Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Britain outside the EU (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33709659)

Hugh 14-11-2021 00:04

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Well, at least he’s not suggesting we should sink the boats or treat any drowned refugees as collateral damage, so, you know, could be worse…

1andrew1 14-11-2021 00:06

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36101099)
Nice pivot. But by linking this explicitly to some strange attempt at pressing for the UK to rejoin the EU you’re really just persisting in the contemptible reasoning you’ve been engaged in over the past 24 hours, using a humanitarian tragedy to shore up your own aims while misrepresenting others.

Not really a pivot, it's another reason to suggest that Nomadking has altered his view on Brexit. I'm not pressing for the UK to rejoin the EU any time soon.

It may be uncomfortable for the implications of the Brexit deal upon repatriation to be discussed ,but I repute your allegation that I'm somehow using a humanitarian tragedy - one which you've not defined - for my own aims.

Carth 14-11-2021 01:55

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36101102)
Well, at least he’s not suggesting we should sink the boats or treat any drowned refugees as collateral damage, so, you know, could be worse…

Both suggestions have as much chance of being implemented as anything other suggestion that gets talked about . . . we may as well give them train fare and have done with it ;)

ianch99 14-11-2021 10:20

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36101103)
Not really a pivot, it's another reason to suggest that Nomadking has altered his view on Brexit. I'm not pressing for the UK to rejoin the EU any time soon.

It may be uncomfortable for the implications of the Brexit deal upon repatriation to be discussed ,but I repute your allegation that I'm somehow using a humanitarian tragedy - one which you've not defined - for my own aims.

Ignore the faux outrage, it's just deflection, as you say, from the uncomfortable & ironic reality that, as a result of Brexit, migrants find it easily to come here and harder to be removed.

I am surprise he does not know this, after all, he knew what he was voting for.

Carth 14-11-2021 10:52

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
The migrant tidal wave into Europe is a growing concern, the EU itself is starting to struggle.

Poland has razor wire fencing, other countries also use concrete walls and barbed wire . . . along with armed forces. Negotiations seem to achieve very little.

We have gunboats but prefer to use lifeboats . . .

TheDaddy 14-11-2021 17:44

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36101123)
The migrant tidal wave into Europe is a growing concern, the EU itself is starting to struggle.

They think 100000 will try and make the journey here

Hugh 14-11-2021 18:08

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carth (Post 36101123)
The migrant tidal wave into Europe is a growing concern, the EU itself is starting to struggle.

Poland has razor wire fencing, other countries also use concrete walls and barbed wire . . . along with armed forces. Negotiations seem to achieve very little.

We have gunboats but prefer to use lifeboats . . .

Are you seriously suggesting we fire on unarmed civilians?

OLD BOY 14-11-2021 18:28

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36101178)
Are you seriously suggesting we fire on unarmed civilians?

You are just a big softee, Hugh.:Yes:

Hugh 14-11-2021 21:04

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36101178)
Are you seriously suggesting we fire on unarmed civilians?

Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36101186)
You are just a big softee, Hugh.:Yes:

Guilty as charged - that would be because I understand the that our Armed Forces have to follow the Geneva Conventions, rather than end up in the International Criminal Court like Radovan Karadžić…

I’d rather be a softy than commit a crime against humanity - you obviously think differently…

OLD BOY 14-11-2021 23:00

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36101212)
Guilty as charged - that would be because I understand the that our Armed Forces have to follow the Geneva Conventions, rather than end up in the International Criminal Court like Radovan Karadžić…

I’d rather be a softy than commit a crime against humanity - you obviously think differently…

Actually, no I don’t.

Hugh 15-11-2021 09:08

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36100965)
Probably not the best move, as that would be murder…

Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36100967)
Maybe you have misjudged the power of the ECJ!

---------- Post added at 02:42 ---------- Previous post was at 02:40 ----------



Or maybe collateral damage?

Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36101186)
You are just a big softee, Hugh.:Yes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36101212)
Guilty as charged - that would be because I understand the that our Armed Forces have to follow the Geneva Conventions, rather than end up in the International Criminal Court like Radovan Karadžić…

I’d rather be a softy than commit a crime against humanity - you obviously think differently…

Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36101232)
Actually, no I don’t.

Your post posits otherwise...

"Collateral damage" is permitted (for lack of a better word) under the Geneva Conventions (as war is messy, and it can be difficult/impossible to only strike military targets without any, especially in urban areas), but there is no interpretation where your suggestion that sinking civilians in boats can be described as such.

jonbxx 15-11-2021 09:14

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
It is amazing the number of people who were saying 'all lives matter' not so long ago don't seem to want to extend that courtesy to asylum seekers..

heero_yuy 15-11-2021 09:23

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jonbxx (Post 36101248)
It is amazing the number of people who were saying 'all lives matter' not so long ago don't seem to want to extend that courtesy to asylum seekers..

But they're not "asylum seekers" That they could have done in any of the EU states that they passed through. They're economic migrants seeking an easy billet.

Quote:

There is only one solution. We need to find a country, probably in Africa, and give them literally hundreds of millions to take these migrants.

We might give them a seven-year contract even though as soon as the migrants find out they will be spending their lives in southern Madagascar they won’t want to come within a thousand miles of Dover.
We need to be generous. We wasted £27billion on test and trace. Let’s ‘’waste’’ a couple of billion on the Madagascar plan.
From Kelvin MacKenzie, "A spokesman Said"

1andrew1 15-11-2021 10:14

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36101246)
Your post posits otherwise...

"Collateral damage" is permitted (for lack of a better word) under the Geneva Conventions (as war is messy, and it can be difficult/impossible to only strike military targets without any, especially in urban areas), but there is no interpretation where your suggestion that sinking civilians in boats can be described as such.

Old Boy's entitled to change his viewpoint during a discussion thread after reading others' insights. That's a good thing. But it would make for a less confusing forum experience if he were able to acknowledge such pivots.

Sephiroth 15-11-2021 10:26

Re: Britain outside the EU
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jonbxx (Post 36101248)
It is amazing the number of people who were saying 'all lives matter' not so long ago don't seem to want to extend that courtesy to asylum seekers..

Ah - but do lives matter more in England than in France? The issue isn't values but is very much a diplomatic matter. If these souks are escaping atrocity or poverty, why mjst it be the UK that receives them?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:17.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum