Cable Forum - Football Season 2011/12

Clear Penalties are denied every week.

Penalty shouts are denied every week in every game.

There is no conspiracy between Man utd and Ref's.

:sleeping:

Didn't say it was a conspiracy between Man Utd & refs, it's the atmosphere in the ground...

adzii_nufc

27-03-2012 00:28

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 35405641)

Didn't say it was a conspiracy between Man Utd & refs, it's the atmosphere in the ground...

Sure...

Every time there is a chance of a penalty at SJP we go mental, But don't recieve one..

I'm guessing it's because we aren't Man utd fans :erm:

You don't happen to support City do you?

Cobbydaler

27-03-2012 00:32

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 35405646)

Sure...

Every time there is a chance of a penalty at SJP we go mental, But don't recieve one..

I'm guessing it's because we aren't Man utd fans :erm:

Shouldn't that be SDA? ;)

And, with respect, there's not the same weight of expectation for success from fans at SDA.

The home crowd at OT can be very intimidating for a ref.

adzii_nufc

27-03-2012 00:41

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Must have intimidated ref's into doing all of this.

v Newcastle 26th November 2011 - Incorrect penalty given for Newcastle, goal for Manchester United wrongly disallowed for offside

v Crystal Palace 30th November 2011 - Glenn Murray's winner offside and allowed to stand

v Blackburn 1st January 2012 - De Gea fouled as Grant Hanley scores the winner

v Ajax 23rd February 2012 - Alderweireld's winner offside and allowed to stand

v Bilbao 8th March 2012 - De Marcos offside goal allowed to stand. Ref gives a free kick against Evra for not having his boot on which leads to a Bilbao goal to make it 1-3 on the night.

Or the united fans were absent for these =[

Uncle Peter

27-03-2012 00:55

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35405574)

A 'focus on potential' is at the root of a lot of football transfers. Liverpool played roughly Â£20 million for Henderson

The Â£20M transfer fee has been flatly denied by the club (in an interview with Damien Comolli himself).

There was an excellent article in the FT a while ago on the moneyball factor with focus on both Comolli and Arsene Wenger in his use of statistical analysis to support transfer activity. And here it is:

linky

My concern over this approach at Liverpool is that the strategy is very much at the mercy of a previously untested relationship between Comolli and the manager. This is something that soon soured between himself and Jol at Spurs when things started going badly. Does Kenny really have the last word on transfers? Apparently he does but I am pretty certain that he is working within boundaries beyond his control.

Cobbydaler

27-03-2012 01:42

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 35405646)

You don't happen to support City do you?

No, I support Southampton because that's where I was born...

---------- Post added at 01:42 ---------- Previous post was at 00:58 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 35405649)

Was it or wasn't it a penalty? Vast weight of opinion from the pundits was that it was...

thenry

27-03-2012 03:38

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Typical. Still there should be a twist or two left in this race for the title.

denphone

27-03-2012 05:48

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 35405611)

Old Trafford atmosphere gets to the Ref again... :rolleyes:

---------- Post added at 22:52 ---------- Previous post was at 22:07 ----------

This is great news :tu:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/17512080

Thats brilliant to hear that.:tu:

colin25

27-03-2012 06:02

Re: Football Season 2011/12

It was a penalty...and giggs tackle should be red card

If either had happened when city were playing, it would have definitely been both.

Poor showing by ref.

denphone

27-03-2012 06:27

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by colin25 (Post 35405674)

It was a penalty...and giggs tackle should be red card

If either had happened when city were playing, it would have definitely been both.

Poor showing by ref.

Yet again another ref at OT has bottled it.:td::(

Mal	27-03-2012 08:50

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 35405649)

Good post :tu:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 35405653)

Was it or wasn't it a penalty? Vast weight of opinion from the pundits was that it was...

When I read his post, I took it that he was replying to your assertion about the crowd, not the validity of the claim.

I don't know if you watched it or not, but the crowd appeared to be even more subdued than normal, even at that point.

Oh, I support my local club as well ;)

gazzae

27-03-2012 08:52

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cobbydaler (Post 35405641)

Didn't say it was a conspiracy between Man Utd & refs, it's the atmosphere in the ground...

Thought there was no atmosphere at Old Trafford.

gazzae

27-03-2012 11:11

Re: Football Season 2011/12

A fact from Opta

Quote:

Since Aug 2006, Manchester United have conceded 9 penalties in the PL at home. 7 other teams, who have been ever-present in the PL during this time (inc Fulham), have conceded fewer at home.

Shadow Demon UK

27-03-2012 11:17

Re: Football Season 2011/12

Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 35405649)