Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
It appears the Cabinet have agreed something. Embargoed conclusions were sent to journalists for reveal at 9pm.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 20:35 ---------- Previous post was at 20:34 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
https://twitter.com/SamCoatesTimes/s...24521589600256
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Michel Barnier @MichelBarnier
13 minutes ago #Chequers discussion on future to be welcomed. I look forward to White Paper. We will assess proposals to see if they are workable & realistic in view of #EUCO guidelines. Next negotiations w/ #UK on WP, & Withdrawal Agreement, w/c 16 July #Brexit |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
An amicable deal with the EU is preferable, but in the absence of that, we should be prepared to walk away. ---------- Post added at 00:40 ---------- Previous post was at 00:35 ---------- Quote:
I think what we don't want is you guys trying to undermine the UK's position on this. So a bit of quiet on this would be good. Fat chance. :grind: ---------- Post added at 00:48 ---------- Previous post was at 00:40 ---------- Quote:
I'm sorry, but do you really think life is all about rolling over and accepting what's coming to you? Can I just remind you that the electorate voted to exit the EU? You have done your best to undermine what the majority want by posting every negative story you can muster. In the end, Theresa May will prove you to be wrong. She is more of a 'man' than so many of her wimpy detractors. Prepare for the final assault. Not long now! :cleader: ---------- Post added at 00:51 ---------- Previous post was at 00:48 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 05:42 ---------- Previous post was at 05:36 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Hopefully the EU will reject this shabby compromise nonsense and then there'll be no time left for yet another capitulation to the remainers and we ACTUALLY leave on WTO rules.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Let's try and keep to debating and have less of the personal digs
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
1) Effectiveness of Theresa May on Friday 2) The White Paper 1) I would praise her for stepping up and showing some leadership skills. I think you can do this without endorsing the White Paper. 2) Not as bad for the country's economy as I feared but we will be an effective rule-taker so less democratic than either being in or 100% out of the EU. Quote:
Quote:
I think that if the Cabinet Brexiters had come up with a firm, worked through proposal and got countries like Australia, India and the US on board for an alternative trade deal then they would have had an alternative solution which the Cabinet Remainers would have found harder to repudiate. Instead, she was faced with the realistic prospect of large chunks of industry leaving the country and so there was no option of a clean Brexit. Clever populist slogans may get you into power but once you're in power, you need to deliver. Brexiters delivered less than Northern Rail and Thameslink put together, and were the architects of their own downfall. This is how I see history will write up Brexit. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
---------- Post added at 09:30 ---------- Previous post was at 09:29 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Looks like the broad terms of a deal with the EU has already been done quietely behind the scenes. Hence May visiting Merkel this week.
So, we'll be in the EU in all but name, but with no say or voting rights on anything. Not great, but better than the nightmare scenario. Hope Farage/Boris etc. are pround of what they have acheived (looks like Boris prefers his ministerial car to principals, of which he has none - he went awol during the Heathrow vote aswell... :D) |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 10:56 ---------- Previous post was at 10:36 ---------- Quote:
---------- Post added at 11:00 ---------- Previous post was at 10:56 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Whilst I am not Mick, the important thing for me is separation from the ECJ and the sovereignty of our Parliament. Along with that come the trade deals we might make with other countries or trading groups.
I can give way on technical matters regarding EU trade such as alignment of standards thus having to take account of the ECJ or ignore rulings on our alignment and thus on trade at our peril. Quite how the Irish border question will pan out is beyond my prediction. One senses that May cleared this with Merkel and thus the Brussels turds will get new instructions - as in not quite there but shows promise. OB might well have been right (as we in Wokingham can often be). |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
I reserve my judgement for now.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Undoubtedly, a deal with Europe would be the best solution, as long as it doesn't involve free movement of people or remaining in the customs union. It looks as though there may be a few problems with the customs issues, but as long as that doesn't restrict our ability to strike our own trade deals or subject us to ECJ rulings, I will probably be able to live with one or two compromises there. Nice to see things coming together now. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
There is no ‘cliff edge’. That is Project Fear, pure and simple. ---------- Post added at 20:31 ---------- Previous post was at 20:29 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/b...-a8080966.html http://uk.businessinsider.com/no-dea...-a-year-2018-3 lots more of them OB not posing every one project fact but you hate facts |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Why don't we await the EU reaction to the UK proposals and also the business reaction to them?
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
We are getting in to petty arguments again - pack it in!
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
well cabinet unity didn't last long Boris at it again
https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2018/07/1.jpg |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Leadership contest is in the pipeline, heard tonight Brexit back benchers are drafting letters to 1922 Committee.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Not necessarily. There wasn’t a GE called when Cameron resigned. Plus there is that little issue of the fixed term parliament act and I think people in U.K. are getting a little tired of elections.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 05:13 ---------- Previous post was at 05:11 ---------- Quote:
---------- Post added at 05:16 ---------- Previous post was at 05:13 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Start queuing for bread and toilet paper.:rolleyes: |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Corbyn is a a very poor leader but if the electorate decide they have had of enough of this utterly shambolic lot then Bobs your uncle no matter how bad the opposition leader is IMO as the one thing the electorate do not like is deep disunity in a governing party...
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
I know it's a disappointment but we're going to be 'aligned' to the EU following their rules, with no say. It's worse than now, but better than the hard-line no deal alternative. The Brexiters didn't have a plan, which is unbelievable . The country has got itself into this mess, and we have to do the best we can. Those that voted for Brexit can't avoid some of the blame, they should really have thought it through rather than follow knee jerk populist tabloid headlines. However they were lied to massively by politicians now trying to save face and rescue their own careers. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 10:15 ---------- Previous post was at 10:08 ---------- Interesting to see the two themes that I mentioned earlier in the year coming together on Friday. The backstop agreement meant a soft Brexit and the Brexiters' lack of a plan meant there was no alternative to clinging tightly to the EU. Here's Sky News's take on why Theresa May triumphed on Friday. Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Brexit will happen because if it does not, it will be the biggest democratic let down in British history, many people will never vote again, ever and I will be one of them - do you really advocate mass voter apathy because that is what will happen? Lastly - I made an instruction to stop referring to Brexiteers as "hard" or "extreme" - There is no such thing there is just Brexiteers, people who voted to leave answered one question, they voted to leave, this does not make them any other thing, so stop using such terms!!! ---------- Post added at 11:34 ---------- Previous post was at 10:15 ---------- Conservative Backbench backlash is growing over the Friday Chequeres Brexit meeting, with some Tory MP's suggesting this morning, they have no confidence in the Brexit deal and thus have no Confidence in Theresa May.... A Conservativehome snap survey suggests 3/5 Tory Members are unhappy with the deal. https://www.conservativehome.com/the...r-britain.html |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Many thanks. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
TM may fall as a result of Brexit, but if she's put the country ahead of her own career then good on her I say. The leadership of the Tories is a piffling issue. Seems others in her cabinet are now more concerned about their own ambitions than any Brexit red lines they once had. Brexit, as we've seen, seems to mean a wide variety of things. Hence the need for the people to have the final say on the terms of any deal with the EU. This isnt a rerun of the referendum, it's a very different issue. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
I take it Mr_K that you expect the EU to accept the details in the white paper. If so dream on, it won't happen.
As I said (perhaps) thousands of posts ago Article 50 gives one option on trade. You leave, you're out. That does not preclude a future trade deal presumably during the 2yr transiion preiod. There is no such thing as hard or soft brexit. There is only brexit. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
I think people expect the EU to come back on this deal yes, it's a starting position not the final proposal.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
The transition period is not two years, Pip. Brexit Day is 29th March 2019 and the transition period ends 31st December 2020. Three months will probably be quite important here. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
I think that any deal will be sweetened with money and that will tip it for the countries you mention v a clean Brexit where the financial sums would presumably be limited to that required by law and reputation. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 13:36 ---------- Previous post was at 13:16 ---------- Quote:
It is Bremain for sure. Us Brexiteers will not stand for this rejection of Democracy, we will revolt and riot if necessary, let the revolt begin en masse, you Remainers may have had your #StopBrexit marches and protests over the last two years but I consider this to be war, did you Remainers think we should just lie down should the Democratic result of the referendum, not be enacted exactly as we voted for? |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 13:54 ---------- Previous post was at 13:52 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
The question on the ballot paper did not ask if we should partially remain in the EU, it was either leave or remain, leave had over a million more votes. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
It is essential that we have the ability to trade with the rest of the world on terms acceptable to us. Anything less would be a betrayal. The room for maneouvre lies in the arrangements we make for customs in relation to goods to and from the EU. If that can be kept separate from our trade with the rest of the world, we will have a good basis to proceed with Theresa May's plan. If the EU reject this proposal, it will be academic anyway and we revert to WTO rules. That suits me just fine. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
However, here's one I agree with. https://www.capitalandconflict.com/b...ood-bad-trade/ |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
If this deal allows us to trade effectively with the rest of the world outside of EU regulations, prevents the free movement of people, brings back our sovereignty, whilst maintaining favourable trading arrangements with the EU, what's not to like? We would be in keeping with the voters wishes in that we leave the EU, but without damaging EU trade. The EU can take that or leave it. I don't care either way. Both options can be made to work for Britain. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
It is pointless being persueded by this compromise ATM as it needs the EU to agree. At present I cannot see them accepting it.
What I would like to see is any remainer or brexiter point me to where article 50 allows for this compromise. I'm willing to be educated. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 17:32 ---------- Previous post was at 17:30 ---------- Quote:
Anything from that date onwards is a matter of negotiation between the EU and the Third Country and is outside the scope of Article 50. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
May I now ask what you and the other remainers in this thread have been wittering on about for months now? No deal could be made before March 2019. How can parliament have a meaningful vote on a deal that cannot be done until we have left? |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
I know Pip's question was a bit awkward for you, but your response would really help us to understand your position. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Cool it folks...
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Pay special attention to this which has nothing to do with trade. Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
The link you linked too: Quote:
But I'm not a lawyer. However we've been working on the assumption that we can get a deal before the deadline. Even if it's just a transition period while we work out a more complicated one. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
The transition period is already covered in article 50.
Quote:
Quote:
So put simply, any negotiation has to be conducted in accordance with article 218(3). Article 50 is unequivocal in that respect. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Ok but I still don't see the issue since we and the EU are clearly working on getting some agreement done that maintains the trading relationship ahead of the deadline. I am not a lawyer so don't quite know how to parse the Article 50 text but the players in this working in a different direction.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
I see where you're coming from Damien and I respect that. My take on it is that the EU cannot under it's own rules accept any deal on trade put forward by the UK. It can only accept a deal on security, at least that is how I read the articles. I could be totally wrong only time will tell.
I should imagine any trade deal would be done during the transition period. Edit Come to think about it what's the point of a transition period if a deal has already been done and agreed? |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
It just goes to show, the lack of any preparations before the referendum in the event that the country could vote leave, this tells me, leave was never meant to win.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
We cannot enter into any trade negotiations with any other country until we leave. ---------- Post added at 23:23 ---------- Previous post was at 23:17 ---------- Quote:
They gambled and lost, now they have to do something they never expected nor wanted. |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
BREAKING: David Davis has resigned as the Brexit Secretary
https://news.sky.com/story/david-dav...etary-11430705 |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
---------- Post added at 23:53 ---------- Previous post was at 23:51 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Theresa May has to be finished now....
Will Boris quit tomorrow ? |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Why didn't David Davis quit on Friday? ---------- Post added at 00:04 ---------- Previous post was at 00:02 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Rumours that Michael Gove will be invited to replace David Davis.
|
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Quote:
Hey-Ho |
Re: Brexit Discussion (New thread-Follow First Post Rules!)
Steve Baker, a Brexit Minister to Davis has also quit tonight...
https://twitter.com/faisalislam/stat...09182288789505 David Davis letter to May... wow, he didn't hold back ! |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 16:17. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.