Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   3D Monitors - Are they any good? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33677512)

Barewolf 12-05-2011 20:02

Re: 3D Monitors - Are they any good?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 35234989)
It's brilliant. 2D pq on it is amazing.

I have VM and wouldn't get Sky as it would cost me too much. VM has a lot of VOD content in 3D now and some free stuff too.

I think you mean stereoscopic and side by side. Polarised is how it works at the cinema, at home it's stereoscopic. It can also be top & bottom or interlaced.

Have a few 3D blu rays and have also tried the TVs 2D to 3D conversion which works quite well on cgi movies.


Welcome to the few who appreciate the 3D, dunno whats up with some people who think its a fad......

TheDon 13-05-2011 13:58

Re: 3D Monitors - Are they any good?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35234812)
Monitors High Demand Yes. They may very well be built for it, but lets face it, for £150 give or take, what you expect it to deliver is not always what actually gets delivered.

There's plenty of higher end 3D Monitors that cost double that that are more than capable of going side to side with a 3D TV.

Many monitors have far better colour reproduction than a TV as well, they're cheaper because they don't have the huge array of picture processing that do nothing but add artifacts and distort colours.

Barewolf 14-05-2011 10:52

Re: 3D Monitors - Are they any good?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDon (Post 35235460)
There's plenty of higher end 3D Monitors that cost double that that are more than capable of going side to side with a 3D TV.

Many monitors have far better colour reproduction than a TV as well, they're cheaper because they don't have the huge array of picture processing that do nothing but add artifacts and distort colours.

Im not disputing that some monitors cant compete with a TV. Obviously something that costs £600 is going to be better than something that cost £150.

But given the choice its better to purchase a 42-46 3DTV

roger skillin 15-05-2011 13:52

Re: 3D Monitors - Are they any good?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barewolf (Post 35236220)
Im not disputing that some monitors cant compete with a TV. Obviously something that costs £600 is going to be better than something that cost £150.

But given the choice its better to purchase a 42-46 3DTV

Completely wrong.

The monitor would not just be for 3D movies but also games, if you've ever hooked a computer up to a tv you would know that the quality is nowhere near as good as using a monitor.
Also completely wrong is your cost argument, paying more does not always mean a better product, most people pay for a name because they have to have it but half the time it's not the best and they could get better for a lot less money

Barewolf 15-05-2011 14:37

Re: 3D Monitors - Are they any good?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by roger skillin (Post 35236910)
Completely wrong.

The monitor would not just be for 3D movies but also games, if you've ever hooked a computer up to a tv you would know that the quality is nowhere near as good as using a monitor.
Also completely wrong is your cost argument, paying more does not always mean a better product, most people pay for a name because they have to have it but half the time it's not the best and they could get better for a lot less money


Its your money at the end of the day. You asked if they were any good, and in my opinion they arent in the same line as the TV's. The technology of monitors to display 3D content just doesnt do it for me. However if you want to wast £150 to learn this lesson then that is your choice.

I said if it was me, I wouldn't waste money on a monitor to display 3D content.

In my opinion bigger is better when it comes to 3D, and you cant skip top brand names that have invested millions of pounds researching the technology, and expect to have a good 3D experience on a monitor that cost £150, I may be wrong but I very much doubt it.

As I said earlier in my post, The 3D monitors that I have seen working are pretty lame in comparison to the 3DTV I have in my lounge. I certainly couldnt sit and play a game or watch a film on the monitor that I saw, which was double what you want to pay for yours.

I also said it may be ok for daily applications and games, but if you want my opinion, save up and buy a TV :dozey:


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:33.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum