Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media News Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   .com to be shut down temporarily (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=4383)

Bex 22-11-2003 14:36

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
cant have been far off though this thread was going crazy at one point yesterday :D :D

sure was mate

Russ 22-11-2003 14:42

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
On the subject of "if they haven't got anything to hide, why don't they say who they are", let me give you a scenario, as there just might be other reasons why people chose pseudonyms.

There was once a guy who used to help mod a discussion forum which was critical of NTL. Customers could go there and air their complaints. NTL knew of this site and regularly read up on what was going. Now this guy was in an awkward position. He actually worked for NTL but had to keep his identity a secret as if his employers knew who he was, he could very well end up in trouble. But he still managed to do both, helping customers via the forum annoymously, and working for NTL.

But who was this guy known as?

Mr Ree

Bex 22-11-2003 14:45

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
:tu: thanks for that russ and i agree....i dont think it is paramount for this forum working effectively for us to know the ins and outs of whom the team are

Frank 22-11-2003 14:55

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
i just wondered if there had been a sudden influx ?????????????

Registrations have roughly quadrupled.

Frank 22-11-2003 14:57

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
There was once a guy who used to help mod a discussion forum which was critical of NTL. Customers could go there and air their complaints. NTL knew of this site and regularly read up on what was going. Now this guy was in an awkward position. He actually worked for NTL but had to keep his identity a secret as if his employers knew who he was, he could very well end up in trouble. But he still managed to do both, helping customers via the forum annoymously, and working for NTL.

I think sums it up very well Russ. I would like for everyone to be completely straight about who they, but sometimes there are good reasons why that cannot happen.

paulyoung666 22-11-2003 15:00

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Keyser
I think sums it up very well Russ. I would like for everyone to be completely straight about who they, but sometimes there are good reasons why that cannot happen.



fair comment i reckon :tu:

paulyoung666 22-11-2003 15:03

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Keyser
Registrations have roughly quadrupled.



all the better for this site then , i still say ntl have shot themselves in the foot by closing down .com , as i see it they had a perfect site for people to find ntl related answers and groan at ntl if they needed to , if they were sensible about it then they could have used the criticism they saw of ntl to remedy problems , instead they choose to shut it down so they dont look so bad , are they really that stupid to think that people wont complain elsewhere :(

Nor 22-11-2003 15:08

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Wish we could just get a straight answer though. I can appreciate the point I guess but trying to use anecdotes to compare situations just adds more grayness to something thats already gray.

I'm prepared to believe what people say if they'll just come out and say it. But nobody seems to be saying it, seems to be all anecdotes and muddying of waters. Maybe Mick and Neil will just say, nope we have nothing to do with this site and never have had.

What Russ D has effectively said is that the people who started this website work for NTL. Neil and Mick work for NTL. I can see why they wouldn't want to give their names as it would mean they'd lose their job and money from ntl for .com. But it also means they've been lying to us, although perhaps their main motive is to throw NTL off their scent.

I have to say I do believe what CJ is said, but perhaps I should just leave it for now as I don't want to lose anyone their job even if they are lying to us all about stuff. It'll all come out in the wash anyway once .com is closed, which can't be far off.

Frank 22-11-2003 15:11

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
but perhaps I should just leave it for now as I don't want to lose anyone their job

I think you should Nor :)

You got MSN Messenger matey? Check mine in my profile is so, and add me to yours.

etccarmageddon 22-11-2003 15:29

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Wish we could just get a straight answer though. I can appreciate the point I guess but trying to use anecdotes to compare situations just adds more grayness to something thats already gray.

I'm prepared to believe what people say if they'll just come out and say it. But nobody seems to be saying it, seems to be all anecdotes and muddying of waters. Maybe Mick and Neil will just say, nope we have nothing to do with this site and never have had.

What Russ D has effectively said is that the people who started this website work for NTL. Neil and Mick work for NTL. I can see why they wouldn't want to give their names as it would mean they'd lose their job and money from ntl for .com. But it also means they've been lying to us, although perhaps their main motive is to throw NTL off their scent.

I have to say I do believe what CJ is said, but perhaps I should just leave it for now as I don't want to lose anyone their job even if they are lying to us all about stuff. It'll all come out in the wash anyway once .com is closed, which can't be far off.

sorry to report back but I was wrong - I can not find anywhere where Neil Mick or Ben deny being these people. although that means nothing.

I'm not interested in a witch hunt but like people to be honest. and remember Mick telling me that if i believe anything Craig says or something like that... then the world is flat! I'd hate to find that Craig is telling the truth!

handyman 22-11-2003 15:29

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
On the subject of "if they haven't got anything to hide, why don't they say who they are", let me give you a scenario, as there just might be other reasons why people chose pseudonyms.

There was once a guy who used to help mod a discussion forum which was critical of NTL. Customers could go there and air their complaints. NTL knew of this site and regularly read up on what was going. Now this guy was in an awkward position. He actually worked for NTL but had to keep his identity a secret as if his employers knew who he was, he could very well end up in trouble. But he still managed to do both, helping customers via the forum annoymously, and working for NTL.

But who was this guy known as?

Mr Ree

Fair point russ, but they don't 'work' for ntl?
When dot com closes we will all find out (so i'm informed).
Until then the conspiracy theories will no doubt continue :erm:

Bex 22-11-2003 16:21

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Neil and Mick work for NTL. I can see why they wouldn't want to give their names as it would mean they'd lose their job and money from ntl for .com. But it also means they've been lying to us, although perhaps their main motive is to throw NTL off their scent.

afaik..having spoken to neil about this already, neil doesn't work for ntl....just thought i would mention that :p

Frank 22-11-2003 16:24

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
afaik..having spoken to neil about this already, neil doesn't work for ntl....just thought i would mention that :p

I think the main point Nor was trying to make was that they would lose any payment, regardless of the technicalities of "employment".

Russ 22-11-2003 16:26

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
What Russ D has effectively said is that the people who started this website work for NTL. Neil and Mick work for NTL. I can see why they wouldn't want to give their names as it would mean they'd lose their job and money from ntl for .com. But it also means they've been lying to us, although perhaps their main motive is to throw NTL off their scent.

Don't you dare!!! I have not said that, effectively or not!!

The example I gave (in case people didn't get it) was on myself - I was Mr Ree and my post described why I chose to stay annonymous. I'm sure I did a bloody good job while as Mr Ree and very few (if any) people knew who I was. The point I made was there are many reasons why someone would want to stay annonymous.

Bex 22-11-2003 16:28

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ D
Don't you dare!!! I have not said that, effectively or not!!

The example I gave (in case people didn't get it) was on myself - I was Mr Ree and my post described why I chose to stay annonymous. I'm sure I did a bloody good job while as Mr Ree and very few (if any) people knew who I was. The point I made was there are many reasons why someone would want to stay annonymous.

i agree with russ actually....i dont think people should implicate him, or suggest that he has said anything.....


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:01.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum