails the public broadcasting of an execution (of anybody) then, frankly, it's a democracy I can do without supporting. My thoughts are with the widows, fathers, mothers, brothers and sisters of the servicemen and women who have lost their lives in exchange for a 30 second clip of morbid sensationalism being streamed around the world. I'm sure it's no comfort, whatsoever, for them - particularly at this time of year. As granny Angry would often say "Two wrongs don't make spilt milk" - or something. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Oh wait, you're wrong again and trivialising their deaths, nice. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
If anyone has trivalised the deaths of service men and women then it is the governments of this country and the US for sending them to war under false pretenses. The fact that they're still there in my opinion is that they've made such a cock up of the whole thing that they(Bush & Blair) need to stay to save face. ---------- Post added at 17:45 ---------- Previous post was at 17:44 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
You may as well infer a link between the increase intelevision viewing and the decline in slavery...... |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
So, bearing in mind what Saddam was doing to large sections of the population, that the provisional government in Iraq does not currently (AFAIK) have enough resources or infrastructure to be able to run the country (and, as has been proved this week, cannot neccesarily trust the infrastructure they do have), and without help, the government is likely to collapse leading to anarchy (although that seems to be a good description of what is going on anyway), what do you suggest we do? The Iraqis are suffering at the moment. I suspect if we left, that suffering would be a lot worse. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Suggesting that their deaths was to get a 30 second clip certainly trivialises the loss of life on all sides. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
I don't think Iraq can be helped. By far the most common form of violence there is Iraqi-on-Iraqi, usually Sunni-on-shiite.
It took something like Saddam's regime to suppress the public sufficiently. That obviously can't be repeated. The only people that can stop that are themselves. The decreasing majority of peaceful, exasperated Iraqis that need to stand up against the increasing majority that want to kill over a 1,300 year old grudge and/or oil/territory rights. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Here is a quote from Tony Blair's address to the UK population on Thursday March 20th 2003. "On Tuesday night I gave the order for British forces to take part in military action in Iraq. Tonight British servicemen and women are engaged from air, land and sea. Their mission: to remove Saddam Hussein from power, and disarm Iraq of its weapons of mass destruction." Notwithstanding the total lack of WMDs being discovered Hussein was effectively removed from power on April 10th 2003. He was then captured on December 13th 2003. Servicemen and women who have died post December 13th, when Hussein was remanded into American custody, have died in circumstances entirely beyond the remit of the stated objective with which they were charged. The execution of Hussein was the final chapter in his total removal from power and elimination as a threat to anyone. The broadcast of his execution is "job done" as far as his adversaries are concerned. Anyone who has lost colleagues and friends in this conflict will tell you that they'd much rather have them back than sit and watch constant Sky News re-runs of some despot dictator dangling off the end of a rope no matter how much that might ease the consciences of those who advocated what has become the most farcical, expensive (in human and fiscal terms) and ill prosecuted regime change exercise in modern history . Gavin is entirely right - Iraq, in it's current state, cannot be helped. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
Quote:
people who think iraq is a better place without him are in for a suprise, you think the violence in previous times is bad i anticipate more bloodshed by the three warring factions, alot of anger again will be directed at western allies, he should have been kept in jail for the rest of his living life. |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
It may only be a 30 second clip of morbid sensationalism to yourself Mr A, but to people less fortunate than yourself, like millions who suffered human rights abuses, like murder and torture, and those who were lucky enough to escape, Iraqi and non-Iraqi alike, I think its rather more them.
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
But equating this historic achievement to a mere '30 second clip' is to belittle it......a murdering, genocidal tyrant has been given his just deserts and that's something that doesn't happen very often. Perhaps it will be a lesson to any other would-be tyrants waiting in the wings and give them pause for thought...... |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
What about all the thousands of Iraqis killed at the orders of Bush & Blair? do their families get to see their murderers hung as well?
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
What do you want next, Our troops arrested and charged as well ? |
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
Re: Update: Saddam Hussein Executed
Quote:
|
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 16:23. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum