Cable Forum - Brexit

That's semantics. Parliament found a way to stop Brexit. The fact the Government enabled it is a red herring. the vote of no confidence option always exists and will continue to exist.

No it is not a red herring - the government could have left it really wanted to have done on 29th March.

Btw - It has not stopped Brexit, why do you keep posting lies?

jfman

30-05-2019 20:24

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35997271)

No it is not a red herring - the government could have left it really wanted to have done on 29th March.

Btw - It has not stopped Brexit, why do you keep posting lies?

As you typed this I edited my post - I should have either said stopped it happening on March 29th or delayed Brexit. Neither of which are lies, and I think it's clear what I meant - albeit I could have been clearer with my language.

The next Government won't have the luxury of running down the clock. I hope they do try it though because it'll give the country the general election it needs.

1andrew1

30-05-2019 20:40

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 35997273)

I don't think the country wants another election despite the collection of buffoons queuing up to be PM. The good thing about BoJo's about turns and track record is that he may quite happily bin Brexit if it helps him stay in power :D.

---------- Post added at 20:40 ---------- Previous post was at 20:39 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 35997270)

That's semantics. Parliament found a way to delay Brexit. The fact the Government enabled it is a red herring. the vote of no confidence option always exists and will continue to exist.

Exactly.

pip08456

30-05-2019 20:44

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 35997273)

The delay did not need legislation.

jfman

30-05-2019 20:44

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 35997279)

The delay did not need legislation.

Statutory instruments are legislation.

Mick	30-05-2019 21:15

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by jfman (Post 35997280)

Statutory instruments are legislation.

Secondary Legislation I think you will find. ;)

In any case you need to stop lying regarding what needed to happen, you keep going on how right you were, you were only right because the government allowed it to be - what I said at the time was accurate, the government could have left on 29th March had it wanted to.

jfman

30-05-2019 23:15

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35997284)

It’s still legislation. The Government could have crashed us off the cliff, but I suspect deep down everyone knew Theresa May wouldn’t and would try for her deal again.

If Parliament suspects the next PM is crazy enough to go through with it the no confidence vote is a realistic proposition. Even Hammond hasn’t ruled out voting in favour of it.

Of course the safer option for MPs (given polling data) to avoid a general election would be to kick it back to the people and blame them. Each could look their electorate in the eyes and pretend they genuinely tried.

Being “allowed to be right” is a curious concept. I correctly predicted circumstances would force an extension. My next roll of the dice is circumstances will force another referendum.

Others said amending the EU Withdrawal Act would require primary legislation- that was incorrect. Were they lying? Or in good faith reflecting their understanding of the situation.

1andrew1

30-05-2019 23:23

Re: Brexit

Pressure on the no-deal prime ministerial candidates

Quote:

Business lobby group CBI warns Tories over no-deal Brexit
The Confederation of British Industry has warned Conservative leadership candidates over leaving the EU without a deal.

A no-deal scenario would do "severe" damage to businesses, it said in an open letter to all the MPs running to lead the party.

Director general Carolyn Fairbairn warned them that smaller companies can not afford the necessary preparations for leaving without a plan.

She invited them to meet her members.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/48465791

Carth

30-05-2019 23:42

Re: Brexit

The Confederation of British Industry

Funny that, I didn't think we had much British Industry left :rolleyes:

Dave42

30-05-2019 23:43

Re: Brexit

YouGov
‏
Verified account

@YouGov
51m
51 minutes ago

More
Our latest Westminster voting intention has the Lib Dems in first place and the Brexit Party second place, with Labour and the Tories pushed into third:
Lib Dem - 24%
Brexit Party - 22%
Con - 19%
Labour - 19%
Green - 8%
UKIP - 1%
Change UK - 1%
Other - 6%

TheDaddy

31-05-2019 02:20

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 35997291)

The Confederation of British Industry

Funny that, I didn't think we had much British Industry left :rolleyes:

We won't have when we leave if you believe brexit economics guru Patrick Minford...

Mick	31-05-2019 05:11

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave42 (Post 35997292)

And yet compared to a larger sample size in the form of Euro Elections. BP flattened the Liberal Anti-Democrats, only last week.

denphone

31-05-2019 05:17

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave42 (Post 35997292)

The thing very much to take from that poll and many others Dave is it just tells you how deeply divided this country is..

jfman

31-05-2019 06:11

Re: Brexit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick (Post 35997297)

And yet compared to a larger sample size in the form of Euro Elections. BP flattened the Liberal Anti-Democrats, only last week.

Doesn’t necessarily translate into a vote at a general election. UKIP for example never turned a good performance at the EP elections into anything at Westminster. Unless of course the public radically changed their minds between two dates a short timeframe apart... but we know that can’t happen ;)